- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
V.Chinnappa v. State Rep. By
This criminal appeal has been preferred against the Judgment, Judgment of Conviction and Sentence, dated 27.01.2006 made in Special Case No.15 of 2002 on the file of the Special Judge-cum-Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thanjavur at Kumbakonam, whereby the appellant / accused was convicted under Section 7 of Prevention of Corruption Act and sentenced to undergo one year RI and to pay a fine of Rs.1,000/-, in default to undergo three months SI and under Section 13 (1) (d) r/w 13 (2) of Prevention of Corruption Act to undergo two years RI and to pay a fine of Rs.2,000/-, in default to undergo six months SI.
2. It is a trap case under the Prevention of Corruption Act. As per the prosecution case, the appellant / accused was working as Sub-Inspector of Survey (Natham/Mobile) at Taluk office, Pattukkotai from 01.01.2000 to 15.02.2002. The defacto-complainant (PW2), Balasundaram, a resident of Mahilamkottai of Pattukottai taluk had approached the appellant / accused towards changing the name for the land in S.No.106/11 and patta number 196 UDR from the name of his deceased father Ganapathy. He requested to transfer the patta in his name during December 2001, for which, he had given a petition before the concerned Revenue officer. To include the name of the defacto-complainant, the appellant / accused allegedly demanded illegal gratification of Rs.1,000/- from the defacto- complainant (P.W.2) and subsequently, at the request of the defacto-complainant, the appellant / accused reduced the amount to Rs.500/-. When P.W.2 approached the appellant / accused on 12.02.2002 at about 4.30 p.m at his residence, the appellant / accused informed P.W.2 to meet him with the statement of the VAO of the concerned village and also to obtain signatures of the other pattadhars and also the amount of Rs.500/- on 15.02.2002. As per the prosecution case, on 15.02.2002, the defacto-complainant was proceeding towards the Taluk office and on the way, the appellant / accused received a sum of Rs.500/-, as demanded by him as illegal gratification / bribe and thereby, committed the offence punishable under Sections 7 and 13 (1) (d) r/w 13 (2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
3. It is seen that after registering the case, copies of the documents relied on by the prosecution were furnished to the appellant, as per Section 207 Cr.P.C. then, charges were framed under Sections 7 and 13 (1) (d) r/w 13 (2) of Prevention of Corruption Act. As the appellant / accused pleaded not guilty, the case was posted for trial. Before the Court below, 14 witnesses were examined and Exs.P.1 to P.14 were marked on the side of the prosecution, apart from marking material objects, M.Os.1 to 7. On the side of the appellant / accused, no witness was examined and no document or material object was marked.
4. After the trial, the Court below found the appellant / accused guilty and convicted and sentenced him, as stated above. Aggrieved by which, this criminal appeal has been preferred by the appellant / accused. Hence, in this appeal, this Court has to decide whether the prosecution has established the guilt against the appellant / accused beyond reasonable doubt and sentenced, as per law.
5. In this appeal, the appellant / accused has stated that the demand aspect pleaded by the prosecution has not been established by uncorroborated testimony of P.W.2 and the sanction for prosecuting the accused under Ex.P.1 is not sustainable in law, as if it did not reveal that the sanctioning authority had satisfied himself with regard to the allegations raised against the accused and that there was no reason for granting sanction to prosecute the appellant. The appellant / accused has further stated that the Court below has relied on the statement recorded under Section 161(3) Cr.P.C to establish the alleged demand made by the appellant / accused, though the same is inadmissible in evidence.
6. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant further submitted that the Court below has not considered that P.W.2 had developed grudge over the appellant / accused, since he had been made to run from pillar to post in getting No Objection Certificate from other co-pattadars. He has further submitted that as per the prosecution case, the appellant / accused had received bribe amount in his right hand, hence, the presence of phenolphthalein powder in the left hand of the accused, as per the prosecution evidence would weaken the case of the prosecution and the Court below has not considered the evidence of P.W.2 that the hand kerchief of the appellant / accused had fallen down when he went to attend the call of nature and further submitted that the Court below has not considered the major contradictions available in the evidence of the prosecution witness, especially in the evidence of P.W.2 and P.W.3. According to him, the contradiction creates serious doubt on the prosecution case and accordingly, pleaded to allow this appeal and record acquittal.
7. The Assistant Director of Land Survey, Thanjavur, who accorded sanction as per Ex.P.1 to prosecute the appellant / accused was examined as P.W.1 before the trial court. He has deposed that he was the competent higher officer, empowered to appoint and remove the appellant / accused. According to him, having gone through the material papers placed before him, granted sanction to prosecute the appellant / accused. Considering the evidence of P.W.1 with reference to Ex.P.1, I could find no infirmity to decide that the prosecution case suffers any infirmity.
8. The defacto-complainant, P.W.2 gave the complaint, Ex.P.6, dated 15.02.2002 to the Vigilance and Anti-corruption, Thanjavur. He has stated that his father had 8 cents of land in Mayilamkottai village and after the death of his father, he wanted to include his name in the UDR patta, for which, he gave a petition in the office of the Revenue Divisional Officer, Pattukottai on 23.07.2001. Thereafter, he went to the office and enquired about the transfer of patta, where he was informed that he has to approach the surveyor Chinappa, who is the appellant / accused. The petition given by him, seeking to enquire his name in the joint patta was marked as Ex.P.2. According to P.W.2, he received a letter, dated 08.12.2001 to appear for enquiry on 19.12.2001, accordingly, he went to the Tahsildar office to include his name in the UDR patta and he met the appellant / accused and requested him to do the needful. According to P.W.2, the appellant / accused demanded Rs.1,000/- as illegal gratification. Then at the request of the defacto-complainant, the same was reduced to Rs.500/- by the appellant / accused. Subsequently, Ex.P.4, letter was received by him to appear before the concerned officer on 12.01.2002, where some of the joint patta- holders were also present and after making enquiry, the appellant / accused called P.W.2 separately and demanded Rs.500/- to be paid to him as gratification, otherwise, the same would not be decided in his favour.
9. According to P.W.2, as instructed by the appellant / accused, he obtained the signatures of 7 joint pattadhars and also the statement of the VAO of the concerned village. However, P.W.2 was not inclined to pay Rs.500/- as demanded by the appellant / accused. On 15.02.2002, he went to the District Vigilance and Anti-corruption Office, Thanjavur and gave a complaint before the Inspector, which was marked as Ex.P.6.
10. Mr..A.Thiruvadikumar, learned counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that the prosecution has not established the guilt beyond reasonable doubt, in respect of demand and the alleged illegal gratification received by the appellant, however, the Court below has convicted the appellant / accused and sentenced him to undergo one year RI and to pay a fine of Rs.1,000/-, under Section 7 of Prevention of Corruption Act with default sentence and convicted and sentenced to undergo two years RI and to pay a fine of Rs.2,000/- with default sentence under Section 13 (1) (d) r/w 13 (2) of Prevention of Corruption Act.
11. The following decisions were relied on by both the learned counsel :
1. State of Kerala vs. C.P.Rao, (2011) 4 MLJ (Crl) 723 (SC)
2. Bansari Dass vs. State of Haryana, (2010) 3 MLJ (Crl) 132 (SC)
3. A.Subair vs. State of Kerala, (2010) 1 MLJ (Crl) 995 (SC)
4. Govindasamy vs. State, (2011) 3 MLJ (Crl) 455
5. V.Kannan vs. State, (2009) 3 SCC (Cri) 1041
6. K.Saravanan vs. State, (2006) 2 MLJ (Crl) 876
12. In V.Kannan vs. State, reported in (2009) 3 SCC (Cri) 1041, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that as per the prosecution case, the money was handed over to the appellant / accused in his presence. Immediately after the bribe amount was handed over to the appellant, he started counting the currency notes. At that time P.W.2 came out and gave the pre-arranged signal to the trap team. Soon after the Inspector and the trap team entered into the room, the appellant was arrested. Sodium carbonate solution was prepared and phenolphthalein test was conducted on both the hands of the appellant separately and that pink colour change was found in the solution and they were preserved in separate bottles. Scientific Assistant Grade I, Forensic Science Department, who was examined as one of the prosecution witness stated in her report that she had received two solution bottles and on examination, it was found that the liquid sent to her contained phenolphthalein and sodium carbonate. In the aforesaid circumstances, upholding the concurrent findings of the Courts below, it is held that no interference was warranted by the Hon'ble Apex Court.
13. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Kerala vs. C.P.Rao, reported in (2011) 4 MLJ (Crl) 723 has held that in a case of bribery, presence of complainant is necessary to corroborate his testimony and evidence to prove the demand of illegal gratification that was not made available before Court, such complaint cannot be relied upon for convicting the accused. It is further held as follows :
10...The mere recovery by itself cannot prove the charge of the prosecution against the accused. In the absence of any evidence to prove payment of bribe or to show that the accused voluntarily accepted the money knowing it to be bribe, conviction cannot be sustained.
It has been made clear by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that mere recovery of money from the accused itself cannot be a proof to convict the accused, in the absence of any evidence to prove the payment of bribe or evidence to show that the accused voluntarily accepted the money knowing it to be bribe.
14. In A.Subair vs. State of Kerala, reported in (2010) 1 MLJ (Crl) 995, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as follows :
The legal position is no more res integra that primary requisite of an offence under Section 13 (1) (d) of the Act is proof of a demand or request of a valuable thing or pecuniary advantage from the public servant. In other words, in the absence of proof of demand or request from the public servant for a valuable thing or pecuniary advantage, the offence under Section 13 (1) (d) cannot be held to be established.
It has been further held in the aforesaid decision that sub-section (3) of Section 20 of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 is a non-obstante clause. It provides that where gratification is trivial and the Court is of the opinion that no inference of corruption may fairly be drawn, it may decline to draw the presumption as referred to in sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 20 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. In other words, the Court is not bound to draw a presumption under Section 20 where the alleged gratification is too trivial. In this decision, it has been categorically ruled that the prosecution has to prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt like any other offence and the accused should be considered innocent till the guilt is established. Proper proof of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification are the vital ingredients, necessary to be established to procure a conviction for the offences under Prevention of Corruption Act.
15. In Banari Dass vs. State of Haryana, reported in (2010) 3 MLJ (Crl) 132, the Hon'ble Apex Court held as follows :
11.To constitute an offence under section 161 of the ipc, it is necessary for the prosecution to prove that there was demand of money and the same was voluntarily accepted by the accused. Similarly, in terms of Section 5 (1) (d) of the Act, the demand and acceptance of the money for doing a favour in discharge of its official duties is sine qua non to the conviction of the accused...
16. In M.K.Harshan vs. State of Kerala reported in AIR 1995 SC 2178, it has been held that when the accused has come forward with a plea that the currency notes were put in the drawer with out his knowledge, there must be clinching evidence to show that it was with the tacit approval of the accused, the money had been put in the drawer as an illegal gratification.
17. In Govindasamy vs. State, reported in (2011) 3 MLJ (Crl) 455, this Court (S.Tamilvanan, J) relying on various decisions of the Hon'ble Apex Court held that culpability of mind of an accused, coupled with actus rea, has to be established by the prosecution, based on the available evidence on record to sustain the conviction against the accused under Prevention of Corruption Act, without any deviation from the basic principles of criminal jurisprudence and the Indian Evidence Act. Mere recovery of tainted money by itself cannot establish the charge of acceptance of illegal gratification in the absence of any evidence to prove the payment as illegal gratification or to show that the accused had voluntarily accepted money knowing it as bribe.
18. In the instant case, the evidence of the defacto-complainant, P.W.2 is so vital to establish the demand of illegal gratification and for establishing the alleged illegal gratification received by the appellant / accused. As per the evidence of P.W.2, in his chief, he had approached the appellant herein on various dates to include his name as one of the joint pattadhars of UDR patta. On 12.02.2002, he went to the Taluk Office to meet the appellant, who was the Taluk Surveyor and as he was not available at his office, the defacto- complainant found out the residential address of the appellant and went to his village and met him. According to P.W.2, when he met the appellant in his native village, he told him that P.W.2 should obtain signatures from the other joint pattadhars, statement of VAO and also the amount, Rs.500/- claimed by him on 15.02.2002. P.W.2 has further stated in his evidence that he had obtained the signatures from 7 joint pattadhars and the said document is Ex.P.5 and also got the statement from the VAO, stating that the Surveyor had asked him to produce the said statement. However, in the cross-examination, P.W.2 would state that the appellant / accused told him that out of 9 joint pattadhars, only 7 persons had signed, hence, asked P.W.2 to get the signatures of other two pattadhars.
19. As contended by the learned counsel appearing for the appellant / accused, as per the evidence of P.W.2, in his chief he has stated that he had obtained signatures of all 7 joint pattadhars but in the cross-examination, he has stated that there were 9 joint pattadhars, however, he got the signatures from only 7 joint pattadhars, hence, he was asked by the appellant / accused to get the signatures of the other two pattadhars, which is self-contrary. P.W.2 has further stated that as the appellant / accused had asked him to get signatures from two other persons, he thought that the appellant is deliberately causing delay in the matter against the interest of P.W.2. Hence, he approached the Vigilance Department. When the document requires signatures of all 9 joint pattadhars and P.W.2 was not entitled to seek change of patta, by including his name in the joint patta, without getting the signatures of other two pattadhars.
20. In the aforesaid circumstances, without getting the signatures of two other pattadhars and after getting the papers returned from the appellant, P.W.2 could not have gone to the Vigilance office and lodged complaint at the incomplete stage. He has admitted further that when he was first examined by the Vigilance Officer, he had not stated the date on which the appellant demanded illegal gratification, only in the second enquiry, he could state the dates, though he was not conversant with English dates. P.W.2 has further stated that if anybody specifically make him to remember, he would remember the English calendar dates.
21. Considering the evidence of P.W.2, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that the dates given in the complaint were all imaginary, otherwise, the defacto-complainant / PW.2 could have stated the dates, even when he was examined by the police at the first instance. Even according to P.W.2, he is an illiterate person, could sign and not able to read or write. In such circumstances, there is every possibility that imaginary dates could have been given by the defacto-complainant. It is argued that the complaint was prepared stating imaginary dates, based on which, P.W.2 deposed his evidence as instructed. P.W.2 had admitted that the document, in which he had obtained signatures of 7 joint pattadhars out of 9 pattadhars was returned to him by the appellant / accused stating that the document should be signed by all the 9 pattadhars for consideration. In the chief-examination, P.W.2 has stated that on the date of occurrence, after he met the appellant at the office, came out from the Taluk office to attend natures call and while so, P.W.2 handed over the money to the appellant / accused and that was recovered by respondent police in the trap. According to P.W.2, the appellant / accused received the money in a white hand kerchief and kept it in his right side pant pocket. However, in the cross-examination, he would state that after attending natures call, while returning to the office, hand kerchief of the appellant / accused was fallen down from his pocket. P.W.2 denied the suggestion that he had placed the money in the hand kerchief and returned the same to the appellant. However, P.W.2 has admitted in his evidence that unless he obtains the signatures from two other joint pattadhars, the appellant / accused would not have completed his request. As per the evidence of P.W.2, without completing the legal requirement of the signatures from 9 joint pattadhars, he went to the Vigilance office, in order to arrange the trap at a premature stage.
22. It is also clear that P.W.3, who accompanied P.W.2 to the office of the appellant has also deposed in his evidence that the appellant / accused had informed P.W.2 that only 7 out of 9 pattadhars had signed and that P.W.2 had to obtain the signatures from other two joint pattadhars, stating the same, the appellant returned the document signed by 7 pattadhars to P.W.2 for the compliance. In the cross-examination, P.W.3 has stated that the appellant, after receiving the money, Rs.500/- from P.W.2, kept it in his pant pocket, however, the recovered money was found in folded white kerchief.
23. In the light of the decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, referred to above, this Court is of the view that the prosecution has not established the alleged guilt that the appellant / accused had demanded illegal gratification from P.W.2 and also received the same knowingly that it was received by him as illegal gratification. The aforesaid two aspects should be proved beyond reasonable doubt for convicting the appellant / accused. However, there is suspicious circumstance, with regard to the alleged demand and the recovery of the tainted money, hence, I am of the view that benefit of doubt should be given to the accused.
24. On the aforesaid facts and circumstances, I find it just and reasonable to allow the criminal appeal, holding that the prosecution has not established the alleged guilt beyond reasonable doubt against the appellant / accused for convicting the appellant / accused under Sections 7 and 13 (1) (d) r/w 13 (2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, accordingly, the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellant by the Special Judge-cum-Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thanjavur at Kumbakonam in Special Case No.15 of 2002 is liable to be set aside, to meet the ends of justice.
25. In the result, this Criminal Appeal is allowed and the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellant / accused by the Court below in Special Case No.15 of 2002 is set aside. The bail bond, if any executed by the appellant shall stand cancelled and the fine amount, if any paid by the appellant shall be refunded to him, as per procedure.
tsvn To
1. The Special Judge-cum-Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thanjavur at Kumbakonam.
2.The Public Prosecutor, Madurai Bench of Madras High Court Madurai.
Alert