- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Palaniammal Petitioner v. V.K Ramanathan And 4 Others S
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff in O.S 117 of 2001 filed an application under Order 6 Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking to amend the plaint. The District Munsif, Namakkal dismissed this application on 14.9.2001, prompting the plaintiff to file the present revision petition challenging that order.
The plaintiff contended that she leased the suit property from the first defendant from 1.1.1979 to 31.12.1998 and was permitted to erect superstructures thereon. She claimed to have constructed buildings and shops, obtained electricity connection, and that municipal assessment stood in the name of her husband. After the lease period, she asserted a right to possession under the Tamil Nadu City Tenants Protection Act. The plaintiff filed multiple suits against various defendants due to interference with her possession and municipal tax assessment changes effected without her hearing.
The first defendant contended that the lease had expired in 1998 and alleged collusion between the plaintiff and the third defendant. The plaintiff sought to amend the plaint to include a prayer for mandatory injunction to restore water supply disconnected by the Municipality, which was opposed by the second defendant on grounds that the amendment introduced a new cause of action and the water connection had been changed in the second defendant’s name prior to the suit.
The District Munsif dismissed the amendment application on the basis that the plaint did not originally seek relief regarding water supply and that the amendment introduced a new cause of action unrelated to the original reliefs.
Legal Issues Presented
- What should be the court's approach in considering the application for amendment?
- Whether the Court can go into the truth or falsity of the case before allowing amendment and whether the Court can give finding on the amendment sought for?
- Whether by seeking an amendment plaintiff is putting forth totally a new case and rather substituting one distinct cause of action for another?
- In case the petition is allowed whether the defendants would be put to hardship and whether the same can be compensated by money?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner/Plaintiff's Arguments
- The plaint requires amendment due to subsequent developments, specifically the disconnection of water supply by the Municipality.
- The amendment is necessary to include a prayer for mandatory injunction to restore water supply.
Second Defendant's Arguments
- The amendment varies and alters the cause of action and subject matter of the suit.
- The water service connection was changed to the second defendant’s name before the suit was filed, and the disconnection occurred thereafter.
- Since the change of water connection was not questioned, the prayer to restore water supply cannot be granted.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| B.K Narayana Pillai v. Parameswaran Pillai, 2000 (1) SCC 712 | Principles governing amendments to pleadings; liberal approach; amendments to avoid multiplicity of litigation; amendments not altering cause of action. | Confirmed that amendments should be allowed when necessary for real controversy determination and do not substitute a new cause of action. |
| Ragu Thilak D. John v. S. Rayappan, AIR 2001 SC 699 | Amendments should be allowed to minimize litigation; limitation issues can be raised after amendment. | Supported the view that amendment sought could not be declined and limitation could be disputed after allowing amendment. |
| A.K Gupta & Sons Ltd. v. Damodar Valley Corpn., AIR 1967 SC 96 | General rule against setting up new cause of action by amendment; exceptions where amendment is a different approach to same facts. | Applied to distinguish between new cause of action and additional approach, allowing amendments that do not constitute new cause. |
| Charan Das v. Amir Khan, AIR 1921 PC 50 | Amendment allowed if not adding a new cause of action. | Referenced to support liberal approach to amendments. |
| L.J Leach and Co. Ltd. v. Jardine Skinner and Co., AIR 1957 SC 357 | Amendments allowed to avoid multiplicity of litigation and not to defeat legal rights. | Supported principle of allowing amendments necessary for real controversy. |
| Kisandas Rupchand v. Rachappa Vithoba Shilwant, ILR 1909 (33) Bom 644 | Amendment not barred if substance of amendment is already in pleading. | Approved to emphasize substance over form in amendments. |
| Pirgonda Hongonda Patil v. Kalgonda Shidgonda Patil, AIR 1957 SC 363 | Similar principle as Kisandas Rupchand regarding amendments. | Approved to reinforce liberal amendment approach. |
| M/S Ganesh Trading Co. v. Moji Ram, 1978 (2) SCC 91 | Shortcomings in pleadings can be rectified by amendments with costs; amendments not to unjustifiably injure accrued rights. | Applied to allow amendment despite initial inefficiency, with costs to compensate inconvenience. |
| Estralla Rubber v. Dass Estate (P) Ltd., 2001 (7) Sup 53 | Delay in amendment application not a ground for rejection if no serious prejudice caused. | Supported allowance of amendment despite delay. |
| Lakshmi Ammal v. Alamelu Ammal, AIR 1924 Madras 309 | Principles on amendment and reliefs ancillary to main relief. | Referenced in context of liberal amendment approach. |
| Karuppanna Pillai v. Ethumalai Pillai, AIR 1927 Madras 859 | Principles on amendments and procedural fairness. | Referenced to support court’s approach. |
| Kumaraswami v. D.R Nanjappa, AIR 1978 Madras 285 (DB) | Amendments and procedural considerations. | Referenced for procedural fairness in amendments. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the application for amendment by considering established legal principles laid down by the Supreme Court. It emphasized that the power to allow amendments is wide but not absolute, requiring a liberal approach to facilitate justice and avoid multiplicity of litigation. The Court rejected the contention that it could assess the truth or falsity of the claim during the amendment stage, clarifying that such merits are to be examined only after framing issues post-amendment.
The Court examined whether the amendment introduced a new cause of action or was ancillary to the existing claims. It found that the amendment seeking restoration of water supply was a natural consequence of the prior relief sought regarding municipal tax assessment changes, and thus ancillary and incidental rather than constituting a new cause of action. The Court noted that the change in water connection followed from the change in property tax assessment, linking the reliefs.
Applying precedents, the Court held that amendments necessary to determine the real controversy should be allowed unless they introduce a new cause of action or cause irreparable prejudice. It also recognized that procedural technicalities should not obstruct substantive justice and that any delay or inconvenience caused by amendments can be compensated by costs.
Holding and Implications
The revision petition is allowed. The order of the District Munsif, Namakkal dated 14.9.2001 dismissing the amendment application is set aside. There is no order as to costs, and the connected miscellaneous petition is closed.
The direct effect of this decision is that the plaintiff is permitted to amend the plaint to include the prayer for restoration of water supply connection. No new precedent is set; the Court reaffirmed the established principles favoring a liberal approach to amendments to ensure justice and avoid multiplicity of litigation.
1. Plaintiff in O.S 117 of 2001 on the file of District Munsif, Namakkal filed an application in I.A No. 413 of 2001 under Order 6 Rule 17 read with Section 151 of Code of Civil Procedure. The learned District Munsif dismissed the said application by an order dated 14.9.2001 The aggrieved plaintiff has preferred the above revision petition against the said order.
2. The petitioner/plaintiff filed the suit in O.S 117 of 2001 on the file of District Munsif Court, Namakkal contending that she took the suit property on lease from the first defendant for the period from 1.1.1979 to 31.12.1998 and as per the terms of the agreement, the plaintiff was permitted to put up super structure. The claim of the plaintiff is that she put up certain building and shops in the suit property and got electricity connection also and that apart, the Municipal assessment too stands in the name of the plaintiff's husband by name Palaniyandi. The plaintiff produced property tax receipts and also water tax receipts. The further claim of the plaintiff is that even after the lease period, she would be entitled to be in possession of the property by virtue of the provisions of the Tamil Nadu City Tenants Protection Act. As there was interference by the first defendant, she filed the suit in O.S 637 of 1998 and also obtained interim injunction in I.A No. 999 of 1998. When the second defendant came out with a plea that he has purchased the property and also threatened to interfere the possession and enjoyment by the plaintiff, she filed a second suit against the second defendant in O.S 527 of 1999. Thereafter in June 2000, third defendant issued notice to the plaintiff claiming to be the absolute owner by virtue of decree obtained for specific performance in O.S 568 of 1999 again on the file of the same Court. The 4th defendant viz., the Municipality, ignoring the telegram sent by the plaintiff wherein the plaintiff informed about the pendency of the suit against the second defendant viz., O.S 527 of 1999, effected mutation of municipal assessment in the name of the second defendant without any enquiry and without hearing plaintiff. In the suit, plaintiff sought for declaration that the proceedings of the 4th defendant/Municipality in changing the house tax assessment from the plaintiff's husband's name to the second defendant is invalid, arbitrary and also prayed for mandatory injunction to restore the tax assessment in the name of plaintiff's husband.
3. The first defendant in the suit filed written statement contending that the lease period was over even way back in the year 1998 and that the plaintiff had put up only some temporary structure and in fact the second defendant is the owner of the suit property. Even according to the first defendant, he was only in possession of the property and not the owner. There is yet another plea that the plaintiff has been colluding with the third defendant and in fact the decree in O.S 568 of 1999 was obtained collusively.
4. Pending suit plaintiff filed I.A No. 413 of 2001 contending that in view of the subsequent development, plaint has to be suitably amended. In the affidavit in support of the petition it has been stated that when the suit was pending, 4th defendant at the instigation of defendants 1 to 3 has disconnected the water supply and hence the prayer for mandatory injunction to restore the water supply has also to be included in the plaint.
5. The second respondent/second defendant resisted the said application contending that the amendment sought for by the petitioner/plaintiff varies, changes and alters the cause of action and subject matter of the suit. According to the second defendant/second respondent, even before filing of the suit i.e,., on 21.12.2000, the water service connection was changed in the name of second defendant/second respondent and the disconnection was only thereafter that was on 20.3.2001 It is also the contention of the second respondent that so long as the change of water service connection in the name of second defendant which was on 21.12.2000 has not been questioned, the present prayer viz., to restore the water supply connection cannot be granted.
6. The learned District Munsif after considering the claims of the respective parties, dismissed the application on the ground that in the plaint, the plaintiff has not asked for any relief with reference to the water supply and the present cause of action put forward by the plaintiff is totally new one and further there is no connection between the reliefs that is sought for in the plaint and the present one mentioned in the application. Being aggrieved by the said order, plaintiff has preferred the present revision petition.
7. On the rival contentions made, the following questions/issues arise for consideration.
1. What should be the court's approach in considering the application for amendment ?
2. Whether the Court can go into the truth or falsity of the case before allowing amendment and whether the Court can give finding on the amendment sought for ?
3. Whether by seeking an amendment plaintiff is putting forth totally a new case and rather substituting one distinct cause of action for another ?
4. In case the petition is allowed whether the defendants would be put to hardship and whether the same can be compensated by money ?
8. Time and again the Supreme Court of India has laid down that the power to allow the amendment is wide, but however the same cannot be claimed as a matter of right and under all circumstances and that the Courts while deciding such prayers should not adopt a hyper technical approach but on the other hand should adopt liberal approach particularly in cases where other side can be compensated with costs. Technicalities of law should not be permitted to hamper the administration of justice between the parties. Amendments are allowed in the pleadings to avoid multiplicity of litigation. Similarly all amendments of the pleadings should be allowed which are necessary for determination of the real controversies in the suit provided the proposed amendment does not alter or substitute a new cause of action on the basis of which the original lis was raised or defence taken. The proposed amendment should not cause such prejudice to the other side which cannot be compensated by costs and no amendment should be allowed which amounts to or results in defeating a legal right accruing to the opposite party on account of lapse of time.
9. The Supreme Court laid down the above principles in the ruling reported in B.K Narayana Pillai v. Parameswaran Pillai, 2000 (1) SCC 712 and after considering plethora of decisions right from the year 1921. In fact this view of the Supreme Court was again confirmed by a recent ruling of the Supreme Court in Ragu Thilak D. John v. S. Rayappan, AIR 2001 SC 699.
10. In A.K Gupta & Sons Ltd., v. Damodar Valley Corpn,. AIR 1967 SC 96 the Supreme Court ruled as under,
“The general rule, no doubt, is that a party is not allowed by amendment to set up a new case or a new cause of action particularly when a suit on new case or cause of action is barred: Weldon v. Neal, 1887 19 QBD 394. But it is also well recognised that where the amendment does not constitute the addition of a new cause of action or raise a different case, but amounts to no more than a different or additional approach to the same facts, the amendment will be allowed even after the expiry of the statutory period of limitation: See Charan Das v. Amir Khan, AIR 1921 PC 50 and L.J Leach and Co. Ltd. v. Jardine Skinner and Co. AIR 1957 SC 357.
The principal reasons that have led to the rule last mentioned are, first, that the object of courts and rules of procedure is to decide the rights of the parties and not to punish them for their mistakes Cropper v. Smith, 1884 (26) CHD 700 and secondly, that a party is strictly not entitled to rely on the statue of limitation when what is sought to be brought in by the amendment can be said in substance to be already in the pleading sought to be amended Kisandas Rupchand v. Rachappa Vithoba Shilwant, ILR 1909 (33) Bom 644 approved in Pirgonda Hongonda Patil v. Kalgonda Shidgonda Patil, AIR 1957 SC 363.
The expression ‘cause of action’ in the present context does not mean ‘every fact which it is material to be proved to entitle the plaintiff to succeed’ as was said in Cooke v. Gill, 1873 (8) CP 107 in a different context, for if it were so, no material fact could ever be amended or added and, of course, no one would want to change or add an immaterial allegation by amendment. That expression for the present purpose only means, a new claim made on a new basis constituted by new facts. Such a view was taken in Robinson v. Unicos Property Corpn. Ltd. 1962 (2) All ER 24 (CA)) and it seems to us to be the only possible view to take. Any other view would make the rule futile. The words ‘new case’ have been understood to mean ‘new set of ideas’: Dornan v. J.W Ellis and Co. Ltd. 1962 (1) All ER 303 (CA)). This also seems to us to be a reasonable view to take. No amendment will be allowed to introduce a new set of ideas to the prejudice of any right acquired by any party by lapse of time.”
And this was again confirmed by the Supreme Court in the ruling reported in B.K Narayana Pillai v. Parameswaran Pillai, 2000 (1) SCC 712. In fact, in M/S Ganesh Trading Co. v. Moji Ram , 1978 (2) SCC 91 the Supreme Court ruled that even if a party or its counsel is inefficient in setting out its case initially the shortcoming can certainly be removed generally by appropriate steps taken by a party which must no doubt pay costs for the inconvenience or expense caused to the other side from its omissions and that the error is not incapable of being rectified so long as remedial steps do not unjustifiably injure rights accrued.
In yet another case reported in Estralla Rubber v. Dass Estate (P) Ltd.., 2001 (7) Sup 53 the Supreme Court observed as under,
“Merely because there was delay in making the amendment application, when no serious prejudice is shown to have been caused to the plaintiff so as to take away any accrued right, the application could not be rejected.”
Also see (1) Lakshmi Ammal v. Alamelu Ammal; AIR 1924 Madras 309 (2) Karuppanna Pillai v. Ethumalai Pillai; AIR 1927 Madras 859 (3) L.J Leach & Co. Ltd. v. Jardine Skinner & Co.;AIR 1957 SC 357 (4) Kumaraswami v. D.R Nanjappa, AIR 1978 Madras 285 (DB) Para 19).
11. In fact, in the recent ruling reported in Ragu Thilak D. John v. S. Rayappan, AIR 2001 SC 699, the Supreme Court ruled thus,
“If the aforesaid test is applied in the instant case, the amendment sought could not be declined. The dominant purpose of allowing the amendment is to minimise the litigation. The plea that the relief sought by way of amendment was barred by time is arguable in the circumstances of the case, as is evident from the perusal of averments made in paras 8(a) to 8(f) of the plaint which were sought to be incorporated by way of amendment. We feel that in the circumstances of the case the plea of limitation being disputed could be made a subject matter of the issue after allowing the amendment prayed for.”
12. Coming to the present case, the plaintiff first filed the suit against the first defendant in O.S 637 of 1998 on the file of District Munsif Court, Namakkal and then another suit against the second defendant in O.S 527 of 1999 and finally filed the present suit. In all the three suits, the property involved and the rights claimed by the plaintiff are virtually same. In the plaint originally filed in this present suit, i.e,. in O.S 1 17 of 2001, the plaintiff sought for a declaration that the proceedings of the 4th defendant/Municipality changing the house tax assessment in the name of second defendant is invalid and arbitrary. Thereafter, the water service connection was disconnected by the Municipality on 20.3.2001 The second respondent would resist the claim contending that the amendment cannot be allowed as the plaintiff has come forward with new cause of action and also seeking new relief and these reliefs have nothing to do with the earlier reliefs already sought for. It is also claimed that even before filing the suit the water service connection was changed in the name of the second respondent and even without questioning the correctness of the same the relief now sought for cannot be considered or granted.
13. Firstly it has to be pointed out that the Courts cannot go into the truth or falsity of the claim made in the application and it cannot give finding on merits of the case without first allowing the amendment and framing issues. That being so, there is no substance in this contention raised by the second respondent.
14. The next question is what is the nature of amendment that is sought for, whether petitioner has come forward with a new case on the basis of new cause of action or it is something in the nature of ancillary or incidental or consequential in view of the subsequent developments.
15. The suit was filed on 23.2.2001 In the amendment petition, the plaintiff wants to include further prayer viz., for mandatory injunction directing the 4th defendant/Municipality to restore the water service connection. It is not the case of the second respondent that even on that day, plaintiff was aware about the change of water service connection in his name on 21.12.2000 The order changing water service connection in the name of second defendant can only because of and pursuant to the change of property tax assessment in the name of the second defendant/second respondent. Or in other words, but for the change in the property tax assessment in the name of second defendant, 4th defendant/Municipality would not have passed the order changing the water service connection in the name of second defendant. In these circumstances, the relief that is sought for can be said to be only in the nature of ancillary and incidental to the relief that has already been sought for in the plaint. Certainly it cannot be said that the plaintiff has come forward with a new case on the basis of new cause of action. The courts can certainly in considering the application for amendment can take note of the subsequent events. In fact, the Supreme Court in the ruling B.K Narayana Pillai v. Parameswaran Pillai, 2000 (1) SCC 712 approved the ruling reported in M/S Ganesh Trading Co. v. Moji Ram , 1978 (2) SCC 91 (cited supra) wherein the Court held that the amendment should be allowed when the same are in the nature of promoting the ends of justice and not for defeating them and that all amendments of the pleadings should be allowed which are necessary for determination of the real controversies in the suit provided the proposed amendment does not alter or substitute a new cause of action on the basis of which the original lis was raised or defence taken.
16. To sum up the legal position,
(1) The power to allow amendment is wide and hence the Court should not adopt hyper technical approach but on the other hand liberal approach should the the general rule particularly in cases where the other side can be compensated with costs.
(2) The general rule is that the party is not allowed to set up new case or new cause of action.
(3) Technicalities of law should not be permitted to hamper the administration of justice between the parties and amendments are allowed in the pleadings to avoid multiplicity of litigation.
(4) Courts cannot go into the truth or falsity of the proposed amendments sought for at the time of considering the application for amendment.
(5) All amendments of the pleadings should be allowed which are necessary for determination of the real controversies in the suit provided the proposed amendment does not alter or substitute a new cause of action on the basis of which the original lis was raised or defence taken.
(6) All reliefs ancillary to main relief and reliefs which are in the nature of additional reliefs should be allowed as general rule.
(7) Even if a party or its counsel is inefficient in setting out its case initially the shortcoming can certainly be removed but however, the party who is put to inconvenience should be suitably paid. The Court has to only see that the error is not incapable of being rectified so long as remedial steps do not unjustifiably injure rights accrued.
(8) The delay in filing petition for amendment should be properly compensated by cost and the error or mistake, if not fraudulent, should not be made a ground for rejecting the application for amendment of plaint or written statement.
17. In the result, the revision petition is allowed. The order of the District Munsif, Namakkal dated 14.9.2001 in I.A No. 413 of 2001 in O.S 117 of 2001 is hereby set aside. There will be no order as to costs. Connected C.M.P 22660 of 2001 is closed.
Alert