- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
R. Ramamurthy And Others v. State .
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners are accused in Crime No. 3/90, registered for offences under Sections 380 and 406 read with Section 120 (B) of the Indian Penal Code. The case originated from a complaint of theft given on 12-2-90 by one Vairaprakasam to the Inspector General of Police (Crime), Madras. Following this, a case was registered on 15-2-90 by the Inspector of Police, CB, CID, Madurai. After investigation, on 16-10-92, the police submitted a report to the Judicial Magistrate stating the case was ‘undetected’. The Chief Judicial Magistrate recorded the case as “undetected” on 8-1-93. Subsequently, on 21-4-95, the police filed a memorandum requesting permission to reopen the case for further investigation based on newly received reliable information. The Magistrate granted this request on the same day. The petitioners challenged the legality of this reopening order by filing a revision petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a Magistrate can permit the police to reopen a case for further investigation after having previously passed a final order accepting the police report as “recorded and undetected”?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- Once the Magistrate accepted the police report as “recorded as undetected” on 8-1-93, that order became final and judicial in nature.
- The Magistrate became functus officio and therefore had no jurisdiction to entertain any further order reopening the case.
- The memorandum dated 21-4-95 seeking reopening of the case for further investigation was not maintainable.
- Relied on the decision in Ramasubba, K. v. State (1987 Mad LW (Crl) 79 : 1988 Cri LJ 214) to support the finality of the Magistrate’s order.
Respondent's Arguments
- Cited the Supreme Court decision in Ram Lal Narang v. State (Delhi Admn.) (1979) 2 SCC 322, AIR 1979 SC 1791, which permits police to seek Magistrate’s permission for further investigation under Section 173(8) Cr. P.C.
- Argued that Section 173(8) Cr. P.C. allows reopening of investigation even after a final report is submitted and accepted by the Magistrate.
- Emphasized that the police acted with due regard to the Court by formally seeking permission to reopen the case upon receiving fresh information.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ramasubba, K. v. State (1987 Mad LW (Crl) 79 : 1988 Cri LJ 214) | Finality of Magistrate’s order accepting police report as “undetected” and prohibition on reopening by same Magistrate. | Rejected by the Court as not good law in light of Supreme Court rulings permitting reopening under Section 173(8) Cr. P.C. |
| Ram Lal Narang v. State (Delhi Admn.) (1979) 2 SCC 322, AIR 1979 SC 1791 | Interpretation of Section 173(8) Cr. P.C. permitting police to seek Magistrate’s permission for further investigation after submission of final report. | Accepted and relied upon by the Court to uphold Magistrate’s power to permit reopening of investigation. |
| State of Rajasthan v. Aruna Devi, 1995 SCC (Cri) 1 | Police can conduct further investigation and Magistrate can take cognizance after further report even if earlier report was accepted as final. | Formed the principal basis for the Court’s decision allowing reopening of the case. |
| State of Maharashtra v. Sharadchandra Vinayak Dongre, 1995 SCC (Cri) 16 | Both referred report and charge sheet are reports under Section 173(2) Cr. P.C., allowing further investigation and reports. | Supported the view that further investigation after initial report is legally permissible. |
| Namasivayam v. Sathar Sayeed, 1981 Mad LW (Crl) 151 | Earlier ruling on limitations of Section 173(8) Cr. P.C. applicability. | Court held this earlier law to be incorrect in light of Supreme Court precedents. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the submissions of both parties and analyzed the relevant statutory provisions, particularly Section 173(8) of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr. P.C.), which permits further investigation after submission of a police report under Section 173(2). The Court referred extensively to Supreme Court precedents, especially State of Rajasthan v. Aruna Devi, which clarified that the Magistrate retains jurisdiction to take cognizance after a further investigation report, even if an earlier report was accepted as final. The Court rejected the petitioners’ reliance on the Madras High Court decision in Ramasubba, K. v. State, finding it inconsistent with Supreme Court rulings.
The Court noted that the police had followed proper procedure by seeking formal permission from the Magistrate to reopen the investigation upon receiving fresh and reliable information. The Court emphasized that the power of the police to conduct further investigation under Section 173(8) Cr. P.C. cannot be curtailed by interpreting the Magistrate’s earlier order as absolutely final. The Court further observed that the initial police report itself stated that the case could be reopened if useful information emerged, reinforcing the permissibility of reopening the investigation.
Holding and Implications
The revision petition challenging the Magistrate’s order permitting the reopening of the case is dismissed.
The direct effect of the decision is to uphold the Magistrate’s power to allow further investigation under Section 173(8) Cr. P.C., even after an earlier police report was accepted as final. No new precedent is set beyond reaffirming existing Supreme Court authority that permits reopening investigations upon receipt of fresh information. The petitioners’ challenge to the Magistrate’s jurisdiction was found to lack merit, and the police were held to have acted within legal bounds by seeking and obtaining permission for further investigation.
1. Could the Magistrate permit the police to reopen the case for further investigation, once the said Magistrate passed an order earlier on the report filed by the police as “recorded and undetected” ? This is the question posed before this Court for consideration.
2. The petitioners are the accused in Crime No. 3/90 registered for the offences under Sections 380 and 406 read with Section 120 (B) I.P.C One Vairaprakasam, the petitioner in Crl. M.P No. 3523/96 requesting for impleading himself as one of the parties, gave a complaint of theft on 12-2-90 to the Inspector General of Police (Crime), Madras. On his direction, the Inspector of Police, CB, CID, Madurai registered a case on 15-2-90 against the petitioners in the above crime. After investigation, on 16-10-92, the Inspector of Police filed a report before the learned Judicial Magistrate, Virudhunagar stating that the case was treated as ‘undetected’. On 8-1-93, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Srivilliputhur passed an order as “Recorded as undetected”. Again on 21-4-95, the Inspector of Police filed a Memorandum requesting for an order to reopen the case for further investigation as some reliable information had been received. On this Memorandum, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Srivilliputhur passed an order as “Yes. Reopened” on 21-4-95. As against this order, the petitioners preferred this revision questioning the legality of the same.
3. Mr. Packiaraj, the learned counsel for the petitioners would submit that it is well settled that once the learned Magistrate has accepted the report of the Police Officer by the order dated 8-1-93 and endorsed as “Recorded as undetected”, the said order is a final judicial order and the learned Magistrate cannot thereafter pass any further order in relation to Crime No. 3/90, unless the final order passed earlier by the Magistrate has been set aside by the appellate Court. To put differently, the submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioners is that the memorandum dated 21-4-95 seeking the permission for reopening the case for further investigation is not maintainable, as the Magistrate has no jurisdiction to entertain the same, since he already became functus officio after accepting the final report as early as in January, 1993.
4. On this aspect, Mr. Sriramulu, the learned senior counsel appearing for the first informant, who is the petitioner in the impleading petition, as well as the learned Government Advocate appearing for. the investigating officer is heard at length.
5. The first informant as well as the accused are close relatives. In fact, A-1 is the younger brother of the first informant A-4 is the younger sister, A-3 is the husband of A-4, and A-2 is the daughter of A-3. It is also seen from records that there are already civil litigations including partition suit pending between the parties. In this situation, the complaint was given by the first informant to the Inspector General of Police on 12-2-90, who in turn asked the Inspector of Police, CB CID to conduct the investigation. Consequently, on 15-2-90, a case was registered in Crime No. 3/90 for the offences referred to above. During the course of investigation, the first petitioner Ramamurthy (A-1) was arrested and subjected to police custody and even then nothing was recovered. In fact, during police custody, he had heart attack and even before the expiry of the police custody, he was produced before the Court and then, on the direction of the Court, he was sent to hospital. The Inspector of Police, CB CID after investigation on 16-10-92, filed a report stating that despite all efforts taken to detect this case, no clue was available and as such, this case was to be treated as ‘undetected’. In the said report, he would further state that if any useful information is received, the case would be reopened and proper action would be taken. On this report, treating the case as ‘undetectable’, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Srivilliputhur passed an order as “recorded as undetected” on 8-1-93.
6. However, it is noticed on 12-9-94, on the orders of the Inspector of General of Police, as some more reliable information was received, the Inspector of Police on 21-4-95 filed a petitioner to permit him to reopen the case for further investigation. On this petition, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate passed an order permitting reopening of the case for further investigation on the ground that some reliable information was subsequently received by the police.
7. Mr. Packiaraj, the learned counsel for the petitioner, placing reliance on the decision in Ramasubba, K. v. State (1987 Mad LW (Crl) 79 : (1988 Cri LJ 214), would submit that the” judicial order passed earlier on 8-1-93 accepting the final report of the police officer cannot be set aside by the same Magistrate by passing another order permitting the police to reopen the case for further investigation.
8. In reply to his submission, Mr. Sriramulu, the learned senior counsel, citing the decision in Ram Lal Narang v. State (Delhi Admn.) (1979) 2 SCC 322 : AIR 1979 SC 1791 : (1979 Cri LJ 1346) would submit that the Apex Court, while interpreting Section 173 (8) Cr. P.C would permit such application by the police requesting the Magistrate for obtaining permission for further investigation.
9. I have considered the submissions made by the counsel for the rival parties.
10. In the light of the rulings of the Apex Court on this aspect, the submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioners/accused cannot be accepted. This aspect has been covered by the Supreme Court decision in State of Rajasthan v. Aruna Devi, 1995 SCC (Cri) 1. This is a case where the police after investigation filed the report on 18-7-81 stating that the complaint was false and the said report was accepted by the learned Magistrate on 23-9-81. However, later on the direction of the Superintendent of Police, further investigation was conducted and the charge sheet was filed against the accused. The learned Magistrate took cognizance on this charge sheet. The said cognizance was quashed by the High Court. While setting aside the judgment of the High Court holding that it was wrong, the Apex Court would observe as follows:
“A perusal of the impugned judgment of the High Court shows that it took the view that the Magistrate had no jurisdiction to take cognizance after the final report submitted by police had been once accepted. Shri Gupta, appearing for the appellant, contends that this view is erroneous in law inasmuch as Section 173 (8) of the Code permits further investigation in respect of an offence after a report under sub-section (2) has been submitted. Sub-section (8) also visualises forwarding of another report to the Magistrate. Further investigation had thus legal sanction and if after such further investigation a report is submitted that an offence was committed, it would be open to the Magistrate to take cognizance of the same on his being satisfied in this regard.”
11. In view of the above observation, there is no difficulty in coming to the conclusion that even though the report was filed under Section 173(2) Cr. P.C referring the matter, Section 173 (8) Cr. P.C would permit the police for further investigation and to send another report to the Magistrate, contrary to the earlier report.
12. In view of this decision, the law laid down in 1987 Mad LW (Crl) 79 : (1998 Cri LJ 214) (Supra) following 1981 Mad LW (Crl) 151 (Namasivayam v. Sathar Sayeed) cannot be held to be a good law.
13. Even assuming that the order passed by the Magistrate recording as a ‘mistake of fact’, ‘mistake of law’, or ‘undetected’ is a judicial order, the power of the police officer conferred under Section 173 (8) Cr. P.C cannot be curtailed, as it otherwise would defect the very purpose of re-investigation.
14. In the decision reported in 1987 Mad LW (Crl) 79 : (1988) Cri LJ 214) (supra), it has been held that Section 173 (8) Cr. P.C would be applicable only in the case where charge sheet was already filed under Section 173(2) Cr. P.C but not to the case where the referred report was filed and accepted. This position is clearly held to be wrong as per the Apex Court decision in State of Maharashtra v. Sharadchandra Vinayak Dongre (1995 SCC (Cri) 16 : ((1995) 1 SCC 42 : AIR 1995 SC 231), in which it has been held that both the referred report as well as the charge sheet are to be considered as report under Section 173 (2) Cr. P.C
15. However, as clearly observed by the Apex Court in (1979) 2 SCC 322 : AIR 1979 SC 1791 : (1979 Cri LJ 1346) (supra) that though the police is empowered to make further investigation even after sending the referred report, the police should inform the Court and seek formal permission to make further investigation, when fresh fact comes to light. The relevant observation is as follows:
“we think that in the interest of the independence of the magistracy and the judiciary, in the interests of the purity of the administration of criminal justice and in the interests of the comity of the various agencies and institutions entrusted with different stages of such administration, it would ordinarily be desirable that the police should inform the Court and seek formal permission to make further investigation when fresh facts come to light…. Where the police desired to make a further investigation, the police could express their regard and respect for the Court by seeking its formal permission to make further investigation.”
This is what exactly done in this case by way of showing regard and respect to the Court. The respondent police approached the Court and sought for permission and the same has been granted by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate after satisfying himself that fresh information has come to light.
16. It is also relevant to note in this case that even when the report was filed earlier as undetected’, it was mentioned in the report that if fresh information comes to light, the further investigation would be done. Therefore, it cannot be contended that once it is recorded as ‘undetected’, neither the Magistrate would have power to permit for further investigation nor the police would have power to reopen the case to make further investigation, especially, when fresh information has been received by the police to detect the offence alleged.
17. In the result, the Revision, which has no merit, is liable to be dismissed and accordingly, the same is dismissed. In view of what is stated above, Crl. M.P No. 4751/95 stands dismissed and no order is necessary in Crl. M.P 3525/96.
18. Revision dismissed.
Alert