- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
V.K. Ramesh v. Superintending Engin...
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The Petition arises from the death in service of the Petitioner's father, Mr. V. Krishnamurthy, who was employed as an Accounts Assistant with the Tamil Nadu Electricity Board (TNEB) and died on 11.05.1996. At that time the Petitioner had completed Plus Two. The Petitioner submitted an initial application seeking appointment on compassionate grounds on 15.01.1997. The 1st Respondent subsequently requested supporting documents, including death certificate, educational certificate, no objection certificate from other family members, copy of Board proceedings sanctioning death relief, and a court order regarding succession certificate.
The Petitioner and other legal heirs obtained a Legal Heir / Succession Certificate from the Sub-Court, Vellore on 07.11.1997 (in S.O.P No. 68 of 1997). The 1st Respondent passed proceedings on 30.12.1999 sanctioning death/retirement/gratuity payments to legal heirs. The Petitioner submitted the prescribed application form and supporting certificates on 15.03.2000. The 1st Respondent rejected the Petitioner's application by order dated 07.05.2001 on the ground that the application was belated. The Petitioner appealed to the 2nd Respondent on 19.09.2001 and sent a reminder on 03.07.2002; no orders were passed on the appeal. Aggrieved, the Petitioner filed the present Writ Petition seeking quashing of the 07.05.2001 proceedings and a direction to appoint him to a suitable post on compassionate grounds.
Family facts noted in the affidavit: the deceased had two wives (first wife K. Sugunambal with five children; second wife K. Kalaiselvi @ Kalaivani with two children, including the Petitioner). The Petitioner's family describes indigent circumstances and the Petitioner's mother earning a small, irregular income.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the 1st Respondent was justified in rejecting the Petitioner's claim for compassionate appointment by order dated 07.05.2001 on the ground that the application was belated.
- Whether the Petitioner's initial application (15.01.1997) made within three years of the father's death should be treated as satisfying the time requirement for seeking compassionate appointment despite later filings of prescribed forms (submitted on 15.03.2000).
- Whether, in view of the relevant administrative instructions and judicial precedents cited, the Petitioner should be considered for appointment on compassionate grounds and accommodated in a suitable post notwithstanding the respondent's objection based on technical delay.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The Petitioner had made an application on compassionate grounds on 15.01.1997, which was within the prescribed three-year period from the father's death (11.05.1996).
- The delay in producing certain documents was attributable to the 1st Respondent's delay in requesting those documents; the Sub-Court issued the Succession Certificate on 07.11.1997 and the 1st Respondent later sanctioned payment to legal heirs on 30.12.1999.
- Having produced all required certificates (including the No Objection Certificate from other legal heirs) the Petitioner's claim has not been considered; he should not be faulted for any consequential timing of submitting the prescribed form on 15.03.2000.
- The Petitioner's family is indigent and deserves consideration for compassionate appointment to mitigate the hardship caused by the father's death in service.
- Relied upon judicial authorities (Syed Khadim Hussain; M. Uma; others) to support that applications made in time or deserving cases should be considered despite technical objections.
Respondents' Arguments
- The Respondents state that the Petitioner's prescribed application form for employment assistance was re-submitted only on 15.03.2000, i.e., after the expiry of three years from the date of death (11.05.1996), and therefore the 1st Respondent rightly rejected the application on 07.05.2001 as belated.
- The Respondents rely on departmental instructions in (BP) Ms. (FB) No. 46 dated 13.10.1995 which, as stated in the counter-affidavit, require that applications in the prescribed format be made within three years from the date of death of Board employees (with specified exceptions such as age limit adjustments for widows).
- The Respondents point out that although a Succession Certificate was obtained on 07.11.1997, the Petitioner failed to submit the prescribed application form within three years from the date of death and therefore the rejection was correct.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Syed Khadim Hussain v. State of Bihar, 2006 (9) SCC 195 | When an applicant/dependent has applied within the prescribed period but the application was rejected without reasons, authorities should consider the application; in that case Supreme Court directed consideration and appointment in the peculiar facts. | The Court invoked this decision as authority supporting that an application made in time ought to be considered and that rejecting such an application without proper basis is not acceptable. |
| M. Uma v. Chief Engineer (Personnel), Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Chennai, 2010 (7) MLJ 644 | Where an application was rejected on the ground of non-submission within three years, the Court directed consideration of the claim taking into account the indigent circumstances of the family; judgments relied upon in that case (e.g., Bhagwan Singh, Parasnath) were held not directly applicable to that fact situation. | The Court relied on this High Court decision as a local precedent that compassionate appointment claims may be considered despite technical non-compliance with the three-year rule, particularly in view of hardship. |
| G. Vijayaraghavan v. General Manager (P) Indian Bank, 2000 (3) LLN 625 | Principle that irrespective of settlement of full-term service gratuity and other benefits, an eligible person can claim appointment on compassionate grounds. | The Court cited this decision to support the proposition that payment/settlement of monetary benefits does not preclude a dependent from claiming compassionate appointment. |
| Balbir Kaur v. Steel Authority of India Ltd., 2000 (6) SCC 493 | The Supreme Court's legal proposition that, in appointment matters, considerations of social and economic justice may require setting aside denial in deserving cases. | The Court relied on this principle to emphasise that compassionate appointment schemes aim to mitigate hardship and that deserving claims should not be denied on mere technicalities. |
| Union of India v. Bhagwan Singh, 1995 (6) SCC 476 | Referenced in the opinion quoted within M. Uma but noted in this opinion as one of the authorities that the M. Uma decision discussed; the present opinion records that such judgments were not directly applicable in that instance. | The Court noted that Bhagwan Singh (as cited in M. Uma) was considered in earlier proceedings but was not directly applicable to the facts of the M. Uma case; it used M. Uma for guidance rather than Bhagwan Singh directly. |
| State of U.P v. Parasnath, 1998 (2) SCC 412 | Referenced in the opinion quoted within M. Uma and cited by the High Court in that context; described in the opinion as not directly applicable to the facts of M. Uma. | The opinion records Parasnath as one of the decisions considered in earlier litigation (M. Uma) but states it was not directly applicable to that case; the present Court relied on M. Uma's reasoning instead of Parasnath. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the timeline and documents on record. It accepted the following factual points from the materials:
- The deceased employee died on 11.05.1996 and the Petitioner (who had passed Plus Two) submitted an application seeking compassionate appointment on 15.01.1997.
- The 1st Respondent subsequently requested the family to submit the prescribed application form and supporting records (death and legal heir certificates, revenue certificates) and provided a specimen application form (Appendix-I).
- The Legal Heir / Succession Certificate was issued by the Sub-Court, Vellore on 07.11.1997; the 1st Respondent sanctioned payments to legal heirs by proceedings dated 30.12.1999.
- The Petitioner submitted the prescribed application form and supporting certificates on 15.03.2000; the 1st Respondent rejected the application on 07.05.2001 as belated.
The Court identified the principal dispute as whether the rejection for belated filing was proper given the Petitioner's initial application on 15.01.1997. The Court reasoned:
- The purpose of compassionate appointment is to mitigate hardship to the family of an employee who dies in service.
- The Petitioner had, in the Court's view, applied for compassionate appointment within the prescribed three-year period by his 15.01.1997 application; the later completion/submission of the prescribed form was in the context of the 1st Respondent's directions and the issuance of the Succession Certificate.
- Given that the Petitioner had made his initial claim within three years and produced the required certificates upon the 1st Respondent's direction, the Court concluded he could not be faulted for the dates on which documents were later filed.
- The Court relied on cited precedents (Syed Khadim Hussain; Balbir Kaur; M. Uma; G. Vijayaraghavan) to support the view that deserving applicants should not be denied compassionate appointment on mere technical grounds and that monetary settlement of benefits does not preclude a claim for appointment.
- Applying these legal principles to the facts, the Court held that the impugned order of rejection dated 07.05.2001 must be set aside and the respondents should consider the Petitioner's claim for compassionate appointment in a suitable post according to his qualifications.
The Court did not undertake an extended factual inquiry into comparative merit for appointment; it framed relief as a direction to consider and pass appropriate orders within a specified time.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Writ Petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 07.05.2001 passed by the 1st Respondent is set aside. The Respondents are directed to consider the Petitioner's claim for compassionate appointment in any suitable post in accordance with his qualifications and to pass appropriate orders within twelve (12) weeks from receipt of a copy of this order. No costs were awarded.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The respondents must reconsider the Petitioner's claim and take a decision on appointment in a suitable post within the specified twelve-week period; the earlier rejection for belatedness is quashed.
- Scope of precedent: The Court applied existing precedents emphasizing social and economic justice in compassionate appointment cases and the permissibility of consideration despite technical delays. The opinion does not state that it creates a new precedent beyond the application of those authorities; its directive is limited to the respondents' fresh consideration of the Petitioner's case.
1. Heard Mr. S. Doraisamy, learned Counsel for the Petitioner and Mr. B. Kumar, learned Counsel appearing for the Respondents/TNEB.
2. Challenging the proceedings of the 1st Respondent dated 07.05.2001, seeking to quash the same and for a direction to the Respondents to appoint him in a suitable post on compassionate grounds, the Petitioner has filed this Writ Petition.
3. Brief facts of the case as set out in the Affidavit would run thus:
(i) The Petitioner's father Mr. V. Krishnamurthy was working as Accounts Assistant in the office of the Executive Engineer, Revenue Branch, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Katpadi (Vellore) and died while in service on 11.05.1996 At that time, the Petitioner passed Plus Two. Thereafter, the Petitioner preferred an Application to the 2nd Respondent on 15.01.1997 for an appointment on compassionate grounds. On 15.04.1998, the 1st Respondent wrote to the Petitioner to submit certain documents namely, (i) Death Certificate of his father (ii) Educational Certificate (iii) No Objection Certificate from other family members for giving appointment to him (iv) A copy of the proceedings from the 1st Respondent sanctioning payment of Death Relief benefits of his father, and (v) a copy of Court order regarding Succession Certificate.
(ii) The Petitioner would state that this father had two wives. His mother K. Kalaiselvi @ Kalaivani is the 2nd wife and K. Sugunambal is the 1st wife. Through the 1st wife, his father had five children and through the 2nd wife, he had two children. Both the family members made a joint application for the payment of Death cum Retirement Gratuity, etc. benefits from the Respondents' Board. Since the 1st Respondent required a Succession Certificate from the Judicial Forum, the Petitioner and other legal heirs of his father preferred a Petition before the Sub-Court, Vellore in S.O.P No. 68 of 1997.
(iii) On 07.11.1997, the Sub-Court issued a Certificate declaring his father's 1st wife and her children and his 2nd wife and her children as legal heirs of his father and granted a Certificate to that effect, stating that they are entitled to succeed to his estate and entitled to claim the amount from the Respondent Board. They produced the Certificate before the 1st Respondent and on 30.12.1999, the 1st Respondent in his proceedings No. 764/49294.Adm.2.A3/99 passed an order sanctioning the amount and computing the amount to be payable to each of the legal heirs.
(iv) In the meanwhile, the 1st wife of his father and her children and the Petitioner's family members gave a no objection letter on 10.09.1999 to the 1st Respondent for providing a job to the Petitioner on compassionate ground in the Respondent Board. According to the Petitioner, his family is leading life in a poor condition and they do not have any specific income. His mother is doing cooly work and earning a sum of Rs. 600/- per month, which is also not permanent.
(v) The Petitioner would further state that in continuation of his Application dated 15.01.1997 and as per the direction of the 1st Respondent, the Petitioner sent all the certificates on 15.03.2000 to the 1st Respondent for appointment. However, the 1st Respondent rejected the Petitioner's Application on 07.05.2001 on the ground that his Application is belated. Thereafter, the Petitioner sent an Appeal to the 2nd Respondent on 19.09.2001 and a reminder on 03.07.2002 for considering his case for appointment in the Respondents' Board on compassionate grounds. However, no order was passed on his Appeal by the 2nd Respondent. Aggrieved by the same, the Petitioner is before this Court.
4. Counter Affidavit has been filed by the Respondents. It is stated therein that the Petitioner's father Mr. V. Krishnamurthy was employed in TNEB as Accounts Assistant in the office of the Executive Engineer, Revenue Branch, Katpadi and died on 11.05.1996 while in service. The Petitioner sent a letter dated 15.01.1997 to the 1st Respondent on 17.01.1997 requesting to consider employment assistance on compassionate grounds duly enclosing the educational qualification certificates. On receipt of the letter, the 1st Respondent sent a letter to the Petitioner's mother, duly enclosing the specimen Application Form (Appendix-I) for seeking employment assistance on compassionate grounds with a request to return the Application Form duly filled in along with the relevant records, i.e Death & Legal Heir Certificates and other certificates obtained from the Revenue Officials for taking further action vide letter dated 25.04.1998 The Petitioner re-submitted the Application Form (Annexure-I) for seeking employment assistance on compassionate grounds along with the relevant records on 15.03.2000 only after a lapse of 3 years from the date of death of the Board employee.
4a. The Respondents would state that as per the instructions issued in per (BP) Ms. (FB) No. 46, dated 13.10.1995,—
(i) The Application in the prescribed format for appointment on compassionate grounds should be made within three years from the date of death of employees of the Board.
(ii) The maximum age limit for such appointment is raised to 50 (fifty) years in the case of widows of the deceased employees of the Board.
(iii) In the case of already expired staff while in service the dependant should apply for employment assistance within three years from the date of issue of the order.
4b. The Respondents would further submit that the Petitioner's father died on 11.05.1996 and the Petitioner submitted the Application in the prescribed format (Annexure-I) seeking employment assistance on 15.03.2000 only after expiry of the prescribed time limit. Even though the Petitioner got Succession Certificate from the Sub-Court, Vellore during 07.11.1997, he had failed to submit the Application form immediately, i.e within a period of three (3) years from the date of death of employee of the Board. But, he had submitted the Application after expiry of 3 years period. Therefore, the 1st Respondent had rightly rejected the Petitioner's Application on 07.05.2001
5. Learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioner would submit that the Petitioner preferred an Application on compassionate ground on 15.01.1997 well within the prescribed period of three years from his father's death on 11.05.1996 He would contend that the 1st Respondent took more than a year to direct the Petitioner to produce some documents and that the Petitioner applied for Succession Certificate and the Sub-Court, Vellore passed an order on 07.11.1997 and based on the same, the 1st Respondent passed an order on 30.12.1999 sanctioning death cum retirement, gratuity, etc. payments. Therefore, there is no delay on the part of the Petitioner in producing the required documents. It is also the contention of the learned Counsel that in spite of producing all the required certificates including the No Objection Certificate from other legal heirs for getting Compassionate Appointment in the Respondents' Board, the Petitioner's claim is so far not considered by the Respondents.
5a. In support of his case, learned Counsel for the Petitioner has relied on the following:
(i) a Supreme Court decision reported in the case of Syed Khadim Hussain v. State of Bihar, 2006 (9) SCC 195:
“5. We are unable to accept the contention of the Counsel for the State. In the instant case, the widow had applied for appointment within the prescribed period and without assigning any reasons the same was rejected. When the Appellant submitted the Application he was 13 years old and the Application was rejected after a period of six years and that too without giving any reason and the reason given by the authorities was incorrect as at the time of rejection of the Application he must have crossed 18 years and he could have been very well considered for appointment. Of course, in the rules framed by the State, there is no specific provision as to what should be done in case the dependants are minors and there would be any relaxation of age in case they did not attain majority within the prescribed period for submitting Application.
6. As the widow had submitted the Application in time the authorities should have considered her Application. As eleven years have passed she would not be in a position to join the Government service. In our opinion, this is a fit case where the Appellant should have been considered in her place for appointment. Counsel for the State could not point out any other circumstance for which the Appellant would be disentitled to be considered for appointment. In the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case, we direct the Respondent-Authorities to consider the Application of the Appellant and give him appropriate appointment within a reasonable time at least within a period of three months. The Appeal is disposed of in the above terms. No costs.”
(ii) a decision of this Court reported in the case of M. Uma v. Chief Engineer (Personnel), Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Chennai, 2010 (7) MLJ 644:
“13. Though the learned Single Judge while rejecting the request of the Petitioner relied on judgment of one of us (P.S, J.) made in W.P No. 14134 of 1991 dated 25.01.1999 and the case of Union of India v. Bhagwan Singh, 1995 (6) SCC 476 as well as the case of State of U.P v. Parasnath, 1998 (2) SCC 412, for the same reasons as stated in para 11 above, those judgments are not directly applicable to the case on hand. In the case of G. Vijayaraghavan v. General Manager (P) Indian Bank, 2000 (3) LLN 625, learned Single Judge of this Court (PSJ) in similar circumstances directed the Indian Bank to consider the claim of the Petitioner therein, who made an Application on attaining majority for employment on compassionate ground. In that decision, it is held that, irrespective of settlement of full term service gratuity and other benefits, eligible person can claim appointment on compassionate grounds.”
6. On the other hand, learned Counsel appearing for the Respondent Board would contend that the Petitioner submitted the Application for compassionate appointment in the prescribed format on 15.03.2000 only after the expiry of the prescribed time limit and therefore, the 1st Respondent had rightly rejected the Petitioner's Application on 07.05.2001
7. I have given careful consideration to the submissions of the learned Counsel on either side and perused relevant materials on record.
8. Admittedly, the Petitioner's father was employed with the Respondent Board as Accounts Assistant and died in harness on 11.05.1996 At that time, the Petitioner passed plus two. On 15.01.1997, the Petitioner preferred an Application to the 2nd Respondent for an appointment on compassionate grounds. On receipt of the same, the 1st Respondent sent a letter to the Petitioner's mother duly enclosing the specimen Application Form (Appendix-I) seeking employment assistance on compassionate ground with a request to return the Application form duly filled in along with the relevant records, i.e Death and Legal Heir Certificates and other certificates obtained from the Revenue officials for taking further action.
9. The only objection raised by the Respondent-Board is that the Petitioner submitted the Application seeking compassionate appointment in the prescribed format only on 15.03.2000, after expiry of the prescribed time limit and hence, the 1st Respondent rejected the Petitioner's Application.
10. It is seen that the Petitioner, after attaining majority, had applied to the 1st Respondent seeking employment on compassionate ground on 15.01.1997 well within the prescribed time of 3 years from his father's death. A perusal of the materials on record would show that the Petitioner and other legal heirs of his father preferred a Petition before the Sub-Court, Vellore in S.O.P No. 68 of 1997 and the Legal Heir Certificate was issued on 07.11.1997 On production of the said certificate before the 1st Respondent, by proceedings dated 30.12.1999, the 1st Respondent passed an order sanctioning the amount payable to each of the legal heirs. Thereafter, as per the direction of the 1st Respondent, the Petitioner sent all the certificates to the 1st Respondent for appointment on 15.03.2000 However, the 1 Respondent rejected the Petitioner's Application on 07.05.2001 on the ground that his application is belated. But, the fact remains clear that the Petitioner has made an Application for compassionate appointment on 15.01.1997 itself well within the prescribed time limit of 3 years from his father's death. Therefore, the Petitioner cannot be faulted with, that he has sent the Application belatedly.
11. The purpose of providing employment to a dependant of a Government servant dying in harness in preference to anybody else is to mitigate the hardship caused to the family of the employee on account of his unexpected death while in service. In the case of Syed Khadim Hussain v. State of Bihar (referred to supra), the Supreme Court has allowed the case of the Petitioner for compassionate appointment. Further, in the case of Balbir Kaur v. Steel Authority of India Ltd., 2000 (6) SCC 493, the legal proposition laid down by the Supreme Court is that in the case of appointment, considering the social and economic justice as enshrined in the Constitution, denial of deserving cases are liable to be set aside. In a similar circumstance, in the case of M. Uma v. Chief Engineer (Personnel), TNEB, Chennai, 2010 (7) MLJ 644, wherein the Petitioner's Application was rejected on the ground that she has not submitted the same within three years, this Court, taking into account the indigent circumstances of the family directed the Respondents therein to consider the claim of the Petitioner seeking compassionate appointment without reference to the objection raised in the impugned order. Also, in the case of G. Vijayaraghavan v. General Manager (P) Indian Bank, 2000 (3) LLN 625, the principle laid down by this Court is that irrespective of settlement of full term service, gratuity and other benefits, the eligible person can claim appointment on compassionate grounds.
12. In view of the legal propositions laid down in the decisions referred to supra and considering the fact that the Petitioner has preferred an Application for compassionate appointment well within the prescribed time, this Court is of the opinion that the Petitioner's claim for compassionate appointment cannot be denied and that the Petitioner can be accommodated in any suitable post as per his qualification. Therefore, the impugned order dated 07.05.2001 passed by the 1st Respondent is set aside and the Respondents are directed to consider the claim of the Petitioner for compassionate appointment in any suitable post and pass appropriate orders within a period of twelve (12) weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
With the above direction, the Writ Petition is allowed. No costs.
Alert