- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
A. Krishna Rao Petitioner v. L.S Kumar
Factual and Procedural Background
The third accused in CC No. 274 of 1994 before the Judicial Magistrate No. II, Wallajapet, filed a Criminal Original Petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C seeking to quash further proceedings in the said case. The complainant, Kumar, initially lodged a complaint at SIPCOT Police Station, Ranipet, resulting in the registration of Crime No. 389/94 under Sections 323, 341, and 506(2) of the IPC. The police investigated and filed a final report on 9.12.1994 categorizing the case as a 'Mistake of fact.' The Magistrate forwarded the complaint for investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C and, after receiving the police report, sent a memo and notice to the complainant. The complainant did not object but subsequently filed a second private complaint concerning the same occurrence, which was taken on file as CC No. 274 of 1994. The petitioner contended that the Magistrate should not have taken cognizance of this second complaint after accepting the police report in the first case.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Magistrate was justified in taking cognizance of the second complaint relating to the same occurrence after having accepted the police report categorizing the first complaint as a 'Mistake of fact.'
- Whether the proceedings in the second complaint (CC No. 274 of 1994) are maintainable in law.
- The legal effect of a Magistrate accepting a police report under Section 173(2) Cr.P.C and the implications for subsequent complaints on the same facts.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The police had already investigated the first complaint and filed a final report categorizing it as a 'Mistake of fact.'
- The Magistrate, having accepted the police report and passed orders accordingly, should not have taken cognizance of the second complaint concerning the same occurrence.
- The second complaint is not maintainable as it amounts to a repetition of the same matter already investigated and disposed of.
- Supported their position by citing precedents where courts quashed second complaints after acceptance of police reports under Section 156(3) and 173(2) Cr.P.C.
Respondent's Arguments
- Relied on the decision in Manoharbal v. Vashdev, asserting that a Magistrate sending a complaint for enquiry under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C does not take cognizance at that stage.
- Argued that acceptance of a police report stating the complaint as false or mistake of fact does not amount to a judicial order, and thus the Magistrate may entertain a second complaint on the same occurrence.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Murugesan v. Kothandam, 1969 L.W Crl. 268 | When a Sub-Inspector investigates under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C and submits report under Section 173(2) Cr.P.C, subsequent complaints on the same occurrence are not maintainable. | The Court applied this principle to hold the second complaint was not maintainable as the police had already investigated and submitted the report. |
| Ramasubbu v. State, 1987 L.W Crl. 79 | Magistrate’s option under Section 173(3) Cr.P.C to accept or reject police report; once accepted as mistake of fact, second complaint not maintainable. | The Court relied on this to conclude that acceptance of the police report barred entertaining the second complaint. |
| Ansari v. Mohammed Ali, 1990 L.W Crl. 201 | Taking cognizance of a second complaint on the same facts without awaiting police report is not maintainable. | Referenced to support the non-maintainability of the second complaint in the instant case. |
| Mariaglory v. John Britto, 1995 (1) L.W Crl. 305 | Once Magistrate accepts police report, taking cognizance of second complaint on same occurrence is illegal. | Applied to reinforce the conclusion that the second complaint was invalid. |
| Manoharbal v. Vashdev, 1983 L.W (Crl.) 319 | Sending complaint for enquiry under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C does not amount to cognizance; Magistrate may entertain second complaint if no judicial order passed. | The Court noted this contrary view but distinguished it from the facts of the instant case where the Magistrate accepted the police report. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the sequence of events and the applicable statutory provisions, particularly Sections 156(3), 173(2), and 173(3) of the Cr.P.C. The police had investigated the first complaint and submitted a final report categorizing it as a 'Mistake of fact.' The Magistrate, by issuing notices and not raising objections from the complainant, was deemed to have accepted the police report as a judicial order. The Court emphasized that once the Magistrate accepts such a report, he cannot entertain a second complaint on the same occurrence. The Court acknowledged the respondent’s reliance on Manoharbal v. Vashdev but found it distinguishable because in the present case the Magistrate had accepted the police report, thereby passing a judicial order. The Court followed the consistent line of precedents which hold that subsequent complaints after acceptance of a police report on the same facts are not maintainable. Accordingly, the Court held that the proceedings in the second complaint were legally untenable and liable to be quashed.
Holding and Implications
The Court held that the second complaint pending as CC No. 274 of 1994 before the Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Wallajapet, is not maintainable and quashed the proceedings therein.
The direct consequence of this decision is the termination of the second complaint proceedings against the petitioner. The Court did not set any new precedent but reaffirmed established legal principles regarding the non-maintainability of subsequent complaints after acceptance of police reports by a Magistrate.
1. The third accused in CC. No. 274 of 1994 on the file of the Judicial Magistrate No. II, Wallajapet has filed this Crl. Original petition under Sections 482 Cr.P.C to quash further proceedings in the said case.
2. The main averments in the petition are that the complainant one Kumar preferred a complaint against the petitioner and others before the SIPCOT Police Station at Ranipet and a receipt in F.D.R No. 1 10 of 1993 has been issued to him by the Police. As the police have not taken any further action on the said complaint, the complainant filed a private complaint before the Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Wallajapet and the learned Magistrate has forwarded the said complaint to the police under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C for investigation and report. The police registered a case in Crime No. 389/94 under Sections 323,341 and 506 (2), I.P.C and after investigation filed the final report on 9.12.94 referring the case as ‘Mistake of fact’ Learned Magistrated sent a memo along with the RCS Notice and the complainant did not file any objection and on the contrary he has filed another private complaint on 15.12.94 and the same was taken on file by the said Court in CC No. 274 of 1994. As the police had already investigated the case and the matter had been referred to as ‘Mistake of fact’, the Magistrate ought not to have taken cognizance of the second complaint. In such circumstances, the proceedings in the second complaint, which is pending in CC. No. 274 of 1994 on the file of the Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Wallajapet, has to be quashed.
3. It was argued on the side of the third accused/petitioner that since the referred charge sheet has been filed by the police in the earlier complaint given by the complainant and after passing the orders on the referred charge sheet, the second complaint filed in respect of the same occurrence is not maintainable to substantiate this argument, the 3rd accused/petitioner has submitted some decisions of this Court.
In Murugesan v. Kothandam, 1969 L.W Crl. 268 this Court in similar circumstances quashed the proceedings in the second complaint stating that when the Sub-Inspector has investigated the case under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C and submitted his report under Section 173(2), Cr.P.C referring the case and subsequent complaint for the very same occurrence would not be maintainable.
In Ramasubbu v. State, The Through The Inspector of Police? Palani Taluk, 1987 L.W Crl. 79 this Court held that when the police was filed a report under Section 173, Cr.P.C, the Magistrate got the option under Section 173(3), Cr.P.C either to agree or to disagree and to give further direction to the police. When once the Magistrate has recorded his findings as mistake of fact in the R.C.S which is a judicial order, thereafter he cannot entertain the second complaint and if entertained the same is not maintainable.
In the instant case the police have already referred the case as mistake of fact and notice has been served on the complainant through Court and he did not raise any objection. When this matter was argued, it was not pointed out on the side of the respondent/complainant that he raised any objection or the learned Magistrate has not accepted the report of the police. If the learned Magistrate has not accepted the report, he would have given further directing in the matter and the very reasons that the magistrate has received the second complaint, would go to show that he has not given any further direction in in the R.C.S which means that he has accepted the same and passed an order accordingly. When once such an order was passed by the learned Magistrate, it was not open to him to entertain one mere complaint regarding the same occurrence.
In Ansari v. Mohammed Ali, 1990 L.W Crl. 201 in similar circumstances when the Magistrate has referred the complaint under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C for investigation, and without obtaining the report of the police, has taken cognizance in the second complaint on the same materials, by referring the decision stated in Murugesan v. Kothandam, 1969 L.W (Crl.) 268 this Court held that the said complaint could be taken as a second complaint for the same occurrence and therefore not maintainable.
In the instant case, the police have already filed a R.C.S on the complaint referred to them under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C and the learned Magistrate has taken cognizance of the 2nd complaint for the very same occurrence and therefore the 2nd complaint is not maintainable.
In Mariaglory v. John Britto, 1995 (1) L.W Crl. 305 this Court held that when once the Magistrate has accepted the report of the police, taking cognizance in the second complaint for every same occurrence is illegal.
In the present case from the averments found in the petition it is clear that the learned Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Wallajapet has passed the order on the R.C.S served by the police in the previous complaint which was referred by him to the police under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C for investigation. There is no contrary evidence on the side of the complaint respondent herein. When once the Magistrate has passed the order on the R.C.S the second complaint for the very same occurrence is not maintainable.
4. Learned counsel for the respondent relied upon a decision of this Court is Manoharbal v. Vashdev 1983 L.W (Crl.) 319 wherein it was held that when a Magistrate sends a complaint for enquiry under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C, he does not take cognizance of the case, that consequently when he receives the report stating that the complaint should be referred either as false or as mistake of fact or mistake of law, he does not pass any judicial order, but merely lodges the complaint and does not take any further action and in such circumstances, there is no bar in law for the Magistrate to entertain a second complaint and take cognizance of it and issue process to the accused. The view expressed by this Court herein is somewhat contrary to the views expressed in the decisions stated supra.
In the present case, the police have filed the referred charge sheet as ‘mistake of fact’. it seems the Magistrate has accepted the R.C.S It is not the case of the respondent herein that the Magistrate has not accepted the R.C.s filed by the police. In such circumstances, when the Magistrate has accepted the R.C.S the second complaint should be filed only after setting aside the order passed by the learned Magistrate in the referred chargesheet. However, the respondent herein has not taken any such action and instead had filed a second complaint which the learned Magistrate has taken cognizance. It has been held in the above decisions that taking cognizance in the second complaint, makes the same not maintainable. I have no hesitation to follow the said view, and as such it has to be held that the second complaint which is pending before the learned Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Wallajapet, in CC No. 274 of 1994 is not maintainable and the proceedings have to be quashed.
5. In the result this Criminal Original Petition is allowed and the proceedings in CC No. 274 of 1994 on the file of the Judicial Magistrate No. 2 Wallajapet, are quashed.
Alert