- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Manickam Moopan v. Lakshmi
Judgment Summary — Second Appeals Nos. 912 & 913 of 2006
Factual and Procedural Background
The two Second Appeals (MD Nos. 912 and 913 of 2006) arise from a common first appellate judgment and involve the same parties and identical questions of law and evidence; they were heard together. The plaintiff sued in O.S. No. 37 of 2003 in the District Munsif Court, Tiruchirappalli, seeking recovery of Rs. 19,125 as arrears of rent from the defendant, who was admitted to be a cultivating tenant. The trial Court decreed Rs. 11,061 with 6% future interest. The defendant appealed (A.S. No. 200 of 2004) and the plaintiff filed a cross-appeal against the disallowed portion. The first appellate Court modified the decree to Rs. 17,025 with 6% future interest, allowing the plaintiff's cross-appeal. The defendant challenged the appellate modification by filing the two Second Appeals now before this Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Second Appeals are maintainable in view of the pecuniary limitation in Section 102, Code of Civil Procedure (no second appeal where subject matter of suit is for recovery of money not exceeding Rs. 25,000).
- If the Second Appeals are barred by Section 102 CPC, whether the appeals may be converted (with leave) into revisions—either under Section 115 CPC or by treating/ converting them into proceedings under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent's Arguments
- Learned counsel for the respondent (Mr. S. Muthukrishnan) submitted that the appeals are not maintainable under Section 102 C.P.C., because the subject matter of the suit is below Rs. 25,000.
- Learned counsel for the respondent (Janab Mohamad Ihram Saibu) additionally submitted that when an appeal is not maintainable due to the pecuniary limit in Section 102 C.P.C., the court cannot dismiss on that account but can grant leave to convert the appeal into a revision.
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant relied on precedents (cited in the opinion) and filed a memo requesting conversion of the appeals into revision petitions.
- The opinion notes that the counsel who filed the memo cannot later contradict that position ("Since Mr. Muthukrishnan is the root cause for filing this memo, he cannot now say otherwise").
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| N. Bansidhar v. Dwarakalal [AIR 1974 Karnatak 117] | Listed by appellant counsel as authority on conversion; later described as dealing with conversion of a revision as an appeal and return for presentation before proper court. | The Court held that this decision is not applicable to the facts of the present case. |
| Jiwan Dass v. Narain Dass [AIR 1981 Delhi 291] | Holds that the label attached to a cause is not conclusive and that courts have discretion to treat an appeal as a revision (or vice versa) where justice demands and conditions under Section 115 CPC are satisfied. | The Court treated this decision as "near us" and noted its principle that labels may be corrected where justice demands and Section 115 conditions are met. |
| R.S Pillai v. M.L Peratchi @ Selvi [2000 (IV) CTC 543 (DB) : 2000-3-L.W. 11] | In that case, a Division Bench converted an appeal into a revision in view of the peculiar facts and circumstances, in the interest of justice. | The Court observed that in peculiar facts and in the interest of justice conversion had been permitted in that precedent. |
| K. Chockalingam v. K.R. Ramasamy Iyer [2004 (4) L.W 586] | Contains detailed analysis that Section 102 CPC bars second appeals where pecuniary limit is not met and that Section 115 CPC should not be invoked to circumvent Section 102; discusses availability of Article 227 when revision under Section 115 is barred. | The Court expressly followed the analysis in Chockalingam and relied on it to determine that conversion should be effected under Article 227 rather than under Section 115 CPC. |
| Sadhana Lodh v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. (2003 (3) SCC 524 : 2003-1-L.W. 815) | Supreme Court authority that where an alternative statutory remedy (appeal/revision) exists, interference under Article 226/227 is not ordinarily permissible; but where revision is expressly barred by statute, Article 227 may lie. | The Court cited this authority for the proposition that Article 227 is permissible only when statutory remedies are unavailable or barred, and used it in the chain of reasoning permitting conversion to Article 227 in the present circumstances. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in these steps:
- It identified Section 102 C.P.C. as the statutory bar: no second appeal lies where the subject matter of an original suit for recovery of money does not exceed Rs. 25,000. The subject matter of the present suit is below Rs. 25,000, so Section 102 bars a second appeal.
- It noted that a revision remedy is provided by Section 115 C.P.C., but examined whether Section 115 can be invoked in this situation to receive the mislabelled second appeal as a revision. The Court referred to precedents and authorities on the permissibility of converting appeals to revisions.
- The Court distinguished N. Bansidhar v. Dwarakalal as inapplicable to the present facts.
- The Court noted Jiwan Dass for the principle that courts may correct labels (treat an appeal as a revision) where justice demands and Section 115 conditions are satisfied.
- The Court examined K. Chockalingam v. K.R. Ramasamy Iyer, which held that Section 115 should not be used to circumvent Section 102 (i.e., to permit, in effect, a second appeal by re-labelling it as a civil revision), and that allowing such conversions would defeat the legislative intent behind limiting second appeals. The Court found this reasoning persuasive and preferred to follow Chockalingam.
- The Court reconciled the above with the Supreme Court decision in Sadhana Lodh, which limits Article 227 interference where statutory remedies exist, but permits Article 227 only where statutory remedies (like revision) are expressly barred. On that basis, the Court accepted that when Section 115 revision is not an appropriate vehicle to circumvent Section 102, conversion under Article 227 may be permissible.
- Applying these principles to the facts, and in view of the memo filed by the appellant requesting conversion, the Court concluded that leave should be given to convert the Second Appeals into Civil Revision Petitions under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
Holding and Implications
The Second Appeals (MD Nos. 912 and 913 of 2006) are to be converted into Civil Revision Petitions under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The Registrar (Judicial) of the Bench is directed to convert the second appeals into Civil Revision petitions under Article 227 and to take necessary administrative actions to give effect to that conversion.
- No broader new legal precedent is announced by the Court; the decision follows and applies existing authorities (in particular K. Chockalingam) to the facts, and frames the conversion as permissible under Article 227 in the circumstances described.
1. Since Second Appeals Nos. 912 and 913 of 2006 arise out of a common judgment rendered by the first appellate Court and the parties are same and the evidence and question of law involved are same, they are heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment.
2. Admittedly, the defendant is a cultivating tenant under the plaintiffs with respect to certain lands situate in Melapandamangalam in Tiruchira-ppalli District. Plaintiff filed the suit in O.S No. 37 of 2003 in the Court of the District Munsif, Tiruchirappalli for recovery of Rs. 19,125/- towards arrears of rent. It was hotly contested by the defendant. Ultimately, the trial Court decreed the suit for Rs. 11,061/- only together with 6% future interest. Aggrieved, the defendant filed A.S No. 200 of 2004, while the plaintiff filed Cross Appeal as against the disallowed portion of the suit claim. The first appellate Court modified the trial court's decree by decreeing the suit for Rs. 17,025/- with 6% future interest, thus, it allowed the plaintiffs cross-appeal. Now, as against modifying the trial court's decree, the defendant filed Second Appeal (MD) No. 912 of 2006 and as against allowing the Cross appeal, he filed Second Appeal (MD) No. 913 of 2006.
3. Mr. S. Muthukrishnan, learned counsel for the respondent referring to Section 102 C.P.C submitted that the appeals are not maintainable in this Court.
4. In the circumstances, Janab Mohamad Ihram Saibu, learned counsel for the respondent submitted that when an appeal was not maintainable in view of the pecuniary limit mentioned in Section 102 C.P.C, on that account an appeal cannot be dismissed, however, the court can grant leave to convert it as a revision.
5. On this aspect, the learned counsel for the appellant cited the following decisions:
(i) N. Bansidhar v. Dwarakalal [AIR 1974 Karnatak 117],
(ii) Jiwan Dass v. Narain Dass [AIR 1981 Delhi 291].
(iii) R.S Pillai v. M.L Peratchi @ Selvi [2000 (IV) CTC 543 (DB) : 2000-3-L.W. 11]
6. The learned counsel for the appellant also filed a memo that the appeals may be converted as revision petitions.
7. Since Mr. Muthukrishnan is the root cause for filing this memo, he cannot now say otherwise.
8. Now, the question arises whether in the circumstances, these Second Appeals could be converted as revisions or not?
9. As per Section 102 C.P.C no second appeal shall lie from any decree, when the subject matter of the original suit is for recovery of money not exceeding twenty five thousand rupees.
10. So, Section 102 C.P.C prescribes a monetary limit of Rs. 25,000/- to file Second Appeal. Thus to file a second appeal, the subject matter of the suit should be above Rs. 25,000/-. Admittedly, the subject matter of the suit in these appeals are below Rs. 25,000/-. So, Section 102 C.P.C is a bar to maintain these second appeals.
11. A revision is provided under Section 115 C.P.C
12. Ban Sidhar v. Dwarakalal [AIR 1974 Karnataka 117] deals with a plea for conversion of a revision as an appeal and also deals with return of that petition for presentation before proper court. That is not the situation before us. It is not applicable to the facts of our case.
13. Jiwan Dass v. Narain Dass [AIR 1981 DELHI 291] is near us. The Delhi High Court held as under:
“It is now a settled law that the label placed on a cause is not conclusive and does not ordinarily affect the jurisdiction of the court to allow the label to be corrected by treating an appeal on a revision or a revision as an appeal. Provided of course the cause of justice so demands. In cases where no appeal lies but an appeal has been wrongly preferred, the Court has the wide discretion to treat it as a revision where the conditions laid down under Section 115 C.P.C are satisfied.”
(emphasis supplied by me.)
14. In R.S Pillai v. Peratchi @ Selvi [2000 (IV) CTC 543 : 2000-3-L.W. 11] in view of the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, a Division Bench of this Court in the interest of justice converted an appeal as a revision.
15. In K. Chockalingam v. K.R. Ramasamy Iyer [2004 (4) L.W 586] exactly similar question as before us arose. A memo was filed seeking the leave of the court to convert the second appeal as a revision. There a controversy arose whether under such circumstances, the revision could be filed under Section 115 C.P.C or under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
16. It is profitable here to note the following portions of the judgment in K. Chockalingam v. K.R. Ramasamy Iyer [2004 (4) L.W 586]:
“13. This revision is filed only under Section 115 C.P.C The suit is one for the recovery of less than a sum of Rs. 25,000/-. After the suit was decreed, an appeal has been preferred, which was allowed nullifying the lower courts decree and judgment. Section 102 of Code of Civil Procedure Code says, no second appeal shall lie from any decree. When the subject matter of the original suit is for recovery of money, not exceeding Rs. 25,000/-. In view of this provision, a second appeal is barred and that is why, a revision is filed under Section 115 C.P.C, which is not maintainable, according to the learned counsel for the respondents. When there is a specific bar for filing the second appeal, when the suit is for recovery of money, not exceeding Rs. 25,000/-, it should be held, a revision is also not maintainable under Section 115 C.P.C Section 115 C.P.C empowers the High Court, to call for the record of any case which has been decided by any Court Subordinate to such High Court in which no appeal lies thereto. From the wordings deployed in the above Section, it is clear, the High Court is empowered to entertain a revision, when no appeal is provided or where no appeal lies. In other words, if the code provides, an appeal provision, from the decree and judgment of the subordinate court, then ordinarily invoking Section 115 C.P.C is not possible. In this case, against the decree and judgment passed by the District Munsif Court, in O.S No. 147/97 an appeal provision is provided, and an appeal has been preferred also. Then, considering the pecuniary jurisdiction of the suit, the second appeal is prohibited or barred. In this view, it cannot be said, no appeal is provided against the decree and judgment, thereby to invoke Section 115 C.P.C under the guise of revisional power. If the cases of this nature are allowed to be entertained under Section 115 C.P.C, it would amount to eclipsing Section 102 C.P.C, which aims the curtailment of Second appeal, in the sense, prolonged litigation. Where the subject matter is less than Rs. 25,000/-, the High Court invoking Section 115 C.P.C, if maintains the revision, it would amount to second appeal under the label of Civil Revision Petition, thereby allowing the parties, to file second appeal, indirectly, ignoring Section 102, thereby defeating the intention of the legislature, which should not be allowed. In this view of the matter, I am of the considered opinion, the revision petition under Section 115 is not maintainable.
14. The learned counsel for the petitioner realising this difficulty alone, as aforementioned, has filed a memo for the conversion of Cr. P.C under Section 227 Cr. P.C which is permissible. In Sadhana Lodh v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., (2003 (3) SCC 524 : 2003-1-L.W. 815), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held, when alternative remedy is available, interference under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India, is not permissible. It is observed:
“Where a statutory right to file an appeal has been provided for, it is not open to High Court to entertain a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution. Even if where a remedy by way of an appeal has not been provided for against the order and judgment of a District Judge, the remedy available to the aggrieved person is to file a revision before the High Court under Section 115 C.P.C Where remedy for filing a revision before the High Court under Section 115 CPC has been expressly barred by a State enactment, only in such case a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution would lie and not under Article 226 of the Constitution.”
15. In this view, it is held, where a remedy for filing a revision petition under Section 115 is barred in such cases, petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, is maintainable. In this view, this petition could be treated, as one filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, and not under Section 115 C.P.C,”
17. In the circumstances, in view of the above position of law explained and described in K. Chockalingam v. K.R. Ramasamy Iyer [2004 (4) L.W 586], I am preferred to follow Chockalingam (supra).
18. Thus, the leave now sought for could be granted to convert the second appeal as a Civil Revision Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
19. In the result,
(1) The second appeals shall be converted as Civil Revision petitions under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
(2) The Registrar (Judicial) of this Bench shall convert the second appeals as Civil Revision petitions under Article 227 of the Constitution of India and take further necessary administrative actions.
VCJ/VCS
Alert