Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Subbulakshmi Ammal And Ors. v. Ganapathi And Anr.

Madras High Court
Feb 25, 1998
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Two related suits and their second appeals were considered together.

(1) O.S. No. 156 of 1981 (Second Appeal S.A. No. 1931 of 1983): On 5.1.1978 a document labelled Ex.A-1 (a sale deed) was said by the plaintiff to have been executed by the defendant in the plaintiff's favour for valuable consideration. The plaintiff alleged Rs. 100 was received by the defendant as part payment and that the defendant agreed to receive the balance at the time of registration and to attend the Sub-Registrar's office on 10.1.1978 and to produce a market-value statement. The defendant did not attend and, after an attempted notice, the plaintiff presented the deed for compulsory registration. The Sub-Registrar refused registration; on appeal the District Registrar refused to direct registration on the ground of non-compliance with the Stamp Rules and inability to ascertain the executant's willingness to attach the market-value statement. The plaintiff sued for compulsory registration; the trial court decreed the suit, the first appellate court set aside that decree and allowed the appeal, and the plaintiff filed the present second appeal.

(2) O.S. No. 206 of 1981 (Second Appeal S.A. No. 1820 of 1984): This suit sought declaration and possession of a portion of a house/site said to belong to the plaintiff (a purchaser). Facts in summary: the suit property descended from the deceased Subramania Pillai; other contiguous portions belonged to agnates and one Arumugham Pillai; plaintiff purchased the suit property from Ganapathy and his heirs; the plaintiff asked the first defendant to surrender possession; the first defendant denied the plaintiff's title and asserted title in favour of the second defendant; the second defendant denied the plaintiff's title and relied on a sale deed said to have been executed in his favour on 5.1.1978 and on a pending suit for compulsory registration (O.S. No. 1338 of 1978). At trial the suit was dismissed; on first appeal the decree was set aside and the suit was decreed; the defendant filed the present second appeal. Because the disputes were interconnected, both second appeals were heard together.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether annexing a statement under Rule 3(1)(A) of the Tamil Nadu Stamp (Prevention of UnderValuation of Instruments) Rules, 1968 is a condition precedent to registration of a sale deed and whether the court could refuse the relief of compulsory registration even though full stamp duty was paid.
  2. Whether the lower court was justified in rejecting compulsory registration solely because the annexure under Rule 3(1)(A) was not attached to the sale deed.
  3. Whether the lower appellate court omitted to construe or misconstrued the material evidence on the question of the genuineness of Ex.A-1 (the sale deed).
  4. Whether the lower appellate court failed to apply the principle for determining whether the second defendant was a bona fide purchaser for value without notice of Ex.A-11 (assuming Ex.A-11 to be true and genuine).

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff (O.S. No. 156 of 1981 / S.A. No. 1931 of 1983)

  • The plaintiff asserted that Ex.A-1 was duly executed by the defendant on 5.1.1978 for valuable consideration.
  • The defendant allegedly received Rs. 100 towards his sons' educational expenses and agreed to receive the balance at registration.
  • The defendant agreed to be present at the Registration Office on 10.1.1978 and to produce a statement of market value, but failed to attend; the plaintiff presented the deed for compulsory registration after attempted notice.
  • Because registration was refused, the plaintiff sought relief (compulsory registration) in court.

Defendant (O.S. No. 156 of 1981 / S.A. No. 1931 of 1983)

  • The defendant denied executing any sale deed and denied receipt of any amount.
  • The defendant denied ever agreeing to receive any balance before the Sub-Registrar and denied the presence of attesting witnesses.

Plaintiff (O.S. No. 206 of 1981 / S.A. No. 1820 of 1984)

  • The plaintiff asserted title by purchase from Ganapathy and heirs and sought declaration and possession of the suit property.
  • The plaintiff issued notice to the first defendant to surrender possession alleging the second defendant had no title.

First Defendant (O.S. No. 206 of 1981)

  • The first defendant denied any tenancy agreement with Subramania Pillai and said he agreed to pay rent to the second defendant.
  • The first defendant alleged he only learned of the plaintiff's purported purchase upon receipt of notice.
  • The first defendant stated O.S. No. 1338 of 1978 (objecting to the sale) was pending and the suits should be tried together.

Second Defendant (O.S. No. 206 of 1981)

  • The second defendant alleged a sale deed in his favour executed by Ganapathy on 5.1.1978 and that a suit for compulsory registration (O.S. No. 1338 of 1978) was pending because the executant did not turn up for registration.
  • The second defendant contended the plaintiff's sale deed was fraudulent and invalid and that the plaintiff was not entitled to the relief claimed.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis focused on statutory and rule-based requirements for compulsory registration of instruments and the effect of non-compliance by the executant.

  1. Identification of the statutory and regulatory provisions at issue: the court considered Rule 3(1-A) of the Tamil Nadu Stamp (Prevention of UnderValuation of Instruments) Rules, 1968 (which prescribes detailed particulars to be specified for buildings, such as type of building, number of storeys, plinth area, nature of walls, year of construction, materials, fittings, well size, and other special features) and Rule 3(2-A) (which states that if the market value required by Section 27 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 is not set forth in the instrument or the required statement is not attached, the registering officer shall refuse registration).
  2. Application of those rules to the facts: the court observed that Rule 3(2-A) envisages a separate statement of market value, duly signed by the party executing the instrument, and that the registering officer must refuse registration where that signed statement is absent.
  3. Findings about the procedural history before the registering authorities: when Ex.A-1 was presented, the Sub-Registrar refused registration because the executant (the defendant) did not appear and had not given a signed market-value statement under Rule 3(1-A). On appeal, the District Registrar (in Ex.A-3) elaborated that although certain provisions of the Registration Act (Sections 19 to 21, 23 and 32) may have been complied with or that the counter-petitioner's counter filed amounts to an admission of execution, the inability to ascertain the executant's willingness to attach the market-value statement and the non-compliance with Stamp Law and the Rules prevented directing registration.
  4. Conclusion on compulsory registration: applying the mandatory wording of Rule 3(1-A) and Rule 3(2-A), the court concluded that non-compliance by the executant (absence of a signed market-value statement) justified the registering officer's refusal to register Ex.A-1. The court agreed with the District Registrar's reasoning and held that the absence of the required statement was a valid ground to refuse compulsory registration.
  5. Effect on related property suit: because the appellant in S.A. No. 1931 (the plaintiff in O.S. No. 156) was held not to be entitled to registration of Ex.A-1, the court accepted the reasoning that the appellant had no right over the suit property in O.S. No. 206. Accordingly, the plaintiff in O.S. No. 206 was held entitled to the declaration and possession sought, and the first appellate court's decree in that suit was upheld.
  6. Appellate review standard and result: the court found no warrant for interfering with the first appellate court's findings in either matter and thus dismissed both second appeals.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Both Second Appeals are dismissed. No costs were awarded.

Implications:

  • Direct effect for S.A. No. 1931 of 1983 / O.S. No. 156 of 1981: the appellant (plaintiff at trial) is not entitled to compulsory registration of Ex.A-1 because the executant did not attach and sign the market-value statement as required by Rule 3(1-A) and Rule 3(2-A); consequently the appellant was found to have no right over the suit property by virtue of Ex.A-1.
  • Direct effect for S.A. No. 1820 of 1984 / O.S. No. 206 of 1981: because the plaintiff in that suit was not shown to be entitled to compulsory registration (and hence had no title derived from Ex.A-1), the plaintiff was entitled to the declaration and possession claimed; the first appellate court's decree in favour of the plaintiff in O.S. No. 206 was upheld.
  • Broader implications: the opinion rests on a rule-based interpretation—that compliance with Rule 3(1-A) (and the requirement in Rule 3(2-A) concerning the signed market-value statement) is mandatory for registration—and applies that requirement to deny compulsory registration where the executant did not produce the signed statement. The opinion does not announce a new legal precedent beyond applying the mandatory rule-language to the facts, and it does not discuss any wider doctrine beyond the immediate statutory application.

This summary is confined to information explicitly contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

1. Plaintiff in O.S.No. 156 of 1981 is the appellant in S.A.No. 1931 of 1983. Defendant in O.S.No. 206 of 1981 are the appellants in S.A.No. 1820 of 1984.

2. The case of the plaintiff in O.S.No. 156 of 1981 (S.A.No. 1931 of 1983) is as follows:

On 5.1.1978, the defendant has duly executed a sale deed in favour of the plaintiff for valuable consideration and the defendant received Rs. 100 towards the educational expenses of his sons and agreed to receive the balance of sale price before the Sub-Registrar at the time of registration. The attestors also attested the document. The defendant has consented to be present in the Registration Office on 10.1.1978 and consented to attach the market value statement. The defendant did not come to the Registration Office on 10.1.1978. The plaintiff sent a registered letter on 11.1.1978 and the defendant did not receive the same. So, the plaintiff presented the document for compulsory registration, since the plaintiff felt suspicious about the conduct of the defendant. Since the defendant did not turn up the Sub-Registrar refused to register it. So, the plaintiff preferred an appeal before the District Registrar in A.P.No. 3 of 1978: The District Registrar passed an order refusing to direct the registration of the document since he was not able to ascertain the willingness of the defendant to attach the statement of market value and as the requirement of stamp law and the Rule thereunder were not complied with. Hence, the plaintiff has come forward with this suit for registration of the document.

3. The defendant has filed written statement contending that he had not executed any sale deed and had not received any amount and he also never agreed to receive any balance amount before the Sub-Registrar. He also denies the presence of the attesting witnesses.

4. The suit was tried by the District Munsif, Jayamkondan and it was decreed. In the first appeal, the judgment and decree of the trial court was set aside and the appeal was allowed.

5. Aggrieved against that judgment and decree, the present Second Appeal S.A.No. 1931 of 1983 is filed by the plaintiff.

6. The plaintiff in O.S.No. 206 of 1981 filed that suit for declaration and possession of the suit property. The suit property belonged to the deceased Subramania Pillai. The suit property is a portion of house and house site while the contiguous other portions belong to agnaters of Subramania Pillai. The other portions belonged to one Arumugham Pillai. After his death, his share devolved on the legal representatives under a will, Subramania Pillai leased out the property on rent to the first defendant. The plaintiff purchased the suit property from Ganapathy and his heirs, who is the son of Subramania Pillai. The plaintiff issued notice to the first defendant to surrender possession. The first defendant denied the title of the plaintiff and falsely put up title in favour of the second defendant in respect of the suit property. The second defendant has no title or any right over the suit property.

7. The first defendant filed written statement contending that he has not agreed with Subramania Pillai for rent and he has agreed to pay rent of Rs. 15 per month to the second defendant. This defendant has knowledge about the sale in favour of the plaintiff only after receipt of notice from the plaintiff, The Second defendant has filed O.S.No. 1338 of 1978 objecting the sale and that suit is pending and the suits to be tried at one time.

8. The second defendant filed written statement contending that Ganapathy son of Subramania Pillai executed a sale deed in favour of this defendant on 5.1.1978. Since he did not turn up for registration, O.S.No. 1338 of 1978 is filed for compulsory registration and is pending. The plaintiff has created fraudulent sale deed and it is not valid. The plaintiff is not entitled to the relief asked for.

9. This suit was tried by the District Munsif, Jayamkondam and it was dismissed. In the first appeal, the judgment and decree of the lower court was set aside and the suit was decreed.

10. Aggrieved against the judgment and decree, S.A.No. 1820 of 1984 is filed by the defendant.

11. The substantial questions of law that were framed at the time of admission of S.A.No. 1931 of 1983 are as follows:

(i) Whether the annexing of a statement under Rule 3(1)(A) of the Tamil Nadu Stamp (Prevention of UnderValuation of Instruments) Rules, 1968 is a condition precedent for registration of a sale deed and whether the court could refused the relief of compulsory registration sought for by the plaintiff even though he has paid the full stamp duty payable under the document?

(ii) Whether the lower court is justified in law in rejecting the relief of compulsory registration on the only ground that the annexure under Rule 3(1)(A) of the said Rules is not attached to the sale deed?

The substantial questions of law framed in S.A.No. 1820 of 1984 as follows:

(i) Whether the lower appellate court omitted to construe and mis-construed the material evidence on record on the question of genuineness of Ex.A-1?

(ii) Whether the lower appellate court has not appreciated and applied the principle to find out whether the second defendant is a bona fide purchaser for value without notice of Ex.A-11 assuming that it is true and genuine?

12. Since the facts and circumstances involved in S.A.No. 1820 of 1984 are connected with S.A.No. 1931 of 1983 this second appeal is taken up along with S.A.No. 1931 of 1983 for disposal. For the sake of convenience, the plaintiff hereinafter referred to is the plaintiff in O.S.No. 156 of 1981 (S.A.No. 1931 of 1983) and the defendant is the defendant in the same suit.

13. According to the plaintiff, the defendant has duly executed Ex.A-1 sale deed for valuable consideration and received Rs. 100 and agreed to receive the balance of sale consideration of the time of registration and also consented to be present in the Registration office on 1.0.1.1978 and produce the statement of market value for the suit property, but, he did not come to the Registration Office and so, the plaintiff has sought for compulsory registration which was refused by the Sub-Registrar and in the appeal also it was refused by the District Registrar and so, the plaintiff in entitled to compulsory registration of the document. The defendant denies the execution of the document and also denies with regard to receipt of any amount.

14. When the document was presented before the registering authority, he refused registration of the document. On appeal, the District Registrar has passed order in Ex.A-3. Under Ex.A-3, the District Registrar has passed an elaborate order and has found that the counter filed by the counter petitioner states that the signatures were obtained by coercion and that tantamounts to admission of execution of Ex.A-1 by the counter petitioner and the provisions of Sections 19 to 21, 23 and 32 of the Registration Act have been complied with. But, the Sub-Registrar has refused registration on the ground that there was non-compliance with the provisions of Rule 3(1-A) of the Tamil Nadu Stamp (Prevention of Under Valuation of Instruments) Rules, 1968 and no appeal has been preferred by the applicant. It is also found in Ex.A-3 that as the counter petitioner has not appeared and he has been declared ex pane, it was not possible to ascertain whether the executant of Ex.A-1 was willing to attach a statement of marked value and as the requirement of Stamp Law and the Rules thereunder have not been complied with by the executant of the suit document, he refused to direct the registration of Ex.A-1. So, it is evident from the order of the District Registrar in Ex.A-3 that there was non-compliance of the provisions of Tamil Nadu Stamp (Prevention of UnderValuation of Instruments) Rules, 1968, Rule 3(1-A) of the said rules reads as follows:

If an instrument relates to only one item of property and that property is a building or if an instrument relates to more than one items of property and one or more such items is or are a building or buildings, the following particulars shall be specified in respect of the building or each of such buildings:

(i) the type of building, i.e., whether tiled or reinforced concrete or Madras terraced or otherwise;

(ii) the number of storeys in the building;

(iii) the plinth area of each floor or storeys in the building with area of each storey or floor or storey;

(iv) the nature of structure of the building specifying whether the walls are built in brick and cement brick and lime mortar or otherwise;

(v) the year of construction of the building;

(vi) the kind of materials used in the construction of the building;

(vii) a brief description of the nature of the sanitary, electrical and other fittings in the building and their quality;

(viii) the size and depth of the well if any in the property; and

(ix) any other special feature affecting the value of the building.

Rule 3(2-A) reads as follows:

If the market value of the property as required by Section 27 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 (Central Act II of 1899) is not set forth in the instrument where the property dealt with therein is a single item or the statement giving the market value of each property separately as required by Sub-rules (I) and (I-A) above is not attached to the instrument, the registering officer shall refuse the registration of the document.

This rule envisages that the party who is executing the document shall attach separate statement duly signed by him and if that statement is not attached to the instrument duly signed by the party executing the instrument, the Registering Officer shall refuse the registration of that document. Since the defendant did not appear before the Sub-Registrar's Office on the date of registration and as he has not given the statement duly signed by him giving the market value of the property as per Rule 3(1-A) the Registering Officer has rightly refused registration of that document. The District Registrar has also correctly passed the order stating that as the requirement of Stamp Law and the Rules thereunder have not been complied with by the executant of the suit document, he refused to direct registration of that document, Ex.A-1. The provisions of Rule 3(1-A) is mandatory to be complied with and as the defendant himself was absent and did not give the statement and as there was no authenticity with regard to that document the Sub-Registrar has correctly refused registration of that document. The first appellate court has correctly negatived the claim of the plaintiff and dismissed the suit by allowing the appeal. The judgment and decree of the first appellate court does not warrant any interference. Therefore, the Second Appeal No. 1931 of 1983 is liable to be dismissed.

15. In view of the above finding in S.A.No. 1931 of 1983 that the appellant therein is not entitled to registration of the document as per the direction of the District Munsif and the appellant has no manner or right over the suit property and as she is not entitled to compulsory registration of the document, the plaintiff in O.S.No. 206 of 1981 (S.A.No. 1820 of 1984) is entitled to the declaration and possession asked for. The lower appellate court has correctly found and allowed the first appeal by decreeing the suit. Hence, this second appeal is liable to be dismissed.

16. In the result, both the second appeals are dismissed. No costs.