- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
S.Nasira Anjum v. The State Of Tamil Nadu
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners seek a direction against respondents 1 to 3 to restore legal possession of land in Survey No.187/1A1B (reclassified as survey Nos.182/1A1B) in Pammal village. Late M. Ahmed Basha purchased the land (2.01 acres) by sale deeds in 1974 and 1976, obtained patta and was in possession until his death on 18.5.1996. After his death, the petitioners (his wife and children) stated that they remained in possession.
The petitioners discovered in 2005 that proceedings under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978 had been initiated to acquire 4,896 sq. mts. as excess vacant land. Objections by late M. Ahmed Basha were overruled, and the excess land was allotted to M/s. Arvind Leather Exports (impleaded as the 4th respondent) by G.O.Ms.No.489 (Revenue) dated 2.6.1995. Writ proceedings were instituted (W.P.No.10563 of 1995) challenging that allotment and an interim stay was recorded, but the appellate authority did not act on the pendency. The writ was transferred and later closed/abated after the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999 came into force.
The petitioners contend they were never dispossessed and were never paid compensation; consequently, the property did not vest in the Government under the Repeal Act. The Tahsildar (respondent 3) refused mutation to reflect the petitioners as owners. Earlier writ petitions (including W.P.No.23732 of 2005) were dismissed as withdrawn with liberty to file afresh; the present petition relies on section 3(2)(a) of the Repeal Act (Act 20 of 1999) and seeks restoration of legal possession.
The respondents (1 to 3) filed a counter affidavit stating that late M. Ahmed Basha filed returns under section 6(1) of the 1978 Act claiming 8,500 sq. mts., exemption was rejected, and acquisition proceedings under sections 9(4), 9(1) were initiated with a draft statement served on 9.10.1982. A final statement under section 10(1) was issued on 26.4.1983 and served on 5.5.1983. Notices under section 11(5) were issued on 1.2.1990 and served on 9.2.1990. The respondents contend the excess land was handed over to the Revenue Department and allotted to the 4th respondent by G.O.Ms.No.489 dated 2.6.1995.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the surplus/excess land declared under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978 vested in the State Government despite the Repeal Act of 1999, where the petitioners assert no physical possession was taken and no compensation paid.
- Whether, in the absence of evidence of physical possession being taken by the Government prior to the Repeal Act, the proceedings initiated under the 1978 Act stand abated and the owners retain title and possession.
- Whether the allotment to the 4th respondent can be sustained where (i) interim orders in writ proceedings existed, and (ii) the Repeal Act caused subsequent abatement of proceedings.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments (as advanced by senior counsel Mr. T.V. Ramanujam)
- Under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999, vesting is deemed to be completed only for lands where the Government had physically taken possession prior to the Repeal Act.
- Unless actual physical possession was taken by the Government before the repeal, the owner in possession is entitled to continue as owner; the petitioners relied on various judicial decisions supporting that proposition.
- The petitioners assert they (and their predecessor) were never physically dispossessed and were not paid compensation; hence the land did not vest with the Government and mutation should be granted in their names.
Respondents' Arguments (as set out in the counter affidavit and advanced by the Additional Government Pleader Mr. V. Viswanathan)
- The records show that symbolic/physical possession was taken on 23.8.1990 — notice under section 11(3) was published in the Gazette on 3.1.1990 and notice under section 11(5) was served on 9.2.1990; a Transfer Charge Certificate records handing over and symbolic possession on 23.8.1990.
- The excess land was handed over to the Revenue Department and was allotted to the 4th respondent by Government Order G.O.Ms.No.489 dated 2.6.1995.
- The Additional Government Pleader produced the original land-ceiling file to demonstrate possession was taken prior to the Repeal Act that came into force in 1999.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| V. Gurunathan vs. The Assistant Commissioner of Urban Land Tax and Ceiling, Tambaram Area, Adambakkam, Chennai and others [2007 (3) CTC 362] | Cited as authority that proceedings under the 1978 Act stand abated on the advent of the Repeal Act, 1999 if possession has not been taken by the authorities prior to the Repeal Act and due compensation has not been paid. | The Court relied on this authority as part of a line of decisions supporting the proposition that absence of possession and non-payment of compensation leads to abatement; applied this principle to find no vesting here. |
| Anees Leathers Manufacturers, rep. by its Proprietor Mr. Anees Ahamed vs. The Government of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary, Revenue Department [2006 (3) LW 437] | Cited in the group of decisions establishing that abatement occurs where possession/compensation prerequisites are not satisfied before repeal. | Cited to support the general proposition that the Repeal Act abates proceedings where possession was not taken or compensation not paid; relied upon in evaluating the facts of this case. |
| Jayaseelan & Ratnaseelan vs. The Government of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary, Revenue Department [2006 (3) LW 440] | Cited as another authority in the series holding that proceedings initiated under the Land Ceiling Act stand abated if the conditions for vesting were not satisfied prior to repeal. | Used to corroborate the Court's reliance on settled judicial position that lack of physical possession/compensation prevents vesting; applied to conclude no vesting here. |
| Sosamma Thampy vs. The Assistant Commissioner (ULT)-cum-Competent Authority (ULC) and others [2006 (2) MLJ 664] | Included among decisions confirming the effect of the Repeal Act where possession/compensation prerequisites were not met. | Served as part of the jurisprudential basis for concluding that proceedings stand abated and there is no vesting where physical possession was not lawfully taken. |
| Vijay Foundation (P) Ltd., rep. by its Director R. Thiagarajan vs. The Principal Commissioner and Commissioner of Land Reforms, Chepauk, Chennai [2006 (5) CTC 52] | Held that unless procedures under sections 7 to 12 of the 1978 Act are followed, possession cannot be presumed; if possession was taken without following procedures, proceedings would still stand abated. | The Court relied on this to emphasize that procedural compliance (sections 7–12) is necessary to establish lawful taking of possession; applied to find the record here did not show lawful physical possession being taken from owners. |
| Smt. Angroori Devi vs. State of U.P. and others [JT 2000 Supp. 1 (SC) 295] | The Supreme Court held that when it is proved that possession under the principal Act was not taken in accordance with law, the subsequent repealing Act would abate all proceedings under the old Act. | The Court cited this Supreme Court authority as binding support for the conclusion that improper or unproved taking of possession results in abatement by the Repeal Act; applied to the present facts to support abatement. |
| S. Sivaparamam vs. The State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary, Revenue Department, Chennai [2007 (6) MLJ 1279] | Held that in the absence of anything on record to show that physical possession of lands has been taken over by the Government, it is not possible to hold that vesting has taken place before the Repeal Act. | The Court relied on its earlier holding to reinforce that absence of documentary proof of physical possession prevents a finding of vesting; applied that approach to the file produced in this case. |
| T. Audikesavan and others vs. Government of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary, Revenue Department, Chennai and others [2008 (3) MLJ 252] | Reiterated the principle that absence of lawful physical possession prior to repeal means proceedings abate and vesting does not survive the Repeal Act. | Used as further support for the conclusion that the Repeal Act abated the relevant proceedings here because the record did not establish lawful physical possession prior to repeal. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court conducted a document-based assessment of the original land-ceiling file produced by the Additional Government Pleader. The file contained:
- A Gazette publication under section 11(3) dated 3.1.1990 declaring the excess land deemed to have vested absolutely in the Government;
- A notice under section 11(5) issued on 1.2.1990 and served on M. Ahmed Basha on 9.2.1990;
- A Transfer Charge Certificate evidencing that symbolic possession was taken on 23.8.1990 and that the piece of land was handed over to the Revenue Inspector.
The Court noted that the Transfer Charge Certificate amounted to an internal exchange between officials stating symbolic possession was taken on 23.8.1990, but found no independent or corroborative record demonstrating that physical possession was in fact taken from the owners (the petitioners or late M. Ahmed Basha). The petitioners' assertion that no compensation was paid was not denied by respondents 1 to 3; respondents did not claim compensation had been paid.
The Court considered the statutory framework in the Repeal Act, particularly:
- Section 3(1)(a): the repeal does not affect vesting of vacant land under sub-section (3) of section 11 where possession has been taken by the Government or an authorized person;
- Section 3(2): where land is deemed to have vested under section 11(3) but possession has not been taken and Government has paid some amount, restoration requires refund of that amount;
- Section 4: all proceedings under the principal Act pending immediately before commencement of the Repeal Act shall abate, except certain proceedings relatable to land in respect of which possession had been taken by the Government or authorized person.
The Court then applied established judicial precedents (both decisions of this Court and the Supreme Court) which hold that:
- If physical possession has not been lawfully taken and compensation has not been paid, proceedings initiated under the 1978 Act stand abated on the advent of the Repeal Act;
- Procedural compliance under sections 7–12 of the 1978 Act is necessary before one can treat possession as having been lawfully taken; possession cannot be presumed without compliance;
- The Supreme Court has held that if possession under the principal Act was not taken in accordance with law, the repealing Act abates all proceedings under the old Act.
Applying these principles to the facts, and noting the continued existence of an interim injunction in related writ petitions, the Court concluded there was no record to show Government had taken physical possession from the owners prior to the Repeal Act. Consequently, the Court held there was no vesting of the alleged surplus land in favour of the Government under the 1978 Act and no continuity of vesting under section 11(3) after the Repeal Act, 1999.
The Court also noted that disputes as to entitlement between the petitioners and the 4th respondent (a purported lessee and alleged allottee) could not be resolved in this writ because civil proceedings on title and possession between those parties were pending; the inter se dispute must be decided by the appropriate civil forum.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The Court directed respondents 1 to 3 as prayed for in the petition (i.e., to restore legal possession to the petitioners as claimed).
Direct consequences and implications:
- The Court found there was no vesting of the alleged surplus land in favour of the Government under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978, because there was no evidence of lawful physical possession having been taken and no evidence of compensation having been paid.
- Proceedings initiated under the 1978 Act in respect of this land stood abated with the coming into force of the Repeal Act, 1999, insofar as possession had not been lawfully taken.
- The Court did not decide entitlement between the petitioners and the 4th respondent; those civil disputes (title and possession) remain for the appropriate civil court to decide.
- The Court ordered no costs and closed the connected miscellaneous petition.
The opinion relies on existing case law to apply established principles; it does not purport to create a new legal precedent beyond applying settled authorities to the facts at hand.
The writ petition is filed for direction against the respondents 1 to 3 to restore legal possession of the property in Survey No.187/1A1B in Pammal village, covered under G.O.Ms.No.58 (Revenue) dated 8.1.1982 and the proceedings of the Assistant Commissioner (ULT), Tambaram dated 26.4.1983 issued under Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978, to the petitioners.
2. Late M.Ahmed Basha was the absolute owner of the land to an extent of 2.01 acres comprised in survey No.187/1A1, having purchased under sale deeds dated 29.4.1974 and 7.4.1976 and obtained patta in his name and he had been in possession till his death on 18.5.1996 and after his death, the first petitioner being his wife and all other petitioners as children stated to be in possession and enjoyment of the land, now reclassified as survey Nos.182/1A1B.
2(a). It was in 2005, when the petitioners approached the Tahsildar for mutation of records, they were informed that certain proceedings under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act,1978, had been initiated in respect of the property. On enquiry, it was revealed that proceedings were initiated to acquire the land of an extent of 4896 sq.mts. under the said Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act,1978, which appeared to have been objected to by late M.Ahmed Basha and when the objection was overruled, an appeal was filed before the Special Commissioner and Commissioner of Land Reforms, Chepauk, Chennai. It is stated that when the said appeal was pending, an order was passed allotting the said land to M/s.Arvind Leather Exports (Private) Limited, which has been impleaded as 4th respondent, on 2.6.1995.
2(b). W.P.No.10563 of 1995 was filed challenging the said allotment, in which there was an order of interim stay of the said allotment. However, the appellate authority in the appeal filed by M.Ahmed Basha did not pass any order on the basis of pendency of the said writ petition. After the death of M.Ahmed Basha on 18.5.1996, the writ petition was transferred to the Tamil Nadu Land Reforms Special Appellate Tribunal, Chennai and re-numbered as TRP No.383 of 1999 and on the advent of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999, the said petition came to be closed as abated.
2(c). It is the case of the petitioners that possession of the said land is still with them and they have never been paid any compensation. In the meantime, it appears that the impleaded 4th respondent is said to have executed various documents to third parties, about which certain criminal as well as civil proceedings are pending. It is stated that late M.Ahmed Basha, husband of 1st petitioner and father of other petitioners had been paying the urban land tax as well as the property tax and subsequently, the petitioners are paying all the taxes. Under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999, (Act 20 of 1999), the lands in respect of which proceedings were initiated under the Land Ceiling Act are deemed to have been vested with the Government and if compensation has been paid to the owners, the same has to be returned to the Government.
2(d). According to the petitioners, no physical possession of the property was ever taken from them or from late M.Ahmed Bhasa or no compensation has been paid in respect of the land and therefore, the property does not vest with the Government. Inspite of explaining the same to the third respondent, the Tahsildar has refused to mutate the revenue records by incorporating the petitioners' names as owners. According to the petitioners, inasmuch as physical possession is with them, it cannot be allotted to any third party. The writ petition in W.P.No.23732 of 2005 for declaration in respect of the property was filed and the same was dismissed as withdrawn with liberty to file a fresh writ petition. Accordingly, the present writ petition is filed on the basis that the respondents have statutory obligation to restore legal possession of the property under section 3(2)(a) of the Repeal Act 20 of 1999. In these circumstances, the present writ petition is filed for the relief as stated above.
3. In the counter affidavit filed by the first respondent on behalf of respondents 1 to 3 it is stated that late M.Ahmed Basha, filed his return under section 6(1) of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act,1978 (in short, "the Act") stating that in Pammal village in survey No.187/1, he owns 8500 sq.mts. of land and the exemption application filed by him was rejected. It was, in those circumstances, proceedings under sections 9(4) and 9(1) of the Act was initiated proposing to acquire the excess vacant land to the extent of 4896 sq.mts. and draft statement was served on 9.10.1982. In the objection dated 9.11.1982, late M.Ahmed Basha has stated that he shifted his industry to Vaniampadi and leased out the factory at Pammal to the 4th respondent for a period of 5 years and he intended to re-shift the industry from Vaniampadi to Madras. However, the objection was overruled and the authority under the Urban Land Ceiling Act declared that an extent of 4896 sq. mts. of land as excess vacant land, under section 9(5) of the said Act.
3(a). The said excess is in survey No.187/1A1B and final statement under section 10(1) of the Act is stated to have been issued on 26.4.1983 and the same was sent to the petitioner, who received the same on 5.5.1983. It is stated that after following the procedures, notice under section 11(5) of the Act was issued on 1.2.1990 and served on 9.2.1990. It is stated that the excess vacant land to the extent of 4896 sq.mts. was handed over to the Revenue Department. In the meantime, the 4th respondent applied for the excess land and hence, the excess land was allotted to the 4th respondent in G.O.Ms.No.489 Revenue Department, dated 2.6.1995. Challenging the said allotment, late M.Ahmed Basha filed W.P.No.10563 of 1995, in which there was a stay and subsequently, it was transferred to the Land Reforms Special Appellate Tribunal and later, it was closed on 24.7.2000 by virtue of repealing Act and also due to the death of M.Ahmed Basha.
3(b). 4. The petitioners filed W.P.Nos.27949 of 2005 and 28523 of 2005 and this Court granted interim injunction on 31.8.2005 and 6.9.2005. After possession was taken over on 23.8.1990, the same was allotted to the 4th respondent under G.O.Ms.No.489, dated 2.6.1995. The counter also admits about the exemption claimed by late M.Ahmed Basha and the subsequent writ petition filed by him.
3(c). It is also admitted that in respect of allotment stated to have been made to the 4th respondent, there has been an order of interim stay and subsequently, by virtue of repealing Act, the petition was closed. It is also the case of the said respondent that by the repealing Act the vesting as per section 11(3) of the Act is not affected. According to the respondents, the vacant land was acquired and handed over on 23.8.1990 and therefore, the vesting has already taken place.
4. Mr.T.V.Ramanujun, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioners would submit that by virtue of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999, (Act 20 of 1999), the vesting is deemed to be completed only in respect of lands where physical possession has been taken by the Government. He would rely upon various judgments to contend that unless and until the actual physical possession has been taken over by the Government before the repeal Act came into existence, the owner who is in possession is entitled to continue to be the owner.
5. On the other hand, the learned Additional Government Pleader Mr.V.Viswanathan, would submit that as per records, physical possession was taken on 23.8.1990 and the repeal Act came into existence only in the year 1999. He has also produced the original file relating to the land ceiling proceedings.
6. On a perusal of the original file, it is seen that notice under section 11(3) of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulations) Act, 1978 was published in Gazette on 3.1.1990 stating that the excess land is deemed to have vested absolutely in the Government and notice under section 11(5) of the Act was issued on 1.2.1990 which is stated to have been served on M.Ahmed Basha on 9.2.1990. Thereafter, a Transfer Charge Certificate was issued and the file contain the said certificate, which is as follows:
"Transfer Charge Certificate I, Thiru V.Kamalanathan, Deputy Tahsildar, Office of the Assistant Commissioner, Urban Land tax Tambaram, hereby certify that I have personally handed over to Alandur Firka Revenue Inspector, Taluk Office, Saidapet, the piece of land described as follows.
Certify that I have taken over symbolic possession on the day of .
District: Chengai Anna District.
Taluk: Saidapet Village: 129.Pammal Survey No.187/1A1B Extent:0.48.96 BOUNDARIES:
North by : S.No.187/1A1 A East by : S.No.187 1B,187/1A2 South by : S.No.187/2 West by : S.No.187/1A1A,186.
7. The said Transfer Charge Certificate is only an exchange of letters between the officials to the effect that symbolic possession of the land in dispute was taken on 23.8.1990. Other than this, there is no record to show that physical possession was taken from the owners of the land. The specific averment made by the petitioners that in respect of the said land declared as surplus and consequently, stated to have been acquired under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulations) Act, 1978, no compensation has been paid, has not been denied in the counter affidavit filed by the respondents 1 to 3. It is also not the case of said respondents that they have paid compensation in respect of the excess land.
8. Section 3 of the Repeal Act, 1999 (Tamil Nadu Act 20/99) states as follows:
" Section 3.(1) The repeal of the principal Act shall not affect-
(a) the vesting of any vacant land under sub-section (3) of section 11, possession of which has been taken over by the State Government or any person duly authorised by the State Government in this behalf or by the competent authority;
(b) the validity of any order granting exemption under sub-section (1) of section 21 of any action taken thereunder.
(2) Where-
(a) any land is deemed to have vested in the State Government under sub-section (3) of section 11 of the principal Act but possession of which has not been taken over by the State Government or any person duly authorised by the State Government in this behalf or by the competent authority; and
(b) any amount has been paid by the State Government with respect to such land, then, such land shall not be restored unless the amount paid, if any, has been refunded to the State Government.
9. Further, under section 4, any proceedings pending under the Land Ceiling Act before any Court or Tribunal stands abated and the said section is as follows:
" Section 4. All proceedings relating to any order made or purported to be made under the principal Act pending immediately before the commencement of this Act, before any Court, tribunal or any authority shall abate:
Provided that this section shall not apply to the proceedings relating to sections 12, 13, 14, 15, 15-B and 16 of the principal Act in so far as such proceedings are relatable to the land, possession of which has been taken over by the State Government or any person duly authorised by the State Government in this behalf or by the competent authority."
10. It is not the case of the respondents that the petitioners or late M.Ahmed Basha had surrendered the possession. Under similar circumstances, in series of orders passed by this Court while dealing with the effect of provisions of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999, on the land acquisition proceedings initiated under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978, it was held that all proceedings initiated under the Act, 1978 would stand abated on the advent of Repeal Act, 1999, if possession has not been taken by the authorities prior to the Repeal Act and due compensation has not been paid. (vide: V.Gurunathan vs. The Assistant Commissioner of Urban Land Tax and Ceiling, Tambaram Area, Sannadhi Street, Adambakkam, Chennai 28 and others [2007 (3) CTC 362]; Anees Leathers Manufacturers, rep. By its Proprietor Mr.Anees Ahamed vs. The Government of Tamil Nadu rep. By its Secretary, Revenue Department, Fort St.George, Chennai and others (2006 (3) LW 437); Jayaseelan & Ratnaseelan vs. The Government of Tamil Nadu rep. By its Secretary, Revenue Department, Fort St.George, Chennai and others (2006 (3) LW 440); Sosamma Thampy vs. The Assistant Commissioner (ULT)-cum-Competent Authority (ULC) and others (2006 (2) MLJ 664); and Vijay Foundation (P) Ltd., rep. By its Director R.Thiagarajan vs. The Principal Commissioner and Commissioner of Land Reforms, Chepauk, Chennai (2006 (5) CTC 52)]
11. Even under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978, when excess lands are acquired, it was held that unless the procedures under sections 7 to 12 are followed, it cannot be presumed that possession of lands have been taken and even if possession has been taken without following the procedures, the proceedings would stand abated. That was the view in Vijay Foundation (P) Ltd., rep. By its Director R.Thiagarajan vs. The Principal Commissioner and Commissioner of Land Reforms, Chepauk, Chennai (2006 (5) CTC 52).
12. The Supreme Court in similar circumstances in Smt.Angroori Devi vs. State of U.P. And others [JT 2000 Supp. 1 (SC) 295] held that when it is proved that possession under the principal Act was not taken in accordance with law, the subsequent repealing Act would abate all proceedings under the old Act. I have held in S.Sivaparamam vs. The State of Tamil Nadu rep. By its Secretary, Revenue Department, Chennai [2007(6) MLJ 1279] that in the absence of anything on record to show that physical possession of lands has been taken over by the Government, it is not possible to hold that the vesting has taken place even before the repeal Act coming into effect. That is also the view taken subsequently in V.Gurunathan vs. The Assistant Commissioner of Urban Land Tax and Ceiling, Tambaram Area, Sannadhi Street, Adambakkam, Chennai 28 and others [2007(3) CTC 362] and T.Audikesavan and others vs. Government of Tamil Nadu rep. By its Secretary, Revenue Department, Chennai and others[2008 (3) MLJ 252].
13. Applying the said established judicial precedents to the facts of the present case which have been narrated above, on reference to the original file produced by the learned Additional Government Pleader, which shows that there is nothing on record that respondents 1 to 3 have taken physical possession of the property in dispute from its owners viz., the petitioners or late M.Ahmed Basha. Further, pending writ petition, injunction was granted and the same continues till date. In such circumstances, it has to be held that there is no vesting of alleged surplus land in favour of the Government under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978 and therefore, there is no question of continuance of vesting under section 11(3) of the Act, even after the Repeal Act,1999, came into existence. In such circumstances, the writ petition stands allowed.
14. In respect of the claim of the 4th respondent who is stated to have been a lessee inducted by late M.Ahmed Basha in the year 1977 and who is alleged to have been allotted the land by the Government, subsequent to the proceedings under the Urban Land Ceiling Act, admittedly, there has been an order of stay in respect of those proceedings and in the meantime, the Repeal Act,1999, came into existence and thereafter, the proceedings stood abated and hence, it is not possible to decide in this case as to whether the 4th respondent is entitled for possession or not. It is also stated across the bar that civil proceedings are pending between the petitioners and the 4th respondent in respect of title as well as possession and it is for the appropriate Court to decide the inter se dispute between the petitioners and the 4th respondent.
In such view of the matter and for the reasons stated above, the writ petition stands allowed with direction to the respondents 1 to 3 as prayed for. No costs. Connected miscellaneous petition is closed.
Alert