Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

S.Arulselvan v. The Government Of Tamil Nadu

Madras High Court
Feb 17, 2006
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a B.E. (Mechanical Engineering) degree holder with 57.75% marks and an M.E. (Production) degree holder with 63.66% marks, challenged Clause 5 of the prospectus issued by the Teachers Recruitment Board (for direct recruitment of Lecturers in Government Engineering Colleges/Polytechnics, 2005-06). Clause 5 prescribes a First Class Master's Degree for Lecturers in certain subjects (English, Mathematics, Physics, Chemistry and Commerce) but prescribes a First Class Bachelor's Degree in the branch of engineering for Lecturers in "all other subjects" (i.e., engineering subjects). The petitioner contended that this differentiation excluded a First Class Master's Degree in engineering as an alternative qualification for engineering lecturers and thus was discriminatory and contrary to AICTE norms. The matter proceeded by way of a writ petition heard by the Court, with argument from counsel for the petitioner and the Additional Advocate General for the respondents. The writ petition was dismissed by the Court; related writ miscellaneous petitions (W.P.M.P.Nos.2784 & 2785 of 2006) were also dismissed and no costs were awarded.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Clause 5 of the prospectus is discriminatory, arbitrary or unreasonable by prescribing different minimum educational qualifications for Lecturers in humanities/science subjects and engineering subjects (i.e., requiring a First Class Master's Degree for certain subjects but only a First Class Bachelor's Degree for engineering subjects).
  2. Whether an AICTE notification/guideline that prescribes a First Class Bachelor's degree or a First Class Master's degree for lecturers can be relied upon by the petitioner as binding on the State in prescribing minimum qualifications for recruitment.
  3. Whether the State's prescription in the prospectus conforms to rules framed under Article 309 of the Constitution and to the regulatory framework under the All India Council for Technical Education Act, 1987 (in particular the relevance of regulations under Section 10(1)(i)).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented)

  • Clause 5 prescribes a First Class Master's Degree for English, Mathematics, Physics, Chemistry and Commerce, but for all other subjects (engineering subjects) it prescribes only a First Class Bachelor's Degree in the relevant engineering branch; this constitutes discriminatory treatment based on subject.
  • The AICTE Notification (Table E-I of Appendix-E) prescribes, for lecturers in engineering/technology disciplines, either a First Class Bachelor's degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology or a First Class Master's degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology. Because the prospectus does not include the Master's alternative for engineering subjects, it conflicts with AICTE norms and removes the petitioner's eligibility (the petitioner is a Second Class Bachelor's degree holder in B.E. Mech Engg but holds a First Class Master's in production).
  • If Clause 5 stands as drafted, the petitioner would be ineligible to apply for the engineering lecturer post despite his Master's qualification.

Respondents' Arguments (as presented)

  • The AICTE notification relied upon by the petitioner are only guidelines and were not issued as regulations under Section 10 of the AICTE Act, 1987; therefore they cannot be treated as binding statutory regulations for the State's recruitment prospectus.
  • Even as guidelines, AICTE's scheme relates to pay scale revision and service conditions and expressly leaves a discretion to the State Government whether to adopt/implement the scheme; hence the State may prescribe the educational qualification it chooses (within that discretion).
  • The State had amended Special Rules of the Tamil Nadu Educational Service (G.O.Ms.No.643, Higher Education (B1) Department dated 26.12.1997) framed under Article 309 of the Constitution; those rules prescribe (for Lecturer in engineering) a First Class Bachelor's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology or a First Class Master's Degree in the appropriate branch of study in the case of teaching posts in Humanities and Science. Clause 5 of the prospectus conforms to those special rules.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K. Suganthi v. State of Tamil Nadu & others (1984 Writ L.R. 249) Supports the view that a prospectus is a binding statement of eligibility norms and restrictions to candidates and authorities. Listed among authorities establishing that the prospectus is binding on candidates and on the Government/selection authorities.
Dr. A. Rathnaswamy v. Director of Medical Education & others (1986 Writ L.R. 207) Consistent authority that prospectus stipulations on eligibility must be followed. Cited as part of consistent jurisprudence that prospectus norms are binding and must be adhered to.
Midhuna Nathan v. State of Tamil Nadu & others (1995 Writ L.R. 851) Another decision supporting the binding nature of a prospectus. Used to demonstrate the consistent view in case law that prospectus rules are binding.
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Chandra Mohan & others (AIR 1977 SC 2411) Authority that prospectus norms and procedures should be strictly followed; limits on deviation from prospectus. Relied on to show the Supreme Court's stance that prospectus stipulations must be followed by authorities.
Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. The International Airport Authority of India & others (AIR 1979 SC 162) Principle that prospectus or similar statements creating expectations must be honored; restrictions on deviation. Applied as a Supreme Court precedent confirming the binding character of prospectus conditions and the limits on authority discretion inconsistent with prospectus terms.
P.A. Manickam v. Government of Tamil Nadu (1984 Writ L.R. 1) State-level authority upholding the binding nature of prospectus stipulations. Cited by the Court as part of the line of authority restricting departure from prospectus norms.
G. Sumathi v. Director of Medical Education & others (1993 Writ L.R. 344) Decision by a Division Bench affirming strict adherence to prospectus norms. Used to reinforce that prospectus conditions cannot be ignored by selection authorities.
Miss. Romini Susan Kurian v. State of A.P. & others (AIR 1992 A.P. 380) Establishes that courts do not have jurisdiction to amend, alter or introduce new clauses into a prospectus; prospectus terms are for the State to frame and not to be rewritten by courts. Applied by the Court to explain the limited scope of judicial review — the Court cannot amend the prospectus and can only intervene if a clause is ex facie arbitrary, unreasonable or discriminatory or contrary to rules.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise analysis, grounded in the text of the prospectus, relevant rules and the scope of judicial review:

  1. The Court began by reiterating the settled principle that a recruitment prospectus is binding on candidates, the Government and selection authorities — a principle supported by a consistent line of precedents cited by the Court.
  2. The Court emphasized the limited scope of judicial review over prospectus terms: the Court cannot alter, amend or insert clauses into a prospectus; judicial intervention is confined to instances where a clause is contrary to existing rules, ex facie arbitrary, unreasonable or discriminatory.
  3. Turning to the statutory/regulatory framework, the Court examined the All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) material relied upon by the petitioner. The Court found that the AICTE issuance relied upon (Table E‑I of Appendix‑E) was part of guidelines/notification for revision of pay scales and service conditions and was not issued as Regulations under Section 10(1)(i) of the AICTE Act, 1987. Thus it could not be treated as binding regulation.
  4. Even on the petitioner's reading of the AICTE guideline, the guideline prescribed either a First Class Bachelor's degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology or a First Class Master's degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology — presenting an option rather than mandating a Master's degree as mandatory for engineers.
  5. The Court next referred to the Special Rules of the Tamil Nadu Educational Service (G.O.Ms.No.643, dated 26.12.1997), framed under Article 309 of the Constitution, which prescribe a First Class Bachelor's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology for the post of Lecturer, or a First Class Master's Degree in the appropriate branch of study in the case of teaching posts in Humanities and Science. The Court read the "or" as evidencing the optional nature of a Master's degree and not an additional mandatory qualification.
  6. Because the prospectus' Clause 5 prescribes a First Class Bachelor's Degree for Lecturers in engineering subjects (consistent with the Special Rules) and the AICTE guideline left the choice to the State, the Court concluded that Clause 5 was not contrary to AICTE prescriptions nor to the Special Rules framed under Article 309.
  7. Finally, applying the restricted scope of review and the above conclusions, the Court found no basis to characterize Clause 5 as ex facie arbitrary, unreasonable or discriminatory; hence no relief to the petitioner was warranted.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed. The Court found no merit in the challenge to Clause 5 of the prospectus. No costs were awarded. Consequentially, W.P.M.P.Nos.2784 & 2785 of 2006 were also dismissed.

Implications:

  • The direct effect of the decision is that Clause 5 of the Teachers' Recruitment Board prospectus (2005-06) stands: the prospectus' prescription of a First Class Bachelor's Degree for engineering lecturer posts (as per the Special Rules) is upheld and remains operative for the recruitment in question.
  • The Court treated the AICTE notification relied upon by the petitioner as non-binding guidelines (not issued as regulations under Section 10(1)(i) of the AICTE Act) and therefore not sufficient to invalidate the State's choice of qualification where the rules under Article 309 and the State's discretion were consistent with the prospectus.
  • The opinion does not announce a new legal principle beyond applying existing precedents: it confirms the settled principles regarding the binding nature of prospectus terms, the limited scope of judicial interference, and the distinction between AICTE guidelines and statutory regulations under Section 10 of the AICTE Act.

Index: yes. Internet: yes. The order also directed communications to the Secretary to Government, Education Department and the Chairman, Teachers Recruitment Board (addresses recorded in the opinion).

Show all summary ...

The petitioner is a B.E.(Mech.Engg.) Degree holder with 57.75% marks. He is also a M.E.(Prod.) Degree holder with 63.66% marks. He has approached this Court questioning Clause 5 of the prospectus issued by the Teachers Recruitment Board for direct recruitment of Lecturers in the Government Engineering Colleges/Polytechnics (2005-06), as the said clause excludes the First Class Master's Degree in the branch of engineering as an alternative qualification.

2. I heard Mr.K.M.Ramesh, the learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr.R.Muthukumaraswamy, the learned Additional Advocate General for the respondents.

3. The Government of Tamil Nadu decided to recruit Lecturers and Senior Lecturers for appointment in Government Engineering Colleges/ Polytechnics (2005-06) by direct recruitment through the Teachers' Recruitment Board, Chennai. In the prospectus, among other eligibility norms, the minimum educational qualification is also prescribed. Clause 5 of the prospectus reads as follows:-

Subjects Qualifications LECTU-RERS ENGLISH, MATHEMATICS PHYSICS, CHEMISTRY and COMMERCE A First Class Master's Degree in the appropriate branch of study. LECTU-RERS (For all other subjects) A First Class Bachelor's degree in the branch of Engineering relating to the post concerned.

SENIOR LECTU-RERS SPINNING and WEAVING

(a) A First Class Bachelor's degree in Textile Technology and

(b) 5 years experience in teaching/industry/research at the level of Lecturer or equivalent grade in Spinning & Weaving.

SENIOR LECTU-RERS TEXTILE CHEMISTRY

(a) A First Class Bachelor's degree in Textile Technology and

(b) 5 years experience in teaching/industry/research at the level of Lecturer or equivalent grade in Textile Processing.

4. Mr.K.M.Ramesh, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that Clause 5 prescribes the minimum eligibility of a First class Master's Degree in the appropriate branch of study for the post of Lecturers in English, Mathematics, Physics, Chemistry and Commerce, but it has restricted the qualification for the post of Lecturers for all other subjects by fixing the qualification as a First Class Bachelor's Degree in the branch of engineering relating to the post concerned. Prescription of a different educational qualification for the post of Lecturers on the basis of the subjects is discriminatory. He would also submit that inasmuch as the All India Council for Technical Education Notification also prescribes the educational qualification requiring a First Class Master's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology, the State Government cannot fix any educational qualification which are not in tune with the norms prescribed by AICTE. In this context, he would refer to Table E-I of Appendix-E of the AICTE Notification relating to the Minimum Qualification and Experience prescribed for Teaching Post in Degree Level Technical Institutions relating to the Engineering and Technology disciplines, which reads as follows:- SL. NO.

CADRE QUALIFICATION EXPERIENCE QUALIFICATION & EXPERIENCE FOR CANDIDATES FROM INDUSTRY & PROFESSION Lecturer First Class Bachelor's degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/ technology or First Class Master's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/ technology No minimum requirement He would submit that if the educational qualification relating to the mechanical engineering branch to which the petitioner would be eligible to apply, is allowed to stand, he would not be qualified, as he is only a Second Class Bachelor's Degree holder in B.E.(Mech.Engg.). Hence, he is aggrieved by the said clause.

5. Mr.R.Muthukumaraswamy, the learned Additional Advocate General appearing for the respondents, on the other hand, would submit that the notification relating to the minimum qualification relied upon by the petitioner are only guidelines and the same have not been issued in terms of Section 10 of the All India Council for Technical Education Act, 1987. In the absence of the same, the petitioner cannot rely upon the said notification relating to the educational qualification. He would also submit that in any event the notification basically relates to the scheme for revision of pay scales. Even in the guidelines, a discretion is left with the State Government to adopt and implement the scheme and in such event, the State Government shall be provided with financial assistance. He would further submit that the Government had issued an amendment to the Special Rules of the Tamil Nadu Educational Service relating to the post of Lecturers in Government Engineering Colleges in G.O.Ms.No.643, Higher Education (B1) Department dated 26.12.1997. The said rules were framed under Article 309 of The Constitution of India. As per the said rule, the following is the prescribed qualification:-

SL. NO.

CADRE QUALIFICATION Lecturer i. First Class Bachelor's Degree in appropriate branch of Engineering/ Technology.

or ii. First Class Master's Degree in appropriate branch of study in the case of teaching posts in Humanities and Science.

He would therefore submit that inasmuch as the said rule requires only a First Class Bachelor's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology for the post of Lecturer, the qualification prescribed in Clause 5 of the prospectus is in conformity with the said special rules.

6. I have given my due consideration to the above submissions. It is well settled law that a prospectus is a piece of information to the candidates stipulating the eligibility norms/restrictions regarding the educational qualification, etc. The prospectus is binding not only on the candidates, but also on the Government and as well on the authorities involved in the process of selection. This consistent view had been taken in number of cases. To quote, the following are few of them.

(1)

K.Suganthi Vs. State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary and Commissioner to Dept. of Health and Medical Education, Madras-9 & two others (1984 Writ L.R. 249
.

(2) "Dr.A.Rathnaswamy Vs. Director of Medical Education, Madras & three others (1986 Writ L.R. 207".

(3) "Midhuna Nathan Vs. State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary, Department of Health, Fort St.George, Madras & seven others (1995 Writ L.R.

851)".

7. It is also equally well settled that the norms and procedures prescribed in the prospectus should be strictly followed and the authorities cannot ignore/deviate from the same, as has been held by the Supreme Court in the decisions in "State of Uttar Pradesh Vs. Chandra Mohan and others (AIR 1977 SC 2411)", in "Ramana Dayaram Shetty Vs. The International Airport Authority of India and others (AIR 1979 SC 162 8)", by a Full Bench of this Court in the decision in "P.A.Manickam Vs. The Government of Tamil Nadu rep. by the Deputy Secretary, Home Department, Madras (1984 Writ L.R. 1)" and as well by a Division Bench of this Court in "G.Sumathi Vs. The Director of Medical Education, Madras & four others (1993 Writ L.R.344)".

8. The scope of judicial review over the prospectus is restricted, as the Court has no power to either alter, amend or introduce a new clause in the prospectus, as has been held in "Miss.Romini Susan Kurian Vs. State of A.P. And others (AIR 1992 A.P. 380)". It will not be within the jurisdiction of the Court either to amend, alter or to add something into the prospectus, as it would be the function of the State in exercise of the powers under Article 162 of The Constitution of India. The eligibility norms, age restrictions and educational qualifications are prescribed in the prospectus as per the policy of the Government consistent with the rules in vogue. The scope of review is restricted only if a clause is contrary to the rules, ex-facie arbitrary, unreasonable and consequently amount to discrimination.

9. Keeping the above in mind, the challenge to clause 5 of the prospectus relating to the educational qualification shall be considered. So far as the fixation of educational qualification is concerned, there cannot be any dispute that the educational qualification must be prescribed in conformity with the educational qualifications prescribed in the All India Council for Technical Education Act. The notification relied upon by Mr.K.M.Ramesh, the learned counsel for the petitioner stipulates a First Class Bachelor's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology or a First Class Master's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology. Regulations relating to the educational qualification, among other norms, must be made by the All India Council for Technical Education in terms of Section 1 0(1)(i) of the All India Council for Technical Education Act. Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon Table E-I of Appendix-E relating to the Minimum Qualification and Experience prescribed for Teaching Post in Degree Level Technical Institutions relating to the Engineering and Technology disciplines. In this regard, a notification was issued by AICTE for revision of pay scales and service conditions and the same are only in the form of guidelines and it cannot be construed to be the Regulations made under Section 10(1)(i) of the Act. Moreover, as per the said guidelines, the qualification prescribed is a First Class Bachelor's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology or a First Class Master's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology. Even if the said guideline is applied, it is for the respondents to prescribe the educational qualification either by stipulating a First Class Bachelor's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology or in the alternative, a First Class Master's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/ technology. When such a discretion is vested, it cannot be contended that prescription of a First Class Bachelor's Degree for the post of Lecturers in the engineering subjects would be contrary to the educational qualification prescribed by the All India Council for Technical Education. It is further contended that inasmuch as the educational qualification relating to English, Mathematics, Physics, Chemistry and Commerce subjects requires a First Class Master's Degree, prescription of only a First Class Bachelor's Degree for engineering subjects would be discriminatory, arbitrary and unreasonable. This argument is also based on misreading of the rules relating to the educational qualification, framed both under Article 309 of The Constitution of India as well as notified by the All India Council for Technical Education. As per the qualification prescribed by the All India Council for Technical Education inasmuch as a First Class Master's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering, the said prescription is only optional. Secondly, as per the rules framed under Article 309 of The Constitution of India, again it contemplates the educational qualification for the post of Lecturers as a First Class Bachelor's Degree in the appropriate branch of engineering/technology or a First Class Master's Degree in the appropriate branch of study in the case of teaching posts in Humanities and Science. The word "or" has to be read as optional and is not in addition to the First Class Bachelor's Degree. In my opinion, clause 5 of the prospectus relating to the qualification has been prescribed in conformity with the rules framed under Article 309 of The Constitution of India. So long as the rules are not questioned, this Court cannot hold that the impugned clause in the prospectus is either arbitrary, unreasonable and discriminatory.

10. For all the above reasons, I do not find any merit in the writ petition. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. No costs. Consequently, W.P.M.P.Nos.2784 & 2785 of 2006 are also dismissed.

Index : yes Internet : yes ss To

1. The Secretary to Government of Tamil Nadu Education Department Fort St.George Chennai 600 009

2. The Chairman Teachers Recruitment Board 4th Floor, EVK Sampath Maligai DPI Compound, College Road, Chennai 600 006