- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sujatha Jayakumar, P... v. M/S. Karnataka Soaps...
Factual and Procedural Background
This Civil Revision Petition challenges the order dated 23.8.2006 of the learned XIII Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai, made in I.A. No. 4780 of 2006 in O.S. No. 769 of 2003. The petitioner in the revision is the defendant in the original suit; the respondent in the revision is the plaintiff in that suit. The respondent-company (M/s. Karnataka Soaps & Detergents Ltd.) sued the petitioner for recovery of an alleged debt. During that suit the petitioner moved I.A. No. 4780 of 2006 seeking dismissal of the suit on the ground that the plaint had been signed and verified by a power-of-attorney agent (and by a Senior Assistant (Accounts)), without the Trial Court having granted the leave required under Order 3, Rule 2, C.P.C. The Trial Court dismissed that application; the petitioner seeks revision of that dismissal. Trial had progressed: issues were framed, P.W.1 was examined in chief and cross-examined in part when the present application before the Trial Court was filed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a suit is maintainable where the plaint and vakalat are signed/verified by a power-of-attorney agent (and a company employee), when leave under Order 3, Rule 2 of the C.P.C. was sought but not recorded as granted by the Trial Court.
- Whether the defect (if any) in not obtaining or recording leave under Order 3, Rule 2 is a curable irregularity that warrants dismissal at the stage it was raised, particularly where the defendant did not raise the objection in the written statement and raised it only after trial had commenced.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The suit is not maintainable because the plaint was signed and verified by a power-of-attorney agent and the plaintiff's application for leave under Order 3, Rule 2 of the C.P.C. was not ordered by the Trial Court.
- Accordingly, the petitioner sought dismissal of the suit and relied on a number of judicial authorities to support that proposition.
Respondent's Arguments
- At the time of filing the suit, a xerox copy of the power of attorney was filed along with an application under Order 3, Rule 2 of the C.P.C.; after verification with the original the suit was numbered and posted to court.
- The petitioner (defendant) had already filed its written statement and did not raise any objection to maintainability at that stage; issues were framed and trial proceeded.
- The petitioner raised the objection belatedly (after P.W.1 had been examined in chief and cross-examination partly conducted), and the application is an attempt to delay or drag on the proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| D. Sornam by Power of Attorney, D.A.S Swami v. State of Madras (1969) | Authorities concerning whether a power of attorney can appear on behalf of the principal. | The Court held such decisions are not of direct assistance here because those cases addressed appearance by power of attorney; in the present case the power of attorney had signed vakalat and sought permission to represent. |
| Major K. Mathews (Retd.) v. Registrar General, High Court of Judicature at Madras and others, AIR 2003 Mad. 411 | Authorities concerning whether a power of attorney can appear on behalf of the principal. | The Court treated this as similarly inapplicable to the present factual position for the reasons stated above. |
| Hari Om Rajender Kumar and others v. Chief Rationing Officer of Civil Supplies, AIR 1990 AP 340 | Authorities concerning whether a power of attorney can appear on behalf of the principal. | The Court concluded it did not support the petitioner's position on the facts of this case. |
| P.M. Desppa Nayanim Varu and others v. Ramabhaktula Ramiab and others, AIR 1952 Mad. 559 | Authorities concerning whether a power of attorney can appear on behalf of the principal. | The Court indicated this authority was not directly helpful to the petitioner given the factual differences. |
| Ram Prasad v. Hari Narain and others, AIR 1998 Raj. 185 | Authorities concerning whether a power of attorney can appear on behalf of the principal. | The Court treated it as not decisive for the present dispute. |
| Indian Commerce and Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Swadharma Swarajya Sanga, 1998 (1) LW 195 (and divisional confirmation Swadharma Swarajya Sanga v. Indian Commerce and Industries Pvt. Ltd., 1998 (1) LW 203) | Whether a suit filed by one of the directors without board authorisation is maintainable. | The Court observed that those decisions hold a director without board authorisation cannot maintain a suit; they are inapposite here because the present case does not concern a director acting without board authorisation. |
| Md. Munawar Hussain v. M/s. Usha Kiran Chit Funds and Others, AIR 2004 AP 63 | That certain procedural irregularities (e.g., numbering before deciding an issue) may not go to the root of the matter and may be curable. | The Court treated this authority as supporting the respondent: procedural irregularity in allowing or recording leave under practice rules may be irregular but need not invalidate the suit; the Trial Court may cure the defect since trial was not complete. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the matter on the following factual and legal bases set out in the opinion:
- Identification of parties and representation: the suit was instituted by M/s. Karnataka Soaps & Detergents Ltd., represented by its Senior Assistant (Accounts) and by a power-of-attorney holder S. Muthian. The power of attorney signed the vakalat and verified the plaint.
- Absence of pleaded objection: the petitioner did not assert in the written statement that the Senior Assistant could not represent the company, nor did it aver that no power of attorney had been granted to the Senior Assistant.
- Filing of application under Order 3, Rule 2: the respondent had filed an application under Order 3, Rule 2 of the C.P.C. and had tendered a xerox of the power of attorney which was later verified with the original, after which the suit was numbered and proceeded.
- Timing and conduct: the petitioner delayed raising the maintainability objection until after P.W.1 had been examined in chief and partly cross-examined, despite having filed a written statement earlier without raising the issue.
- Nature of the defect: the Court treated any failure to have the Order 3, Rule 2 application formally allowed by the Trial Court as at most a curable irregularity; it should not be used to dismiss the suit where the defect can be remedied and where the petitioner had not timely objected.
- Precedents: the Court found most authorities cited by the petitioner concerned different factual questions (e.g., whether a power of attorney could appear for the principal) and therefore were not directly applicable. The Court relied on the reasoning in Md. Munawar Hussain (AIR 2004 AP 63) to the effect that certain procedural irregularities may not go to the root of the case and can be cured during trial.
- Remedial possibility: because trial was not complete, the Trial Court retained the ability to allow the Order 3, Rule 2 application and cure the irregularity.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court CONFIRMED the order dated 23.8.2006 of the learned XIII Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai in I.A. No. 4780 of 2006 in O.S. No. 769 of 2003 and DISMISSED the Civil Revision Petition. The connected miscellaneous petition was closed. There was no order as to costs.
Implications: The direct effect is that the Trial Court's order stands and the respondent's suit proceeds. The opinion states that the procedural irregularity (if any) in not having the Order 3, Rule 2 application earlier allowed is curable and, since trial was not over, the Trial Court can yet allow the application. The decision, as expressed in this opinion, does not announce any new legal principle beyond applying existing authorities to the facts; the ruling leaves the matter of costs and further conduct of the trial to the Trial Court.
Prayer: Civil Revision Petition filed against the order dated 23.8.2006 made in I.A No. 4780 of 2006 in O.S No. 769 of 2003 on the file of the XIII Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai.
JUDGMENT
1. The present Civil Revision Petition is directed against the order of the learned XIII Assistant Judge, City Civil Court dated 23.8.2006 made in I.A No. 4780 of 2006 in O.S No. 769 of 2003.
2. The defendant in the above referred Suit is the petitioner and the plaintiff thereon is the respondent herein. The respondent herein laid the Suit against the petitioner herein for recovery of the amount said to be due by the petitioner. In the said Suit, the petitioner had taken out an Application in I.A No. 4780 of 2006 to dismiss the Suit. The said Application was dismissed by the Court below and the present Revision is directed against the said order.
3. In the affidavit filed in support of the Application for dismissing the Suit the petitioner had averred that the Suit has been laid through power of attorney agent, who has verified the Plaint and signed the vakalat on behalf of the plaintiff and the plaintiff had also filed an Application for leave of the Court to sign and verify the pleadings, which has not been ordered by the Trial Court. Hence, the plaintiff cannot maintain the Suit as the power of attorney was not permitted to sign the Plaint.
4. In the counter affidavit, the respondent herein has stated that while filing the Suit, the xerox copy of the power of attorney was filed along with an Application under Order 3, Rule 2 of C.P.C After verifying the same with the original, the Suit was numbered and posted before the Court. The petitioner, who have already filed their written statement did not raise any objection with regard to the maintainability of the Suit. Issues were framed and thereafter trial had commenced. P.W.1 was examined in chief and thereafter on behalf of the petitioner, P.W.1 was cross-examined in part. Without completing the cross-examination the present Application has been filed in order to drag on the proceedings.
5. Mr. C. Ravichandran, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. D. Venkateswaran, learned counsel appearing for the respondent had made their submissions on the pleadings raised by them in the affidavit and counter affidavit respectively.
6. Mr. C. Ravichandran, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner contended that since the Application filed on behalf of the respondent for permission permitting the power agent to sign and verify the Plaint was not ordered by the Court below, the Suit itself is liable to be dismissed. For the said proposition, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner relied on number of authorities.
7. It is to be seen that the Suit had been laid by the respondent M/s. Karnataka Soaps & Detergents Ltd., represented by its Senior Assistant (Accounts) and also the Power of Attorney one S. Muthian. The said power of attorney has signed the vakalat on behalf of the respondent/plaintiff and he has also verified the Plaint. It is not the case of the petitioner that the Senior Assistant cannot represent the Karnataka Soaps & Detergents Ltd. Nowhere in the written statement such a plea has been taken. Further more, it is not the case of the petitioner either in the written statement or in the affidavit filed in support of the Application that power of attorney was not given to the Senior Assistant. It is also not the case of the petitioner that the Application for leave which had been filed to represent the respondent by the power agent was not filed by the petitioner/plaintiff. While so now to plead that the Senior Assistant cannot represent the respondent/plaintiff/Company, when once the respondent filed an Application for permission under Order 3, Rule 2 of C.P.C to represent through power agent cannot be entertained. Even if it was not allowed by the Court below, it could only be a curable defect. The mistake in not allowing the Application should not be put against the respondent. Further, it has to be seen that the petitioner, who has not raised the above plea in the written statement sought to raise only after P.W.1 was examined in chief and cross-examination in part.
8. The decisions that have been cited by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner viz.,
1. D. Sornam by Power of Attorney, D.A.S Swami v. State of Madras, rep. by Secretary, Health Department, Fort St. George, Madras, 1969 (82); 2. Major K. Mathews (Retd.) v. Registrar General, High Court of Judicature at Madras and others, AIR 2003 Mad. 411; 3. Hari Om Rajender Kumar and others v. Chief Rationing Officer of Civil Supplies, AIR 1990 AP 340; 4. P.M Desppa Nayanim Varu and others v. Ramabhaktula Ramiab and others, AIR 1952 Mad. 559; 5. Ram Prasad v. Hari Narain and others, AIR 1998 Raj. 185;
may not be of any use to the petitioner since in those decisions, the question was whether the power of attorney could appear on behalf of the Principal. In the case on hand the power of attorney has signed the vakalat and he has sought permission for defending the case on behalf of the respondent/plaintiff.
9. The other decision cited by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner is reported in Indian Commerce and Industries Private Ltd. v. Swadharma Swarajya Sanga, 1998 (1) LW 195, which has been confirmed by the Division Bench of this Court and the same is reported in Swadharma Swarajya Sanga v. Indian Commerce and Industries Private Ltd., 1998 (1) LW 203. In that decision the consideration was whether the Suit filed by one of the Directors of the Company without any authorisation by the Board of Directors was maintainable or not. The learned Single Judge and the Division Bench of this Court in that decision have held that one of the Director without authorisation by the Board of Directors cannot maintain the Suit but in the case on hand, that is not the position. It is not the case of the petitioner that the Senior Assistant was not authorised by the Board of Directors to represent the respondent/plaintiff.
10. Yet another decision that has been relied on by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner is reported in Md. Munawar Hussain v. M/s. Usha Kiran Chit Funds and Others, AIR 2004 AP 63. The said judgment in fact supports the case of the respondent. Para 11 of the said Judgment can be usefully extracted hereunder:
“11. From the above said judgment, it is clear that the learned Judge, after making himself clear about the maintainability of the Suit has proceeded further. Of course, there is an irregularity in disposing of the Suit i.e before numbering the Suit the learned Judge ought to have decided this issue and being satisfied that it is in accordance with Rule 32 of Civil Rules of Practice, he ought to have numbered the Suit. In the instant case, of course, he did not follow the said procedure as contemplated under Rule 32 and only after numbering the Suit has decided the issue. This irregularity in proceeding with the Suit may not go to the roots of the case and as such, I am not inclined to accept the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the very judgment and decree are contrary to Rule 32 of Civil Rules of Practice.”
Even in the case on hand, though the respondent/plaintiff preferred an Application under Order 3, Rule 2 of the C.P.C, the Court below has not allowed the Application and the Suit has been proceeded further. The procedure adopted by the Court below may be irregular but may not go to the root of the case. Even now the Court below can allow the Application since the trial is not over.
11. Considering the above facts and circumstances of the case, I am not inclined to interfere with the order of the learned XIII Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai dated 23.8.2006 made in I.A No. 4780 of 2006 in O.S No. 769 of 2003 as there is absolutely no irregularity or infirmity in the said order. In the result, the said order is confirmed. The Civil Revision Petition stands dismissed. Consequently, the connected M.P is closed. However, there is no order as to costs.
Alert