Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Athianna Gounder And Another v. Kumaraswamy (Now Deceased) And R. Natarajan And Others

Madras High Court
Jan 20, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judicial Opinion — Structured Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This Revision Petition was filed by the judgment-debtors in O.S. No. 211 of 1973 (Sub Court, Sankari). The first respondent (plaintiff in the original suit) obtained a decree for recovery of amounts due on a promissory note. To execute that decree Execution Petition No. 28 of 1985 was filed. While the execution petition was pending (initially before the Subordinate Judge's Court, Salem), the petitioners paid a total of Rs. 28,500 towards the decree debt.

The execution proceedings were later transferred to a newly constituted Sub Court at Sankari (transfer arising from administrative reorganization). A sale was held in November 1985 (the opinion records a sale date as 22-11-1985 in one place and records the sale as conducted on 21-11-1985 in another passage). At the time of the sale the balance stated as payable to the decree-holder is recorded in the opinion variously as a small sum (the text records Rs. 1,887 at one point and Rs. 1,487 at another).

The petitioners contended they were entitled to statutory benefit (Act 40 of 1979 / Act 17 of 1979 is referred to in the narrative) and, having paid more than the amount then required, they believed no further amount was payable and that the decree was discharged. They challenged the sale on several grounds including lack of fresh proclamation or notice (alleged contravention of Order 21, Rule 66, C.P.C.), sale of the entire property when only a portion would have sufficed, and that the purchaser was effectively the decree-holder (purchase made in the name of the decree-holder's relative) and therefore the purchase was invalid.

Procedural history in brief: the executing Court initially dismissed petitioners' application as not maintainable because a Sale Certificate had been issued. This dismissal was set aside by this Court in C.R.P. No. 81 of 1990 (order dated 8-3-1990), which directed the executing Court to decide the petitioners' application under Section 47, C.P.C., on merits. Subsequent steps included issuance of a Sale Certificate to the auction-purchaser and an order for delivery of possession. A Civil Revision Petition (C.R.P. No. 1194 of 1991) challenging delivery of possession was dismissed by this Court (order dated 28-6-1991), with an observation that if petitioners succeed under Section 47 they would be entitled to restitution. After evidence was taken by the executing Court, that Court again dismissed the petitioners' application (R.E.A. No. 179 of 1986), and this dismissal is the subject-matter of the present revision petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a sale ordered by an executing court after transfer of the execution petition to another court (due to administrative reorganization) without issuing fresh notice under Order 21, Rule 66, C.P.C. to the judgment-debtor is valid or is a nullity.
  2. Whether, in execution of a decree, the court was obliged to examine and decide whether the entire property or only a part of it needed to be sold (in light of Order 21, Rule 64 and related provisions), when a substantial portion of the decree debt had already been paid before sale.
  3. Whether the validity of a sale can be treated as non-justiciable in execution proceedings after issuance of a Sale Certificate, or whether an application under Section 47, C.P.C. can be entertained on merits despite a Sale Certificate having been issued.
  4. Whether a purchase made in the name of a relative of the decree-holder (specifically the decree-holder's brother's son) can be treated as a purchase by the decree-holder himself and, if so, whether that purchase is invalid without the Court's sanction.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners had already paid Rs. 28,500 towards the decree debt while the execution petition was pending and, by reason of statutory benefit under the relevant Act (referred to in the opinion), they were bound to pay only the principal (Rs. 15,000) and reduced interest; in consequence they believed the decree was discharged and no further payment was due.
  • The sale proceeded after transfer of the execution petition to the Sub Court, Sankari without any fresh notice or fresh proclamation under Order 21, Rule 66, C.P.C.; thus the petitioners were not given an opportunity to present their estimate of value or to prevent the sale.
  • The sale covered more than ten acres and was for a paltry sum (figures in the record show the property valued at Rs. 50,000 whereas the sale fetched only a small sum); only a small portion of the property should have been sold to satisfy the decree.
  • The auction-purchaser was the decree-holder's brother's son and thus the purchase was effectively by the decree-holder in the name of a relative, without the Court's sanction, and therefore invalid.
  • The conduct of the sale was fraudulent, without jurisdiction and required a declaration that the sale was invalid.

Respondents' Arguments

  • All proceedings, including the sale, were conducted in accordance with law and there was no fraud upon the Court or the petitioners.
  • The petitioners received notice of R.E.A. No. 421 of 1985 (the application for sale) and therefore had the onus to watch the proceedings and file objections; having failed to do so after transfer and renumbering (as R.E.A. No. 7 of 1985), they cannot now complain about the sale.
  • No fresh notice under Order 21, Rule 66, C.P.C. is required when an execution petition is transferred to another court; the proceedings were a continuation and not a fresh proceeding requiring fresh proclamation or service.
  • The property constituted one lot and therefore could be sold only as one lot; a grant that part only should be sold must have been pressed by the judgment-debtors at the time of sale, and it is not open to them later to seek division after proclamation and sale proceedings were settled.
  • The executing Court which actually conducted the sale is the proper forum to examine the validity of the sale, and the petitioners' application was, in the executing Court's view, not maintainable once a Sale Certificate had been issued.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Desk Bandhu Gupta v. N.I. Anand Rajinder Singh, (1994) I SCC 131 = 1994-1-L.W. 49 Service of notice on the judgment‑debtor under Order 21, Rule 66(2) is mandatory unless waived; omission to serve notice renders the sale a nullity as it deprives the judgment‑debtor of opportunity to give estimate and to protect his interest. The Court relied on this Supreme Court authority to hold that absence of notice after transfer was fatal and sufficient to set aside the sale as being without jurisdiction.
S.N. (Takkaseela Pedda Subba Reddi v. Pujati Padmavathamma), (1977) 3 SCC 337 = 90 L.W. 124 Where the amount specified in the sale proclamation is fully satisfied by sale of certain items, sale of further items should be stopped; sale beyond the decretal amount specified in the proclamation vitiates further sales. The Court cited this decision to support the proposition that the executing court must stop sale once the amount specified in the proclamation is satisfied and must not sell further property unnecessarily.
Ambatti Narasayya v. Subba Rao, (1989) Sup. (2) SCC 693 = AIR 1990 S.C. 119 The executing court must first decide whether the entire property is necessary to satisfy the decree; if only a portion suffices, the court is obligated to sell only that portion even if the property is one lot. The Court applied this authority to hold that the executing court had the duty to determine and limit the sale to such part as required to meet the decree and that failure to do so renders the sale illegal and without jurisdiction.
Karimbal Ice & Cold Storage Co. v. SSBT and another, (1995) 1 K.L.T. 495 (Kerala High Court) Followed the principle in Ambatti Narasayya that a court must sell only such portion as is sufficient to satisfy the decree. The Court referred to this decision as an instance of a High Court following the Ambatti principle, reinforcing the binding nature of that principle for execution sales.
Parvathy Antharjanan v. Indian Bank, 1990 I K.L.T. 319 (Kerala High Court) Applied the same principle about limiting sale to the portion necessary to satisfy the decree. The Court noted this decision as another authority following Ambatti, supporting the requirement that execution courts limit sales appropriately.
C.R.P. No. 81 of 1990 (V. Ratnam, J. — High Court order dated 8-3-1990) Held that an application under Section 47, C.P.C. must be decided on merits and that issuance of a Sale Certificate does not, by itself, preclude consideration of an application to set aside the sale. The Court relied on this High Court order in the procedural history and in rejecting the executing Court's earlier technical view that the sale could not be challenged after issuance of a Sale Certificate; this Court restored the petitioners' application to be decided on merits.
C.R.P. No. 1194 of 1991 (Srinivasan, J. — High Court order dated 28-6-1991) Held that if the petitioners succeed under Section 47, C.P.C., they would be entitled to restitution (to get back possession) without further requirement. The present Court relied on this prior order to conclude that, having allowed the revision, petitioners are entitled to possession by way of restitution without a further application.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a step-by-step analysis limited to the facts and law recorded in the opinion. The critical strands of reasoning were:

  1. Notice obligation upon transfer: The Court found that the execution petition had been transferred from the Subordinate Judge's Court, Salem to the Sub Court, Sankari due to administrative reorganization. The transferred court had a duty to issue notice under Order 21, Rule 66, C.P.C. to the judgment‑debtors. The Court concluded that no such notice was served in the transferred proceedings and therefore the judgment‑debtors were deprived of the opportunity to give their estimate of value or to take steps to prevent or limit the sale.
  2. Mandatory nature of O.21, R.66: Relying on the cited Supreme Court authority (Desk Bandhu Gupta), the Court held that service of notice under Order 21, Rule 66(2) is a fundamental and mandatory step in execution procedure which, if omitted (absent waiver or voluntary appearance), renders the sale void. The Court observed the absence of notice caused irremediable injury to the judgment‑debtors and that omission rendered subsequent sale proceedings void and without jurisdiction.
  3. Duty to limit sale to necessary portion: The Court examined valuation and payments: the decree‑holder had earlier declared the total value of the properties at Rs. 50,000; the judgment‑debtors had paid Rs. 28,500; and the balance at the time of transfer/sale was a small sum (variously recorded as Rs. 1,887 and Rs. 1,487 in the record). The Court held that under Order 21, Rule 64 and related provisions (and the statutory amendment to Rule 66(a) by Act 104 of 1976), the executing court had a duty to consider whether the entire property needed to be sold or only a part sufficient to meet the decree. Because the court did not apply its mind to that obligation and proceeded to sell the whole parcel as one lot, the sale was contrary to the obligations imposed by law.
  4. Non-application of mind and material irregularity: The Court found that the executing court failed to take into account the petitioners' objections and the valuation material; it allowed the sale to proceed without considering that a modest balance remained payable and that sale of the whole (ten acres) produced an inadequate return in relation to declared value. The failure to give notice and the failure to limit the sale established material irregularity and illegality.
  5. Effect of prior procedural rulings: The Court noted the prior High Court direction in C.R.P. No. 81 of 1990 that the Section 47 application must be decided on merits and that issuance of a Sale Certificate does not preclude consideration on merits. Having regard to that direction and to the subsequent order in C.R.P. No. 1194 of 1991 (that successful petitioners under Section 47 are entitled to restitution), the Court concluded that petitioners were entitled to relief without the need for further application.
  6. Relief and consequential orders: Having concluded the sale was without jurisdiction and tainted with material irregularity, the Court set aside the order of the executing Court and allowed the revision. The Court directed immediate restitution of possession, assessed costs in this Court, and left quantification of profits to the executing Court once petitioners have been put back in possession.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The Civil Revision Petition is allowed; the execution sale was set aside as being conducted without jurisdiction and tainted by material irregularity and illegality.

Direct consequences and orders made by the Court (as stated in the opinion):

  • The order of the executing Court dismissing the petitioners' application was set aside and the revision was allowed.
  • The respondents (including the auction-purchaser) are directed to hand over possession of the property to the petitioners within two weeks from the date of the order; if they fail to do so, the executing Court is directed, on production of a copy of this order or receipt of it, to ensure the petitioners are put in possession without further delay.
  • The executing Court must comply with this order within 15 days of receiving a copy and forward a compliance report to this Court.
  • Costs were awarded to the petitioners: the Court quantified costs in the High Court at Rs. 1,000 and ordered costs also for the Court below (costs to be paid by the respondents).
  • The respondents, having taken possession under a sale that the Court held illegal, are liable for profits; quantification of profits is left to the executing Court after restitution is effected.
  • The auction-purchaser is permitted to withdraw the amount deposited in Court.

Broader legal implication (as reflected in the opinion): the decision applies established principles (including mandatory notice under Order 21, Rule 66(2), and the obligation under Order 21, Rule 64 to sell only so much property as is necessary to satisfy the decree) to the facts of this case; the Court set aside the sale on those established grounds. The opinion does not purport to create novel legal principles but applies and follows the precedents it cites.

KA/RR/VCS
Show all summary ...

This Revision Petition is by the judgment-debtors in O.S No. 211 of 1973, on the file of Sub Court, Sankari.

2. First respondent herein, as plaintiff filed the above suit for recovery of the amount due on a promissory note. The suit was decreed, and to recover the amount, Execution Petition No. 28 of 1985 was filed. Even though the Execution Petition was for recovery of the principal amount of Rs. 15,000/- and interest thereon, pending Execution Petition itself, petitioners paid Rs. 28,500/-, towards the decree debt. At that time, Execution Petition was pending before Sub Court, Salem. When a new Sub Court was constituted at Sankari, the Execution Petition was transferred to that Court and sale was held on 22-11-1985. On the date of sale, the balance amount payable to the decree-holder as per the Execution Petition was only Rs. 1,887/-. It is the case of the petitioners that they are entitled to the benefit of Act 40 of 1979 and, therefore, the petitioners are liable to pay only the actual principal amount of Rs. 15,000/- and Rs. 7,500/- as interest. Since they have already paid more than that amount, they were under the bona fide belief that they need not pay any amount, and it was their further case that the decree-holder cannot pursue the execution. The entire debt, according to them, was wiped out. It is said that the property was purchased by decree holder's brother's son, who is also a member of the joint family. Therefore, the purchase is by the decree-holder himself, though in the name of another member, the same is without sanction of Court and hence invalid. It is further said that the decree-holder filed R.C.A No. 421 of 1985 for sale of all the properties for the same upset price without notice to the counsel or to the petitioners. It was at that time, the said proceedings were transferred to the Sub Court at Sankari and re-numbered as E.A No. 7 of 1985. Without notice to the petitioners or their counsel, R.E.A No. 421 of 1985 was allowed, and the property was directed to be sold. There was no fresh Proclamation. Order 21, Rule 66, C.P.C has been violated. More than 10 and odd acres of property, the value of which will be more than Rs. 2 lakhs, was sold for a paltry amount. Even if any amount is payable to the decree-holder, the entire property need not be sold. Even if a small portion of the property was sold, the decree debt could have been discharged. The executing Court also did not apply its mind while selling 10 and odd acres. The petitioners came to know about the same only long thereafter. The entire proceedings in execution, i.e, the conduct of sale was fraudulent and void in law. The same is also without jurisdiction. They seek a declaration that the sale is invalid.

3. Both the decree holder as well as the auction-purchaser have filed separate objections, but on the same lines. It is their case that all the proceedings have been taken in accordance with law, and they have not played any fraud either on Court or on the petitioners. It is their further cease that the petitioners have given notice of the R.E.A 421 of 1985 for fresh sale of the petitioners' properties. It is their further case that when the petitioners have received notice of such an application it is their duty to watch the further proceedings. When the proceedings were transferred to Sub Court, Sankari and re-numbered as R.E.A No. 7 of 1985, the petitioners did not care to file any objection. Therefore, the sale was ordered to take place. The contention that they did not have any opportunity to contest the case is also denied. It is their further case that no fresh notice under O. 21, R. 66, C.P.C need be issued when the Execution Petition is transferred to another court. Regarding the contention that only a small portion of the property could have been sold to satisfy the decree, the objection is that there is only one item of property and the same could be sold only as one lot. Even if the decree amount is small, the entire property is liable to be sold. It is their case that when the property was brought to sale it cannot be split up after settlement of proclamation, even if the judgment-debtors had paid a major portion of the amount. It is their case that the judgment-debtors ought to have taken steps to have the property split up when the property was brought to sale. They prayed for dismissal of the application.

4. Originally, the Application was dismissed by the executing Court as not maintainable on the ground that the Sale Certificate has already been issued, and nothing survives in execution. The executing Court was of the view that the validity of the sale cannot be a matter in issue after the sale was confirmed and the Sale Certificate has been issued to the decree-holder on the auction-purchase. That order was challenged before this Court in C.R.P No. 81 of 1990. V. Ratnam, J., as he then was, set aside the order on 8-3-1990. (reported in this issue at Page 373) This Court held that since the application was under S. 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure the executing Court should have decided the matter on merits. It was further found that if the sale is set aside, the issuance of a Sale Certificate is of no consequences and the technical reasoning given by the Executing Court cannot be sustained. The Executing Court was directed to restore the application filed by the petitioners and decide the matter afresh.

5. Pursuant to the said order, the Execution Petition was restored. But in the meanwhile, the auction purchaser filed an application praying that he may be issued a Sale Certificate. That was allowed. After getting the Sale Certificate, the auction purchaser filed an application that he may be allowed to take possession of the property. Even though the same was seriously objected by the petitioners, their objection was overruled and delivery was ordered. Against the said order, the petitioners filed C.R.P No. 1194 of 1991, on the file of this Court. Srinivasan, J. as he then was, as per order dated 28-6-1991, dismissed the Civil Revision Petition holding that there is no jurisdictional error in passing the order. Even before the Civil Revision Petition was filed, it was represented by learned counsel for the respondents that the property has been taken delivery through Court on 19-4-1991, and the Revision Petition was filed only a week later. The said submission was also recorded by the learned Judge while dismissing the Revision Petition. This Court was careful enough in safeguarding the interest of the judgment-debtor by directing the Executing Court to dispose of their application to set aside the sale, on or before 30-8-1991, and report to this Court about the compliance of that direction. The learned judge further declared thus:

“… If the petitioners succeed in the application under S. 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure they will be certainly entitled to get back possession by way of restitution …. …. …”

With the above observation, the said revision was dismissed.

6. After the disposal of the said Revision Petition, the Executing Court took evidence, both oral and documentary. Thereafter, by the impugned order, it dismissed the application once again. It is that order that is challenged in this revision.

7. While dismissing the application R.E.A No. 179 of 1986, Executing Court held that the application which was filed before the Subordinate Judge's Court, Sankari, itself was not maintainable. It was of the view that the sale was conducted by the Subordinate Judge's Court, Salem. It was further held that the question whether the auction purchaser was entitled to get possession of the property or not, or whether the sale is invalid, really does not arise in execution, once the Sale Certificate is issued. It was further held that R.E.A No. 179 of 1986 was filed suppressing the fact of confirmation of sale. According to the Executing Court, only that Court which conducts the sale can consider the validity, and, therefore, the application is not maintainable. The same was dismissed with costs. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the order of the Court below is perverse, and an interference under Section 115, C.P.C is necessary. Learned counsel submitted that the lower court has not taken note of the admitted facts or the records that were available before that Court. The observation by the lower Court that the sale was conducted by the Subordinate Judge's Court, Salem, is patently wrong. The sale was conducted only by the Court which passed the impugned order. The further finding of the Court below that once the sale is confirmed, the provisions of Section 47, or Order 21, Rule 90 C.P.C need not be considered, as against the provisions of law, and also against the order in C.R.P No. 81 of 1990 which directed that court to decide the matter on merits. It is further contended by learned counsel that when more than 95% of the decree debt has been discharged, 10 and odd acres of property need not be sold for recovery of a paltry amount of only Rs. 1,500/-. Even as per the valuation given by the decree holder, the property is worth more than Rs. 50,000/- only that much extent of property that is required for satisfying the decree should nave been sold. The executing court did not apply its mind in that regard. It was further contended, that originally the execution petition was pending before Subordinate Judge's Court, Salem, and after the same was transferred to another court due to change of territorial jurisdiction and the sale was conducted after 30 days, the entire proceedings is a nullity. From the transferred court, no notice has been served on the petitioners and if such a notice had been sent to them, they could have at least made an attempt to settle the transaction. That opportunity was also not given to them.

8. All these contentions were opposed by learned counsel for the respondents. According to them, the proceeding was taken in accordance with law. The question whether the entire property should have been sold, or only a portion of it should have been sold, is a matter which the petitioners ought to have urged at the time of sale, and having failed to raise such a question at the appropriate time, that cannot be a ground for setting aside the sale. Learned counsel further submitted that no fresh proclamation is required, since it was only a continuation of the earlier proceedings.

9. Having considered the rival submissions I am of the view that the contention of the petitioners has to succeed. I state the reasons hereunder.

10. The following properties have been brought to sale:—

The total area comes to more than ten acres. From the proclamation schedule, which is marked as Ex. C-3, I do not find that the property has been encumbered in any way. Even at the time of original proclamation, i.e, at a time when more than Rs. 28,000/- was due, the decree holder declared the value of all the properties at Rs. 50,000/-. The Amin who was deputed to assess the value of the property also fixed the value of the property at Rs. 50,000/-. In one of the counters to the execution petition, the judgment-debtors contended that the value of the property will be more than Rupees Two lakhs. That is in R.E.P No. 180 of 1992. It was long thereafter, the Execution Petition was transferred to the Subordinate Judge's Court, Sankari. But the value of the judgment-debtors was not incorporated. The proclamation was allowed to be settled without taking into consideration the objection of the judgment-debtors.

11. Even though the amount mentioned in the original Execution Petition when the same was filed before the Subordinate Judge's Court, Salem was more than Rs. 28,000/-, a major portion of the amount was already paid, and, from the records of the case, it is seen that the petitioners have paid a total amount of Rs. 28,500/-. It is the case of the petitioners that since they are entitled to the benefits of Act 17 of 1979, they are bound to pay only half the interest, thus totalling Rs. 22,500/-, excluding the costs. Since that amount had ready been fully paid, they were under the belief that nothing more need be paid, and the decree-holder has also agreed not to proceed with the Execution Petition. Even if that part of the contention has not been proved, according to the decree-holder's own showing, the balance amount payable when the decree was transferred to Sub Court, Sankari was only Rs. 1,487/-. On the basis of the very same proclamation, and on the basis of the very same valuation, the decree-holder wanted sale of the property. He filed R.E.A No. 421 of 1965 for the said purpose before Sub Court, Salem. The same was transferred to Sub Court, Sankari. Since no objection was filed by the petitioners, the same was allowed. From the evidence in this case, it is seen that the sale was ordered on 11-9-1985 and therefore the sale was conducted on 21.11.1985 There was no fresh settlement of proclamation pursuant to the order in R.E.A No. 421 of 1985 (renumbered as R.E.A 7 of 1985). After the transfer to the Subordinate Judge's Court, Sankari, no notice had been served on the petitioners either regarding the date or time of sale. The entire 10 and odd acres of land was sold in one lot since the petitioners were not present at the time of sale. The Court also did not apply its mind whether the entire property has to be sold or a portion of it will be sufficient to satisfy the decree debt. Under the Code of Civil Procedure, Order 21, Rule 64, onwards, deals with the Procedure for sale of immovable property. Order 21, Rule 66 sub-rule (2), C.P.C says thus:—

“Such proclamation shall be drawn up after notice to the decree-holder and judgment-debtor and shall state the time and place of sale, and specify as accurately as possible— (a) the property to be sold (or, where a part of the property, would be sufficient to satisfy the decree, such part) (b) to (d)******(e) every thing which the Court considers material for a purchaser to know in order to judge of the nature and value of the property.”

Rule 69 of Order 21. C.P.C deals with adjourment and stoppage of sale. Along with the same, the Court also will have to take into consideration the provisions of Order 21, Rule 90, C.P.C Even if the grounds mentioned in Order 21, Rule 90, C.P.C are not proved, if it is made out that there had been a contravention of law in the conduct of the sale, de hors Order 21, Rule 90, C.P.C, the sale has to be set aside under Sec. 47, C.P.C

12. While narrating the facts I have already said that the Execution Petition was transferred from one Court to another, not in the same place, but in a different taluk. The transfer was made due to bifurcation of Districts, for administrative reasons, and not on application of parties. When a new Sub Court was formed, certain suits were transferred to that Court. Naturally, that Court was bound to issue notice to the judgment-debtors that their case has also been transferred, and Execution Petition will be proceeded by that Court. Unfortunately that procedure was not adopted in this case. After sale was ordered in R.E.A No. 421 of 1985 (renumbered as R.E.A No. 7 of 1985), a duty was cast on that Court to issue notice under Order, 21, Rule 66, C.P.C That procedure was also not adopted. A sale without notice under O. 21, R. 66 C.P.C is always declared as a nullity and as a matter without jurisdiction. In a very recent decision of the Supreme Court reported in (1994) I SCC 131 = 1994-1-L.W. 49 (Desk Bandhu Gupta v. N.I Anand Rajinder Singh), their Lordships held thus:—

“Service of notice on judgment-debtor under Order 21 Rule 66 (2), unless waived by appearance or retained ex parte, is fundamental step in the procedure of the Court in execution. Judgement-debtor should have an opportunity to give his estimate of the property. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 66 enjoins the Court that the details enumerated in sub-rule (2) shall be specified as fairly and accurately as possible. The duty to “comply with it arises only after service of the notice on the judgment-debtor unless he voluntarily appears and is given opportunity in the settlement of the value of the property. The absence of notice causes irremedial injury to the judgment-debtor. Equally publication of the proclamation of sale under Rule 67 and specifying the date and place of sale of the property under Rule 66 (2) are intended that the prospective bidders would know the value so as to make up their mind to offer the price and to attend at sale of the property and to secure competitive bidders and fair price to the property sold. Absence of notice to the judgment debtor disables him to offer his estimate of the value who better knows its value and to publicise on his part, canvassing and bringing the intending bidders at the time of sale. Absence of notice prevents him to do the above and also disables him to know fraud committed in the publication and conduct of sale or other material irregularities in the conduct of sale. It would be broached from yet another angle. The compulsory sale of immovable property under Order 21 divests right, title and interest of the judgment-debtor and confers those rights in favour of the purchaser. It thereby deals with the rights and disabilities either of the judgment-debtor or the decree-holder. A sale made, therefore, without notice to the judgment-debtor is a nullity since it divests the judgment-debtor of his right, title and interest in his property without an opportunity. The jurisdiction to sell the property would arise in a court only where the owner is given notice of the execution for attachment and sale of his property. It is very salutory that a person's property cannot be sold without his being told that it is being so sold and given an opportunity to offer his estimate as he is the person who intimately know the value of his property and prevailng in the locality through exaggeration may at time be possible. Therefore, notice under Order 21 Rule 66(2), unless proviso is applied if not already issued under Order 21 Rule 22, and service is mandatory. The omission thereof renders the further action and the sale in pursuance thereof void unless the judgment-debtor appears without notice and thereby waives the service of notice.”

(Emphasis supplied)

That itself will be sufficient for setting aside the sale.

13. For other reasons also, the sale cannot stand in this case. I have already said that even according to the decree-holder, the value of the property was Rs. 50,000/- at the time when the entire decree amount was payable to him. No sale was conducted, and more than 1-1/2 years thereafter, the entire property has been sold when the decree is executed only for Rs. 1,487/-. The same proclamation was made use of for the purpose of sale. In view of the amendment to Order 21, Rule 66 (a), C.P.C (extracted supra), as Act 104 of 1976, a duty is cast on the Court to verify whether the entire property has to be sold, or a sale of only a portion of it will be sufficient to meet the decree amount. In this case, admittedly, that procedure was not adopted. The decree holder himself has admitted in his counter that since the entire property is one lot and it was shown in the proclamation for sale, the same was sold as such, even though a major portion of the decree amount had already been paid. He accuses the judgment-debtors for not demarcating the entire property into plots.

14. I cannot agree with the contention of the decree-holder in that regard. Even if the judgment-debtor did not object to the procedure, the court cannot remain silent when the law casts a duty on it. In taking this view, I am supported by the decision reported in (1977) 3 S.C.C 337 = 90 L.W 124. S.N (Takkaseela Pedda Subba Reddi v. Pujati Padmavathamma and others) wherein it was held thus:—

“Even though the decree-holder had obtained the second decree before the sale, he did not approach the Court for amending the decretal amount mentioned in the sale proclamation to include both the decrees, so, under the provisions of Order 21, Rule 64 of the Code when the amount as specified in the sale proclamation was fully satisfied by the sale of the first set of properties the Court should have stopped the sale of further items of the properties. It is manifest that where the amount specified in the proclamation of sale for the recovery of which the sale was ordered is realised by sale of contain items, the sale of further items should be stopped. Under Order 21, Rule 64 the Executing Court derives jurisdiction to sell properties attached only to the point at which the decree is fully satisfied. The words “necessary to satisfy the decree” clearly indicate that no sale can be allowed beyond the decretal amount mentioned in the sale proclamation.

The fact that the judgment-debtor did not raise an objection on this ground before the Executing Court is not sufficient to put him out of Court because this was a matter which went to the very root of the jurisdiction of the Executing Court to sell the properties and the non-compliance with the provisions of Order 21, Rule 64 of the Code was sufficient to vitiate the same so far as further items of properties were concerned”

(Emphasis supplied).

The above decision was followed the Supreme Court in 1989 Sup. (2) S.C.C 693 = 1991-1-L.W. 602 = AIR 1990 S.C 119 (Ambatti Narasayya v. Subba Rao and another), wherein (in para 7) their Lordships said thus:—

“It is of importance to note from this provision that in all execution proceedings, the court has to first decide whether it is necessary to bring the entire satisfy property to sale or such portion thereof as may seen necessary to atta the decree. If the property “is large and the decree to be satisfied is small, the court must bring only such portion of the property, the proceeds to which would be sufficient to satisfy the claim of the decree holder. It is immaterial whether the property is one or several. Even if the property is one, if a separate portion could be sold without violating any provision of law on, such portion of the property should be sold. This, in our opinion, is not just a discretion, both and obligation imposed on the court. Care must be taken to put only such portion of the property to sale the consideration of which is sufficient to meet the claim in the execution petition. The sale held without examining this aspect and not in conformity with this requirement would be illegal and without jurisdiction.”

15. The decision reported in 1989 Sup. (2) S.C.C 693 = AIR 1990 S.C 119 = 1991-1-L.W. 602 (supra was followed by the (Kerala High Court in the decisions reported in (1995) 1 K.L.T 495 (Karimbal Ice & Cold Storage Co. and another v. SSBT and another) and also in 1990-I-Kerala Law Times page 319 (Parvathy Antharjanan v. Indian Bank).

16. In view of the above settled principles of law, the contention of the decree-holder that since the judgment debtors failed to have the property divided in lots, the entire property is liable to be sold cannot stand. In this case, that question cannot arise in view of my finding on the earlier point that the judgment-debtors were not given any notice by anyone regarding the date and time of sale. Even the Court before which they should appear was not known to them. The conduct of the judgment-debtors also makes me to believe that if only an opportunity had been given to them, they would have settled the entire matter. More than 95% of the decree debt has been paid by them within a short period of one year after the Execution Petition was filed. When the balance due was a paltry sum of Rs. 1,487/-, they would not have hesitated to wipe off the decree debt, to save the entire ten acres of land. It is an unenumbered agricultural property belonging to the family. The decree-holder should have taken steps to issue notice to the judgment-debtors when the property was sold by the transferee Court. When the Court has failed to discharge this duty, the party should not suffer on account of the same.

17. The sale was conducted violating the provisions of law and, therefore, it was one without jurisdiction. Because, the judgment-debtors were not given opportunity to pay the amount, to avoid the sale, it cannot but be held that they were put to irreparale loss and the sale is tainted with material irregularity and illegality.

18. The Court below has not taken into consideration any of the above facts, and dismissed the Application on irrelevant considerations. I set aside the order of the Court below and allow the Revision.

19. I have already said that Srinivasan, J., as he then was, in C.R.P No. 1194 of 1991, has held that if the application under another Section 47, C.P.C is allowed, the petitioner will be entitled to get restitution. That order binds the parties to the proceedings. In view of the said order, I hold that the petitioners will be entitled to get possession of the property even without a further application. The respondents have in the earlier proceedings, admitted that they have dispossessed the judgment-debtors on 19-4-1991. This Court has taken note of the said statement, and that was the reason for dismissal of the Civil Revision Petition. Now they cannot turn round and say that they did not obtain possession. They are bound to hand over possession of the property forthwith. Since they have taken possession of the property under sale which is held to be illegal and without jurisdiction, they are also liable for profits, which is to be ascertained by the Executing Court.

20. In the result, the Civil Revision Petition is allowed with costs before this Court well as in the Court below. In this Court I quantify the costs at Rs. 1,000/. The respondents herein are direct to hand over possession of the property to the petitioners within two weeks from to-day, and in case they failed to do so, the Court below on production of a copy of this order, by the petitioners, or on receipt of the copy of this order from this Court shall see that the petitioners herein are in possession of the property in question without any further delay. The Order will have to be complied with by the Court below within 15 days from the date of receipt of the copy of this order, and a compliance report should be forwarded to this Court without fail. The question of quantifying the profits can wait till the petitioners are put in possession of the property as directed above. The auction-purchaser is permitted to withdraw the amount deposited in Court.

KA/RR/VCS