Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation Employees Welfare Union v. State Of Tamil Nadu

Madras High Court
Jul 21, 2000
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Judgment

Factual and Procedural Background

The Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation Employees Welfare Union (the union) filed two writ petitions before the High Court:

  • W.P. No. 15236 of 1998 — the union, through its President, sought a writ of mandamus directing the State of Tamil Nadu and Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation Ltd. (the Corporation / second respondent) to regularise the services of union members from their dates of joining and to pay back-wages and attendant benefits.
  • W.P. No. 17147 of 1998 — the union sought a direction that the Corporation give employment on Saturdays to its members and pay back-wages for the preceding four Saturdays, alleging differential treatment after filing litigation.

The union's factual case: the association (registered under the Societies Act) represented that its members were employed on daily-wage/temporary basis by the Corporation since 1995, often continuously and sometimes on Sundays, with several members having worked in excess of 480 days in a 24-month period. The union submitted multiple representations (20 April 1997; 13 January 1998; May 1998; 10 June 1998 to the Chief Minister) requesting regularisation. The union alleged attempts by the respondents to terminate existing casual employees and replace them with others.

The second respondent Corporation admitted its nature and functions as a government-controlled company, described extensive computerisation and reorganisation of procurement/distribution, and contended that appointments were temporary and made according to government norms. The Corporation denied certain factual claims (e.g., numbers employed), claimed the union was not registered under the Trade Unions Act, and asserted alternative remedies (Labour Commissioner / Labour Court) and that disputed facts required enquiry not suitable under Article 226.

After hearing arguments and considering the pleadings, the Court heard rival contentions and directed appropriate enforcement steps as set out in the operative order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 (Tamil Nadu Act 46 of 1981) applies to the second respondent Corporation.
  2. If the Act applies, whether individual members of the petitioning union who satisfied the statutory criterion (continuous service of 480 days in 24 calendar months) are entitled to conferment of permanent status / regularisation.
  3. Whether the claim for employment on Saturdays and back-wages for specific Saturdays (W.P. No. 17147 of 1998) should be considered in relation to the permanent status enquiry and by what forum.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner-Union's Arguments

  • The second respondent is an industrial/commercial establishment under State control performing functions (procurement, storage, distribution of medicines) that bring it within the scope of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981.
  • Members were continuously employed from 1995 onwards on daily-wages and many satisfied the statutory criterion of 480 days' continuous service in 24 months; therefore they must be regularised and made permanent from the date they satisfy the condition.
  • In W.P. No. 17147/1998, denial of Saturday work to union members (while permitting permanent employees) is arbitrary and violative of Article 14 and contravenes Section 9A of the Industrial Disputes Act (noting lack of notice).
  • The union, though not a trade union under the Trade Unions Act, is registered under the Societies Act and can espouse the members' cause; hence the writ is maintainable.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The second respondent contended that the writ petitions were not maintainable because (a) applicability of the Act was doubtful, (b) factual disputes (number of days worked, identities, categories) required adjudication on oral and documentary evidence not appropriate under Article 226, and (c) there were effective alternate remedies (Labour Inspector / Commissioner of Labour / Labour Court) to raise industrial disputes.
  • The Corporation emphasised radical computerisation and a manpower study recommending reduction in manpower; it asserted it did not require the number of casual labourers claimed and that there were no sanctioned posts to regularise the casuals.
  • It also disputed the union's claimed numbers (denying that about 100 were employed, stating only about 62) and filed additional annexures late in proceedings; the Corporation raised points about technical designations and use of specialised agencies for certain tasks.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Madhyamik Siksha Parishad, Uttar Pradesh v. Anil Kumar Mishra [1994 (1) L.L.N 851] Principle: In the absence of sanctioned posts, directions for regularisation of casual workmen cannot be issued; ad hoc assignments that anticipateably end do not justify regularisation by analogy to Industrial Disputes Act provisions. The Court noted this authority relied upon by the respondent but contrasted it with the special statutory mandate of the Tamil Nadu Act; the Court did not allow the Corporation's contention to defeat conferment of permanent status where the special enactment applies.
State of Haryana v. Piara Singh [1992 (2) L.L.N 1037] Principle: A court must act with due care and caution when issuing directions for regularisation of casual workers. The Court acknowledged the principle and applied it in a measured way — by directing the statutorily empowered Inspector to verify records and determine claims within a timeframe rather than directly imposing regularisation without inquiry.
Basant Kumar v. Eagle Rolling Mills [A.I.R. 1964 S.C. 1260] Principle: Wide powers under Article 226 are not to be used to adjudicate industrial disputes of the kind that should be ventilated before statutory labour forums; alternative statutory remedies may be appropriate. The Court accepted the cautionary principle but, given the special enactment (Tamil Nadu Act 46 of 1981) and the material before it, framed relief by invoking the Act's enforcement machinery (Inspector) rather than declining jurisdiction outright.
Tamil Nadu Electricity Board v. Sumathi [(2000) 4 S.C.C. 543] Principle: Disputed questions of fact ordinarily cannot be gone into under Article 226. The Court recognized this principle but found that sufficient documentary material had been placed by the petitioners and that the appropriate course was to direct the statutory Inspector to verify records and determine factual questions under the Act.
Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation Modern Rice Mill Engineering Section Employees Union v. Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation [1999 (3) L.L.N 286] Principle / Holding: Interpreting S.3 of the Tamil Nadu Act 46/1981, a court directed conferment of permanent status to casual employees from the date they satisfied the 480-day condition. The Court relied on this decision as a supporting precedent where similar relief was granted; it reinforced the view that the statutory mandate requires conferment where conditions are met.
A. Palanivel v. Tamil Nadu Khadi and Village Industries Board [(1997) 3 L.L.N 509] Principle / Holding: A similar direction for regularisation in the context of S.3 of the Tamil Nadu Act. The Court referenced this prior order as consistent support for directing regularisation where statutory criteria are established.
(1991) 1 SCC 28 : A.I.R. 1990 S.C. 2228 (authority cited in text) Principle: Employees who serve long spells and have requisite qualifications should not be summarily dismissed and, where possible, their services should be regularised. The Court cited this Supreme Court authority to underline the policy that long-serving employees with qualifications should be regularised where appropriate; it formed part of the reasoning favouring regularisation under the state Act.
N. Mamundiraj v. Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd., Trichy [1998 (5) L.L.N (Supp.)] Principle: Where workmen plead completion of 480 days, the employer must determine (after hearing) whether the condition is satisfied and whether any interruption was due to unfair labour practice; if satisfied, worker to be made permanent with consequential reliefs. The Court relied on this Division Bench decision and adopted its approach by directing the Inspector to determine whether the petitioners met the statutory test and to pass orders within a limited time (three months), affording an opportunity of hearing.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a structured manner:

  1. Determine applicability of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 (the Act) to the second respondent:
    • The Court examined the Memorandum and Articles of Association and functions of the Corporation (procurement, distribution, district warehouses, supply to primary health centres), and concluded the Corporation is a company owned by the State and operates as a commercial agency.
    • Relying on the definition of "commercial establishment" in Section 2(3) of the Tamil Nadu Shops and Establishments Act, 1947, the Court held the Corporation falls within that definition and therefore the Tamil Nadu Act 46 of 1981 is applicable to the Corporation.
  2. Maintainability and locus of the union's petition:
    • The union is registered under the Societies Act (Registration No. 116 of 1998) and was formed for the welfare of its members; the Court held the union can espouse the cause of its members and that the writ petition is maintainable despite not being a trade union under the Trade Unions Act.
  3. Assessment of evidence and contested facts:
    • The petitioners furnished appointment orders, lists of members, dates of joining, qualifications and charts of days worked (pages 23–35 of the typed-set). The counter-affidavit by the Corporation contained general denials but no detailed factual contradiction except a late additional affidavit disputing numbers and designations.
    • The Court treated the late additional particulars by the Corporation as an afterthought because the detailed material was not filed earlier.
  4. Legal effect of the Act and response to the Corporation's defences:
    • Section 3 of the Tamil Nadu Act mandates conferment of permanent status where a workman is in continuous service for 480 days within 24 calendar months, with continuity defined to allow for certain authorised interruptions.
    • The Corporation's argument that computerisation and reduced manual work / absence of sanctioned posts preclude regularisation was considered, but the Court held that the special statutory mandate could not be frustrated by such operational changes; the statute imposes an obligation where the statutory test is met.
    • The Court took judicial precedents into account (both cautionary and supportive), but opted to invoke the Act's administrative enforcement machinery (Inspector) to resolve disputed facts and implement relief rather than dismissing the petitions for lack of factual minutiae.
  5. Choice of remedy and directions:
    • Rather than directly ordering individual regularisations, the Court directed the statutorily empowered Inspector (under Section 4 of the Act and the Rules) to inspect and verify the Corporation's registers and records, determine eligibility under Section 3, and pass appropriate orders.
    • The Inspector was also directed to consider the Saturday-employment/back-wages claim (W.P. No. 17147 of 1998) in the course of the enquiry.
    • The Inspector was given a time-bound mandate: ascertain and decide within three months from receipt of a copy of the order, after affording both parties an opportunity to be heard.
  6. Interim measures:
    • Status quo as on date was directed to be maintained by both parties until the Inspector passes orders.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core rulings emphasized):

  • The Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 (Tamil Nadu Act 46 of 1981) is applicable to the second respondent-Corporation.
  • The Inspector having jurisdiction over the second respondent is directed to inspect and verify the records and to pass appropriate orders under Section 3 of the Act with regard to the union members' claims.
  • The Inspector is also directed to consider the claim regarding employment on Saturdays and related back-wages.
  • The Inspector must determine the referred questions within three months from receipt of a copy of the order after affording both parties an opportunity to be heard.
  • Till the Inspector's order, the status quo as on date shall be maintained by both parties.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The immediate consequence is administrative: the statutorily appointed Inspector will conduct an inquiry into the records and determine which individual workers satisfy the 480-days-in-24-months test and are therefore entitled to conferment of permanent status under Section 3.
  • The Inspector will also consider claims about Saturday employment and back-wages as part of that inquiry; the Court did not itself decide the Saturday/back-wages claim but delegated fact-finding and order-making to the Inspector under the Act.
  • The writ petitions were allowed to the extent set out in the order; no costs were awarded and miscellaneous petitions were closed.
  • Broader legal policy consequences were not expansively re-determined by the Court in this order; the decision implements the statutory mechanism of the Tamil Nadu Act rather than announcing a new, generalized rule beyond the Act's framework. The immediate effect is the initiation of statutory inspection and possible regularisation for eligible individuals identified by the Inspector.

Note: This summary is strictly confined to and derived from the content of the provided judgment text. No facts or conclusions not explicitly contained in that text have been introduced.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

1. The Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation Employees Welfare Union is the petitioner in both the above writ petitions. In W.P No. 15236 of 1998, the said union through its President prays for issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the respondents, namely, the State of Tamil Nadu and Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation, Ltd., to regularise the services of the petitioner-association members from the date their joining service and to pay back-wages and other attended benefits.

2. In Writ Petition No. 17147 of 1998, the very same Corporation has prayed for similar direction directing the second respondent Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation, Ltd., to give employment on Saturdays to the petitioner-association members and to pay back-wages for the previous four Saturdays and other attendent benefits.

3. The case of the petitioner-union is briefly stated hereunder:

According to the union Secretary Ms. C. Sumathi, the association is registered under the Societies Act and the same was formed for the welfare of the members of the union. The Second respondent-Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation, Ltd., is a company registered under the Indian Companies Act on 1 July 1994. The main object of the Corporation is to buy or otherwise acquire all kinds and varieties of generic and patent medicines, drugs, etc., and to sell or supply to various hospitals and other health Centres; to purchase, distribute, assemble, instal, maintain all types of capital equipments and instruments required in hospitals; to undertake designing and construction of hospitals and or other buildings for Government, or for any other person including local authorities, Corporation, trusts, companies, firms and individuals; to establish modem warehouses and engineering workshops to manufacture, assemble, repair or otherwise maintain various medical equipments, surgical instruments, diagnostic equipments, etc., and to establish research and development centres and institutes for medical and para-medical personnel for imparting training in various Techno-Managerial fields. Thus, the second respondent-company is an industrial establishment under the control of Health Department of Government of Tamil Nadu, first respondent herein.

4. The annual turn over is approximately more than Rs. 80 crores and the respondent-Corporation supplies medicines and surgical instruments to all the Primary Health Centres and Medical Institutions in the State of Tamil Nadu. The second respondent is having warehouse in Madras City and also 23 warehouses in the 23 District headquarters, for storing of medicine and drugs. So, according to her, the employees of the Corporation are discharging tremendous work in procuring medicine from all leading companies and disbursing the medicines and surgical instruments to all the institutions in a fast and quick manner. In order to achieve the objects adumbrated in Articles of Association, the second respondent-company employed the union members for their various works purely on temporary basis continuously without any break. There was no Standing Orders. There is no service law governing the employees. At the end of the month they have been paid salaries to the days they are working. At present 101 members of the union are working in different departments of the second respondent-company. Many of mem are Graduates, Post Graduates and technical persons and they come to office and report for duty at 9.30 A.M and leave office in the late evening in order to finish the pending works. Since it is a medical service, several times they worked on Sundays also. The daily salaries were revised from time to time. It is further stated that from 1995 on wards till date, the petitioner members were continuously employed by the second respondent. Even though the members of the union have completed and worked more than 480 days in a period of 24 calendar months in an industrial establishment, the second respondent has not taken any steps to regularise their services. They submitted several representations to the respondents to regularise their services. Representation was made to the second respondent on 20 April 1997. On 13 January 1998, another representation was made to the Health Secretary for regularisation of their services. In May 1998, another representation was made to the second respondent. On 10 June 1998, the petitioner association has given representation to the Hon'ble Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu to regularise their services. Instead of regularising their services, the respondents are taking steps to terminate the services of the members and to employ new persons in their place. In such circumstances, having no other effective remedy, the union has approached this Court by way of the present Writ Petition No. 15236 of 1998.

5. In W.P No. 17147 of 1998, the case of the petitioner-union is that from the inception of the second respondent-Corporation Saturday was working day for the past four years from the date of filing of the writ petition. Because the petitioner-association has filed writ petition, the second respondent for the first time on 10 October 1998 did not allow the petitioner-association members to work for Saturday. But the second respondent permitted all the permanent employees to work on 10 October 1998. The second respondent also did not allow the members of the petitioner-association to work on the subsequent Saturdays, namely, on 17 October 1998 and 24 October 1998. But all other permanent employees were permitted to work on those days. The act of the second respondent to deny the work on Saturdays for the members of the petitioner-association even though the Saturday is working day is illegal and violative of Art. 14 of the Constitution of India. It is further submitted that not giving employment on Saturdays without giving notice is a clear violation of S. 9A of the Industrial Disputes Act.

6. Second respondent-Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation filed a counter-affidavit in W.P No. 15236 of 1998 wherein it is stated that the second respondent is a nodal agency set up by the Government of Tamil Nadu to procure essential drugs, other medical equipments/items for the Government sector. The second respondent has brought about sweeping changes in the tender system to make it more transparent and has also appointed expert committee consisting of experts drawn from various medical fields to go into the quality of the samples submitted by the tenderers. The second respondent has also set up godowns in all the District headquarters which is a point of drug distribution in the district. The drug manufacturers are required to supply drugs to the district godowns. The respective hospitals are given allocation of funds through pass-book for drawal of drugs from the second respondent. Each institution is given a pass book indicating its annual entitlement in monetary terms within which it can draw any drug from the District Drug Warehouses (DWH). The entire operation of the second respondent has been computerised. Each DWH has a computer linked to the central computer in the second respondent's head office at Madras through NICNET. Receipts and issues of drugs have been computerised resulting in instantaneous adjustments in stock position. The second respondent had appointed certain individuals temporarily on daily-wages. Those who were approved data entry operator were paid consolidated salary every month. Appointment were made only on the basis of norms and qualifications fixed by the Government for all purposes. The second respondent is adopting the rules framed by the State Government only. Service Rules are now under preparation. The actual man power requirement for this Corporation has yet to be worked out. The second respondent has made radical developments in ensuring total computerisation of its tender procurement distribution, supply, etc. Apart from the above factual information, it is also stated that the petitioner-union is not registered under the Trade Unions Act. The writ petition has been filed against the Managing Director of the second respondent and not against the Corporation. There is an effective alternative remedy by approaching the Commissioner of Labour and raising industrial disputes. The disputed question of fact may not be gone into by this Court and on this ground itself the writ petition is liable to be dismissed. The prayer for mandamus to regularise services is not maintainable.

7. The second respondent has also filed an additional affidavit wherein they denied the averment that there are about 100 odd members of the petitioner's association in the services of their Corporation. At present only about 62 of them are presently employed in their Corporation. The designation of various persons mentioned therein are incorrect. The chart filed by the union does not reflect the correct factual position. The second respondent has conducted a detailed manpower study which has recommended drastic reduction in manpower requirements. The second respondent does not require so many casual labours. Since the entire process has been computerised and this has entailed drastic reduction in the work force. In view of the injunction order by this Court, the second respondent is not in a position to dispense with the casual labourers. One of the casual employees P. Sivanandanam has approached the Labour Inspector, Circle II, Chennai, who is the statutory authority under the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 on the same issue regarding confirmation and regularisation of service. They have not appointed any person in the place of casual employees. Only in the area of computer operation, software development and security the services of specialised agencies like Broadline Computers and Ex-servicemen Welfare Board are used since the second respondent does not have necessary expertise in those areas. It is finally stated that at present only 62 of the alleged members of the petitioner-union are working in various offices of the second respondent as given in Annexure A of the annexed typed set. With these averments, the second respondent prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.

8. The first respondent has filed counter-affidavit adopting the counter-affidavit of the second respondent in so far as it concerns the first respondent.

9. Since similar details have been furnished by the petitioner-union and the second respondent with regard to their respective claim in W.P No. 17147 of 1998, I am not referring the same once again.

10. In the light of the above pleadings, I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner-union as well as respondents.

11. Sri K. Chandru, learned senior counsel for the Employees Welfare Union, after taking me through the service particulars of the members of the union and the relevant provisions from the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 (hereinafter referred to as the Act), would contend that the second respondent company being an industrial establishment in terms of the said Act, the respondents are duty bound to regualrise the services of the members of the union from the date of their appointment. He also contended that inasmuch as the members of the petitioner-union satisfied the criteria, namely, continuous service for a period of 480 days in a period of 24 calendar months in an industrial establishment, their services should be made permanent. On the other hand, Sri R. Krisnnamurthy, learned senior counsel for the second respondent- Medical Services Corporation, would contend that inasmuch as the applicability of the Act itself is doubtful, the writ petition is not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed. He also contended that the issue raised herein relates to regularisation of the service of the members of the petitioner-union which requires adjudication in the form of oral and documentary evidence, hence the disputed questions or facts cannot be gone into by this Court under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India. In any event, according to him, there is an effective alternative mechanism available under the said Act, hence they have to approach the Labour Court and establish their claim. Hence, both the writ petitions are liable to be dismissed.

12. I have carefully considered the rival submissions.

13. The second respondent-Corporation, viz., Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation, Ltd., is a company registered under the Indian Companies Act on 1 July 1994. The object of the company as seen from the Memorandum of Articles of Association are as follows:

“(i) To buy or otherwise acquire all kinds and varieties of generic and patent medicines, drugs, mixtures, formulations, tablets, pills, powders, pharmaceutical and medical products, needleles, syringes, injectables vaccines, sera, immunogens, phylacogens, chemicals and surgical dressings, kits and instruments and to sell or supply to various hospitals and other health centres.

(ii) To purchase, distribute, assemble, install, maintain or otherwise deal in all types of capital equipments and instruments required in hospitals.

(iii) To undertake designing and constructions of hospital and or other buildings for Government, or for any other person including local authorities, corporations, societies, trusts, companies, firms and individuals.

(iv) To establish modern warehouses and engineering workshops to manufacture, assemble, repair or otherwise maintain various medical equipments, surgical instruments, diagnostic equipments, fire-fighting equipments, furniture and fittings including hospital furniture and also to undertake civil and other general maintenance of hospitals.

(v) To establish research and development centres and institutes for medical and para-medical personnel for imparting training in various techno-managerial fields. Thus, the second respondent-company is an industrial establishment under the control of Health department of Government of Tamil Nadu.”

The Corporation supplies medicines and surgical instruments to all the Primary Health Centres and Medical Institutions in the State of Tamil Nadu. It is having Warehouse in Madras City and 23 Warehouses in the 23 District Headquarters, for storing of medicine and drugs. It is the grievance of the petitioner-union that in order to achieve the object enumerated in the Articles of Association, the second respondent-company employed the union members for their various works purely on temporary basis continuously without any breach. According to them, there is no Standing Order or Service Rules governing the employees. They have been paying salaries to the days they are working at the end of the month. It is also their definite case that at present 101 members of the union are working in different departeents of the second respondent-company. Many of them are graduates, post graduates and technical persons and they report for duty at 9.30 AM and leave the office in the late evening. Since it is a medical service, several times they work on Sundays also. The petitioner-union has also furnished the details regarding the name of the post and the salary being paid per day. It is also their definite case that from 1995 onwards the members were continuously employed by the second respondent and in spite of several representations to regularise their services, instead of acceding to their request and regularise their services, they are taking cteps to terminate the services of the members of the unyon and employ new person in their place. Since the learned senior counsel for the second respondent-Corporation raised a doubt regarding applicability of the Act (Tamil Nadu Act 46 of 1981),. at the foremost I shall consider whether the Act is applicable to second respondent-Corporation. The Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 (Tamil Nadu Act, 46 of 1981) (in short the Act) came into force on 1 January 1982. The Statement of Objects and Reasons for the enactment of the said Act would show that many workers in industrial establishments are being kept under temporary rolls and on that pretext are being denied various statutory as well as non-statutory benefits which are given to permanent workers. Mainly, in many establishments non-permanent workers are given consolidated wages which are far below the occupational wages and do not carry the benefit of dearness allowance paid to permanent employees. Similarly they are denied various other benefits like payment of festival, cyclone and marriage advances, payment of ex gratia over and above the statutory bonus, supply of uniforms and tea, preference for the dependents of the employees in the matter of employment, etc. In order to curb various unfair labour practices and following the decision at the 25th meeting of the State Labour Advisory Board the Government have decided to undertake a special legislation to confer permanent status to the workers in various industrial establishments who have put in a service for a period of 480 days in a period of 24 calendar months in such industrial establishments. The said Act applies to several industrial establishments in which not less than 50 workmen were employed on any day of the preceding 12 months. It is also open to the State Government to make the provisions of the Act applicable to any of the industrial establishments employing such number of workmen less than 50 by way of notification. Section 2(3) defines “industrial establishment” as follows:

“Section 2(3) ‘Industrial establishment’ means—

(a) to (d) xxx

(e) an establishment as defined in Cl.(6) of S. 2 of the Tamil Nadu Shops and Establishments Act, 1947 (Tamil Nadu Act XXXVI of 1958); or

(f) and (g) xxx

Section 2(4) ‘workman’ means any person employed in any industrial establishment to do any skilled or unskilled, manual, supervisory, technical or clerical work for hire or reward, whether the terms of employment be express or implied, but does not include any such person—

(a) who is employed in the police service or as an officer or other employee of a prison; or

(b) who is employed mainly in managerial or administrative capacity; or

(c) who, being employed in a supervisory capacity, draws wages exceeding one thousand rupees per mensem or exercises, either by the nature of the duties attached to the office or by reason of the powers vested in him, functions mainly of a managerial nature.

Section 3. Conferment of permanent status to workmen.— (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force every workman who is in continuous service for a period of four hundred and eighty days in a period of twenty-four calendar months in an industrial establishment’ shall be made permanent.

(2) A workman shall be said to be in continuous service for a period if he is, for that period, in uninterrupted service, including service which may be interrupted on account of sickness or authorised leave or an accident or a strike, which is not illegal, or a lockout or on account of non-employment or discharge of such workman for a period which does not exceed three months and during which period a substitute has been employed in is place by the employer, or a cessation of work which is not due to any fault on the part of the workman.”

The definition of “commercial establishment” and “establishment” as defined in the Tamil Nadu Shops and Establishments Act, 1947 (Act 36 of 1947) are as follows:

“Section 2 (3) ‘commercial establishment’ means an establishment which is not a shop but which carries on the business of advertising, commission, forwarding or commercial agency, or which is a clerical department of a factory or industrial undertaking or which is an insurance company, joint stock company, bank, broker's office or exchange and includes such other establishment as the State Government may by notification declare to be a commercial establishment for the purpose of this Act;

(4) and (5) xxx

(6) ‘establishment’ means a shop, commercial establishment, restaurant, eating-house, residential hotel, theatre or any place of public amusement or entertainment and includes such establishment as the State Government may by notification declare to be an establishment for the purposes of this Act.”

I have already stated that the second respondent-Corporation is a company registered under the Companies Act and wholly owned by the Government of Tamil Nadu. The perusal of the objects and nature of the work from the Articles of Association would show that it is a commercial agency and it comes within the definition of “commercial establishment” under S. 2(3) of the Act 36 of 1947; accordingly I hold that the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 (Act 46 of 1981) is applicable to the second respondent-Corporation.

14. Now I shall consider the other aspect namely, whether the members of the petitioner-union are to be regularised and made permanent in terms of Tamil Nadu Act 46 of 1981. The petitioner-union has filed a copy of the appointment orders issued by the second respondent in the typed-set of papers. It is clear that the members of the union were appointed in different categories on daily-wages for a period of 89 days. After working several years from 1995, they sent a representation to the second respondent for regularisation. The representations have been made on 20 April 1997 to the second respondent and on 13 January 1998 to the first respondent. They also made similar representation to the Hon'ble Chief Minister on 10 June 1998. Since there is no response from any of the respondents, the petitioner-union which is registered under the Societies Registration Act, has approached this Court for necessary relief. All the representations find place in the typed-set of papers. The petitioner-union has also filed a list of their members, their designation, academic and technical qualification, date of joining number of days worked from 1995 to 1998 and the total number of days worked by way of separate chart. Those details find place from pages 23 to 35 in the typed-set of papers. Though it is stated that petitioner-union is not a trade union registered under the Trade Unions Act, it is clear that it is registered under the Societies Act with Registration No. 116 of 1998. It is clear that the association was formed for the welfare of the members of the union. In such a circumstances, I am of the view that petitioner can espouse the cause of the members of the Union and the present writ petition is maintainable.

15. I have already referred to the factual particulars of the members of the petitioner-union such as their educational qualification, initial appointment and number of days worked. In the counter-affidavit filed by the second respondent, except certain general denial, no other material has been placed to dislodge the claim made by the petitioner. In the counter-affidavit, dated 18 December 1998, without furnishing any kind of details or controverting the information given by the petitioner-union in the typed-set of papers, it is merely stated that the writ petition is liable to be dismissed on the ground that petitioner is not registered under the Trade Unions Act, that the same is filed against the Managing Director of the second respondent and not against the Corporation, that there is no cause of action, that there is an effective alternative remedy for approaching the Commissioner of Labour by raising an industrial dispute and that the disputed questions of fact may not be gone into by this Court, etc. No doubt, on the last day of the hearing, namely, 3 July 2000 that too at the time of closing of the argument, the Managing Director of the second respondent has filed an additional affidavit stating that the list furnished by the petitioner-union is not correct and that at present only about 62 of them are employed in their company. By saying so, the second respondent has also furnished a typed-set containing Annexures A to F. Annexure A to C contain list of persons under various categories working in the second respondent-Corporation. Annexure D refers to letters said to have been made by two workmen informing the company that they are not interested in continuing in the second respondent-company. Annexure E refers to representation made by one P. Sivanandham, casual labourer, to the Labour Inspector, Chennai-6, requesting him to issue direction to the second respondent-company for regularising his service. Annexure “F” shows that on the basis of the complaint made by the very same person, namely, Sivanandham, notice has been issued by the Labour Officer for enquiry under S. 2A of the Industrial Disputes Act. It is not clear why the second respondent has not furnished those details in the earlier counter-affidavit, dated 18 December 1998. In such a circumstances I am of the view that furnishing certain details on the last date of the argument is an after-thought.

16. On the other hand, in the light of my conclusion, namely, applicability of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981, to the second respondent-Corporation and in the light of the information furnished by the union regarding the educational qualification and number of days worked by their members and in the absence of any specific denial supported by facts and figures, it would be possible for this Court to issue necessary direction for conferment of permanent status to the persons concerned. Sri R. Krishnamurthy, learned senior counsel for the second respondent, by pointing out that now the entire process has been computerised and this has entailed drastic reduction in the work force; hence in the absence of any sanctioned post and manual work by the labourers are being dispensed with, the second respondent is not in a position to absorb the members of the petitioner-union. He very much relied on a decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Madhyamik Siksha Parishad, Uttar Pradesh v. Anil Kumar Mishra [1994 (1) L.L.N 851], their Lordships of the Supreme Court in that case have held that in the absence of sanctioned post, direction for regularisation of casual workmen cannot be issued. The learned senior counsel very much relied on the following passage in the said decision, in Para. 5, at page 852:

“We are unable to uphold the order of the High Court. There were no sanctioned posts in existence to which they could be said to have been appointed. The assignment was an ad hoc one which anticipatedly spent itself out. It is difficult to envisage for them, the status of workmen on the analogy of the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, importing the incidents of completion of 240 days work. The legal consequences that flow from work for that duration under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, are entirely different from what, by way of implication, is attributed to the present situation by way of analogy. The completion of 240 days' work does not, under that law import the right to regularisation. It merely imposes certain obligations on the employer at the time of termination of the service. It is not appropriate to import and apply that analogy, in an extended or enlarged form here.”

The other decision referred to is in the case of State of Haryana v. Piara Singh [1992 (2) L.L.N 1037], wherein their Lordships have held that the Court must Act with aue care and caution, while issuing direction for regularisation of casuals. He also relied on another decision in the case of Basant Kumar v. Eagle Rolling Mills [A.I.R 1964 S.C 1260], in which it has been held that although the powers conferred on the High Court under Art. 226 are very wide they could not take in within their sweep industrial dispute of the kind which the contention of the workmen sought to raise. It has also been held that the proper remedy which was available to the workmen to ventilate their grievances in respect of the notices and circulars regarding withdrawal of certain medical benefits was to take recourse to S. 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act or seek relief, if possible, under Ss. 74 and 75 of the Employees' State Insurance Act. By pointing out a decision in Tamil Nadu Electricity Board v. Sumathi [(2000) 4 S.C.C 543], learned senior counsel for the second respondent, would contend that disputed questions of fact cannot be considered under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India. With regard to the legal position, it is not the case of the second respondent that neither their workload is reduced nor their activities restricted to certain areas. On the other hand, it is seen from the Counter-affidavit of the second respondent, dated. 18 December 1998 and 3 July 2000, that since they made radical developments in ensuring total computerisation of its tender process, procurement, distribution, supply, etc., the manual handling is likely to be reduced, hence they are not in a position to regualrise all these persons. Such contention cannot be accepted in view of the provisions of the special enactment, namely, the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981. As per S. 3 of the said Act, notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force every workmen who is in continuous service for a period of four hundred and eighty days in a period of twenty-four calendar months in an industrial establishment shall be made permanent. Continuous service has been explained in Sub-sec.(2) of S. 3. I have already held that the second respondent-company is an establishment and it is a commercial agency in terms of S. 2(3) of the Tamil Nadu Shops and Establishments Act, 1947 and they cannot escape from the clutches of the statutory mandate and wriggle out from its responsibility. In the case of Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation Modern Rice Mill Engineering Section Employees Union v. Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation [1999 (3) L.L.N 286], P.D Dinakaran, J., in a similar circumstance in respect of casual employees working in Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation, by interpreting S. 3 of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishment (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981, directed the management — Civil Supplies Corporation to confer permanent status to individual workman from the day which they satisfy the condition namely completing the continuous service for period of 480 days in a period of 24 calendar months in their establishment. Similar direction has been issued by me in A. Palanivel v. Tamil Nadu. Khadi and Village Industries Board [(1997) 3 L.L.N 509]. In (1991) 1 SCC 28 : A.I.R 1990 S.C 2228, their Lordships have held that employees who are serving in the establishment for long spells and have the requisite qualifications should not be thrown out, but their services have to be regularised as far as possible. I have already stated that the petitioner-union has esteblished that their members in various posts have worked at the respective posts for reasonable long spells, accordingly, they are entitled to regularisation in service.

17. Among the above mentioned decisions, it is useful to refer to the recent Division Bench decision of this Court in N. Mamundiraj v. Bharat Heavy Electrical, Ltd. Trichy [1998 (5) L.L.N (Supp.)]. The issue before the Division Bench was with reference to conferment of permanent status to casual labourers working in Bharat Heavy Electricals, Ltd., Trichy, who have completed 480 days of continuous service. Their Lordships after accepting the case pleaded by the workmen, directed the second respondent therein to determine whether the appellants (workmen) had worked for 480 days in preceding 24 calendar months and whether the interrupted period of service, if any of cessation of work if any, brought about is an unfair labour practice. They further observed that in view of the observations made in the earlier part of their judgment, if the answer is in affirmative, the worker would be entitled to the conferment of the status of permanent employee with effect from the date of termination of service with all other consequential reliefs following from such a declaration. The Bench has also directed the second respondent therein to determine the above referred questions within three months from the date of receipt of a copy of that judgment, after affording an opportunity of being heard to both the parties. Section 4 of the Tamil Nadu Act 46 of 1981 enables the Government to appoint Inspectors for the purpose of implementing the provisions of the Act. As a matter of fact, the Government have appointed Inspectors. The powers of Inspectors have been enumerated in rule 3 of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Rules, 1981. As per rule 4, it is incumbent on the employer of an industrial establishments to furnish all the required information to the Inspector. As per rule 6, every employer of an industrial establishment has to maintain a register of workmen in Form No I and produce the same whenever it is required by the Inspector having jurisdiction over the industrial establishment. Sub-rule (4) of rule 6 envisages the employer to make a representation to the Inspector and the latter can examine the representation after making enquiries and issue suitable directions to the employer for rectification of the register in Form No. 1 or issue orders conferring permanent status to the workman concerned. In the light of the powers conferred on the Inspector, by the statute and in view of the factual information furnished by the petitioner-union, it would be appropriate, for this Court to issue direction to the concerned Inspector to verify the registers of the second respondent-Corporation with reference to the claim made by the petitioner-union and pass appropriate orders conferring permanent status to the eligible workmen.

18. With regard to the claim made by the very same union in WP. No. 17147 of 1998 regarding providing employment on Saturdays to the members of the petitioner-union and to back-wages for the previous four Saturdays, I am of the view that the same may also be considered by the Inspector while conducting enquiry with regard to permanent status of the members ofthe petitioner-union.

19. Under these circumstances, I pass the following orders:

(1) the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 (Tamil Nadu Act 46 of 1981) is applicable to the second respondent-Corporation;

(2) the ‘Inspector’ having jurisdiction over the second respondent is directed to inspect and verify the records of the second respondent-Corporation and pass appropriate orders under S. 3 of the said Act with regard to the claim made by the members of the petitioner-union;

(3) the ‘Inspector’ is also directed to consider the claim made by the petitioner-union regarding employment on Saturdays to the members of the petitioner-union;

(4) the ‘Inspector’ is further directed to determine the above referred questions within three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order after affording an opportunity of being heard to both parties; and

(5) till an order is passed by the ‘Inspector’ as stated above, status quo as on date shall be maintained by both parties. Writ petitions are allowed to the extent mentioned above. No costs. All the miscellaneous petitions are closed.

Petitions allowed.