- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Tamil Nadu Civil Sup... v. Tamil Nadu Civil Sup...
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner is the Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation Modern Rice Mill Engineering Section which filed a writ petition seeking a writ of mandamus directing the first respondent (the Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation) to regularise 73 casual workmen who, the petitioner alleged, had completed more than 24 calendar months (480 days) of continuous service. The petitioner later restricted relief sought to 69 persons whose names appeared in Annexures I and II of the first respondent's proceedings.
The petitioner relied on S. 3(1) of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 ("the Act"), which, it was contended, obligated the industrial establishment to make permanent any workman in continuous service for 480 days in 24 calendar months. The petitioner asserted that representations were made to the first respondent and to the second respondent (Deputy Chief Inspector of Factories, Tiruchirapalli). The second respondent forwarded the representations to the first respondent and advised the first respondent to extend benefits in accordance with S. 3(1).
The first respondent issued internal guidelines on 3 June 1986 for regularisation of casual labourers, including a clause (iii) providing that absorption would be against sanctioned permanent posts only and that engagement when no sanctioned post exists is prohibited. On 24 February 1989 the first respondent issued proceedings stating that services of certain casual labourers (40 persons in Annexure I and 69 persons in Annexure II) were regularised with effect from 15 December 1988.
The petitioner contended that, once persons met the statutory 480-day condition, they should have been regularised with effect from the date they completed the condition rather than with effect from the single date 15 December 1988 or conditioned on availability of sanctioned posts or Employment Exchange sponsorship. The first respondent contended the matter had been addressed by the 24 February 1989 order and that it could not regularise persons not sponsored by the Employment Exchange.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, under S. 3(1) of the Act, a workman who has rendered continuous service for 480 days in a period of 24 calendar months must be conferred permanent status irrespective of other service rules, availability of sanctioned posts or sponsorship by the Employment Exchange.
- Whether the first respondent could lawfully fix a single consequential date (15 December 1988) for conferment of permanent status for all eligible casual workmen instead of conferring status from the individual date each workman satisfied the statutory condition.
- What are the powers and duties of Inspectors under S. 5 of the Act, and whether those powers include conducting enquiries, taking evidence and initiating action under S. 6 for contraventions of S. 3(1).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Under S. 3(1) of the Act every workman who is in continuous service for 480 days in 24 calendar months shall be made permanent; this is a statutory obligation on the industrial establishment.
- No special or separate enquiry is required under the Act to implement the statutory right; a mere representation by the workman to the employer should be sufficient for the employer to provide S. 3(1) benefits, failing which penal action under S. 6 would lie.
- The petitioner had made several representations to the first respondent and approached the Deputy Chief Inspector; the Inspector forwarded and advised the first respondent to extend benefits.
- The first respondent's internal guideline (3 June 1986), particularly clause (iii) which conditions absorption on the existence of sanctioned permanent posts or sponsorship, should not defeat the statutory right; the first respondent ought to have regularised the 69 persons from the date each completed 480 days rather than with effect from 15 December 1988.
Respondent's Arguments
- The first respondent contended that the grievance had been considered and appropriate orders were passed by its proceedings dated 24 February 1989, regularising the services with effect from 15 December 1988, and that no further orders were necessary.
- The first respondent, being a Government owned Corporation, asserted it could not regularise services of labourers whose names were not sponsored by the Employment Exchange.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analysed the statute and the facts as follows:
- Statutory primacy of S. 3(1): The court observed that S. 3(1) is a non obstante provision and therefore prevails over any other law in force, including service rules, Government orders or Government instructions. Consequently, the absence of sanctioned posts or the requirement of appointment through the Employment Exchange could not be invoked to deny the statutory right under S. 3(1) to workmen who satisfy its conditions.
- Scope of S. 5 (Inspectors' powers): The court noted S. 5(b) empowers an Inspector to examine registers, records and take evidence and S. 5(c) permits the Inspector to exercise other powers necessary to carry out the purposes of the Act. The court construed these provisions to include powers to hold enquiries, take evidence, pass orders and implement them, as well as to initiate penal action under S. 6 for contravention of S. 3(1).
- Consequences of administrative action or inaction: Because the second respondent (Inspector) had satisfied himself that the union members were entitled to S. 3(1) benefits and had forwarded representations to the first respondent, the court held that if the first respondent failed to pass appropriate orders conferring permanent status, it would be liable to prosecution under S. 6.
- On the fixation of a single date (15 December 1988): The court held that selecting 15 December 1988 as the common effective date for conferment of permanent status was arbitrary and unreasonable. S. 3(1) confers a right on each individual workman upon satisfaction of the statutory condition, and therefore the effective date should be the date on which each individual satisfied the 480-day condition.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is allowed and the respondents are directed to modify their proceedings dated 24 February 1989 so as to confer permanent status on each individual workman from the date on which that individual completed continuous service for a period of 480 days in 24 calendar months.
Directives and immediate consequences:
- The respondents must pass appropriate orders effecting such modification within six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of the court's order.
- The writ petition is disposed of accordingly and no costs were awarded.
The opinion does not discuss broader policy or precedent effects beyond directing the respondents to give effect to statutory rights of individual workmen under S. 3(1); no other wider implications are explicated in the text.
JUDGMENT
1. Heard Sri K. Chandru, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri N. Kannadasan, learned counsel for the contesting respondents.
2. The petitioner, viz., Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation Modern Rice Mill Engineering Section has filed the above writ petition for issue of a writ of mandamus directing the first respondent to forthwith regularise the 73 casual workmen, working in the Modem Rice Mills, those who have completed more than 24 calender months with effect from the date on which they had completed 480 days of their service.
3. Sri K. Chandru, learned counsel for this petitioner, however restricts the prayer with regard to 69 persons only, whose names are found in Annexures I and II of the proceedings of the first respondent-Corporation. Sri K. Chandru, learned counsel for the petitioner-union, also contends that as per S. 3(1) of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 (hereinafter called as the Act), it shall be the statutory obligation on the part of the industrial establishment, such an the first respondent herein, to make every workman as permanent, who is in service for a continuous period of 480 days in a period of 24 calender months in such as industrial establishment. He further contends that there is no specific enquiry or separate proceedings is contemplated under the Act for implementing the above statutory right by a workman, who has been denied of such right. But, however, he points out S. 6 of the Act, which provides for a penalty to the employer who contravenes the provisions of S. 3 of the Act.
4. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, as per the scheme of the Act, on a mere representation by the workman to the industrial establishment or the employer, as the case may be, seeking the above statutory right conferred under S. 3 of the Act, such industrial establishment or employer shall provide the benefits of S. 3 of the Act to the workman, otherwise, such employer shall have to face the prosecution as provided under S. 6 of the Act. In the instant case, he points out that the petitioner had made several representations to the first respondent-Corporation and also have approached the second respondent, Deputy Chief Inspector of Factories, Thiruchirapalli for necessary relief. The second respondent by his proceedings, dated 2 May, 1986, informed the petitioner-union that their representations were forwarded to the first respondent-industrial establishment for appropriate relief. Again by the subsequent proceedings, dated 20 May, 1986, the second respondent also advised the first respondent industrial establishment to extent all the benefits to all the deserving casual labourers strictly in accordance with S. 3(1) of the Act.
5. It is no doubt true that in pursuance of such representations sent by the petitioner-union the first respondent by proceedings, dated 3 June, 1986, framed certain guidelines for regularising the casual labourers, who are similarly placed and who are entitled for the conferment of permanent status on completion of their continuous services for a period of four hundred and eighty days in a period of 24 calendar months, The proceedings so issued by the Chairman-cum-Managing Director of the Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation (Head Office, Madras, dated 3 June, 1986, runs as follows):
“Copy of letter Rc. E6/46073/82, dated 3 June, 1986, received from the Chairman-cum-Managing Director, T.N.S.C.S, Ltd., Head Office, Madras. Addressed to the Senior Regional Manager, T.N.C.S.C, Ltd. Thanjavur Region.
Sub: Casual Labourers-Regularisation of service-Guidelines issued.
Ref; S.R.M Thanjavur Rc. 5148/81.A8, dated 12 March, 1986, and 24 April, 1986.
The above matter was placed before the Board and the Board has issued the following guidelines for regularisation of casual labourers, services working in the Modem Rice Mills.
The casual labourers working on daily wages in Modem Rice Mills of the Corporation who have put in service for a continuous period of 480 days in the period of 24 calendar months be considered for regularisation in the scale of Rs. 450-10-720, subject to the following conditions:
(i) The casual service will count only from the date of appointment on being sponsored by the Employment Exchange, except in cases where such engagement without consultation with Employment Exchange is specifically approved by the Government.
(ii) If during the casual service in any calender year, the casual worker renders less than 240 days service, his service becomes discontinuous and this particular year will not be counted for completion of eligible days of service.
(iii) The absorption of time-scale will be against sanctioned permanent posts only Engagement of a casual Labourers when there is no vacant sanctioned post is strictly prohibited.
(iv) In respect of the casual workers whose services have been ordered to be regularised against permanent vacancies during 1985 and 1986, the fixation against regular scale of pay would be with effect from the dates of issue of order from the head office, viz., 20 August, 1985 and 17 January, 1986, respectively.
(v) The performance of the casual worker should be closely watched and in the case of those casual workers whose performance is not within satisfactory levels, their services should be terminated after following the procedure laid down in the statutes.
(vi) Proposals for regularisation of eligible casual workers will be submitted by Regional Managers to the Chairman-cum-Managing Director every year as on the 1st of January of the year.
The Senior Regional Managers and Regional Managers are requested to follow the guidelines and to take necessary further action in this regard.
Yours faithfully,
for T.N.C.S, Ltd.,
A.S RAMASAMY
MANAGER (Adm. I/C.)”
6. Sri K. Chandru, learned counsel for the petitioner also invited my attention of Cl. (iii) of the said proceeding extracted above. Clause (iii) of the said proceeding would go to show that the absorption of time-scale will be against the sanctioned permanent posts only and that the engagement of casual labourers, when there is no vacant sanctioned post is strictly prohibited. Again, by another proceedings of the first respondent-Corporation, dated 24 February, 1989 in MEI/46073/82, the Chairman-cum-Managing Director of the Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation, Ltd., requested all the Senior Regional Managers concerned to regularise the services of the 69 casual labourers, as shown in the Annexure I and II therein. They were stated to be in continuous service for a period of 480 days in a period of 24 calendar months in the time scale of Rs. 450-10-520-15-720 in the cadre of Junior Helper with effect from 15 December, 1988. In pursuance of the said proceedings, dated 24 February, 1989, the services of 40 casual labourers, whose names and other particulars are furnished in Annexure I and who are stated to have been appointed between 1 January, 1978 and 8 July, 1980 and 69 persons, whose names and other particulars are finished in Annexure II and who are stated to have been appointed after 8 July, 1980, were regularised with effect from 15 December, 1988.
7. Sri K. Chandra, learned counsel for the petitioner further contends that the first respondent-Corporation, having agreed to regularise the services of the casual labourers in pursuance of Cl. (iii) of the proceedings, dated 3 June, 1986, ought to have regularised the services of the 69 persons immediately with effect from the date of completion of continuous service for a period of 480 days of service in a period of 24 calendar months but not with effect from 15 December, 1988, irrespective of the sanction for the post or sponsorship of the names of the employees by the Employment Exchange.
8. Per contra, Sri N. Kannadasan, learned counsel appearing for the first respondent-Corporation contends that the grievance of the petitioner, viz., 69 persons have already been considered by the first respondent-Corporation and appropriate orders are passed in their proceedings No. MEI/46073/82, dated 24 February, 1989, and as their services were regularised with effect from 15 December, 1988, and therefore no further orders are required in the above writ petition. Sri N. Kannadasan further contends that since the first respondent is a Government owned Corporation, they cannot regularise the service of the labourers, whose names are not sponsored by the Employment Exchange.
9. I have given my anxious consideration to the rival submission of learned counsel appearing on either side.
10. In this connection, it is relevant to refer the following provisions of the said Act.
Section 3(1):
“Conferment of permanent status to workmen.— Notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force every workman who is in continuous service for a period of four hundred and eighty days in a period of twenty-four calendar months in an industrial establishment shall be made permanent.”
Section 5:
“Powers and duties of Inspectors.— Subject to any rules made by the Government in this behalf, the Inspector may, within the local limits for which he is appointed,
(a) enter at all reasonable times and with such assistants, if any, who are persons in the service of the Government or of any local authority as he thinks fit to take with him, any industrial establishment;
(b) make such examination of the industrial establishment and of any registers, records and notices and take on the spot or elsewhere the evidence of such person as he may deem necessary, for carrying out the purposes of this Act; and
(c) exercise such other powers as may be necessary for carrying out the purposes of this Act.”
Section 6:
“Penalties.— (1) Every employer who contravenes the provisions of section shall be punishable with fine which may extend to five thousand rupees and in the case of continuing offence with a further fine which may extend to two hundred rupees for every day after the first during which the offence continues.
(2) No prosecution for an offence punishable under the section shall be instituted except with the previous sanction of the prescribed authority.”
11. Section 3(1), being a non obstante provision, it prevails over any law for the time being in force which includes any service rules, Government orders or Government instructions. Therefore, want of sanctioned posts as required under General Service Rules cannot take away the rights conferred under S. 3(1) of the Act. Similarly, Government orders which require that the appointment should be made only through Employment Exchange also cannot be a ground to refuse the right provided under S. 3(1) of the Act of the petitioners (sic.) if they comply with the requirements prescribed under S. 3(1). Therefore, it is not open for the respondent to take shelter under any other law in force much less any Government orders, Government instructions to deny the benefits conferred under S. 3(1) of the Act, to the petitioners if they satisfy the conditions prescribed therein, irrespective of the fact whether there are irrespective of the availability of sanctioned posts or sponsorship from Employment Exchange.
12. It is also relevant to observe S. 5 which prescribes the powers and duties of Inspectors. Under S. 5 (b), the Inspector is empowered to evidence (sic.) of such person as he may deem necessary for carrying out the purposes of the Act. Section 5(c) further empowers the Inspector to exercise such other powers as may be necessary for carrying out the purposes of the Act. Therefore, under the scheme of the Act, the Inspector is empowered to exercise all such powers that are necessary for carrying out the purposes of the Act including taking evidence, holding enquiry, passing orders, achieve the object of the Act and also to implement such orders for carrying out the purposes of the Act which includes power to initiate penal action under S. 6 of the Act for contravention of S. 3(1) of the Act.
13. In the instant case, the second respondent after satisfying himself that the members of the petitioner-union are entitled for the benefit of S. 3(1) of the Act, forwarded the representation of the members of the petitioner-union for appropriate relief. Under such circumstance, if the first respondent-Corporation failed to pass appropriate orders, giving benefits of conferring permanent status to the members of the petitioner-union, certainly the first respondent shall face the consequences of prosecution provided under S. 6 of the Act.
14. That apart, fixing 15 December, 1988 as a crucial date for conferment of permanent status to all the persons and regularisation of their service is again arbitrary and unreasonable as much as S. 3(1) confers right of the permanent status on every individual workman, if the conditions contemplated under S. 3(1) are complied with, in the case of individual workman.
15. Therefore, the respondents are directed to modify the proceedings, dated 24 February, 1989, to confer the permanent status to individual workman from the day on which they satisfy the condition namely completing the continuous service for period of 480 days in a period of 24 calendar months in the respondent establishment. The respondent shall pass appropriate orders as directed above within six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
16. The writ petition is ordered accordingly. No costs.
Alert