Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Navaneetha Krishnan v. State

Madras High Court
Apr 6, 2015
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

These connected Criminal Original Petitions arise from bail applications filed by the Petitioners against Orders of the Trial Court, the Assistant Sessions Judge, Tirupattur, Vellore District. The Petitioners are accused in cases registered by the Natrampalli Police under Sections 395 and 397 of the Indian Penal Code. The Trial Court granted bail on 21.8.2014 but imposed a condition requiring each Petitioner to deposit Rs. 25,000 as Cash Security for each case. The Petitioners, who are poor and unable to pay this amount, challenged this bail condition seeking its modification.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Trial Court can impose a condition requiring the accused to deposit a cash security amount as a prerequisite for bail, especially when the accused are poor and unable to pay such amount.
  2. Whether the imposition of a heavy cash security amount as bail condition amounts to denial of bail and violates constitutional protections under Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
  3. Whether the Trial Court failed in its constitutional duty to provide legal aid to the Petitioners in filing bail petitions.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Petitioners are very poor and cannot afford to pay Rs. 25,000 as cash security in each case.
  • They appeared in person before the Trial Court and have no means even to engage a lawyer.
  • The condition to deposit cash security is onerous and causes them hardship, effectively denying them the benefit of bail.
  • The Trial Court cannot straightaway require cash security without first directing execution of a bail bond with sureties.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The learned Government Advocate submitted that since the accused are involved in property offences, the condition of cash security was imposed to ensure their presence and safeguard the investigation and trial process.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan @ Pappu Yadav, 2004 (7) SCC 528 Principle that bail is generally the rule and jail the exception; bail may be refused for serious offences, habituality, or tendency to abscond. Cited to emphasize the general principle favoring bail subject to circumstances.
State Of U.P Through CBI v. Amarmani Tripathi, 2005 (8) SCC 21 Factors for refusal of bail in serious offences. Reinforced the discretion of courts in granting bail based on facts.
Sanjay Chandra v. C.B.I, 2012 (1) SCC 40 Considerations in bail applications involving serious allegations. Supported the principle that bail conditions must be reasonable.
Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2014 (8) SCC 273 Guidelines on arrest and bail to prevent unnecessary detention. Used to stress the importance of liberty and fair bail conditions.
State of Mysore v. H. Venkatarama Kotaiyah, 1968 Crl. L.J 696 Reasonable bail bond amounts and conditions. Referenced for the principle that bail conditions should not be excessive.
Moti Ram v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 1978 (4) SCC 47 Reasonableness of bail conditions. Applied to support the argument against arbitrary bail conditions.
Babu Singh v. The State of U.P, AIR 1978 SC 527 Judicial discretion in imposing bail conditions. Used to highlight the need for sound judicial principles in bail.
Gokul Das v. The State Of Assam, 1981 Crl. L.J 229 Reasonable bail conditions and cash security. Supported the view that cash security must be reasonable and not arbitrary.
Afsar Khan v. State of Karnataka, 1992 Crl. L.J 1676 Fairness in bail conditions. Referenced to emphasize non-oppressive bail conditions.
Bhikhabhai Udesinh Darbar v. State Of Gujarat, 1998 (1) GLR 315 Reasonableness and judicial discretion in bail conditions. Applied to underline judicial caution in imposing bail conditions.
Parades Patra v. State of Orissa, 1993 (2) OLR 452 Non-excessiveness of bail bond amounts. Used to reinforce the principle against onerous bail conditions.
Sandeep Jain v. National Capital Territory of Delhi, 2000 (2) SCC 66 Constitutional protection of personal liberty in bail matters. Supported the constitutional basis for reasonable bail conditions.
Amarjit Singh v. State Of NCT Of Delhi, 2002 (2) CTC 63 (SC) Judicial discretion and constitutional safeguards in bail. Referenced for the principle that bail conditions must not be arbitrary.
Sheikh Ayub v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 2004 (13) SCC 457 Reasonableness of bail conditions. Applied to support the non-excessive bail condition principle.
Ramathal v. Inspector of Police, 2009 (12) SCC 721 Judicial discretion in bail and bail bonds. Used to emphasize sound judicial discretion in bail conditions.
Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, AIR 1978 SC 597 Any law or procedure depriving life or liberty must be just, reasonable and equitable under Article 21. Fundamental to holding that onerous bail conditions violating personal liberty are unconstitutional.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by affirming the general principle that bail is the rule and jail is the exception, rooted in the constitutional guarantee of personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. It acknowledged that courts have broad judicial discretion to impose bail conditions to ensure the accused’s presence during investigation and trial, but such conditions must be reasonable, not arbitrary or oppressive.

The Court analyzed the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure, particularly Sections 440, 441, and 445, which regulate bail bonds and cash security. It held that a court cannot directly require a cash deposit without first directing the execution of a bail bond with sureties, and even then, the amount of cash security must be reasonable and not excessive.

The Court noted that imposing a cash security of Rs. 25,000 per case on poor accused, unable to pay or engage counsel, effectively defeats the purpose of bail and amounts to denial of liberty. This was held to be contrary to the constitutional principles established in Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India and international human rights covenants ratified by India.

The Court further observed that the Trial Court failed in its constitutional duty to provide legal aid to the Petitioners, who were unrepresented and poor, thus compounding the hardship caused by the onerous bail condition.

Accordingly, the Court set aside the cash security condition and directed release of the Petitioners on their own bond of Rs. 5,000 each, with conditions to appear before the Trial Court as required. It also directed the Trial Court to engage Legal Aid Panel Advocates for the Petitioners and to expedite disposal of the cases.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the Criminal Original Petitions and set aside the Trial Court’s direction requiring the Petitioners to deposit Rs. 25,000 as cash security for bail.

The Petitioners were ordered to be released on their own bond of Rs. 5,000 each, subject to their appearance at trial. The Trial Court was directed to ensure legal aid representation for the Petitioners and to expedite the trial process. The decision highlights the constitutional imperative that bail conditions must not be onerous or arbitrary, especially for poor accused, reaffirming the principle that bail is a matter of right and the denial of liberty must be reasonable and just. No new precedent was set, but the ruling reinforces existing constitutional and procedural safeguards against excessive bail conditions.

Show all summary ...

1. As these Petitions are connected on factual matrix and are directed as against the similar Orders of the Trial Court, they are tagged together and are being disposed of by this common Order.

2. These Petitions are filed under Section 439(1)(b) of Cr.P.C seeking modification of the Bail condition imposed by the learned Assistant Sessions Judge (Sub-Judge), Tirupattur.

3. The Natrampalli Police in Vellore District registered these cases under Sections 395 & 397, I.P.C as against the Petitioners.

4. Petitioners have sought for bail in these cases in the Court of Assistant Sessions Judge, Tirupattur, Vellore District.

5. On 21.8.2014, in all these cases, the Trial Court passed prototype Order granting them bail, however, directing them to deposit Rs. 25,000/- as Cash Security in each case.

6. Aggrieved, the Petitioners have directed these Criminal Original Petitions to modify the said Bail condition.

7. The details of the Petitions are as under:

Sl. No. Name of the Accused Crime No. Crl.M.P No. (Trial Court) S.C No Crl.O.P No. (High Court) 1 Navaneetha Krishnan 42/2011 52/2014 14/2013 4707/2015 2 Navaneetha Krishnan 55/2011 -do- 15/2013 4708/2015 3 Navaneetha Krishnan 41/2011 -do- 13/2013 4709/2015 4 Vinoth Kumar 41/2011 53/2014 13/2013 4710/2015 5 Vinoth Kumar 42/2011 -do- 14/2013 4711/2015 6 Vinoth Kumar 55/2011 -do- 15/2013 4712/2015 7 Sathish Kumar 42/2011 54/2014 14/2013 4713/2015 8 Sathish Kumar 55/2011 -do- 15/2013 4714/2015 9 Sathish Kumar 42/2011 -do- 13/2013 4715/2015

8. The learned Assistant Sessions Judge, Tirupattur granted them bail in the following terms and conditions:

“ORDER:

2. This Court issued Notice to the Respondent/Complainant and the Additional Public Prosecutor in Dis. No. 1719/2014, dated 19.08.2014

3. There is no reply from the Respondent/Complainant and the Additional Public Prosecutor and this Court passed the following order:

No reply from Police and Additional Public Prosecutor. The accused is in custody from 25.2.2011 The case is at under-trial stage. There is no necessity arise to detain the Accused in prison and no explanation from the side of State with reasonable cause to retain the Accused in judicial custody. This Court inclined to release the Accused on bail with following conditions:

1. Accused should deposit a sum of Rs. 25,000/- as Cash Security for each case separately and execute a bond for the like sum to forfeit the same to the State if he failed to appear in Court without any reasonable cause.

2. Accordingly, this Bail Application allowed.”

9. According to the learned Counsel for the Petitioners, Petitioners are very poor. They have no money even to engage a Lawyer. In the Bail Petitions, they themselves have appeared before the Trial Court. In the circumstances, the Trial Court directing them to deposit Rs. 25,000/- in each case as Cash Security is onerous and causes them much hardship. They have no money to deposit. That is how they are suffering in jail, in spite of the Bail Orders. The Trial Court cannot straightaway direct them to make Cash Security. In the circumstances, the said Bail condition may be modified.

10. The learned Government Advocate submitted that since the Accused are involved in property offences, such a condition has been imposed on them.

11. I have anxiously considered the rival submissions, perused the impugned Bail Orders and also the several decisions cited by the learned Counsel for the Petitioners.

12. Now, ‘Bail is the Rule and Jail is the Exception’. Generally, grant of bail is to be considered because it is in furtherance of liberty of the individual guaranteed under Article 21, Constitution of India. However, in certain circumstances such as seriousness of the offence alleged, habituality in criminality, tendency of abscondence, etc., bail will be refused (see Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan @ Pappu Yadav, 2005 (1) CTC 783 (SC) : 2004 (7) SCC 528; State Of U.P Through Cbi v. Amarmani Tripathi., 2005 (8) SCC 21; Sanjay Chandra v. C.B.I, 2012 (1) MWN (Cr.) 161 (SC) : 2012 (1) SCC 40; and Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2014 (2) MWN (Cr.) 501 (SC) : 2014 (8) SCC 273).

13. Chapter XXXIII of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 is a self-contained Code dealing with Bail and Bail Bonds. While granting bail, Courts have the power to impose conditions. It is with a view to ensure the availability of the Accused during investigation and also during the trial of the case and it is not at all for harassing the Accused persons.

14. Grant of bail is an exercise of judicial discretion by the Court based on consideration of several factors. Imposition of Bail condition is also part of such exercise. It should be based on sound judicial principles. It should not be arbitrary, mechanical. Imposition of bail condition should not be for the sake of imposition of Bail condition.

15. Under the guise of imposition of Bail condition, there shall not be imposition of any onerous condition. Conditions which are in the nature of and which could not be complied with by the accused would be like granting bail by one hand and taking it away by another hand.

16. Imposition of onerous and stringent conditions amount to denial of bail. Actually, our bail system is not mainly based on any cash system. If it is so then poor people have to spend rest of their life in jail itself. That is not the objective of a bail system. The object of bail is to enable the accused to send him out of jail with an assurance to return to the Court to put up an effective defence.

17. While granting bail, the Court can direct the accused to execute Bail Bond. As per Section 440, Cr.P.C, the Bond amount should not be excessive. When a person so directed to execute the Bond either with Surety or without Surety is not able to furnish the Sureties, then under Section 445, Cr.P.C, he has the option to offer Cash Security. But even then, it must be a reasonable amount. It should not be an arbitrary, excessive amount. It should not be in the nature of deprivation of grant of bail by fixing an heavy amount as Surety amount. If heavy amount is directed to be deposited as Cash Security, the bailee/accused will not be in a position to comply it. If heavy amount is demanded from the surety, then the bailor will not be forthcoming. And ‘haves’ will go out, while ‘have nots’ will remain in jail.

18. Reading Sections 440, 441 & 445, Cr.P.C together, it is clear that straightaway a Court cannot direct the Accused to deposit Cash Security. First of all, the Court has to direct execution of bail bond by the sureties in case if the release is not on his own bond. Only in lieu of that deposit of Cash Security could be directed (see Section 445, Cr.P.C). Thus, the Court cannot straightaway direct the Accused to deposit Cash Security.

19. As already stated even if the Cash Security is ordered under Section 445, Cr.P.C, the Court must pay regard to the circumstances of the case and the amount should not be excessive (see Section 440, Cr.P.C). Also see State of Mysore v. H. Venkatarama Kotaiyah, 1968 Crl. L.J 696; Moti Ram v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 1978 (4) SCC 47; Babu Singh v. The State of U.P, AIR 1978 SC 527; Gokul Das… v. The State Of Assam…Opposite Party., 1981 Crl. L.J 229; Afsar Khan v. State of Karnataka, 1992 Crl. L.J 1676; Bhikhabhai Udesinh Darbar… v. State Of Gujarat…., 1998 (1) GLR 315; Parades Patra v. State of Orissa, 1993 (2) OLR 452; Sandeep Jain v. National Capital Territory of Delhi, 2000 (2) SCC 66; Amarjit Singh v. State Of Nct Of Delhi., 2002 (1) MWN (Cr.) 217 (SC) : 2002 (2) CTC 63 (SC) : JT 2002 (1) SC 291; Sheikh Ayub v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 2004 (13) SCC 457; Ramathal v. Inspector of Police, 2009 (12) SCC 721; Amaldoss v. The Inspector of Police, Patteeswaram Police Station, Thanjavur District, Crl.O.P(MD) Nos. 19196 & 19197 of 2014 dated 5.2.2015; and Sakthivel v. The Inspector of Police, Belukurichi Police Station, Namakkal District, Crl.O.P Nos. 835 & 836 of 2015 dated 4.2.2015

20. Article 3 of Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 declares that ‘everyone has the right of life, liberty and security of person’. Article 21, Constitution of India, 1950 proclaims that ‘no one shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except by procedure established by law’. And Article 6 of International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966 declares that no one shall be arbitrarily deprived of his life.

21. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, AIR 1978 SC 597, held that any law, procedure depriving a person's life or liberty, which is ‘unjust’, ‘unreasonable’ and ‘inequitable’ militates against the Constitutional mandate in Article 21, Constitution of India. It is also in abridgment of human right of accused persons.

22. Thus, directing a poor man to deposit Rs. 25,000/- in each case is against Article 21, Constitution of India and Maneka Gandhi (supra) principle and also the said International Covenants, which have been ratified by our country.

23. In the circumstances, the learned Sessions Judge, Tirupattur straightaway directing the Petitioners to deposit Rs. 25,000/- in each case as Cash Security is totally not in accordance with law. Further, Petitioners are languishing in jail nearly for five years. Further, they are poor. They have no money not even to engage a Counsel to file Bail Petitions. Although bail was granted to them as early as on 21.8.2014, they could not come out of jail indicates that the Bail condition imposed by the Trial Court is onerous and it causes them much hardship.

24. In such circumstances, actually, the Trial Court in its capacity as Chairman of the Taluk Legal Services Committee, Tirupattur should have nominated Legal Aid Panel Advocates to file the Bail Petitions on behalf of the Petitioners. It is its Constitutional duty to do so (see Articles 14, 21, 22, 39-A, Constitution of India and also see Sections 303, 304, Cr.P.C). But the Trial Court did not discharge its Constitutional duty.

25. In the facts and circumstances, the interference of this Court is called for and set at naught the onerous Bail condition imposed by the learned Assistant Sessions Judge, Tirupattur.

26. Ordered as under:

(i) These Criminal Original Petitions are allowed;

(ii) The direction of the learned Assistant Sessions Judge, Tirupattur, Vellore District passed in Crl.M.P Nos. 52, 53 & 54 of 2014 in S.C Nos. 13 of 2013, 14 of 2013 & 15 of 2013 issued on 21.8.2014, directing each Petitioner to deposit a Cash Security of Rs. 25,000/- in each case are set aside.

(iii) Petitioners shall be released on their own bond of Rs. 5,000/- each to the satisfaction of the Superintendent, Central Prison, Vellore.

(iv) Petitioners shall appear before the Trial Court on all the hearing dates unless their absence is condoned by a Petition filed under Section 317, Cr.P.C

(v) The Trial Court shall address the Superintendent of Police, Vellore District to execute the NBWs pending against the absconding Accused at an early date.

(vi) The Chairman/Sub-Judge, Taluk Legal Services Committee, Tirupattur will engage Legal Aid Panel Advocates to defend the Petitioners, if they have not engaged defence Counsel.

(vii) The Trial Court shall take all out efforts to dispose of these cases at an early date.