Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sri Ram.A (Minor) Rep. v. State Of Tamil Nadu Another

Madras High Court
Sep 1, 2005
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Writ Petitions Seeking Inclusion of "Grandchildren of Freedom Fighters" in Prospectus (Academic Year 2005-06)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a batch of writ petitions in which the petitioners sought inclusion of "the grandchildren of Freedom Fighters" in the prospectus for consideration, selection and admission to professional courses (medical, dental and engineering) for the academic year 2005-06. Historically, the State's yearly "Policy Government Orders" (issued under Article 162 of the Constitution) set norms for admission, and until the academic year 2003-04 the Government had reserved three seats in medical/dental courses for the children/grandchildren of Freedom Fighters. From 2004-05 onwards, the Government limited that reservation to the children of Freedom Fighters; the 2005-06 prospectus similarly reserved seats only for children of Freedom Fighters and enumerated documentary requirements for such candidates. Petitioners contended that the benefit previously extended to grandchildren was unjustly withdrawn, argued there were few or no eligible children of Freedom Fighters left, and alleged discrimination because grandchildren were made eligible for Teacher Training Courses. The writ petitions were heard by the Court and, after considering legal principles and precedents, the petitions were dismissed. The order records that all writ petitions fail and are dismissed; no costs; connected writ miscellaneous petitions (W.P.M.Ps.) are also dismissed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prospectus for the academic year 2005-06 should include "grandchildren of Freedom Fighters" as a source of admission (i.e., whether the Government's omission of grandchildren from the special-category reservation can be judicially remedied).
  2. Whether the petitioners can claim, as a matter of right, continuation of a concession (reservation) that had been extended to grandchildren in earlier years.
  3. Whether the Court may direct the Executive/Government to amend the prospectus or fix the source of admission for a particular special category (i.e., whether the Court can legislate or substitute its own policy judgment for that of the Government).
  4. Whether the Government's differing treatment of grandchildren across different professional courses (e.g., allowing grandchildren for Teacher Training but not for medical/engineering courses) constitutes prohibited discrimination.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners argued that the benefit previously extended to grandchildren of Freedom Fighters had been unjustly taken away by the Government in the 2005-06 prospectus.
  • Counsel for the petitioners submitted that in the recent years there were no eligible candidates falling under the "children of Freedom Fighters" category, and that, given the passage of time (about 53 years since independence), there may be few or no children of Freedom Fighters left who meet eligibility and qualification criteria; thus, excluding grandchildren defeats the purpose of the concession.
  • They further argued that the Government's decision was discriminatory because the prospectus and policy made grandchildren eligible for the Teacher Training Course, yet the same benefit was withheld for medical/dental/engineering courses.

State/Government Position (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The State issues yearly policy Government Orders under Article 162 and may determine the number of seats, eligibility, source of admission and other admission norms for each professional course.
  • The Government, in exercise of its executive and policy-making powers, limited the special-category reservation in the prospectus for the 2005-06 academic year to "children of Freedom Fighters" (excluding grandchildren) for medical/dental/engineering courses.
  • The opinion records the legal position (supported by authorities) that the State is entitled to identify and fix the source of admission for each course and may treat different courses differently in fixing eligibility/source of admission.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K. Suganthi v. State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary and Commissioner to Dept. of Health and Medical Education (1984 Writ L.R. 249) Establishes that the prospectus is binding on students, the Government and selection authorities; it contains the summary of norms and rules for selection and is enforceable. Cited to support the proposition that the prospectus is a binding document and that its norms are to be followed by the authorities and the Government.
Dr. A. Rathnaswamy v. Director of Medical Education, Madras and others (1986 Writ L.R. 207) Also cited for the binding character of the prospectus and the need to follow its norms. Used as authority for the binding nature of the prospectus and that selection procedures must be adhered to.
Midhuna Nathan v. State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary, Department of Health, Fort St. George, Madras and others (1995 Writ L.R. 851) Cited for the binding nature of the prospectus; also later cited among authorities that the Court should not direct legislation or amend executive policy. Cited to support both that the prospectus binds the parties and that judicial intervention cannot substitute for legislative or executive policy-making.
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Chandra Mohan and others (Supreme Court) Holds that prescribed procedures under rules should be strictly followed and authorities cannot ignore them. Relied upon to emphasize that admission procedures and rules are to be respected and followed.
Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. The International Airport Authority of India and others (Supreme Court) Also cited for the principle that procedural rules must be strictly followed by authorities. Used to support the requirement of adherence to prescribed procedures in selection processes.
P.A. Manickam v. The Government of Tamil Nadu rep. by the Deputy Secretary, Home Department, Madras (1984 Writ L.R. 1) Cited alongside Supreme Court authorities for the proposition that procedures/rules should be followed and that courts should not intrude into executive policy-making. Cited to buttress the point that the Court cannot amend or rewrite executive policies or prospectuses.
R. Chitralekha v. State of Mysore and others (Supreme Court) Recognises the power of the Government to identify the source of admission. Cited to support the proposition that the State can determine the source of admission for professional courses.
Minor P. Rajendran v. State of Madras and others (Supreme Court) Also recognises the State's power to identify the source of admission. Cited to show judicial recognition of the executive's competence in fixing sources of admission.
Kumari Chitra Ghosh and Anr. v. Union of India and others (Supreme Court) Another authority recognising the Government's power regarding source of admission. Applied as part of the body of precedent affirming executive competence in admission policy.
Krishna Priya Ganguly etc. v. University of Lucknow and others (Supreme Court) Recognises Governmental authority to determine source of admission. Used to underline the State's entitlement to fix admission sources for courses.
M.Aarthi (Minor) rep. by her mother v. The State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary to Government, Health & Family Welfare Department, Chennai and others (2002 (4) CTC 449) — Full Bench Full Bench held that beyond the reservations enacted in Tamil Nadu Act 45 of 1994, permissible reservations by executive are limited to certain horizontal categories (physically handicapped, eminent sportsmen, children of Freedom Fighters and children of ex-servicemen); executive cannot create additional special category seats or increase the quantum of reservation beyond the Act. Relied upon to limit the executive's power to create or expand special-category reservations and to characterise certain reservations as concessions rather than enforceable rights.
T.T. Saravanan, Minor rep. by his father and natural guardian Dr. G.T. Thangarajan and others v. State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary to Government, Health and Family Welfare Department, Chennai and others (2005 Writ L.R. 69) Held that special-category reservations are benefits or concessions to identified groups and are not constitutional obligations equivalent to reservations under Article 15(4) and Article 16(4). The Court agreed with this reasoning and relied on it to reject the contention that the exclusion of grandchildren was unreasonable or that grandchildren had an enforceable right to continued concession.
Miss Romini Susan Kurian v. State of A.P. and others Cited for the proposition that courts should not direct legislation and that legislation is the exclusive domain of the Legislature. Applied to hold that it is not within the Court's jurisdiction to direct the Government to legislate or to amend prospectuses under Article 162; the Court cannot substitute its policy choice for that of the Government.
G. Sumathi v. The Director of Medical Education, Madras and others Cited among authorities supporting the limited role of the Court vis-à-vis executive/legislative policy-making in admission norms. Used to reinforce the principle that courts should not direct executive policy or legislate by judicial order.
P. Nithiyan (Minor) rep. by father R. Palanisamy v. The State of Tamil Nadu rep. by Secretary to Government, Education Department, Chennai and others (1994 Writ L.R. 624) Supports the proposition that the Government may fix different sources of admission for different professional courses. Relied upon by the Court to reject the petitioners' discrimination argument arising from differential treatment of grandchildren across courses (e.g., Teacher Training vs medical/engineering courses).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in a series of legally grounded steps, applying constitutional and precedent-based principles to the facts disclosed by the prospectus and the petitions.

  1. The Court first set out the administrative context: annual policy Government Orders (under Article 162) determine admission norms for each professional course, including number of seats, eligibility and source of admission. The State may also make special provisions under Article 15(4) for advancement of socially and educationally backward classes and scheduled castes/tribes.
  2. The Court recited the factual history: earlier reservations had included children and grandchildren of Freedom Fighters for certain years; from 2004-05 the Government limited the special-category reservation in medical/dental/engineering to children (excluding grandchildren) and the 2005-06 prospectus reflected that limitation, together with documentary requirements for claiming the category.
  3. The petitioners' core grievances were stated: (a) that grandchildren had been unjustly deprived of a previously available concession; (b) that there were few or no eligible children remaining making exclusion of grandchildren unreasonable; and (c) that differential treatment between courses (grandchildren allowed for Teacher Training but not medical/engineering) was discriminatory.
  4. The Court recalled the settled legal position that a prospectus is binding on students, the Government and selection authorities and that prescribed procedures must be followed. It cited a line of authorities to support this proposition; however, the Court distinguished between enforceable reservations under Article 15(4)/Article 16(4) and executive concessions.
  5. The Court examined the scope of executive power to identify the source of admission, citing several Supreme Court decisions that recognise this power. The Court noted that the State, which runs most professional colleges, is entitled to restrict admission and to distribute seats among eligible candidates and to identify the source of admission.
  6. The Court relied on the Full Bench decision in M.Aarthi to explain limits on the executive's power to create reservations: beyond the reservations enacted in Tamil Nadu Act 45 of 1994, permissible executive-created special categories are limited and the executive cannot create additional special-category seats or expand the quantum of reservation provided by the statute. The Court observed that reservations like those for sportsmen, ex-servicemen and Freedom Fighters are concessions extended by the Government.
  7. Addressing whether the concession (to grandchildren) could be claimed as a matter of right, the Court reasoned that such concessions previously extended by Government Orders do not automatically transform into a perpetual entitlement. Judicially directing legislation or compelling the Government to adopt a particular admission source or to amend the prospectus is beyond the Court's jurisdiction. The Court cited authorities holding that the Court should not legislate or amend executive policy and that prospectus changes fall within executive competence under Article 162.
  8. The Court rejected the petitioners' argument that exclusion of grandchildren was unreasonable, relying on authority (T.T. Saravanan) holding that special-category reservations are benefits/concessions and not constitutional obligations; the Court stated agreement with that view.
  9. On the discrimination point, the Court explained that different professional courses have differing seat availability and institutional arrangements; accordingly, the Government is competent to fix different sources of admission for each course. The Court cited P. Nithiyan in support of this proposition and held that eligibility for grandchildren in Teacher Training could not automatically entitle grandchildren to the same treatment in medical or engineering admissions.
  10. Concluding its analysis, the Court found no legal basis to order inclusion of grandchildren in the 2005-06 prospectus or to direct the Government to consider grandchildren for selection. The petitions were therefore dismissed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: All writ petitions are dismissed. The Court found no merit in the petitioners' request to include "grandchildren of Freedom Fighters" in the prospectus for academic year 2005-06 and dismissed all connected writ miscellaneous petitions. The order records "No costs."

Direct Consequences for the Parties

  • The petitioners' requests for judicial direction to include grandchildren of Freedom Fighters in the medical/dental/engineering prospectus for 2005-06 were denied.
  • The prospectus as issued — which reserves specified seats for "children of Freedom Fighters" and lists documentary requirements for those candidates — stands for the 2005-06 admissions covered by these petitions.

Broader Implications Noted by the Court

The opinion does not elaborate broader legal or policy changes beyond these cases. The Court emphasized established principles: (a) concessions by the executive (special-category reservations) are not equivalent to constitutional reservations under Articles 15(4) and 16(4); (b) the executive has the competence to identify sources of admission and to vary them across courses; and (c) courts should not direct the executive to legislate or to amend prospectuses. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities to the facts.

Show all summary ...

1. In this batch of writ petitions, the petitioners have made one more attempt for inclusion of "the grandchildren of Freedom Fighters" in the prospectus for consideration, selection and admission to the professional courses like medicine and engineering for the academic year 2005-06.

2. In exercise of powers under Article 162 of The Constitution of India, the State Government issues each year the Government Orders, which are normally known as "Policy Government Orders" containing norms for admission of candidates to various professional courses. Such Government Orders include the number of seats to be filled in, the colleges in which such seats are filled, eligibility, educational qualification, age restriction, the source of admission, etc. The State, under Article 15(4), could make any special provision for the advancement of any socially and educationally backward classes of citizens or for the scheduled castes or scheduled tribes, which is known as "communal reservation". Till the academic year 2003-04, the Government, in exercise of the powers under Article 15(4), reserved three seats in medical/dental courses for the children/grandchildren of Freedom Fighters. It appears that from the academic year 2004-05, the Government have reserved three seats in medical/dental courses only to the children of Freedom Fighters. The same reservation is followed for admission to the medical/dental courses for the academic year 2005-06 as well. Similarly, certain number of seats were reserved for the children/grandchildren of Freedom Fighters for selection and admission to engineering courses till the academic year 2004-05 and, for the current academic year, the Government had decided to earmark those seats only to the children of Freedom Fighters.

3. Clause 15 of the prospectus for the academic year 2005-06 relating to medical/dental courses, which is put in issue, reads as follows:-

"SEATS RESERVED FOR SPECIAL CATEGORIES IN GOVERNMENT COLLEGES:

Seats earmarked for the special categories will be allotted following Horizontal Reservation.

SPECIAL CATEGORIES:

(i) SEATS RESERVED FOR CHILDREN OF Freedom Fighters:

NO. OF SEATS RESERVED IN M.B.B.S. - 3 The candidates while applying under the Special Category mentioned above should furnish the following copies of documents along with the application.

a. Assistance Certificates/Freedom Fighter Pension Orders issued by the Central/State Government to the freedom fighter.

(OR) Jail Extract duly recommended by the District Committee for the Freedom Fighters.

b. Particulars of the Freedom Fighter in the book containing Freedom Fightersnames published by Government of Tamil Nadu.

c. Proof that the candidate is the child of the Freedom Fighter.

d. Tahsildar Certificate to establish the relationship with the Freedom Fighter.

e. Birth Certificate to ascertain the parentage of the candidate.

f. Legal heir certificate of the Freedom Fighter.

..."

Similar is the clause for admission to engineering courses.

4. The grievance of the petitioners is that the benefit hitherto given to the grandchildren of Freedom Fighters have been unjustly taken away, especially when the present clause itself is not workable. The respective counsel, in support of the above grievance, would submit that in the last year and in the current academic year, there were no candidates eligible to apply for admission to medical courses in the category of children of Freedom Fighters. They would submit that there may not be children of Freedom Fighters after nearly 53 years with eligibility conditions and qualifications for being considered for admission. The further grievance of the petitioners is that when a provision entitling grandchildren of Freedom Fighters is made for admission to the Teacher Training Course, the decision of the Government in not extending the same benefit to the students opting for medical/dental/engineering courses would be discriminatory.

5. It is well settled law that the prospectus, which is a piece of information to the candidates, containing summary and essence of the norms and rules by which the applications of candidates for selection would be considered, is binding not only on the students, but also on the Government and as well on the authorities involved in the process of selection. This consistent view had been taken in number of cases. To quote, the following are few of them.

(1)

" K. Suganthi v. State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary and Commissioner to Dept. of Health and Medical Education, Madras-9 and two Ors. (1984 Writ L.R. 249"
.

(2) "Dr. A. Rathnaswamy v. Director of Medical Education, Madras and three Ors. (1986 Writ L.R. 207".

(3)

" Midhuna Nathan v. State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary, Department of Health, Fort St. George, Madras and seven Ors. (1995 Writ L.R. 851)"
.

It is also equally well settled that the procedures prescribed under the rules should be strictly followed and the authorities cannot ignore the same, as has been held by the Supreme Court in the decisions in "State of Uttar Pradesh v. Chandra Mohan and Ors. ", in "Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. The International Airport Authority of India and Ors. " as well by a Full Bench of this Court in the decision in "P.A. Manickam v. The Government of Tamil Nadu rep. by the Deputy Secretary, Home Department, Madras (1984 Writ L.R. 1)".

6. The power of the Government to identify the source of admission is well recognised by the Supreme Court in the following judgments:-

(1) "R. Chitralekha v. State of Mysore and Ors. ".

(2) "Minor P. Rajendran v. State of Madras and Ors. ".

(3) "Kumari Chitra Ghosh and Anr. v. Union of India and Ors. ".

(4) "Krishna Priya Ganguly etc., v. University of Lucknow and Ors. etc., ".

7. The State, which is running most of the professional colleges, is entitled to restrict the admission and distribute the seats equally from among the eligible candidates. For the said purpose, the State is empowered to identify the source of admission. The normal rule is merit-based admission. However, the State, in exercise of its legislative power, has enacted the Tamil Nadu Backward Classes Schedule Castes and Schedule Tribes (Reservation of Seats in Educational Institutions and of Appointments or Posts in the Services under the State) Act, 1993 (Tamil Nadu Act 45 of 1994) providing 69% reservation to various communities and leaving 31% to open category. The power of the State to earmark certain number of seats under special category came up for consideration before a Full Bench of this Court in the decision in "M.Aarthi (Minor) rep. by her mother and natural guardian Mrs. M. Renuka and 2 Ors. v. The State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary to Government, Health & Family Welfare Department, Chennai and 11 Ors. (2002 (4) CTC 449)". By a majority, the Full Bench held that "other than the reservation in Tamil Nadu Act 45 of 1994, what is permissible is only for physically handicapped, eminent sportsmen, children of Freedom Fighters and children of ex-servicemen being horizontal reservation and the executive power of the State no longer would be available to create additional special category seats or to add the quantum of reservation provided in the act 45 of 1994". Even the reservation under the above categories, the right for reservation for physically handicapped viz., disabled persons could be traced to the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995. So far as the reservation of seats to sportsmen, children/grandchildren of ex-servicemen and Freedom Fighters is concerned, it would be only a concession extended to them by the Government.

8. How far the said concession could be claimed as a matter of right is a further question that arises for consideration. Of course, the Government, in its wisdom while issuing policy Government Orders, had earmarked certain number of seats to the children/grandchildren of Freedom Fighters in the previous years. On that account, whether the petitioners would be well within their rights to claim the extension of the same benefit to all the years to come? In my opinion, it cannot be for the following reasons.

9. Law is well settled that this Court, in exercise of its powers, shall not enter upon to direct legislation in a particular subject, as legislation on a subject is the exclusive jurisdiction of the Legislature, as has been held in various judgments, more particularly, in "Miss.Romini Susan Kurian v. State of A.P. And Ors. ", in

" Midhuna Nathan v. State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary, Department of Health, Fort St. George, Madras and seven Ors. (1995 Writ L.R. 851)"
and in "G.Sumathi v. The Director of Medical Education, Madras and Ors. ". It will not be within the jurisdiction of the Court either to amend, alter or to add something into the prospectus, as it would be the function of the State in exercise of the powers under Article 162 of The Constitution of India. Either the challenge or the direction for inclusion of grandchildren of Freedom Fighters, ex-servicemen has no legs in the context that the petitioners cannot firstly insist the Government to identify the source of admission under special category in a particular manner or request the Court to direct the Government to identify and earmark certain number of seats for a particular special category of persons.

10. So far as the unreasonableness is concerned, my attention is drawn to a similar challenge made before this Court in a batch of writ petitions and this Court had repelled the said contention in the decision in

"T.T. Saravanan, Minor rep. by his father and natural guardian Dr. G.T. Thangarajan and 4 Ors. v. State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary to Government, Health and Family Welfare Department, Chennai and Ors. ( 2005 Writ L.R.69)"
, where the learned single Judge held that the special category reservations are more in the nature of benefits given to certain identified group of persons and there is no constitutional obligation as in the case of reservation under Article 15(4) and Article 16(4) of The Constitution of India. I am entirely in agreement with the said judgment.

11. So far as the discrimination is concerned, it is the contention of the respective learned counsel that the grandchildren of Freedom Fighters were made eligible for admission to the Teacher Training Course. In the policy note of the Government for the academic year 2005-06, the Government have come out with a policy of reserving certain number of seats for the grandchildren of Freedom Fighters and the said policy was not reflected in the prospectus. It must be kept in mind that the policy of the Government in prescribing the admission norms particularly, the eligibility, educational qualification, age restriction, etc., identifying the source of admission shall depend upon the number of seats available vis-a-vis number of colleges established. Each professional course is different and the Government is competent to fix different source of admission for each course. This proposition of law is supported by the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in

"P.Nithiyan (Minor) rep. by father and natural guardian R. Palanisamy v. The State of Tamil Nadu rep. by Secretary to Government, Education Department, Chennai and Ors. ( 1994 Writ L.R. 624)"
. Merely because the Government had made the grandchildren of Freedom Fighters eligible for selection and admission to Teacher Training Course, it cannot be a ground for the petitioners to seek for extension of the said benefit to the medical or engineering course, as the case may be.

12. For all the above reasons, I find absolutely no merits in the grievance of the petitioners for inclusion of the grandchildren of Freedom Fighters in the prospectus 2005-06 and to consider them for selection. Accordingly, all the writ petitions fail and the same are dismissed. No costs. Consequently, all the connected W.P.M. Ps. are also dismissed.