- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
P. Nagarathna Pandian Petitioner v. The Managing Director, Tamil Nadu Housing Board
Summary of Opinion — W.P. No. 6902 of 2006 (Pre-Delivery Order dated 30.7.2010)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner was a long-standing employee of the Tamil Nadu Housing Board, appointed initially as Junior Engineer on 5.3.1965 and promoted through various grades up to Superintendent Engineer in 1994. He attained superannuation on 30.11.1998. On 28.11.1998 the petitioner was placed under suspension and was not permitted to retire, following issue of a charge memo dated 18.11.1998 alleging rejection of a Government of India tender while on deputation.
The petitioner submitted an explanation denying the charge on 2.12.1998. An enquiry was held and the enquiry officer submitted a report holding that the charge was not proved. The Housing Board accepted the enquiry report, passed a resolution on 27.11.2003 to drop the charge and to allow the petitioner to retire effective 30.11.1998. That resolution was sent to Government and was approved by Government by G.O.(1D) No.164, Housing and Urban Development Department, dated 14.4.2004. The Board issued final proceedings on 25.5.2004 allowing retirement from 30.11.1998 and treating the period of suspension as duty.
Because payments due on retirement were disbursed after substantial delay (approximately six years), the petitioner sought interest on belated disbursement of terminal benefits and retirement dues. The impugned administrative order refusing interest was dated 22.8.2005 and is the subject-matter of this writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Amounts admitted in the petition as paid after delay (with dates of disbursement in the record) include:
- Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity (DCRG): Rs. 3,20,067/- paid on 2.8.2004
- Commutation of pension: Rs. 3,99,164/- paid on 2.8.2004
- Special Provident Fund: Rs. 10,058/- paid on 19.8.2004
- Provident Fund: Rs. 1,23,234/- paid on 16.6.2004
- Surrender of Earned Leave: Rs. 1,60,784/- paid on 30.11.2004
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to interest from 30.11.1998 on belated payments of retirement benefits (including gratuity, provident funds, commutation of pension and encashment of leave) where disciplinary charges that delayed payment were ultimately dropped.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner relied on G.O.Ms No. 510, Finance (Pension) Department dated 27.6.1995 (amendment to Rule 45-A of the Tamil Nadu Pension Rules, 1978) which prescribes periods beyond which interest is payable in cases where payment is withheld due to disciplinary proceedings and subsequently allowed.
- The petitioner relied on Supreme Court and High Court authorities (including S.K. Dua v. State of Haryana and Government of T.N. v. Deivasigamani) establishing that an employee is entitled to interest on belated payment of pension and other terminal benefits, even in the absence of statutory rules, and that interest can be claimed under Part III of the Constitution (Articles 14, 19 and 21).
- The petitioner contended that because the charges were ultimately dropped and the delay in payment lasted about six years (from 30.11.1998), he is entitled to interest on the belated disbursements and specifically sought interest at the rate indicated in earlier authority (2000 (2) SLR 686).
Respondents' Arguments
- In the counter affidavit the respondents accepted the factual history but contended that the petitioner's request for payment of interest was not maintainable because the charge was dropped only on 25.5.2004 (i.e., payment followed the dropping of the charge), and therefore the delay in payment was attributable to pendency of disciplinary proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| O.P. Gupta v. Union of India, (1987) 4 SCC 328 | Principle that an officer under suspension is entitled to expect departmental proceedings to be concluded with reasonable diligence and within a reasonable period; recognition of prejudice caused by prolonged enquiries. | Referred to for the general principle that prolonged departmental proceedings can give rise to relief including interest for delayed pensionary benefits; used to support awarding interest. |
| Dr. Uma Agrawal v. State of U.P., (1999) 3 SCC 438 | Recognition that grant of pension is a right (not a bounty) and that courts can keep in mind time-schedules and relevant factors when awarding interest for delayed payment of retirement benefits. | Relied upon to show courts may award interest and quantify compensation for delay in settlement of retiral benefits. |
| State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair, (1985) 1 SCC 429 | Endorsement of High Court findings awarding interest for belated settlement and remark on State liability where culpable neglect causes delay. | Referred to for principle that State may be saddled with liability for culpable neglect causing delay in payment of retiral dues. |
| R. Lakshmikanthan v. Government of Tamil Nadu, 2006 WLR 623 (Madras High Court) | Application of Supreme Court decisions to order interest for belated payment where delay was unreasonable. | The court relied on this earlier decision of the same Court as a similar instance in which interest was ordered; used as persuasive precedential context. |
| S.K. Dua v. State of Haryana, (2008) 3 SCC 44 | Held that even in absence of statutory rules or administrative instructions, an employee can claim interest for belated payment relying on Part III (Articles 14, 19, 21) of the Constitution. | Applied as authority for the proposition that entitlement to interest on delayed retiral benefits exists even where statutory rules do not specifically provide for it. |
| Government of T.N. v. Deivasigamani, (2009) 3 MLJ 1 (Division Bench) | Followed S.K. Dua and held that employee is entitled to interest on belated pension and retiral benefits; recognized Article 14/19/21 route. | Applied as binding/persuasive authority of the Court reiterating entitlement to interest even absent statutory rules; specifically cited and followed. |
| Union of India v. M.S. Abdulla, (2006) 6 SCC 455 | Authority where Supreme Court ordered 12% interest per annum for belated payment of retirement benefits for voluntary retirement. | Referred to as an instance where the Supreme Court quantified interest; used in the survey of rates awarded in prior decisions. |
| Vijay L. Mehrotra v. State of U.P., 2000 (2) SLR 686 | Decision in which the Supreme Court ordered payment of 18% interest from date of retirement till payment of retirement dues. | Referred to by the petitioner and by the court in the discussion of precedents that have awarded differing interest rates, including 18% in that case. |
| Government of A.P. v. C. Purushotham, 2002 (7) SLR 760 (Andhra Pradesh High Court, Division Bench) | Division Bench awarded 12% interest for belated payment of terminal benefits. | Cited as another judicial instance awarding interest for delayed retiral dues; used in the comparative survey of precedents. |
| H. Gangahanume Gowda v. Karnataka Agro Industries Corpn. Ltd., 2003 (2) SLR 326 | Supportive authority for awarding interest for belated payment of retiral benefits. | Included in the list of authorities indicating consistent judicial practice to award interest on belated payments. |
| Gorakhpur University v. Dr. Shitla Prasad Nagendra, (2001) 6 SCC 591 | Another Supreme Court authority aligned with the view that interest may be awarded for delayed payment of retiral benefits. | Referred to as part of the body of Supreme Court decisions supporting award of interest for belated settlement. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in the following analytical steps based on the material in the record:
- The court first examined the statutory/administrative framework and identified G.O.Ms No. 510 (Finance (Pension) Department, dated 27.6.1995), which amends Rule 45-A of the Tamil Nadu Pension Rules, 1978. That amendment prescribes time periods beyond which interest is payable in cases where payment of Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity or other benefits is withheld due to disciplinary proceedings and later allowed. The court concluded that this Government Order shows an entitlement to interest for belated payment under Rule 45-A where the specified conditions are met.
- The court surveyed relevant judicial authority (both Supreme Court and High Court decisions) that consistently recognize entitlement to interest on belated payment of pensionary and other retiral benefits. The court emphasized precedents establishing that an employee may claim interest even in the absence of a statutory rule, relying on fundamental rights (Articles 14, 19 and 21) as explained in S.K. Dua and followed by the Division Bench in Government of T.N. v. Deivasigamani.
- The court assessed the facts of delay. It noted that the enquiry report finding the charge not proved was available on record and that the disciplinary process had resulted in an unreasonable delay before charges were formally dropped and retirement allowed. The opinion specifically refers to the enquiry officer's report being submitted on 31.8.1999 and the Board action only occurring several years later (resolution dated 27.11.2003; final proceedings dated 25.5.2004).
- Given the above, the court held the respondents' contention (that interest is not payable because the charge was dropped only on 25.5.2004) was not a sufficient justification for denying interest. The court observed that the delay in concluding disciplinary proceedings caused mental agony and financial prejudice to the petitioner, and that the petitioner should not be penalised for delays that were not his fault.
- On the question of rate and scope of interest, the court applied the G.O. (Rule 45-A) and the cited precedents to conclude that the petitioner was entitled to interest on the belated disbursements. The court differentiated components: it ordered statutory interest for gratuity, provident fund and special provident fund, and directed interest for commutation of pension and surrender of earned leave to be paid as per the Government Order referred to in the judgment.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition is allowed and the impugned order dated 22.8.2005 is set aside. The second respondent is directed to pay statutory interest for the gratuity amount, provident fund and special provident fund; and to pay interest for commutation of pension and surrender of earned leave as per the Government Order referred to in the judgment. The second respondent is directed to comply within six weeks from receipt of a copy of the order. No costs were awarded.
Implications
- Direct effect on the parties: The administrative order refusing interest is quashed and the Housing Board (through the second respondent) must pay interest on specified components of the petitioner's delayed retirement dues within six weeks.
- Scope of the decision: The court applied existing Government Orders (Rule 45-A) and a body of Supreme Court and High Court precedents to reach its conclusion. The opinion follows and applies earlier authorities that recognize an employee's entitlement to interest on belated payment of retiral benefits, including where charges that delayed payment are ultimately dropped.
- No novel legal principle or broad new precedent is announced beyond applying the Government Order and established case law to the facts of this petition; the judgment enforces entitlement to interest on delayed retiral dues under the factual circumstances presented.
Order dated: 30.7.2010. Judge: N. Paul Vasanthakumar, J. Connected miscellaneous petition closed. Compliance directed within six weeks.
(R-2 impleaded as per order of the Court dated 21.12.2009 in W.P.M.P No. 1062 of 2009)
PRAYER : This writ petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India with a prayer to issue a writ of certiorarified mandamus calling for the records relating to the proceedings of the Administrative Officer, Tamil Nadu Housing Board, the second respondent herein made in letter No. PT.1/29589/2004 dated 22.8.2005 quash the same and direct the Managing Director, Tamil Nadu Housing Board, Chennai - 35, the first respondent herein to disburse the arrears of leave on private affairs due to the petitioner and the interest on the belated disbursement of retiral benefits such as DCRG, commuted value of pension, encashment of earned leave, encashment of surrender leave, encashment of leave on private affairs, provident fund, special provident fund at the rate of 18% per annum calculated cumulatively as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in 2000 (2) SLR 686 and disburse all the accrued arrears thereon within a short date that may be fixed by this Court.
(Prayer amended as per order of the Court dated 21.12.2009 in W.P.M.P No. 1063 of 2009)
ORDER
The prayer in the writ petition is to quash the order of the second respondent dated 22.8.2005 and direct the Tamil Nadu Housing Board to disburse the arrears of leave salary, encashment of earned leave, Surrender leave, leave on private affairs, disbursement of retirement benefits such as DCRG, commuted value of pension, provident fund, special provident fund and pay 18% interest for the belated payment as held by the Supreme Court in the decision reported in 2000 (2) SLR 686.
2. The case of the petitioner is that he was appointed as Junior Engineer on 5.3.1965; promoted as Assistant Executive Engineer on 13.6.1970; as Executive Engineer in the year 1977; and as Superintendent Engineer in the year 1994. The petitioner attained the age of superannuation on 30.11.1998 He was not allowed to retire by passing an order of suspension on 28.11.1998 stating that while he was holding the post of General Manager (Technical) in the Tamil Nadu Adi Dravidar Housing Development Corporation on deputation, a charge memo was issued on 18.11.1998 alleging that he rejected the tender submitted by the Government of India during the process of pre-qualification bid. Petitioner submitted his explanation to the charge memo on 2.12.1998 and denied the same. An enquiry was conducted and a report was submitted holding that the charge levelled against the petitioner was not proved. The Housing Board accepted the Enquiry Officer's report and passed a resolution on 27.11.2003 to drop the charge framed against the petitioner and also resolved to allow the petitioner to retire from service with effect from 30.11.1998 The Board resolution was sent to the Government for its approval. The Government also granted approval through G.O(1D) No. 164 Housing and Urban Development Department, dated 14.4.2004 The Board by proceedings dated 25.5.2004 passed final orders and allowed the petitioner to retire from service from 30.11.1998 and also ordered that the period of suspension is to be treated as duty period.
3. According to the petitioner due to the frivolous charge framed against him, he was denied the terminal benefits from 1.12.1998 for about six years and hence he is entitled to get interest for the belated payment of terminal benefits. According to the petitioner following amounts were disbursed to the petitioner even though the same were due as on 30.11.1998
Particulars Amount Date of disbursement
DCRG Rs. 3,20,067/- 2.8.2004
Commutation of pension Rs. 3,99,164/- 2.8.2004
Spl. Provident Fund Rs. 10,058/- 19.8.2004
Provident Fund Rs. 1,23,234/- 16.6.2004
Surrender of Earned Leave Rs. 1,60,784/- 30.11.2004
The said amounts having been paid after about a period of six years, the petitioner has requested to sanction interest for the belated payment, which was rejected by the second respondent through the impugned order. Hence this writ petition.
4. The respondents have filed counter affidavit by narrating the facts as stated in the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition as stated supra. The only reason stated in the counter affidavit is that since the charge was dropped only on 25.5.2004, petitioner's request for payment of interest for the belated payment of retirement benefits is not maintainable.
5. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the Government issued G.O.Ms No. 510 Finance (Pension) Department dated 27.6.1995 and ordered payment of interest for the belated payment of each retirement benefit. Apart from that even against a charged employee, the charges having been dropped, the Honourable Supreme Court in (2008) 3 SCC 44 (S.K Dua v. State of Haryana) and Division Bench of this Court in the decision reported in (2009 ) 3 MLJ 1 (Government of T.N v. Deivasigamani) ordered payment of interest and held that an employee is entitled to get interest on belated payment of pension and other terminal benefits even in the absence of statutory rules under Part III of the Constitution of India and therefore the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner is entitled to get interest for the belated payment of retirement benefits.
6. Heard the learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
7. The point for consideration in this writ petition is whether the petitioner is entitled to get interest from 30.11.1998, for the belated payments of retirement benefits after he was permitted to retire by dropping the charge.
8. G.O.Ms No. 510 Finance (Pension) Department, dated 27.6.1995 reads as follows:
“GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU
ABSTRACT
PENSION - Tamil Nadu Pension Rules 1978 - Amendment to Rule 45 A - Orders - Issued.
G.O.Ms No. 510 Dated 27-6-1995
Read:
G.O.Ms No. 21397.Pension/91.Finance (Pension) dt.10.5.91
G.O.Ms No. 64731.Pension/93-1/Finance (Pension) dt.19-7-93.
Order:
The following Notification will be published in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette:
NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India, the Governor of Tamil Nadu hereby makes the following amendment to the Tamil Nadu Pension rules, 1978.
2. The amendment hereby made shall be deemed to have come into force on the 10th May 1991.
AMENDMENTS
In the said rules, in rule 45-A, after sub rule (1) the following sub-rule shall be inserted namely:-
“(1-A), The period beyond which such interest is payable, shall be as follows:-
1) in the case of a Government Servant retired otherwise on superannuation and where the Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity is withheld on account of disciplinary proceeding pending against him.
a) three months from the date of retirement where the Government Servant is exonerated of all charges and where the Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity is paid on the conclusion of disciplinary proceedings.
b) three months from the date of death where the disciplinary proceedings are dropped on account of death of Government servant.
c) three months from the date of issue of orders by competent authority allowing payment of Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity where the Government Servant is not fully exonerated on the conclusion of disciplinary proceedings and where the competent authority desire to allow payment of Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity.
2) six months from the date of retirement of a Government Servant otherwise than on superannuation under Fundamental Rule 56(2) or 56(3) or rules 33, 36, 38, 39 and 42 of the Tamil Nadu Pension Rules, 1978.
3) Six months from the date of death of a Government Servant while in service and where the delay is not caused on account of more than one claimant.
4) three months from the date of issue of orders revising the emoluments where the amount of Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity already paid is enhanced on account of revision of emoluments; and
5) six months from the date of absorption in the case of permanent absorption in the Public Sector Undertaking or autonomous bodies otherwise than on mass transfer on or conversion of Government department or a part thereof into Public Sector Undertakings or Autonomies bodies.
(BY ORDER OF THE GOVERNOR)
S. PITCHAI,
Joint Secretary to Government”
Thus it is evident that for the belated payment of terminal benefits the petitioner is entitled to get interest as per Rule 45-A of the Tamil Nadu Pension Rules, 1978.
9. (a) In the decision reported in 2006 WLR 623 (R. Lakshmikanthan v. Government of Tamil Nadu) I had an occasion to consider similar issue and following the decisions of the Supreme Court, interest was ordered to be paid. Paragraphs 8 and 9 reads as follows:
“8. (a) The Supreme Court in the decision reported in (1987) 4 SCC 328 (O.P Gupta v. Union of India), in paragraph 15, after taking note of the 20 years of protracted departmental enquiry, held as follows,
”… It is clear principle of natural justice that the delinquent officer when placed under suspension is entitled to represent that the departmental proceedings should be concluded with reasonable diligence and within a reasonable period of time. If such a principle were not to be recognised, it would imply that the executive is being vested with a totally arbitrary and unfettered power of placing its officers under disability and distress for an indefinite duration.”
In the said case, the Supreme Court awarded 12% interest in favour of the appellant for the delayed payment of pension.
(b) In the decision reported in (1999) 3 SCC 438 (Dr. Uma Agrawal v. State of U.P), the Apex Court quantified the interest as Rs. 1.00 lakh for the belated payment of retirement benefits.
(c) In (1985) 1 SCC 429 (State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair) also the Supreme Court endorsed the findings of the High Court in payment of interest for the belated settlement of retirement benefits. Further, in paragraph 5 of the judgment, the Court observed thus,
“We are also of the view that the State Government is being rightly saddled with a liability for the culpable neglect in the discharge of his duty by the District Treasury Officer who delayed the issuance of the L.P.C, but since the concerned officer had not been impleaded as a party defendant to the suit the Court is unable to hold him liable for the decretal amount. It will, however, be for the State Government to consider whether the erring official should or should not be directed to compensate the Government the loss sustained by it by his culpable lapses. Such action if taken would help generate in the officials of the State Government a sense of duty towards the Government under whom they serve as also a sense of accountability to members of the public.”
9. In this case, petitioner's contentions in respect of the belated settlement of retirement benefits, are well founded. As observed earlier, the enquiry report having been filed as early as on 10.2.1992, there is no justification on the part of the respondents to delay the said proceedings for over ten years. Hence I hold that the petitioner is entitled to interest as claimed in the petition. ………..”
(b) Similar issue was considered by the Supreme Court in the decision reported in (2008) 3 SCC 44 (S.K Dua v. State of Haryana). In paragraphs 13 and 14 the Supreme Court held thus,
“13. …………. It is not in dispute by and between the parties that the appellant retired from service on 30-6-1998. It is also undisputed that at the time of retirement from service, the appellant had completed more than three decades in government service. Obviously, therefore, he was entitled to retiral benefits in accordance with law. True it is that certain charge-sheets/show-cause notices were issued against him and the appellant was called upon to show cause why disciplinary proceedings should not be initiated against him. It is, however, the case of the appellant that all those actions had been taken at the instance of Mr. Quraishi against whom serious allegations of malpractices and misconduct had been levelled by the appellant which resulted in removal of Mr. Quraishi from the post of Secretary, Irrigation. The said Mr. Quraishi then became Principal Secretary to the Chief Minister. Immediately thereafter charge-sheets were issued to the appellant and proceedings were initiated against him. The fact remains that proceedings were finally dropped and all retiral benefits were extended to the appellant. But it also cannot be denied that those benefits were given to the appellant after four years.
14. In the circumstances, prima facie, we are of the view that the grievance voiced by the appellant appears to be well founded that he would be entitled to interest on such benefits. If there are statutory rules occupying the field, the appellant could claim payment of interest relying on such rules. If there are administrative instructions, guidelines or norms prescribed for the purpose, the appellant may claim benefit of interest on that basis. But even in absence of statutory rules, administrative instructions or guidelines, an employee can claim interest under Part III of the Constitution relying on Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution. ………….”
(c) The said decision was followed by the Division Bench of this Court in the decision reported in (2009) 3 MLJ 1 (Government of T.N v. Deivasigamani), wherein in paragraphs 4, 5 and 7 it is held as follows:
“4. Pleadings disclose that the first respondent was due to retire on 31.01.1987, on attaining the age of superannuation. But, he was not allowed to retire on that day, on account of pending charges. On completion of the enquiry, he was dismissed from service in and by the proceedings of the District Collector, Periyar District, dated 03.09.1988 Thereafter, the petitioner filed an appeal before the Special Commissioner and Commissioner for Revenue Administration, Madras, which was rejected on 06.11.1988 Thereafter, the petitioner has preferred an appeal before the Government on 22.12.1988 Since no orders were passed by the Government, the petitioner was constrained to file O.A No. 943 of 1992 before the Tamil Nadu Administrative Tribunal, Madras for a direction, directing the Government to pass orders on his appeal. Pursuant to the order of the Tribunal, dated 17.02.1992, the Government, by its order in G.O (2D) No. 123 Revenue Department dated 18.11.1992, have set aside the order of dismissal and allowed the petitioner to retire from service. Though the respondent has preferred the statutory appeal in the year 1998, the Government have taken nearly four years to pass orders on the appeal. Though, the Government have passed orders in 1992, exonerating him from the charges and allowed him to retire, pensionary and other benefits have been granted only in the year 1994, after two years. The District Collector, Erode, by impugned order, dated 18.11.1992, has disallowed interest for the belated payment of pension, Commutation of pension and other retiral benefits. However, he had recommended to the Government for sanction of interest amount of Rs. 10,381/- for the belated payment of DCRG made to the first respondent, based on the Government Order in G.O.Ms No. 517, Finance (Pension), dated 12.06.1987 and G.O.Ms No. 818, Finance (Pension), dated 01.12.1988 Subsequently, G.O(D) No. 192, dated 13.04.2007, has been passed, sanctioning payment of Rs. 11,890/-, towards interest on belated payment of Death cum Retirement Gratuity. But for the disciplinary action and erroneous dismissal, in normal course, the respondent would have retired from service on attaining the age of superannuation and granted pension and other retiral benefits.
5. In Dr. Uma Agarwal v. State of U.P, reported in (1999) 3 SCC 438, the Supreme Court held that,
”….grant of pension is not a bounty but a right of the government servant. The Government is obliged to follow the Rules mentioned in the earlier part of this order in letter and in spirit. Delay in settlement of retiral benefits is frustrating and must be avoided at all costs. Such delays are occurring even in regard to family pensions for which too there is a prescribed procedure. This is indeed unfortunate. In cases where a retired government servant claims interest for delayed payment, the Court can certainly keep in mind the time-schedule prescribed in the Rules/Instructions apart from other relevant factors applicable to each case.”
7. In view of the judgment of the Supreme Court, it is now well settled that an employee is entitled to interest on belated payment of pension and other retiral benefits, even in the absence of statutory rules/administrative instructions or guidelines and he can make his claim for interest, under Part III of the Constitution, relying on Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution.”
(d) In (2006) 6 SCC 455 (Union of India v. M.S Abdulla) the Supreme Court ordered 12% interest per annum for the belated payment of retirement benefits for a person, who voluntarily retired from service.
(e) In 2000 (2) SLR 686 (Vijay L. Mehrotra v. State of U.P) the Supreme Court ordered to pay 18% interest from the date of retirement till the date of payment of all the retirement dues.
(f) In 2002 (7) SLR 760 (Government of A.P v. C. Purushotham) a Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court ordered 12% interest for the belated payment of terminal benefits.
(g) Same is the view taken by the Supreme Court in the decisions reported in 2003 (2) SLR 326 (H. Gangahanume Gowda v. Karnataka Agro Industries Corpn. Ltd..) and (2001) 6 SCC 591 (Gorakhpur University v. Dr. Shitla Prasad Nagendra).
10. Applying the above decisions of the Supreme Court and of this Court to the facts of this case, I hold that the petitioner has made out a case for the grant of interest for the belated payment of retirement benefits.
11. The reason stated by the respondents that only due to the pendency of the charge against the petitioner payment of terminal benefits was delayed, cannot be accepted as the charge, which was found not proved was ultimately dropped. The delay in completing the disciplinary proceeding has already caused mental agony to the petitioner after reaching the age of superannuation. The retirement benefits payable as on 30.11.1998 was delayed for about six years for which the petitioner cannot be blamed. It is not the case of the respondents that the disciplinary proceeding was delayed at the instance of the petitioner. From the perusal of the typed set of papers filed, it is evident that the enquiry officer submitted his report stating that the charge was not proved. The said Enquiry Officer's report was submitted as early as on 31.8.1999 Even assuming that the pendency of the charge was not the reason for not paying the terminal benefits, there was unreasonable delay in dropping the charge, though the delay is explained in the counter affidavit. For no fault on the part of the petitioner, petitioner cannot be penalised by denying interest for the belated payment of retirement benefits.
12. In view of the above findings and decisions of the Supreme Court and of this Court, the writ petition is allowed and the impugned order is set aside. The second respondent is directed to pay the statutory interest for the gratuity amount, provident fund, special provident fund. For commutation of pension and surrender of earned leave, the second respondent is bound to pay interest for the belated payment as per the Government Order referred above. The second respondent is directed to comply with this order within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order. No costs. Connected miscellaneous petition is closed.
Index : Yes/No.
Website : Yes/No. 30-7-2010
To
1. The Managing Director, Tamil Nadu Housing Board, 493, Ana Salai, Nandanam, Chennai - 600 035.
2. The Administrative Officer, Tamil Nadu Housing Board, Nandanam, Chennai - 35.
N. PAUL VASANTHAKUMAR, J.
Pre-Delivery Order in W.P No. 6902 of 2006
30.7.2010
Home
Alert