Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

N. Ramanathan And Another Petitioner v. Meenakshisundaram

Madras High Court
Aug 8, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Two civil revision petitions (C.R.P. No. 2856 of 1999 and C.R.P. No. 2857 of 1999) were filed by the same parties — the 11th and 12th defendants in O.S. No. 104 of 1995 — against the sole plaintiff. The defendants had earlier moved the Court of the Subordinate Judge, Devakottai, in two interlocutory applications:

  • I.A. No. 641 of 1998 (under Order 9, Rule 7, C.P.C.) seeking to set aside an ex parte order dated 9.9.1997;
  • I.A. No. 655 of 1998 (under Section 151, C.P.C.) seeking appointment of a different advocate-commissioner to inspect the suit property in place of the advocate-commissioner already appointed by the court.

The lower court dismissed both interlocutory applications with costs on 10.12.1998. Because both applications were filed by the same defendants against the same plaintiff and formed part of the same suit, the two revision petitions were heard together before the revisional court, which passed the common order summarized here.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the lower court erred in dismissing the application under Order 9, Rule 7, C.P.C. (I.A. No. 641 of 1998) seeking to set aside the ex parte order dated 9.9.1997, rather than allowing the defendants to be heard on such terms as the court may direct (for example, payment of costs).
  2. Whether the lower court erred in dismissing the application under Section 151, C.P.C. (I.A. No. 655 of 1998) seeking appointment of a different advocate-commissioner, having regard to the allegation that the commissioner appointed (R. Sundrasrinivasan) was a junior in the office of the advocate who drafted the plaint (R. Rajagopalan) and that the commissioner had inspected the property without giving notice to the parties.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (11th & 12th defendants)

  • In I.A. No. 641/1998 (Order 9, Rule 7): The petitioners said they were residents of Madurai, had previously appeared in person, and because they worked in Madurai they requested a friend at Karaikudi to follow up on court developments. That friend failed to inform them, resulting in them being set ex parte on 9.9.1997. Their absence was not wilful or wanton; they sought setting aside of the ex parte order.
  • In I.A. No. 655/1998 (Section 151): The petitioners alleged that the advocate-commissioner appointed by the lower court (R. Sundrasrinivasan) was a junior in the office of the advocate who prepared the plaint (R. Rajagopalan), creating an appearance of partiality. They also asserted the commissioner inspected the suit property without issuing notice to all parties as instructed by the court, and they only became aware of the inspection on 31.10.1998. They had paid court-fee and filed a memo for their 1/6 share in the properties and contended they would suffer irreparable loss unless a new commissioner was appointed.

Respondent's Arguments (Sole plaintiff)

  • In opposition to I.A. No. 641/1998: The respondent filed a short counter alleging the petitioners were aware of proceedings and that the application was a measure to cause unnecessary delay and inconvenience. The respondent also contended the petitioners would not be prejudiced if the application was dismissed.
  • In respect of I.A. No. 655/1998: No counter or opposing pleadings were filed or made available on record.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The revisional court analyzed the matters separately but in the same order:

Concerning I.A. No. 641/1998 (Order 9, Rule 7, C.P.C.)

  • The court recited the purpose of Order 9, Rule 7, C.P.C.: when a defendant who has been put ex parte appears and assigns good cause for his previous non-appearance, the court may, upon such terms as it directs (including costs), permit the defendant to be heard as if he had appeared on the fixed day.
  • The revisional court emphasized the rule's underlying considerations: it is unreasonable to permanently deny a defendant the opportunity to participate in proceedings affecting his valuable rights; where non-appearance cannot be satisfactorily proved, punishment by the imposition of costs (or other terms) is appropriate rather than denying the right to be heard.
  • The lower court's dismissal was examined: the lower court had held that the petitioners' explanations (reliance on a friend to inform them and residence at Madurai) were not proved by oral or documentary evidence and that, notwithstanding receipt of summons on 9.9.1997, petitioners did not respond for about a year; the delay was not substantiated nor reliable. On that basis the lower court dismissed with costs.
  • The revisional court found that, on the general honest thinking behind Order 9, Rule 7, the lower court should have allowed the application subject to heavy costs rather than permanently denying the petitioners the right to defend the suit. The court stressed the principles of natural justice and reiterated that tardy appearance should be punished by costs rather than by denial of the opportunity to contest the suit.
  • Accordingly, the revisional court concluded that the lower court erred in dismissing the Order 9, Rule 7 application outright and allowed the revision in respect of C.R.P. No. 2856 of 1999, setting aside the dismissal of I.A. No. 641/1998.

Concerning I.A. No. 655/1998 (Section 151, C.P.C. — appointment of advocate-commissioner)

  • The revisional court reviewed the petitioners' assertions that the advocate-commissioner appointed (R. Sundrasrinivasan) was a junior in the office of the advocate who drafted the plaint (R. Rajagopalan), and that the commissioner inspected the property without issuing notice to parties as directed, with the petitioners learning of the inspection only on 31.10.1998.
  • The court noted there was no counter to these allegations on record. The lower court had dismissed I.A. No. 655/1998 primarily on the ground that the petitioners' other application (I.A. No. 641/1998) had been dismissed; the lower court treated that dismissal as a basis to refuse the request for a different commissioner.
  • The revisional court found this approach inadequate: because the petitioners' substantive allegation about the commissioner being a junior of the plaintiff's advocate was unchallenged and because the lower court gave no tangible reasons for refusing to consider that allegation, the dismissal of I.A. No. 655/1998 was "absolutely bereft of any merit" and could not be sustained in law.
  • To allay the petitioners' apprehensions and in the interest of justice, the revisional court directed the lower court to appoint a new advocate-commissioner, on payment of the commissioner's fee by the petitioners as fixed by the court. The revisional court thus allowed C.R.P. No. 2857 of 1999 in favor of the petitioners on this point.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: Both civil revision petitions (C.R.P. No. 2856 of 1999 and C.R.P. No. 2857 of 1999) succeed and are allowed.

Direct Consequences (as ordered by the revisional court)

  1. The orders dated 10.12.1998 passed in I.A. Nos. 641 and 655 of 1998 in O.S. No. 104 of 1995 by the Court of Subordinate Judge, Devakottai, are set aside.
  2. With respect to C.R.P. No. 2856 of 1999 (challenging dismissal of I.A. No. 641/1998 under Order 9, Rule 7): the revisional court allowed the application but imposed costs of Rs. 750 to be paid by the petitioners to the respondent within thirty days from receipt of a copy of the revisional order by the lower court; failure to pay within that time would automatically cancel the order.
  3. With respect to C.R.P. No. 2857 of 1999 (challenging dismissal of I.A. No. 655/1998 under Section 151): the lower court is directed to appoint a new advocate-commissioner in place of the one previously appointed; the petitioners shall pay the commissioner's fee as fixed by the court.
  4. There shall be no order as to costs in C.R.P. No. 2857 of 1999.
  5. Consequently, C.M.P. No. 16120 of 1999 is closed.

Broader Implications Discussed by the Court

  • The revisional court reiterated the principle embedded in Order 9, Rule 7, C.P.C.: where a defendant offers an explanation for prior non-appearance, the preferable course is to allow the defendant to be heard on suitable terms (such as imposing costs), rather than permanently depriving the defendant of the opportunity to be heard on the merits of the suit.
  • Natural justice considerations require that defendants be given an opportunity to defend claims affecting their valuable rights; procedural non-compliance or delay should, in appropriate cases, be remedied by imposing costs rather than denial of the right to participate.
  • Where allegations raising a reasonable apprehension of partiality in a court-appointed officer (here, an advocate-commissioner) are made and remain unchallenged on the record, the proper course is to consider appointing a new officer to allay the parties' fears, subject to appropriate terms (such as payment of the commissioner's fee).

Note: This summary is confined strictly to the content and holdings present in the provided opinion. No external precedents or facts not contained in the opinion have been introduced.

Show all summary ...

1. Both the above civil revision petitions have been filed by one and the same parties, viz., the 1 1th and 12 defendants in the suit, as against the sole plaintiff and these defendants No. 1 1 and 12 have filed two applications before the lower court the first one in I.A No. 641 of 1998 in the pending suit in O.S No. 104 of 1995 and the second one in I.A No. 655 of 1998 on the file of the Court of Subordinate Judge, Devakottai.

2. I.A No. 641 of 1998 has been filed by defendants No. 1 1 and 12 under Order 9, Rule 7, C.P.C seeking to set aside the exparte order dated 9.9.1997 and the other I-A. No. 655 of 1998 has been filed under Section 151, C.P.C seeking to appoint some other advocate commissioner to inspect the suit property and to file a report with plan, in the place of the advocate commissioner already appointed by the court. The lower court has passed individual orders in both those applications and since both the applications have been filed by one and the same parties to the suit against the same plaintiff and since being forming part of the same suit, both the above civil revision petitions are heard together and this common order is passed.

3. The petitioners would file their first application in I.A No. 641 of 1998 on averments such as that he is a resident of Madurai town and that he had already appeared before the court in person in the above suit; that since he is working at Madurai, he requested one of his friends at Karaikudi to follow-up the matter and inform him of the developments; that since that friend did not communicate him the developments of the case, the petitioners, who are the 1 1th and 12th defendants had been set ex parte on 9-9.1997; that their absence was neither wilful nor wanton and on such grounds, they would pray to set aside the ex parte order passed by the lower court.

4. This application would be opposed on the part of the respondents before the lower court on a short counter filed with averments such as that the petitioners were aware of the proceedings of the case and in order to cause unnecessary delay and inconvenience to the respondent, they have filed the the petition and that the petitioners would be in no way affected if the petition was not allowed. Only on these two grounds alleged, the respondent would pray to the dismiss the application.

5. Based on these pleadings, the lower court would pass an order dismissing the application with costs on grounds that for the allegations that the petitioner has relied on his friend to inform him of the position and developments of the case and that he failed to inform the same and since the petitioner is a resident of Madurai. he was not aware of the proceedings etc., have not been proved by proper evidence either oral or documentary; that in spite of receipt of summons on 9.9.1997, the petitioners have not responded to the later proceedings for about an year and the reasons assigned for such a long delay are also not substantiated, nor reliable, and therefore, would ultimately arrive at the conclusion to dismiss the application with costs.

6. It is an application filed under Order 9, Rule 7, C.P.C which contemplates that the defendant on his appearance assigns good cause for his previous non-appearance, he may, upon such terms as the Court directs as to costs or otherwise, be heard in answer to the suit as if he had appeared on the day, fixed for his appearance. Rule is clear to the effect that on such terms of costs imposed, the petition could be allowed, since it is a suit pending thereby meaning that it is unreasonable on the part of the court to reject the plea of such a petition being filed by one of the defendants or some of defendants, since it is unreasonable to obstruct the defendant from participating in the very suit proceedings, where his valuable rights are involved, and therefore, as concluded by many upper forms of law that even in the event that such petitioners are not able to substantiate the reasons assigned on their part for their non-appearance in the past, they could be punished only on such terms as costs being saddled on them, but not denying their right to contest the very suit in which their valuable rights get involved.

7. On the above general honest thought, the lower court should have allowed the appeal on heavy costs, instead of denying the opportunity for the petitioners to defend the case, wherein their valuable rights are involved. Moreover, the denial of such opportunity just for the simple reason that such petitioners are slack in their appearance, especially in realisation of their fault when they come forward to continue the proceedings, they must be given opportunity to be heard in .the suit, thus giving effect to the principles of natural justice. Even though they were at a stage, set ex parte in the pending suit, the only way to punish such parties is to saddle them with heavy costs, but not with denial of opportunity to contest the very suit.

8. In view of the above observations, this court, so far as it is concerned with C.R.P No. 2856 of 1999 is of the opinion to allow the revision petition, setting aside the order passed by the lower court in dismissing the application filed by the petitioners under Order 9, Rule 7, C.P.C

9. So far as the other C.R.P No. 2857 of 1999 is concerned, the petitioners have prayed therein for the appointment of some other Commissioner, instead of one who has already been appointed by the court. It seems that the court has already appointed one R. Sundrasrinivasan as the advocate commissioner. The petitioners would submit that the said advocate appointed as the Commissioner by the lower court, has been the junior in the office of Sri R. Rajagopalan, who prepared the very suit, and therefore, it is not fair and proper to appoint the said advocate as the Commissioner, in this matter. Moreover, in spite of clear instructions imparted by the court to issue, notice to all the parties to the suit concerned and to inspect the suit property in their presence and submit the report and plan. On such observations made, the learned Commissioner appointed by the court had not given any notice to all the parties concerned, but had inspected the suit property, which the petitioner came to know only on 31.10-1998 i.e the date on which the case was again posted.

10. The further averments are that the petitioner has paid the necessary court-fee along with the separate memo. for getting his 1/6 share in the suit properties, and hence, it is just and proper to appoint some other advocate commissioner in this proceeding of alloting 1/6 share in the suit property, lest he would be subjected to irreparable loss and hardship and in the said process, no prejudice is caused to the other side also. On such grounds, the petitioners have sought for a different Commissioner to be appointed in the place of one who had already been appointed by the court for inspecting the suit property and to file his report with plan.

10. However, no counter seems to have been filed, nor one made available on record.

11. Based on the above pleadings in the application, the lower court having remarked that the other I.A filed by the petitioner in Interlocutory Application No. 641 of 1998 seeking to set aside the ex parte order dated 9.9.1997 made against them had already been dismissed and in such a situation, the petitioners have come forward to file this application to appoint some other Commissioner in the place of one who has already been appointed for determining the final decree proceedings, on inspection; that since the other application to set aside the ex parte order passed against them itself having been already dismissed, this application has no reason to be allowed, and therefore, on such grounds would dismiss this application also.

13. On the contrary, the question raised on the part of the respondent is thought provoking and the allegations made on the part of the petitioner to the effect that the Commissioner already appointed by the court is the junior in the office of an advocate, viz., R. Rajagopalan, who drafted the very plaint, and therefore, it is not fair and proper to appoint the junior counsel of the plaintiff's lawyer as the Commissioner, stands unchallenged since there is no counter or counter arguments seem to have been filed or advanced on the part of the other side and only citing the dismissal of the application filed by the petitioner in 1.A No. 641 of 1998 to set aside the ex parte order, the lower court, without assigning any other reason much less in a tangible manner for the main allegation levelled against the Commissioner by the petitioner, has bluntly decided the above application dismissing the same with costs, thereby revealing that the allegations made by the petitioners against the Commissioner coming to be proved to be true and in these circumstances, it is always desirable on the part of the court below to think of appointing a new Commissioner in the place of one already appointed. Therefore, this order passed by the lower court since being absolutely bereft of any merit, the same cannot be sustained in law. However, it is desirable that the lower court appoints a new advocate commissioner, on payment of the Commissioner's fee, etc., by the petitioners to allay the fear and apprehension of the petitioner.

In result

(i) both the above civil revision petitions succeed and they are allowed;

(ii) the fair and decretal orders dated 10.12.1998 respectively made in I.A Nos. 641 and 655 of 1998 in O.S No. 104 of 1995 by the Court of Subordinate Judge, Devakottai, are hereby set aside;

(iii) so far as C.R.P No. 2856 of 1999 is concerned, since the petitioners have caused much inconvenience to the respondent by absenting for nearly one year it is appropriate to allow the application with costs of Rs. 750, which shall be paid by the petitioners in favour of the respondent, within thirty days from the date of receipt of a copy of this order by the lower court, lest this order shall automatically get cancelled;

(iv) so far as C.R.P No. 2857 of 1999 is concerned, the lower court is directed to appoint a new advocate commissioner- in the place of one who has already been appointed by the lower court, of course, on payment of Commissioner's fee, etc. by the petitioners, as fixed by the court.

(v) however, in the circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs in C.R.P No. 2857 of 1999.

Consequently, C.M.P No. 16120 of 1999 is closed.