- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Geetha And Others Petitioners v. Arunakumari
Factual and Procedural Background
This Criminal Revision Case was filed by the accused challenging an order of the Principal Sessions Judge, Chennai that transferred C.C. No. 6063 of 2003 from the file of the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai to the file of the Mahila Court, Chennai. The petitioner contended that after the Government established Mahila Courts and a Sessions Judge was posted as head of such a Mahila Court, the powers of a Metropolitan Magistrate (or Judicial Magistrate of First Class) could not be conferred on that Mahila Court or on the Sessions Judge by the High Court unless the State Government had first issued a specific notification establishing the posts of Metropolitan Magistrate or Judicial Magistrate of First Class. The learned Single Judge considered the legal question to be one of importance involving jurisdiction and constitution of courts and placed the matter before a Division Bench.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court had jurisdiction to appoint Smt. S. Vimala to be the Metropolitan Magistrate in the metropolitan area of Chennai in the absence of a notification by the State Government establishing the post of Metropolitan Magistrate.
- Whether the High Court validly conferred the powers of a Judicial Magistrate of the First Class on Smt. S. Kalavathy (a Sessions Judge posted as head of the Mahila Court at Coimbatore) by exercising power under Section 11(2) or Section 11(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
- Whether the transfer of the case to the Mahila Court (in the capacity of a Metropolitan Magistrate or Judicial Magistrate of First Class) was appropriate, and if not, whether such transfer should be quashed.
- Whether judgments and orders already pronounced by the Mahila Courts while exercising functions as Judicial Magistrate of First Class or Metropolitan Magistrate are ipso facto illegal because of defects in posting or constitution of the courts.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The High Court lacked jurisdiction to appoint Smt. S. Vimala as a Metropolitan Magistrate for Chennai because the State Government had not issued a notification creating the post of Metropolitan Magistrate (or establishing Courts of Metropolitan Magistrates) as required by Section 16(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
- The High Court's notification purporting to confer the powers of a Judicial Magistrate of the First Class on Smt. S. Kalavathy (who had been posted as a Sessions Judge heading a Mahila Court at Coimbatore) was legally questionable because the State Government had not established a Court of Judicial Magistrate of the First Class by notification as required by Section 11(1)/(2), and Section 11(3) (which permits conferment on a member of the Judicial Service functioning as a judge in a civil court) did not apply to a Sessions Judge posted as head of a Mahila Court.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any arguments advanced on behalf of the State or other respondents in opposition; only the petitioner's contentions are specifically described.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Vidyadharan v. State of Kerala, 2004 SCC (Cri) 260 | Observed (after noticing other decisions) that unless positively and specifically provided otherwise, no Court of Session can take cognizance of an offence directly without the case being committed to it by a Magistrate. | The court relied on this authority to reinforce the principle that a Court of Session cannot directly take cognizance of offences triable by a Magistrate and to support the conclusion that transferring a matter to a Sessions Judge acting as a Magistrate (without committal) was inappropriate. |
| A.R. Antulay v. Ramdas Sriniwas v. Ramdas Srinivwas Nayak, 1994 SCC (Cri) 277 | Noted by the Supreme Court in Vidyadharan; referenced in the context of authorities considered on the question of Sessions Court taking cognizance without committal. | Identified as one of the decisions noticed in Vidyadharan which collectively support the principle that a Court of Sessions ordinarily cannot take cognizance without committal by a Magistrate; used as part of the jurisprudential background for the court's analysis. |
| Directorate of Enforcement v. Deepak Mahajan, 1994 SCC (Cri) 785 | Noted by the Supreme Court in Vidyadharan as part of the body of decisions addressing limits on direct cognizance by Sessions Courts. | Referred to through Vidyadharan to justify the court's conclusion on the necessity of magistrate committal before Sessions Courts take cognizance. |
| Gangula Ashok v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 2000 SCC (Cri) 488 | Noted by the Supreme Court in Vidyadharan and cited among authorities relevant to the principle that Sessions Courts cannot ordinarily take original cognizance without committal by a Magistrate. | Used, via Vidyadharan, to support the court's view that the transfer to a Sessions Judge functioning as a Magistrate was legally impermissible without proper committal. |
| Gokaraju Rangaraju v. State of Andhra Pradesh, AIR 1981 SC 1473; 1981 (3) SCC 132 | Recognised the de facto doctrine: judgments rendered by a person acting in an official capacity cannot be treated as ipso facto illegal solely because of defects in the appointment or posting of that person. | The court applied the de facto doctrine from this decision to hold that judgments/orders already pronounced by Mahila Courts exercising functions as Judicial Magistrates of First Class or Metropolitan Magistrates are not automatically illegal; each such judgment must be decided on its own merits in accordance with law. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in a sequence tied closely to the statutory scheme in the Code of Criminal Procedure and to the factual posture of the administrative notifications:
- The court examined the State Government's administrative action (Ms. No. 556 dated 28-6-2002) that sanctioned constitution of two Mahila Courts (Magalir Neethimandram) to be headed by District and Sessions Judges at Chennai and Coimbatore, and the High Court's Notification No. 95 of 2002 (16-7-2002) which appointed Sessions Judges to head those courts and on its face purported to confer on them the powers of Judicial Magistrate of First Class (in Coimbatore) and Metropolitan Magistrate (in Chennai) under provisions of the CrPC.
- The court analysed Section 11 of the CrPC (Courts of Judicial Magistrates). It noted that Section 11(1) vests the power to establish Courts of Judicial Magistrates of the First and Second Class with the State Government (after consultation with the High Court) and that under Section 11(2) the High Court appoints the presiding officer only after such establishment by the State Government. Accordingly, the High Court's exercise of power under Section 11(2) in respect of a post that the State Government had not established was inappropriate.
- The court considered Section 11(3), which allows the High Court to confer the powers of a Judicial Magistrate of the First Class on a member of the Judicial Service functioning as a judge in a civil court. The court concluded that this provision could not be invoked in the present situation because Smt. S. Kalavathy was a Sessions Judge (not functioning as a judge in a civil court) and hence Section 11(3) did not apply.
- Turning to Section 16 of the CrPC (Courts of Metropolitan Magistrates), the court observed that Section 16(1) requires the State Government (after consultation with the High Court) to establish Courts of Metropolitan Magistrates; Section 16(2) provides that presiding officers shall be appointed by the High Court. The court concluded that the High Court could not validly appoint a Metropolitan Magistrate to a non-existent post (i.e., where the State Government had not issued the required notification establishing the Court of Metropolitan Magistrate).
- The court noted that Section 16 lacks any provision analogous to Section 11(3) (i.e., no provision permitting the High Court to confer metropolitan magisterial powers on a judge functioning in a civil court), and therefore the High Court's notification purporting to appoint Smt. S. Vimala as a Metropolitan Magistrate appeared illegal.
- On the jurisdictional consequence of transferring a case to a Sessions Judge acting as a Magistrate, the court invoked the rule, as stated in Vidyadharan (and the authorities there noticed), that unless specifically provided otherwise, a Court of Sessions cannot take cognizance directly without committal by a Magistrate. The court held that the transfer in question could not be treated as a committal and that the alleged offence was triable by a Magistrate and not exclusively by a Court of Sessions. Thus, transfer was inappropriate.
- Addressing the impact on past proceedings, the court applied the de facto doctrine (from Gokaraju Rangaraju) to hold that prior judgments/orders pronounced by Mahila Courts while exercising magisterial functions are not ipso facto illegal solely because of defects in posting; those judgments must be considered on their own merits in accordance with law.
- Finally, having found the High Court notifications legally infirm in the specific respects identified, the court concluded that the transfer order should be quashed and made recommendations to remedy the procedural/administrative defects (i.e., communication to the Government to formally establish the necessary magistrate posts so that the High Court can validly post Sessions Judges as Magistrates where appropriate, or alternatively to create separate Judicial Magistrate of First Class and Metropolitan Magistrate posts to handle non-sessions matters).
Holding and Implications
Holding: Criminal Revision Allowed; the transfer order to the Mahila Court in its capacity as a Metropolitan Magistrate/Judicial Magistrate of First Class is quashed.
Immediate consequences for the parties:
- The specific transfer of C.C. No. 6063 of 2003 to the Mahila Court (as a Metropolitan Magistrate) was declared inappropriate and quashed. The matter shall not be dealt with by the regular Metropolitan Magistrate (in the capacity arising from the invalid notification).
- Orders and judgments already pronounced by Mahila Courts while exercising the functions of Judicial Magistrate of First Class or Metropolitan Magistrate are not automatically void; under the de facto doctrine they must be assessed on their individual merits and in accordance with law.
Recommendations and broader implications:
- The court recommended that appropriate communication be sent to the State Government to formally establish Courts of Judicial Magistrate of First Class and Courts of Metropolitan Magistrates in those places where Sessions Judges are designated to head Mahila Courts. Once such establishment is effected by the State Government, the High Court could validly post Sessions Judges in charge of Mahila Courts with magisterial powers.
- The court suggested consideration of creating separate Judicial Magistrate of First Class and Metropolitan Magistrate posts (or designating Additional Mahila Courts at the magistrate level) so that matters triable exclusively by a Court of Sessions are committed to the Sessions Judge holding the Mahila Court post while other cases are dealt with by magistrates, thereby preserving appropriate appellate routes and avoiding procedural complications.
The opinion does not purport to create a new legal principle but applies existing statutory rules and established doctrines (including the de facto doctrine and Supreme Court authority on committal and cognizance) to the facts at hand; its direct effect is to quash the specific transfer order and to direct remedial administrative steps.
JUDGMENT
P.K Misra, J.
1. This Criminal Revision Case has been filed by the accused person against the order passed by the Principal Sessions Judge, Chennai in transferring the case C.C No. 6063 of 2003 on the file of the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai to the file of Mahila Court, Chennai.
2. While considering the matter, a contention has been raised before the learned Single Judge to the effect that a Sessions Judge was posted as Mahila Court after such Mahila Court was established by the Government. However, the power of a Metropolitan Magistrate could not have been conferred on such Mahila Court or the Sessions Judge without a specific Notification by the State Government establishing such Court of Metropolitan Magistrate and, therefore, the proceedings pending before Addl. Chief Metropolitan Magistrate should not have been transferred to such Mahila Court.
3. Since such question raised a question of law of importance and also relating to jurisdiction and constitution of Court, learned Single Judge thought it appropriate to place the matter before a Division Bench and that is how the matter is now placed before the Division Bench.
4. The State Government had issued Ms. No. 556 dated 28-6-2002 sanctioning the Constitution of two Magalir Neethimandram (Mahila Courts), one at Chennai and the other at Coimbatore to be headed by District and Sessions Judges for speedy trial and disposal of cases of offences committed against women and also cases under other social laws enacted by the Central and State Government for the protection of women. Thereafter, the High Court issued Notification No. 95 of 2002 dated 16-7-2002, which is extracted in extenso:
“In exercise of the powers conferred under Section 9(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Central Act 2 of 1974) the High Court hereby appoints the Judicial Officers mentioned in Column (1) below to be the Sessions Judges to preside over the Court of Sessions in the Sessions Division and Head Quarters noted against their names in Column (2) below with effect from the date on which they took charge:
1 Tmt. S. Vimala to be the Sessions Judge in the Sessions Division comprising the Metropolitan Area of Chennai 2 Tmt. S. Kalavathy to be the Sessions Judge in Coimbatore Sessions Division with Head Quarters at Coimbatore
In exercise of the powers conferred under Section 11(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Central Act 2 of 1974), the High Court, Madras, hereby confers on Tmt. S. Kalavathy the powers of Judicial Magistrate of First Class in the Coimabtore District with Head Quarters at Coimbatore with effect from the date on which she took charge. She shall exercise all the powers of Judicial Magistrate First Class under the said Code.
In exercise of the powers conferred under Section 16(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Central Act 2 of 1974), the High Court, Madras, hereby appoints Tmt. S. Vimala, to be the Metropolitan Magistrate in the Metropolitan area of Chennai from the date on which she took charge. She shall exercise all the powers of the Metropolitan Magistrate under the said Code.”
5. In the present case, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that the High Court had no jurisdiction to appoint Smt. S. Vimala to be the Metropolitan Magistrate in the Metropolitan area of Chennai in the absence of creation of such a post by the State Government. Incidentally the learned counsel has also questioned the wisdom and legality of the Notification of the High Court conferring the power of Judicial Magistrate of the First Class on Smt. S. Kalavathy, who as a Sessions Judge was appointed as Mahila Court for Coimbatore District.
6. The Notification issued by the High Court has already been extracted in extenso. The second sub-paragraph of such notification relates to conferment of power of Judicial Magistrate of the First Class on the Sessions Judge, who had been appointed as the Mahila Court for Coimbatore district. The Notification specifically refer to Section 11(2) of the Code of Criminal procedure. Section 11 is extracted in extenso.
“11. Courts of Judicial Magistrates.— (1) In every district (not being a metropolitan area), there shall be established as many Courts of Judicial Magistrates of the First Class and of the Second Class, and at such places, as the State Government may, after consultation with the High Court, by notification, specify:
Provided that the State Government may, after consultation with the High Court, establish, for any local area, one or more Special Courts of Judicial Magistrates of the first class or of the second class to try any particular case or particular class of cases, and where any such Special Court is established, no other Court of Magistrate in the local area shall have jurisdiction to try any case or class of cases for the trial of which such Special Court of Judicial Magistrate has been established.”
7. A perusal of the aforesaid Section clearly indicates that the power to establish a Court of Judicial Magistrate of First Class and of the Second Class is vested with the State Government and the State Government is required to exercise such power after consultation with the High Court. Once such Court of Judicial Magistrate is established by the State Government by Notification, under Section 11(2) the Presiding Officer of such Court is to be appointed by the High Court.
8. The Notification issued by the State Government clearly indicates that Mahila Court is constituted to be headed by District and Sessions Judge. The Notification issued by the State Government does not purport to establish any Court of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class. The power of the High Court to appoint Presiding Officer of such Court of Judicial Magistrate of the First Class under sub-section (2) of Section 11 can be exercised only when there is establishment of Judicial Magistrate of the First Class by the State Government. Therefore, apparently the notification issued by the High Court purporting to exercise power under Section 11(2) appears to be inappropriate. However, Section 11(3) of the Code empowers the High Court, whenever it appears to it to be expedient or necessary to confer the powers of a Judicial Magistrate of the First Class on any member of the Judicial Service functioning as a Judge in a Civil Court. Even the power under Section 11(3) could not have been exercised because, in the present case, Smt. S. Kalavathy has been posted to be the Sessions Judge in Coimbatore Sessions Division with Head Quarters at Coimbatore. Section 11(3) specifically contemplates the conferment of powers of Judicial Magistrate of First Class on any member of the Judicial Service functioning as a Judge in a Civil Court. It cannot be said that Smt. S. Kalavathy, who was posted as a Sessions Judge, was functioning a Judge in a Civil Court. Therefore, such Notification appears to be inappropriate.
9. Next comes the question relating to appointment of Smt. S. Vimala, to be the Sessions Judge in the Sessions Division in the Metropolitan area of Chennai. Notification is in apparent exercise of power under Section 16(2). The entire Section 16 of the Code is extracted hereunder:
“16. Courts of Metropolitan Magistrates.— (1) In every metropolitan area, there shall be established as many Courts of Metropolitan Magistrates, and at such places, as the State Government may, after consultation with the High Court, by Notification, specify.
(2) The presiding officers of such Courts shall be appointed by the High Court.
(3) The jurisdiction and powers of every Metropolitan Magistrate shall extend through the metropolitan area.”
10. Section 16(1) is similar to Section 11(1). In other words, it is the State Government, which can establish a Court of Metropolitan Magistrate after consultation with the High Court. In the present case, there is no dispute that even though a Mahila Court was established, no notification has been issued by the State Government establishing a Court of Metropolitan Magistrate. Under Section 16(2), the Presiding Officer of such Court shall be appointed by the High Court which is also in pari-materia with Section 11(2). In the present case, the High Court has purported to exercise power under Section 16(2) in appointing Smt. S. Vimala as the Metropolitan Magistrate, apparently against a non-existent post. It is also to be noticed that Section 16 does not contain the provision similar to Section 11(3). Moreover, even assuming that such a power was there, as already noticed, Smt. S. Vimala was appointed as a Sessions Judge in Mahila Court. The notification issued by the High Court, therefore, appears to be illegal.
11. In view of the above conclusion in the matter, it is obvious that the case, which was transferred to Mahila Court in the capacity of such a Court as Metropolitan Magistrate, was inappropriate and liable to be quashed.
12. In this context one is also required to consider the fact that in view of the provisions contained in Section 193, any Court of Sessions shall take cognizance of any offence as a Court of original jurisdiction unless the case has been committed to it by a Magistrate under the Code of Criminal Procedure. By no stretch of imagination the transfer effected can be considered to be a committal of a case. Moreover, even the alleged offence was not triable by a Court of Sessions, but triable by a Court of Magistrate. In this context, the Supreme Court in Vidyadharan v. State Of Kerala, 2004 SCC (Cri) 260, after noticing the decisions reported in A.R Antulay v. Ramdas Sriniwas v. Ramdas Srinivwas Nayak, 1994 SCC (Cri) 277; Directorate of Enforcement v. Deepak Mahajan, 1994 SCC (Cri) 785; and Gangula Ashok v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 2000 SCC (Cri) 488, observed that unless it is positively and specifically provided differently, no Court of Session can take cognizance of any offence directly, without the case being committed to it by a Magistrate.
13. A question may arise that in the meantime such Mahila Court at Coimbatore and Chennai and may be in other places must have dealt with the matters on the basis of transfer of cases to such Mahila Court in their capacity as Judicial Magistrate of First Class or Metropolitan Magistrate. A question may also arise whether the orders/judgments pronounced by those Courts in the capacity of Judicial Magistrate of First Class or Metropolitan Magistrate are ipso facto illegal.
14. In view of the de facto doctrine, which has been recognised by the Supreme Court in the decision reported in Gokaraju Rangaraju v. State of Andhra Pradesh, AIR 1981 SC 1473: 1981 (3) SCC 132, such judgments cannot be considered as illegal merely because of the defect in posting of Judicial Officers and the question of legality or otherwise of those judgments already rendered by such Mahila Courts exercising the function as Judicial Magistrate of the First Class or Metropolitan Magistrate are required to be decided on their own merit in accordance with law.
15. In view of the above conclusion, the transfer order is required to be quashed. The matter shall not be dealt with by the regular Metropolitan Magistrate.
16. In order to overcome the technical defects, which have been accepted by us, we recommend that appropriate communication may be sent to the Government to formally establish a Court of Judicial Magistrate of First Class and Metropolitan Magistrate in the places where Sessions Judges are being designated as Mahila Courts. Once such a course is adopted, there would not be any legal hurdle for the High Court to post a Sessions Judge in charge of Mahila Court as Magistrate.
17. In this context, the other contention raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner is to the effect that if a Sessions Judge is designated as a Judicial Magistrate of First Class or Metropolitan Magistrate to decide a matter triable by a Magistrate and not exclusively triable by a Court of Sessions, the accused person would lose a chance of filing Appeal before the regular Appellate Court and thereafter filing a Revision.
18. Technically speaking, if a Sessions Judge is also posted as a Magistrate, the Appeal may be filed before the regular Court i.e, it would come before another Sessions Judge. We do not think adoption of such a course be practicable nor it would be judicious. It is therefore suggested that apart from posting a Sessions Judge as a Mahila Court, possibility of creating a separate Court of Judicial Magistrate of First Class and Metropolitan Magistrate can be considered and Judicial Officers at the level of Judicial Magistrate of First Class or Metropolitan Magistrate can be suitably posted. In other words, only cases exclusively triable by a Court of Sessions would be committed to the Sessions Judge holding the post of Mahila Court and other cases can be posted before the Judicial Magistrate of First Class or Metropolitan Magistrate which can be designated as Additional Mahila Court.
19. Subject to the above observations and recommendations, the Criminal Revision is allowed.
Alert