- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Bank Of India Kotagiri Branch v. Chokkalingam Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The State Bank of India, Kotagiri Branch, filed a revision petition under Article 227 challenging the order dated 10th September 2007 passed by the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal (DRAT), Chennai, which dismissed the bank's appeal and affirmed the order dated 17th January 2007 of the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT), Coimbatore. The dispute arose from loans taken by the partnership firm M/s. Sree Vari Corporation, represented by respondents 1 to 3 as partners. The firm initially obtained a crop loan on 14th December 1996 and later obtained a loan of Rs. 70 lakhs on 23rd January 1998, secured by mortgage of properties at Thekkampatti village. After a one-time settlement and full payment of Rs. 74,34,485 in respect of the Rs. 70 lakh loan, respondents 1 to 3 requested the bank to return the original title documents. The bank refused, citing outstanding dues on the earlier crop loan, which had been renewed twice. The DRT directed the bank to return the original mortgaged documents, a decision upheld by the DRAT.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the bank has a general lien over the mortgaged properties deposited by respondents 1 to 3 in respect of loans taken by the partnership firm, including the right to withhold original title documents despite full settlement of the Rs. 70 lakh loan.
- Whether Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act and Section 60 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, restrict the bank's right to exercise a general lien over the mortgaged properties in the absence of dues related to the specific loan secured by those properties.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (State Bank of India)
- The bank asserted a general lien under mercantile custom over all securities or negotiable instruments deposited by customers in the ordinary course of banking business.
- Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court decision in Syndicate Bank Vs Vijay Kumar & Ors, AIR 1992 SC 1066, to support the proposition that the bank’s lien extends to all such securities and negotiable instruments.
Respondents' Arguments (Partners of M/s. Sree Vari Corporation)
- Respondents relied on Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act and Section 60 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, arguing that the bank had no right to exercise a general lien over the mortgaged properties in respect of credit facilities availed by the partnership firm.
- They contended that since the Rs. 70 lakh loan was fully settled, the bank could not withhold the original title documents on the basis of dues relating to other loans.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Syndicate Bank Vs Vijay Kumar & Ors, AIR 1992 SC 1066 | Recognition of the banker's general lien over securities and negotiable instruments deposited in the ordinary course of banking business; explanation of the lien as an implied pledge and valuable right. | The court relied on this precedent to affirm that the bank holds a general lien over the securities deposited by respondents, which cannot be ignored absent an agreement to the contrary. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the provisions of Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act and Section 60 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, alongside the Supreme Court’s decision in Syndicate Bank Vs Vijay Kumar & Ors. The court noted that the Tribunal had held that once the loan amount taken by the partnership firm was fully paid, the bank could not exercise a general lien over the mortgaged properties. However, the Supreme Court judgment clarified that by mercantile custom, a bank has a general lien over all forms of securities or negotiable instruments deposited by or on behalf of a customer in the ordinary course of banking business. This lien is a valuable right, judicially recognized, and applies unless displaced by express or implied agreement. The court emphasized that the lien extends to negotiable instruments and securities deposited for collection or safe custody, including fixed deposit receipts (FDRs). Consequently, the bank’s general lien over the properties mortgaged by the respondents could not be ignored merely because one loan account was settled. The court accordingly set aside the orders of both the DRT and DRAT, holding that the bank’s lien remained valid.
Holding and Implications
The civil revision petition filed by the State Bank of India is allowed.
The court set aside the impugned orders of the DRAT and DRT directing the return of the original mortgaged documents. However, the order does not prevent respondents 1 to 3 from repaying any outstanding dues to the bank and subsequently requesting the release of the documents. The decision reinstates the bank's right to exercise a general lien over securities deposited by customers in the ordinary course of banking business. No broader precedent beyond the application of established principles was created; the ruling directly affects the parties by affirming the bank's lien rights in this context.
S.J.MUKHOPADHAYA, J.
This revision petition under Article 227 has been preferred by State Bank of India, Kotagiri Branch, against order dated 10th Sept., 2007, passed by Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal, Chennai, (hereinafter referred to as 'DRAT') in M.A. No.40/2007. By the said order, DRAT dismissed the appeal affirming the order dated 17th Jan., 2007, passed by Debts Recovery Tribunal, Coimbatore, (hereinafter referred to as 'DRT').
2. The case of the petitioner-Bank is that respondents 1 to 3, who are the partners of the firm, M/s.Sree Vari Corporation, initially obtained crop loan on 14th Dec., 1996. Subsequently, the partnership firm, through respondents 1 to 3, on 23rd Jan., 1998, also obtained loan to the tune of Rs.70 lakhs, Rs.20 lakhs towards cash credit and Rs.50 lakhs towards term loan. While taking such loan, properties at survey No.678 and 679 of Thekkampatti village were mortgaged. The original documents were deposited with the bank. Pursuant to one time settlement in respect of loan amount of Rs.70 lakhs, the borrower, partnership firm, paid a sum of Rs.74,34,485/= in full and final settlement of the loan account. Thereafter, respondents 1 to 3, who are the guarantors, requested the bank to return the documents of title in their favour. The bank refused to return the documents on the ground that the crop loan taken on 14th Dec., 1996, which was renewed twice, on 23rd Oct., 1997 and 5th Feb., 1997, have not been returned by respondents 1 to 3.
DRT, Coimbatore, after hearing the parties, by its order dated 17th Jan., 2007, directed the bank to return those original mortgaged documents, which was affirmed by DRAT by impugned order dated 10th Sept., 2007.
3. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the bank submitted that by Mercantile System, the bank has a general lien over all forms of securities or negotiable instruments deposited by or on behalf of the customer in ordinary course of banking business. Reliance was placed on Supreme Court decision in Syndicate Bank Vs Vijay Kumar & Ors. reported in AIR 1992 SC 1066.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents 1 to 3 referred to Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act and Section 60 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, and submitted that the bank has no right by virtue of Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act to exercise general lien over the properties mortgaged by respondents 1 to 3 in respect of the credit facility availed by the 4th respondent, partnership firm.
4. We have heard the parties, noticed the impugned order dated 10th Sept., 2007, passed by DRAT and the judgment of the Supreme Court in AIR 1992 SC 1066 as referred to by counsel for the petitioner. We find that giving reference to Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act and Section 60 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the Tribunal was of the view that after the total amount in respect of loan amount taken by 4th respondent, partnership firm having paid, the bank cannot exercise general lien over the properties mortgaged by respondents 1 to 3 in respect of such credit facility availed by the 4th respondent.
5. The question of bankers lien/general lien fell for consideration before the Supreme Court in Syndicate Bank Vs Vijay Kumar & Ors. reported in AIR 1992 SC 1066. The provision of Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 was also noticed in the said case. Taking into consideration Halsbury's Laws of England and provisions of the contract act in respect of bankers lien, the following observation was made by the Supreme court :-
"6. In Halsbury's Laws of England, Vol. 20, 2nd Edn. p.552, para 695, lien is defined as follows :-
"Lien is in its primary sense is a right in one man to retain that which is in his possession belonging to another until certain demands of the person in possession are satisfied. In this primary sense it is given by law and not by contract."
In Chalmers on Bills of Exchange, thirteenth Edition page 91 the meaning of "Banker's lien" is given as follows :
"A banker's lien on negotiable securities has been judicially defined as "an implied pledge." A banker has, in the absence of agreement to the contrary, a lien on all bills received from a customer in the ordinary course of banking business in respect of any balance that may be due from such customer."
In Chitty on Contract, Twenty-sixth Edition, page 389, Paragraph 3032 the Banker's lien is explained as under :
"By mercantile custom the banker has a general lien over all forms of commercial paper deposited by or on behalf of a customer in the ordinary course of banking business. The custom does not extent to valuables lodged for the purpose of safe custody and may in any event be displaced by either an express contract or circumstances which show an implied agreement inconsistent with the lien........................ The lien is applicable to negotiable instruments which are remitted to the banker from the customer for the purpose of collection. When collection has been made the process may be used by the banker in reduction of the customer's debit balance unless otherwise earmarked."(Emphasis supplied) In Paget's Law of Banking, Eighth Edition, Page 498, a passage reads as under :
THE BANKER'S LIEN Apart from any specific security, the banker can look to his general lien as a protection against loss on loan or overdraft or other credit facility. The general lien of bankers is part of law merchant and judicially recognised as such.
In Brandao v. Barnett (1846) 12 Cl & Fin 787 it was stated as under :
"Bankers most undoubtedly have a general lien on all securities deposited with them as bankers by a customer, unless there be an express contract, or circumstances that show an implied contract, inconsistent with lien."
The above passages go to show that by mercantile system the Bank has a general lien over all forms of securities or negotiable instruments deposited by or on behalf of the customer in the ordinary course of banking business and that the general lien is a valuable right of the banker judicially recognised and in the absence of an agreement to the contrary, a Banker has a general lien over such securities or bills received from a customer in the ordinary course of banking business and has a right to use the proceeds in respect of any balance that may be due from the customer by way of reduction of customer's debit balance. Such a lien is also applicable to negotiable instruments including FDRs which are remitted the Bank by the customer for the purpose of collection. There is no gainsaying that such a lien extends to FDRs also which are deposited by the customer."
6. In view of the finding of the Supreme Court, we are of the view that the bank has a general lien over the securities and other instruments deposited by respondents 1 to 3 in the ordinary course of banking and such general lien being valuable right of the banker, as per Supreme court decision, it cannot be ignored in absence of an agreement to the contrary.
7. We, accordingly, set aside the impugned order dated 10th Sept., 2007, passed by DRAT as also the order dated 17th Jan., 2007, passed by DRT, Coimbatore. But this order will not stand in the way of respondents 1 to 3 to pay back the dues to the bank and, thereafter, to request the bank to release the documents. The civil revision petition is allowed. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is closed. But there shall be no order as to costs.
GLN To The State Bank of India Kotagiri Branch Kotagiri.
Alert