- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
A. Veeriya Perumal v. Secretary To Government, Health And Family Welfare Department, Chennai
Structured Summary of the Judgment delivered by D. Murugesan, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant joined the Medical Department on 4 August 1966. Multiple charge-memos were issued against him in 1999:
- Chargememo dated 28 May 1999 containing six charges under Rule 17(b) of the Tamil Nadu Civil Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules — all charges were held proved; the Government imposed the punishment of censure in G.O. (D) No. 1074 dated 5 October 2004.
- Chargememo dated 14 December 1999 containing one charge — the charge was held proved; the Government imposed the punishment of censure in G.O. (D) No. 214 dated 17 March 2006.
- Chargememo dated 30 June 1999 containing twelve charges — in the enquiry all charges were held to be proved as per the enquiry officer's report dated 2 February 2002.
While the disciplinary proceedings were pending, a question arose about retiring the appellant on medical invalidation. Initially the Government refused to retire him on the ground that orders in respect of the 30 June 1999 chargememo were yet to be passed. Eventually, by an order dated 11 July 2006, the appellant was permitted to retire from service on medical invalidation with effect from 22 February 2002 A.N., without prejudice to the pending disciplinary proceedings, and to draw provisional pension at the rate of Rs. 3,255.
The matter was heard by the Court (the judgment records hearing of learned counsel for the appellant and the learned Government Pleader for the respondent).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the punishments of censure imposed on the appellant on 5 October 2004 and 17 March 2006 were sustainable in view of findings that the appellant was mentally unsound when the misconduct was committed.
- Whether the chargememo dated 30 June 1999 and the Government order dated 11 July 2006 permitting retirement on medical invalidation (effective 22 February 2002 A.N.) were valid and sustainable in law.
- Whether the appellant could be deprived, on the ground of medical invalidation, of the benefit of alternative employment and the salary and other benefits attached to such post until the date of his superannuation (31 August 2006).
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Narendra Kumar Chandla v. State of Haryana, 1994 (2) L.L.N. 746 | Establishes that Article 21 protects right to livelihood; where an employee becomes physically incapacitated while in service the employer must endeavour to adjust him to a suitable post and protect his last drawn pay (example given of relaxing typing test and appointing to a suitable post with pay protection). | The Court relied on this precedent to support the proposition that an employee incapacitated in service should be adjusted to a suitable post where feasible and that his last drawn pay should be protected when rehabilitation into an appropriate post is ordered. |
| Kunal Singh v. Union of India, 2003 (2) L.L.N. 324 | Interprets Section 47 of the Persons with Disabilities Act, 1995 as a mandatory protective provision: an establishment shall not dispense with or reduce in rank an employee who acquires a disability during service; provides for shifting to another post with same pay-scale or keeping on a supernumerary post until suitable post is available or superannuation. | The Court used the authority to emphasise the mandatory nature of S.47 and to conclude that statutory protection exists for employees who acquire disability during service; this informed the Court's view that the appellant's right to alternative employment is protected by S.47. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
- The Court first examined the punishments of censure imposed on 5 October 2004 and 17 March 2006. It found that those punishments were inflicted after it had been held that the appellant was mentally unsound when he committed the misconduct (as recorded in the chargememos dated 28 May 1999 and 14 December 1999). On that ground the Court concluded that the censure orders were liable to be set aside, and it set them aside.
- The Court then identified the remaining question: the validity of the chargememo dated 30 June 1999 and the Government order dated 11 July 2006 permitting retirement on medical invalidation effective 22 February 2002 A.N.
- The factual basis for the medical invalidation was the Regional Medical Board proceedings of 22 February 2002, which found the appellant unfit to continue in service due to a large ischemic infarction in the left middle cerebral artery territory causing severe aphasia, and noted that he was hypertensive and diabetic. The appellant’s superannuation date (but for invalidation) would have been 31 August 2006.
- The Court analysed the appellant’s right to continue in employment through the lens of the right to livelihood under Article 21 of the Constitution. It observed that Article 21 protects the right to livelihood as an integral facet of the right to life and linked this constitutional protection to statutory safeguards for disabled employees.
- The Court examined Section 47 of the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995, which provides (in terms reflected in the opinion) that an establishment shall not dispense with or reduce in rank an employee who acquires a disability during service; that such an employee may be shifted to another post with the same pay-scale and benefits if not suitable for the original post; and that if adjustment is not possible, the employee may be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is available or until superannuation.
- Relying on the cited precedents (Narendra Kumar Chandla and Kunal Singh), the Court emphasised the mandatory and protective nature of the statutory scheme and the constitutional right to livelihood. From this legal framework the Court concluded that an employee incapacitated during service is entitled to continuance of service in a suitable alternative post with the same pay-scale and service benefits.
- Applying these principles to the facts, the Court held that the appellant’s right to alternate employment could not be denied solely on the ground of medical invalidation. However, because the appellant was due to attain superannuation on 31 August 2006 (a short time after the date from which he was permitted to retire on medical invalidation), the Court declined to direct provision of alternative employment in the appellant’s case.
- Instead, the Court directed that the appellant is entitled to pension calculated on the basis of his last drawn salary for the entire period of service up to the date of superannuation, and that arrears of salary claimed before the Court in a specified sum be paid.
Holding and Implications
Final Disposition:
- The writ appeal is disposed of.
- The orders imposing punishment of censure on the appellant dated 5 October 2004 and 17 March 2006 are set aside.
- The Court directed the respondent to pay the balance salary amount of Rs. 1,86,608 to the appellant within three months from receipt of a copy of the order, and to pay the pension calculated on the basis of the appellant's last drawn salary.
- No costs were awarded.
Implications:
Direct effect on the parties: the appellant benefits from the setting aside of the two censure orders and is awarded payment of arrears and pension calculated on his last drawn salary up to superannuation. The Court affirmed the legal position that an employee who acquires disability during service has statutory and constitutional protection (Article 21 and Section 47 of the Persons with Disabilities Act, 1995) entitling such an employee to consideration for alternative employment with the same pay-scale and benefits; however, in the present factual matrix (imminent superannuation) the Court declined to order specific alternative employment and limited relief to monetary compensation and pension.
The opinion applies existing constitutional and statutory principles and cites controlling authorities to interpret and give effect to S.47 of the 1995 Act; it does not purport to announce a new legal principle beyond those authorities cited.
Disposed of.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
D. Murugesan, J.:— The appellant joined in the Medical Department on 4 August, 1966. He was issued with a chargememo dated 28 May, 1999 containing six charges under Rule 17(b) of the Tamil Nadu Civil Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules. As all the charges were held to be proved in the enquiry, finally, the Government in G.O (D) No. 1074, Health and Family Welfare (11) Department, dated 5 October, 2004, imposed the punishment of Censure on the appellant. He was also issued with another chargememo, dated 14 December, 1999, containing one charge, which was also held to be proved. Finally, the Government in G.O (D) No. 214, Health and Family Welfare (I-I) Department, dated 17 March, 2006 imposed the punishment of censure. The appellant was also issued with another chargememo, dated 30 June, 1999, containing twelve charges. In the enquiry, all the charges were held to be proved, as could be seen from the report of the enquiry officer, dated 2 February, 2002. While the matter was pending before the Government, a clarification was sought regarding the retirement of the appellant on medical invalidation. However, the Government refused to retire the appellant from service on the ground that the orders are to be passed in respect of the chargememo, dated 30 June, 1999. Ultimately, by order dated 11 July, 2006, the appellant was permitted to retire from service on medical invalidation with effect from 22 February, 2002 A.N, without prejudice to the disciplinary proceedings pending against him with a further direction permitting the appellant to draw provisional pension at the rate of Rs. 3,255.
2. We have heard the learned counsel for the appellant and the learned Government Pleader for the respondent.
3. In so far as the punishments of censure imposed on the appellant on 5 October, 2004 and 17 March, 2006, we are of the considered view that those punishments are liable to be set aside in view of the fact that they were inflicted even after holding that the appellant was mentally unsound when he had committed the misconduct, as contained in both the chargememos, dated 28 May, 1999 and 14 December, 1999. Hence we set aside both the orders imposing punishment of censure on the appellant.
4. In view of the above, the only question that remains to be considered is whether the chargememo, dated 30 June, 1999, and the final order, dated 11 July, 2006, permitting the appellant to retire from service on medical invalidation with effect from 22 February, 2002 A.N, are valid and could be sustained in the eye of law.
5. By an order, dated 11 July, 2006, the appellant was permitted to retire from service on medical invalidation. By the proceedings of the Regional Medical Board, Government General Hospital held on 22 February, 2002, the Medical Board found that the appellant was unfit to continue in service, as he has a large ischemic infarction left middle cerebral artery territory causing severe aphasia and he is also hypertensive and diabetic. But for the medical invalidation, the appellant would attain the age of superannuation only on 31 August, 2006.
6. On the above facts, it is now to be considered as to whether the appellant could be deprived of the benefit to alternate employment and consequently the salary and other benefits attached to such post on the ground of medical invalidation till the date of superannuation on 31 August, 2006.
7. The right of the appellant to continue in employment shall be considered with reference to his right to livelihood. Article 21 of the Constitution of India reads as follows:
“Article 21: Protection of life and personal liberty: No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.”
8. Article 21 protects “the right to livelihood as an integral facet of right to life”. Such right includes the right to live with human dignity. Such human dignity could be achieved only if there is a protection to the employment, of course, subject to disciplinary proceedings.
9. The Apex Court, while considering the absorption of an employee who is physically incapacitated'due to disease while in service, in Narendra Kumar Chandla v. State of Haryana, [1994 (2) L.L.N 746], has held as follows, in Para. 7, at page 748:
“Article 21 protects the right to livelihood as an integral facet of right to life. When an employee is afflicted with unfortunate disease due to which, when he is unable to perform the duties of the posts he was holding, the employer must make every endeavour to adjust him in a post in which the employee would be suitable to discharge the duties. Asking the appellant to discharge the duties as a carrier attendant is unjust. Since he is a matriculate, he is eligible for the post of LDC. For LDC, apart from matriculation, passing in typing test either in Hindi or English at the speed of 15/30 words per minute is necessary. For a clerk, typing generally is not a must. In view of the facts and circumstances of this case, we direct the respondent Board to relax his passing of typing test and to appoint him as LDC. Admittedly, on the date when he had an unfortunate operation, he was drawing the salary in the pay-scale of Rs. 1,40,02,300. Necessarily, therefore, his last drawn pay has to be protected. Since he has been rehabilitated in the post of LDC we direct the respondent to appoint him to the post of LDC protecting his scale of pay of Rs. 1,40,02,300 and direct to pay all the arrears of salary.”
10. Keeping the disability sustained by the employee while in service and the possibility of the employee losing his livelihood in mind, the Legislature enacted the “Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995. Section 47 of the said Act reads as under:
“47. Nondiscrimination in Government employments.— (1) No establishment shall dispense with, or reduce in rank, an employee who acquires a disability during his service:
Provided that, if an employee, after acquiring disability is not suitable for the post he was holding, could be shifted to some other post with same pay-scale and service benefits:
Provided further that if it is not possible to adjust the employee against any post, he may be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is available, or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier.
(2) No promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the ground of his disability:
Provided that the appropriate Government may, having regard to the type of work carried on in any establishment by notification and subject to such conditions, if any, as may be specified in such notification, exempt any establishment from the provisions of this section”.
11. Subsection (1) of S. 47 is clear in terms that “no establishment shall dispense with or reduce in rank, an employee who acquires a disability during his service. In fact under Subsec. (2), there is a right conferred to a person who sustained disablement even for promotion and no establishment shall deny promotion to a person merely on the ground of his disability. In fact, the scope of S. 47 came up for consideration before the Apex Court in the judgment in Kunal Singh v. Union of India, [2003 (2) L.L.N 324], wherein the Apex Court has held as follows:
“An employee, who acquires disability during his service, is sought to be protected under S. 47 of the Act specifically. Such employee, acquiring disability, if not protected, would not only suffer himself, but possibly all those who depend on him would also suffer. The very frame and contents of S. 47 clearly indicate its mandatory nature. The very opening part of section reads “no establishment shall dispense with, or reduce in rank, an employee who acquires disability during his service.” The section further provides that if an employee after acquiring disability is not suitable for the post he was holding, could be shifted to some other post with the same pay-scale and service benefits; if it is not possible to adjust the employee against any post, he will be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is available or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier. Added to this no promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the ground of his disability as is evident from Subsec. (2) of S. 47. Section 47 contains a clear directive that the employer shall not dispense with or reduce in rank an employee who acquires a disability during the service. In construing a provision of social beneficial enactment that too dealing with disabled persons intended to give them equal opportunities, protection of rights and full participation, the view that advances the object of the Act and serves its purpose must be preferred to the one which obstructs the object and paralyses the purposes of the Act. Language of S. 47 is plain and certain, casting statutory obligation on the employer to protect an employee acquiring disability during service.”
12. The right to livelihood which is an integral facet of right to life as guaranteed undet Art. 21, coupled with the protection under S. 47 of the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995 entitles the employee who was incapacitated during service, for continuance of service in suitable alternative post with same scale of pay drawn by him and other service benefits.
13. From the above discussions, we are of the considered view that the appellant's right to alternate employment cannot be deprived of solely on the ground of medical invalidation, as his right is protected under S. 47 of the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995. However, as the appellant is due to retire on 31 August, 2006, we are not inclined to direct the respondent to provide him with alternate employment, except directing that the appellant is entitled to pension as per the last drawn salary for the entire period of service calculated till the date of superannuation and the arrears of salary as furnished before us in a sum of Rs. 186.608
14. Accordingly, the writ appeal is disposed of with a direction to the respondent to pay the balance salary amount of Rs. 1,86,608 to the appellant within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and as well pay the pension calculated on the basis of the last drawn salary to the appellant. No costs.
Disposed of.
Alert