- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
B.Krishnan v. Tamilnadu Water Supply &
Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ appeal challenges the learned single Judge's order dated 16.07.2002 in W.P.No.7416 of 2000, which confirmed an earlier appellate order dated 14.02.2000.
The appellant/petitioner was a Deputy Superintending Engineer in the Tamil Nadu Water Supply and Drainage Board (TWAD Board). He reached the age of superannuation on 31.05.1995. However, by an order dated 29.05.1995 he was not permitted to retire and was placed under suspension on that date on the ground that departmental enquiry was pending.
Disciplinary proceedings arose from alleged irregularities in purchase of materials when he served as Executive Engineer at Ooty, based on an audit report for the period 1981-82 to 1987-88. He was initially placed under suspension on 02.09.1988. He challenged that suspension in W.P.No.19276 of 1992; this Court directed completion of the disciplinary proceedings within three months. When the enquiry was not completed, an extension application was rejected and the petitioner was directed to be reinstated; he was reinstated by proceedings dated 12.03.1993.
Charges were framed on 29.05.1995. The petitioner alleges he was not supplied documents; he sought supply and filed W.P.No.1247 of 1996. This Court directed production of documents within four weeks and completion of enquiry within three months. The enquiry report (submitted 14.05.1997) found most charges not proved except certain specified charges (1(i), 1(vi) proved; 1(viii) partially proved). Multiple extension applications and miscellaneous petitions (WPMP.No.1094 of 1997; WPMP.No.3400 of 1998) followed; there was a change of Enquiry Officer; an ex parte enquiry was completed and final orders were passed by the respondents. The petitioner filed a contempt petition for non-compliance of the Court's directions and was permitted to peruse records and submit explanation. Thereafter an impugned order dated 22.06.1999 was passed by the second respondent; an appeal to the first respondent on 15.07.1999 was rejected on 14.02.2000. The petitioner challenged that rejection by filing the present writ petition which was dismissed by the single Judge; this writ appeal followed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondents had lawful authority to refuse the petitioner permission to retire on 31.05.1995 and to place him under suspension by orders dated 29.05.1995 in the circumstances described.
- Whether the respondents could continue or revive disciplinary proceedings and pass final orders after this Court had refused to extend time for completion of the enquiry.
- Whether the learned single Judge's orders in the contempt proceedings (permitting perusal of records and submission of explanation) were within the scope of the contempt proceedings and consistent with earlier directions refusing extension of time.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant / Petitioner
- The petitioner contended that he attained superannuation on 31.05.1995 but was not allowed to retire because the second respondent issued an order dated 29.05.1995 refusing retirement and placing him under suspension, purportedly because a departmental enquiry was pending.
- He asserted that charges framed related to alleged irregularities while he was Executive Engineer at Ooty for the period 1982–1985, and that he had been reinstated by this Court in 1993 after orders directing completion of enquiry which was not done within time.
- The petitioner alleged non-supply of documents in relation to the charge memo (he sent a representation dated 18.07.1995 seeking documents), prompting W.P.No.1247 of 1996 in which this Court ordered production of documents and completion of enquiry within three months; despite that, respondents failed to pass final orders.
- He argued that subsequent extensions and actions by the respondents (including appointing a second Enquiry Officer and completing the enquiry ex parte) were contrary to earlier Court orders, and that the impugned order(s) preventing his retirement were without authority.
Respondents
- The learned Standing Counsel for the respondents submitted that the petitioner had committed grave financial irregularities contrary to applicable regulations.
- She further submitted that despite delays in concluding departmental proceedings, the petitioner could not be permitted to retire while disciplinary proceedings were pending (implying the impugned orders were sustainable in law).
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court reviewed the factual and procedural history, emphasizing these points:
- Disciplinary proceedings had been initiated based on an audit report covering 1981-82 to 1987-88 when the petitioner was Executive Engineer at Ooty; the petitioner was suspended on 02.09.1988.
- This Court, in W.P.No.19276 of 1992, directed completion of the enquiry within three months; when the direction was not complied with, an application for extension was rejected and the petitioner was reinstated on 12.03.1993.
- Charges were framed later (29.05.1995); the petitioner was due to retire on 31.05.1995. Respondents issued orders on 29.05.1995 refusing retirement and placing him under suspension, citing a criminal investigation by Directorate of Vigilance & Anti-Corruption (DVAC) and the pendency of departmental proceedings.
- After reinstatement, an Enquiry Officer was appointed on 30.11.1996 and an enquiry report submitted on 14.05.1997 which mostly did not prove the charges. The Court had repeatedly directed finalisation of the enquiry within specific time frames but respondents failed to pass final orders despite extensions being granted (including WPMP.No.1094 of 1997 granting time and a later one-month extension).
- When further time was sought (WPMP.No.3400 of 1998, dismissed on 28.04.1998), the Court refused extension. Subsequently the respondents changed the Enquiry Officer, completed enquiry ex parte and passed final orders; the petitioner objected to this procedure.
- The petitioner filed a contempt petition for non-compliance of the Court’s directions. The learned single Judge closed the contempt petition after recording an undertaking by respondents but allowed the petitioner to peruse records and submit explanation; the respondents were directed to pass a final order. The appellate court found that permitting submission of explanation in those circumstances was contrary to the earlier order rejecting an extension of time (referred to as WPMP.No.3440 of 1998 in the opinion) and therefore legally improper.
- The court analyzed relevant government orders and guidelines (G.O.Ms.No.439 Personnel and Administrative Reforms (Per.N) Department dated 27.07.1999 and G.O.144 Personnel and Administrative Reforms (Per.N) Department dated 08.06.2007) including the quoted guidelines: (iv) warning against failure to issue final orders three months before retirement; (v) the circumstances when Fundamental Rule 56(1)(c) may be used to retain services beyond superannuation; and (vii) that the guidelines are not applicable to DVAC enquiries and criminal cases.
- The court noted that those guidelines indicate that suspension orders or orders retaining service beyond retirement should not be issued on the date of retirement (except in the narrow circumstance where a Government servant is already under suspension and retention beyond retirement is necessary), and emphasized that the respondents’ conduct—reviving proceedings and placing the petitioner under suspension two days before retirement—was contrary to the G.O.s and the Court’s prior directions.
- The opinion records that although criminal investigation by DVAC had taken place and a criminal case was filed, the petitioner was acquitted in 2005 (this fact is recited in the court's analysis).
- On that basis the court concluded the impugned order(s) were "without any authority" and constituted a misuse of the process and of powers contrary to the Court's earlier refusals to grant extensions and contrary to the Government Orders cited.
Holding and Implications
The impugned order is set aside and the writ appeal is allowed.
Direct consequences recorded in the opinion:
- The impugned orders (including the order dated 22.06.1999 and related orders that prevented retirement and placed the petitioner under suspension) have been set aside by the court.
- The writ appeal filed by the petitioner is allowed.
- There will be no order as to costs.
Broader implications: the opinion does not announce a new binding precedent. The court based its decision on the facts of the case, the sequence of this Court's prior directions, and the cited government orders and rules; it concluded that the respondents' actions were contrary to those directions and guidelines. The opinion does not purport to create a new legal principle beyond the application of existing rules and the cited G.O.s to these facts.
(Judgment of the Court was delivered by ELIPE DHARMA RAO,J.,) The writ appeal is directed against the order of the learned single Judge dated 16.07.2002 made in W.P.No.7416 of 2000, confirming the order in Appeal dated 14.02.2000.
2. The case of the appellant/petitioner is that he being a Deputy Superintending Engineer, Tamil Nadu Water Supply and Drainage Board, has reached the age of superannuation as early as 31.05.1995. However, he was not allowed to retire from service by an order dated 29.05.1995 and also he was placed under suspension by another order of the same date, namely, 29.05.1995 that the departmental enquiry was pending.
3. The further case of the petitioner is that he was a diploma holder in Sanitary Engineering and was appointed as a Public Works Supervisor in Rasipuram Municipality on 20.04.1960. Thereafter, he was promoted as Municipal Engineer, Assistant Engineer and Executive Engineer on 17.08.1966, 21.10.1970, and 23.07.1980 respectively. Further, he was worked as Deputy Superintending Engineer at Tirunelveli from 1993 to 1995. While he was working as Executive Engineer at Ooty, based on the audit report for the period 1981-82 to 1987-88, he was confronted with irregularities in the matter of purchase of materials in the above division during the period from 12.05.1982 to 16.05.1985. Thereafter, he was placed under suspension by the second respondent, by his Proceedings dated 02.09.1988. Challenging the same, he filed W.P.No.19276 of 1992 and by order dated 02.12.1992 this Court had directed the respondents to complete the disciplinary proceeding within a period of three months. When the enquiry was not completed within three months as stipulated in the order, an extension application in WMP.No.6081 of 1993 in the said writ petition was filed. This Court, by order dated 08.03.1993 rejected the same and directed reinstatement of the petitioner. Thereafter, by Proceedings dated 12.03.1993 he was reinstated into service. After reinstatement, for the first time, three charges were framed on 29.05.1995 for the irregularities committed by him during the period from 1982 to 1985.
4. The further case of the petitioner is that it is pertinent to note that he has to retire on attaining the age of superannuation on 31.05.1995. However, the second respondent has not permitted him to retire from service in exercise of powers conferred under FR 56(1)(c) read with Regulation 58 of TWAD Service Regulations, 1972. By another order dated 29.05.1995, the petitioner was placed under suspension. Though the charge memo was issued, he has not been served with copies of documents. Hence, he sent a representation on 18.07.1995 for supply of documents, but it was not considered. Hence, he filed W.P.No.1247 of 1996 challenging the charge memo and this Court, by order, dated 12.04.1996 directed the respondents to make available all the documents in four weeks and directed the Enquiry Officer to complete the enquiry within three months from the date of appointment of the Enquiry Officer. Thereafter, the petitioner submitted his explanation on 13.11.1986 and the Enquiry Officer was appointed on 30.11.1996 and after completing the enquiry, a report was submitted on 14.05.1997 holding that except charges 1(i), 1(vi), other charges were not proved and only charge No.1(viii) was partially proved. When they failed to pass final orders, as directed by this Court, WPMP.No.1094 of 1997 in W.P.No.1247 of 1996 was filed for extension of time and one month time was granted. Even though the time was extended by one month, final order was not passed and they filed WPMP.No.3400 of 1998 praying further extension of time, but it was dismissed on 28.04.1998. In the mean time, due to the retirement of the Enquiry Officer, another Enquiry Officer was appointed and it was objected to by the petitioner. They have completed the enquiry exparte and final orders were passed. By virtue of the order dated 26.11.1997 in WPMP.No.1094 of 1997, the respondents have no power to go on with the enquiry. In the meantime, a contempt petition was filed by the petitioner for not complying with the order passed by this Court dated 12.04.1996. In the contempt petition, after considering the facts and circumstances of the case, the learned single Judge, closed the same, recording the undertaking filed by the respondents and passed orders on merits and granted time to the petitioner to peruse the records. Accordingly, the petitioner submitted a representation for perusal of records, but it was not conceded as if the petitioner had already perused the records. Thereafter, the impugned order dated 22.06.1999 was passed by the second respondent; against which the petitioner filed an appeal on 15.07.1999 before the 1st respondent; but it was rejected on 14.02.2000. Challenging the same, he filed the writ petition.
5. The learned single Judge, after hearing both sides and taking into consideration the said facts, dismissed the same. Aggrieved over the same, the present writ appeal is filed.
6. Heard the learned counsel for both sides and perused the records. It is clear that when the petitioner was working as an Executive Engineer at Ooty, on the basis of the audit report for the year 1981-82 to 1987-88, disciplinary proceedings were initiated and he was placed under suspension on 02.09.1988 for the irregularities committed by him. When they failed to complete the enquiry, he approached this Court by filing W.P.No.19276 of 1992 and it was disposed of with a direction to complete the enquiry within a period of three months and when it was not complied with, a petition for extension of time was filed and the same was rejected, directing to reinstate him. Thereafter, he was reinstated by order dated 12.03.1993 as Deputy Superintending Engineer. After lapse of two years, when his retirement was due on 31.05.1995, the respondents revived the proceedings and placed him under suspension on 29.05.1995. Simultaneously another order was issued not permitting him to retire in view of the criminal investigation by Directorate of Vigilance & Anti-corruption. One Enquiry Officer was appointed on 30.11.1996 but orders were not passed. Hence, he was constrained to file W.P.No.1247 of 1996 and this Court granted time to complete the enquiry within three months, which was not complied with. Thereafter, time was extended to pass a final order on the ground that enquiry shall be completed within one month. Even then no orders were passed and the second Enquiry Officer was appointed and when further time was prayed, this Court has refused to grant the same. Therefore, when once the Court has refused to extend the time for completion of enquiry, the petitioner filed the contempt petition for non-compliance of the order dated 26.11.1997 passed in the miscellaneous petition filed in W.P.No.1247 of 1996. The learned Judge, while closing the contempt petition, allowed the writ petitioner to peruse the records and submit his explanation within the period as stated in para 11 of the affidavit and the respondents are directed to pass a final order.
7. Accordingly, the respondents passed the impugned order, which, in our considered view, is without any authority and is liable to be set aside on the ground that when this Court refused to extend the time for completing the enquiry for the alleged irregularities committed by him during the period from 1981-82 to 1987-88 when he was working as Executive Engineer, Ooty (on the basis of the audit report) and by virtue of the orders passed by this Court, he was reinstated and even though time was granted to complete the enquiry, they failed to complete the same. Though criminal investigation was conducted and criminal case was filed, he was acquitted in 2005. Taking into consideration his date of retirement from service on 31.05.1995, they have revived the disciplinary proceedings and placed him under suspension by order dated 29.05.1995 and he was not allowed to retire on the same day, which, in our view, is contrary to the orders passed by the Government in G.O.Ms.No.439 Personnel and Administrative Reforms (Per.N) Department dated 27.07.1999 and G.O.144 Personnel and Administrative Reforms (Per.N) Department dated 08.06.2007 and the relevant guidelines are as follows:
"(iv) Any failure on the part of the disciplinary authority to issue final orders three months before the date of retirement of a delinquent officer will be viewed seriously and it will entail severe action to be initiated against the officials responsible for dragging on the case to the dte of retirement of Government Servant concerned.
(v) Where the delinquency committed by a Government servant is very grave which warrants imposition of major penalty such as dismissal or removal from service and if it is not possible to pass final orders in such departmental proceedings, then it is necessary to suspend the Government Servant from service and not to permit him to retire on attaining the age of superanuation under Fundamental Rule 56(1)(c). In such cases also, the disciplinary authorities have to ensure that the suspension orders are not issued on the date of retirement of the Government servants. However, where a Government servant is already under suspension, orders retaining the services of Government servant beyond the dte of superannuation under Fundamental Rule 56(1)(c) have to be issued on the date of retirement only.
.....
(vii) The above instructions shall not be made applicable to cases of Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption enquiry and criminal cases".
It is made clear from the above guidelines that the same are not applicable when he was acquitted from the criminal case filed by the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption.
8. Therefore, when the Court has given time twice to conduct enquiry, the respondents at one time submitted that they have completed the enquiry and sought time for passing final order and on the said representation, three months time was granted. Though one month time was extended thereafter, no final order was passed. But when a contempt petition was filed by the petitioner for not furnishing the documents for his perusal in order to submit his explanation to the charge memo, which was filed before the rejection of the extension of time for completing the enquiry, the learned Judge, contrary to the order passed by this Court in rejecting the extension petition WPMP.No.3440 of 1998, allowed the petitioner to submit his explanation. In our view, this is contrary to law. Therefore, the impugned orders are liable to be set aside.
9. On the other hand, the learned Standing Counsel for the respondents submitted that the petitioner has committed grave financial irregularities, contrary to the Regulations passed. She further submitted that though lapses or delay in concluding the departmental proceedings, he may not be allowed to retire. Therefore, the impugned order is sustainable in law.
10. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, we are satisfied that even though the departmental proceedings were initiated in 1988, after a lapse of six years, he was placed under suspension for the charges framed on the basis of the internal audit report for the year from 1981-82 and 1987-88 when he was working as Executive Engineer at Ooty and even though time was granted by this court in the above writ proceedings to conclude the enquiry, the respondents have failed to complete the enquiry and pass final orders. On the other hand, taking into consideration the date of retirement, two days before his retirement once again he was placed under suspension and was not allowed to retire from service on the ground of pendency of departmental proceedings, which is contrary to the above said G.Os.and orders passed by this Court . Therefore, the order passed by the learned single Judge in the contempt proceedings is beyond the scope of the contempt proceedings. Therefore, on the basis of the order passed in the contempt petition, the impugned orders are liable to be set aside.
Accordingly, the impugned order is set aside and the Writ appeal is allowed. There will be no order as to costs.
gl To
1. The Chairman, Tamilnadu Water Supply & Drainage Board, Chepauk, Chennai-5.
2. The Managing Director, Tamilnadu Water Supply & Drainage Board, Chepauk, Chennai 5.
Alert