Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Managing Director, T... v. Abdul Salam And Others

Madras High Court
Jan 29, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 19.1.1995, at approximately 11:00 a.m., the deceased was traveling as one of the pillion riders on a motorcycle when it was struck by a bus owned by the appellant Corporation, driven rashly and negligently in the opposite direction. The impact caused the deceased to be thrown off the motorcycle, resulting in death on the spot. The legal representatives of the deceased filed a claim petition seeking compensation on the basis that the deceased earned Rs. 3,000 per month and his death caused loss of contribution to his family. The appellant contested the claim, arguing that the accident was caused by the rash and negligent driving of the motorcycle rider who was attempting to overtake a lorry while carrying three persons, which was illegal and contributed to loss of control. The Tribunal found the accident was due to the bus driver's rash and negligent driving, assessed the deceased’s age as 23, estimated his income at Rs. 2,000 per month after discounting unsubstantiated claims, and awarded a total compensation of Rs. 2,20,000, including funeral and loss of love and affection expenses. The appellant filed the present appeal challenging the compensation award and the Tribunal’s findings on contributory negligence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the deceased’s illegal act of traveling as one of three persons on a motorcycle, which is meant for two persons, constitutes contributory negligence affecting the compensation claim.
  2. Whether the Tribunal erred in awarding full compensation without reducing it for contributory negligence on the part of the deceased and other riders.
  3. Whether traveling with three persons on a motorcycle can be a ground to deny or reduce compensation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The deceased was one of three persons traveling on a motorcycle designed for two, which is illegal and unauthorized.
  • The motorcycle rider’s rash and negligent driving in overtaking caused the accident, not the bus driver alone.
  • The presence of three persons on the motorcycle impaired the rider’s control, contributing to the accident.
  • Compensation should be reduced or denied due to this contributory negligence, as the act violated statutory provisions and insurance policy conditions.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The deceased was a pillion rider and cannot be attributed any negligence.
  • There is no evidence of negligence on the part of the motorcycle rider.
  • Traveling with three persons on a motorcycle is common and should not be a basis to deny compensation.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged the commonality of three persons traveling on a motorcycle but emphasized that legally a motorcycle is meant for only two persons: the rider and one pillion rider. The Court found that carrying three persons is illegal and unauthorized, causing cramped seating that restricts the rider’s control over the vehicle’s brakes and steering. The Court noted that unusual movements by the two pillion riders could further destabilize the motorcycle. The Court criticized enforcement authorities for failing to prevent this illegal practice, which has become widespread. Based on these considerations, the Court held that traveling with three persons on a motorcycle constitutes contributory negligence. Consequently, the Court apportioned 50% contributory negligence to the deceased and reduced the compensation by half. The Court clarified that this principle would not apply in cases where a family (husband, wife, and children) travels together unless more than one child above 10 to 12 years is involved, in which case contributory negligence applies.

Holding and Implications

The Court partly allowed the appeal by holding that the deceased was liable for 50% contributory negligence due to illegal traveling of three persons on a motorcycle. Accordingly, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal was reduced by 50%, resulting in Rs. 1,10,000 payable to the claimants with interest at 9% per annum, apportioned as per the Tribunal's original ratio. The Court’s decision directly affects the parties by reducing the compensation but does not establish a new broad precedent beyond clarifying contributory negligence in cases of unauthorized overloading on motorcycles. The Court also emphasized the need for stricter enforcement of traffic laws to prevent such illegal practices.

Show all summary ...

2. The claimants' case is that on 19.1.1995 at about 11.00 a.m when the deceased was travelling in a motor cycle as one of the pillion riders, the bus belonging to the appellant Corporation bearing Registration No.TN-37-N-0616 came in the opposite direction, driven by the driver in a rash and negligent manner and dashed against the motor cycle. Due to the impact, the deceased was thrown away and died on the spot.

3.The claim petition was filed on the basis that the deceased was earning a sum of Rs. 3,000/- p.m and now the legal representatives of the deceased lost his contribution to the family and as such they are entitled for the compensation.

4. The appellant herein contested the claim of the respondents 1 to 6 stating that the deceased was travelling in the motor cycle as a pillion rider along with another deceased Mr. Usman. Both the deceased were travelling in the motor cycle along with another one. Hence three persons were travelling in the motor cycle and either without noticing the bus which was coming in the opposite direction or unmindful of the available distance to cross through, the rider of the motor cycle over took the lorry and consequently the accident occurred only due to the rash and negligent driving of the motor cycle. Further when the three persons were travelling in the motor cycle, the rider also could not have complete control of the vehicle and as such the accident was not due to the rash and negligent driving of the bus by the driver. Even assuming that the bus was driven in a rash and negligent manner, there will be a contributory negligence on the part of the driver of the motor cycle in which the deceased was travelling as a pillion rider and there should be proportionate contributory negligence on the part of the two wheeler.

6. On behalf of the appellant Corporation, the driver of the bus was examined as R.W.1 On behalf of the claimants, the father of the deceased was examined as P.W.1 On consideration of the evidence let in by both the parties, the Tribunal determined the age of the deceased as 23.

7. Coming to the income of the deceased, the Tribunal accepted the evidence of the father who deposed that the deceased was employed in a tea-shop and he was earning a monthly income of Rs. 3,000/-. Even though there is no documentary evidence or independent witness to speak about the income of the deceased, the Tribunal found that the deceased could have earned an income of Rs. 2,000/- p.m and arrived the annual income at Rs. 24,000/-. After deducting 1/3rd towards his personal expenses, the Tribunal determined the contribution of the deceased to the family at Rs. 16,000/-. Considering the age of the father and mother which are 52 and 48 respectively, adopting the multiplier of 13, the Tribunal determined the total compensation of Rs. 2,08,000/-. The Tribunal further awarded a sum of Rs. 2,000/- for funeral expenses and Rs. 5,000/- towards loss of love and affection to claimants 1 and 2. The Tribunal totally awarded the compensation of Rs. 2,20,000/-. As against the same the present appeal has been filed. The Tribunal also found that the accident was due to the rash and negligent driving of the bus.

8. The only contention of the learned counsel for the appellant is that the deceased was travelling as one of the pillion riders in the motor cycle. It is an admitted case that three persons travelled in the motor cycle. When the motor cycle is meant for two persons viz., the rider and a pillion rider, the travelling of three persons is not only illegal but also unauthorised. When three persons are travelling in a motor cycle, sitting in a cramped manner, the rider of the motor cycle may not be in a position to have total control of the same. When three persons travelled in the motor cycle and the accident occurred due to an illegal act, none of the victims or their legal representatives are entitled for any compensation. Hence the Tribunal is not correct in awarding the compensation under the Award. Even otherwise, the Tribunal ought to have reduced the compensation by making a deduction towards contributory negligence by the rider as well as the pillion riders of the motor cycle, as they travelled in the motor cycle contrary to the provisions of the Act as well as the conditions of their own insurance policy.

9. The learned counsel for the respondents vehemently contended that the deceased being a pillion rider, no negligence can be attributed to him. There is absolutely no evidence with regard to any negligence on the part of the rider of the motor cycle. In such circumstance, there cannot be any contributory negligence, as contended by the learned counsel for the appellant. Three persons travelling in a motor cycle is a common affair as on today and hence that also cannot be a ground to refuse the compensation.

10. We carefully considered the above contentions of the respective counsels. We find some force in the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant. There is no gain say in saying that now-a-days it has become the normal course that three persons are travelling in a motor cycle.

11. We are concerned as to whether such action of the individuals is permissible under law. The motor cycle and any other two wheelers are meant only for two persons, the rider and a pillion rider. If more than two persons are travelling in a motor cycle or any other two wheeler, undoubtedly such action of the individual would become illegal and unauthorised. It is an awful sight when we come across three persons travelling in a motor cycle. They are sitting in such a cramped manner that the rider of the motor cycle almost sitting on the petrol tank or at the front edge of the seat. When he was sitting in such a position, naturally because of the restricted movement of his legs, he cannot have the complete control over the brake. The movements of his hands also so restricted. When that be so, this Court is of the opinion that definitely the rider of the two wheeler cannot have full control over the vehicle.

12. Apart from that, when three persons are travelling in a motor cycle, two as pillion riders, any unusual movement of the pillion riders would make the rider of the motor cycle to loose his control over the vehicle. Even though such travelling of three persons in a motor cycle is contrary to the statute, still the enforcement wing do not care to take note of the same and failed to take action against their illegal action. Virtually because of the failure on the part of the enforcement wing, such travelling of three persons in the two wheelers has become a regular sight. Even though the highway patroling is available but it is a rare sight to see a highway patrolling vehicle. The travelling of three persons has become rampant in the mofussils and in the City; especially among the youngsters like the college students. When that be the case, the enforcing authority is expected to enforce the statute with some strictness to avoid any untoward incident. There is no purpose in conducting the Road Safety Week without infusing the road sense in compliance of the Rules and Regulations of the statute in the minds of those who are using the vehicles.

13. When three persons travelled in a motor cycle which is meant for two persons, this Court is of the view, the conduct of the persons who travelled in such a manner are liable for contributory negligence; especially when their action is contrary to the statute.

14. Hence we hold that the deceased was liable for 50% of the contributory negligence and consequently 50% of the compensation is deducted towards contributory negligence and the claimants/respondents 1 to 6 are entitled for the compensation of Rs. 1,10,000/- together with interest at 9% p.a They are entitled for their respective share in the same ratio as apportioned by the Tribunal. The appeal is partly allowed with the above modification. Consequently C.M.P.165 of 2003 is closed.

15. While we lay down the law in respect of the contributory negligence by the unauthorised travelling of three persons in a motor cycle, we make it clear that it will not be applicable to a case where a family consisting of husband, wife and children are travelling. Even in such cases, if more than one child aged above 10 to 12 years is being taken, then we make it clear that the principle of contributory negligence will be applicable in respect of any accident.