Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. K. Bhuvanendran And Others

Madras High Court
Dec 14, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Judgment: Tax Case (Appeals) Nos. 2663 to 2665 of 2006 (Decided December 14, 2006)

Factual and Procedural Background

These appeals arise from Revenue appeals under section 260A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, against the order of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chennai ("D" Bench), dated March 17, 2006. The appeals raise common questions concerning the admissibility and effect of statements recorded under section 132(4) of the Income-tax Act and the consequences of subsequent retraction of such statements.

T.C. (A) No. 2663 of 2006 (Buyer: Sri K. Bhuvanendran): On March 19, 1999, a search was conducted at the assessee's residence. A notice under section 158BC was issued and, after being given time to file a return, the assessee filed Form No. 2B on November 19, 1999, declaring undisclosed income of Rs. 1,48,500. During the search the assessee is recorded to have admitted payment of Rs. 23,00,000 as "on-money" over and above the registered sale consideration of Rs. 34,00,000 for a commercial property purchased by his wife and sons. The Assessing Officer added Rs. 23,00,000 as undisclosed income for the relevant block period. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) deleted the addition; the Tribunal confirmed that deletion; Revenue appealed to this Court.

T.C. (A) Nos. 2664 and 2665 of 2006 (Sellers of the property): The respondents (sellers) filed returns for AY 1997-98 showing small incomes. On the basis of information arising from the buyer's search and his alleged admission of Rs. 23,00,000 on-money, surveys were conducted and the Assessing Officer completed assessments treating the sellers as having received on-money. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) set aside those assessments; the Tribunal confirmed the appeals in favour of the sellers; Revenue appealed to this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the statement made during the course of search under section 132(4) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, voluntarily by a person is admissible in evidence or not?
  2. Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the case, an admission made voluntarily relating to undisclosed income, not immediately retracted within a reasonable time, and retracted only after the service of summons during the course of recording statement, would itself negate the admission?

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue's Arguments

  • A mere denial by affidavit could not absolve the assessee from the consequence of sworn testimony recorded under section 132(4).
  • The assessee had admitted payment of on-money of Rs. 23,00,000 voluntarily during the search, without compulsion or undue influence; that admission is therefore reliable and can form the basis of assessment.
  • Accordingly, the Assessing Officer was justified in assessing Rs. 23,00,000 as undisclosed income in the block period (and in assessing the sellers on receipt of such on-money).

Assessee(s)' / Respondents' Arguments

  • The statement recorded during the search was subsequently retracted by the assessee by affidavit and during later statements; the retraction and denials were corroborated by the sellers and the seller of the property who denied receipt of any on-money.
  • No material or documentary evidence was found or seized during the search to support the alleged payment of on-money; the registered sale deed only disclosed Rs. 34,00,000 consideration and there was no evidence to show any additional amount was paid.
  • It is inequitable to tax on a notional or fictional income where no evidence shows the income arose or was received by the assessee (or sellers).

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the factual record, the orders of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal, and the materials placed before the Assessing Officer. The Court's analysis proceeded on the following lines, drawn from the Tribunal's findings which the Court adopted:

  1. Evidence Found in Search: The Tribunal and this Court accepted that no material or documentary evidence was discovered during the course of the search operation to prove that any on-money of Rs. 23,00,000 had passed in the sale transaction. The absence of seized material negatives reliance on the statement alone.
  2. Retraction and Rebuttal: The statement attributed to the buyer (the assessee in T.C. No. 2663) was subsequently retracted and the retraction was supported by later statements. The sellers and the recorded seller (Shri K. Jagannathan) also denied receipt of any on-money in recorded statements. The Tribunal found these retractions and denials relevant to evaluating the reliability of the initial admission.
  3. Statutory Standard under Section 158BB: The Tribunal interpreted section 158BB as making undisclosed income computable on the basis of "evidence found as a result of search or any other material or information available with the Assessing Officer and relatable to the evidence found during the course of search." Because no evidence or material was found during search and the statement was not relatable to any seized material, the Tribunal concluded the statement alone could not form the basis for determining undisclosed income.
  4. Burden of Proof and Sale Deed: The Tribunal emphasized that when a sale deed discloses a sale consideration, it is for the Revenue to show that what is disclosed in the sale deed is not the correct sale consideration. In the absence of any material to show understatement of sale consideration, the sale consideration must be accepted. The Tribunal relied on the general proposition that market price reflects agreement between willing buyer and seller; absent contrary material, the disclosed consideration stands.
  5. Assessment Against Sellers: For the seller assessments, the Tribunal found that additions were made only on the basis of the buyer's (alleged) statement; because that statement was retracted and there was no corroborative material, the Tribunal found no basis to sustain additions to the sellers' incomes.
  6. Conclusion on Legal Sufficiency: Based on the concurrent findings of the lower authorities — no material seized, retraction and rebuttal of statement, and the registered deed showing the disclosed consideration — the Court concluded there was no legal infirmity in the Tribunal's reasoning and no special factor warranting interference. The Tribunal's approach was thus upheld as based on valid materials and evidence.

Holding and Implications

All tax cases dismissed.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The Tribunal's order confirming the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) in deleting the addition of Rs. 23,00,000 (in T.C. (A) No. 2663) is affirmed by this Court.
  • The Tribunal's orders in favour of the sellers (T.C. (A) Nos. 2664 and 2665) are likewise affirmed; additions made by the Assessing Officer based solely on the buyer's statement were set aside in the absence of corroborative material.
  • No substantial question of law arises for the consideration of this Court, and the assessments challenged by the Revenue are dismissed accordingly.
  • The Court noted that, on the facts, the Revenue had not produced material to show understatement of sale consideration; hence it would be inequitable to tax alleged income that had not arisen or been received. The decision does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond the application of the statutory provisions and the established principle that evidence found during search (or material relatable thereto) is required to compute undisclosed income under section 158BB.
  • No costs were imposed; incidental miscellaneous petitions (T.C.M.P Nos. 1 of 2006 in the two appeals) were closed.

This summary is prepared exclusively from the provided judgment text and includes only information explicitly contained therein.

Show all summary ...

Tax Case (Appeals) Nos. 2663 to 2665 of 2006

Decided on December 14, 2006

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

P.P.S Janarthana Raja, J.:— These appeals are filed under section 260A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, by the Revenue against the order of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chennai, “D” Bench, dated March 17, 2006, in I.T (SS) A. No. 116.Mds/2002 for the block period April 1, 1988, to March 18, 1999, I.T.A No. 2270.Mds/2003 for the assessment year 1997-98 and I.T.A No. 796.Mds/2004 for the assessment year 1997-98, raising the following common substantial questions of law:

“1. Whether the statement made during the course of search under section 132(4) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, voluntarily by a person is admissible in evidence or not?

2. Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the case an admission made voluntarily relating to undisclosed income, not immediately retracted within a reasonable time, and was retracted only after the service of summons during the course of recording statement would itself negate the admission?”

T.C (A) No. 2663 of 2006:

2. The facts arising out of this appeal are as under:

(i) There was a search in the assessee's residential premises on March 19, 1999. Notice dated October 26, 1999, was issued under section 158BC of the Income-tax Act (“the Act” in short) to the assessee on October 28, 1999, giving 40 days time for filing the return. Subsequently, the assessee filed a return in Form No. 2B on November 19, 1999, declaring an undisclosed income of Rs. 1,48,500. The assessee did not specifically include the sum of Rs. 23 lakhs as undisclosed income in the return even though he admitted the payment of the said amount relating to the purchase of a property at door Nos. 8 and 9, Arunachala Asari Street, Salem, by his wife, Rajalakshmi, and his sons, K.B Srinivasan and B. Sakthivel, over and above the amount of Rs. 34 lakhs disclosed in the sale deed. Based on the admission, the Assessing Officer added the amount of Rs. 23 lakhs as undisclosed income for the assessment year 1997-98 of the block period April 1, 1988, to March 18, 1999. Aggrieved by the order, the assessee filed an appeal to the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals). The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) allowed the appeal and directed the Assessing Officer to delete the addition of Rs. 23 lakhs. Aggrieved, the Revenue filed an appeal to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (“the Tribunal” in short). The Tribunal dismissed the Revenue's appeal and confirmed the order of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals).

(ii) Learned standing counsel appearing for the Revenue submitted that a mere denial of payment of on-money over and above Rs. 34 lakhs mentioned in the document, by filing an affidavit could not absolve the assessee from the consequences of the sworn testimony recorded under section 132(4) of the Act. Further it is submitted that the assessee had no case to retract that the on-money has not been paid later and also the assessee himself has accepted that the admission given by him before the Deputy Director of Income-tax (Investigation) on the date of search is purely voluntary and not out of compulsion, or there is no undue influence on the assessee. Further it is contended, no more is necessary to prove and hence, the Revenue is right in assessing the sum of Rs. 23 lakhs as undisclosed income for the block period.

(iii) Heard counsel. In July, 1996, the wife and the two sons of the assessee purchased a commercial complex at door Nos. 8 and 9, Arunachala Asari Street, Salem, for a sum of Rs. 34 lakhs. In a statement recorded during the course of search, the assessee stated that a sum of Rs. 23 lakhs was paid over and above the registered value shown in the document and also admitted that the same would be offered as undisclosed income for the block period. Later on, the assessee did not offer this amount in the return for the block period, by a subsequent retraction by filing an affidavit. On the facts, we found in the statement recorded on February 8, 2001, from the assessee, that the assessee had reached Salem from Chennai at 6.15 a.m on March 19, 1999 and soon after the arrival, the search officials arrived at his premises at 7.30 a.m placing two police officials with guns at the entrance of his house. The assessee did not have peaceful sleep during the train journey because of stomach pain due to gastric ulcer and was restless. The assessee was told by the search officials that the proceedings will be completed smoothly if he agrees that there is on-money payment of Rs. 23 lakhs. Hence, the assessee also admitted the same, without being aware of the consequences. Further, the assessee made a statement that he was physically and mentally nervous and did not know what he answered and also denied on February 8, 2001, that neither he nor any of his family members made any on-money payment. Further, it is seen from the record that the assessee is not the owner of the property and only his wife and children are the co-owners. Later, on January 4, 2001, all the three co-owners have also categorically denied payment of any on-money to the seller over and above Rs. 34 lakhs mentioned in the registered document. Two statements were recorded from Shri K. Jagannathan, the seller, on April 23, 1999, as well as on February 8, 2001, and he has also categorically stated that neither he nor any of his family members received any on-money from the buyer. Further, there is no documentary evidence found or discovered during the course of search to prove that on-money has passed in the sale transaction. There is no basis for making addition by way of undisclosed income. The Assessing Officer had only relied on the statement of a person who is not a party to the immovable transaction and hence, there is no basis for determining the undisclosed income for the block period. The following factors emerges from the facts of the case:

(a) No material found during the course of search;

(b) Statement recorded from the assessee was subsequently retracted and rebutted;

(c) Registered sale deed does not show any payment more than what was disclosed.

3. Taking into consideration of the above factors including the fact that the Revenue could not bring on record any material or evidence to show that the assessee had paid on-money of Rs. 23 lakhs, we are of the view that the statement which is not relatable to seized material could not be a basis for making any addition in the block assessment.

4. Both the first appellate authority as well as the Tribunal had given a concurrent finding. Paragraphs Nos. 4 and 5 of the order of the Tribunal reads as under:

“4. Admittedly, no material was found during the course of search operation. The statement said to be recorded from the assessee was subsequently retracted and rebutted. The registered sale deed does not show any payment more than above what was disclosed. In the absence of any material, in our opinion, there cannot be any addition as undisclosed income.

5. Section 158BB of the Income-tax Act provides for computation of undisclosed income. According to section 158BB, undisclosed income shall be the aggregate of the total income of the previous years falling within the block period computed in accordance with the provisions of the Income-tax Act on the basis of the evidence found as a result of search or any other material or information available with the Assessing Officer and relatable to the evidence found during the course of search. In this case, admittedly, there is no evidence or material found during the course of search operations. The statement recorded from the assessee was subsequently retracted and rebutted. Further more, the statement is not relatable to any seized material. Therefore, even the statement cannot be the basis for making any addition. When the sale deed discloses a sale consideration, it is for the Revenue to show that what was disclosed in the sale deed is not correct sale consideration. In this case, the Revenue could not bring on record any material to show that the assessee has paid on-money of Rs. 23,00,000. Therefore, in our opinion, the learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) has rightly deleted the addition. We do not find any infirmity in the order of the learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals). Accordingly, we confirm the same.”

5. From a reading of the above, it is evident that the reasons given by the Tribunal are based on valid materials and evidence and hence we do not find any error or legal infirmity in the order of the Tribunal and there is no special factor or compelling reason which warrants interference of the impugned order of the Tribunal. Hence, no substantial questions of law arise for consideration of this court and accordingly, the tax case is dismissed.

T.C (A) Nos. 2664 and 2665 of 2006:

6. The facts arising out of these appeals are as under:

(i) The respondents in both these appeals are sellers of the said property situated at door Nos. 8 and 9, Arunachala Asari Street, Salem. The relevant assessment year involved in both these appeals is 1997-98 and the corresponding accounting year ended on March 31, 1997. The assessees in T.C Nos. 2664 of 2006 and 2665 of 2006, filed returns of income admitting total income of Rs. 62,640 and Rs. 75,900, respectively, on March 31, 1999, for the assessment year 1997-98. The returns were processed under section 143(1)(a) of the Act and, subsequently, notices under section 148 were issued on the basis of the information received from the Deputy Director of Income-tax that a survey was conducted in the business premises of the assessees consequent to the information gathered at the time of search in the case of Sri K. Bhuvanendran, the assessee in T.C (A) No. 2663 of 2006. At the time of search, the said Bhuvanendran had admitted, while replying to question No. 2 in the sworn statement recorded on March 19, 1999, that his sons Sri K.B Sreenivasan and B. Sakthivel and his wife Smt. B. Rajalakshmi had purchased a property at 8 and 9, Arunachala Asari Street, Salem, for a sum of Rs. 34 lakhs as registered value and also paid Rs. 23 lakhs as on-money to purchase the above property. In consequence of the same, a survey was conducted in the business premises of the sellers, the respondents herein, on April 23, 1999. The assessees denied the receipt of on-money from the purchasers. The Assessing Officer was of the view that the on-money of Rs. 23 lakhs had been passed on to the sellers and hence the assessments were completed accordingly. Aggrieved by the orders, the assessees filed appeals to the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals). The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) allowed the appeals and set aside the orders of assessment. Aggrieved, the Revenue filed appeals to the Tribunal. The Tribunal dismissed the appeals of the Revenue and confirmed the orders of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals).

(ii) Learned standing counsel appearing for the Revenue submitted that the Revenue is right in making assessments on the basis of the statement made by the buyer and hence, the assessments are in accordance with law.

(iii) Heard counsel. The Tribunal considered all the relevant materials and facts and come to a correct conclusion that there is no material available for the Revenue to assess the same. Paragraph No. 6 of the order of the Tribunal reads as follows:

“6. Now, coming to I.T.A Nos. 2270.Mds/2003 and 796.Mds/2004, these appeals relates to the vendors of the property. The addition was made only on the basis of the statement said to be made by Shri Bhuvanendran on March 19, 1999. Admittedly, the said Shri Bhuvanendran retracted the statement. No other material was available to show that any on-money was paid. The Assessing Officer found that the property was located in a busy commercial locality and the market price is much more than the price quoted in the document. It is well-settled principles of law that market is nothing but the price agreed between a willing purchaser and a willing seller. Therefore, it is for the purchaser and the seller to determine the market price after taking into consideration of the locality of the property. The State Revenue authorities after considering the transaction accepted the market price disclosed in the sale deed. Therefore, the burden of proof is on the Revenue to show what is apparent is not real. In other words, the sale consideration disclosed in the sale deed cannot be rejected without any material to show that the sale consideration disclosed in the sale deed was not correct. In this case admittedly no material was available to show that the sale consideration disclosed in the sale deed was not correct. In those facts and circumstances in our opinion the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) has rightly deleted the addition. Accordingly, we do not find any infirmity in the order of the lower authority.”

7. The reasoning of the Tribunal is based on valid materials and evidence. In the present cases, the Revenue failed to establish that there is actually on-money passed on to the seller and also there is no evidence to show that there is understatement of sale consideration in the document. If the Revenue is able to produce evidence to show that there is understatement of sale consideration in the document, the Revenue may be right in inferring that on-money has been passed on to the seller. It would be otherwise harsh and inequitable to tax the assessee on income which has neither arisen to him nor is received by him. It amounts to tax on notional or fictional income. Hence, we do not find any error or legal infirmity in the order of the Tribunal so as to warrant interference. Hence, no substantial questions of law arise for consideration of this court and accordingly, the tax cases are dismissed.

8. Under the circumstances, all the tax cases are dismissed. Consequently, T.C.M.P No. 1 of 2006 in T.C (A) No. 2664 of 2006 and T.C.M.P No. 1 of 2006 in T.C (A) No. 2665 of 2006 are closed. No costs.