Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

S. Raghuraman, Clerk v. Union Of India (Uoi)...

Madras High Court
Oct 1, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Sri S. Raghuraman (Emp. No. 806354), originally appointed on 13.3.1989 and promoted as Station Master Gr.II w.e.f. 9.11.1991 (scale Rs. 1400-2300, revised Rs. 5000-8000), was declared medically unfit for the safety category of Station Master on 03.02.1997. Following a suitability test, he was offered an alternative post as Head Train Clerk on 04.07.1997, which he declined, and later sought appointment as Head Clerk/Sr. Clerk/Clerk either in the Divn./HQ/ICF. The petitioner underwent a suitability test for Office Clerk on 18.09.1997, was directed to report to CPO/ICF on 19.09.1997, and joined ICF as Office Clerk the same day.

The petitioner sought fitment to the scale Rs. 5000-8000 as Head Clerk with retrospective seniority from 9.11.1991 and filed writ petitions challenging orders denying such fitment: - O.A. Nos. and inter se chronology: O.A. 534/98 in CAT Madras (filed after ICF refused his request), R4 Tribunal directed consideration under para 1304 IREM (18.4.2000), R2 responded refusing the request (7.6.2000), contempt petition dismissed (10.10.2000), O.A. No. 1441/2000 was filed (20.12.2000) and dismissed by CAT on 22.11.2001. Aggrieved, the petitioner filed the present writ petition.

The central factual dispute is whether the petitioner — medically decategorised and absorbed in ICF as Clerk Gr.II — is entitled to protection of his service conditions (including pay scale and seniority) under Section 47 of the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995 (the "Disabilities Act") and relevant provisions of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual (IREM) and the Absorption of Medically Incapacitated Staff in Alternative Employment Rules.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Railway employee who has been medically decategorised and absorbed in an alternative post in another railway establishment (Integral Coach Factory) is entitled to protection of his service conditions (including pay scale and seniority) under Section 47 of the Disabilities Act and the relevant provisions of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual and the Absorption rules (Paras 1301–1310 and Paras 312–313 of IREM).
  2. Whether the absorption of such medically incapacitated staff into another railway establishment can be treated as a transfer "on request" (with consequences such as bottom ranking in seniority), or whether it must be treated under the special rules applicable to medical decategorisation that aim to protect pay and service benefits.
  3. Whether the fact that Southern Railway and Integral Coach Factory are administratively distinct units within the Ministry of Railways prevents application of the protections in Section 47 and the relevant IREM provisions across these units.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner (through learned counsel) contended he is entitled to protection under Section 47 of the Disabilities Act and the relevant provisions of IREM (Paras 312, 313 and Chapter XIII paras 1301–1310), and cannot be treated as seeking a transfer on request or a one-way transfer.
  • He asserted a statutory right to be fitted in alternative employment without loss of pay and, if necessary, a supernumerary post must be created (relying on Section 47 and the IREM provisions extracted in the opinion).
  • The petitioner emphasized that he repeatedly requested placement in a clerical post (Head Clerk/Sr. Clerk/Clerk) and that writing the word "Clerk" did not amount to waiving his entitlement to pay protection under the Act and rules.
  • The petitioner relied on precedent(s) (including a judgment in The Management of Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation v. B. Gnanasekaran) to support his case (as noted in the opinion).

Integral Coach Factory / Respondent's Arguments

  • Learned Senior Counsel for ICF contended that the petitioner was informed early that he could return to Southern Railway and that ICF did not have a post commensurate with his former position; the petitioner chose to come to ICF and accepted the terms subject to which the transfer was ordered.
  • ICF argued that fitting the petitioner into ICF in the higher grade would disrupt internal seniority in ICF.
  • ICF submitted that the petitioner ought to have impleaded Southern Railway for a binding adjudication regarding his transfer and posting.

Southern Railway (as argued / described)

  • It was repeatedly urged on behalf of the respondent side that Southern Railway and ICF are different organizations under the Ministry of Railways and the petitioner should have impleaded Southern Railway because the transfer originated from Southern Railway.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Comptroller & Auditor General of India v. Farid Sattar, 2000 (4) SCC 13 Principle: In that case the Supreme Court rejected a claim for protection of pay where the workman had applied for universal transfer after seeking reversion to a lower post as a direct recruit; the Court treated the circumstances as disentitling him to pay protection. The opinion notes this case was cited on behalf of the respondent but observes that the factual basis of that decision does not apply to the present case.
Kunal Singh v. Union of India, 2003 (4) SCC 524 Principle: Interprets Section 47 of the Disabilities Act as casting a mandatory obligation on employers not to dispense with or reduce in rank an employee who acquires disability during service; treats the Indian Railways as an establishment for purposes of the Act in protecting disabled employees. The Court relied on and quoted this decision to emphasize the mandatory nature of Section 47 and to support the proposition that Indian Railways must be treated as an establishment obliged to protect the disabled employee's rank and service benefits.
State v. K. Mohammed Mustafa, 2007 WLR 256 Principle: The benefit under Section 47 of the Disabilities Act can be considered in addition to other beneficial provisions; if either the G.O. or the Act is more beneficial, the more beneficial provision can be applied. The opinion cites this authority to support the view that Section 47's protections may be applied in addition to other beneficial provisions and that beneficial provisions should be applied to advance the Act's object.
Tamil Nadu State Transport Corpn. v. R. Jayakumar, Writ Appeal No. 610 of 2007 Principle: Section 47 of the Disabilities Act imposes a mandatory duty on the employer to provide alternative employment to an employee who suffered disability during employment; receipt of compensation under other statutes does not preclude entitlement to alternative employment under the Act. The Court relied on this decision to underline that Section 47 imposes a mandatory duty and that other forms of compensation are not a ground to deny the statutory protection of alternative employment.
A. Veeriya Perumal v. Secretary to Government, Health & Family Welfare Dept., Chennai, 2006 (4) MLJ 335 Principle: Sub-section (1) of Section 47 is clear that no establishment shall dispense with or reduce in rank an employee who acquires disability during service; the right to livelihood and protection under Section 47 entitles continuance in suitable alternative post with same scale of pay and other service benefits. The opinion cites this Division Bench decision to support the proposition that Section 47 protects continuance of service in a suitable alternative post with the same pay scale and service benefits.
The Management of Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation (Villupuram Division-III) Ltd., Kancheepuram v. B. Gnanasekaran, Writ Appeal No. 860 of 2007 Principle: (As cited by the petitioner) the opinion does not extract the specific rule from this judgment in the text provided, only that it was relied upon by the petitioner. The opinion records that the petitioner relied upon this judgment but does not state in the provided text the specific application the Court made of its principle beyond mentioning it was relied on.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds from the statutory and regulatory framework extracted in the opinion: Section 47 of the Disabilities Act; Paras 312 and 313 of the Indian Railway Establishment Manual (IREM); and Chapter XIII (Paras 1301–1310) of the Absorption Rules for medically incapacitated staff. The court emphasizes the distinctions the rules themselves draw between transfers on request (Para 312) and absorption on account of medical decategorisation (Para 313 and Chapter XIII). Key steps in the court's reasoning are:

  1. Identification of the legal framework: The court set out Section 47 and the IREM provisions dealing specifically with medically decategorised staff and the duties on railway administrations to find alternative employment, protect pay as far as possible, create supernumerary posts until a permanent post is found, and to ensure that the interests of staff in service are not adversely affected.
  2. Distinguishing transfer on request from medical absorption: The court held that transfers on request (paragraph 312) and transfers arising from medical decategorisation (paragraph 313 and Chapter XIII) are different in character; the latter confer rights on the employee which are not equivalent to a voluntary transfer on request (including consequences such as bottom-ranking in seniority).
  3. Assessment of the facts against the rules: The petitioner was medically decategorised at a relatively young age (36). The IREM provisions emphasize that alternative employment must be found, that the name of such employees should be circulated across establishments if necessary, and that absorption should aim to minimize loss in emoluments. The court noted the petitioner's repeated requests for clerical accommodation and that he had been directed to report to ICF following his suitability test.
  4. Rejection of the administrative characterization of the transfer as a routine "one-way" inter-railway transfer: The court examined the ICF office order imposing conditions (e.g., ranking junior to all Clerks Gr.II, no representation for fixation of seniority in higher grade, and no retransfer to Southern Railway) and found them inconsistent with the rights conferred by Section 47 and the IREM provisions applicable to medically decategorised staff.
  5. Treatment of organisational distinctions: Although Southern Railway and ICF are administratively distinct (different General Managers and listings in the Manual of Office Procedure), the court relied on Kunal Singh to hold that for the purposes of giving effect to Section 47 and Para 1306(3) of IREM the Indian Railways should be treated as an "Establishment" obliged to protect the rights of a disabled employee. Thus, administrative separateness of units does not defeat the statutory protections.
  6. Reliance on precedents: The court cited authorities (Kunal Singh; State v. K. Mohammed Mustafa; Tamil Nadu State Transport Corpn. v. R. Jayakumar; A. Veeriya Perumal) to support the mandatory and protective scope of Section 47 and to show that the Act's protections should be preferred where they advance the objectives of the legislation.
  7. Conclusion of entitlement: On this basis the court concluded that the petitioner's claim for protection under Section 47 and the IREM provisions is meritorious and that the case should be treated as a special case of medical decategorisation rather than as an ordinary inter-railway transfer on request.

The reasoning in the opinion is constrained to the legal materials and factual record extracted in the judgment; the court repeatedly underscores that the IREM and Section 47 require that a medically incapacitated employee be accommodated so as to minimize loss of pay and service benefits and, where needed, be placed on a supernumerary post until a suitable permanent post is found.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Writ Petition was allowed. The court expressly agreed with the view of Justice Dharmarao Elipe that the petitioner is entitled to the protections under Section 47 of the Disabilities Act and the relevant IREM provisions.

DISPOSITION: The Writ Petition is allowed.

Implications and consequences:

  • The direct effect is that the petitioner is entitled to the protections afforded by Section 47 of the Disabilities Act and by the IREM provisions governing absorption of medically incapacitated staff. The petitioner’s situation must be treated as a special case of medical decategorisation, not as a routine inter-railway transfer on request.
  • The court left it open for Integral Coach Factory and Southern Railway to arrive at a satisfactory solution regarding the petitioner's fitment and seniority in a manner consistent with the Act and the Manual. The opinion urges both wings of the Ministry of Railways to consider the case in the spirit of the Act and the purpose of the relevant IREM paragraphs.
  • The opinion applies existing precedents and statutory/regulatory provisions to reinforce that an employee who acquires disability during service is entitled to protective measures (including, where appropriate, supernumerary posts and pay protection) and that administrative separateness of railway units does not defeat those protections for purposes of the Act and the IREM provisions cited.
  • The opinion does not expressly state that it creates a new binding precedent beyond its application to the present facts; it applies established authorities and the statutory/regulatory framework to reach the decision in this case.
Show all summary ...

1. In view of the difference in the decision between Dharmarao Elipe, J. and K. Suguna, J. with regard to the right of the petitioner protection of his service conditions in terms of the Disabilities Act this matter has been placed before me.

2. The dispute is with regard to the question whether a Railway employee who has been medically decategorised and has been given alternative employment in Integral Coach Factory is entitled to such protection. K. Suguna, J. found that his claim was without merit, whereas, Dharmarao Elipe, J. allowed the claim.

3. The chronological dates and events are as follows:

W.P No. 40730 … Sri. S. Raghuraman, now working as of 2002 Clerk Gr.II in ICF is the petitioner.

Prayer in W.P … W.P is filed to quash the order dated 22.11.2001 passed by CAT/MAS in O.A 1441/2000, rejecting Petitioner's claim for fitment of his scale of pay in Rs. 5000-8000 as Head Clerk from 19.9.1997 and to reckon his seniority with effect from 9.11.1991, i.e the date on which he was promoted as Station Master in scale Rs. 1,400-2300 (Revised as Rs. 5000 - 8000 with effect from 1.1.1996).

w.e.f 9.11.1991 … Petitioner was promoted as Station Master Gr.II in scale Rs. 1400 - 2300 (Revised as 5000 - 8000) and posted at Jolarpettai and later on transferred to Athipattu.

13.3.1989 … Petitioner was initially appointed as Asst. Station Master in Scale Rs. 1200 - 2040 (Revised as Rs. 4500 - 7000).

03.02.1997 … Petitioner was declared medically unfit to continue in the safety category of Station Master.

02.06.1997 … Suitability Test. Orders Passed.

04.7.1997 … Petitioner was offered alternaste post of Head Train Clerk in the same scale of pay of Rs. 1400-2300(RP Rs. 5000 - 8000).

17.7.1997 … Petitiner representation declining (Page 2) to accept the alternate employment as Head Train Clerk.

04.08.1997 … Further representation requesting to (Page 3A) appoint him as Head Clerk/Sr.Clerk/Clerk either in MAS Divn./HQ/ICF(equivalent)

08.08.1997 … DRM/MAS wrote to CPO/MAS informing (Page4) Applicant's request to post him as Office Clerk either in Dn.Or.HQ or ICF, and that there is no clerical vacancies, besides ban on copy was marked to CPO/ICF

13.08.1997 … CPO/ICF informed DRM/MAS that they have few in clerial cadre in scale Rs. 950-1500 and the medically decategorised employee can be absorbed as Clerk Gr.II in scale Rs. 950-1500. (RP Rs. 3050 - 4590).

… His suitability to the post of Clerk Gr.II should be assessed before directing to report duty to ICF.

17.08.1997 … DRM/MAS appointed DCM-I and DPO-I to form a committee.

15.09.1997 … CPO'S letter to DRM/MAS asking to take further action, pursuant to CPO/ICF letter dated 13.8.1997

17.09.1997 … Petitioner was asked to attend the suitability test at Sr.DPO's Office at 15.00 Hrs. on 18.9.1997

15.09.1997 … CPO's letter to DRM/MAS asking to take further action, pursuant to CPO/ICF letter dated 13.8.1997

17.09.1997 … Petitioner was asked to attend the suitability test at Sr.DPO's Office at 15.00 Hrs. on 18.9.1997

18.09.1997 … Suitability test conducted and found suitable for the post of Office Clerk.

19.9.1997 … DRM/MAS passed orders directing the petitioner to report to CPO/ICF.

19.9.1997 … Same day, petitioner reported to CPO/ICF and joined duty in ICF as Office Clerk.

27.09.1997 … Posting Order in ICF given with conditions.

29.11.1997 … Petitioner gave a representation requesting to post him as Head Clerk instead of clerk Gr.II

12.02.1998 …Petitioner's representation was forwarded to southern Railway.

30.03.1998 … Southern Railway replied that the transfer was at the request of the Petitioner and hence he could continue in ICF only

16.4.1998 … ICF informed the petitioner that his request is not agreed to. Petitioner filed O.A.534/98 in CAT/Madras, praying for a direction to post him in Grder Rs. 5000 -8000, w.e.f the date of absorption.

18.4.2000 … R4 Tribunal directed R1 & R2 to consider his claim and pass suitable orders in the light of para 1304 of IREM within 3 months.

07.06.2000 … R2 informed that Petitioner's request (page 4) to post him in the Grade of Rs. 5000 - 8000 is not agreed to.

… Petitioner filed Contempt Petition 61/2000 alleging that the order dated 7.6.2000 passed by R2 is not in compliance of the directions of the R4 Tribunal.

10.10.2000 … Contempt Petition was dismissed with an observation that the petitioner could challenge the order dated 7.6.2000, if so advised.

20.12.2000 … Thereafter, the petitioner filed O.A No. 1441/2000.

22.11.2001 … CAT dismissed O.A

… Aggrieved by this order, petitioner filed the present W.P

4. The relevant rules that apply to the petitioner are Section 47 of the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995 (Act 1 of 1996) (‘Disabilities Act’ in short), Paragraph Nos. 312 and 313 of the Railway Establishment Manual (Volume-I) and Paragraphs 1301 to 1310 under Chapter XIII of the Absorption of Medically Incapacitated Staff in Alternative Employment Rules. These are extracted hereunder:

Section 47. Non-discrimination in government employment.— (1) No establishment shall dispense with, or reduce in rank, an employee who acquires a disability during his service:

Provided that, if an employee, after acquiring disability is not suitable for the post he was holding, could be shifted to some other post with the same pay scale and service benefits:

Provided further that if it is not possible to adjust the employee against any post, he may be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is available or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier.

(2) No promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the ground of his disability:

Provided that the appropriate Government may, having regard to the type of work carried on in any establishment, by notification and subject to such conditions, if any, as may be specified in such notification, exempt any establishment from the provisions of this Section.

312. Transfer on Request:

The seniority of railway servants tranferred at their own request from one railway to another should be allotted below that of the existing confirmed, temporary and officiating railway servants in the relevant grade in the promotion group in the new establishment irrespective of the date of confirmation or length of officiating or temporary service of the transferred railway servants.

Note: (i) This applies also to cases of transfer on request from one cadre/division to another cadre/division on the same railway.

(Rly.Bd No. E(NG) I-85 SR 6/14 of 21.01.1986)

(ii) The expression “relevant grade” applies to grade where there is an element of direct recruitment. Transfers on request from Railway employees working in such grades may be accepted in such grades. No such transfers should be allowed in the intermediates grades in which all the posts are filled entirely by promotion of staff from the lower grade(s) and there is no element of direct recruitment.

(No. E(NG) I-69 SR 6/15, dated 24.06.1969) ACS-14)

313. Medically unfitted Railway Servants:

(a) (i) Medically decategorised staff may, as far as possible, be absorbed in such alternative posts which should broadly be in allied categories and where their background and experience in earlier posts could be utilised. For example, traffic running and operating staff need not necessarily be absorbed in the ticket checking cadre alone but they could also be absorbed in other commercial, station or yard categories.

(ii) The medically decategorised staff absorbed in alternative posts, whether in the same or other cadre, should be allowed seniority in the grade of absorption with reference to the length of service rendered in the equivalent or corresponding grade, irrespective of the rate of pay fixed in the grade of absorption under the extant rules. In the case of staff who are in grade higher than the grade of absorption at the time of medical decategorisation, total service in the equivalent and higher grade is to be taken into account:

Provided that if a medically decategorised employee happens to be absorbed in the cadre from which he was originally promoted, he will not be placed above his erstwhile seniors in the grade of absorption.

(iii) While absorbing the medically decategorised Running Staff in alternative posts, a percentage of basis pay representing the pay element in Running Allowance, as decided by the Government through administrative instructions from time to time, should be added to the minimum as well as maximum of the scale of pay for purposes of identifying ‘equivalent’ posts and their seniority should then be fixed in the equivalent absorbing posts.

(No. E(NG) II/77.RE-3-2 OF 2-9-77 and E(NG) I-80-SR-6/83 of 5.3.1981)

(b) Railway servants whose services were terminated either because of the maximum limit of all leave including extraordinary leave having been exceeded or the medical authorities could not recommend the grant of extraordinary leave in the case of tuberculosis, pleurisy and leprosy patients and are re-employed in railway service after being declared fit to work by the medical authority should take their seniority below all permanent railway servants on the date of their re- employment provided they were permanent before medical unfitness or would have been confirmed in the meantime. Railway servants who were officiating or temporary at the time of medical unfitness or would not have been confirmed in the meantime should be placed below the officiating or temporary employees as the case may be on the date of their re-employment.

(c) Seniority of medically unfitted staff mentioned in sub-para (a) above, on restoration to their original posts should be determined as under:

(i) Railway servants who properly Appeal within the time limit laid down for Appeals or whose Appeal is entertained in a reasonable period waiving the time limit and get declared fit, should not lose their seniority or their claim for consideration for promotion for which they were eligible in the original categoroy in which they were employed.

(ii) Seniority of railway servants who prefer delayed Appeals and are declared fit or who take treatment and consequently get declared fit, if they were formerly confirmed in the grades in which they were, would be affected to the extend of any persons who may have been confirmed before their re-absorption into the original category. If however, they were only officiating in the original category, then their seniority should be below the staff confirmed till then, but need not be affected vis-a-vis their original juniors who happen to be till officiating.

(d) In the case of staff coming to a new unit on own request by accepting bottom seniority and then getting medically decategorised, provision of sub-para (a)(ii) above will be applicable only to the extent of service in the new unit.

(No. E(NG)I-71 SR 6/39 dated 31.5.1977)

(e) In the case of staff who are not required to undergo periodical Medical examination but who of their own accord request for change of category on grounds of health, and are recommended change of occupation by the medical authority, their change will be treated as transfer on own request and dealt with as per para 312.

(No. E(NG)I - 76 SE 6/37, dated 18.09.1976)”

“CHAPTER XIII

Absorption of Medically Incapacitated Staff in Alternative Employment:

1301. A railway servant who fails in a vision test or otherwise becomes physically incapable of performing the duties of the post which he occupies should not be discharged forthwith but every endeavour should be made to find alternative employment for him as expeditiously as possible. Such employment must be of suitable nature and on reasonable emoluments having regard to the emoluments previously drawn by the railway servant.

1302. Classification of railway servants declared medically unfit — Railway servants declared medically unfit for further service are divisible into two groups:

(i) Those completely incapacitated for further service in any post on the railway, i.e, those who cannot be declared fit even in the “C” medical category;

(ii) Those incapcited for further service in the post they are holding but declared fit in a lower medical category and eligible for retention in service in posts corresponding to this lower medical category.

1303. Railway servant totally incapacitated for further service: (Not Applicable)

1304. Railway servants incapacitated for service in posts held by them —

(a) Permanent Railway Servants: (1) A permanent railway servant in group (ii) of Para 1302 above must also cease to perform the duties of the post, he was holding from the date he is declared medically unfit. Here again, no officer has the authority to permit him to perform his duties in hat post beyond that date. He should be granted leave as admissible to him, under the leave Rules by which he is governed, from that date he is incapacitated subject to the proviso that where the railway servant has not got six months leave to this credit, his leave shall be made upto six months by the grant of extraordinary leave. If an alternative employment cannot be found for such a person within the period of leave so granted his service should, be extended by grant of extraordinary leave, subject to the condition that the total amount of extraordinary leave to be granted to the railway servant does not exceed six months. It should be possible within the period of leave thus extended to find either a permanent or a temporary post for his absorption. If the railway servant is absorbed against a temporary post in a permanent cadre a supernumerary post may also be created and his lien counted against the post. It should, however, be noted that, —

(i) the actual creation of supernumerary post will follow the acceptance of offer of alternative post;

(ii) the supernumerary post should be abolished as soon as a permanent post is found for the railway servant concerned.

The purpose of granting extraordinary leave envisaged in this para is that in case the Railways administration is able to find a suitable alternative employment for a medically incapacitated employee, there should be no break in his service. Since the period of such extraordinary leave counts for the purpose of special contribution to P.F in the case of a railway servant governed by the state Railway Provident Fund Rules but not in the case of pensionable Railway servant the letter employee may not like to avail of the extraordinary leave but may instead prefer to quit service on pension, immediately on the expiry of his period of leave with allowances. In such case extraordinary leave need not be granted to a railway servant, if he so desires.

(2) In the matter of absorption of a medically incapacitated staff in alternative post, Railway administrations, should take care to ensure that the interest of staff in service are not adversely affected as far as possible. The alternative appointment should be offered only in posts which the staff can adequately fill.

(b) Temporary Railway Servants: A temporary Railway Servant in group (ii) of para 1302 above who becomes medically unfit for the post held by him on account of circumstances arising out of and in the course of his employment, the benefit admissible to permanent Railway servants as at (a) above should be given.

A temporary employee has become medically fit for the post held by him, on account of circumstances which did not arise out of and in the course of employment, the benefit of Rule 304 RI (of Fifth edition 1985) will not be admissible. While, therefore, it is strictly not obligatory to find alternative employment for such an employee, every effort would nevertheless, be made to find alternative employment. The employee concerned should be granted such leave as is due to him plus extraordinary have not exceeding three months; the total not exceeding six months. If no alternative employment be found in this period, the employee should be discharged from service.

1305. Alternative employment must be found in the case of permanent and temporary railway servants:

Medically decategorised staff may, as far as possible, be absorbed in such alternative posts which should broadly be in allied categories and where their background and experience in earlier posts could be utilised. There should be no difficulty in providing such alternative employment and no reversion of any officiating railway servant for the purpose of absorbing the disabled railway servant should be necessary. For this purpose attempts should be made to absorb the disabled railway servant not only within the District/Division or Department but in another District/Division or Department.

1306. Steps to be taken for finding alternative employment:

(1) With a view to determine the categories in which a medically incapacitated railway servant is suitable for absorption, a Committee should examine him. The committee may consist of two or three officers under whom the medically incapacitated railway servant was working, the railway servant's immediate officer being one of the members of the Committee. After the Committee has examined the railway servant and determined his suitability for certain categories of posts, the officer under whom the railway servant was working will proceed to take further action to find suitable alternative employment for him.

(2) The officer concerned will prepare a list of vacancies within his jurisdiction in the categories for which the medically incapacitated railway servant has been found suitable and a post with emoluments as near as possible to his earlier emoluments will be offered to him.

(3) It will be the responsibility primarily of the officer under whom the railway servant is directly serving to find suitable alternative employment for him. This will be done first by trying to find alternative employment for him. This will be done first by trying to find alternative employment in the officer's own District, sub-district, sub-division, office, workshop and c. and a register. Vide sub-paragraph (7) below will be maintained for this purpose.

(4) If there is no immediate prospect of employment in his own District, sub-district, sub-division, office and c. the name of the Railway servant with particulars as given in sub-paragraph (7) below, will be circulated to all other offices or establishments where suitable employment is likely to be found.

(5) The names of railway servants likely to be suitable for clerical appointments should be intimated to the Divisional Office as well as to the Headquarters Office.

(6) Nothing in the previous sub-paragraphs debars a railway servant from applying for a particular post for which he is likely to be deemed suitable and which is known to be vacant under any officer. Such an Application must be addressed through the immediate officer of the railway servant concerned and must contain full particulars of his service and must be forwarded to the officer to whom addressed or to the authority competent to make the appointment. The result of the application must be communicated to the railway servant.

(8) A medically incapacitated railway servant who is permanent will be appointed substantively to the alternative post subject to his suitability. His further chances of promotion thereafter will be in accordance with the normal channels of promotion, and he will not be entitled to consideration for out-of-turn promotions merely because of his absorption in the post as a consequence of medication incapacitation.

1307. Absorption in alternative employment to be circularised.

1308. Before any post is filled or a promotion is ordered, officers concerned will refer to their registers and satisfy themselves that no medically incapacitated servant who is suitable for the post is available. Such medically incapacitated railway servant under all circumstances be given preference over surplus retrenched or demoted railway servant and shorter service.

1309. Alternative employment to be suitable. —

(i) The alternative post to be offered to a railway servant should be the best available for which he is suited, to ensure that the loss in emoluments is a minimum….

(E(NG) ISO SR6/83 dt. 5.3.1981).

Note: Care should be taken by Railway administration to see that the interests of the staff in service are not affected adversely as far as possible and alternative appointment should be offered only in post which the staff can adequately fill. Their suitability for the alternative posts be judged by holding suitability test/interview as prescribed under the extent instructions….

(E(NG) II-73 RE 3/16 dt. 11.4.1975)

1310. Offer of alternative employment to be in writing. — The alternative employment must be offered in writing, stating the scale of pay and the rate of pay at which it is proposed to reabsorb him in service. On no account should the Railway servant be posted to an alternative appointment until he has accepted the post. A railway servant is at liberty to refuse an offer of alternative appointment and the leave granted to him will not be terminated pre-maturely merely because of his refusal. The Leave must run its course. He will continue to remain eligible for other alternative offers of appointment till his leave expires and efforts to find such appointments should, therefore, continue throughout the currency of his leave.”

These are the rules based on which the petitioner claims relief.

5. Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner is entitled to protection of his rights in terms of Section 47 of the Disabilities Act as well as the provisions of Indian Railway Establishment Manual which is extracted above and that he cannot be treated as a person seeking transfer on request or as a one way transfer case. The learned Counsel submitted that he has a statutory right to be fitted in an alternative employment without loss of pay and if necessary a super numerary post must be created.

6. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for ICF submitted that the petitioner was informed even at the earliest possible time that he could go back to the Southern Railway and that in ICF a post commensurate with the post he was holding Southern Railway was not available. In spite of that, he opted to come to ICF and he knew the terms subject to which is transfer was ordered. The learned Senior Counsel submitted that if the petitioner were to be fitted in ICF it would disrupt the seniority in ICF. The learned Senior Counsel also submitted that the petitioner ought to have impleaded the Southern Railway to get a binding adjudication.

7. On the side of the petitioner, the judgment in The Management of Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation (Villupuram Division-III) Ltd., Kancheepuram v. B. Gnanasekaran, Writ Appeal No. 860 of 2007, was relied on. Comptroller & Auditor General of India v. Farid Sattar, 2000 (4) SCC 13, is cited on behalf of the respondent. In the latter case, the claim for protection of pay was rejected on the ground that the workman had applied for universal transfer after seeking reversion to the lower post of Accountant as a direct recruit, which the respondent before the Supreme Court accepted and thereafter had prayed for protection of pay and it was rightly rejected by the Supreme Court. This does not apply to the present case.

8. It must be remembered that the petitioner herein was only aged 36 years when he was medically incapacitated. The relevant rules have been extracted. It is clear even from a reading of the paragraphs extracted from the Manual that the transfers on request and transfers on medical incapacitation are different. The former is dealt with under paragraph 312 and the latter is dealt with under paragraph 313 of Indian Railway Establishment Manual. The relevant clauses in Chapter XIII of the Absorption of Medically Incapacitated Staff in Alternative Employment Rules protect the rights of medically incapacitated staff. There is reference to supernumerary posts as provided in Section 47 of the Disabilities Act and the creation of supernumerary posts is only until a permanent post is found for the railway servant concerned, which is almost similar to the Proviso to Section 47 of the Act. Extraordinary leave is granted to such railway servants to ensure that there was no break in his service. It is also made clear that in the matter of absorption in an alternative post, the railway administration should take care that the interest of the staff is not adversely affected as far as possible. Paragraph 1305 declares in no uncertain terms that alternative employment must be found in the case of railway servants (emphasis supplied). The insistence that the railway servant shall not suffer any prejudice is seen from the fact that this paragraph requires the administration to absorb a disabled railway servant not only within the district division or department, but in another district, division or department. Paragraph 1306(2) shows the list of vacancies which is prepared for accommodation of the railway servant must contain posts with emoluments as near as possible to the earlier emoluments. Paragraph 1306(3) shows that this alternative employment should be first found in the officer's own district, sub-division, office, workshop, etc., but if it is not possible, then the administration shall circulate the name of the railway servant with particulars to all other offices or establishments where suitable employment is likely to be found. Paragraph 1306(8) shows that he is entitled to all normal channels of promotion. What he cannot claim is an out-of-turn promotion because of his absorption in the post as a consequence of medical incapacitation.

9. Much was stressed on the side of the respondent to show that Southern Railway and I.C.F are different organisations under the Ministry of Railways, and cannot be treated as one unit. Paragraph 56 of the Manual of Office Procedure shows that Southern Railway, Madras is listed under A(vi) and Integral Coach Factory, Madras is listed under A(xi). But, when their own Manual shows that they are bound to accommodate the medically unfit employee in any other district or establishment, the fact that I.F.C has a different General Manager and Southern Railway has a different General Manager is hardly significant. It is true that after his medical decategorisation, the petitioner was offered alternative employment as HTNC. He made a request that because of his vertigo and bronchitis, it will not be possible for him to discharge his duty satisfactorily since as a HTNC, he will have to maintain the relevant records, physically collecting the materials by moving in and around the coach yard (petitioner's letter dated 17.7.1994). Therefore, he requested that he should not be given work in the Open Line. He requested that he may be given a post of headclerk/senior clerk/clerk under the control of the Southern Railway in a headquarters or in I.C.F The fact that he had written the word ‘Clerk’ in his request does not mean that he was waiving his right to claim pay protection because that benefit is given to him under the relevant laws and rules. Not just once, but repeatedly, both the Manual and the categoric language of Section 47 of the Disabilities Act stress that the loss in pay suffered by the medically incapacitated person should be at a minimum. It is in this background that we should view his appointment as Clerk in I.C.F on 18.9.1997

10. The Office Circular reads as follows:

INTEGRAL COACH FACTORY, CHENNAI-38

General Manager's Office,

Personnel Branch/Shell

Dated 27.9.07

OFFICE ORDER No. PB/S1C/2157

The undermentioned employee who was working as Station Master Gr.III in scale Rs. 1400-2300 has been transferred from S. Rly to IFC on Inter Railway Transer (One way). He has been taken on the rolls of ICF as Clerk G.II in Scale Rs. 0950-1500 from the date mentioned against him.

Sl. No. Name & Emp. No. Father's Name S/Shri Date of Birth Date of Appt. Date of reporting in ICF Pay fixed Unit 1, Raghuraman S. 806354 R. Sethuraman 30.5.65 13.3.89 19.9.97 Rs. 1500 9OD

He has declared that he is not residing in Railway Quarters. The above Inter Railway One Way Transfer is ordered subject to the following conditions:

i. He will rank Junior most to all permanent and temporary Clerks Gr.II in Scale Rs. 0950-1500 as on the date of joining the new seniority unit i.e Personnel Dept.

ii. At any point of time, he should not repersent seeking fixation of seniority or absorption in any higher grade other than Clerk G.II in Scale Rs. 0950-1500.

iii. His request if any for retransfer to South Railway at a later date will not be considered under any circumstances.

SENIOR PERSONNEL OFFICER/R&T

The first flaw in this order is that this is not an inter- railway transfer of the ordinary category. He is transferred to another establishment only because he was medically incapacitated. He is entitled to this under Paragraph 1306. It is not a transfer on request. It is a right of transfer which the law gives him and therefore, the respondent can neither say that he will rank junior to all permanent and temporary clerks, neither can they say that his request for re-transfer will not be considered in any circumstances. On 29.11.1997, the petitioner requested that he may be accommodated in the Headquarter Grade and that he came to understand that there are vacancies. This letter is extracted hereunder:

“S. Raghuraman,Emp. No. 806354,CG-II, General Section,Personnel Branch,ICF/Chennai-38.

ToThe CPO,ICF.Thro' Proper Channel

Sub: Absorption of Medically decategorised SM - Self - Representation - Submitted

Ref: Your office order No. M/153/97 dated 19.9.1997 and letter No. M/P-439.I/Opt/ R/Vol.VI dated 19.9.1997

Consequent to my decategorisation, I was directed to report to the CO/ICF for absorption in an alternative employment. Accordingly, I have been absorbed as an Office Order mentioned above and now I am working in that category in ICF from 19.9.1997 In this connection, I wish to submit as follows:

Prior to decategorisation, I was working as a Station Master (permanent employee) of the Railways from 13.3.1989 and I have been promoted to the grade of Rs. 1400-2300 with effect from 8.11.1991

I now come to understand that there are vacancies in Head Clerk Grade in scale Rs. 1400- 2300. With respect to Para 1314(C)(1) of IREM, I am privileged to be accommodated as an Head Clerk in grade Rs. 1400-2300 with due protection of the last drawn pay and other consequential benefits. In as much as I had been working on the grade SM- III i.e in the above said scale of pay and the above mentioned vacancy being a clerical category in which I could be fitted after decategorisation, I request your goodself to kindly consider absorption to the above grade at the earliest.”

On 7.6.2000, his request is treated as an inter-railways transfer on bottom seniority.

11. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Southern Railway repeatedly said that the petitioner should have made Southern Railway as a party since it is only from Southern Railway that he was transferred to I.C.F The first respondent is the Union of India and both Southern Railway, Madras and Integral Coach Factory are only field organisations under the Ministry of Railways. The following paragraphs of Kunal Singh v. Union of India, 2003 (4) SCC 524 are relevant:

8. The need for a comprehensive legislation for safeguarding the rights of persons with disabilities and enabling them to enjoy equal opportunities and to help them to fully participate in national life was felt for a long time. To realize the objective that people with disabilities should have equal opportunities and keeping their hopes and aspirations in view a meeting called the “Meet to Launch the Asian and Pacific Decades of Disabled Persons” was held in Beijing in the first week of December 1992 by the Asian and Pacific countries to ensure “full participation and equality of people with disabilities in the Asian and Pacific regions”. This meeting was held by the Economic and Social Commission for Asia and Pacific. A proclamation was adopted in the said meeting. India was a signatory to the said proclamation and agreed to give effect to the same. Pursuant thereto this Act was enacted, which came into force on 1.1.1996 The Act provides some sort of succour to the disabled persons.

9. Chapter VI of the Act deals with employment relating to persons with disabilities, who are yet to secure employment. Section 47, which falls in Chapter VIII, deals with an employee, who is already in service and acquires a disability during his service. It must be borne in mind that Section 2 of the Act has given distinct and different definitions of “disability” and “person with disability”. It is well settled that in the same enactment if two distinct definitions are given defining a word/expression, they must be understood accordingly in terms of the definition. It must be remembered that a person does not acquire or suffer disability by choice. An employee, who acquires disability during his service, is sought to be protected under Section 47 of the Act specifically. Such employee, acquiring disability, if not protected, would not only suffer himself, but possibly all those who depend on him would also suffer. The very frame and contents of Section 47 clearly indicate its mandatory nature. The very opening part of the section reads “no establishment shall dispense with, or reduce in rank, an employee who acquires a disability during his service”. The Section further provides that if an employee after acquiring disability is not suitable for the post he was holding, could be shifted to some other post with the same pay scale and service benefits; if it is not possible to adjust the employee against any post he will be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is available or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier. Added to this no promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the ground of his disability as is evident from sub-section (2) of Section 47. Section 47 contains a clear directive that the employer shall not dispense with or reduce in rank an employee who acquires a disability during the service. In construing a provision of a social beneficial enactment that too dealing with disabled persons intended to give them equal opportunities, protection of rights and full participation, the view that advances the object of the Act and serves its purpose must be preferred to the one which obstructs the object and paralyses the purpose of the Act. Language of Section 47 is plain and certain casting statutory obligation on the employer to protect an employee acquiring disability during service.

10. The argument of the learned Counsel for the respondent on the basis of the definition given in Section 2(t) of the Act that benefit of Section 47 is not available to the appellant as he has suffered permanent invalidity cannot be accepted. Because, the appellant was an employee, who has acquired “disability” within the meaning of Section 2(i) of the Act and not a person with disability

11. We have to notice one more aspect in relation to the appellant getting invalidity pension as per Rule 38 of the CCS Pension Rules. The Act is a special legislation dealing with persons with disabilities to provide equal opportunities, protection of rights and full participation to them. It being a special enactment, doctrine of generalia specialibus non derogant would apply. Hence Rule 38 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules cannot override Section 47 of the Act. Further, Section 72 of the Act also supports the case of the appellant, which reads:

72. Act to be in addition to and not in derogation of any other law. The provisions of this Act, or the rules made thereunder shall be in addition to, and not in derogation of any other law for the time being in force or any rules, order or any instructions issued thereunder, enacted or issued for the benefit of persons with disabilities.

12. Merely because under Rule 38 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, the appellant got invalidity pension is no ground to deny the protection mandatorily made available to the appellant under Section 47 of the Act. Once it is held that the appellant has acquired disability during his service and if found not suitable for the post he was holding, he could be shifted to some other post with same pay scale and service benefits; if it was not possible to adjust him against any post, he could be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post was available or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier. It appears no such efforts were made by the respondents. They have proceeded to hold that he was permanently incapacitated to continue in service without considering the effect of other provisions of Section 47 of the Act.

So, for the purpose of ensuring that the Disabilities Act is given its full effect, the Indian Railways must be treated as an Establishment and it is obliged in law to see that its disabled employee does not suffer reduction of rank. There may be other situations where such unit of the Indian Railways may have to be treated as different units. But, for advancing the objects of the Disabilities Act and to give effect to Para 1306(3) of the IREM, the Indian Railways must be treated as an Establishment.

12. In The State v. K. Mohammed Mustafa, 2007 WLR 256, a Division Bench had held that the benefit envisaged under Section 47 of the Disabilities Act can be considered in addition to the benefits contemplated under the Act and observed thus:

“If in a given case the provisions contained in the G.O are more beneficial notwithstanding any provision contained in the Act, such beneficial provision of the G.O can be made applicable, and similarly, if the provisions contained in the Act are more beneficial as compared to the provisions contained in the G.O, benefit of such Act can be made available.”

13. In Tamil Nadu State Transport Corpn. v. R. Jayakumar, Writ Appeal No. 610 of 2007, decided on 13.4.2007, a Division Bench held that Section 47 of the Disabilities Act casts a mandatory duty on the part of the employer to provide an alternative employment to an employee who has suffered disability during the course of his employment, and the fact that such an employee has received some compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act is no ground to deny him the alternative employment, to which he is otherwise entitled under the Disabilities Act.

14. In A. Veeriya Perumal v. Secretary to Government, Health & Family Welfare Department, Chennai, 2006 (4) MLJ 335, a Division Bench held that sub-section (1) of Section 47 of the Disabilities Act is clear in terms that “no establishment shall dispense with or reduce in rank, an employee who acquires a disability during his service”. The Division Bench held that the right to livelihood, which is an integral facet of the right to life as guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, coupled with the protection under Section 47 of the Disabilities Act entitles the employee who was incapacitated during service for continuance of service in suitable alternative post with same scale of pay drawn by him and other service benefits. It was also held that the appellant/employee's right to alternate employment cannot be deprived solely on ground of medical invalidation, as his right is protected under Section 47 of the Disabilities Act.

15. Under the Indian Railway Establishment Manual, the employee has the right not to be treated as a new entrant. A transfer on request is a transfer which is made on the volition of the employee, whereas a transfer or an alternative accommodation given to a workmen on his being found medically incapacitated is a right given to the railway servant to choose the best option that is available to him, since he is no longer able to serve in the post where he was serving earlier and it is not a transfer on request. It is an option that he exercises by virtue of the right that is made available to him. In the Manual, under Chapter II dealing with General Conditions of Service, Paragraph 226 deals with transfers. It reads thus:

“Ordinarily, a railway servant shall be employed throughout his service on the railway or railway establishment to which he is posted on first appointment and shall have no claim as of right for transfer to another railway or another establishment. In the exigencies of service, however, it shall be open to the President to transfer the railway servant to any other department or railway or railway establishment including a project in or out of India.”

So, under normal circumstances, a railway servant will be employed throughout in the same railway or railway establishment. But medical incapacity and diminishment of vision at the age of 36 is not an ordinary situation, so in that situation, the rule does not apply. Moreover, the same Rule states:

“Railway Ministry's decision. — Requests from railway servants in Groups C & D for transfer from one railway to another on grounds of special cases of hardships may be considered favourably by the railway administration. Such staff transferred at their request from one railway to another shall be placed below all existing confirmed and officiating staff in the relevant grade in the promotion group in the new establishment, irrespective of date of confirmation or length of officiating service of the transferred employees.”

Therefore, on the Railway Ministry's decision, such requests can be considered in special cases of hardship. A case of an employee who has suffered medical disability is indisputably a case of hardship.

16. Therefore, the writ petitioner's prayer deserves to be granted since that is a right given to him in law and the rules can also be construed so as to advance the objects of the Act and to protect the rights of the person who has been medically incapacitated. I am inclined to agree with Elipe Dharmarao, J. The Writ Petition is, therefore, allowed. It is always open to the Integral Coach Factory and the Southern Railway to arrive at a satisfactory solution with regard to the fitment of the petitioner since this should be treated as a special case and not a routine case of inter-railway transfer and we earnestly hope that both these wings of the Ministry of Railways will consider the case of the petitioner in the spirit of the Act and the purpose for which the relevant paragraphs of the Manual have been introduced.