Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Radhey Sham Sawhney And Another Petitioners v. Bawa Joginder Singh Bhalla And Another S

Delhi High Court
Sep 24, 1968
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter arises from a defendants' revision under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure challenging an order of the Subordinate Judge 1st Class, Delhi dated 13-9-1967. The Subordinate Judge had repelled the defendants' jurisdictional objection to a suit being tried under Order 37 of the Code and, in the same order, considered and disposed of the defendants' application for leave to defend. That order directed the defendants to deposit by way of security Rs. 500 (admitted by them to be due) together with Rs. 75 estimated costs, and to furnish security for the balance of Rs. 1,200 together with estimated costs of Rs. 200.

On revision the principal question raised by the defendants was whether the trial Court had jurisdiction to entertain the suit under Order 37 in view of changes arising from the enforcement of the Delhi High Court Act (1966). The Single Judge referred a central question for consideration by a Division Bench. The Division Bench heard argument and delivered its decision, after which the matter was sent back to the Single Bench for final disposal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the amendment to Rule 1 of Order 37 (as made by the Lahore/Punjab High Court) — which, as amended, expressly applied Order 37 to the Courts of the District Judges and Subordinate Judges of the First Class in the Union Territory of Delhi — continued to be operative in those Delhi Courts after the coming into force of the Delhi High Court Act (appointed day 31-10-1966).
  2. Whether the creation of a separate High Court for Delhi (and the transfer of rule-making power to the new High Court under the Delhi High Court Act) caused the amendment previously made by the Punjab High Court to cease automatically to have effect in the subordinate Courts in the Union Territory of Delhi.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant-Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The defendants (through learned counsel Shri Sehgal) argued that the amendment to Order 37, Rule 1 relied upon by the trial Court was made by the High Court when it had jurisdiction (Lahore/then Punjab High Court) and that with the enforcement of the Delhi High Court Act (and the Punjab High Court ceasing to exercise jurisdiction over Delhi), those amendments could not continue to bind the subordinate Courts in Delhi unless the High Court of Delhi itself enacted similar rules.
  • The contention was that section 7 of the Delhi High Court Act vested the Delhi High Court alone with power to make rules and orders with respect to practice and procedure, and therefore rules made previously by the Punjab High Court in respect of subordinate Courts at Delhi must cease to have effect on the appointed day.
  • Counsel placed reliance by analogy on a Single Bench decision (Munnilal Kailash Chandra v. Akabai, AIR 1969 MP 130) concerning the effect of reorganisation on rules made under section 122 of the Code, to support the proposition that delegated rules do not continue automatically across territorial or constitutional changes.

Plaintiff’s Position (as presented in the opinion)

  • The plaintiff’s position, as set out in the opinion, was that once the amendment to Rule 1 of Order 37 had been validly made by a delegated authority (the High Court under section 122), and the conditions for making it had been satisfied, the amendment operated as if enacted in the body of the Code and should continue to have effect unless lawfully annulled or altered.
  • Put succinctly in the opinion: there was no justification for automatically deleting clause (d) of Rule 1 on the appointed day merely because a separate High Court (Delhi) had been created.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhondu Mal v. Muhammad Ahmad-Mushtaz Ahmad, ILR & Lah. 156 Upheld validity of High Court's exercise of power under section 122 to alter/add to rules in the First Schedule (i.e., validity of amendments made by a High Court under delegated power). The Division Bench treated the decision as establishing that a High Court validly exercising section 122 may lawfully amend a rule such as Rule 1 of Order 37; the ratio was applied to support the validity of the Punjab High Court's amendment.
Munnilal Kailash Chandra v. Akabai, AIR 1969 MP 130 Addressed whether rules made under section 122 by a High Court prior to territorial/reorganisation changes retained enforceability; held rules under section 122 were delegated legislation and governed differently from other transitional provisions. The Division Bench observed that the reported decision did not support the defendant's submission and, on the facts and reasoning, found the analogy inapposite to the Delhi situation.
Dr. Kishan Singh v. Bachan Singh, AIR 1942 Lah. 201 Relied on Empress v. Burah: where a subordinate authority is given conditional legislative power and conditions are fulfilled, the subordinate legislation becomes absolute; upheld validity of a rule amended by the Lahore High Court. The court invoked this decision to reinforce that rules lawfully made by a High Court under section 122, once the relevant conditions are fulfilled and the rules published, operate as part of the Code and their validity in the present case is not assailed.
Empress v. Burah, ILR 4 Cal. 172 Principle that when a subordinate authority is empowered to "legislate conditionally" and the conditions are fulfilled, the legislation becomes absolute. Quoted (via Dr. Kishan Singh) as an authoritative statement of the principle governing delegated rule-making; the Division Bench relied on this principle in concluding the Punjab High Court's amendment has continuing effect.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in sequential steps grounded in the text of the Code and the history of the relevant amendments:

  1. Identification of the textual amendment: The court reproduced Rule 1 of Order 37 as amended to show that clause (d) expressly applied Order 37 to the Courts of the District Judges and Subordinate Judges of the First Class in the Union Territory of Delhi.
  2. Source and validity of the amendment: The amendment had been made by the Lahore High Court (later acted upon by the Punjab High Court) under the power conferred by section 122 of the Code to annul, alter or add to rules in the First Schedule. The Lahore/Punjab High Court's exercise of this power previously had been upheld (Bhondu Mal), and the validity of the Punjab High Court's amendment was not challenged.
  3. On the legal effect of delegated rule-making: The court explained (drawing on Dr. Kishan Singh and Empress v. Burah) that when a delegated authority lawfully enacts rules within its competence and the conditions are satisfied, those rules become operative (effectively as if enacted in the Code) and do not automatically cease to exist merely because the delegate later ceases to exercise the power.
  4. Consideration of statutory text and transitional provisions: The court examined Part X of the Code (sections 121 and 127), which provide that rules in the First Schedule have effect as if enacted in the body of the Code until altered, and that rules made under sections 122–126, upon publication, have the same force within the local jurisdiction of the High Court that made them. The court interpreted these provisions as reinforcing the continued operative effect of validly made rules.
  5. Specific challenge under the Delhi High Court Act: Counsel for the defendants relied on section 7 of the Delhi High Court Act, contending that only the Delhi High Court could make practice-and-procedure rules for Delhi and that previous Punjab-made rules must cease. The Division Bench analyzed the text and purpose of section 7 and concluded that it was intended to carry forward the law in force immediately before the appointed day (with necessary modifications) to the Delhi High Court; it did not, on its plain reading, manifest an intention to revoke or automatically annul rules relating to subordinate Courts in Delhi which had been validly made earlier.
  6. Rejection of the defendant's position: The court found no authority or principle advanced at the Bar that justified holding that clause (d) of Rule 1 ceased to apply as of the appointed day. It rejected the proposition that the mere creation of a separate High Court for Delhi had the effect of nullifying, automatically, an amendment which had been validly enacted and applied to specified subordinate Courts in Delhi.
  7. Conditional continuity and future action: The court emphasized that while the amended Rule 1 continues to apply, the newly constituted Delhi High Court retains the power under section 122 to annul, alter or add to the provisions of Rule 1; the continued operation is subject to lawful action by the Delhi High Court, should it choose to exercise that power.
  8. Procedural disposition: Given the importance and frequency of the question, the Single Judge had referred the issue to a Division Bench for authoritative determination. The Division Bench made its ruling (as summarized above) and directed that the case return to the Single Bench for final disposal in accordance with this conclusion.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Division Bench held that Rule 1 of Order 37, as amended by the Punjab High Court, continues to apply to the Courts of the District Judges and of Subordinate Judges of the First Class in the Union Territory of Delhi.

Direct implications for the parties and proceedings:

  • The trial Court (Subordinate Judge 1st Class, Delhi) was competent to entertain and proceed with the suit under Order 37 in reliance on the amended Rule 1.
  • The revision was remitted to the Single Bench for final disposal consistent with the Division Bench's ruling.
  • The Division Bench recognized that the Delhi High Court may, in future, exercise its rule-making power under section 122 to alter or annul the provisions of Rule 1; until such action is taken by the Delhi High Court, the existing amended Rule 1 remains operative in respect of the specified Delhi subordinate Courts.

Broader implications and precedent: The opinion explains the legal basis for continuity of delegated rule-making across institutional changes and applies established principles (as cited) to the Delhi context. The text does not purport to set out further normative consequences beyond the direct effect on the present dispute and the observation that the Delhi High Court may itself alter the rule in due course.

Show all summary ...

I.D Dua, C.J (4-1-67):— This is the defendants' revision under section 115, Code of Civil Procedure, from the order of a learned Subordinate Judge 1st Class, Delhi, dated 13-9-1967 disposing of the defendants' objection questioning the jurisdiction of the Court below to entertain, try and dispose of the suit under Order 37 of the Code. The Court below repelled the defendants' challenge holding that even after the enforcement of the Delhi High Court Act (No. 2 of 1966), it was competent to entertain the present suit by virtue of the amended Rule of Order 37. The Court below also disposed of by the impugned order the defendants' application for leave to defend the suit. It directed deposit by way of security, by the defendants, of the amount of Rs. 500, which was admitted by the defendants to be due to the plaintiff, along with a sum of Rs. 75, the estimated costs thereon. In regard to the balance of Rs. 1,200 together with costs estimated at Rs. 200, the defendants were also directed to furnish security.

Before me on revision, the first and foremost challenge against the order of the Court below relates to its competence to entertain and proceed with the present suit under Order 37 of the Code. The argument forcefully pressed by the learned counsel for the defendant-petitioner is that the amendment in Order 37, Rule 1 of the Code, on which reliance has been placed, was made by the High Court of Lahore in 1923 and 1932 and that with the enforcement of the Delhi High Court Act, on 31-10-1966, unless the High Court of Delhi amends Order 37, Rule 1, as originally enacted, with the object of extending the operation of Order 37 to the civil Courts in the Union Territory of Delhi, the Court below could not assume such jurisdiction. Briefly put, the argument is based on the assumption that with the Punjab High Court ceasing to exercise jurisdiction over the Union Territory of Delhi, the amendment which was operative up to 30-10-66, must be deemed automatically to have exhaustive itself and to have died a natural death.

It is necessary at this stage to reproduce Rule 1 of Order 37 as amended, which was admittedly in force up to 30-10-66, and the validity of which up to that date has not been challenged before me. This Order prescribes summary procedure on negotiable instruments and Rule 1 reads as under :

“1. Application of order.—This order shall apply only to

(a) the High Courts of Judicature at Fort William, Madras and Bombay;

(b) the Court of the Judicial Commissioner of Sind;

(c) any other Court to which section 532 to 537 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1882, have been already applied; and

(d) the Courts of the District Judge and Subordinate Judges of the First Class of the Delhi Province and the Courts of the District Judges and Subordinate Judges of the First Class in the Civil Districts of Lahore and Amritsar in the Province of the Punjab.”

The amendment contained in clause (d) was made by the Lahore High Court pursuant to the power conferred by section 122 of the code which authorised it to annul, alter or add to all or any of the Rules in the First Schedule to the Code: High Court Rules and Orders, Vol I, Chapter 21, page 30. The validity of the exercise of the power under section 122 for the purpose of altering or adding to Rule 1 of Order 37 was upheld by a Division Bench of the Lahore High Court in Bhondu Mal v. Muhammad Ahmad-Mushtaz Ahmad ILR & Lah. 156 Now, it is axiomatic that if the delegated legislative authority makes a law within its competence as such delegate, then the law so made must continue to be operative, if the language so warrants, in spite of the delegated authority ceasing to exist. The delegate having exercised the power has achieved the object of the delegation and it is not necessary that the power to make the law delegated by the principal should continue in order to sustain the life of the delegated legislation. No authority has been cited, no precedent appealed to and no principle has been pressed into service in support of the proposition put forward by the defendant-petitioners' learned counsel. It is noteworthy that the language of clause (d) of Rule 1, as reproduced above, does not extend the application of Order 37 to the subordinate Courts functioning within the jurisdiction of the Lahore High Court or of the East Punjab High Court which came into existence on the partition of the country and which later became the Punjab High Court. On the other hand, the provisions of Order 37 were made applicable to the Courts of the District Judges and Subordinate Judges of the First Class in Delhi as also to some other Courts in the Civil Districts of Lahore and Amritsar. After the unfortunate partition of the country in 1947, the Courts at Lahore having remained within the jurisdiction of the Lahore High Court, which is now in Pakistan, Amritsar and Delhi continued to exercise the power conferred by the amended rule, even after 15-8-1947 by virtue of this very amendment. It is true that section 182 of the code empowered the High Courts mentioned therein to make rules regulating their own procedure and the procedure of the civil Courts subject to their superintendence and it was only by such rules that they were authorised to annul, alter or add to the rules in the First Schedule, but it being conceded that the amended Rule 1 of Order 37 was applicable to the Courts mentioned therein at Delhi up to 30-10-1966, the only question requiring consideration is, whether the mere enactment of the Delhi High Court Act, 1966, clause (d) of Rule 1 of Order 37, as lawfully added by the legislative delegate, ceased automatically to apply to them with effect from 31-10-1966.

The power conferred by section 122 is of course limited to the Courts subordinate to the High Court making the rules and this is understandable, for a High Court cannot claim power to make binding rules for Courts not within its superintendence. But it would also seem that as soon as the rules contained in the First Schedule are lawfully altered, then the rules as altered would have effect as if enacted in the body of the Code. Now, once the altered Rule 1 of Order 37 has the effect of being lawfully enacted in the body of the Code then the plaintiff may well argue that there is no justification for automatically deleting clause (d) from this Rule on 31-10-1966 merely because of the creation of the High Court of Delhi. In the interest of continuity, it may be contended that all the provisions of the Code lawfully enacted, continue to apply to the Courts at Delhi as hereto fore until they are varied in accordance with law, notwithstanding the delegated character of the legislative authority in regard to some of its provisions.

The question raised is of importance and is likely to arise very frequently. It is accordingly desirable to have it authoritatively settled by a larger Bench. The case may, therefore, be placed before a Division Bench within three weeks.

Order of the Divisions Bench

I.D Dua, C.J:— This case has been placed before us pursuant to my order of reference dated 14-11-1967 which may be read as a part of the present order. The only question requiring authoritative determination is whether the amendment made in Rule 1 of Order 37 of the Code of Civil Procedure by the Punjab High Court is still operative in the Courts of the District Judges and Subordinate Judges of 1st Class in the Union territory of Delhi. The submission eloquently pressed by Shri Sehgal on behalf of the defendant-petitioner is that under section 7 of the Delhi High Court Act No. 26 of 1966, the Delhi High Court alone has the power to make rules and orders with respect to practice and procedure and all rules made by the Punjab High Court with respect to such practice and procedure in relation to the subordinate Courts at Delhi must cease to have effect as soon as the Punjab High Court ceased to have jurisdiction over such subordinate Courts. In support of his submission, Shri Sehgal has cited a Single Bench decision of the Madhya Pradesh High Court by Shiv Dayal, J. in Munnilal Kailash Chandra v. Akabai AIR 1969 MP 130. The question arising for decision in the reported case was whether the Rules made by the High Court at Nagpur in exercise of the powers conferred under section 122, Civil P.C, and which were in force in the former State of Madhya Pradesh as it existed before the Reorganisation of States on 1-11-1956, were enforceable in that territory of the new Madhya Pradesh which up to 31-10-1950 was called the Part B State of Madhya Bharat. Section 54 of the States Reorganisation Act, 1956 falling in Part V of that Act was held not to apply to the Rules made under section 122, Civil P.C because that section referred to only those laws, rules and orders which dealt with the practice and procedure “in the High Court” and not those which deal with practice and procedure “in all Courts”. A rule made by a High Court under section 122, Civil P.C, was, according to the reported decision, a piece of delegated or subordinate legislation and was governed by section 119 and not by section 54 of the States Reorganisation Act. It is obvious that the reported case does not support Shri Sehgal's submission. I may here reproduce the following observations from the reported judgements :

“It is obvious enough that any of the rules in “the first schedule of the Code could be annulled, altered or added to by such rules as a High Court made under that power. Rules made in exercise of that power became a part and parcel of the First Schedule of the Civil Procedure Code so far as that State was concerned. In that view of the matter, the rules made by the High Court of the ‘corresponding State’ of Madhya Pradesh (that is, the former M.P which existed prior to November 1, 1956) continued to be operative in those territories of the new Madhya Pradesh State even after November 1, 1956. But since they have not yet been adapted under S. 120 of the States Reorganisation Act for the other territories of the ‘corresponding new State’ (that is, the present State of Madhya Pradesh) they are not operative and cannot regulate the procedure of the Civil Courts there. The territories of the former State of Madhya Bharat are, therefore, outside the operation of those rules.”

The observations just reproduced, if I may say so, run counter to the counsel's submission. The learned counsel then attempted to seek some assistance by way of analogy from the High Courts (Punjab) Order, 1947 made by the Governor-General at the time of the unfortunate partition of the Punjab in 1947 when India became independent, but that analogy, in our view, is of little guidance because the two situations are far from parallel.

Rule 1 of Order 37, Civil P.C was originally amended by the Lahore High Court in 1923 and 1932. According to the amendment, as it stood at the time of the partition of the country, Order 37 was applicable to the Courts of the District Judge and Subordinate Judges of the First Class of Delhi Province and the Courts of the District Judges and Subordinate Judges of First Class in the civil Districts of Lahore, and Amritsar in the Province of Punjab. On the partition of the country in 1947, Lahore was included in Pakistan and Delhi and Amritsar in India. These two latter towns fell within the jurisdiction of the East Punjab High Court created by the High Courts (Punjab) Order, 1947. Later, the Punjab High Court took action under section 122 of the Code of Civil Procedure and amended, among other rules contained in the First Schedule of the Code, Rule 1 of Order 37. The amended rule so far as relevant for our purpose, reads as under :

“Order XXXVII, Rule 1.—Summary Procedure on Negotiable Instruments—This order shall apply only to—

(a) * * * * * *

(b) * * * * * *

(c) * * * * * *

(d) the Courts of the District Judges and Subordinate Judges of the First Class of the Union Territory of Delhi and the Courts of the District Judges and Subordinate Judges of the First class in the civil district of Amritsar in the State of the Punjab.”

(See pp. 39 & 40 of Chapter 21 of Vol. 1 of the Rules and orders of the Punjab High Court). This statutory amendment of Order 37, Rule 1, was lawfully effected by the Punjab High Court by virtue of the power delegated to it under section 122 of the code. Indeed, the validity of the amendment has not been challenged on the ground of want of power in the High Court or any other ground. In the referring order dated 14-11-1967, reference has been made to a Bench decision of the Lahore High Court in Bhondu Mal's case upholding the validity of the rule made by the Lahore High Court. The ratio of that decision fully applies to the rule in question as altered by the Punjab High Court after partition.

Turning now to the scheme of Part X of the Code dealing with the Rules, section 121 lays down that the rules in the First Schedule shall have effect as if enacted in the body of the Code of Civil Procedure until annulled or altered in accordance with the provisions of that part. section 127 lays down that the rules made and approved as provided in sections 122 to 126, shall be published in the Official Gazette and, from the date of publication or from such other date as may be specified, have the same force and effect within the local limits of the jurisdiction of the High Court which made them as if they had been contained in the First Schedule. In Dr. Kishan Singh v. Bachan Singh AIR 1942 Lah. 201, a Division Bench of the Lahore High Court (Tek Chand and Beckett JJ.), while upholding the validity of Rule 23-A of Order 41, Civil P.C, as amended by the Lahore High Court, relied on the observations of Lord Selborne in Empress v. Burah ILR 4 Cal. 172, that when power is given to a subordinate authority to “legislate conditionally” and “the conditions have been fulfilled, the legislation becomes absolute.” The ratio of the decision in Dr. Kishan Singh's case fully applies to the case in hand and the validity of Rule 1 of Order 37, as amended by the Punjab High Court, has rightly been not assailed.

It is undoubtedly true that section 127 of the Code lays down that the rules made, approved and published have the same force and effect within the local limits of the jurisdiction of the High Court which made them. Section 122 also empowers the High Courts mentioned therein to make rules regulating their own procedure and the procedure of the civil Courts subject to their superintendence. But even without this clause, the rules made by the High Courts could not possibly operate beyond their territorial jurisdiction The question requiring determination in the present case is that when Rule 1 of Order 37 has been validly amended by the Punjab High Court so as to apply the summary procedure on negotiable instruments to the Courts of the District Judges and Subordinate Judges of the First Class of the Union Territory of Delhi, can this amendment be held automatically nullified merely because a separate High Court has been set up for such Union territory ? In other words, do sections 122 and 127 of the Code have this effect ? Nothing has been said at the Bar in support of this proposition. All that has been argued is that these rules relate to practice and procedure in the Courts subordinate to the High Court and, therefore, section 7 of the Delhi High Court Act does not continue them. This section, according to the argument saves from discontinuance only the law in force immediately before the appointed day with respect to practice and procedure of the High Court of Punjab and not the law so in force with respect to practice and procedure in Courts subordinate to the High Court. This argument, though prima facie attractive, seems to me to be difficult to sustain. Section 7 appears to have been intended to apply, the law in force immediately before the appointed day with respect to practice and procedure in the High Court of Punjab with necessary modifications, to the High Court of Delhi, to which obviously such rules were not, and could not be, applicable before the appointed day, for the simple reason that the High Court of Delhi did not exist before the appointed day. This section, on its plain reading, does not seem to contemplate the negative by excluding the applicability of the law in force immediately before the appointed day with respect to practice and procedure in the Courts of the District Judges and Subordinate Judges of the First Class in the Union territory of Delhi. The Parliament, in my view, did not intend by enacting section 7 that Rule 1 of Order 37, as indisputably applicable in express terms to the subordinate Courts in the Union Territory of Delhi, would cease to apply to them with effect from the appointed day. The Courts of the District Judges and of Subordinate Judges of the First Class in the Union Territory of Delhi having been expressly included in the amendment made by the Punjab High Court in Rule 1 of the Order 37, nothing contained in sections 121 and 127, in my view, would automatically repeal this part of Rule 1 or render this part of the amendment ineffectual or inoperative with effect from the appointed day. Section 127, prescribing publication of the rules, emphasises the initial enforcement of the rules within the local limits of the jurisdiction of the High Court making them. I am not inclined to construe this section to lay down that as soon as the High Court making the rule is replaced by another High Court, the rule validly made and applied to the proceedings in certain specified Courts in a given locality, would lose its vitality in regard to them. In the absence of clear indication, I find it difficult to impute such intendment to the Legislature. No principle has been brought to our notice and no precedent has been cited in support of the submission pressed by Shri Sehgal. The Punjab High Court having validly exercised its legislative power as a delegate in suitably adding to Rule 1 of Order 37 so as to make it applicable to certain specified Courts in the Union territory of Delhi. In my view, this rule as amended continues to apply to the relevant legal proceedings in those Courts in just the same way as the main body of the Code of Civil Procedure applied to them, the creation of the Delhi High Court notwithstanding. Of course it is open to the Delhi High Court at any time to again annul, alter or add to the provisions of Rule 1 of Order 37, but so long as this Court does not choose to take action under section 122 of the Code, the existing Rule 1 must continue to apply to the Courts specified therein.

As a result of the foregoing discussion, I am inclined, as at present advised, to hold that Rule 1 of Order 37, as amended by the Punjab High Court, would continue to apply to the Courts of the District Judges and of Subordinate Judges of the First Class in the Union Territory of Delhi. The case will now go back to the Single Bench for final disposal of the revision.

S.K Kapur, J.—I agree.

A.N.K Order accordingly.