Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Fedders Lloyd Corporation Pvt. Ltd. Petitioner v. Lt. Governor, Delhi & Others S

Delhi High Court
May 28, 1969
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (V.S. Deshpande, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition challenges the Delhi Administration's order dated 28-11-1968 (under section 10(1)(c) and section 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947) referring to the Labour Court (presided by Shri R.K. Baweja) the question: “Whether the non-employment of Shri Ajab Singh is unjustified and/or illegal and if so, to what relief is he entitled?”

Material factual points (undisputed in the opinion):

  • Respondent No. 3 (Ajab Singh) was employed as Security Officer from 22-11-1961 until 4-7-1967, when he is said to have expressed inability to work and resigned; he was relieved on 4-7-1967.
  • On 31-8-1967 an ex-gratia payment (on the basis of retrenchment compensation generally paid) was made and accepted by Respondent No. 3, who gave a receipt in full and final settlement.
  • On 18-11-1967 Respondent No. 3 requested and received a service certificate which recorded that he had resigned.
  • Respondent No. 3 later wrote to the Labour Commissioner (10-1-1968) stating an industrial dispute existed and seeking reference for adjudication, alleging wrongful retrenchment and seeking reinstatement.
  • The Conciliation Officer called the petitioner-company on 12-1-1968 for conciliation. Conciliation failed and the Delhi Administration issued the reference on 28-11-1968 to the Labour Court.
  • The petitioner-company filed the present writ petition attacking the reference on several grounds including the identity of the presiding officer, absence of any demand to the management, competence to refer, validity of section 2-A, and vagueness of the reference.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reference to the Labour Court presided over by Shri R.K. Baweja was invalid because Shri Baweja was on leave at the time and another officer (Shri Desh Deepak) was appointed to preside during that leave.
  2. Whether an industrial dispute existed between Respondent No. 3 and the petitioner-company prior to the Government's reference (i.e., whether Respondent No. 3 had first raised the demand with the employer so as to create an industrial dispute competent to be referred under section 10).
  3. Whether a dispute between an individual workman and his employer can constitute an "industrial dispute" after insertion of section 2-A of the Act (i.e., constitutional and legislative validity and scope of section 2-A).
  4. Whether the terms of the reference ("non-employment") were too vague to permit adjudication.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner (the company) — principal contentions

  • The reference to the Labour Court presided over by Shri R.K. Baweja was invalid because Shri Baweja was on leave from 26-11-1968 to 1-1-1969 and Shri Desh Deepak was appointed presiding officer bynotification dated 12-12-1968 (annexure B).
  • Respondent No. 3 did not raise any dispute with the petitioner-company before approaching the Government; therefore the Lt. Governor of Delhi was not competent to refer the matter to the Labour Court.
  • A dispute between an individual workman and the employer is not an industrial dispute; section 2-A authorising such reference is bad and ultra vires.
  • The terms of the reference are vague and cannot support adjudication.

Respondent No. 3 (Ajab Singh) — principal contentions

  • He did not resign but was retrenched and was paid retrenchment compensation.
  • He requested the petitioner-company several times for reinstatement; after refusal he approached the Conciliation Officer and sought reference to adjudication.
  • His retrenchment was illegal because junior Security Officers were retained while he was removed.
  • He supported the order of reference as valid.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M/s. Toshniwal Bros. Pvt. Ltd. v. Lt. Governor, Delhi & others Previous High Court/Single Judge observations on when an industrial dispute exists and on references; used as a point to be re-examined in light of Sindhu Resettlement Corporation. The Court re-examined that decision and distinguished its facts; found that the earlier case involved a pre-existing demand by some workmen which made an industrial dispute exist prior to reference, unlike the present case.
Sindhu Resettlement Corporation v. Industrial Tribunal, Gujarat (Supreme Court) Established principle: a demand must be raised first on the management and rejected by them before an "industrial dispute" (as referred by the State) arises; mere application to the Government/Conciliation Officer without prior demand to employer is not sufficient. The Court relied on this decision as decisive: since Respondent No. 3 had not shown he made a demand on the petitioner-company before applying for reference, no industrial dispute existed and the reference was incompetent.
United Commercial Bank Ltd. v. Workmen Interpreted when a vacancy arises under section 8 (distinguishing temporary absence from vacancy); absence on appointment elsewhere or indefinite absence can create a vacancy but leave does not. Used to support the conclusion that the presiding officer's leave was a temporary absence, not a vacancy justifying appointment under section 8; therefore the notification purporting to fill a vacancy was unsupportable.
Alok Kumar v. Dr. S.N. Sharma Principle that a judge appointed to other whole-time duties cannot act as judge during that tenure (i.e., distinction between temporary absence and permanent re-assignment). Cited to contrast circumstances where absence is not temporary; court used it to show the present case involved simple leave (temporary), unlike the Alok Kumar circumstances.
Standard Coal Company v. S.P. Verma Observation that workers may skip direct demand to management and approach Government machinery; suggested such conduct could still constitute an industrial dispute. The Court observed this dictum may be incorrect insofar as it conflicts with the Sindhu Resettlement Corporation principle and therefore cannot be regarded as good law on that point.
Goodyear (India) Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal Rajasthan, Jaipur Attempted to distinguish Sindhu on facts: there the employee applied to the Conciliation Officer challenging termination and seeking reinstatement, and employer opposed reinstatement. The Court considered the distinction and found it unpersuasive: even where an application to the Conciliation Officer was made, the Supreme Court in Sindhu held no industrial dispute existed if no demand was previously made on the employer.
Kandan Textile Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal Madras Observation (by Mack, J.) that bringing matter to Government's notice by a responsible officer may constitute an industrial dispute of limited scope. The Court noted the observation but said it was not clear whether it supports the proposition that a demand not directly made on management (but made to Labour Commissioner) counts; the present Court did not adopt that view as decisive.
Western India Automobile Association v. Industrial Tribunal, Bombay (Federal Court) Held that the term "non-employment" includes retrenchment and refusal to reinstate. Relied upon to reject the petitioner's contention that "non-employment" is too vague; the Court held the term covers retrenchment and refusal to reinstate and therefore the reference's language was adequate.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in two main strands: (A) validity of the appointment/identity of the presiding officer and (B) whether an industrial dispute existed prior to reference.

A. Presiding officer / appointment issue

  1. The Court read the 28-11-1968 reference together with the 12-12-1968 notification and concluded the reference was made to the Labour Court "at present presided over by Shri R.K. Baweja." Under section 20(3) of the Act, proceedings are deemed to have commenced on the date of reference (a legal commencement), even though practical steps (service of notices, hearings) may occur later.
  2. Procedural rules (Rules 10-B(1)–(3)) permit statements and replies to be filed within statutory periods and allow the presiding officer to fix the first hearing within six weeks; these provisions meant Shri Baweja could receive filings and fix hearing dates upon return from leave.
  3. Section 7(1) and 7(2) show a Labour Court is constituted and consists of one person; section 8 concerns filling vacancies. The Court held the temporary leave of Shri Baweja did not create a "vacancy" within section 8 because the office was not demitted and the absence was temporary.
  4. Reliance on United Commercial Bank and Alok Kumar illustrated the distinction between a temporary absence (leave) and a true vacancy caused by permanent re-assignment or indefinite absence; the 1956 amendment inserting “other than a temporary absence” clarified the intention that section 8 applies only to permanent vacancies.
  5. The 12-12-1968 notification appointing Shri Desh Deepak purportedly under section 8 was therefore unsupportable. It also could not be read as a valid section 7 notification constituting a separate Labour Court because it did not in fact constitute a new Labour Court presided over by Shri Desh Deepak for the specified period.
  6. Even if Shri Desh Deepak took initial procedural steps during Shri Baweja's leave, those steps did not oust Shri Baweja's jurisdiction to adjudicate once he returned. Fundamentally, Shri Baweja's jurisdiction remained intact and the reference could properly be adjudicated by him.

B. Existence of an industrial dispute prior to reference

  1. The Court examined section 10(1) and the scheme of the Act (including section 12 and Chapter II & III) and reasoned that an industrial dispute must exist or be apprehended before the appropriate Government can make a reference under section 10(1); the Conciliation Officer's duties under section 12 presuppose an existing or apprehended industrial dispute.
  2. Section 2(k)'s definition of "industrial dispute" involves a dispute/difference where one party asserts something denied by the other — in practice, that a demand by workmen is made on the employer and rejected or disputed.
  3. The Court analyzed Respondent No. 3's application (annexure D) and found it began by asserting an industrial dispute existed but the particulars (per Rule 3 of the Rules) were silent as to any demand made on the petitioner-company or any effort to settle with the employer prior to approaching the Government.
  4. There was no documentary evidence that Respondent No. 3 made a prior demand on the petitioner-company; the Conciliation Officer did forward the claim to management and the management replied orally, but no written comments were filed.
  5. The Court relied significantly on the Supreme Court's decision in Sindhu Resettlement Corporation v. Industrial Tribunal, Gujarat, which it interpreted to establish that a workman must first raise the demand with the employer and have it refused before an industrial dispute (competent for State reference) can be said to have arisen. The Court treated contrary dicta of some High Courts as no longer good law where inconsistent with Sindhu.
  6. Applying Sindhu to the present facts, since no demand was shown to have been made on the petitioner-company prior to the application for reference, the Court concluded that no industrial dispute existed at the relevant time and the Government's reference was not competent.
  7. The Court also dealt with section 2-A (statutory insertion permitting reference of disputes between an individual workman and employer), holding it valid and that it permits an individual workman to be the subject of an industrial dispute; the Court explained that section 2-A should be harmonised with the rest of the Act and is not implicitly repealed.
  8. Lastly, on the petitioner's contention that the phrase "non-employment" in the reference was vague, the Court held that section 2(k) expressly includes disputes connected with "employment or non-employment." Citing Western India Automobile Association, the Court concluded "non-employment" covers retrenchment and refusal to reinstate and therefore the reference wording was adequate.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The order of reference dated 28-11-1968 is quashed and set aside, and the Labour Court, Delhi presided over by Shri R.K. Baweja is directed not to entertain the reference.

Implications (as stated or directly supported by the opinion):

  • Direct effect on the parties: The challenged reference is invalid and the Labour Court must not proceed with adjudication of that reference; there is no order as to costs.
  • On the law: The Court affirmed the principle (as stated by the Supreme Court in Sindhu Resettlement Corporation) that, ordinarily, a demand by workmen must first be made on the employer and rejected before an appropriate Government may properly refer a matter as an industrial dispute for adjudication. Applications to the Conciliation Officer or the Government without prior demand to the employer do not necessarily create an industrial dispute for the purposes of a Government reference.
  • On the status of individual workmen's disputes: Section 2-A (allowing a dispute between an individual workman and his employer to be the subject of an industrial dispute) is valid and must be harmonised with other provisions of the Act.
  • On administrative appointments: A temporary absence (leave) of a presiding officer does not create a "vacancy" under section 8 such as to justify appointment of another presiding officer to the same Labour Court; the Government should use constitution of a separate court (under section 7) or other proper measures when providing for temporary cover.
  • The Court indicated that earlier High Court authorities inconsistent with the Supreme Court's Sindhu decision cannot be treated as good law on that point; in particular, dicta suggesting a direct approach to Government without prior demand could constitute an industrial dispute were questioned.

Order concluding the opinion: "Order accordingly." No costs were awarded.

Show all summary ...

V.S Deshpande, J.:— This writ petition is directed against the order of the Delhi Administration passed on the 28th November, 1968 under section 10(1)(c) and 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, (hereinafter called ‘the Act’), copy of which being annexure ‘A’ to the writ petition, referring to the Labour Court at Delhi, presided over by Shri R.K Baweja, the following industrial dispute :

“Whether the non-employment of Shri Ajab Singh is unjustified and/or illegal and if so, to what relief is he entitled ?”

The undisputed facts leading to the above reference are as follows : Respondent No. 3 Ajab Singh was employed by the petitioner-company as Security Officer from 22-11-1961 till 4-7-1967, when he is said to have expressed his inability to work and resigned. He was, therefore, relieved of his duties on 4-7-1967. On 31-8-1967 ex-gratia payment was made to respondent No. 3 on the basis of compensation generally paid to workers who are retrenched from service. Respondent No. 3 accepted the payment and gave receipt in full and final settlement of all his claims. On 18-11-1967, respondent No. 3 requested for a service certificate which was issued by the petitioner-company, a copy being at annexure ‘C’ to the written statement. The petitioner-company has stated therein that respondent No. 3 had resigned from service and he has endorsed thereon that he received the certificate with thanks. Respondent No. 3 did not thereafter make any demand on the petitioner-company directly. He, however, appears to have written to the Labour Commissioner Delhi a letter, as per annexure ‘D’ to the written-statement, on 10-1-1968 stating that an industrial dispute existed between him and the petitioner-company and it was expedient that the matters specified in the enclosed statement should be referred to industrial adjudication. In the attached statement, it was stated that respondent No. 3's services were terminated by way of retrenchment by the petitioner-company and that the said retrenchment was wrongful and arbitrary. It was prayed that the said retrenchment should be set aside and respondent No. 3 should be reinstated in the service.

The petitioner came to know of the above only when a notice was received by it on 12-1-1968 from the Conciliation Officer, Delhi, calling upon the petitioner company to appear before the Conciliation Officer on 17-1-1968. The petitioner company resisted the claim of respondent No. 3 during the conciliation proceedings on the ground that there was no industrial dispute between the parties which could be referred to industrial adjudication. Nevertheless, the Delhi Administration made order of reference reproduced above. This order of reference was challenged by the petitioner-company on the following grounds :—

(1) The reference to the Labour Court presided over by Shri R.K Baweja was invalid inasmuch as Shri Baweja was on leave from 26th November, 1968 to the 1st of January, 1969 and during this period Shri Desh Deepak was appointed as the presiding officer of the Labour Court by an order dated 12-12-1968 at annexure ‘B’ to the writ petition;

(2) Respondent No. 3 did not raise any dispute with petitioner-company and hence respondent No. 1 Lt. Governor of Delhi, was not competent to refer the dispute to the Labour Court;

(3) The dispute, if any, between individual workman, like respondent No. 3 and the petitioner-company, is not an industrial dispute and cannot be referred to adjudication. Section 2-A of the Industrial Dispute Act, 1947 authorising such reference is bad and ultra vires : and

(4) The terms of the reference are so vague that no adjudication can take place on the basis of it.

In resisting the writ petition, respondent No. 3 reiterated that he did not resign but was retrenched from service and was paid retrenchment compensation. He also stated that he had requested the petitioner-company several times to reinstate him in service and that it was after the refusal to do so that he approached the Conciliation Officer. He averred that his retrenchment was illegal as Security Officers, who were junior to him were retained in service. He supported the order of reference as being valid.

It is the second contention urged by the petitioner which made this reference to the Division Bench necessary as certain High Court decisions and a general observation of a learned single Judge of this Court in the Management of M/s. Toshniwal Bros. Pvt. Ltd. v. Lt. Governor, Delhi & others (1) and of the Letters Patent Bench consisting of two of us in LPA 65 of 1968 decided on 18-3-1969, had to be re-examined in the light of the Sindhu Resettlement Corporation v. Industrial Tribunal Gujarat(2). We, therefore, proceed to consider the pros and cons of the above mentioned contention of the petitioner-company below.

(1) Reading the order dated 28-11-1968 with the order dated 12-12-1968, it is clear that the Labour Court is presided over by Shri R.K Baweja and that he does not cease to be the presiding officer of the Labour Court during the period of his leave. This is why the reference of the dispute has been made to the Labour court presided over by Shri R.K Baweja on 28-11-1968, though he had proceeded on leave from 26-11-1968 to 1st of January, 1969. Under sub-section (3) of section 20 of the Act, the proceeding before the Labour Court is deemed to have commenced on the date of the reference. This, however, is a commencement in the eye of law only. Physically, the order of reference may not reach the Labour Court on the same day and the parties to the dispute would not be before the Labour Court from the same date. This does not, however, prevent the pendency of the dispute before the Labour Court beginning from the date of the reference. Under Rule 10-B(1) of the Industrial Disputes (Central Rules, 1957 hereinafter called ‘the Rules’), the workmen have to file with the Labour Court a statement of their demands included in the order of reference within two weeks after receiving the order of reference. Under Rule 10-B(2) the opposite party has to file a reply within the next two weeks. Under Rule 10-B(3) the Labour Court shall ordinary fix the date for the first hearing of the dispute within six weeks of the date on which the dispute was referred to it for adjudication, provided that for reasons to be recorded in writing, it can fix a later date for the first hearing of the dispute. The statements, in the present case, could, therefore, be filed in the Labour Court presided over by Shri R.K Baweja and he could have fixed the date for hearing of the case on his return from leave in compliance with the above provisions of law. The reference was properly made to him and he was in a position to adjudicate upon the same.

The only disturbing element in the situation is the order dated 12-12-1968 by which Shri Desh Deepak is appointed as the presiding officer of the same Labour Court from 26-11-1968 to 1-1-1969, vice Shri R.K Baweja on leave. Under section 7(1), the appropriate Government may constitute one or more Labour Courts. The Labour Court presided over by Shri Baweja is one such Labour Court. Under section 7(2) a Labour Court shall consist of one person only to be appointed by the appropriate Government. It is, thus, clear that at one time one Labour Court can be presided over only by one person. Therefore, Shri Baweja and Shri Desh Deepak cannot be said to be simultaneously presiding over this Labour Court between 26-11-1968 and 1-1-1969. The intention of the Government that Shri Baweja continues to preside over this Labour Court during the period of leave is clear from the fact that on 28-11-1968 the Government referred the dispute to the Labour Court at present presided over by Shri R.K Baweja. The appointment of Shri Desh Deepak is purported to be made under section 8 of the Act. Section 8, however, refers to the filling of vacancies. It distinguishes a vacancy from a temporary absence. The absence of Shri Baweja on leave from actually doing the work of a Labour Court must be regarded as a temporary absence, inasmuch as the absence was not only for a short period, but after the leave Shri Baweja was to resume work and during the leave also he was to continue to remain to be the presiding officer of the Labour Court. In United Commercial Bank Ltd. v. Workmen,(3) Kania C.J, speaking for the majority of the Court discussed when a vacancy can be said to arise within the meaning of section 8 and when it does not arise due to a temporary absence of a member of the Tribunal. The absence of Shri Chandrashekar Iyer J. in that case could not be considered to be temporary firstly because he was appointed a whole time member of another Tribunal and secondly, initially it was not known how long he would continue to do the other duty. In Alok Kumar v. Dr. S.N Sharma,(4) the Supreme Court pointed out that a High Court Judge appointed to do another whole time work could not act as a High Court Judge so long as the other work lasted. In the United Commercial Bank's case, therefore, a vacancy within the meaning of section 8 had arisen. In the present case, on the other hand, Shri Baweja was merely on leave and it is well known that a leave is merely a period of rest and recreation, but the office is not demitted during leave. The reason for the insertion of the words “other than a temporary absence” after the word “vacancy” in section 8 by the amending Act 36 of 1956 was to clarify that a vacancy must be a permanent one and is not caused by the temporary absence of the presiding officer. The amendment, thus, seems to have given effect to the view of the Supereme Court expressed in the United Commercial Bank's case. For, when a vacancy is filled under section 8 of the Act, proceeding is continued from the stage at which the vacancy is filled. The intention obviously is to make a permanent arrangement necessitated by the occurance of a permanent vacancy. It is obvious that there was no “vacancy” within the meaning of section 8 caused by the going on leave of Shri R.K Baweja for a period of 34 days. The appointment of Shri Deepak as a presiding officer of the same Labour Court for these 34 days could not then be regarded as being made under section 8 though the Government Notification dated 12-12-1968 purports to do so.

We further consider whether the notification dated 12-12-1968 could be construed to be one under section 7 assuming that the mention of section 8 therein was wrong. A notification under section 7 would have to be for the constitution of another Labour Court, inasmuch as the Labour Court presided over by Shri Baweja still continued. The notification dated 12-12-1968 does not constitute a new Labour Court presided over by Shri Desh Deepak and cannot, therefore, be upheld under section 7 also.

We appreciate the desire of the Government to make some provision for the performance of the work of the Labour Court during the temporary absence of leave of its presiding officer, but the method adopted by the Government in the present case to achieve this purpose does not seem to be the right one. It is for the Government to consider if at all the object could have been achieved in some other way such as by the Constitution of a separate Labour Court presided over by Shri Desh Deepak under section 7 of the Act for the specified period and then by making an order under Section 33-B that the cases before the second Court should after these 34 days be transferred to the court of Shri Baweja.

The notification dated 12-12-1968 being unsupportable either under Section 8 or section 7 of the Act, the appointment of Shri Desh Deepak seems to be invalid. However, from 1-1-1969 Shri Baweja came back from leave and is actually presiding over the Labour Court. This reference which was made to him by name can be adjudicated upon by him. If during his leave any initial handling of this reference, such as issuing of notices to the parties was made by Shri Desh Deepak, it does not affect the jurisdiction of Shri Baweja to adjudicate on this reference. Even if the petitioner-company were to ignore whatever steps were taken by Shri Desh Deepak, all that would happen is that Shri Baweja may have to issue notice again to the petitioner-company. Fundamentally, the jurisdiction of Shri Baweja to adjudicate on the reference is not affected by the order of the Government dated 12-12-1968.

(2) Under section 10(1) of the Act, the appropriate Government is empowered to make a reference if it is of the opinion that an industrial dispute either exists or is apprehended. The reference at annexure ‘A’ to the petition is of an existing industrial dispute. We are not, therefore, concerned in this case with any apprehended dispute. The question is whether an industrial dispute existed before it was referred to the Labour Court. Section 2(k) of the Act defining an “industrial dispute” refers to a dispute or difference. This means that one party asserts something, which is denied by the other or that the demand of one party is refused by the other. Preamble of the Act says that the Act makes provision for the investigation and settlement of Industrial Disputes. Chapter II of the Act constitutes certain authorities to compose any material difference of opinion or to settle industrial disputes between the employers and the employees. Such authorities include Conciliation Officers as well as the Labour Courts. In Chapter III of the Act, Section 10 deals with the reference of the disputes by the appropriate Government for settlement to the authorities under the act and section 10-a deals with voluntary reference of the disputes by the parties to arbitration. Chapter IV has laid down the procedure, powers and duties of the authorities in dealing with industrial disputes. From the scheme of the Act, therefore it is clear that an industrial dispute must exist or must be apprehended before it can be referred by the appropriate Government under section 10(1) to the authorities mentioned therein. Section 12 which deals with the duties of the Conciliation Officer pre-supposes that an industrial dispute exists or/is apprehended before the Conciliation Officer can deal with it there-under. It does not contemplate that an Industrial dispute can arise for the first time during the proceedings before the Conciliation Officer. When the parties are unable to settle the dispute between themselves, an application is made under sub-section (2) of section 10 of the Act for reference of the dispute to an authority under the Act by the appropriate Government. The contents of such an application are to include, according to Rule 3(e) of the Rules, the efforts made by the parties themselves to adjust the dispute. This would also show that a dispute must exist between the parties before an approach is made to the appropriate Government for reference of the dispute to adjudication. The application made by respondent No. 3 in the present case is at annexure ‘D’ of the writ petition. It begins by saying that an industrial dispute exists between the parties. But the particulars of the dispute given in accordance with the requirements of Rule 3 are significantly silent about any demand made by respondent No. 3 against the petitioner-company. It does not say that any effort was made by respondent No. 3 to settle any dispute with the petitioner-company. The inference that arises is that no demand whatever was made by respondent No. 3 on the petitioner-company before he applied under section 10(2) to the appropriate Government, for such reference of the dispute for adjudication. Respondent No. 3 has not placed any documentary evidence on the record that he made demand on the petitioner-company before making the application under section 10(2). The referring Judge, therefore, called for the proceedings before the Conciliation Officer and found that the same application under section 10(2) was before the Conciliation Officer. The claim of respondent No. 3 was sent by the Conciliation Officer to the management for comments, but no comments were received in writing. The matter was, however, orally discussed and the management conveyed to the Conciliation Officer their defence on merits. As there was no possibility of settlement, the Conciliation proceedings were closed and a report was made by the Conciliation Officer to the Government. Under Section 12(5) of the Act on a consideration of this report, the Government was satisfied that there was a case for reference to the Labour Court and accordingly the reference at annexure ‘A’ to the petition was made.

The petitioner-company relies upon the Supreme Court decision in Sindhy Resettlement Corporation Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal of Gujarat(3), for the proposition that the reference is incompetent as no industrial dispute existed between the parties prior to the reference. In that case the demand on the management related only to retrenchment compensation and not to reinstatement. The Supreme Court, therefore, observed in paragraph (4) of the judgment as follows :—

“Since no such dispute about reinstatement was raised by either of the respondents before the management of the appellant, it is clear that the State Government was not competent to refer a question, “of reinstatement as an industrial dispute for adjudication by the Tribunal.” The dispute that the State Government could have referred competently was the dispute relating to payment of retrenchment compensation by the appellant to respondent No. 3 which had been refused. No doubt, the order of the State Government making the reference mention that the Government had considered the report submitted by the Conciliation Officer under sub-section (4) of section 12 of the Industrial Dispute Act, in respect of the dispute between the appellant and workmen employed under it, over the demand mentioned in the Schedule appended to that order; and, in the Schedule, the Government mentioned that the dispute was that of reinstatement of respondent No. 3 in the service of the appellant and payment of his wages from 21st February, 1958. It was urged by Mr. Gopalkrishana on behalf of the respondents that this Court cannot examine whether the Government, in forming its opinion that an industrial dispute exists, came to its view correctly or incorrectly on the material before it. This proposition is, “no doubt, correct, but the aspect that is being examined is entirely different. It may be that the Conciliation Officer reported to the Government that an industrial dispute did exist relating to the reinstatement of respondent No. 3 and payment of wages to him from 21st February, 1958, but when the dispute came up for adjudication before the Tribunal the evidence produced clearly showed that no such dispute had ever been raised by either respondent with the management of the appellant. If no dispute at all was raised by the respondents, with the management, any request sent by them to the Government would only be a demand by them and not an industrial dispute between them and their employer. An industrial dispute, as defined, must be a dispute between employers and employees, employers and workmen, and workmen and workmen. A mere demand to a Government, without a dispute being raised by the workmen with their employer, cannot become an industrial dispute. Consequently, the material before the Tribunal clearly showed that no such industrial dispute, as was purported to be referred by the State Government to the tribunal, had ever existed between the appellant Corporation and the reference, obviously committed an error in basing its opinion on material which was not relevant to the formation of opinion. The Government had to come to an opinion that an industrial dispute did exist and that opinion could only be formed on the basis that there was a dispute between the appellant and the respondent relating to reinstatement. Such material could not possibly exist when as early as March and July, 1958, respondent No. 3 and respondent No. 2 respectively had confined their demands to the management to retrenchment compensation only and did not make any demand for reinstatement. On these facts, it is clear that the reference made by the Government was not competent. The only reference that the Government could have made had to be related to payment of retrenchment compensation which was the only subject-matter of dispute between the appellant and the respondents.”

In our anxiety to understand precisely what the Supreme Court meant I studied the whole of their decision and also the Gujarat High Court decision reported in (1965) 2 LLJ 268, which was reversed by the Supreme Court. At page 271 of the report of the Gujarat High Court judgment it is stated that respondent No. 3 had made a complaint to his Union, respondent No. 2, who thereupon presented the demand to the Corporation for the reinstatement of respondent No. 3. But the Supreme Court has held that the evidence before the Tribunal clearly showed that no such demand was made by the workmen concerned or by the Union on the Management of the Sindhu Resettlement Corporation and I feel bound to accept this latter position. The Supreme Court has also clarified that even if the Conciliation Officer found that an industrial dispute existed and so reported to the Government, this could not be regarded as the existence of the industrial dispute which has to be founded upon a demand by the workmen on the employers. If this is the ratio of the Supreme Court decision, it cannot be said that an industrial dispute existed in the present ease as no demand was made by respondent No. 3 on the petitioner-company before he made an application under Section 10(2) for reference. In that event the fact that the demand of respondent No. 3 was forwarded by the Conciliation Officer to the petitioner-company and was not accepted by the latter would not constitute an industrial dispute. The observation in Standard Coal Company v. S.P Verma(5), in paragraph (15), that “where workers may consider it wholly useless to make a demand on the management and prefer to move the appropriate machinery set up by the Government for the redress of their grievances………it will be an industrial dispute” may not be correct if it is opposed to the above Supreme Court decision. In Goodyear (India) Limited v. Industrial Tribunal Rajasthan, Jaipur(6), Mehta J., purported to distinguish the decision of the Supreme Court in S.R Corporation v. Industrial Tribunal(7), referred to above, on the ground that in the case before him the employee had made an application to the Conciliation Officer challenging the termination of his services and requesting for reinstatement and the employer opposed the reinstatement. The learned Judge did not consider that in the Supreme Court case also the application to the conciliation Officer had been made. In accordance with the usual procedure the comments of the employer on the said application might have been called for by the Conciliation Officer and at this stage the employer may have opposed the demand for reinstatement. Nevertheless, the Supreme Court held that no industrial dispute regarding reinstatement existed. We have re-examined our decision in the Management of M/s. Toshiniwal Bros. Pvt. Ltd. v. Lt. Governor, Delhi(7), referred to above, dismissing the appeal against the decision of Kapur J. in that case(1). We find that in that case a demand by some workmen including all the workmen of the subordinate staff had at first been made on the Management and was refused by the Management. That dispute was not referred to industrial adjudication. Inasmuch as it had not been supported by a substantial number of workmen, but later the same industrial dispute in respect of the subordinate staff only was referred to industrial adjudication as between the management and the subordinate staff only. The subordinate staff did not repeat their demands to the management again before the reference was made. But the demand of the subordinate staff was included in the first demand made by them and some others on the Management. In that case, therefore, an industrial dispute between the subordinate staff and the management had come into existence before the said industrial dispute was referred to adjudication by the management. It is not quite clear if the following observation of Mack, J. in Kandan Textile Limited v. Industrial Tribunal Madras(8), takes the view that a demand not directly made on the Management could be made on the Labour Commissioner and would still constitute an industrial dispute. The observation is as follows :—

“This may have been in law an industrial dispute brought as it was to the notice of the Government by one of its responsible officers, which would have justified a reference to a Tribunal of a dispute of very limited scope.”

We are of the view that the decision of the Supreme Court in S.R Corporation v. Industrial Tribunal, Gujarat(2), referred to above, has finally established the proposition that a demand by the workmen must be raised first on the Management and rejected by them before an industrial dispute can be said to arise and exist and that the making of such a demand to the Conciliation Officer and its communication by him to the Management, who reject the same is not sufficient to consitute an industrial dispute. The decision and dicta of some of the High Court to the contrary can no longer be considered good law.

(3) It is clear that section 2-A enables the Government to refer to adjudication an industrial dispute between an individual workman and his employer. The previous view that an industrial dispute must be between the employer on the one side and the workmen collectively on the other side or at any rate the dispute of an individual workman must be sponsored collectively by the other workmen to constitute an industrial dispute is to that extent superseded by legislation. It is true that the insertion of section 2-A in the Act was not accompanied by consequential changes in the Act to make it clear that even a dispute between a single workman and the employer can constitute an industrial dispute. But the relevant provision in the Act referring to “workmen” would henceforth have to be construed as including “workman”, so that section 2-A is harmonised with the rest of the provision of the Act. At any rate section 2-A being a later provision is in no danger of being impliedly repealed by the older provisions. The implied repeal can only be of an older provision by a later provision. Further, the expression “industrial dispute” as used in entry 29 of the Concurrent Legislative List in the Government of India Act, 1935 was not based on any judicial decisions construing the said expression as relating only to a dispute between the workmen collectively and their employer. It cannot be said, therefore, that the use of the said expression in the Act necessarily meant a dispute between the employer and the workmen collectively. Entry 22 of the Concurrent List of the Constitution, therefore, did not use the said expression as being restricted to disputes of workmen collectively. Parliament was, therefore, competent to enact Section 2-A under entry 22 of the Concurrent List of the Constitution. Even if it is assumed for the sake of argument that entry 22 of the Concurrent List was not wide enough to include the dispute of an individual workman with his employer, Parliament could legislate about such an individual dispute under the residuary entry 97 of the Union List read with Article 248 of the Constitution, on the ground that the subject fell outside the Concurrent List and the State List of the Constitution and the Parliament had, therefore, unrestricted power to legislate upon it. This contention has therefore, no substance.

(4) The claim of respondent No. 3 in annexure ‘D’ is for the setting aside of the retrenchment and for the reinstatement. According to his learned counsel it is covered by items 3 and 6 of the Second Schedule and item 10 of the Third Schedule of the Act. The learned counsel for the petitioner, however, contends that the word “non-employment” used in the reference is vague. This argument overlooks the fact that the very definition of “industrial dispute” in section 2(k) of the Act says that the dispute or difference which is connected with “the employment or non-employment” is an industrial dispute. The word “non-employment” would, therefore, include retrenchment as well as refusal to reinstate, which is the grievance of respondent No. 3. We are fortified in this view by the decision of the Federal Court in Western India Automobile Association v. Industrial Tribunal, Bombay(9), and the Gujarat High Court decision in Sindhu Resettlement Corporation v. Industrial Tribunal(10), which was not reversed by the Supreme Court on this point.

For the above reasons, we quash and set aside the order of reference dated 28-11-1968, copy iof which is at annexure ‘A’ to the writ petition, and direct the Labour Court, Delhi, presided over by Shri R.K Baweja not to entertain the same. We make no order as to costs.

A.N.K Order accordingly.