- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Pillaiyar Petitioner v. Ganesan And Another S
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
(Summary based exclusively on the provided opinion)
This civil revision challenges an order of the Principal District Munsif, Srivilluputhur, in I.A. No. 862 of 1998 in O.S. No. 213 of 1998, which appointed an Advocate Commissioner to inspect the suit property, record physical features and file a plan and report. The underlying suit sought a declaration that the pathway shown as CDEFGHI in the plaint plan (referred to as suit item 2) belonged exclusively to the plaintiff, and sought consequential reliefs including injunctions restraining defendants (including K. Rajamani, the third defendant) from interfering with plaintiff's possession and from carrying out construction in specified parts (for example area GH), and mandatory orders to close doorways on parapet walls (T and G).
While the suit and an interlocutory injunction application were pending, the respondents filed I.A. No. 862/1998 praying for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to inspect the disputed pathway, measure it, note physical features and prepare a plan and report. They alleged that the pathway had been used as a common passage for generations, that the plaintiff had suppressed that fact and had attempted to block the way after filing suit.
The revision petitioner opposed the application, asserting exclusive title to the pathway and stressing that respondents had not yet filed their written statement or produced documents; he contended that an Advocate Commissioner should not be appointed until respondents took a definite stand by filing their counter/ documents. The District Munsif allowed the commission application (without recording detailed reasons) and appointed an Advocate Commissioner. The petitioner filed this civil revision seeking to set aside that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the lower court erred in appointing an Advocate Commissioner without recording reasons supporting that exercise of judicial discretion.
- Whether an Advocate Commissioner can properly be appointed before the defendants file their written statement or before any evidence is recorded.
- Whether, on the specific facts alleged by the respondents (common use of the pathway for generations and attempts by the plaintiff to block it), the appointment of an Advocate Commissioner was justified despite the laconic order below.
Arguments of the Parties
Revision Petitioner's (Plaintiff's) Arguments
- The pathway (suit item 2) belongs exclusively to the revision petitioner; documents supporting exclusive title were filed with the plaint.
- The respondents had not filed any written statement or disclosed documents in support of their claim; therefore the lower court should not have appointed an Advocate Commissioner before respondents set up their defence.
- The lower court did not assign any reasons for appointing the Advocate Commissioner; an order of commission requires reasoned satisfaction and the absence of reasons vitiates the order.
- Reliance was placed on authorities (cited in the petitioner's submissions) said to support the proposition that a commission should not be issued in such circumstances.
Respondents' Arguments (as presented in their application/affidavit)
- The second item of the suit property (the pathway) had been used by the respondents and the revision petitioner as a common pathway for generations, and this fact had been suppressed by the revision petitioner.
- The revision petitioner had allegedly attempted, after filing the suit, to block the common pathway; immediate inspection was necessary to ascertain the true state of affairs.
- Other than the common pathway in question, the defendants had no other way of passage; these factual matters required on-the-spot investigation which only a commissioner could undertake.
- The respondents therefore sought appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to visit the suit property, measure and note physical features, and prepare a plan and report to assist the Court and to prevent possible obliteration of the state of affairs by the petitioner.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| K. Raghunath Rao v. Smt. Tumula Jailaxmi, AIR 1988 Ori. 30 | While normally a commission is for local investigation to appreciate evidence already recorded, departures are possible depending on facts (illustrations given where commission may be issued even before evidence). | Cited to show there is no rigid rule and that, depending on facts and circumstances, a commissioner may be appointed even before evidence is recorded; used to support the view that soliciting a commission can be appropriate here. |
| Gopal Chettiar (deceased) & Ors. v. P.A.A. Sahul Hameed & Anr., 1998 (3) LW 773 | Held objection to appointment of another commissioner where a commissioner had already been appointed and had submitted a report; principle that commission should not be used merely to collect evidence where inappropriate. | Referred to as one of the authorities relied upon by the petitioner; the Court considered its ratio but found the present facts distinguishable and did not treat it as precluding appointment in this case. |
| D.S. Reddy (rep. by power agent D.P.S. Reddy) v. Dr. G.V. Reddy (rep. by power agent M.S. Murthy) — 1999 (I) CTC 172 | An order appointing a commission is a judicial discretionary order and should be supported by reasons so that propriety of the exercise of discretion is visible. | Quoted to acknowledge the general principle that courts should record reasons; Court observed that although the lower court's order lacked express reasons, the material in the record (respondents' affidavit) justified the commission and therefore the laconic order need not be set aside. |
| In Re Moosa Kutty, AIR 1953 Mad. 717 | Order 26, Rule 9 CPC — commission is for elucidating matters local in character and must be made before the case is closed; commission is not for collecting evidence that could be taken in court. | Applied to emphasise that commission is for local elucidation and that timing matters (must be before evidence is closed); supported the view that on-the-spot inquiry was appropriate here. |
| Mahendranath Parida v. Purnanada Parida & Ors., AIR 1988 Ori. 248 | When the court considers a local investigation to be requisite or proper, ordinarily it should not decline to issue a commission. | Cited to reinforce that where local investigation is necessary, courts should ordinarily appoint a commissioner; court found this principle supportive of appointment on the facts before it. |
| John v. Kamarunissa, AIR 1989 Ker. 78 | There is no legal bar to issue of commission before the written statement is filed; waiting for written statement could delay recording of facts of great relevance. | Relied upon to support the proposition that a commissioner may be appointed prior to filing of written statements to secure timely evidence; Court accepted this reasoning as applicable to the present urgency. |
| A. Nagarajan v. A. Madhanakumar, 1996 (I) CTC 229 : 1996 (I) LW 278 | A decision that dissented from John v. Kamarunissa on the issue of appointing a commissioner before written statements/evidence in some circumstances. | Cited by the petitioner in support of opposing view; the Court treated that decision as confined to its facts and not as an absolute bar to early appointment of a commissioner. |
| Ponnusamy v. Salem Vaiyappamalai Jangamar Sangam, 1985 (I) MLJ 380 : AIR 1986 Mad. 33 | Local investigation is often the best way to resolve factual controversies about encroachment and constructions; a party should not be shut out from seeking local investigation. | Used to support the proposition that local inspection by a commissioner may be necessary and appropriate to ascertain on-the-spot facts relevant to the dispute. |
| Appulu v. A. Fatima Zohra & Anr., 96 L.W. 369 : 1982 TLNJ 482 | Only a commissioner inspecting property promptly and recording timely assessment may assist courts to decide correctly; urgency in appointing a commissioner can protect parties' rights. | Relied upon to underline the urgency and the need for prompt on-the-spot inspection to prevent destruction or alteration of material facts; the Court found urgency justified here. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in a stepwise analysis, grounded in both the facts before the lower court and principle drawn from precedent:
- Acknowledge procedural deficiency: The District Munsif's order appointing the Advocate Commissioner was laconic and did not set out detailed reasons. The Court recognised the general principle (from D.S. Reddy) that an order of commission is discretionary and should ideally be supported by reasons so that the propriety of the discretion is visible.
- Examine the material before the lower court: The Court looked beyond the bare order and examined the affidavits and counter-affidavits that were before the lower court. The respondents' affidavit specifically alleged (a) that the pathway had been used as a common pathway for generations, (b) that the plaintiff had suppressed that fact in the plaint and the injunction application, and (c) that the plaintiff had made attempts to block the common pathway after filing suit.
- Assess necessity and urgency: Given these allegations (particularly the claim that the petitioner might obliterate the state of affairs), the Court found there was real urgency and a need for an on-the-spot investigation to record physical features and preserve the position as it existed when the suit was filed. The Court noted that parties sometimes alter physical conditions under the cover of interim orders, so early inspection can be necessary to prevent prejudice.
- Reconcile authority: The Court reviewed authorities both for and against early appointment of a commissioner. It accepted that while reasons are desirable, the absence of an elaborate reasoned order below did not automatically vitiate the appointment where the record contained specific material justifying the commission. The Court also accepted that there is no rigid rule forbidding appointment before written statements or evidence and that the issue depends on facts and circumstances (citing K. Raghunath Rao and other supporting cases).
- Distinguish contrary authorities: The Court distinguished decisions relied upon by the petitioner (for example Gopal Chettiar and the dissenting view in A. Nagarajan) on their facts, concluding those did not constitute a bar to appointment in the present factual matrix.
- Conclude on propriety: On balance, and having regard to the specific allegations before the lower court that a common passage was being blocked and might be obliterated, the Court held that the District Munsif's order appointing an Advocate Commissioner was justified on the materials before it despite the order's lack of elaborated reasons.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The civil revision petition is dismissed. The Court held that the lower court's appointment of an Advocate Commissioner was justified on the material before it and therefore the impugned order would not be set aside despite its laconic form. Consequentially, the related stay petitions (C.M.P. No. 15061/98) were also dismissed.
Practical consequences and implications:
- The appointment of the Advocate Commissioner to inspect the suit property, note physical features and prepare a plan and report remains in force.
- The dismissal means the revision petitioner failed to obtain an order setting aside the commission; the on-the-spot inquiry authorized below can proceed to preserve facts and assist the trial court.
- The Court emphasised that while the order below did not contain detailed reasons, the presence of specific allegations in the respondents' affidavit justified the commission; however, the Court cautioned subordinate courts that they "would do well to support their order with reasons."
- No broader change in law was declared; the opinion applies existing principles (Order 26, Rule 9 CPC and relevant case law) to the facts and clarifies that commissions may, in appropriate facts, be issued before written statements or formal evidence is on record—but that the issue is fact-specific and subordinate courts should ordinarily record reasons for discretionary orders.
End of summary. This summary reflects only information expressly contained in the supplied opinion.
1. This revision has been filed against the order of the learned Principal District Munsif, Srivilluputhur, in I.A No. 862 of 1998 in O.S No. 213 of 1998 appointing an advocate Commissioner to inspect the suit property, note down the physical features and file a report along with a plan.
2. The suit has been for a declaration that the pathway covered by the letter CDEFGHI as shown in the plaint plan belongs to the plaintiff exclusively and consequential injunction restraining defendants 1 and 2 and another K. Rajamani who is the third defendant in the suit, from interfering with petitioner's/plaintiff's possession and enjoyment for a mandatory injunction directing the first respondent herein to close the door way fixed on the parapet wall T for mandatory injunction directing the third defendant in the suit to close the door way kept by him on the parapet wall ‘G’ and for a permanent injunction restraining the second respondent herein from putting up any construction in the area converted by ‘GH’ in the plaint plan and for other reliefs.
3. Pending the suit the revision petitioner applied for an interim injunction and notice has been ordered and the injuction application is pending. The respondents herein took out an application in I.A No. 862 of 1998 for the appointment of an advocate Commissioner to visit the suit item 2, measure the same, note down the physical and other features and file a plan along with a report. The allegations in support of the application for the appointment of an Advocate Commissioner are that the respondents and the revision petitioner had been using the second item of the suit properties as common pathway for generations, that this fact has been suppressed by the revision petitioner and he had filed the suit and an injunction application with false facts, that the revision petitioner had after the filing of the suit attempted to block the common pathway and that for appreciating the correct state of affairs that other than the common pathway in suit item 2 the defendants have no other way for passage and these details had to be brought to the notice of the Court and this could be done only by the appointment of an Advocate Commissioner.
4. This application was opposed by the revision petitioner by contending that the pathway shown as suit item 2 belongs to the revision petitioner exclusively, that he has filed the relevant documents to substantiate this along with the plaint, that the respondents have suppressed these facts and claimed rights in the property which is illegal and improper. The revision petitioner further contented that the respondents had not filed any counter in the application for injunction, that an Advocate Commissioner if at all could be appointed only after the respondents filed their counter and their documents and took up a definite stand.
5. The learned District Munsif after setting out the rival contentions of the parties, allowed the application by appointing an Advocate Commissioner. Aggrieved the present revision petition has been filed and it is contented by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the learned District Munsif has not assigned any reason whatsoever for granting the prayer by appointing an Advocate commissioner. The learned counsel vehemently contented that the lower court seriously erred in appointing an Advocate Commissioner even before the respondents set up their defence and disclosed as to how they were making a claim to the suit second item. It is the further contention of the learned counsel that no Advocate Commissioner could be appointed to find out as to who is in possession of the suit property and for this reason alone the order passed by the lower Court is to be set aside.
6. In support of her contentions the learned counsel relied on the following decisions:
(1) K. Raghunath Rao v. Smt. Tumula Jailaxmi, AIR 1988 Ori 30; (2) Gopal Chettiar (deceased) and 3 others v. P.A.A Sahul Hameedandanother, (3) LW 773; (3) D.S Reddy rep by his power Agent D.P.S Reddy v. Dr. G. V. Reddy-rep by his power Agent M.S Murthy and another, (1) CTC 172 and (4) A. Nagarajan v. A. Madhanakumar, 1996 (I) CTC 229 1996 (1)LW 278.
7. The respondent are unrepresented. Though they have been served they have chosen not to contest the civil revision.
8. The lower court no doubt, has not given reasons for allowing the application for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner. After extracting the case of the parties in their respective affidavit and counter affidavit the learned District Munsif has straightway appointed an Advocate Commissioner.
9. In D.S Reddy Etc., 1999 (I) CTC 172 Govindarajan, J has held that an order appointing a commission is a judicial discretionary order and should be supported by reasons so that the propriety of exercise of discretion becomes visible. In the case before the learned judge the plaintiff filed the application before the lower court for opening a locker and taking inventory or alternatively for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to break open the locker and take inventory. There was no reason given in the affidavit in support of the application by the plaintiff in that case as to why an inventory had to be taken except saying that such inventory was necessary to decide about the future course of action to be taken. The learned Judge in the circumstances of that case held that there were no materials disclosed and the order of the lower court also was bereft of any reason for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner. I do not for a moment say that the lower court need not give reasons in support of its conclusion.
10. In the instant case, as already noticed, the lower court after merely paraphrasing the earlier contentions directed the appointment of an Advocate Commissioner. In my view, this is a case where one has to travel beyond the order of lower court to find out whether the ultimate decision by the lower court to appoint an Advocate Commissioner can be justified. The respondents have clearly stated in their affidavit in support of the application for the appointment of an Advocate Commissioner that the revision petitioner themselves have been using the suit second item as common pathway for generations, that this has been suppressed by the revision petitioner/plaintiff and he had filed the suit and the injunction application with false details and that after filing of the suit he was making attempt to block the common pathway. Having regard to this specific stand taken by the respondents in my view, the lower court was justified in appointing an Advocate Commissioner to visit the suit property, note down the physical and other features and file a report along with a plan. Merely because the learned District Munsif has not given elaborate reasons for ordering the application, the order need not be set aside and it will be inequitable. The apprehension entertained by the respondents may be justified and unless the commissioner visited the property and noted down the physical and other features and filed a report along with a plan, the petitioner might obliterate the state of affairs obtaining at the time of the filing of the suit. It is not an uncommon occurrence that under the cloak of interim orders parties attempt to create the state of affairs matching their case.
11. Let me now refer to the other decisions relied on by the learned counsel for the revision petitioner.
12. In K. Raghunath Rao v. Smt. Tumula Jailaxmi, AIR 1988 Ori. 30 a learned judge of the Orissa High Court interfered with the order of the lower Court appointing an Advocate Commissioner on the ground that the lower court had not recorded the satisfaction supported by reasons. In the very same case, it is stated that,
“though the normal rule is for the appointment of an Advocate Commissioner for local investigation to appreciate the evidence already recorded, there may be departures from the normal rule for issue of a commission also. An illustration could be where evidence is necessary to note the depth of water in a particular season, a commissioner can be deputed even though evidence has not been recorded. Another illustration is where it is to be found as to on which plot the disputed land lies, the commissioner can be appointed.”
It is further stated in that decision that there can be no hard and fast rule in this regard and issue of Commission for local investigation would depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case.
13. I have already stated as to why having regard to the facts and circumstances of this case the order appointing an Advocate Commissioner by the lower court is justified.
14. The next decision relied on by the learned counsel is Gopal Chettiar (deceased) and 3 others v. P.A.A Sahul Hameed and another, 1998 (3) LW 773. In that case an application for inspection of the building and report by Commissioner about alleged changes or waste committed was filed before the Appellate Authority. Objection was taken that a Commissioner was already appointed by the Rent controller and the Commissioner had submitted his report and there were no objection filed his report. It was held by Abdul Wahab, J (as the learned judge then was) that there can be no appointment of Commissioner for collecting evidence or gathering materials.
15. It has been held in a number of decisions and in particular in In Re Moosa Kutty, AIR 1953 Mad. 717, that,
“the object of a commission under this rule, viz. Order 26, Rule 9 CPC is not to collect evidence which could be taken in Court but obtain for elucidating matters which are local in character and it is in the discretion of the court to issue it or not. The object is for elucidating any matter in dispute by local investigation at the spot.”
16. In Mahendranath Parida v. Purnanada Parida and others, AIR 1988 Ori. 248, it has been held that,
“When the Court considers a local investigation to be requisite or/and proper ordinarily it should not decline to issue a Commission.”
17. This is a clear case where it is necessary to obtain evidence which from its peculiar nature can only be had on the spot. The order of the lower Court does not suffer from any illegality or irregularity nor has it been passed in error of jurisdiction though supportive reasons for the conclusion could have been given by the lower court.
18. The matter does not end here. Yet another objection has been raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the respondents have not filed their written statement with supporting documents and had not made their case known and in this circumstances the lower court not to have granted the prayer.
19. In John v. Kamarunissa, AIR 1989 Ker. 78, it has been held that,
“If the court is required to wait till the written statement is filed, then the court will be deprived of a precious opportunity of bringing on record facts of great relevance for just and proper decision of the dispute. Moreover, for filing written statement the defendant will have to go through the plaint as well as the plaintiff's documents. All that it will take time. In the meantime, if certain facts are necessary to be ascertained there can be no legal bar to the issue of commission.”
No doubt, a learned single judge of this court has dissented from the view expressed in the Kerala decision and this decision A. Nagarajan v. Madhankkumar, 1996 (I) CTC 229: 1996 (I) LW 278 has been relied on by the learned counsel for the revision petitioner.
20. In Ponnusamy v. Salem Vaiyappamalai Jangamar Sangam, 1985 (I) MLJ 380: AIR 1986 Mad 33, the appointment of an Advocate Commissioner was sought for by the defendant in a suit for injunction to restrain him from digging foundation in the plaintiff's land. The defendant contended that the land belonged to him. The Court refused to issue Commission. Nainar Sundaram, J. (as the learned Judge then was) interfered in revision and the reasoning of the learned judge was as follows:
“A controversy, as we would see from the pleadings, has arisen as to whether the constructions put up by the third defendant are within his land or whether they have encroached into the lands of the plaintiff. A local investigation is the best way to find out the position and the party, viz. the third defendant coveting the evidence to place before the court through local investigation by the Commissioner cannot be shut out of that right”.
21. In Appulu v. A. Fatima Zohra and another, 96 L.W 369: 1982 TLNJ 482, it has been held by this court that,
“there may be very many circumstances in which only a commissioner inspecting the property promptly and recording timely assessment of what obtains relating to the building, could alone assist courts to decide correctly. If such prompt actions are not taken, it may destroy the valuable right of the parties. It may so happen, when a landlord high-handedly starts pulling down a portion of the main building, the tenant would be greatly interested in securing a commissioner appointed forthwith. If the right of the tenant to have access to staircase is constructed, he is most interested in seeking appointment of the commissioner and secure immediate relief for restoring amenities, which is assured to him under the Act…”
22. The urgency in the present case cannot be gain-said. The apprehension of the respondents justified the appointment of an Advocate Commissioner even before their filing the written statement and even before any evidence had come on record. The respondents have also indicated their specific stand in the affidavit in support of the application. It cannot therefore be contented by the revision petitioner that the respondents have not put forward their case. The decision in A. Nagarajan v. A. Madhanakumar, 1996 (I) CTC 229: 1996 (I) LW 278 has indeed dissented from the view expressed in John v. Kamarunnissa, AIR 1989 Ker 78 of the Kerala High Court. In my view, it cannot be said that there cannot be an Advocate Commissioner appointed either before the written statement is filed or before any evidence is adduced.
23. In fact, in In Re Moosa Kutty, AIR 1953 Mad. 717 it has been held that an application under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure must b made before the case is closed and a commission cannot be issued after the evidence is closed. In the case before the learned Judge Nagarajan v. Madhankumar, 1996 (I) CTC 229: 1996 (I) LW 278 the question arose whether a commissioner could be appointed after the closure on his side of evidence by party for the purpose of clarification, explanation and proof of the matter in issue or a fact which required elucidation. We have already noticed that there could be circumstances in which a Commission may be issued even before the evidence is recorded. The learned Single Judge was not deciding and it was also unnecessary to decide that question in that case. The decision has to be confined to the facts of that case.
24. In view of the discussion above, I hold that an exception can be taken to the order though laconic passed by the lower court. The civil revision petition fails and the same is dismissed. Consequently, the stay petitions C.M.P No. 15061/98 is also dismissed. Subordinate Courts would do well to support their order with reasons.
Alert