Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Orissa Cement Ltd. Petitioner v. The Commissioner Of Income Tax, Delhi

Delhi High Court
Oct 11, 1968
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench "A", by a consolidated statement of case made at the instance of both the assessee and the Commissioner of Income-tax, referred five questions to the Court concerning the assessment year 1957-58. The questions concerned: (i) whether wealth-tax paid was allowable as a deduction under section 10(1) or 10(2)(xv) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922; (ii) whether a payment of Rs. 1,00,000 to the Congress Party was an allowable deduction under the same provisions; (iii) whether an excess dividend tax by withdrawal of corporation tax rebate could be levied and collected under the Income-tax Act, 1922 (in light of provisions in the Finance Act, 1957); (iv) whether legal charges incurred for obtaining a loan from the Industrial Finance Corporation were allowable in computing business profits; and (v) whether development rebate was allowable on certain sanitary and drainage fittings of value Rs. 46,877.

The first four questions were referred at the instance of the assessee and the fifth at the instance of the Commissioner. The Court received the Tribunal's statement of case and proceeded to answer the referred questions, in some instances disposing the reference and in others remitting matters for further particulars.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether wealth-tax of Rs. 85,835.40 (as finally determined under the Wealth-tax Act) paid for 1957-58 is allowable against profits and gains of the company's business under section 10(1) or 10(2)(xv) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922?
  2. Whether the sum of Rs. 1,00,000 being contribution to the Congress Party is an allowable deduction under section 10(1) or 10(2)(xv) of the Income-tax Act, 1922?
  3. Whether the levy of excess dividend tax by withdrawal of corporation tax rebate can be made and collected under the Income-tax Act, 1922 (having regard to provisos to Paragraph D of Part II of the Finance Act, 1957)?
  4. Whether legal charges of Rs. 1,10,138 incurred for obtaining a loan from the Industrial Finance Corporation are allowable in the computation of the assessee's profits and gains of business?
  5. Whether development rebate was allowable to the assessee-company on drainage and sanitary fittings of Rs. 46,877 (i.e., whether those items constituted plant or machinery for the purpose of section 10(2)(vi)(b))?

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • With respect to the Rs. 1,00,000 payment to the Congress Party, the assessee claimed (by letter dated 1.6.1961) that the payment was made for furtherance of the business, arguing commercial expediency: the factory's remote location caused supply problems (coal, packing bags, cement) which were effectively solved by the Government (ruled by the Congress party), and therefore the contribution was "wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the business."
  • The assessee further contended that the Government had provided benefits (an interest-free loan of Rs. 50 lakhs, subscription to Rs. 40 lakhs of preference capital, and agreement to buy cement for the Hirakud Dam), and that these benefits made the payment commercially expedient to secure continued government goodwill.
  • Regarding the development rebate on drainage and sanitary fittings, the assessee asserted that those items formed part of plant and machinery and were therefore eligible for development rebate under section 10(2)(vi)(b); this contention was accepted by the Tribunal but required factual particulars.

Revenue / Departmental Arguments

  • The Income-tax Officer and the Appellate Assistant Commissioner disallowed the Rs. 1,00,000 deduction to the Congress Party on the ground it was motivated by political consideration and had no connection with the assessee's business.
  • For the levy arising under the Finance Act, 1957 (question 3), the Revenue's position (as recorded) was that under the specified provisos the amount could be levied and collected; the Court records the assessee's counsel conceded this point in argument.
  • On the question of legal charges for obtaining the loan (question 4), Revenue's counsel (Mr. Dalip K. Kapur) argued that if a loan was taken for acquiring a capital asset, the expenditure incurred in obtaining that loan should be treated as capital expenditure (hence not deductible as revenue expenditure).
  • The Appellate Assistant Commissioner treated the drainage and sanitary fittings as part of the building (not plant) and disallowed development rebate on that basis.

Tribunal / Earlier Findings

  • The Tribunal recorded that the Rs. 1,00,000 payment to the Congress Party had been "rightly disallowed" by the departmental officers as having no connection with the business.
  • On the drainage and sanitary fittings, the Tribunal disagreed with the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and held those items constituted part of plant and machinery, entitling the assessee to development rebate; however, the Court found the printed record lacked adequate description and remitted the matter back for particulars.
  • For the wealth-tax question, the Court observed that the matter was concluded against the assessee by a prior Supreme Court decision (Travancore Titanium), which the Tribunal's reference brought to the Court's notice.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Travancore Titanium Products Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Kerala (Supreme Court) Held that wealth-tax paid under the Wealth-tax Act is not a permissible deduction under section 10(2)(xv) of the Indian Income-tax Act, because wealth-tax is imposed on the owner of assets and not on any commercial activity. The Court concluded that the first question must be answered in the negative and against the assessee, following Travancore Titanium.
Morgam (Inspector of Taxes) v. Tate & Lyle Ltd. (House of Lords) Upheld a Commissioner’s finding that expenditure spent to prevent nationalization (a campaign to preserve the company's existence) was "wholly and exclusively" for the purposes of the company's trade and therefore deductible. The Court distinguished this case as not comparable: that expenditure preserved the company's very existence, whereas here the payment to a political party lacked a direct and intimate business nexus; Morgam was held not to assist the assessee.
J.K. Cotton Spg. & Wvg. Mills Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax U.P. (Allahabad High Court) Disallowed a claim for a contribution to the Congress Parliamentary Board for lack of direct nexus between the payment and the payer's business. The Court expressed respectful agreement with this decision and relied on it in concluding the Rs. 1,00,000 contribution was not allowable.
India Cement Limited v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Madras (Supreme Court) Held that amounts spent towards stamp duty, registration fee and lawyer's fees for obtaining a loan from the Industrial Finance Corporation (secured by charge on fixed assets) were permissible deductions under section 10(2)(xv); the purpose for which the loan was intended was irrelevant to classification of the expenditure as revenue or capital. The Court followed India Cement and held the legal charges for obtaining the I.F.C. loan were revenue in nature and deductible; question four was answered in favour of the assessee.
Nagpur Electric Light and Power Co. v. Commissioner of Income-tax (Nagpur Judicial Commissioner, 1931, 6 I.T.C. 28) Held that the purpose for which a loan was required is irrelevant to the question whether the expenditure for obtaining the loan was revenue or capital expenditure. The Court cited and applied this principle (as quoted in India Cement) to reject the Revenue's contention that the purpose of the loan should determine the nature of expenditure.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed each referred question sequentially, applying precedent and statutory language where appropriate and noting factual deficiencies where they prevented final determination.

Question 1 (Wealth-tax deduction)

  • The Court applied the Supreme Court decision in Travancore Titanium which held that wealth-tax paid under the Wealth-tax Act is not deductible under section 10(2)(xv) because the tax is imposed on ownership of assets, not on a commercial activity.
  • Accordingly, the Court answered the question negatively and against the assessee.

Question 2 (Contribution to Congress Party)

  • The Court reviewed the administrative findings (Income-tax Officer, Appellate Assistant Commissioner and Tribunal) and the assessee's own explanation (letter dated 1.6.1961 asserting commercial expediency and reliance on governmental goodwill derived from loans, subscription to preference capital and purchase commitments).
  • The Court reiterated the legal principle that for allowance under section 10(2)(xv) an expenditure must be directly and intimately connected with the business, or laid out by the taxpayer in his character as a trader; mere remote or political connections are insufficient.
  • The Court found Morgam v. Tate & Lyle distinguishable because that expenditure was to preserve the company's very existence; here the Tribunal had found no connection between the political contribution and the business, and the Court agreed.
  • The Court also cited and approved the Allahabad High Court's decision in J.K. Cotton as supportive of disallowance where no direct nexus is established.
  • On the basis of the Tribunal's factual finding and the legal standard requiring an intimate connection with trade, the Court answered the question negatively and against the assessee.

Question 3 (Levy and collection under Finance Act, 1957)

  • The Court recorded that the assessee's counsel (Mr. K.K. Jain) conceded that under the specified provisos of Paragraph D of Part II of the Finance Act, 1957 the amount could be levied and collected, though the assessee had separately challenged the vires of that provision by a pending writ petition.
  • Because the point of law as to levy and collection was not contested before the Court (and counsel conceded the statutory power to levy), the Court answered the question in the affirmative and against the assessee.

Question 4 (Legal charges for obtaining IFC loan)

  • The Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in India Cement, which held that expenses (stamp duty, registration fee, lawyer's fees) incurred in obtaining a loan from the Industrial Finance Corporation were revenue in nature and deductible under section 10(2)(xv), and that the purpose for which the loan was obtained is irrelevant to characterisation of such expenditure.
  • The Court quoted India Cement at length to reject the Revenue's argument that the nature or purpose of the loan should determine whether expenditure was capital or revenue.
  • Applying this reasoning, the Court concluded that the tribunal's view that the expenditure was capital was incorrect, and therefore answered the question in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee.

Question 5 (Development rebate on drainage and sanitary fittings)

  • The Court noted that development rebate under section 10(2)(vi)(b) is available only for machinery or plant and not for building. "Plant" is defined in sub-section (5) of section 10 but the definition is not exhaustive.
  • Crucially, the Court observed that the printed record and the statement of case lacked the description and nature of the fittings (water-supply distribution lines, water-pipe lines, drainage and sanitary fittings) as to how and where they were installed and utilised—facts which materially affect whether items are plant.
  • Because the factual particulars necessary to determine whether the fittings were "wholly used for the purposes of the business" were missing, the Court found the statement of case insufficient to answer the question finally.
  • Consequently, the Court remitted the matter back to the Appellate Tribunal with directions to indicate the nature of the assets, their description and how and where they are installed and/or utilised, and to send a revised statement of case within two months.

Holding and Implications

Holding (summary of answers to the five referred questions):

  • Question 1 (Wealth-tax deduction): Answered in the negative and against the assessee — wealth-tax not allowable as a deduction under section 10(2)(xv), following Travancore Titanium.
  • Question 2 (Contribution to Congress Party): Answered in the negative and against the assessee — payment disallowed for lack of direct and intimate connection with the business.
  • Question 3 (Levy under Finance Act, 1957): Answered in the affirmative and against the assessee — the amount could be levied and collected under the specified provisos of the Finance Act, 1957 (the assessee had conceded this point before the Court, though validity challenge was pending separately).
  • Question 4 (Legal charges for obtaining IFC loan): Answered in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee — legal charges found to be revenue expenditure and allowable under section 10(2)(xv), following India Cement.
  • Question 5 (Development rebate on drainage and sanitary fittings): Not finally determined; matter remitted to Tribunal for further particulars — Court remitted to the Appellate Tribunal to provide a revised statement of case describing the nature, description and use/installation of the assets; the Tribunal to send the revised statement within two months.

Direct consequences on the parties: the reference instituted at the instance of the assessee is disposed of as indicated above (questions 1, 2 and 4 decided against or for the assessee as stated) with no order as to costs; the reference made at the instance of the Commissioner (question 5) is remitted to the Tribunal for further particulars. The Court did not purport to lay down any broader novel precedent beyond applying and following existing authorities; its decision primarily applied settled principles from cited precedents to the facts and record before it.

No other broader implications or newly established legal principles were discussed in the opinion beyond the Court's application and reliance on the cited authorities and statutory provisions.

Order signed by Kapur, J.; T.V.R. Tatachari agreed; A.N.K. ordered accordingly.

Show all summary ...

Kapur, J.:— By a consolidated statement of case made at the instance of both the assessee and the Commissioner of Income-tax, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, (Delhi Bench “A”) has referred the following five questions to the Court :—

“(i) Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case, wealth-tax of Rs. 85,835.40 (as finally determined under Wealth-tax Act) paid for 57-58 Wealth-tax assessment under the Wealth-tax Act, 1957, is allowable against profits and gains of the company's business under section 10(1) or 10(2)(xv) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922” ?

(ii) Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case the sum of Rs. 1,00,000 being contribution to the Congress party is an allowable deduction under section 10(1) or 10(2)(xv) of the Income Tax-Act, 1922?

(iii) Whether the levy of excess dividend tax by withdrawal of Corporation tax rebate can be made and collected under the Income-tax Act, 1922 ?

(iv) Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case the legal charges of Rs. 1,10,138 incurred for obtaining loan from Industrial Finance Corporation are allowable in the computation of profits and gains of the business of the assessee ?

(v) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the development rebate was allowable to the assessee-company on the sanitary and drainage fittings of Rs. 46,877 ?”

The first four questions were referred at the instance of the assessee and the fifth question at the instance of the Commissioner of Income-Tax. The period of assessment is the assessment year 1957-58.

The first question stands concluded against the assessee by the decision of their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Travancore Titanium Products Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax Kerala .(1) In that case the Supreme Court held that the amount of tax paid on the net wealth of the assessee under the Wealth-tax Act not a permissible deduction under section 10(2)(xv) of the Indian Income Tax Act, in his assessment to income tax, for tax imposed under the Wealth Tax Act on the owner of the assets and not on any commercial activity. In this view the question must be answered in the negative and against the assessee.

Regarding the second question, the Income-tax Officer and the Appellate Assistant Commissioner declined to allow deduction of Rs. one lakh paid to the Congress Party on the ground that the same was motivated by political consideration and had no connection with the business of the assessee. The assessee went up in appeal before the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal and the Tribunal upheld the view of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner. Before the tribunal the assessee claimed on the basis of its letter, dated 1.6.1961, that the amount was paid for furtherance of the business. In the said letter it is, inter alia, stated:—

“Due to commercial expediency, the company has spent the same with a view to ensure smooth and efficient running of the factory. The factory is situated at a place far away from Calcutta and other places. Supply of coal, packing bags, supply of cement etc. envisage problems which are effectively solved by the Government, ruled by the Congress party. This contribution is, therefore, an expenditure, wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the the business.”

The assessee contended before the Tribunal that the Government had given to the assessee an interest-free loan of Rs. 50 lakhs. The Government has also subscribed for Rs. 40 lakhs worth of preference capital in the company and had also agreed to buy the entire cement for the Hirakud Dam, and since the Congress party was a ruling party the payment was motivated by commercial considerations. The Tribunal recorded the finding that “we have carefully considered the matter, but we think that the payment has been rightly disallowed by the departmental officers as having no connection with the business carried on by the assessee-company.”

While it is true that the expenditure incurred need not necessarily yield results or be incurred to directly benefit the business or be directly related to the earning of income yet it must be incidental to the business and must be necessitated or justified by commercial expediency. Before an expense can be allowed under section 10(2)(xv) it must be directly and intimately connected with the business and be laid out by the taxpayer in his character as a trader. The assessee has to establish a direct and intimate connection between the expenditure and the business i.e between the expenditure and the character of the assessee as a trader. In short only such expenditure can be allowed which is really incidental to the trade itself. An expenditure remotely connected with the trade does not qualify for permissible deduction. The learned counsel for the assessee relied on Morgam (Inspector of Taxes) v. Tate & Lyle Ltd.(2). In that case the assessee incurred expenditure in carrying out a “campaign” against the nationalization of sugar refining industry. The Commissioner recorded a finding that ‘the sum in question was money wholly and exclusively laid out or ‘expended-for the purpose of the company's trade and was an admissible deduction from its profits for income-tax purposes. “The House of Lords by a majority decided that the money was spent for the purposes of company's trade and to preserve the very existence thereof and the finding of the Commissioner was, therefore, correct. That case is of no assistance to the assessee as the expense incurred to prevent seizure of the company's assets could not but be accurately described as money expended for the purposes of enabling the company to carry on trade and earn profits. In this case the Tribunal has recorded a finding that the payment had no connection with the business of the assessee. I am inclined to agree with that view. It cannot be said that the expenditure is directly or intimately related to the business. The learned counsel for the assessee strongly emphasised the benefits received by the assessee from the Government by way of loan, purchases of preference shares and of cement for Hirakud Dam and the necessity, therefore, of helping the Congress in retaining power. There is nothing to show as to when all this happened. That apart, the expense was neither directly nor intimately connected with the business of the assessee as a trader.

In J.K Cotton Spg. & Wvg. Mills Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax U.P.(3) the Allahabad High Court disallowed such a claim on the ground of absence of direct nexus between the business of the assessee and the contribution made to the Congress Parliamentary Board. I am in respectful agreement with the view of the Allahabad High Court. I am not prepared to say that in no case can such an expenditure be allowed. An expense incurred voluntarily but wholly and exclusively for the expender's trade may in given circumstances, be a permissible deduction even though it ensures to some extent to a third parties' benefit. Similarly payments for political purposes may be for the purposes of the trade. In all such cases a link between the trade and the payment has to be established. I would in the circumstances, rest my decision in this case on the failure of the assessee to show that necessary conditions for allowance of the amount as a deduction were satisfied. This question, therefore, must be answered in the negative and against the assessee.

That takes me to the third question. Mr. K.K Jain, the learned counsel for the assessee, conceded that under clause (ii) of the proviso to Paragraph D of Part II read with the further proviso to the said paragraph D of the Finance Act, 1957 the amount could be levied and collected. He, however, said that the assessee had challenged the vires of the said provision of the Finance Act, 1957 by a separate writ petition which is pending and it was not open to him to raise the question of the validity of the provision in this reference. In view of this the question must be answered in the affirmative and against the assessee.

The point arising in the fourth question is covered in favour of the assessee by the decision of their Lordships of the Supreme Court in India Cement Limited v. Commissioner of Income-tax Madras (4). It was held in that case that the amounts spent towards stamp duty, registration fee, lawyer's fees for obtaining a loan from the Industrial Finance Corporation secured by a charge on the assessee's fixed assets was a permissible deduction under section 10(2)(xv) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922.

Mr. Dalip K. Kapur, the learned counsel for the Revenue strongly emphasised upon the necessity looking at the purpose for which the loan was obtained. He contended that if a loan is taken for the acquisition of a capital asset the expenditure would be capital. That contention was expressly negatived by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in India Cement's case in the following words:—

“Although the conclusion of the High Court was correct, we are not able to agree with the principle that the nature of the expenditure incurred in raising a loan would depend upon the nature and purpose of the loan. A loan may be intended to be “used for the purchase of raw material when it is negotiated, but the company may, after raising the loan, change its mind and spend it on securing capital assets. Is the purpose at the time the loan is negotiated to be taken into consideration or the purpose for which it is actually used. Further suppose that in the accounting year the purpose is to borrow and buy raw-material but in the assessment year the company finds it unnecessary to buy raw-material and spends it on capital assets. Will the Income-tax Officer decide the case with reference to what happened in the accounting year or what happened in the assessment year. In our opinion, it was rightly held by the Nagpur Judicial Commissioner in Nagpur Electric Light and Power Co. v. Commissioner of Income-tax, (1931) 6 I.T.C 28, that the purpose for which the new loan was required was irrelevant to the consideration of the question whether the expenditure for obtaining the loan was revenue expenditure or capital expenditure.

To summarise this part of the case, we are of the opinion that : (a) the loan obtained is not an asset or advantage of an enduring nature; (b) that the expenditure was made for securing the use of money for certain period; and (c) that it is irrelevant to consider the object with which the loan was obtained. Consequently, in the circumstances of the case, the expenditure was revenue expenditure within section 10(2)(xv).”

In these circumstances, I am not in agreement with the view taken by the Tribunal that the expenditure was of a capital nature. The question must, therefore, be answered in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee. That disposes of the reference at the instance of the assessee.

Now I take up the fifth question referred at the instance of the Commissioner.

During the accounting year the assessee made additions to the assets of the company consisting, inter alia, of water-supply distribution lines, water-pipe lines, drainage and sanitary fittings. The Income-tax Officer disallowed development rebate on these items. On appeal by the assessee the appellate Assistant Commissioner decided that drainage and sanitary fittings, which were of the value of Rs. 46,877, did not form part of the plant and machinery but were a part of the building and no development rebate could be allowed thereon. In respect of the first two items he found that the development rebate had not been claimed before the Income-tax Officer and he directed the Income-tax Officer to look into the matter. On further appeal by the assessee to the Tribunal the Tribunal came to the conclusion that the items of drainage and sanitary fittings constitute part of plant and machinery and not of building as held by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the assessee was, therefore, entitled to development rebate thereon.

It may be pointed out that under section 10(2)(vi)(b) development rebate is allowed only in respect of machinery or plant and not on building as in the case of depreciation. Plant has been defined under sub-section (5) of section 10 of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, as including vehicles, books, scientific apparatus and surgical equipment purchased for the purpose of business, profession or vocation. The definition is not exhaustive and the question, therefore, is whether or not the drainage and sanitary fittings constitute part of the plant or machinery. The nature of the items and their description is neither available on the printed record sent to us nor in the statement of the case. Whether or not the items constitute plant which is “wholly used for the purposes of the business carried on by the assessee” will, to a considerable extent, depend on their description and the nature of use. I am not, therefore, satisfied that the statement of the case is sufficient to enable me to determine the question raised. I would, therefore, refer the case back to the Appellate Tribunal for the purposes of indicating the nature of the assets, their description and how and where they are installed and/or utilised. The Tribunal will send the revised statement of case within two months. The reference at the instance of the assessee is, therefore, disposed of as discussed above with no order as to costs while that of the Commissioner sent back to the Tribunal for a further statement of case.

T.V.R Tatachari.—I agree

A.N.K Order accordingly.