- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
S. Sivaparamam & 2 O... v. The State Of Tamil N...
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ petition was filed seeking a declaration that the lands comprised in Survey Nos. 649/18, 649/19, 649/25 (Plot Nos. 13, 14, 15, 16, 27, 28, 31 and 32) measuring 17,790 sq. ft. at V.O.C. Nagar of Velachery Village, Chennai, belonging to the petitioners, do not attract the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978 (the "Principal Act") or Section 3(1)(a) of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999 (the "Repealing Act").
The petitioners asserted title by purchase in 1985, having independent pattas and continuous physical possession. They applied to the Tahsildar (4th respondent) on 29.3.2006 for inclusion of their lands in the Town Survey Register and issuance of a new patta. The 4th respondent treated the properties as attracted by the Principal Act.
No counter affidavit was filed by the respondents. On the Court's direction, the Government Advocate produced the departmental files relating to the land-ceiling proceedings to ascertain whether physical possession had been taken by the State or its authorised officers prior to the repeal of the Principal Act.
The produced files show a series of actions under the Principal Act: notice under section 7(2) issued to the vendor on 3.11.1995; a notice under section 9(4) on 5.8.1997 and a statement prepared under section 9(1) (Form III) on the same date; an order under section 9(5) dated 8.9.1997; a final statement under section 10(1) on 7.10.1997; a notification under section 11(1) dated 4.3.1998; a consequential notification under section 11(3) dated 18.6.1998; and a notice under section 11(5) dated 15.9.1998.
One departmental note dated 21.12.1998 recorded that an official stated that she had handed over possession to another official. Apart from that single note, the files did not contain contemporaneous records evidencing that physical possession had been taken from the owner or vendor, nor did they show payment of any amount by the Government in respect of the land.
The petitioners produced evidence of continued possession, including urban land tax receipts, certificates issued by the village karnam, and a patta issued by the Tahsildar dated 23.12.1999. The Court ultimately allowed the writ petition and awarded no costs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the subject lands attract the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978 (the Principal Act), or are saved from such application by the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999.
- Whether physical possession of the lands had been taken by the State (or by a person authorised by the State) before the commencement of the Repealing Act, so as to fall within the exceptions in Sections 3 and 4 of the Repealing Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners acquired title by purchase in 1985, received independent pattas and have been in continuous, physical possession of the lands at all material times.
- By virtue of the Repealing Act, proceedings under the Principal Act lapsed and authorities under the old Act could not continue action; the only exception is where physical possession had been taken by the Government prior to the Repealing Act, which the petitioners say never occurred in their case.
- The petitioners produced urban land tax receipts, village karnam certificates and a patta dated 23.12.1999 as evidence of continued physical possession.
Respondents' / Government Advocate's Points
- No counter affidavit was filed by the respondents; however, the Government Advocate produced the departmental files on the Court's direction.
- The Government Advocate relied heavily on a departmental note dated 21.12.1998 in which an official stated that she had handed over possession to another official, endeavouring to show that physical possession had been taken by the authorities.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Pt. Madan Swaroop Shrotiya Public Charitable Trust v. State of U.P (AIR 2000 SC 3415) | Reiterates that after repeal the authorities under the Principal Act could not initiate proceedings; the exception is where physical possession had been taken by the Government prior to repeal. | The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that where no possession was taken by the State, proceedings under the Principal Act are deemed to have abated under Section 4 of the Repealing Act. |
| Smt. Angoori Devi v. State of U.P. & Ors (JT 2000 (Suppl.1) SC 295) | Supports the Constitutional Bench view that repeal of the Principal Act causes abatement of proceedings unless physical possession had been taken by the State before repeal. | The Court cited this case as consistent authority that proceedings should abate where there is no evidence of the State taking physical possession prior to repeal. |
| Mrs. Ayesha Haque v. State of Tamil Nadu & others (2003 Writ L.R 193) | States that the repeal does not affect only those cases where vesting under section 11(3) and physical possession by the State had been completed. | The Court cited this judgment to emphasize that repeal leaves unaffected only those matters where vesting and possession by the State had in fact occurred. |
| S. Antony & others v. The Special Commissioner, Commissioner Land Reforms (W.P. No. 19845 of 2006, order dated 31.7.2006) | Explains the operation of sections 11(5) and 11(6) of the Principal Act: an order to surrender possession under 11(5) and power to take possession under 11(6); where 11(6) is not resorted to and repeal intervenes, proceedings abate. | The Court relied on this reasoning to hold that mere issuance of notices under sections 11(4) and 11(5) is insufficient; actual exercise of the power under 11(6) or other evidence of possession is required to prevent abatement on repeal. |
| C.V. Narasimhan v. The Government of Tamil Nadu (2002 (2) L.W 764) | Holds that where physical possession continues with the owner, statutory vesting under section 11(3) is of no relevance. | The Court cited this view to support the proposition that mere statutory vesting (if not accompanied by physical possession) does not validate continued proceedings after repeal. |
| Allind Metal Fabricators Pvt. Ltd., Madras v. The Secretary to Government, Revenue Department, Govt. of Tamil Nadu (2002 (2) CTC 716) | Following Angoori Devi, holds that if possession under the Principal Act prior to repeal was not taken, then no proceedings can be subsequently initiated. | The Court referenced this judgment to reinforce the position that absence of possession prior to repeal causes abatement of proceedings and bars later initiation. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the departmental files produced by the Government Advocate and traced the chronology of notices and orders issued under the Principal Act between 1995 and 1998 (including steps under sections 7(2), 9(4), 9(5), 10(1), 11(1), 11(3) and 11(5)). The Court noted one departmental entry dated 21.12.1998 stating that an official had handed over possession to another official; the Government Advocate relied on that entry to contend that physical possession had been taken.
However, the Court found there were no other contemporaneous records in the files to demonstrate that the owner or vendor had surrendered physical possession, that possession had in fact been taken by the authorities in conformity with section 11(6) of the Principal Act, or that the Government had paid any amount in respect of the lands (which would be relevant under Section 3(2) of the Repealing Act where deemed vesting is claimed but physical possession has not been taken).
The Court analysed Sections 3 and 4 of the Repealing Act as reproduced in the record. It reasoned that the Repealing Act abates all proceedings under the Principal Act pending immediately before its commencement, except in respect of lands where possession had actually been taken by the State (or a person authorised by it) or where vesting under section 11(3) had occurred and the Government had paid the amount for the value of the land and such amount had not been refunded.
Applying the statutory scheme to the facts, and relying on the cited precedents (including Pt. Madan Swaroop, Angoori Devi, and the other decisions summarised above), the Court concluded that the departmental material did not establish that physical possession had been taken or that compensation had been paid. The single note of handing over possession was insufficient, in the absence of corroborative contemporaneous records, to demonstrate that the State had taken possession prior to repeal.
Having accepted the petitioners' evidence of continued physical possession (urban land tax receipts, village karnam certificates, patta dated 23.12.1999, etc.), and finding no adequate proof of possession by the State, the Court held that the proceedings under the Principal Act in respect of these lands were deemed to have abated upon the coming into force of the Repealing Act.
Holding and Implications
WRIT PETITION ALLOWED.
Direct effect on the parties:
- The Court allowed the petitioners' claim, effectively concluding that the proceedings under the Principal Act in respect of the properties in question have abated and that the petitioners continue in physical possession.
- No costs were ordered.
Broader implications and precedent:
The judgment applies established principles (as set out by the cited Supreme Court and High Court authorities) that the Repealing Act abates pending proceedings under the Principal Act except where the State had, before repeal, taken physical possession or where vesting plus payment by the State had occurred. The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal principle; it applies existing authorities to the facts at hand.
Note: This summary is drawn exclusively from the text of the provided opinion. No facts or legal conclusions beyond those appearing in the opinion have been added.
The writ petition is filed for declaration that the land comprised in Survey Nos. 649/18, 649/19, 649/25 bearing Plot Nos. 13, 14, 15, 16, 27, 28, 31 and 32 measuring 17,790 sq.ft situated at V.O.C Nagar of Velachery Village, Chennai belonging to the petitioners does not attract the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978 or Section 3(1)(a) of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999.
2. The case of the petitioners is that under various documents they have acquired title in respect of the abovesaid properties and the purchases were made in the year 1985 and independent pattas were given and they have been in absolute possession. The petitioners have approached the 4th respondent-Tahsildar on 29.3.2006 for inclusion of their lands in Town Survey Register by issuing new patta. In spite of the fact that the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978 which came into effect in 1978 has lost its legal validity in the year 1999 on account of passing of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999 by virtue of which the lands which were under the proceedings of the earlier Act became free-hold lands except in cases where the possession has been taken by the Government which is saved by Section 3(1)(a) of the said Act, the 4th respondent has wrongly held that the properties are attracted by the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978. According to the petitioners, they are the title holders of the properties and are in actual and physical possession and their possession has never been taken by the Government at any point of time under the old Act.
3. The petitioners relied upon the judgements of the Supreme Court in Pt. Madan Swaroop Shrotiya Public Charitable Trust v. State of U.P (AIR 2000 SC 3415) and Smt. Angoori Devi v. State of U.P & Ors. (JT 2000 (Suppl.1) SC 295), stating that by virtue of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999, the authorities functioning under the erstwhile principal Act could not have jurisdiction to initiate proceedings under the new Act and it is categorical that only exception to that is in respect of properties wherein physical possession has been resumed by the Government prior to coming into the new Act and this proposition has also been followed by this Court in various decisions and in view of the same, the present writ petition has been filed.
4. Even though the respondents have not filed counter affidavit, on direction from this Court, the learned Government Advocate has produced the entire files relating to the land ceiling proceedings regarding the properties in dispute for the purpose of ascertaining as to whether physical possession has been taken by the respondents.
5. I have referred to the files. It is seen that notice under section 7(2) of Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 24/1978 was issued to the vendor of the petitioners on 3.11.1995 Subsequently, a notice under section 9(4) of the said Act was issued on 5.8.1997 calling for objection for the proposed action under the said Act. A statement was prepared as per section 9(1) of the Act in Form No. III as per Rule 8 of the concerned Rules on the same date. By order dated 8.9.1997, the third respondent has passed orders under section 9(5) in respect of taking proceedings to take possession. The Competent Authority under section 10(1) of the Act has prepared a final statement on 7.10.1997 Subsequently, notification under section 11(1) was issued by the Competent Authority on 4.3.1998 and the consequential notification under section 11(3) was issued on 18.6.1998, for acquisition of the excess vacant land held by the vendor of the petitioners and likewise, the notice under section 11(5) of the Act was also issued on 15.9.1998
6. It is seen in page 137 of the file produced by the learned Government Advocate that one of the officials have stated that she has handed over possession to another official. That was dated 21.12.1998 The learned Government Advocate would heavily place reliance on the said paper to show that the official has handed over possession and therefore it should be presumed that the physical possession has been taken. Apart from the abovesaid papers, there are no other record to show that the owner of the property has handed over the physical possession to the respondents. The legal position in this regard is clear. After the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Repeal Act, 20/1999, the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978 and the action taken under the said Act lapsed. Section 4 of the Act 20/1999 states that all proceedings relating to any order made or purported to be made under the Principal Act, viz., Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1978 pending immediately before the commencement of the Act 20/1999 before any Court, Tribunal or any authority shall abate. However, the said Section saves the action taken in respect of the lands possession of which has been taken over by the State Government or any other person authorised by the State Government or by the competent authorities. Section 3 of the Act 20/1999 also states that vesting of possession of any property taken earlier or granting of any exemption under section 21(1) shall not be affected by the repealing Act. It also further states that in respect of cases wherein under section 11(3) of the Principal Act (Old Act, 1978) in respect of which possession has not been taken, but an amount has been paid by the State Government to such lands, such lands shall not be restored unless the amount already paid is not refunded to the Government. In this regard, it is relevant to reproduce sections 3 and 4 of the repealing Act which state as follows:
“Section 3.(1) The repeal of the principal Act shall not affect-
(a) the vesting of any vacant land u under sub-section (3) of section 11, possession of which has been taken over by the State Government or any person duly authorised by the State Government in this behalf or by the competent authority;
(b) the validity of any order granting exemption under sub-section (1) of section 21 of any action taken thereunder.
(2) Where-
(a) any land is deemed to have vested in the State Government under sub-section (3) of section 11 of the principal Act but possession of which has not been taken over by the State Government or any person duly authorised by the State Government in this behalf or by the competent authority; and
(b) any amount has been paid by the State Government with respect to such land, then, such land shall not be restored unless the amount paid, if any, has been refunded to the State Government.
Section 4. All proceedings relating to any order made or purported to be made under the principal Act pending immediately before the commencement of this Act, before any Court, tribunal or any authority shall abate:
Provided that this section shall not apply to the proceedings relating to sections 12, 13, 14, 15, 15-B and 16 of the principal Act in so far as such proceedings are relatable to the land, possession of which has been taken over by the State Government or any person duly authorised by the State Government in this behalf or by the competent authority.”
Therefore, a combined reading of these sections will make it clear that action under the old Act would abate except in respect of cases where possession has already been taken over by the Government or in respect of cases where possession has not been taken over but deemed to have vested under Section 11(3) with the State Government and the Government paid the amount for the value of the land and the same has not been refunded. That is relating to deemed possession under section 11(3) of the Principal Act.
7. On the facts which I have narrated earlier, on going through the files, even though a notification under section 11(3) of the Principal Act was given on 18.6.1998 about the deemed possession, it is nowhere in the files seen that the respondents have paid compensation or any amount to the petitioners or the vendor of the petitioners, viz., previous owner. Therefore, it is clear that the order passed by the authority contemplated under the Principal Act in declaring excess land in respect of the property in dispute cannot be stated to have become final and therefore the proceedings under the Principal Act are deemed to have abated. It was held by the Supreme Court in Pt. Madan Swaroop Shrotiya Public Charitable Trust v. State of U.P (AIR 2000 SC 3415) that in cases where it is proved that the possession under the Principal Act had not been taken over and there is nothing on record to indicate that the State has taken possession over the surplus land, the said proceedings should be deemed to be abated under section 4 of the repealing Act 1999. That was also the view taken by the Supreme Court in Smt. Angoori Devi v. State of U.P & Ors. (JT 2000 (Suppl.1) SC 295). In similar circumstances, K.P Sivasubramaniam, J. in the judgement rendered in Mrs. Ayesha Haque v. State of Tamil Nadu & others (200 3 Writ L.R 193) has held,
“A perusal of the above quoted sections 3 and 4 makes it clear that the repeal shall not affect only the cases where the vesting of the land has taken place in favour of the Government under section 11(3) and possession having been taken by the State Government”
8. In a similar situation like that of the present case, Prabha Sridevan, J. in the order dated 31.7.2006 rendered in W.P No. 19845 of 2006 in S. Antony & others v. The Special Commissioner, Commissioner Land Reforms, Chennai-5 and others, has dealt with the notice issued under section 11(5) of the Principal Act, 1978, by relying upon section 11(5) and (6) of the Principal Act which reads as under:
“SECTION 11(5) Where any vacant land is vested in the State Government under sub-section (3), the competent authority may, by notice in writing, order any person who may be in possession of it to surrender or deliver possession thereof to the State Government or to any person duly authorised by the State Government in this behalf within thirty days of the service of the notice.
SECTION 11(6) If any person refuses or fails to comply with an order made under sub-section(5), the competent authority may take possession of the vacant land or cause it to be given to the State Government or to any person duly authorised by the State Government in this behalf and may for that purpose use such force as may be necessary.”
In the said case, the learned Judge has held that even if the original owner refuses to part with the possession under section 11(5) of the Principal Act, under 11(6) there is power to take possession and if such provision is not resorted to and in the meantime, the repealing Act has come into existence, the proceedings under the Principal Act should be deemed to have abated. In fact, the learned Judge, while deciding so, has also relied upon an earlier order of this Court in W.P No. 35490 of 2004 in which it was held as follows:
“When the respondent does not say that the petitioner had surrendered possession on its own, then the respondent ought to have taken possession, under section 11(6) of the Principal Act, whenever a urban land owner fails to surrender possession as demanded under section 11(5) of the Act, then the competent authority may take possession of the land and may, for that purpose use such force as may be necessary. Therefore, from the above two aspects, namely, the urban land owner was directed to surrender possession and since he is not shown to have surrendered possession and the power of the Government to use such force as may be necessary in taking possession, clearly indicate that the physical possession of the land must be taken by the competent authority. There is nothing on record to show that ‘on what day possession was taken; was any representative of the writ petitioner present; the name of the person who took possession; the person from whom possession was taken; are there any contemporary record to show that possession was in fact taken at such a time and on such a date, when possession was handed over to the Revenue Inspector, Pallikaranai; are there any record to show such handing over to Revenue Inspector, Pallikaranai and the name of the officer, who received the possession of the land……
In 2002 (2) L.W 764 (C.V Narasimhan v. The Government of Tamil Nadu, etc. and 2 others), while considering the impact of the repealing Act, had held that where physical possession of such land continues to be with the owner, the statutory vesting under section 11(3) of the Act is of no relevance at all.”
9. On the factual situation, in the present case, as I have enumerated above, even though steps have been taken under section 11(4) and 11(5) of the Principal Act, nevertheless it remains the fact that on record there is nothing to show that physical possession has been taken from either of the petitioners or from their vendor in conformity with section 11(6) of the Principal Act. R. Jayasimha Babu, J. in Allind Metal Fabricators Pvt. Ltd., Madras v. The Secretary to Government, Revenue Department, Government of Tamil Nadu, Madras, reported in 2002 (2) CTC 716, by placing reliance on the judgement of the Supreme Court in Smt. Angoori Devi v. State of U.P & Ors. (JT 2000 (Suppl.1) SC 295), has also held that if the possession under the Principal Act prior to the repeal was not taken, as per the judgement of the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court, no proceedings can be subsequently initiated.
10. On the other hand, the petitioners have categorically stated that they are in physical possession of the properties and have also produced various certificates including urban land tax receipts, certificates issued by the village karnam, patta issued by the Tahsildar dated 23.12.1999, etc. to show that the petitioners continue to be in physical possession of the properties in dispute. In view of the same, the writ petition stands allowed. No costs.
VCJ/VCS
Alert