Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

National Insurance Co. Ltd., Rep. By Its Branch Manager v. Mahadevan

Madras High Court
Apr 27, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Civil Miscellaneous Appeal arising from M.C.O.P. No. 619 of 2003 (Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Dindigul)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Civil Miscellaneous Appeal was filed against the award and decree dated 26.09.2005 in M.C.O.P No. 619 of 2003 on the file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Principal District Judge), Dindigul. The Insurance Company (the appellant) challenged an award of compensation of Rs. 3,65,000 with interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of claim.

The underlying facts, as recorded in the opinion, are: on 15.07.2003 at about 4:30 p.m., the deceased (named as Murugeswari and Selvarani in the text) were standing at a bus stop on Dindigul–Trichy Main Road when a lorry owned by the fourth respondent and insured with the appellant struck them in a rash and negligent manner; both died on the spot. Two separate claim petitions were filed by the legal representatives of the deceased; because both petitions arose from the same accident they were taken up together with common evidence. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 3,65,000 to the claimants (respondents).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in the absence of proof of avocation, the Tribunal should treat the deceased as a non-earning housewife and what notional income should be adopted for quantifying dependency compensation.
  2. Whether the multiplier applied by the Tribunal (criticized by the appellant as '17') was excessive, and which multiplier is appropriate for the deceased's age.
  3. How to quantify the pecuniary value of the multifarious services rendered by a deceased housewife (including loss of domestic services, personal attention to children, and loss of consortium) in the computation of compensation.
  4. Whether the amounts awarded by the Tribunal for loss of love and affection and other heads (transportation expenses, loss of consortium) were adequate or required enhancement.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Insurance Company)

  • The Tribunal should have treated the deceased as a housewife in the absence of proof of avocation and fixed a notional income of Rs. 15,000 per annum for computing dependency compensation.
  • In the absence of proof of income, the Tribunal should consider the multifarious services rendered by the housewife but follow the dictum in Lata Wadhwa & others v. State of Bihar.
  • The application of multiplier ‘17’ (as criticized by counsel) for arriving at dependency compensation is excessive.

Respondents' Arguments (Claimants)

  • The deceased was a tailor at the time of the accident and was contributing Rs. 3,000 per month; this income supported the family.
  • The husband and minor children have lost the deceased's services and the husband may have to engage another person to do domestic work; the tailoring contribution was supplementary and should be considered in awarding compensation.
  • The compensation of Rs. 20,000 awarded for loss of love and affection was inadequate, and the Tribunal failed to award adequate compensation for transportation expenses; the husband (allegedly aged 33 according to counsel's submission) lost his wife at a relatively young age and should receive reasonable compensation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Regan v. Williamson, 1977 ACJ 331 (QBD, England) Principle that dependents are to be compensated for value of services lost; companionship, grief and maternal love were traditionally ignored; Judge cautioned that "services" should be construed to include constant attendance and personal attention. Used as guidance on the basis for qualifying for compensation for loss of services by housewives; the Court extracted and relied on the English law commentary to broaden understanding of "services".
Metmet v. Perry, 1978 ACJ 112 (QBD, England) Assessment of pecuniary value of a wife's services under three heads: (a) housekeeping services, (b) personal attention to children apart from housekeeping, (c) personal care and attention to the husband. Cited to illustrate the heads under which domestic services can be valued and awarded.
A. Rajam v. M. Manikya Reddy, 1989 ACJ 542 (AP) Loss to family is computed by estimating loss of services and taking into account substitution costs and loss of personal care; "services" should be broadly construed. Relied upon as an Indian authority supporting the broad construction of "services" and the method for computing loss, including substitute costs and personal attention losses.
Lata Wadhwa & others v. State of Bihar, 2001 ACJ 1735 Laid down principles for assessment of services rendered by non-earning housewives; suggested Rs. 3,000 per month (Rs. 36,000 per annum) as a modest estimation for housewives aged 34–59 and conventional amounts for other age groups (e.g., Rs. 50,000 conventional amount; Rs. 10,000 p.a. for elderly 62–72 with multiplier 8). Treated as a principal Supreme Court authority on valuation of housewives' services; the Court reviewed and applied the principles but adjusted the notional annual contribution to Rs. 20,000 in view of the circumstances described in the present case.
Bontu Venkata Rao v. Kalia Venkataramana, 2005 ACJ 77 (AP) Considered value of domestic services and quantified loss; discussed substitution wages (example cited Rs. 30/day) and awarded Rs. 25,000 for loss of services for a 30-year-old deceased. Cited to illustrate how domestic services have been quantified and to support the approach of awarding lump sum for loss of services.
Amar Singh Thukral v. Sandeep Chhatwal, 2005 ACJ 1187 (Delhi) Held that "services" of a housewife should be given a broad and expansive meaning; in absence of scientific method, resort may be had to wages of a skilled worker as per minimum rates. Relied upon for the proposition that valuation should be expansive and that, where no precise method exists, reference to wage rates can be used.
H.V. Rangataju v. Muqbul Pasha, 2004 (3) ACC 802 (Karnataka) Considered loss of services of a deceased aged about 28 and quantified compensation (Rs. 1,50,000) on the basis of domestic work for a number of years. Cited as an example of substantial quantification for a younger deceased housewife and as supportive authority for awarding higher amounts for domestic services.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Shamsher Singh, 2004 (1) ACC 209 (J&K) Following Lata Wadhwa, considered the services rendered by a housewife (aged about 24) and enhanced compensation; referred to heads of pecuniary loss set out in Kemp & Kemp. Used to support the list of heads of loss (household contribution, additional expenses, etc.) and to justify enhancement of compensation.
Kemp & Kemp, Quantum of Damages (textbook) Lists various heads of pecuniary loss on death of a wife, including loss of wife's household contribution, additional expenses from hiring a house-keeper, clothing expenses for children, and loss of security element. Referenced in the opinion as an authoritative list of pecuniary heads to be considered when quantifying loss to the husband/family.
Captain Singh v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., 2005 ACJ 910 (Delhi) Followed Lata Wadhwa and evaluated multifarious services of the deceased housewife to determine annual income. Cited to show an approach where courts evaluate various services to arrive at an annual notional income for the deceased housewife.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Vishwa Bandhu, 1999 ACJ 42 (Punjab & Haryana) Determined the value of services of a deceased housewife (aged about 28) as Rs. 1,000 per month. Cited as a comparative judicial valuation for a young deceased housewife.
T.C. Batiya v. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., 2000 ACJ 327 (Himachal Pradesh) Considered loss of services and awarded Rs. 1,00,000 under that head for a deceased aged about 50 years. Referenced as one of the authorities demonstrating variation in awards depending on age and circumstances.
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Banshidhar Gupta, 2003 (1) ACC 572 (Allahabad) Fixed annual loss to the family due to death of a housewife (aged about 29) at Rs. 12,000 per annum. Cited as an example of annual valuation adopted by another High Court for a young housewife.
Divisional Manager, K.S.R.T.C. v. Mahadeva Shetty, 2003 AIR SCW 3797 : 2004 (1) TN MAC 534 (SC) Provides guidance on the appropriate multiplier to be applied to annual loss based on the age of claimants; the opinion states the multiplier applicable to the age of the claimants in this case is 15. The Court applied the multiplier "15" (as indicated by this authority) to the annual contribution it fixed for the deceased to calculate dependency compensation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court heard learned counsel for both sides and reviewed English authorities and numerous Indian decisions addressing valuation of services rendered by non-earning housewives. The analysis proceeded along the following lines (as recorded in the opinion):

  1. The Court acknowledged the difficulty of measuring loss of services of housewives in monetary terms because there is no statutory norm and reasoned that the factors for quantification must be culled from judicial precedents and English law guidance (citing Regan, Metmet, and several Indian High Court and Supreme Court decisions).
  2. The Court surveyed the authorities (including Lata Wadhwa) which suggested methods and illustrative figures (e.g., Lata Wadhwa’s Rs. 3,000 per month for certain age groups) but observed that the notional income figure adopted in 1994 cannot be mechanically applied many years later without accounting for inflation and changes in cost of living.
  3. After considering the importance of loss of services and the ages of the dependants, the Court concluded it would be reasonable to fix the annual contribution of the deceased (a non-earning member) at Rs. 20,000 per annum for the purpose of computing dependency compensation in this case.
  4. The Court examined the specific factual matrix: the deceased was about 27 years old at the time of the accident (leaving two minor children aged about 12 and 2); the husband was about 35; though the respondents asserted the deceased was a tailor earning Rs. 3,000 per month, no documentary proof of that avocation/income was produced and therefore the claim of actual earnings could not be accepted.
  5. The Court followed Divisional Manager, K.S.R.T.C. v. Mahadeva Shetty in applying a multiplier of 15 (applicable to the age of the claimants) to compute dependency compensation: Rs. 20,000 (annual contribution) × 15 (multiplier) = Rs. 3,00,000.
  6. The Court accepted that the Tribunal's award of Rs. 20,000 for loss of love and affection to the children was not disputed. The Court noted that the Tribunal had failed to award any sum for loss of consortium to the husband and therefore awarded Rs. 10,000 for loss of consortium. Funeral expenses of Rs. 5,000 were also included.
  7. Accordingly, the Court recalculated the total award as Rs. 3,35,000 and ordered that interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of claim be maintained; if the amount had already been deposited, the Tribunal was directed to refund any balance with proportionate interest to the appellant insurance company within two months of receiving a copy of the order.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is partly allowed; the award is modified and the respondents/claimants are awarded Rs. 3,35,000 with interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of claim.

Apportionment of the Award (as directed by the Court):

  • Dependency Compensation: Rs. 3,00,000
  • Loss of Love and Affection (children): Rs. 20,000
  • Loss of Consortium (husband): Rs. 10,000
  • Funeral Expenses: Rs. 5,000
  • Total: Rs. 3,35,000

Consequences and immediate effects:

  • The appellant's challenge resulted in a revision of the Tribunal's award (reduced from Rs. 3,65,000 to Rs. 3,35,000 as apportioned above), but the claimants remain entitled to a substantial award with interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of claim.
  • If the awarded amount had already been deposited, the Tribunal is directed to refund the balance (if any) with proportionate accrued interest to the appellant Insurance Company within two months of receipt of a copy of the order.
  • The appeal was partly allowed and no costs were awarded by the Court.

Note: The opinion extensively surveys and relies upon prior English and Indian decisions for principles and comparative figures in valuing the services of non-earning housewives; in this case the Court departed from earlier numerical notional figures (e.g., figures suggested earlier in 1994 or in other decisions) and fixed an annual notional contribution of Rs. 20,000 for the deceased in light of the facts and the passage of time.

Show all summary ...

The Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed against the award and decree dated 26.09.2005 made in M.C.O.P No. 619 of 2003 on the file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Principal District Judge) Dindigul.

JUDGMENT

1. The Insurance Company, who suffered a decree for compensation of Rs. 3,65,000/- with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of claim, has preferred this Appeal.

2. Brief facts leading to the Appeal are as follows:

On 15.07.2003 about 4.30 pm., when the deceased-Murugeswari and Selvarani were standing in the bus stop on Dindigul-Trichy Main Road, a lorry owned by the fourth respondent and insured with the appellant-Insurance Company came in a rash and negligent manner, dashed against them and both of them died on the spot. Two separate Claim Petitions were filed by the legal representatives of the deceased. As the Claim Petitions arose out of the same accident, both the Petitions were taken up together, common evidence was let in and documents marked. As far as the claimants in the present Appeal are concerned, the Tribunal awarded Rs. 3,65,000/- with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of claim.

3. Heard Mr. Srinivasa Raghavan, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr. Ajmal Khan, learned counsel for the respondents.

4. Mr. Srinivasa Raghavan, learned counsel for the appellant submitted that in the absence of proof of avocation, the Tribunal ought to have considered that the deceased was only a house wife and should have fixed the notional income of Rs. 15,000/- for the purpose of computing dependency compensation. He further submitted that in the absence of any proof of income, the Tribunal has to take note of multifarious services rendered by the house wife and ought to have followed the dictum laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Lata Wadhwa & others v. State of Bihar, 2001 ACJ 1735. He further submitted that the application of multiplier ‘17’ for arriving at the dependency compensation is excessive.

5. On the other hand, Mr. Ajmal Khan, learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the deceased was a tailor at the time of accident and was contributing Rs. 3,000/- per month. He further submitted that the first respondent, husband of the deceased and his minor children have lost the services rendered by the deceased and the first respondent has to engage another person for doing domestic work. The contribution from tailoring work was supplementary to the family, which is now required from other source and therefore, the said factor has to be considered for awarding compensation. He further submitted that the compensation of Rs. 20,000/- awarded for Loss of Love and Affection is inadequate and the Tribunal has failed to award adequate compensation for transportation expenses. He submitted that the Tribunal ought to have awarded reasonable compensation to the first respondent, who has lost his wife at the age of 33 years.

6. Before dealing with the facts and the decisions of Indian Courts on the determination of quantum of compensation, guidance is taken from the judgment of the Supreme Court, which has extracted a portion of the Queen's Bench decision of England, as to what would be the basis for qualifying for compensation for Loss of Services rendered by house wives. In Regan v. Williamson, 1977 ACJ 331 (QBD, England), it was noted that the present law is that “dependents are to be compensated only for the value of the services lost to them by the death of a wife and mother. A wife's companionship is to be ignored, likewise the grief and misery caused by her departure and, so too, a mother's love, guidance and influ-ence in bringing up children”. Reference was made to causes in which there was strict disregard to those features of the life of a woman beyond her so-called services, to keep house, cook food, buy clothes, wash them, etc. Though the learned Judge found himself bound by the law, yet he expressed the view that the work ‘services’ has been too narrowly construed. The observations of the Learned Judge is as follows:

“It should, at least, include an acknowledgment that a wife and mother does not work to set hours and, still less, to Rule. She is in constant attendance, save for those hours when she is, if that is the fact, at work. During some of those hours she may well give the children instruction on essential matters to do with their upbringing and, possibly, with such things as their homework. This sort of attention seems to be as much of a service, and probably more valuable to them, than the other kinds of service conventionally so regarded.”

7. In Metmet v. Perry, 1978 ACJ 112 (QBD, England), the pecuniary value of a wife's services were assessed and granted under three heads:

(a) Loss to the family of the wife's housekeeping services.

(b) Loss suffered by the children of the personal attention of their mother, apart from housekeeping services rendered by her.

(c) Loss of the wife's personal care and attention, which the husband had suffered, in addition to the loss of her housekeeping services.

Some of the decisions dealing with the estimation of the services rendered by the house wives are briefly dealt with.

8. The Andhra Pradesh High Court in A. Rajam v. M. Manikya Reddy, 1989 ACJ 542 (AP), held, inter alia, as follows:

“The loss to the husband and children consequent upon the death of the housewife or mother has to be computed by estimating the loss of ‘ser-vices’ to the family, if there was rea-sonable prospect of such services being rendered freely in the future, but for the death. It must be remem-bered that any substitute to be so employed is not likely to be as eco-nomical as the housewife. Apart from the value of obtaining substituted ser-vices, the expense of giving accommodation or food to the substitute must also be computed. From this total must be deducted the expense the family would have otherwise been spending for the deceased housewife.

While estimating the ‘services’ of the housewife, a narrow meaning should not be given to the meaning of the word ‘services’ but it should be construed broadly and one has to take into account the loss of ‘personal care and attention’ by the deceased to her children, as a mother and to her husband, as a wife. The award is not diminished merely because some close relation like a grandmother is prepared to render voluntary services.”

9. The Apex Court in Lata Wadhwa & others v. State of Bihar, 2001 ACJ 1735, has laid down certain principles for assessment of services rendered by the deceased-housewives, who were not earning any income. In that case, a devastating fira engulfed the VIP Pandal, causing the death of number of persons including children and women. Former Chief Justice of India, Hon'ble Mr. Justice Y.V Chandrachud looked into the matter and formulated certain principles, for asse-ssment of compensation to the legal representatives of the deceased as well as compensation payable to the injured per-son. On the basis of the report submitted by the Hon'ble Judge, the Apex Court awarded compensation to the victims, who had lost their kith and kin and to those who sustained bodily injuries. The Supreme Court was pleased to award reasonable compensation to the Legal Representatives of the deceased. While dealing with the compensation payable to the legal representatives of the wives, who died in the accident, in Paragraph 10 of the judgment, the Supreme Court held that,—

“But even in the absence of such datas and taking into consideration the multifarious services rendered by the housewifes for managing the entire family, even on a modest estimation, should be Rs. 3,000/- per month and Rs. 36,000/- per annum. This would apply to all those housewives between the age group of 34 and 59 and as such who were active in life. The compensation awarded, therefore, should be recalculated, taking the value of the services rendered per annum, to be Rs. 36,000/- and thereafter applying the multiplier, as has been applied already and so far as the conventional amount is concerned, the same should be Rs. 50,000 instead of Rs. 25,000 given under the report. So far as the elderly ladies are concerned in the age group of 62 to 72, the value of the services rendered has been taken at Rs. 10,000/- per annum and the multiplier applied is eight.”

10. In a decision in Bontu Venkata Rao v. Kalia Venkataramana, 2005 ACJ 77, the Andhra Pradesh High Court considered the value of domestic services of the deceased in awarding compensation to the legal representatives. In Paragraph 7 of the judgment the Court held as follows:

“the services have been rendered by the deceased to the family shall have to be quantified. It is in the evidence that the workplace where the deceased used to work has been closed for the last eight months preceding the date of accident and the death of the deceased. If the claimant was expec-ted to have engaged a domestic servant for rendering services he would have definitely paid wages to the servant at the rate of Rs. 30 per day. The deceased in this case died at an age of 30 years. Her assistance to the family would be only for a particular period beyond which it cannot be expected of. But her assistance to the husband would be continued as long as both of them are alive. In that view of the matter it is a loss to claimant throughout his life. He having been aged 35 years at the appropriate time would have received the assistance of the deceased for another period of 35 years having regard to the longevity that has been fixed in this country on an average basis. As years pass on it would be reduced at a latter part of the life it is nothing but a mere companionship than assistance. In that view of the matter the compensation can be granted in a lumpsum for the Loss of Services to be rendered by the deceased to the family and services towards the domestic chores at Rs. 25,000/-.”

11. In Amar Singh Thukral v. Sandeep Chhatwal, 2005 ACJ 1187, the Delhi High Court after considering the principles laid down in Lata Wadwa's case, held that,—

“The ‘services’ rendered by a house-wife to her household should be given a broad interpretation and an expansive meaning.”

The Court further held that,—

“Since there is no scientific method of assessing the contribution of a house-wife to her household, in cases such as the present, resort should be had to the wages of a skilled worker as per the minimum rates of wages in Delhi. Although this may sound unchari-table, if not demeaning to the house-wife, there is hardly any other option available in the absence of any statutory guidelines.”

In the above reported case, the deceased-housewife was aged about 36 years old.

12. The Karnataka High Court in H.V Rangataju v. Muqbul Pasha, 2004 (3) ACC 802, considered the Loss of Services of the deceased, who aged about 28 years and quantified the compensation of Rs. 1,50,000/- on the basis of domestic work for number of years.

13. In Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Shamsher Singh, 2004 (1) ACC 209, the Jammu and Kashmir, following the decision in Lata Wadwa, considered the services rendered by the deceased house-wife, who was aged about 24 years at the time of accident and enhanced the compensation. In Paragraph 6 of the said judgment, the Court held that,—

“In Kemp and Kemp on Quantum of Damages, Vol. 1, various heads of pecuniary loss for the husband on the death of his wife have been listed out. Included there is loss of the wife's contribution to the household from her earnings, the additional expenses incurred or likely to be incurred by having the household run by a house-keeper or servant, instead of the wife, the expenses by buying clothes for the children instead of having them made by the wife, and similarly having his own clothes mended or stitched elsewhere than by his wife, and the loss of that element of security provided to the husband where his employment was insecure or his health was bad and where the wife could go out and work for a living.”

14. In a decision in Captain Singh v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., 2005 ACJ 910, the Delhi High Court following the decision in Lata Wadwa's case, evaluated the multifarious services of the deceased as housewife on the date of accident and determined the annual income of the deceased.

15. In a decision in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Vishwa Bandhu, 1999 ACJ 42, the deceased was aged about 28 years at the time of accident. The Punjab & Haryana High Court determined the value of services of the deceased house-wife as Rs. 1,000/- per month.

16. In a decision in T.C Batiya v. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., 2000 ACJ 327, the Hirnachal Pradesh High Court considered the Loss of Services to the family and awarded compensation of Rs. 1,00,000/- under that head. In the above said case, the deceased was aged about 50 years at the time of accident.

17. In United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Banshidhar Gupta, 2003 (1) ACC 572, the Allahabad High Court has considered the annual loss to the family due to the death of housewife, aged about 29 years and fixed Rs. 12,000/- per annum under that head.

18. It is difficult to measure the Loss of Services of housewives in terms of money, as there is no prescribed norms in the statute. The factors for quantifying the Loss of Services are to be culled out from the judgments of various Courts and the broad guidelines given in English Laws.

19. Courts in India have recognised the invaluable contribution of the house-wife to the house which is more than the pecuniary value. The gratuitous services rendered by wife with true love and affection to the children and her husband and managing the household affairs can-not be equated with the services rendered by others. An housekeeper or maidservant can do the household work, such as cook-ing food, washing clothes and utensils, keeping the house clean, etc., but she can never be a substitute for a wife who would render selfless service to her husband and children. However, the Loss of Service to the household is estimated on the expenses incurred for the abovesaid multifurious services rendered by the wife. The claimants who have lost the gratuitous service rendered by the deceased are entitled to adequate compensation.

20. The notional income for non-earning member was fixed in the year 1994. Quantifying the pecuniary loss at the same rate or amount even after 13 years after the amendment, ignoring the escalation in the cost of living and the inflation, may not be justifiable. Considering the importance of Loss of Services and the age of the minors, it would be reasonable to fix the annual contribution of the deceased at Rs. 20,000/- and compute the dependency compensation.

21. In the present case, the deceased was aged about 27 years at the time of accident, leaving behind two minor chil-dren aged about 12 and 2 years respect-tively. The first respondent was aged about 35 years. Though the respondents have claimed that the deceased was a tailor, they have failed to produce any document to that effect. Two minor children have lost their love and affection of their mother at the tender age and the first respondent-husband has tost her valuable services and for that purpose he would have engaged some other person to look after his children and do other domestic work.

22. Following the decision of the Supreme Court in Divisional Manager, K.S.R.T.C v. Mahadeva Shetty, 2003 AIR SCW 3797: 2004 (1) TN MAC 534 (SC), the multiplier applicable to the age of the claimants is “15”. Applying the said multiplier to the annual contribution of Rs. 20,000/-, the dependency compensation works out to Rs. 3,00,000/-. The compensation of Rs. 20,000/- awarded for Loss of Love and Affection to the children aged about 12 and 2 respectively, is not disputed. The Tribunal has failed to award compensation for Loss of Consortium to the husband. A sum of Rs. 10,000/- is awarded for Loss of Consortium.

23. In the result, the respondents/claimants are entitled to Rs. 3,35,000/- with 7.5% per annum from the date of claim. The award amount is apportioned hereunder:

Dependency Compensation : Rs. 3,00,000/- Loss of Love and Affection : Rs. 20,000/- Loss of Consortium : Rs. 10,000/- Funeral Expenses : Rs. 5,000/- Total Rs. 3,35,000/-

If the amount has already been deposited, the Tribunal is directed to refund the balance amount with proportionate accrued interest to the appellant Insurance Company within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.

24. In the result, Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is partly allowed. No costs.