Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Selvi. R. Anbarasi v. The Chief Engineer (Personnel)

Madras High Court
Mar 28, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition seeks a writ of certiorarified mandamus to call for the records of the second respondent's order dated 17.10.2004, quash that order and direct respondents to provide compassionate appointment to the petitioner.

The petitioner's father, S. Rajendran, was employed as a helper in the respondent Board and died on 27.09.1996 while in service, leaving behind his legal heirs including the petitioner. The petitioner's mother made a representation requesting compassionate employment assistance which was rejected on 29.05.1998 by the second respondent on the ground that an educational qualification certificate produced by the petitioner's mother was not genuine. The petitioner contends that for the post of Sweeper no educational qualification is required.

The petitioner's mother subsequently made a representation on 25.03.1999 seeking compassionate appointment for the petitioner, but by letter dated 27.07.1999 the second respondent stated that the petitioner had not completed 18 years of age and therefore an application form could not be issued. After the petitioner attained 18 years and completed 12th standard, the petitioner's mother made a further representation on 11.10.2004. The second respondent rejected that request on 17.10.2004 on the ground the application was belated and not made within three years from the date of death of the petitioner's father. The present writ petition challenges the 17.10.2004 order.

The Court referred to an earlier judgment in W.P.No.1584/2001 (reported as 2004 (3) CTC 120 — T. Meer Ismail Ali Vs. The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board) where a similar issue was considered and the Court treated a subsequent application as a continuation of an original application made within three years when the earlier application had not been considered because the applicant was under 18 years of age. An appeal (W.A.No.4008/2004) against that judgment was dismissed by the Division Bench on 01.12.2004. The present Court applied that settled law and quashed the impugned order, directing respondents to issue compassionate appointment to the petitioner within six weeks. The writ petition was allowed and no costs were awarded.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an application for compassionate appointment submitted after three years from the date of death can be rejected as belated when an earlier application was made within three years but was not considered because the applicant had not then attained 18 years of age.
  2. Whether a subsequent application should be treated as a continuation of the original application for the purpose of compassionate appointment when the original application was made within the three year period but not acted upon for reasons related to the applicant's age.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner's mother had earlier sought compassionate appointment and the earlier application had been made within three years of the father's death; it was not considered at that time because the petitioner had not completed 18 years of age.
  • Relying on the earlier decision in W.P.No.1584/2001 (2004 (3) CTC 120 — T. Meer Ismail Ali Vs. The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board), the subsequent application should be treated as a continuation of the original application and therefore cannot be rejected as belated on the ground that it was submitted after three years.
  • For the post of Sweeper no educational qualification is required, so the issue earlier raised about the genuineness of the educational qualification certificate produced by the petitioner's mother is not material to the petitioner's claim.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
2004 (3) CTC 120 (T. Meer Ismail Ali Vs. The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board) The principle that where an application for compassionate appointment was made within three years but not considered because the applicant had not attained 18 years of age, a subsequent application should be treated as a continuation of the original application and cannot be rejected as belated. The Court relied on this settled law to quash the impugned 17.10.2004 order and directed the respondents to issue compassionate appointment to the petitioner within six weeks.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted the chronological facts: the father's death on 27.09.1996; the mother's initial representation and its rejection on 29.05.1998 for alleged non-genuine educational certificate; the 1999 correspondence indicating the petitioner was under 18; and the 11.10.2004 representation by the mother after the petitioner became eligible. The second respondent's 17.10.2004 rejection was founded on the three-year limitation from the date of death.

Relying on the Court's prior decision in W.P.No.1584/2001 (reported as 2004 (3) CTC 120) and the subsequent dismissal of W.A.No.4008/2004, the Court treated the later application as a continuation of the earlier application that had been made within three years but not considered because the petitioner was under 18 at that time. On that basis and in view of the settled law established by the cited judgment (which had been followed in a number of cases and had become final), the Court held the impugned order rejecting the application as belated was not tenable.

Accordingly, the Court quashed the 17.10.2004 order and directed the respondents to issue a compassionate appointment order to the petitioner according to her qualifications within six weeks from receipt of the copy of the Court's order.

Holding and Implications

Writ petition allowed; impugned order dated 17.10.2004 quashed; respondents directed to issue compassionate appointment to the petitioner within six weeks.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The respondents must issue the compassionate appointment order to the petitioner in accordance with her qualifications within six weeks of receiving a copy of the Court's order.
  • The Court applied settled law as reflected in the cited precedent (2004 (3) CTC 120). The opinion indicates that the earlier judgments have been followed in a number of cases and have become final. The order also records that no costs were awarded.
Show all summary ...

The prayer in this writ petition is to issue a writ of certiorarified mandamus calling for the records relating to the orders passed by the second respondent dated 17.10.2004 and quash the same and consequently direct the respondents to provide compassionate appointment to a suitable post to the petitioner.

2. The brief facts necessary for the disposal of this writ petition is that the petitioner's father, named S. Rajendran was employed as helper in the respondent Board and he died on 27.09.1996 by an accident while in service leaving behind the legal heirs, namely, the wife, three daughters, one son, mother and father. The petitioner's mother made a representation to the respondent Board requesting to provide employment assistance on compassionate ground to her. The said representation was rejected on 29.05.1998 by the second respondent on the ground that the educational qualification certificate produced by the petitioner's mother was not genuine. The case of the petitioner is that for the post of Sweeper, no educational qualification is required. However, the petitioner's mother did not press for compassionate appointment to her and she made a representation on 25.03.1999 to the second respondent and requested to give compassionate appointment to the petitioner. By letter dated 27.07.1999, the second respondent informed that the petitioner has not completed 18 years of age and therefore, the application form for compassionate appointment could not be issued. The petitioner after attaining the age of 18 years and completing 12th standard, the petitioner's mother made a representation on 11.10.2004 to the second respondent and prayed for issuing appointment order on compassionate ground to the petitioner. The second respondent rejected the said request on 17.10.2004 on the ground that the application was a belated one, i.e., the application was not made within a period of three years from the date of death of the petitioner's father. The said order is challenged in this writ petition.

3. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that a similar issue, rejecting the compassionate ground appointment on the ground that the application was submitted beyond three years and the same was rejected earlier on the ground that the petitioner therein has not completed 18 years of age, was considered by this Court in W.P.No.1584/2001 and this Court held that the applications having been made within a period of three years and the same having not been considered on the ground that the petitioner therein was not 18 years of age at that time, the subsequent application cannot be rejected on the ground that the application was submitted within three years. The learned Judge directed the respondents not to treat the second application as an application for compassionate appointment, but it is to be treated as continuation of the application originally submitted. The said Judgment is reported in 2004 (3) CTC 120 (T. Meer Ismail Ali Vs. The Tamil Nadu Electricity Board through its Chairman, No.800 Anna Salai, Chennai-2 and 2 others). This Court, ultimately, directed the respondents to give compassionate appointment to the petitioner therein.

4. The respondent herein filed W.A.No.4008/2004 against the said Judgment which was also dismissed by the Division Bench of this Court by order dated 01.12.2004. The said Judgments were subsequently followed in number of cases and the said Judgment has also become final.

5. In view of the settled law, the impugned order is quashed and the respondents are directed to issue compassionate appointment order to the petitioner as per her qualification within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.

6. The writ petition is allowed with the above direction. No costs.

To

1. The Chief Engineer (Personnel) Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, No.800, Anna Salai, Chennai-2.

2. The Superintending Engineer, Villupuram Electricity Distn. Circle, Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Villupuram-605 602.