- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State v. Mehar Chand .
Factual and Procedural Background
This reference arises from the case of Mehar Chand, who was initially arrested by the Delhi police under section 364 I.P.C. for kidnapping or abducting Hima Ram with intent to murder. After the statutory remand period expired, he was confined in judicial lock-up under the Magistrate's orders pursuant to section 344 Cr.P.C. During investigation, the police found evidence implicating him in offences under sections 302 and 201 I.P.C. for murder and concealment of evidence related to Hima Ram’s death. The police sought to remand him again to police custody for further investigation, but the Magistrate refused this request. The State filed a revision application, which was allowed by the Sessions Judge who recommended setting aside the Magistrate's order and directed that the accused be formally arrested in court and remanded to police custody for up to 15 days under section 167(2) Cr.P.C. This reference was made to address the legal question arising from that recommendation.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an accused who is already in judicial custody under section 344 Cr.P.C. for one offence can be remanded to police custody for investigation of more serious offences discovered during the same investigation.
- Whether the police can make a formal arrest of an accused already in judicial custody for additional offences under the same case or if this is permissible only in a different case.
- The scope and application of sections 344 and 167 Cr.P.C. regarding detention, remand, and police custody in continuing investigations involving multiple charges.
Arguments of the Parties
State's Arguments
- The State relied on the Division Bench decision in State v. Sukh Singh (A.I.R 1954 Raj. 290), which held that an accused kept in jail under section 344 Cr.P.C. can be handed over to police custody in another case for investigation purposes.
- The police argued that further investigation into more serious offences required remanding the accused to police custody, even if the offences arose from the same case.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent contended that the ruling in State v. Sukh Singh did not apply because it permitted handing over the accused to police only when required in a different case, not in the same case.
- He argued that the offences under sections 302/201/34 I.P.C. were part of the same case originally registered under section 364 I.P.C., thus no new case existed warranting a fresh police custody remand.
- The respondent further argued that section 167 Cr.P.C. regulates the Magistrate's power to remand and requires that the accused be arrested for the offence under investigation, which was not possible since he was already in judicial custody.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State v. Sukh Singh, A.I.R 1954 Raj. 290 | Held that an accused detained under section 344 Cr.P.C. can be handed over to police custody for investigation in another case. | The Court considered this precedent in determining whether the accused could be remanded to police custody for further investigation of additional offences discovered during the same case, ultimately finding no principled distinction between remand in another case and remand for further investigation in the same case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the statutory scheme governing detention and remand under the Code of Criminal Procedure, particularly sections 167 and 344. It identified three stages of custody: initial 24-hour detention by police, up to 15 days remand by Magistrate under section 167(2), and extended detention under section 344 when investigation cannot be completed within 15 days. The Court emphasized that section 344 applies when reasonable grounds exist to believe the accusation is true and investigation requires continuation beyond 15 days.
The Court rejected the respondent’s distinction that the accused could only be handed over to police custody in a different case, holding that the same principle applies when new charges arise during the same investigation. It reasoned that the Magistrate’s role is to supervise custody but should not obstruct police investigation. The Court further held that the police can formally arrest the accused again for the new offences, even though he is already in judicial custody, and the Magistrate may remand him to police custody under section 167(2) for up to 15 days if satisfied a good case exists.
Accordingly, the Court accepted the Sessions Judge's recommendation to set aside the Magistrate’s refusal and to allow formal arrest and remand to police custody for further investigation.
Holding and Implications
The Court's final decision is in favour of the State, directing that the Magistrate should bring the accused before the Court, allow a formal arrest for the new offences, and remand him to police custody for a maximum of 15 days under section 167(2) Cr.P.C.
The direct effect of this decision is to permit continued police custody and investigation of additional offences discovered during an ongoing case, even if the accused is already in judicial custody under section 344 Cr.P.C. The opinion clarifies that the procedural protections of the Code do not prevent police from formally arresting and remanding the accused anew for further investigation in the same case. No broader precedent beyond the facts was established.
Hardayal Hardy, J.:— This reference by the Sessions Judge, Mahasu Sessions Division raises an interesting question of law and arises in the following circumstances:— Respondent Mehar Chand was arrested by the Delhi police for an ofience under section 364 I.P.C on the allegation that he had kidnapped or abducted one Hima Ram in order that he may be murdered, and is presenty confined in judicial lock-up at Solan under the orders of the Magistrate 1st Class, Kasumpti after the statutory period of remand had him out under section 167 Cr.P.C The order of detention was passed under the provisions of section 344 Cr.P.C It appears that during the course of investigation the police came to the conclusion that besides the offence under section 364 I.P.C the accused-respondent was also involved in the offence punishable under section 302 I.P.C read with section 201, I.P.C for having caused the death of Hima Ram and for concealment or destruction of the evidence disclosing the commission of the offence of murder by him. The police therefore felt that the association of the accused-respondent with the police for further investigation had become necessary with a view to discover the concealment of the dead body which is ‘corpus delicti’ in the case. The police therefore with the object of making further investigation into the additional offence of which the accused-respondent was suspected to be guilty, moved the learned Magistrate for an order of his remand to police custody. The request was however turned down by the learned Magistrate by his order dated 28th January, 1967.
2. An application was thereupon moved by the State through the Public Prosecutor for revision of the learned Magistrate's order with a prayer that the respondent be ordered to be remanded to police custody in the interest of justice. The prayer of the State had found favour with the learned Sessions Judge who has recommended that the order of the Magistrate dated 28th January, 1967 be set aside. The learned Sessions Judge has also directed by the same order that the Magistrate should order the accused-respondent to be brought to his Court and then to allow the police officer to formally arrest him. After the respondent is thus arrested he should be handed over to the police custody for a maximum period of 15 days as provided in section 167(2) Cr.P.C The present reference is the result of the aforesaid recommendation and direction made by the learned Sessions Judge.
3. An examination of the order of the learned Sessions Judge shows that the police had first applied to the learned Magistrate on 7th January. 1967 for an order that the respondent be called from judicial lock-up and remanded to the police custody for 15 days. This was followed by another application on 27th January, 1967 wherein it was stated that the accused-respondent had previously been arrested in the course of investigation of an offence under section 364 I.P.C and had on the expiry of the period of remand been sent to the judicial lock-up. Thereafter a case under sections 302/201/34 I.P.C had been made out against the accused-respondent and therefore it was prayed that the police be permitted to make a formal arrest of the accused in the Court room and thereafter he may be remanded to police custody for 15 days.
4. Learned Magistrate's order on the first application made by the police was that the facts placed before him were not sufficient to enable him to accede to their request. As regards the second request made by the police, the learned Magistrate ordered that since the accused was already in judicial custody, the police could show the formal arrest while he was still in judicial custody in a symbolic manner without actually arresting him or taking him into custody. It is this order of the learned Magistrate which the learned Sessions Judge has recommended to be set aside with the additional direction mentioned above.
5. Mr. K.C Pandit learned Counsel for the State appearing in support of the reference has relied upon a Division Bench Judgment of Rajasthan High Court in State v. Sukh Singh . A.I.R 1954 Raj. 290., wherein it has been laid down that where an accused is kept in jail by orders of adjournment or remand under section 344 he can be handed over to the police in some other case for purposes of investigation.
6. Learned counsel for the respondent has argued that this ruling has no application to the present case as according to that decision the accused could be handed over to the police only when he was required in some other case” and not “in the same case”. He argued that the present proceedings against the accused do not relate to any other case; it is the same case which was orginally registered by the police in respect of an offence under section 364 I.P.C and is now under investigation in respect of an offence under sections 302/201/34 I.P.C There is therefore no new case. All that has happened is that there are different charges in the same case.
7. I do not think it is permissible to draw the distinction that the learned counsel for the respondent seeks to do. The scheme embodied in the Code of Criminal Procedure with regard to the custody and deten-tention of persons accused of cognizable offences appears to be this; the first stage is detention of the accused for a period of 24 hours; during this period the police have absolute discretion to detain the person anywhere they like during investigation. If the investigation cannot be completed within 24 hours the accused must be forwarded to the nearest Magistrate (See section 167(1)).
8. The second stage consists of detention for a total period of 15 days; the Magistrate to whom the accused has been forwarded by the police is authorized to order his detention in such custody as he thinks fit for a term not exceeding 15 days in all; (See section 167(2))”. The Code expects investigation to be completed within the period of 15 days, but sometime investigation must go on for more than 15 days for variety of reasons. There is therefore a third stage of investigation e.g the state after 15 days. Merely because investigation cannot be completed within the period of 15 days, and it is frequently so in investigation of serious crimes like dacoity and murder, it does not follow that the arrested person must be released from custody after the expiry of 15 days regardless of the nature of the accusation or information against him and regardless of the quantity of evidence so far available against him. A provision has therefore been made for continuing the arrested person's detention after 15 days in suitable cases. This provision is to be found in section 344.
9. It follows that section 344 is meant to be applied only in those cases where the investigation cannot be completed within 15 days and there is reasonable ground to believe that the accusation or information is true. The accused in such a case has to be remanded by the Magistrate for such time as he considers reasonable provided that no accused can be remanded to custody under this section for a term exceeding 15 days at a time.
10. While the accused is in custody as a result of an order made by the Magistrate under section 344. he may be found to be implicated in another case or as a result of the investigation already carried on by the police and the evidence collected by them he may be found to be implicated in a more serious offence than the one for which he was originally arrested. The investigation in both the cases is an investigation into crime which the police alone are authorised to carry out. The Magistrate's function is only to enquire into and try the offence after the police have completed their investigation and submitted a charge sheet against the accused. He cannot however hamper the police investigation by refusing to allow the police to perform their duties. The only object of restricting the power of the police to detain the accused in their custody to a total period of 15 days is to prevent the use of third degre-methods by them. But when there is no such allegation there is no apparent reason why the police should not be able to obtain the custody of the accused in order that they may question him or obtain his assistance in investigation in some other lawful manner. I fail to understand why if an accused who is in magisterial custody in one case can be allowed to be remanded to police custody in another case then the same rule should not apply to the accused who is in magisterial custody and is sought to be turned over to police custody at a subsequent stage of investigation in the same case when the information discloses his complicity in more serious offences. On principle, I can see no difference at all between the two types of cases.
11. Learned counsel for the respondent next argued that the Magistrate's power to remand an accused person to police custody is regulated by the provisions of section 167 Cr.P.C only. That section requires that before the Magistrate can pass an order of remand the accused person must have been arrested by the police for the offence which is under investigation and forwarded to such Magistrate. In the present case the accused-respondent was forwarded to the Magistrate after he had been arrested by the police for an offence under section 364 I.P.C If he is therefore to be remanded to police custody once again he must be arrested for the offence under sections 302/201/34 I.P.C and this is not possible so long as the accused is already under detention in magisterial custody. I see no insuperable difficulty in the way of the police arresting the accused for the second time for the offence for which he is now wanted by them. The accused being already in magisterial custody it is open to the learned magistrate under section 167(2) to take the accused out of jail or judicial custody and hand him over to the police for the maximum period of 15 days provided in that section. All that he is required to do is to satisfy himself that a good case is made out for detaining the accused in police custody in connection with investigation of the case. It may be that the offences for which the accused is now wanted by the police relate to the same case but these are altogether different offences and in a way therefore it is quite legitimate to say that it is a different case in which the complicity of the accused has been discovered and the police in order to complete their investigation of that case require that the accused should be associated with that investigation in some way.
12. I therefore accept the reference and direct that the learned Magistrate should order the accused to be brought to the Court and to allow the police to formally arrest him. The accused may then be handed over to the police custody for the maximum period of 15 days as provided in section 167(2) Cr.P.C
13. Reference answered affirmatively.
Alert