Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

R. Baskar v. State By Inspector Of Police, Perambalur Police Station, Crime No. 137 Of 2011 .

Madras High Court
Mar 27, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — K.N. Basha, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal challenges the conviction and sentence imposed by the Sessions Judge, Mahila Court, Perambalur dated 14.6.2012 in S.C. No. 89/2011, whereby the appellant was convicted under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to life imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 5,000 (default 2 years' simple imprisonment).

Facts as presented by the prosecution: the deceased, Premavathi, was a craft teacher at Moulana School, Perambalur; her husband (PW1) testified that on 9.3.2011 he dropped her at school and later heard hue and cry and saw the accused cutting the deceased with an aruval; the accused ran away with the aruval. PW2 (an English teacher at the same school) and PW3 (a remote resident) were said to have witnessed or observed the accused running with the weapon. The police recorded the report (Ex.P1/Ex.P14), investigated (PW16), conducted inquest (Ex.P15) and post-mortem (PW12, Ex.P9). An aruval (MO5) was alleged to have been recovered pursuant to an admissible portion of the accused's confession (Ex.P5).

Procedurally, the prosecution examined PWs 1–16 and produced Exs. P1–P15 and MOs. The accused denied the incriminating circumstances under Section 313 CrPC and did not lead evidence. The trial court convicted and sentenced the accused; this appeal followed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution proved the charge under Section 302 IPC beyond reasonable doubt, having regard to the eyewitness testimony and forensic evidence.
  2. Whether the identification evidence (particularly that of PW2 and PW3) is reliable in the absence of an identification parade and given admissions that the accused was unknown to them before trial.
  3. Whether the First Information Report (Ex.P1) is genuine or fabricated, and if fabricated, whether that collapse of the FIR undermines the entire prosecution case.
  4. Whether the arrest and recovery of the weapon (MO5) were satisfactorily proved by independent evidence and reliable procedures.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as advanced by Dr. A.E. Chelliah)

  • The prosecution failed to prove its case with clear, cogent and consistent evidence; eyewitnesses' evidence (PWs 1 & 2) suffer serious infirmities and inconsistencies; PW3 is unreliable.
  • PW1 (husband of the deceased) is an interested witness and his presence at the scene is doubtful because he was employed as a college watchman and admitted signing the college Attendance Register; the Attendance Register was not seized or produced.
  • There was no production/recovery of blood-stained clothes from PW1 despite his claim of lifting the stabbed deceased, raising doubts about his presence at the scene.
  • PW1 admitted the police station was only 10 feet away, yet he waited 45 minutes before giving the report; this delay undermines his credibility.
  • The prosecution suppressed any earlier report: PWs suggested police reached earlier than the recorded time of the FIR (discrepancy between claimed police arrival times and FIR registration time of 9.45 a.m.).
  • PW2 did not know the accused before trial and identified him for the first time in court without any identification parade; such identification is unreliable.
  • PW3, a chance witness from a village 15 km away, did not identify the accused earlier and gave no identifying features; his evidence is not helpful.
  • The recovery of the aruval (MO5) is doubtful: the time and circumstances of arrest and recovery are inconsistent, and there were no independent witnesses to corroborate the recovery/confession.

Prosecution's Arguments (as advanced by the Additional Public Prosecutor)

  • The case is established by the eyewitnesses PW1 and PW2, corroborated by PW3 who saw the accused running with the aruval after the occurrence.
  • Medical evidence (PW12) corroborates the injuries consistent with the prosecution case.
  • There was no unreasonable delay in reporting to the police: the report was given within 45 minutes and reached the Magistrate's Court by 1:00 p.m. on 9.3.2011.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kanan v. State of Kerala, 1980 (24) MLJ (Cri) 1 Where a witness identifies an accused in court for the first time (the accused being unknown to the witness earlier), that evidence is valueless unless a previous identification parade (T.I. Parade) was held to test the witness's power of observation (Section 9 Evidence Act reference). The court applied this principle to hold that PW2's in-court identification, given that no identification parade was conducted and PW2 admitted not knowing the accused earlier, carried no value and could not be relied upon.
Marudanal Augusti v. State of Kerala, AIR 1980 SC 638 Where the First Information Report (FIR) is found to be fabricated or brought into existence long after the occurrence, the entire fabric of the prosecution case may collapse because witnesses could be added without any check on authenticity. The court relied on this principle after finding serious doubt about the genuineness of Ex.P1 (the Report/FIR) and held that if Ex.P1 is fabricated, the prosecution case collapses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a careful examination of the entire record, focusing on the credibility and reliability of the eyewitnesses, the documentary and forensic material, and the conduct of the police investigation.

1. General observation: the court observed that the prosecution case "bristled with suspicious circumstances" and that eyewitness evidence (PWs 1 & 2) suffered serious infirmities, inconsistencies and inherent improbabilities. The court acknowledged that PW1, as husband of the deceased, was an interested witness whose evidence must be scrutinized with caution.

2. Examination of PW1's testimony and surrounding facts:

  • PW1's account of his routine (dropping the deceased to school every day) contained inconsistencies: initially PW1 stated the deceased used her own cycle and later said he dropped her.
  • PW1 admitted signing the college Attendance Register on the date of occurrence (9.3.2011) yet said he did not attend work thereafter. The Investigating Officer (PW16) did not seize or verify the Attendance Register. PW16 admitted that had PW1 been on morning duty he could not have witnessed the occurrence.
  • The court drew an adverse inference for non-production/withholding of the Attendance Register given its materiality to test PW1's presence at the scene.
  • PW1 claimed he lifted the severely stabbed deceased immediately after the attack, yet neither he produced any blood-stained clothes nor did the Investigating Officer recover any from him; this absence raised doubts about his presence.
  • Although the police station was reportedly only 10 feet from the scene, PW1 waited 45 minutes before going to the police station and could not explain the delay; the court regarded this as inconsistent with normal human conduct and a factor undermining his credibility.
  • PW1 also admitted that police arrived at the scene on hearing the hue and cry; despite police presence, PW1 did not give an immediate report, further weakening his account.

3. Examination of PW2's testimony:

  • PW2 was said to have stood about 30 feet away and witnessed the occurrence, but he admitted not knowing the accused before the trial and identified the accused for the first time in court.
  • The Investigating Officer (PW16) confirmed that no identification parade was arranged and that PW2 did not give identifying features during police examination. The court applied the Kanan principle and held that PW2's in-court identification without a prior T.I. parade was of no value.
  • The absence of PW2's name in PW1's initial report (Ex.P1), despite both working at the same school, further diminished the reliability of PW2's evidence in the court's view.

4. Examination of PW3's testimony:

  • PW3 was a chance witness from a village 15 km away who stated only that he saw a person running with an aruval; he did not give identifying features, admitted he did not know the accused earlier and did not identify the accused prior to the trial. The court found PW3's evidence unhelpful to the prosecution.

5. On the possibility of suppression or fabrication of earlier police reports / timing discrepancies:

  • Several witnesses (PW1, PW2, PW3, PW7, PW8) gave accounts suggesting the police and public arrived at the scene earlier than the prosecution's recorded time for the FIR (Ex.P1). PW2 stated that police examined him at 9:30 a.m., but Ex.P1 is dated/registered at 9:45 a.m. The court found these discrepancies significant.
  • Given the admitted closeness of the police station to the scene and multiple witness statements that police reached and acted promptly, the court found that the possibility of suppression of an earlier report could not be ruled out and concluded that Ex.P1 was likely fabricated.
  • The court relied on Marudanal Augusti to hold that if the FIR is fabricated, the prosecution case would collapse because unverified witnesses could be added later.

6. On arrest and recovery (MO5):

  • The Investigating Officer (PW16) stated the accused was arrested at 4:00 p.m. and an admissible portion of a confession led to recovery of the aruval (MO5). However, the court found this timeline doubtful because other witness testimony suggested police chased and caught the accused much earlier.
  • PW8 (VAO) did not support recording of the confession as alleged, and the Investigating Officer did not examine independent witnesses to corroborate the arrest/recovery apart from official witnesses. For these reasons the court found the recovery unproved and unreliable.

7. Medical evidence:

  • The post-mortem (PW12) described a severe cut injury and opined death by shock and hemorrhage from injury to vital neck structures. Although the medical findings corresponded to fatal neck injuries, the court considered such medical corroboration insufficient to overcome the serious infirmities, inconsistencies and doubts identified in the eyewitness and investigation evidence.

8. Overall assessment:

  • Weighing the inconsistencies, the court concluded that the prosecution's case suffered from material defects: unreliable eyewitness identification, possible fabrication/suppression of the FIR, non-production of the attendance register, unexplained gaps regarding blood-stained clothing, and unsatisfactory proof of arrest and recovery. These factors led the court to conclude the conviction could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed: the conviction and sentence imposed by the Sessions Judge, Mahila Court, Perambalur dated 14.6.2012 in S.C. No. 89/2011 are set aside and the appellant is acquitted of all charges.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The appellant's conviction under Section 302 IPC has been reversed and he is acquitted.
  • Any fine paid is to be refunded to the appellant.
  • The court expressly held that the prosecution case had collapsed in view of the serious doubts about the FIR (Ex.P1) and the unreliability of the key eyewitness and recovery evidence.
  • The opinion does not state that it establishes a new legal precedent; it applies existing precedents (cited) to the facts and resolves the case on evidentiary grounds.

This summary is prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond those contained in the judgment text.

Show all summary ...

K.N Basha, J.

1. The challenge in this Appeal is to the Judgment of the learned Sessions Judge, Mahila Court, Perambalur dated 14.6.2012 made in S.C No. 89/2011, convicting the Appellant for the offence under Section 302, I.P.C and sentencing him to undergo Life Imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 5,000/- in default to undergo 2 years' Simple Imprisonment.

2. The Accused/Appellant faced the trial under the following backdrop:

2.1 PW1 is the husband of the deceased Premavathi. The deceased was working as Craft Teacher in Moulana School at Perambalur. PW1 was working as Watchman in Dhanalaxmi Srinivasan Polytechnic College, Perambalur. They have been blessed with two female children, namely, Rekha and Priya. Everyday, PW1 used to drop the deceased to School in his cycle.

2.2 The Accused is also a resident of the same place. PW1 alleged that the Accused was troubling his daughter Rekha frequently for the last two years. On one day, the deceased, wife of PW1 along with Rekha, daughter of PW1 was proceeding near Uzhavar Sandhai and at that time, the said Rekha pointing out the Accused and stated to the deceased that he was frequently troubling her. The deceased warned the Accused. Rekha also complained to PW1 about the frequent trouble given by the Accused. Fifteen days prior to the occurrence, PW1 and the deceased made marriage arrangements for their daughter Rekha and the marriage was also over. In view of the same, there were strained feelings between the Accused and the deceased family.

2.3 On the fateful date of occurrence, i.e, on 9.3.2011, at 8.45 a.m, PW1 took his wife, the deceased, in his cycle and left her in the School. Thereafter, while he was returning at 9.30 a.m, he heard the hue and cry of the deceased. When he turned back, he saw the Accused cutting the deceased on her chest and neck with an Aruval. Thereafter, the Accused ran away from the scene with the Aruval. PW1 lifted the deceased and found that the deceased already dead.

2.4 The above said occurrence was also claimed to have been witnessed by PW2, who was working as English Teacher in the same school viz., Moulana School, Perambalur, where the deceased was working. PW3, who was residing in a different place, claimed to have seen the Accused running with an Aruval on 9.3.2011 at 09.00 a.m

2.5 Thereafter, PW1 went to Perambalur Police Station and narrated about the occurrence to PW15, the Sub-Inspector of Police, which was recorded by PW15 under Ex.P1 PW15 registered a case in Crime No. 137/2011 for the offence under Section 302, I.P.C Ex.P14 is the Express F.I.R PW15 sent the Express F.I.R, Ex.P14 & Ex.P1 to the higher officials and to the Court.

2.6 PW16, the Inspector of Police, took up the investigation on receipt of the F.I.R He went to the scene of occurrence at 10.45 a.m and prepared Observation Mahazar, Ex.P2 and Rough Sketch, Ex.P3 in the presence of the witnesses PW7 and another. He held inquest on the dead body of the deceased at 12.00 noon. Ex.P15 is the Inquest Report. During inquest, he has also examined the witnesses. He has sent the body for Post-mortem.

2.7 PW12, the Doctor attached to the Government Hospital, Perambalur conducted Post-mortem on 9.3.2011 He found the following injuries:

“A cut injury over back of middle neck 10 cm from both ear lobes runs transversly from lateral margin of left side neck up to right side neck stemo leidomartoid with injury right carotid and jagalar vessel and transection of spinal cord at C4 level. Dimension 15 × 5 × 7 in centimeter.”

The Doctor is of the opinion that the deceased would appear to have died of shock and hemorrhage due to injury to vital organs like spinal cord and blood vessels of neck about 3 to 8 hours prior to autopsy.

2.8 PW16, in continuation of his investigation, recovered Blood Stained Earth, MO1, Ordinary Earth, MO2, one pair Chapels, MO3, one black colour Rexin Bag, MO4 from the scene under Mahazar in the presence of the witnesses. He has examined the other witnesses and recorded their statements. At 4.00 p.m, on the same day i.e, 9.3.2011, he has arrested the Accused near Samathuvapuram Arch. In pursuance of the admissible portion of the confession of the Accused under Ex.P5, he recovered MO5, Aruval, as produced by the Accused. He has produced the Accused before the Court for remand. He has examined the Police Constables. He has sent the seized articles for chemical-examination through the Court. After examining the witnesses PWs.1 to 3, including the Doctor, PW12 and others, he has received the Post-Mortem Certificate, Ex.P9, Biological Report, Ex.P12 and Serological Report, Ex.P13 After completion of the investigation, he has filed the Final Report on 18.5.2011 for the offence under Section 302, I.P.C against the Accused/Appellant.

3. The prosecution, in order to bring home the charges against the Accused, examined PWs.1 to 16, filed Exs.P1 to P15 besides marking MOs.1 to 11.

4. When the Accused was questioned under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code in respect of the incriminating circumstances appearing against him through the evidence adduced by the prosecution, he has come forward with the version of total denial. He has not chosen to examine any witness or mark any document on his side.

5. The learned Trial Judge on consideration and appreciation of the entire evidence adduced by the prosecution, has found the Accused guilty and convicted and sentenced him as stated above. Hence, the present Appeal.

6. Dr. A.E Chelliah, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Appellant, while assailing the impugned Judgment of conviction, vehemently contended that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove its case by adducing clear, cogent and consistent evidence and the evidence of the eyewitnesses PWs.1 & 2 suffers from serious infirmities and inconsistencies and the evidence of PW3 is unbelievable and unreliable and put forward the following contentions:

(i) PW1, apart from being the husband of the deceased and being the interested witness, could not hav been present at the time of occurrence at the scene as he was working as Watchman in a College and also admitted that he has signed in the Attendance Register on the date of occurrence and he has not clearly stated as to whether he was on day duty or evening duty.

(ii) The prosecution has not seized the Attendance Register of the College where PW1 was working in spite of the fact that PW1 admitted that he has signed in the Attendance Register and as such, adverse inference could be drawn against the prosecution case.

(iii) Though PW1, an Eyewitness, claimed that he has lifted the deceased immediately after the occurrence and admittedly the deceased sustained some stab injuries, there should have been profuse bleeding, but PW1 has not produced any blood-stained shirt or the Investigating Officer, PW16 has not recovered any blood-stained shirt from PW1, which raises serious doubt about the presence of PW1 at the time of occurrence.

(iv) PW1 categorically stated in his cross-examination that the Police Station is only 10 feet away from the scene of occurrence and in spite of the same, he has not chosen to give any report immediately to the Police and further, he has admitted that he went to the Police Station only after 45 minutes, which raises serious doubt about his presence at the scene and his version is unreliable.

(v) PW1 also admitted that on hearing the hue and cry, Police officials came to the scene and if such version is true, the Police could have recorded a report from PW1 much before the time now claimed by the prosecution to the effect that PW15 recorded the Report-Ex.P1 from PW1 only at 9.45 a.m, whereas the occurrence said to have taken place between 8.45 to 9.00 a.m

(vi) PW1 also admitted in his cross-examination that he has not stated to anyone about the occurrence till his examination by the Police and such conduct is most unnatural, raising doubts about the credibility of his version.

(vii) The evidence of PW2, the other eyewitness, is also highly doubtful and he could not have been present at the time of occurrence. If really he was present at the scene, PW1 could have stated about his presence, but PW1 has not stated anything about the presence of PW2 in his evidence. PW1 categorically admitted in his cross-examination that none of the witnesses arrived at the scene for a period of 10 minutes after the occurrence in spite of raising hue and cry and on the other hand, PW2 claimed that he was present even at the time of occurrence, which raises serious doubt about the presence of PW2 at the scene at the time of occurrence.

(viii) The prosecution suppressed the earliest report in view of the admission of PW2 to the effect that the Police arrived at the scene on hearing hue and cry, as PW2 stated that the Police examined him at 9.30 a.m itself and recorded his statement whereas the prosecution version is to the effect that the report was recorded only at 9.45 a.m and such being the position, the possibility of recording earlier report from PW2 and suppression of the same cannot be ruled out.

(ix) PW2 admitted in his cross-examination that he has not seen the Accused earlier and the Accused was unknown to him and he has identified the Accused only for the first time before the Court, as the prosecution has not conducted any Identification Parade and as such, the evidence of PW2 is unbelievable and unreliable.

(x) Though PW3 claimed that he has seen the Accused running with Aruval after the occurrence, he has not informed the Police immediately and he was examined subsequently. PW3 also admitted that he has not seen the Accused earlier and the Accused was unknown to him and he identified the Accused only for the first time before the Court and he has also not stated to the Police about the identifying features of the Accused during examination by the Police and as such, the identification of the Accused by PW3 for the first time before the Court is unreliable.

(xi) Even the recovery of Aruval, MO5, is doubtful as the prosecution has miserably failed to prove the same by adducing clear evidence.

7. Per contra, Mr. V.M.R Rajendran, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor contended that the prosecution has established its case through the evidence of the eyewitnesses, PWs.1 & 2. It is contended that the evidence of PWs.1 & 2 is also corroborated by the evidence of PW3, who has seen the Accused running with the weapon, Aruval, after the occurrence. It is further contended that the evidence of the eyewitnesses is also corroborated by the Medical evidence through the Doctor, PW12, who has conducted post-mortem and found corresponding injuries. It is also contended that there is no delay in giving report to the Police as the report was given within 45 minutes after the occurrence and the report reached the Magistrate Court at 1.00 p.m itself on 9.3.2011

8. We have given our careful and anxious consideration to the rival contentions put forward by either side and thoroughly scanned through the entire evidence available on record and perused the impugned Judgment of conviction.

9. At the outset, it is to be stated that the entire prosecution case bristled with suspicious circumstances and the evidence of the eyewitnesses PWs.1 & 2 are suffering from serious infirmities, inconsistencies and inherent improbabilities. The learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant pointed out several infirmities in the evidence of the eyewitnesses PWs.1 & 2. It is true that PW1, being the husband of the deceased, is an interested witness and on that score, his evidence cannot be discarded and on the other hand, we have to scrutinize such evidence with great care and caution.

10. PW1 was admittedly working as Watchman in a College at the time of occurrence. It is his version that everyday he used to take his wife to the nearby School in his cycle in the morning, but such version is highly doubtful as the School is not far away from his house and further, it was initially stated by PW1 that the deceased used to attend the School in her own cycle but subsequently he has stated that he used to drop her everyday. Added to such infirmity, it is seen that the PW1 signed in the Attendance Register of the College even on the date of occurrence i.e, 9.3.2011, as per his specific admission in his cross-examination, but strangely he has stated that after signing the Attendance Register, he has not attended the work. It is also admitted by him that there is an Attendance Register in the School, but the Investigating Officer, PW16, has not produced the said Attendance Register, which is a vital document to test the veracity of the version of PW1. PW16, the Investigating Officer has also admitted in his cross-examination that he has not verified the Attendance Register of the College and he has further admitted that if PW1 was on duty during morning time, he could not have witnessed the occurrence. PW16 is not able to give any reasonable and probable explanation for not seizing and producing the Attendance Register, which is a vital document to substantiate the presence of PW1 at the time of occurrence at the scene. Therefore, we are constrained to draw adverse inference for withholding the vital document, namely, Attendance Register in view of the admission of PW1 that he has signed in the Attendance Register on the date of occurrence i.e, 9.3.2011 and his version that after signing the Attendance Register, he has not attended the college, is unbelievable and unreliable.

11. Yet another factor to be borne in mind of this Court is that PW1 has categorically stated even in his chief-examination that soon after the occurrence, he has lifted the deceased, his wife and the deceased has sustained severe stab injuries, but he has not produced any blood-stained shirt or clothes to substantiate the same to the effect that he was present at the scene at the time of occurrence and the Investigating Officer, PW16 has also not recovered any blood-stained shirt or clothes from PW1, which raises serious doubt about his presence at the time of occurrence.

12. It is pertinent to note that according to PW1, the occurrence said to have taken place between 8.45 a.m to 9.00 a.m on 9.3.2011 and the Police Station is just 10 feet away from the scene and such being the position, immediately after the occurrence, normal human conduct of a person is to rush to the Police Station which is just 10 feet away from the scene, but in the instant case, PW1 has categorically admitted in his cross-examination that he remained in the scene for 45 minutes and only thereafter, he went to the Police Station for giving the report and he has also admitted that he cannot give any explanation for such conduct.

13. Added to the above said infirmities, it is also admitted by PW1 that the Police arrived at the scene after hearing the hue and cry. If really PW1 was present when the Police arrived at the scene, nothing prevented him from giving report immediately to the Police about the occurrence. Therefore, we are of the considered view that it is most unsafe and hazardous to place reliance on the evidence of PW1.

14. Now coming to the evidence of the other eyewitness, namely, PW2, it is to be stated that PW2 was working in the same School, where the deceased was working and he claimed that at the time of occurrence at 9.00 a.m, he was proceeding towards the School through Moulana Mosque Road and he has witnessed the occurrence by standing at a distance of 30 feet. PW2 categorically admitted in his cross-examination that he has not seen the Accused earlier to the occurrence and he has seen the Accused for the first time before the Court. PW2 has not given any identification features of the Accused during his examination by the Police as per the categorical admission of PW16 in his cross-examination. It is also stated by PW16 that PW2 has not stated that he can identify the Accused if he has seen the Accused in person. PW16 also admitted that he has not arranged for any Identification Parade. Therefore, we have no hesitation to hold that no value could be attached by the identification of the Accused by PW2 for the first time before the Court. It is quite natural for any witness to identify the single Accused standing before the Court at the time of trial. It is also pertinent to note that the name of PW2 is also not mentioned in the report, Ex.P1 given by PW1 in spite of the fact that he was also working in the same School in which the deceased was working and further, PW2 admitted that he knows PW1 earlier. In view of the said factors, we are of the considered view that it is most unsafe to place reliance on the evidence of PW2.

15. At this juncture, it is relevant to refer the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Kanan v. State of Kerala, 1980 (24) MLJ (Cri) 1, wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court has held as hereunder:

“It is well-settled that where a witness identified an Accused who is not known to him in the Court for the first time, his evidence is absolutely valueless unless there has been a previous T.I Parade to test his powers of observation. The idea of holding T.I Parade under Section 9 of the Evidence Act is to test the veracity of the witness on the question of his capability to identify an unknown person whom the witness may have seen only once. If no T.I Parade is held then it will be wholly unsafe to rely on his bare testimony regarding the identification of an Accused for the first time in Court.”

The principle laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the decision cited supra is squarely applicable to the facts of the instant case, as in this case also, admittedly, the Investigating Officer, PW16 has not made arrangements for conducting any Identification Parade and PW2 identified the Accused for the first time before the Court and admitted that the Accused is not known to him earlier and as such, no value could be attached by the identification of the Accused by PW2 for the first time before the Court.

16. The next piece of evidence adduced by the prosecution is the evidence of PW3, who has claimed that he has seen the Accused running with an Aruval after the occurrence. The fact remains that PW3 is a Chance Witness and he has admitted in his cross-examination that his village is 15 kms away from the scene of occurrence. It is also pertinent to note that the Accused is a total stranger to PW3 as he has not mentioned about the Accused name or identified the Accused before the Court. PW3 clearly admitted in his cross-examination that he has not seen the Accused earlier to the occurrence and he has not given the identification features of the Accused to the Inspector of Police at the time of his examination. PW3 has simply stated that one person running away with an Aruval. Therefore, we are of the considered view that it is unsafe to place reliance on the evidence of PW3, as the same is not helpful to advance the case of the prosecution in any manner.

16-A. Yet another serious disturbing feature in this case is that the possibility of the suppression of the earlier report cannot be ruled out. PW1 admitted in his cross-examination that the Police Station is only 10 feet away from the scene and as such, on hearing the hue and cry, the Police could have very well arrived at the scene immediately. Accordingly, PW1 also admitted that on hearing the hue and cry, the Police arrived at the scene. PW2 categorically admitted in his cross-examination that on hearing the hue and cry nearly 40 to 50 persons arrived at the scene and Police Constables came from the nearby Police Station and chased the Accused. It is further admitted that Police recorded his statement at 9.30 a.m itself whereas the present version of the prosecution is that the F.I.R itself was registered at 9.45 a.m PW3 also admitted in his cross-examination that the Police came to the scene immediately after the occurrence and chased the Accused. PW7, the Secretary of the Moulana School, in which the deceased worked, also stated in his chief-examination itself that he rushed to the scene at 9.00 a.m on hearing the hue and cry and at that time, the Police was also present along with PW1. PW8, the Village Administrative Officer admitted in his cross-examination that he went to the scene of occurrence at 9.30 a.m and at that time itself, 3 to 4 Police officials were present at the scene. All these clear, consistent and categorical version of the above said witnesses makes it crystal clear that the Police could have very well rushed to the scene immediately after the occurrence and they could have recorded the report either from PW1 or PW2, the Eyewitnesses in this case and as such, the possibility of suppression of the earlier report cannot be ruled out. The said factor raises serious doubt about the genuineness of the Report-Ex.P1 in this case. Therefore, we have no hesitation to hold that the present Report-Ex.P1 is nothing but a fabricated document. At this juncture, it is relevant to refer a decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Marudanal Augusti v. State Of Kerala, AIR 1980 SC 638, wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court has held as follows:

“.. the entire fabric of the prosecution case would collapse if the First Information Report is held to be fabricated or brought into existence long after the occurrence and any number of witnesses could be added without there being anything to check the authenticity of their evidence….”

The principle laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the decision cited supra is squarely applicable to the facts of the instant case, as in this case also, we have already held that there is serious doubt about the genuineness of the Report, Ex.P1 and the F.I.R in this case is a fabricated document and as such, the entire prosecution case would collapse.

17. The last but not the least evidence relied by the prosecution is the arrest and recovery of MO5, Aruval. In order to substantiate such version, the prosecution examined the VAO, PW8, who has admitted clearly in his cross-examination that he has not stated about recording of the confession of the Accused during the course of his examination by the Police. It is to be stated that PW16 claimed that the Accused was arrested on 9.3.2011 at 4.00 p.m and thereafter, he has recorded his confession and recorded the blood-stained Aruval, MO5, but the fact remains that PW2 admitted in his cross-examination that the Police immediately arrived at the scene on hearing the hue and cry and chased the Accused and he heard that ultimately the Police caught hold of the Accused. PW3 also stated that soon after the occurrence, the Police chased the Accused. In view of the aforesaid factors, the date and time of arrest and the recording of the confession from the Accused is highly doubtful. Apart from the said factor, PW16, the Investigating Officer, has not examined any independent witness to speak about the arrest and recovery, except examining the official witness, PW8, the Village Administrative Officer and as such, we cannot place reliance on the alleged recovery of MO5, Aruval.

18. In view of the aforesaid reasons, we have come to the irresistible conclusion that the impugned Judgment of conviction is unsustainable. Accordingly, the Appeal is allowed and the conviction and sentence imposed on the Appellant by the Judgment of the learned Sessions Judge, Mahila Court, Perambalur dated 14.6.2012 made in S.C No. 89/2011 is set aside. The Appellant is acquitted of all the charges levelled against him. Fine amount paid, if any, is directed to be refunded to the Appellant.