- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Asservadham And Others v. Indian Airlines, Ltd.
Legal Opinion Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeals concern the regularization of casual Class IV unskilled workers (helpers, loaders, peons, etc.) employed by Indian Airlines Ltd. The appellants were engaged casually for a maximum of ninety days at a stretch in a year; some claimed service dating back to 1977. By notification dated 4 June 1997 Indian Airlines called for applications from those who worked as casual/part-time/contract basis for a maximum period of ninety days during twelve consecutive months in the last three years for the post of helpers. The appellants contended that under S.25-H of the Industrial Disputes Act read with rule 78 of the Industrial Disputes Rules they were entitled to re-employment and filed writ petitions seeking to quash the notification and to direct regularization of their services.
Pending the writ petitions this Court (by order dated 23 December 1997) directed the respondent to frame a scheme. Indian Airlines framed a scheme dated 8 September 1999. The learned Single Judge upheld that scheme and directed appellants to seek remedies under it. The workers appealed that decision to the present Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellants have a legal right to automatic regularization in service.
- Whether the respondents are resorting to unfair labour practice by engaging casual workers in lieu of regular appointments.
- Whether the scheme framed by the respondent for regularization is workable.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- Continuous engagement as casuals should amount to absorption/regularization and is not merely recruitment; it is de jure recognition of de facto functioning for more than 240 days.
- Absorption/regularization should apply to casuals who worked for more than 240 days, entitling them to automatic empanelment for permanent service.
- Any empanelment should remain alive until all such casuals are permanently absorbed.
- Section 25-H of the Industrial Disputes Act confers on them a direct legal right to absorption.
- The work they perform is of permanent nature (handling packages, cleaning), subject only to seasonal fluctuations, and they therefore should be considered for regularization.
- The respondents engage casuals for repeated ninety-day stints, amounting to unfair labour practice.
- Appellants require security of service because their work involves security aspects of aircraft, airport and citizens.
- The scheme framed did not comply with the Court's directions (e.g., regarding furnishing number of workmen departmental needs for 1998) and it considered casual workers only from 1991.
- The scheme imposes arbitrary and unworkable clauses (minimum educational qualification, selection by selection committee per recruitment rules, and reservation of only 50% vacancies), and is at variance with the Court's direction.
- The Court has jurisdiction to modify the scheme.
Respondent's (Management's) Arguments
- The learned Single Judge took a pragmatic view and correctly upheld the scheme.
- Appellants are unskilled casual workers engaged according to exigencies of work, seasonal demands, absenteeism and leave of regular employees; their engagement does not establish a permanent post.
- Indian Airlines had framed and followed similar schemes in other stations (Bombay and Calcutta); the Madras scheme is not materially different.
- As a commercial corporation competing in a liberalized market, the airline must consider financial and rationalization concerns before creating posts; in the absence of regular posts, appellants have no right to regularization.
- Regularization must account for redeployment recommendations, rationalization committees, and Pay Commission recommendations; a pragmatic scheme is necessary for feasibility and effective implementation.
- The proposed scheme is most beneficial to appellants and does not require interference other than possible modifications for implementation.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Punjab Land Development and Reclamation Corporation, Ltd. v. Labour Court [1990 (1) L.L.N 1054] | Meaning of "retrenchment" under S.2(oo) — held to mean termination by employer of service of a workman for any reason except those expressly excluded. | Relied upon to conclude that non-renewal of a contract on expiry does not equate to retrenchment for the purposes of S.25-H; therefore appellants cannot claim automatic continuation of service on that basis. |
| Workmen of American Express International Banking Corporation v. American Express International Banking Corporation [1985 (2) L.L.N 817] | Case dealing with continuous service for not less than one year and actual employment of 240 days as relevant to absorption claims. | Referenced to show that precedents addressing absorption typically involved longer continuous service (one year/240 days), differing from the present facts. |
| State of Haryana v. Piara Singh [1992 (2) L.L.N 1037] | Ad hoc employees continuing in service for several years without regularization; limits on automatic directions for regularization. | Used to illustrate that regularization directions depend on factual circumstances and qualifications; one decision does not mandate identical relief in all cases. |
| Chief Conservator of Forest v. Jagnnath Maruti Kondhare [1996 (1) L.L.N 475] | Case where 25 workmen employed for 5–6 years with periods of 100–330 days per year and finding of unfair labour practice. | Cited to show factual situations where unfair labour practice and entitlement to relief were recognized; by contrast, present facts differ (maximum 90 days per year). |
| Dharwad District Public Works Department Literate Daily wages Employees' Association v. State of Karnataka [1990 (1) L.L.N 1011] | Large-scale long-term daily/ monthly rated employees (50,000) working for long periods without regularization. | Illustrative of cases where large numbers of temporary workers were regularized through schemes; court noted such precedents when considering framing/approval of schemes. |
| M. Jacob v. Kerala Water Authority [1990 (2) L.L.N 1032] | Temporary employees serving long spells under statutory rule with requisite qualifications entitled to regularization. | Used to support the proposition that long continuous service with qualifications may justify regularization subject to facts and rules. |
| Hindustan Machine Tools v. M. Rangareddy [2000 (4) L.L.N 548] | Directed framing of a scheme for casual workers engaged for long periods, subject to eligibility and age relaxation. | Referenced as an example where the Supreme Court directed a scheme-based approach rather than blanket regularization. |
| G.B. Pant University of Agriculture and Technology v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2000 (3) L.L.N 1065] | Supreme Court directed regularization in terms of a Labour Court award rather than ignoring the award. | Cited as a precedent where the Court enforced regularization in accordance with prior adjudicatory findings. |
| Jammu and Kashmir Public Service Commission v. Dr. Narinder Mohan [1993 (2) L.L.N 938] | Continuance of service for some years does not automatically entitle ad hoc appointees to regularization. | Used to caution against treating mere continuance as an unconditional right to regularization. |
| Central Welfare Board v. Anjali Bepari [1997 (1) L.L.N 560] | Workers appointed against casual vacancies for long periods (over three years) — management directed to evolve a scheme. | Supports the approach of directing schemes for large numbers of long-serving casuals rather than blanket absorption. |
| State of Uttar Pradesh v. Ajay Kumar [1998 (1) L.L.N 320] | There must exist a post and administrative/statutory rules to appoint a person; daily-wage appointment relates to contingent establishment where no permanent post exists. | Applied to emphasize that daily/ casual appointments do not create permanent posts and so do not automatically entitle incumbents to regularization. |
| Himanshu Kumar Vidyarthi v. State of Bihar [1997 (2) L.L.N 982] | Disengagement of temporary employees on daily wages cannot be construed as retrenchment. | Reinforces the distinction between termination on expiry of daily-wage/temporary engagement and retrenchment under S.2(oo)/S.25-H. |
| Central Bank of India v. S. Satyam [1997 (2) L.L.N 31] | Relates to retrenched workmen employed for short periods and the application of S.2(oo); laches can bar relief. | Cited to show that application of S.2(oo) and S.25-H depends on factual findings and delay (laches) may preclude relief; court cannot assume unfair labour practice without Industrial Court examination. |
| Indian Airlines Ltd. v. Samaresh Bhowmick [1999 (4) L.L.N 57] | Scheme of regularization of casual employment was upheld; court summarized a detailed scheme (eligibility, age relaxation, educational requirement, selection board, reservations, ex gratia payment for those not appointed, etc.). | The present Court relied on and reproduced that scheme as a precedent for an acceptable, pragmatic scheme; used to validate the respondent's scheme subject to modifications. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the factual matrix and legal authorities and proceeded by stages:
- Facts: It accepted as admitted that appellants were engaged as casual workers for a maximum period of ninety days in a year and that casual workers were used in rotation throughout the year. Attendance/registers prior to 1991 were not available and the Court confined consideration largely to the period from 1991 onwards, consistent with earlier Court directions.
- Statutory interpretation: The Court noted the 1984 amendment inserting exceptions into S.2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act and relied on Punjab Land Development (Constitution Bench) to conclude that “retrenchment” is not intended to cover contractual non-renewal on expiry; thus, an expiry/non-renewal of casual/contract engagement is distinguishable from retrenchment that would trigger S.25-H rights.
- Precedential matrix: The Court surveyed multiple Supreme Court decisions and distilled common features: cases entitling regularization typically involved long and continuous engagement (often years and substantial days of service), factual findings of continuous work and unfair labour practice, and direction to frame schemes rather than blanket absorption. The Court emphasized that financial, administrative and practical constraints must be considered when framing regularization schemes.
- Unfair labour practice claim: The Court found insufficient material to conclude that respondents committed unfair labour practice. It noted that Indian Airlines had made regular recruitments in various years (1983, 1984, 1986, 1988, 1990, 1991, 1992, 1994, 1997) and observed that appellants had not shown why they had not applied or been unsuccessful in those recruitments. The airline’s asserted needs (seasonal demand, absenteeism, temporary workload) were accepted as plausible reasons for casual engagement.
- Remedy under S.25-H: Even assuming some appellants could be considered retrenched workmen, the Court observed that entitlement under S.25-H does not negate eligibility requirements for permanent posts. Appellants could not claim exemption from qualifying criteria or selection processes merely because they were initially engaged casually.
- Workability of scheme: The Court evaluated competing submissions about seniority lists and cut-off dates. It endorsed a pragmatic limitation: for consideration under the scheme a worker should have put in a minimum of 90 days of service in a year from 1991; it found impractical the inclusion of persons with only a few days of work over many years. Except for this modification, the Court approved the scheme framed by Indian Airlines and confirmed the Single Judge's judgment.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: All these appeals are disposed of accordingly; the scheme of the respondent is upheld with a modification.
Direct consequences for the parties:
- The judgment of the learned Single Judge upholding the Indian Airlines scheme is confirmed.
- The scheme is modified to provide that, for consideration, a worker must have put in a minimum of 90 days of service in a year from 1991; otherwise the scheme stands as framed (including provisions such as age relaxation, educational qualification, selection by constituted board, reservation and ex gratia compensation for those not absorbed as indicated in the Court's discussion of the Samaresh Bhowmick scheme).
- The Court found no sufficient material to hold that Indian Airlines indulged in unfair labour practice in the circumstances of this case.
- No costs were awarded.
Broader implications: The opinion emphasizes a scheme-based, pragmatic approach to regularization claims — courts will examine factual continuity, existence of posts, eligibility criteria and financial/administrative feasibility before ordering wholesale absorption. The present decision does not establish an automatic right to regularization where engagement is limited to short, recurrent casual stints (maximum 90 days in a year) and where statutory definitions (S.2(oo)) and precedent distinguish between contract expiry and retrenchment.
Shanmugam, J.:— The subject-matter of the appeal relates to question of regularization of casual workers. The learned Single Judge upheld the scheme of the respondent for regularization. Not being satisfied, the workers have filed the above writ appeals.
2. The appellants are working with the respondent Indian Airlines, Ltd., as Class IV unskilled casual workers like, helpers, loaders, peons, etc. They are being engaged casually for a maximum period of ninety days at a stretch in a year. According to the appellants, some of them have been working from 1977 onwards and though there were regular recruitments, the appellants' claims were ignored. By a notification dated June 4, 1997, the Indian Airlines, Ltd., called for applications from those who worked as casual/part-time/contract basis for a maximum period of ninety days during a period of twelve consecutive months in the last three years for the post of helpers. As many of the appellants are not qualified either with regard to the age or educational qualifications, etc., they claim that under S. 25-H of the Industrial Disputes Act read with rule 78 of the Industrial Disputes Rules, they are entitled for re-employment and on that basis, they have filed writ petitions seeking to quash the notification calling for applications for regular appointments and to direct the respondent to regularize their services. Pending the writ petitions, this Court, by order, dated December 23, 1997, directed the respondent to frame a scheme and pursuant to this order, the Indian Airlines, Ltd., framed a scheme, dated September 8, 1999. In the final hearing, the learned Judge upheld the scheme and directed the appellants to work out their remedy under that scheme. Not being satisfied, the above writ appeals have been preferred.
3. M/s. M. Sundar, P.V.S Giridhar, K.P Krishna Shetty, K. Palanisamy, V. Prakash, K.M Ramesh, K. Venkataramani, M.V Muralidharan and Fredric Castra appearing for the appellants made elaborate submissions on the rights of their services to be regularized and as to how the scheme is at variance with the direction of the learned Judge and unworkable. Their submissions are summarized as follows:
(i) In the light of continuous engagement of the appellants as casuals, the absorption and regularization in the respective post is not recruitment. It is a de jure recognition accorded for their de facto functioning for more than 240 days;
(ii) absorption or regularization connotes all the casuals to work for more than 240 days to get themselves automatically empanelled for a permanent service;
(iii) any empanelment should be kept alive until all of them are absorbed permanently;
(iv) section 25-H of the Industrial Disputes Act directly confers right to the appellants under law and therefore, they have got a legal right for absorption;
(v) as their work is of a permanent nature, namely, handling of packages, cleaning, etc., subject to fluctuation in demand due to seasonal traffic, the appellants are entitled to be considered for regularization;
(vi) in this case, the respondents are consistently following the unfair labour practice of engagement for ninety days to the whimsical likes of the respondents;
(vii) the appellants are entitled to security of service. Their work involves security aspect of the aircraft, airport and citizens, and therefore, the appointment must be secured;
(viii) as per the order dated December 23, 1997, the scheme has been prepared in reference to the casual workers from the year 1991. However, the direction to furnish the number of workmen who can be gainfully employed in the relevant department in the year 1998 and also the number of casual labourers required in the department, if all the existing vacancies in the grade of helpers are fixed by making regular appointments thereto, are not complied with; and
(ix) the scheme prepared by the Indian Airlines, Ltd., is at variance with the direction of this Court. The clauses in the scheme regarding minimum educational qualification and selection by a selection committee as per recruitment and promotional rules and the reservation of 50 per cent of the vacancies only are clearly arbitrary and unworkable;
(x) This Court has ample jurisdiction to modify the scheme.
4. Sri N.G.R Prasad, learned senior counsel representing on behalf of the management supported the order of the learned single judge. According to him, the learned single judge has taken a pragmatic view. The appellants who are unskilled casual workers, are engaged depending on the exigencies of the work required in order to maintain the customers' service with the least inconvenience to the travelling public. Apart from this, there occurs temporary or seasonal additional workload. Besides, they have to take care of absenteeism and leave of regular employees in the cadre. The question of absorption of casual workers was pending without a satisfactory solution. In other stations, the Indian Airlines has formulated schemes and they are upheld and are being followed. According to him, there is not much difference between the scheme proposed at Madras and the schemes operating at Bombay and Calcutta. He further submits that the respondent-Indian Airlines, Ltd., is a commercial corporation and that they have to effectively compete with private airlines in the context of liberalized and globalization for their survival. They are no longer monopoly players. They have to keep in tune with their financial and other considerations like the actual requirement, rationalization before creating posts. In the absence of regular posts, the appellants have no right. He also submits that they have to consider the recommendation for redeployment of Class IV employees and rationalization of workforce by the committees constituted for that purpose and the Pay Commission's recommendations. The regularization scheme, if any, can be feasible only after taking all these things into consideration and with a pragmatic approach. He submits that the scheme as such is most beneficial to the appellants and no interference is called for with the order of the learned Judge. Any modification can only be for effective implementation of the scheme.
5. We have heard the rival submissions, gone through the records and considered the matter carefully.
6. Three main questions that arise for consideration in the writ appeals are:
(i) whether the appellants have got a legal right for automatic regularization in service?
(ii) whether the respondents are resorting to unfair labour practice? and
(iii) whether the scheme is workable.
7. It is an admitted fact that all the appellants have been working as casual workers for a maximum period of ninety days in a year. It is also not in dispute that casual workers have been engaged by the respondent throughout the year in rotation. We need not go into the services of those appellants who have worked prior to 1991, as the list as such has been prepared as per the direction of this Court from the year 1991 and the crucial year of 1991 is not in controversy for the purpose of consideration. Besides, it is claimed that the attendance registers are not available prior to 1991.
8. It is stated that there were 2506 casual employees during the period from 1991 to 1997. Among them, there are persons who worked for one day to 622 days, i.e, there are 27 persons worked for one day only and two persons who worked for 622 days. For instance, the persons who worked from 31 to 89.days are 635; between 90 to 179 days are 810; and between 180 to 269 days are 442 and so on. But, it is not in dispute that none of them have worked continuously for more than ninety days in a year and that they were regular recruitment almost yearly, but the appellants were not able to get permanent appointments either because of lack of qualification or that they were not found suitable for the selection.
9. There are no details as to the nature of entry, terms of period of service, nature of employment, terms of termination in reference to each of the employees. Similarly, there are no particulars as to the need of the respective service department wise. While the appellants argue that engagement of casual workers regularly even though the appellants were given only 90 days' work follows that there is permanent heed, the management submits that the need is only seasonal, and to meet the particular need but not of permanent nature.
10. After the insertion of Cls. (bb) to S. 2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act by Amending Act 49 of 1984 with effect from August 18, 1984, excluding a contractual termination of service from the definition of retrenchment, it would appear that it could never have been the intention of the Legislature to make retrenchment synonymous with discharge simpliciter.
11. In Punjab Land Development and Reclamation Corporation, Ltd. v. Labour Court, [1990 (1) L.L.N 1054], the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court, while considering the definition of the word “retrenchment”, has concluded as follows, in Para. 82, at page 1082:
“Applying the above reasonings, principles and precedents, to the definition in S. 2(oo) of the Act, we hold that ‘retrenchment’ means termination by the employer of the service of a workman for any reason whatsoever except those expressly excluded in the section.”
12. According to the Supreme Court, even though there are apparent incongruities in the provisions of Ss. 25-F, 25-G and 25-H of the Act, there is room for a harmonious construction. Their Lordships have observed as follows, in Para. 76, at page 1080:
“…In our view, the principle of harmonious construction implies that in a case where there is a genuine transfer of an undertaking or genuine closure of an undertaking as contemplated in the aforesaid sections, it would be inconsistent to read into the provisions, a right given to the workmen deemed to be retrenched’ a right to claim re-employment, as provided under S. 25-H. In such cases, as specifically provided in the relevant sections, the workman concerned would only be entitled to notice and compensation in accordance with S. 25-F …”
13. Therefore, if there is termination of the service of a workman as a result of the non-renewal of the contract of employment, on the expiry of such contract, they cannot be treated as if they had been retrenched for the purpose of re-employment under S. 25-H of the Act. Hence, it cannot be stated that the appellants have got a legal right for automatic continuation of their service.
14. In none of the decisions referred to, the rights of casual workers who have been put in maximum of 80 days work in a year has been considered for the purpose of absorption. In Workmen of American Express International Banking Corporation v. American Express International Banking Corporation, [1985 (2) L.L.N 817], the Supreme Court has dealt with a case of continuous service for not less than one year and the actual employment of 240 days. In State of Haryana v. Piara Singh, [1992 (2) L.L.N 1037], the Supreme Court has dealt with a case of ad hoc employees who have been continuing in service for several years without being regularized. In Chief Conservator of Forest v. Jagnnath Maruti Kondhare, [1996 (1) L.L.N 475], a case of 25 workmen who went to the Industrial Court, it was found that they had been admittedly employed by the State for 5 to 6 years and in each year they has worked for period ranging from 100 to 330 days and that there was unfair labour practice.
15. In Dharwad District Public Works Department Literate Daily wages Employees' Association v. State of Karnataka, [1990 (1) L.L.N 1011], the Supreme Court was concerned with 50,000 daily-rated or monthly rated employees working for a period of 10-0 years without being regularized. In M. Jacob v. Kerala Water Authority, [1990 (2) L.L.N 1032], the Supreme Court has considered the case of employees appointed temporarily under a statutory rule and who were erving with the establishment for long spells with requisite Qualification. The Supreme Court held in tht case that since they have worked in the posts for reasonably long spells, they are entitled for regularization of their service. In Hindustan Machine Tools v. M. Rangareddy, [2000 (4) L.L.N 548], the Supreme Court directed framing of a scheme for the casual workers who and been engaged for long period, subject to fulfilment of the conditions of eligibility qualification with relaxation of the age prescribed under the rules.
16. In G.B Pant University of Agriculture and Technology v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [2000 (3) L.L.N 1065], as against the direction of the Labour Court to regularize 175 employees, the Supreme Court directed to regularize the services of the employees in terms of the award passed by the Labour Court.
17. In Jammu and Kashmir Public Service Commission v. Dr. Narinder Mohan, [1993 (2) L.L.N 938], the Supreme Court has held that continuance of service for some years would not entitle the ad hoc appointees to regularization.
18. In Central Welfare Board v. Anjali Bepari, [1997 (1) L.L.N 560], where the workers were appointed against casual vacancy for a long period of over three years, the management was directed to evolve a scheme.
19. In State of Uttar Pradesh v. Ajay Kumar, [1998 (1) L.L.N 320], the Supreme Court held that there must exist a post and either administrative instructions or statutory rules must be in operation to appoint a person to the post, and that daily-wage appointment will obviously be in relation to contingent establishment in which there cannot exist any post and it continues so long as the work exists.
20. In Himanshu Kumar. Vidyarthi v. State of Bihar, [1997 (2) L.L.N 982], it has been held that disengagement from service of temporary employees on daily wages cannot be construed as retrenchment.
21. From the above decisions, the following facts emerge:
(i) In most of the cases, temporary workers were engaged continuously for a long number of years;
(ii) the Industrial Courts have gone into the question of regularization and on facts, holding existence of continuous work, to claim unfair labour practice;
(iii) in the case of large number of casual workers, directions have been given for regularization by framing a scheme;
(iv) the financial constraints and the practical and pragmatic view and effect of increasing the cadre strength are directed to be taken into account;
(v) the absorption of casual workers would, in all cases, be subject to fulfilment of the condition of the eligibility with relaxation of the age prescribed under the Rules;
(iv) the general wholesale regularization without conditions should not be made.
22. In Central Bank of India v. S. Satyam, [1997 (2) L.L.N 31], the Supreme Court has dealt with a case of retrenched workmen, who had been employed for short periods from 1974 to 1976. The writ petition has been filed in the year 1982 and it was found that on the ground of laches, they were not entitled to the relief. Their Lordships held that the ordinary meaning of the expression “retrenched workmen” must relate to the wide meaning of “retrenchment” given in S. 2(oo). It was further held that the definition under S. 2(oo) would apply in that case. On the facts of the case on hand, unless the matter is gone into by the Industrial Court, it may not be possible to hold it as an unfair labour practice so as to claim the benefit of S. 25-H of the Act, ignoring the exclusion clause contained in S. 2(oo)—exception (bb).
23. The contention raised is that the respondent is resorting to unfair labour practice in engaging casually the permanent vacancy. According to the appellants, when the casual workers are being engaged right from 1979, there must be a permanent need and consequential regularization and that failure to regularize the casuals is unfair labour practice. The said submission fails to take note of the fact that the respondent has been admittedly making regular appointments in the years 1983, 1984, 1986, 1988, 1990, 1991, 1992, 1994 and 1997. It is not clear whether the appellants applied for the regular posts and as to why they did not agitate the failure to recruit them. It is therefore obvious that the appellants either did not succeed in the selection or did not qualify for the selection. The contention on behalf of the Indian Airlines is that they have to maintain casual workers to meet the need/exigencies of the work, seasonal demand and additional workload, absenteeism, etc. They are prepared to for consider regularization of the casuals engaged from the year 1991 as per the scheme. Therefore, assuming for the sake of argument that the management passed have kept casuals from the year 1991, theirpresent stand that they are prepared to go in for a scheme, would only show their readiness to absorb the casuals. On the facts of this case, we have no materials to conclude that the respondents are resorting to unfair labour practice.
24. Assuming that the appellants herein can be brought under the category of retrenched workmen, they have to work out their remedy as and when vacancies arise and recruitment takes place and preference being given to those who have been retrenched employees. But the appellants are not prepared to subject themselves to go in for recruitment process, but what they seek is only a regularization. Admittedly, the appellants were initially taken in without following the requirements for permanent service and by that engagement, they won't acquire legal right to dispense with the eligibility qualifications. In State of Haryana case, [1992 (2) LLN 1037] (vide supra), it as been held that just because in one case a direction was given to regularize employees who have put in one year of service as far as possible and subject to their fulfilling the qualifications, it cannot be held that in each and every case such a direction must follow irrespective of or/and taking into account the other relevant circumstances. The relief must be moulded in each case having regard to the facts and circumstances of that case.
25. On the question whether the scheme is workable, counsel for the appellants took conflicting stands. Some of them claimed combined seniority as prepared in the list should be followed and some of them submitted that preference to be given on the basis of number of days worked and the cut-off date must be June 4, 1997, the date of the earlier notification. It is further submitted that the experience gained as per the interim order should not come to the advantage or disadvantage of the other appellants.
26. In Indian Airlines Ltd. v. Samaresh Bhowmick, [1999 (4) L.L.N 57], the scheme of regularization of casual employment is upheld. The scheme as proposed in that case was set out in Para. 6, at page 58 as follows:
The said scheme for regularization of all casual employees is extracted below:
“(1) All the casuals irrespective of the fact that their names were borne on any panel or not will be treated on a par provided they have worked for 90 days as casual during the last three years.
(2) Notification will be issued inviting applications from casual employees for the posts of helpers in commercial, engineering, stores, ground support, catering canteens and peons.
(3) Age relaxation to the extent of casual employment will be given subject to a maximum age requirement of 40 years for general category, 43 years for OBC and 45 years for SC and ST as on date of the order of the Court.
(4) The candidates must fulfill the educational qualification of having passed 8th class from a recognized institution for the post of helpers in commercial, engineering, stores, ground support and peons.
(5) Selections will be made by duly constituted selection board as per the recruitment and promotion rules of the company.
(6) Merit lists, category/cadrewise will be prepared and the selected candidates would be offered employment against the vacancies in order of merit.
(7) While making appointments, the directives of the Government with regard to reservations will be adhered to.
(8) Those who cannot be appointed due to non-availability of regular vacancies would be given ex gratia payment calculated on the basis of compensation payable under S. 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. However, they will have no claim for re-employment as casuals or otherwise in future.
(9) The appointment of the above-mentioned empanelled casual employees, will be subject to their completing all the pre-employment formalities and on being declared medically fit by the Medical Officer of the company.
(10) This will be a onetime exercise only.”
27. The Division Bench of the High Court had directed that the candidates selected as per the scheme should be considered for present as well future vacancies and they should be regularized first. The Supreme Court while holding that the scheme could not have been overlooked since the selections will have to be made by duly constituted selection board as per the recruitment and promotion rules of the company and the selection list cannot have operation for more than a period of two years.
28. In the present case, the learned Single Judge found that in view of the various clauses of the scheme, particularly, relaxation of age for certain period keeping 50 per cent of the vacancies for the post of helpers (commercial) exclusively for them and agreeing to pay compensation as per S. 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act to those who do not get absorption, the scheme formulated has to be approved. The learned Judge also took note of the fact that when a large number of people were continued to be employed on rotation basis and they had accepted their position for quite some time, they cannot claim that all of them should be regularized and that if such direction is issued, it will lead to an impossible state of affairs, when there are no permanent posts also. The learned Judge taking note of the Kelkar Committee's report which has advised ban on recruitment and reduction in work force, observed that any regularization should take note of these facts and that regularization will depend on vacancy position and qualification. In our view, the learned Judge has taken into account both the factual and legal positions and taking a pragmatic approach, upheld the scheme formulated by the respondent. Hence, we do not find any grounds to interfere with the orders of the learned Single Judge.
29. After considering the submissions on either side on the method prescribing the norms in the preparation of the list of casual workers from the year 1991, we are of the view that for the purpose of consideration, a worker should have put in a minimum of 90 days of service in a year from 1991. We find, it is not practical or rational to include even those workers who have put in just a few days of work all these 10 years for the purpose of consideration. It is quite possible, as submitted, many of such persons would have gone to different places or jobs and the unwieldy list would not be practicable for preparation. Excepting this direction to modify the scheme in this respect, in all other respects, we uphold the scheme and confirm the judgment of learned Single Judge. All these appeals are disposed of accordingly. No costs.
Alert