- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Investment Trust Of India Ltd.
Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, in pursuance of an order of this Court in T.C.P. No. 348 of 1996 dated April 1, 1997, stated a case and referred two questions of law to the Court. The two questions related to (1) whether the assessee-company was entitled to investment allowance under section 32A of the Income-tax Act on machinery leased out in the course of its business of leasing, and (2) whether expenditure incurred on advertisements inviting fixed deposits from the public formed part of sales promotion expenses disallowable under section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act.
The assessment year in question is 1984-85. As to procedural history on the second question: the assessee claimed Rs. 2,93,340 as advertisement expenditure for collecting fixed deposits. The Income-tax Officer applied sub-section (3A) of section 37 and disallowed a portion of that expenditure. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) allowed the claim of the assessee; that order was confirmed by the Appellate Tribunal. The case was referred to this Court by way of stated case for determination of the two legal questions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the assessee-company is entitled to investment allowance under section 32A of the Income-tax Act on machinery leased out in the course of its business of leasing?
- Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the expenditure incurred on advertisement inviting fixed deposits from public does not form part of the sales promotion expenses calling for disallowance under section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act?
Arguments of the Parties
Revenue's Arguments
- The advertisement expenditure was incurred in newspapers inviting fixed deposits from the public and was both advertisement and sales promotion expenditure; therefore, it should be disallowed (or restricted) under section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act.
- Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court decision in Eskayef v. CIT, where distribution of drug samples was held to be publicity and sales promotion within section 37(3A); the Revenue argued that this principle extends to the present advertisement expenditure.
- The Revenue cited the Andhra Pradesh High Court decision in CIT v. J & J Dechane Laboratories (P.) Ltd. as referenced by the Supreme Court in Eskayef to support the view that publicity/sales-promotion expenditures generally fall within section 37(3A).
- Reliance was placed on Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. v. CIT for the proposition that circulars or instructions of the Central Board of Direct Taxes cannot override High Court or Supreme Court decisions; accordingly, the Revenue argued that any circular relied upon by the assessee cannot trump Supreme Court authority.
Assessee's Arguments
- The advertisements were published in compliance with the statutory requirements of section 58A of the Companies Act, 1956 (and rules thereunder) for inviting deposits; therefore the amounts were bona fide business expenditure and allowable.
- The Central Board of Direct Taxes Circular No. 240 dated May 17, 1978 states that section 37(3A) would not apply to expenditure incurred for publication in any newspaper of any notice required to be published by or under any law; reliance was placed on that circular to contend the expenditure was outside s.37(3A).
- The Appellate Tribunal correctly held that the advertisement expenditure did not qualify for disallowance under section 37(3A).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| CIT v. Shaan Finance P. Ltd., [1998] 231 ITR 308 | Used by the Court as controlling authority on the first question (investment allowance on leased machinery). | The Court followed this decision and answered the first question in the affirmative, against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee. |
| Eskayef v. CIT, [2000] 245 ITR 116 | Holds that distribution of free pharmaceutical samples to medical practitioners is publicity/sales-promotion expenditure within the scope of section 37(3A). | The Court treated Eskayef as authority on non-statutory promotional expenditure but distinguished it as inapplicable here because the present advertisements were statutory in nature (required by section 58A of the Companies Act). |
| CIT v. J and J Dechane Laboratories (P.) Ltd., [1996] 222 ITR 11 (Andhra Pradesh HC) | Discussed in Eskayef; involved a distinction between expenditure essential to running the business and other publicity/sales-promotion expenditure. | The Supreme Court (in Eskayef) held that the distinction drawn by the Andhra Pradesh High Court was not correct; the present Court noted that the Revenue relied on that line of reasoning but held it inapplicable where expenditure is statutorily required. |
| Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. v. CIT, [2000] 243 ITR 808 | Principle that circulars or instructions of the Central Board of Direct Taxes cannot override the view of the High Court or the Supreme Court. | The Revenue cited this authority to challenge reliance on the Board's circular; the Court held Hindustan Aeronautics did not assist the Revenue because the Board's circular was not in conflict with High Court or Supreme Court views in the matters before this Court. |
| CIT v. Mohd. Ishaque Gulam, [1998] 232 ITR 869 (Madhya Pradesh HC) | Noted the Board's circular and held the circular clarifies the meaning of "publicity and sales promotion." | The Court observed that this decision noticed the circular and treated it as clarifying the expression; it was cited in support of exempting statutory notices from s.37(3A). |
| CIT v. M.P. State Handloom Weavers' Co-operative Society, [1998] 233 ITR 62 (Madhya Pradesh HC) | Held that expenditure incurred in compliance with statutory directives/instructions (government directives) is business expenditure and not subject to the limitations of section 37(3A). | The Court expressed respectful agreement with this decision and applied the same reasoning: statutory compulsion makes the expenditure a business expenditure, not within s.37(3A). |
| Paper Products Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, [2001] 247 ITR 128 (Supreme Court) | Holds that circulars issued by the Board bind the Department and preclude the Department from challenging correctness of circulars even on grounds of inconsistency with statutory provision. | The Court relied on this principle to observe that the Board's circular (Circular No. 240) would bind the Department and supports the assessee's reliance on the circular. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in the following analytical steps, based strictly on the text of the opinion:
- Statutory framework:
- Section 37 generally allows expenses "wholly and exclusively for the purpose of the business" except capital or personal expenditure.
- Sub-section (3A) of section 37 was inserted effective April 1, 1984 (Finance Act, 1983) to subject expenditure on advertisement, publicity and sales promotion to specified disallowance rules.
- Characterisation of the assessee's expenditure:
- The assessee incurred advertisement expenses to invite fixed deposits from the public, in the amount claimed of Rs. 2,93,340.
- Under section 58A of the Companies Act, 1956 and the rules (Companies (Acceptance of Deposits) Rules, 1975), certain deposits may be invited only in a prescribed manner and a statutory form of advertisement is required. Non-compliance attracts return of deposit and penalties.
- Because the advertisement was made to comply with the statutory requirement under section 58A, the Court held the expenditure to be revenue in nature and incurred in compliance with law, not discretionary publicity.
- Interaction with section 37(3A)/(3B) and the object of the provision:
- The Court acknowledged that section 37(3A) was introduced to curb extravagant and socially wasteful advertising expenditures chargeable to the revenue account.
- However, where an advertisement is statutorily required (i.e., a legal obligation to publish certain information), such expenditure does not fall within the ambit of "publicity and sales promotion" intended to be caught by section 37(3A).
- Precedent and circulars:
- The Court noted Circular No. 240 dated May 17, 1978, which states that section 37(3A) does not apply to publication in a newspaper of any notice required to be published by or under any law. The Court relied on this circular as clarifying that statutory notices are excluded from s.37(3A).
- The Court considered relevant High Court authorities (Mohd. Ishaque Gulam; M.P. State Handloom Weavers' Co-operative Society) that had applied similar reasoning where statutory directives required publicity and where the courts held such expenditure to be ordinary business expenditure not subject to s.37(3A).
- The Court distinguished Eskayef v. CIT on the ground that Eskayef involved non-statutory distribution of free samples (clearly publicity/sales-promotion), whereas the present advertisements were statutorily mandated under section 58A and its rules.
- The Court addressed the Revenue's reliance on Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. v. CIT (that circulars cannot override court decisions) by observing that the Board's circular did not contravene any High Court or Supreme Court view in the relevant matters and therefore that line of argument did not assist the Revenue. The Court also cited Paper Products Ltd. for the proposition that circulars bind the Department.
- Conclusion of analysis:
- Given the statutory compulsion to publish the advertisement in the prescribed form and manner under section 58A and the Companies rules, and having regard to the object of section 37(3A), the Court concluded that such statutory advertisements cannot be regarded as publicity/sales-promotion expenses falling within the scope of section 37(3A).
- Therefore, the Appellate Tribunal was correct in holding that the advertisement expenditure for inviting deposits does not form part of sales promotion expenses subject to disallowance under section 37(3A).
Holding and Implications
Holding (core rulings):
- First question: Following the decision of the Supreme Court in CIT v. Shaan Finance P. Ltd., the first question (entitlement to investment allowance under section 32A on leased machinery) is answered in the affirmative — against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee.
- Second question: The Appellate Tribunal was correct: the expenditure incurred for inviting deposits from the public (statutory advertisements required under section 58A of the Companies Act and the relevant rules) does not form part of sales promotion expenses disallowable under section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act. The second question is answered in the affirmative — against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee.
Implications:
- The direct effect on the parties is that the assessee's claimed advertisement expenditure for statutory deposit notices is allowable as business expenditure and is not subject to the disallowance provisions of section 37(3A), as applied in this case.
- The Court distinguished authorities dealing with non-statutory publicity (e.g., Eskayef) and relied upon a Board circular and relevant High Court decisions to support the exemption of statutorily-required notices from s.37(3A)'s restrictions.
- No order as to costs was made in the result.
- The opinion does not state that it is establishing a new, general precedent beyond applying and reconciling existing authorities and the Board's circular to the facts before the Court; the Court expressly followed and applied prior decisions and the circular in reaching its conclusions.
End of summary.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
N.V Balasubramanian, J.:— The Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, in pursuance of the order of this court in T.C.P No. 348 of 1996 dated April 1, 1997, has stated a case and referred the following questions of law:
“1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in holding that the assessee-company is entitled to investment allowance under section 32A of the Act on machinery leased out in the course of its business of leasing?
2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in law in holding that the expenditure incurred on advertisement inviting fixed deposits from public does not form part of the sales promotion expenses calling for disallowance under section 37(3A) of the Act?”
2. The assessment year with which we are concerned is 1984-85 and as far as the first question of law referred to us is concerned, it is fairly submitted by learned counsel for the Revenue that the issue raised in the first question is covered against the Revenue by a decision of the Supreme Court in the case of CIT v. Shaan Finance P. Ltd., [1998] 231 ITR 308. Following the decision of the Supreme Court in CIT v. Shaan Finance P. Ltd., [1998] 231 ITR 308, the first question of law is answered in the affirmative, against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee. The second question deals with the allowability of the expenditure incurred by the assessee on advertisements inviting fixed deposits from the public. The assessee claimed a total sum of Rs. 2,93,340 as advertisement expenditure for collecting fixed deposits. The Income-tax Officer applied the provisions of Sub-section (3A) of section 37 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and disallowed a portion of the expenditure as provided in the section on the ground that the expenditure was incurred towards advertisements and towards sales promotion expenditure and, hence, disallowance has to be made under section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), on appeal, allowed the claim of the assessee on the ground that the expenses were sales promotion oriented expenses. The order of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) was confirmed by the Appellate Tribunal, on appeal.
3. The case of the Revenue is that the assessee had incurred the expenditure on advertisements in newspapers inviting fixed deposits from the public and the expenditure was incurred by way of advertisements and by way of sales promotion and therefore, the expenditure would qualify for disallowance under section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act. Learned counsel for the Revenue placed reliance on the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Eskayef v. CIT, [2000] 245 ITR 116, wherein the Supreme Court has held that the distribution of samples of drugs to medical practitioners was tantamount to publicity and sales promotion expenses falling within the scope of section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act, subject to the limitations as to allowability therein contained. Learned counsel for the Revenue therefore submitted that the Supreme Court referred to the decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in the case of CIT v. J and J Dechane Laboratories (P.) Ltd., [1996] 222 ITR 11 and held that the distinction made by the High Court between the expenditure that is essential to the running of the business and other expenditure is not correct and all the expenditure for publicity or sales promotion would fall within the scope of section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act. Learned counsel therefore submitted that since the expenditure incurred was advertisement expenditure and sales promotion expenditure, the entire expenditure is not allowable, but it is allowable subject to the restrictions contained in section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act. Learned counsel also relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. v. CIT, [2000] 243 ITR 808 and submitted that the Supreme Court has held that the circulars or instructions of the Central Board of Direct Taxes cannot override the view of the High Court or the Supreme Court. Learned counsel therefore submitted that the circular issued by the Central Board of Direct Taxes which has been relied upon by the learned counsel for the assessee cannot override the law laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of Eskayef v. CIT, [2000] 245 ITR 116. He therefore submitted that the view taken by the Appellate Tribunal is not correct and not in consonance with the decision of the Supreme Court.
4. Mr. J. Narayanaswamy, learned counsel for the assessee, on the other hand, submitted that the assessee had incurred expenditure on advertisements in compliance with the provisions of section 58A of the Companies Act, 1956, and the amount spent on advertisements is allowable as business expenditure. He submitted that the Central Board of Direct Taxes has issued the Circular No. 240, dated May 17, 1978 (see [1979] 117 ITR (St.) 17), explaining that the provision of section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act would not apply in relation to an expenditure incurred for publication in any newspaper of any notice required to be published by or under any law. He therefore submitted that the Appellate Tribunal was correct in holding that the amount of expenditure does not qualify for disallowance under section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act.
5. We carefully considered the submissions of learned counsel for the Revenue and learned counsel for the assessee. Section 37 of the Act provides that any expenditure incurred, laid out or expended wholly and exclusively for the purpose of the business other than the capital expenditure or personal expenditure is allowable as business expenditure. Sub-section (3A) of section 37 of the Income-tax Act was inserted by the Finance Act, 1983, with effect from April 1, 1984, and under section 37(3A), any expenditure incurred on advertisement, publicity and sales promotion would be allowable subject to the disallowance provided in section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act. section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act was the subject matter of consideration by the Supreme Court in Eskayef v. CIT, [2000] 245 ITR 116 and the Supreme Court was dealing with the case of an expenditure incurred by a pharmaceutical company on distribution of free samples of drugs to the medical practitioners and the question arose whether the expenditure incurred by the company would be an expenditure in the nature of publicity and sales promotion expenditure. The Supreme Court held that the expenditure incurred by the company on distribution of free samples of drugs to the medical practitioners would be in the nature of publicity and sales promotion expenditure and would fall within the scope of section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act and would be subject to the limitation as to the allowability therein contained.
6. The assessee herein had incurred the expenditure by way of advertisements in the newspapers for inviting deposits from the public. Under section 58A of the Companies Act, 1956, no company is permitted or allowed to invite deposits from the public unless the deposits are invited in accordance with the rules made under the section and the statutory advertisement should contain the statement showing the financial position of the company and the advertisement shall be issued by the company in such form and in such manner as may be prescribed under the rules. Sub-section (4) of section 58A of the Companies Act provides that if any deposit is accepted in contravention of the rules, the company is required to return the amount of deposit and further, if there is any contravention in relation to the deposit, the company is also punishable with fine which may extend to Rs. 1,00,000 but shall not be less than Rs. 5,000. In other words, the company desiring to invite deposits from the public has to comply with the provisions of section 58A of the Companies Act and publish the advertisement in the form prescribed inviting deposits from the public. In other words, it is not open to the company to invite deposits in any other form. The statutory form prescribed is fairly a lengthy one under the Companies (Acceptance of Deposits) Rules, 1975, and it requires that the advertisement shall be made in a leading English newspaper and in one vernacular newspaper circulating in the State in which the registered office of the company is situate. The text of the advertisement shall contain the information regarding the name of the company, the date of incorporation of the * company, the business carried on by the company and its subsidiaries, brief particulars of the management of the company, names, addresses and occupations of the directors, the profits of the company before and after making provision for tax for the three financial years immediately preceding the date of advertisement, the dividends declared by the company in respect of the said years and a summarised financial position of the company as in the two audited balance sheets immediately preceding the date of advertisement in the form prescribed in the rules. We are therefore of the view that in view of the statutory provision contained in section 58A of the Companies Act, the assessee-company has to advertise the notice calling for deposits and if there is any breach, the company is liable to be proceeded against under the relevant provisions of the Companies Act. Since there is a statutory compulsion on the assessee-company to advertise the notice calling for deposits from the public, we hold that the expenditure on advertisements is revenue in nature.
7. The only question is whether in view of the specific provision contained in section 37(3A) read with section 37(3B) of the Income-tax Act, the expenditure incurred for the advertisements is allowable subject to the limitations of allowability as prescribed in section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act. We are of the view, when the assessee has complied with the statutory provisions and issued advertisements calling for deposits from the public, it would not amount to sale promotion expenditure falling under section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act. It must be remembered that section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act was introduced to curb the extravagant and socially wasteful expenditure on advertisement at the cost of the exchequer. Keeping in view the object behind the introduction of sections 37(3A) and 37(3B) of the Income-tax Act, we are of the view that the advertisements effected by the assessee which the assessee was required to make under the provisions of law cannot be regarded as an expenditure falling within the scope and ambit of section 37(3A) read with section 37(3B) of the Income-tax Act. The Central Board of Direct Taxes in Circular No. 240 dated May 17, 1978 (see [1979] 117 ITR (St.) 17), has realised the position and issued the circular stating that the provision would not apply to the expenditure incurred by the taxpayer, inter alia, on the publication in any newspaper or any notice required to be published by or under any law. The above circular was noticed by the Madhya Pradesh High Court in CIT v. Mohd. Ishaque Gulam, [1998] 232 ITR 869 and the court held that the circular clarifies the meaning of the expression, publicity and sales promotion.
8. A similar question was considered by the Madhya Pradesh High Court in CIT v. M.P State Handloom Weavers' Co-operative Society, [1998] 233 ITR 62 and in the case before the Madhya Pradesh High Court, the State Government has issued directions under section 49C of the Madhya Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, to all co-operative societies in the State to popularise the co-operative movement by effecting an advertisement and the co-operative society in question incurred certain expenditure towards propaganda and the question arose whether the expenditure incurred by the assessee for propaganda would constitute advertisement on sales promotion within the meaning of section 37(3A) read with section 37(3B) of the Income-tax Act. The Madhya Pradesh High Court held that the directives of the State Government to cooperative societies were statutory in nature and in compliance with the directives, the expenditure was incurred by the assessee and hence, the expenditure would constitute a business expenditure and the expenditure was not subject to the limitation of allowability prescribed in section 37(3A) of the Income-tax Act. We are in respectful agreement with the view expressed by the Madhya Pradesh High Court in M.P State Handloom Weavers' Co-operative Society's case, [1998] 233 ITR 62. The assessee had incurred the expenditure on advertisements for collecting fixed deposits and the advertisements were statutory advertisements and therefore the provisions of section 37(3A) read with section 37(3B) of the Income-tax Act do not apply to the said expenditure.
9. As far as the decision of the Supreme Court in Eskayef v. CIT, [2000] 245 ITR 116 is concerned, the Supreme Court was dealing with a case of non-statutory expenditure and the expenditure was incurred on the distribution of physician's sample for the purpose of publicity and sales promotion and therefore, the decision in Eskayef's case, [2000] 245 ITR 116 is not applicable to the facts of the case. Learned counsel for the Revenue relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. v. CIT, [2000] 243 ITR 808, wherein the Supreme Court held that the circular of the Central Board of Direct Taxes cannot override the decision of the Supreme Court or the High Court. We are of the view that the above decision of the Supreme Court does not assist counsel for the Revenue as the Board has not issued the circular in contravention of the view expressed by the High Court or the Supreme Court. On the other hand, the Supreme Court in Paper Products Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, [2001] 247 ITR 128 has held that the circulars issued by the Board would bind the department and the Department is precluded from challenging the correctness of the circulars even on the ground of the same being inconsistent with the statutory provision. Hence, the circular issued by the Central Board of Direct Taxes would bind the Department.
10. In the result, we hold that the Appellate Tribunal was correct in holding that the expenditure incurred for inviting deposits from the public does not form part of the sales promotion expenses. Accordingly, we answer the second question of law referred to us in the affirmative, against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee. However, in the circumstances, there will be no order as to costs.
Alert