Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

R. Raju v. The Government Of Ta...

Madras High Court
Jul 27, 1998
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the owner of Anand Cottage, Bearsdenola Road (Kodaikanal, Madurai District), which comprises a main bungalow and six flats (RR flats). The electricity connections relevant to the dispute are identified as Consumer Service Nos. W-163 and W-166 (also referred to as S.C. No. 163 and S.C. No. 166 in the opinion) and a separate connection for the bungalow and other flats (S.C. No. 95 and S.C. No. 94 references appear in the pleadings).

Flats covered by S.C. No. 166 (flats 1–3) were leased to Neyveli Lignite Corporation from April 1987 for residential use by its officers on season/visit. Flats under S.C. No. 163 (flats 4–6) were partly leased to Mr. Satyanathan (flat 4) and flats 5 and 6 were leased to M/s. Bharat Petroleum Corporation for residential occupation of their staff; occupation dates are pleaded in the affidavit.

The petitioner alleged that the premises (including the bungalow and the flats) were used for bona fide residential purposes only and that no mess, canteen or office was run by the tenants. The petitioner sought revision of tariff classification from a commercial tariff (Tariff VIII) to Domestic Tariff (Tariff I) by application dated 26.5.1986; that application was returned by a Junior Engineer but later the higher authorities changed the tariff to Domestic with effect from 21.5.1988.

In September 1988 the petitioner received notices accusing misuse of tariff for Service Connections W-163 and W-166 and demanding penalty/compensation: Rs. 2 per unit for 4,858 units for W-166 and Rs. 4,566 for 2,253 units for W-163 (covering March 1987–April 1988). The respondents inspected the premises on 27.4.1988 (by Anti Power Theft Squad) and concluded the premises were not used for bona fide domestic activity but as rest/guest houses for visiting employees; they levied compensation charges (stated as Rs. 9,716 total) computed for a 12-month period prior to inspection, demanded a portion be paid and disconnected service when payment was not made (disconnection on 15.10.1988).

The petitioner filed the present Writ Petition seeking, inter alia, a writ of mandamus to restrain assessment and collection under Tariff VIII, to direct charges under Domestic Tariff I, to order refund/adjustment of excess collections, and to restore the electricity charges and stay any commercial charging until disposal.

The court heard rival counsel and proceeded to decide whether the respondents were entitled to charge under Tariff VIII for the relevant service connections.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents are entitled to assess and collect electricity consumption charges under Tariff VIII (Commercial) for Consumer Service Nos. W-163 and W-166 when those premises were let out to Neyveli Lignite Corporation and Bharat Petroleum Corporation and allegedly used for residential purposes by their staff.
  2. Whether the respondents' actions in changing the tariff classification and levying compensation/penalty were in violation of the principles of natural justice (specifically for lack of prior notice) and/or arbitrary, unreasonable, or violative of the provisions of the Electricity Act, as contended by the petitioner.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The respondents illegally levied electricity charges for Service Nos. W-163 and W-166 under Tariff VIII (Commercial) instead of Tariff I (Domestic).
  • The respondents acted contrary to the principles of natural justice by not issuing any prior notice before changing the tariff.
  • The respondents' action was arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of provisions of the Electricity Act.
  • The premises (including bungalow and flats) were used exclusively for residential purposes; no mess, canteen or office activities were conducted by the tenants (Neyveli Lignite Corporation and Bharat Petroleum Corporation).

Respondents' Arguments

  • The premises were leased to Neyveli Lignite Corporation and Bharat Petroleum Corporation and used as guest houses/rest houses for visiting staff, not for bona fide domestic residence.
  • An inspection (by Anti Power Theft Squad) on 27.4.1988 found the services were not used for bona fide domestic activities; therefore, as per the Board's rules and the applicable tariffs, compensation/penalty charges for misuse were correctly levied covering the 12 months prior to inspection.
  • The action of changing the tariff to Tariff VIII and levying compensation was in accordance with the tariff provisions and terms and conditions of supply; hence the petition should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court set out the core factual dispute as to classification of use: whether the premises were being used for bona fide domestic residence (Tariff I) or as rest/guest houses for visiting employees of the two undertakings (which the respondents said justified Tariff VIII). The reasoning followed these principal steps drawn from the opinion:

  1. The court reviewed the parties' pleadings, the inspection report of 27.4.1988 (by the Anti Power Theft Squad) and the correspondence from the Superintending Engineer, which recorded that the premises were used as rest houses/guest houses for employees of Neyveli Lignite Corporation and Bharat Petroleum Corporation.
  2. The court examined the tariff revision document (letter No. 728.Administration.Br./Tariff-I (2)/86-1 dated 24.12.1986) effective from 1.1.1987, noting how Low Tension Tariff-I is defined (domestic purposes) and that Tariff VIII is described as covering categories not otherwise covered under Tariffs I–VII.
  3. The court observed that the tariff schedule did not specifically include "Rest House" or "Guest House" in any of the enumerated categories. Because no specific reference to guest or rest houses existed in the tariff clauses, the court concluded the respondents were not justified in claiming Tariff VIII on that basis alone.
  4. The court analyzed the meaning of the words "guest" and "residence" using dictionary definitions cited in the opinion: "guest" (Oxford Advanced Dictionary) as persons staying or paying a visit, and "residence" (Dictionary of Law by L.B. Curzon and Oxford) as a place where a person abides or has his home. Using these meanings, the court found that premises used as rest/guest houses for visiting officers fall within residential use rather than a distinct commercial activity requiring Tariff VIII treatment.
  5. The court also relied on the undisputed factual findings (as presented in the respondents' own inspection report) that the only activity found at the premises was letting to the two government undertakings, and there was no claim by the respondents that the tenants ran messes, canteens or offices. That factual situation reinforced the conclusion that the use was residential in nature.
  6. On the procedural fairness argument (no detailed separate analysis recorded), the court's core focus was on tariff classification and whether Tariff VIII applied; having found no specific tariff categorization encompassing rest/guest house in the tariff schedule, the court rejected the respondents' contention that Tariff VIII was applicable.
  7. Consequently, the court held that the petitioner's claim for domestic tariff treatment was justified and that reliefs prayed in items 1 and 2 of the petition should be granted.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The court ordered that the respondents are restrained from assessing and collecting electricity consumption charges for Consumer Service Nos. W-163 and W-166 under Tariff VIII and that the respondents are entitled to collect charges under Tariff I (Domestic) in respect of those service connections. The court also directed refund of excess amounts collected.

Specific orders made by the court (as stated in the opinion):

  1. The respondents are restrained from assessing and collecting from the petitioner the electricity consumption charges in respect of Consumer Service Nos. W-163 and W-166, Kodaikanal, Madurai District, under Tariff No. VIII.
  2. The respondents are entitled to collect the same under Tariff-I in respect of the said service connections.
  3. The respondents are directed to refund the excess amount collected by them from the petitioner either by way of penalty or as compensation; the court also directed that if there is any excess payment claimed and paid for Service No. 95, the same may be refunded to the petitioner.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The petitioner's service connections W-163 and W-166 must be charged under Domestic Tariff I rather than Tariff VIII; any excess amounts collected as compensation/penalty are to be refunded or adjusted as directed.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion focuses on tariff interpretation in the particular factual matrix and does not state or purport to establish a broad new legal precedent beyond the immediate corrective orders for the parties. No case law precedent was cited or relied upon in the opinion.

This summary is confined strictly to the facts, arguments, reasoning and orders contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

The prayer in the Writ Petition is as follows:—

To issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other writ or order against the respondents (1) by ordering them to forbear from assessing and collecting from the petitioner electricity consumption charges in respect of consumer service No. W-163 and W-166 Kodaikanal, Madurai District under Tariff-VIII intended for commercial tariff but instead charge the said Consumer Service No. W-163 and W-166 Kodaikanal, Madurai District under Domestic Tariff of (I) only and (2) to refund the excess amount collected by the respondents from the petitioner either by way of penalty or as compensation so far amounting to more than Rs. 5,000/- or adjust the same towards future bills, (3) restore the electricity consumption charges to consumer service No. W-166 Kodaikanal, Madurai District immediately and (4) to direct the second respondent to charge electricity consumption charges for service connection Nos. W-163 and W-166, Kodaikanal, Madurai District under Domestic tariff of Tariff I until the disposal of the above Writ Petition.

2. The case of the petitioner as seen from the affidavit is briefly stated hereunder. According to him he is the owner of Anand Cottage, Bearsnola Road, Kodaikanal, Madurai District. There are six flats known as RR flats in the Anand Cottage. The main bungalow is used by him for residential purposes and the electricity connection is under S.C No. 95 and a separate connection for the first floor bearing service connection No. 94 for the flats which were let out. S.C No. 166 is connected to flats 1 to 3 which are leased out by him to Neyveli Lignite Corporation from April 1987 for residential use of their officers during seasons. Similarly S.C No. 163 represents three flats i.e Flat Nos. 4, 5 and 6 out of which 4 was leased out to one Mr. Satyanathan and family from 12.4.1987 to 11.3.1988 Flat Nos. 5 and 6 are leased out to M/s. Bharath Petroleum Corporation for the residential occupation of their staff from 1.6.1987 and the flats were occupied by them only from 1.4.1988 It is stated that, even for the residential occupation of the Bungalow, the second respondent has been charging under Tariff IV applicable to industries and the said Tariff was levied from the date of the service connection. Thereafter the petitioner approached the department to revise the tariff to domestic by application dated 26.5.1986, the same was returned by Junior Engineer after 15 months noting that since there are two connections in one building, the revision is not possible. However, the matter was set right by the higher authorities and changed the same to domestic Tariff with effect from 21.5.1988 Suddenly in September 1988, he received a notice for Service Connection No. W-166 and W-163 accusing him of misuse of Tariff and demanding a sum of Rs. 2/- per unit as penalty for 4,858 units covering a period from March 1987 to April 1988 in respect of W-166 and another sum of Rs. 4,566/- for consuming 2,253 units from March 1987 to April 1988 for Service Connection No. W-163. The petitioner made several representations to the respondents. It is also stated that the services mentioned have to be treated only as domestic and domestic Tariff I alone should be charged in view of the entire premises being used only for residential purposes. His further submission was that there is no mess, canteen or any office is run by the said tenants viz., Neyveli Lignite Corporation and Bharath Petroleum Corporation. In such circumstances, the petitioner has approached this Court by way of the present Writ Petition.

3. On behalf of the second respondent, the Superintending Engineer, Anna Electricity Distribution Circle has filed a counter affidavit wherein it is stated that all the three flats viz., 1, 2 and 3 in Service Connection No. 166 are used as guest houses by the staff of the Bharath Petroleum Corporation who are coming on visit to Kodaikanal and not for bonafide domestic use. Likewise flat Nos. 5 and 6 are used by the staff of the Neyveli Lignite Corporation who visit Kodaikanal on tour and not for bonafide dwelling purposes. He has further stated that S.C No. 166, Kodaikanal was inspected by Assistant Executive Engineer, Anti Power Theft Squad, Madurai on 27.4.1988 and found that the above service was not used for bonafide domestic activities. As such, as per the Rules of the Board, compensation charges were levied as misuse of Tariff from March 1987 to April 1988. The compensation worked out to Rs. 9,716/-. Accordingly, the consumer was asked to pay 50% on that assessment inspection charges + Rs. 50/- within 15 days. Since the amount was not paid, the service connection was disconnected on 15.10.1988 He has further stated that as per the terms and conditions of supply of the Board, compensation charges is to be levied for a period of 12 months prior to the date of Inspection. He has also stated that the action was taken in accordance with the said terms and conditions of Supply. There is no irregularity or illegality in the action taken by the second respondent and accordingly he prayed for dismissal of the Writ Petition.

4. In the light of the above pleadings, I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner as well as the respondents.

5. Mr. C. Lakshminarain, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has raised the following contentions:—

i) The action of the respondents in levying electricity charges to the petitioner's Service No. W-163 and W-166 at Kodaikanal, Madurai District under Tariff VIII (Commercial) instead of Tariff-I (Domestic) is illegal.

ii) The action of the respondents is against the Principles of Natural Justice since they have not issued any notice prior to changing the Tariff from I to VIII.

iii) The action of the respondents is not only arbitrary, unreasonable but also violative of the provisions of the Electricity Act.

6. On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents, after taking me through various averments made in the counter affidavit as well as the relevant Tariff, has contended that inasmuch as the premises in question were leased out to Neyveli Lignite Corporation and Bharath Petroleum Corporation and taking note of the activities, the action of the respondents changing the Tariff from I to VIII is in accordance with the Tariff applicable at the relevant point of time. He also submitted that inasmuch as the action was taken in accordance with the provisions, the petition is liable to be dismissed.

7. I have carefully considered the rival submissions.

8. The point to be decided in this Writ Petition is whether the respondents are entitled to claim electricity consumption charges under Tariff VIII when tile premises in question were used by the undertakings of the Government of India viz., the Neyveli Lignite Corporation and Bharath Petroleum Corporation. According to the petitioner, the flats/premises in question were leased out to Neyveli Lignite Corporation as well as the Bharath Petroleum Corporation for occupation of their staff as and when they visit Kodaikanal. It is also the definite case of the petitioner that those premises/fiats were used only for residential purposes. It is also specifically stated that there is no mess, canteen or any office is run by the said tenants viz., Neyveli Lignite Corporation and Bharath Petroleum Corporation. It is seen from the letter from the Superintending Engineer, Anna Electricity Distribution Circle, Dindigul addressed to the petitioner, it is mentioned “the Service No. 163 W 166 W. Kodaikanal standing in your name were inspected by Anti Power Theft Squad, Madurai on 27.4.1988 During inspection, it was found that there was no bonafide activity in the above premises and they were used as Rest House for the employees of the Neyveli Lignite Corporation and Bharath Petroleum Corporation on tour. As such the appropriate Tariff applicable is only Tariff VIII and therefore the necessary compensation charges bad to be levied…..”‘The above factual position supports the case of the petitioner that the said premises were let out only to the Neyveli Lignite Corporation and Bharath Petroleum Corporation for their use whenever they come to Kodaikanal. In other words, even after inspection, the only activity as found by themselves was letting out to the two Government of India Undertakings. It is not the case of the respondents that other domestic activities are being engaged in the said premises. It is also not their case that any mess, canteen or any office is being run by the said tenants.

9. In this regard, it is useful to mention the relevant fault applicable to the petitioner's premises. It is clear from the letter No. 728.Administration. Br./Tariff-I (2)/86-1 dated 24.12.1986 The said letter relates to revision of Tariff effective from 1.1.1987 Part B deals with Low Tension Supply. Low Tension Tariff-I refers to Domestic purposes, for lights and fans including radios and power loads 55 paise per KWH. Minimum monthly current consumption charges-Rs. 4 per service. Tariff II to VII refers to various other categories. By pointing out Low Tension Tariff VIII, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent contended that in the light of the activities being carried out in the premises in question they are entitled to charge under Tariff VIII. Tariff VIII speaks about all categories of consumers not covered under Low Tension Tariff I, II, III, IV, V, VI and VII. In the light of the submission made by the learned counsel for the respondents, I have carefully perused the various clauses in the letter referred to above. Admittedly “Rest House or Guest House” has not been included in any one of the Tariff mentioned in that letter. Taking note of the fact that there is no such specific reference in any one of the clauses, as contended, the respondents are not justified in claiming charges under Tariff VIII.

10. I have already referred to the categorical statement that the flats in question were being used by the Neyveli Lignite Corporation and Bharath Petroleum Corporation for residential purposes. I have also referred to the report of the Superintending Engineer after inspection of the premises in question. In the light of the factual position stated above and in the absence of any specific reference in the revision of Tariff effective from 1.1.1987 I am unable to accept the arguments of the learned counsel for the resppondents.

11. In this regard, it is relevant to mention the word “Guest” is explained in Oxford Advanced Dictionary as persons staying or paying a visit to another's house or being entertained at a meal. In Dictionary of Law by L.B Curzon, the word “Residence” is explained, as a place where a person abides viz., where he has his home. Likewise in the Oxford Advanced Dictionary for the word “Residence” it is stated that living in the house officially provided for him - place where one resides In the light of the meanings referred to above, according to the respondents those premises/flats were being used only as “Rest House”. If that is so, the relevant Tariff would be only Tariff-I. It is also clear that except for residence those flats/premises have not been used for any other purposes. In such circumstances, the petitioner is justified in claiming that the proper Tariff would be only Tariff-I and not Tariff VIII as contended by the respondents. Accordingly the relief-prayed for in item No. 1 and 2 has to be granted in favour of the petitioner.

12. Net result, I pass the following order:—

1) The respondents are hereby restrained from assessing and collecting from the petitioner the electricity consumption charges in respect of Consumer Service No. W 163 W 166 Kodaikanal, Madurai District under Tariff No. VIII.

2) The respondents are entitled to collect the same under Tariff-I in respect of the said Service connections.

3) The respondents are directed to refund the excess amount collected by them from the petitioner either by way of penalty or as compensation. I also make it clear, for Service No. 95, if there is any excess payment claimed and paid, the same may be refunded to the petitioner.

RR/VCS