- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
St. John'S Teacher Training Institute For Women v. State Of Tamil Nadu
Judgment Summary — Swamidurai, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff-appellant is St. John's Teacher Training Institute for Women, represented by its correspondent S. Jayaraj. The institute was established on 27.9.1985. The plaintiff filed O.S. No. 776 of 1986 in the District Munsif Court, Ambasamudram seeking a declaration that the institute is a minority school protected under Article 30(1) of the Constitution, that an order passed by educational authorities dated 10.12.1985 is invalid, and a direction to allow its students to write the examinations.
The plaintiff's pleaded facts included: the founder Jayaraj is a Christian; there was no teacher training institute within a 32 km radius; the institute admitted women students (allegedly 80% Christian), ran a hostel and taught the Bible; applications and examination fees were submitted but the 4th defendant refused to accept the applications alleging the school was unrecognised; and the plaintiff alleged that rules framed under Tamil Nadu Act 29/74 and related government circulars curtailed its constitutional rights.
The defendants contested minority status and other factual averments, relied on statutory rules (including R.4(3) of the Tamil Nadu Minority Schools (Recognition and Payment of Grant) Rules, 1977), and defended the refusal to grant recognition. The trial court (District Munsif) decreed the suit. The defendants appealed (O.S. No. 18/86) to the Subordinate Judge, Tenkasi, which allowed the appeal, set aside the trial court decree and dismissed the suit. The plaintiff thereafter filed this second appeal to the High Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the civil courts have jurisdiction to entertain and decide a suit seeking a declaration that an educational institution is a minority institution, in view of Section 53 of the Tamil Nadu Recognised Private Schools (Regulation) Act, 1973.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (for the plaintiff)
- The appellant argued that Section 53 of the 1973 Act does not oust the civil court's jurisdiction to entertain a suit declaring an institution to be a minority institution.
- Counsel contended that Act 29/74 contains no machinery to determine minority character and thus civil courts remain competent to decide such declarations.
- Evidence was advanced to show the founder's Christian identity (Exs. A.1 Baptism certificate and A.2 marriage certificate), the institution's administration by Jayaraj, conduct of Bible classes, closure on Christian festivals, and that a sister school (St. John Middle School) already enjoyed minority status.
- Counsel relied on numerous judicial decisions to support the proposition that civil courts can grant declarations of minority status and that institutions founded and administered by minorities are entitled to constitutional protection under Article 30(1).
- It was contended that the appellate court wrongly rejected the evidence of P.W.1 (the founder) as interested testimony without reason.
Respondent's Arguments (for the defendants)
- The defendants asserted the plaintiff is not a minority institution and is not entitled to prepare students for Government diploma examinations in teacher training.
- They disputed factual claims regarding student strength and the existence of a hostel.
- The defendants relied on R.4(3) of the 1977 Rules to contend that institutions opened without departmental permission must apply for recognition within three months and that certain conditions for recognition are prescribed; the plaintiff's application was rejected in departmental proceedings for stated reasons.
- They referred to a government circular restricting practical training for students of unrecognised institutions and submitted the 1977 Rules do not offend Article 20(1) (sic — as mentioned in the opinion) or Act 29/74 and are not ultra vires.
- The defence also raised a procedural objection that the suit was liable to be dismissed for want of valid notice under Section 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sekhara Pillai v. Government Of Tamil Nadu, 1992-2 L.W. 143 | Cited for the proposition that a school established and administered by a minority falls within the statutory definition of a minority school and is entitled to declaratory relief. | Cited by appellant; the judgment's reasoning (as quoted) was relied upon by counsel in support of entitlement to a declaration. The court accepted the appellant's line of authorities in overturning the lower appellate court. |
| State Of Kerala & Ors. v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial & Ors., AIR 1970 S.C. 2079 | Cited by appellant in support of the broader principle that minority institutions enjoy protection under Article 30 and that courts can adjudicate relevant declarations. | Placed before the court by appellant's counsel as supporting authority; the court found no contrary binding authority presented by respondents and restored the trial court decree. |
| State of Punjab v. Dewan Chunilal, AIR 1971 S.C. 2086 | Cited by appellant to support the position regarding minority rights and institutional recognition under constitutional protections. | Relied on by appellant's counsel; the court noted the line of decisions cited and concluded the lower appellate decision was not according to law and facts. |
| D.A.V. College, Jullundur v. State of Punjab, AIR 1971 S.C. 1737 | Cited to support the proposition that institutions established/ administered by minorities are entitled to constitutional protection and declaratory relief. | Cited by appellant; included among authorities the court considered in reaching the result that restored the trial court judgment. |
| A.P. Christians Medical Educational Society v. Government of A.P., 1986 (2) S.C.J. 594 | Cited to support the appellant's contention on minority status and related reliefs under Article 30. | Cited by appellant's counsel; the court accepted the appellant's reliance on authorities and found the lower appellate decision unsound. |
| Vice Chancellor, L.N. Mithila University v. Dayanandjha, 1982 (2) S.C.J. 605 | Cited in support of the appellant's submissions regarding rights of educational institutions and declarations. | Presented by appellant; treated as part of the body of authority favoring the appellant's position. |
| R.M.B.T. School v. State (1973 Ker. 87) | Cited by appellant as supportive precedent concerning minority institution issues. | Listed among the decisions relied on by appellant; the court proceeded to restore the trial court decree in the absence of a respondent authority to the contrary. |
| N. Prameswara Kurup v. State, AIR 1986 Mad 126 | Cited by appellant on minority-institution related legal principles. | Cited by appellant and noted by the court in its consideration of authorities relied upon. |
| Virendra Nath Gupta & Another v. Delhi Administration & Others, J.T. 1990 (1) S.C. 403 | Cited by appellant in support of the contention that civil courts can grant declarations pertaining to institutional status and related reliefs. | Included in the list of authorities relied upon by appellant; the court found the appellant's line of authorities persuasive in concluding for restoration of the trial court's judgment. |
| Unreported: W.P. No. 3754/91 — The Congregation of the Sisters of St. Annem v. The Joint Director of School Education (Secondary), Madras (High Court, dated 8.4.91) | Cited for the proposition that once a High Court recognises an institution or a management as minority, it may not be necessary to obtain a separate civil court declaration for every new school started by that agency. | Cited by appellant to argue that repeated declarations for each institution are unnecessary; the court referenced this principle in the appellant's submissions. |
| W.P. No. 19419/90 dated 3.9.1991 — His Holiness Srilasri Kasi... v. State of Tamil Nadu | Cited to support the contention that the government need not insist upon a separate declaration for each school when the managing agency's minority character is established. | Relied upon by appellant; the court recorded this authority among those supporting the appellant's position and found the lower appellate decision unsustainable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The High Court examined the substantial question of law whether Section 53 of the Tamil Nadu Recognised Private Schools (Regulation) Act, 1973 (which provides that no civil court shall have jurisdiction to decide questions required to be decided under that Act) ousts the jurisdiction of civil courts to entertain a suit seeking a declaration that an educational institution is a minority institution.
The court noted the appellant's contention that the 1973 Act contains no machinery to determine minority character and therefore Section 53 does not intend to oust civil jurisdiction in suits of this nature. The court recorded the appellant's evidence and points: the founder's Christian identity, administration by the founder, conduct of Bible classes, and other indicia asserted to show minority character.
The court considered the submissions of the Additional Government Pleader who did not point to any provision in the Act that explicitly ousted civil court jurisdiction in relation to a declaration of minority status, and who accepted that the present suit did not seek recognition under the statutory scheme but only a declaration of minority character.
The appellant relied on a series of judicial decisions (some reported, some unreported) to support the proposition that civil courts can and have granted declarations regarding minority status and that recognition of minority character of a managing agency may obviate the need for repeated declarations for each institution. The court observed that learned counsel for the respondents was unable to rely upon any decision to the contrary.
On this basis the High Court concluded that the lower appellate court's view—that the civil court had no jurisdiction to entertain the suit—was misconceived. The High Court held there was no statutory prohibition ousting the civil court from deciding the question of minority character in a suit for declaration, and therefore restored the judgment and decree of the trial court that had granted the declaration sought by the plaintiff.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The second appeal is allowed; the High Court set aside the lower appellate court's judgment and restored the decree of the trial court. The trial court's decree granting the declaration that the plaintiff-institute is a minority institution (and granting reliefs as prayed in the suit) was restored. The court expressly rejected the view that Section 53 of the 1973 Act ousts the civil court's jurisdiction in the present type of suit.
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the plaintiff's suit for a declaration of minority status succeeds and the trial court's decree in favour of the plaintiff is re-instated.
- The High Court's decision indicates that, in the circumstances of this case, Section 53 of the 1973 Act did not operate to deprive civil courts of jurisdiction to entertain a suit seeking a declaration of minority character where no statutory recognition proceeding under the Act was being sought in the suit.
- The opinion records reliance on a body of authorities cited by the appellant to support the proposition that civil courts can adjudicate declarations of minority status and that, where a managing body has been recognised as minority, separate declarations for each institution may be unnecessary; the court found no contrary authority presented by respondents. The judgment did not purport to lay down new law beyond the result reached on the facts and submissions in this case.
Order as to costs: none.
KA/RR/VCS
JUDGMENT
Swamidurai, J.
The plaintiff in O.S No. 776 of 1986 on the file of the learned District Munsif, Ambasamudram, is the appellant. The plaintiff is St. John's Teacher Training Institute for Women represented by its correspondent S. Jayaraj. He filed the suit for declaration that the Plaintiff/school is a minority school and the order passed by the Educational authorities on 10.12.1985 is not valid and for a direction to the defendants to allow the student to write the examinations. The case of the Plaintiff briefly stated is as follows: The plaintiff/institute was established by S. Jeyaraj on 27.9.1985 and he is a Christian by birth. There is no teacher training institute at Veeramanallur, Ambasamudram Taluk within the radius of 32 K.Ms The women students have to go for a long distance from Ambasamudram in search of teacher training institute. The vocational course which was started in the Higher Secondary Schools is not sufficient to meet the needs of women students. So Jayaraj established the school for the benefit, welfare and uplift of women students in his religion. Even women students belonging to other religion also were admitted. Trained and fully qualified teachers were appointed in his institution. 80% of the women are Christians. 40 students were admitted for the academic year 1985-1986 and for the 1986-1987 60 students were studying. The school is also running a hostel and Bible is taught in the school. The correspondent is also running a High School by name St. John's Middle School and he is also running an English School for the past 10 years. The plaintiff/school is protected under Art. 30(1) of the Constitution of India. There are eight teachers working in the English Medium School. The defendants have given recognition for similar schools and permitted the students to write the examinations. The Rules framed by the Government of Tamil Nadu under Tamil Nadu Act 29/74 have curtaildd the rights guaranteed to the plaintiff under the Constitution. The Plaintiff has remitted the examination fees for the 40 student for the examination to be conducted in the moth of April, 1987 and sent the application forms along with the Challan on 31.10.86 But the 4th defendant has refused to receive the application by stating that the plaintiff/school is not recognised. The defendants pointed out a Circular dated 14.7.86 issued by the State Government to the effect that private management schools had no right to conduct the teacher training and so the students were given an opportunity to join the high school. Therefore, the students of the plaintiff/training school were prevented from getting practical training in the elementary school and also in the High Schools. The plaintiff has submitted an application under S. (1) of Act 29/74 on 30.10.1985 to the second defendant. The second defendant refused to grant recognition in his order dated 10.12.1985 The plaintiff was not given an opportunity to represent his case as per Ss. 9 and 10 of Tamil Nadu Act 29/74. It is not necessary that the plaintiff has to get prior permission for starting a school. The Rules which are framed in the year 1977 are ultra vires. Hence the plaintiff has filed the suit.
2. The defendants filed a written statement raising the following defence. The plaintiff is not a minority institution and the plaintiff is not entitled to train, prepare and guide pupils for the Government Examinations in Diploma in Teacher Training Education. The defendants do not admit that the Manager Jayaraj belongs to minority community. There is already one Government Teacher Training Institute for women, three aided recognised teacher training institutes for women and a number of higher secondary schools having vocational course in teacher training in Tirunelveli District. The Educational needs of the District are being adequately met by these institutions and therefore there was no necessity to open one such by the plaintiff. The defendants do not admit that the plaintiff has got a strength of 40 students for the year 1985-1986 and 60 students for the year 1986-1988 and the alleged existence of students' hostel is also not admitted. As per R. 4(3) of the Tamil Nadu Minority Schools (Recognition and Payment of Grant) Rules, 1977, minority schools, which have been opened without the permission of the Department shall apply for recognition within three months from the date of opening. The Plaintiff-institute is not entitled to claim recognition and certain conditions for recognition have been prescribed in the abovesaid Rules The application of the plaintiff for recognition was rejected for the reasons stated in the proceedings of the Joint Director of School Education. It was noticed by the Department that some of the schools for which recognition was refused by the Department, run on their own risk and the students of the unrecognised Institutions are permitted for teaching practice in the recognised schools. So, a Circular was issued to all the inspecting officers not to give permission for students of unrecognised training institutes for teaching practice in the recongised schools. Rules of 1977 do not offend Art. 20(1) of Constitution of India and those Rules are not ultra vires the Tamil Nadu Act. 29/74. There is no mala fide on the part of the definitions in refusing recognition to the plaintiff/institute. The suit is liable to be dismissed for want of valid notice under S. 80, C.P.C
3. The plaintiff examined Jayaraj as P.W 1 and marked Exs. A.1 to A. 27. On the side of the defendants, Thangavelu was examined as D.W 1 and no exhibits were marked. The trial Court, after considering the evidence elaborately, decreed the suit as prayed for. The defendants filed O.S No. 18/86 before the learned Subordinate Judge, Tenkasi against the Judgment and decree made in O.S No. 776/86 dated 4.12.87 and the lower appellate Court allowed the appeal with costs and dismissed the suit. Hence the plaintiff has filed this second appeal.
4. The Second Appeal was admitted on the following substantial question of law, namely, whether the Jurisdiction of the Civil Court to declare that the particular Educational Institution is a minority Institution is based in view of S. 53 of the Tamil Nadu Recognised Private School (Regulation) Act. 1973).
5. S. 53 of the Tamil Nadu Recognised Private Schools (Regulation) Act, 1973 reads as follows:—
“53. Civil Court not to decide question under this Act:— No Civil Court shall have jurisdiction to decide or deal with any question which is by or under this Act required to be decided or dealt with by any authority or officer mentioned in this Act.”
Mr. A.L Somayaji, learned Counsel appearing for the appellant contended that the view taken by the lower appellate Court that civil court has no jurisdiction to entertain a suit of this nature is erroneous and that S. 53 of the abovesaid Act does not contemplate ouster of jurisdiction of the civil Court for trying the suit of this nature. According to him, no machinery is created under the provisions of Act 29/74 to decide about the minority character of an educational institutions. He pointed out that the appellant/school was established by Jayaraj who is a member of the Church of South India for catering to the needs of young Christian girls who are finding it difficult to secure admission in other teacher training institutions. Learned Counsel for the appellant pointed out that Bible classes also are conducted on some days for preaching the teachings of Jesus Christ. It is also to be noted that St. John Middle School which was established by the very same Jayaraj is enjoying the minority status. In the grounds of appeal, it is mentioned that the plaintiff/institution remains closed on a Christian festivals and other Government holidays. Ex. A.1 is the Baptism certificate issued to Jayaraj and Ex. A.2 is the marriage certificate of Jayaraj and these would show that Jayaraj is a Christian attached to the Church of South India. There is evidence that Jayaraj alone would be administering the plaintiff/school. So, Mr. Somayaji contended that the appellant-institute was founded and is administered as a minority institution. He pointed out that the lower appellate court rejected the evidence of P.W 1 as interested testimony without assigning any reason especially when P.W 1 is Founder and is administering the school.
6. Mr. R. Swaminathan learned Additional Government Pleader submitted that there is no provision in the abovesaid Act that declaration regarding minority status of a school should be obtained before starting the school. A careful perusal of S. 53 of the abovesaid Act does not reveal that the civil Court has no jurisdiction to decide the question of minority status. It is admitted by both parties that the plaintiff is not seeking for recognition of the plaintiff/school in the suit. But he seeks for declaration that the plaintiff/institute is a religions minority institution. I do not find that there is any prohibition inbuilt in the abovesaid Act or any where in any other statute ousting the jurisdiction of the civil Court, to decide the question regarding the minority nature of a school in a suit seeking for a declaration that it is a minority institution. The lower Appellate Court is misconceived in deciding the issue that the Civil Court has no jurisdiction to try the suit.
7. Mr. A.L Somayaji, learned Counsel for the appellant cited several decisions in support of his contention that the jurisdiction of the civil court is not ousted in granting the relief of declaration as prayed for in the present suit. He relied upon the decision in the case of Sekhara Pillai v. Government Of Tamil Nadu reported in 1992-2-L.W. 143. In that decision, Pratap Singb, J. held as follows:—
“It is in evidence that students in classes in Tamil Medium outnumber the number of students studying in Malayalam medium. Furthermore, as per Act 29/94 the minority school is one which is established and administered, or administered by a minority. The plaintiff's case comes within the ambit of this definition also and hence is entitled to the reliefs prayed for. In view of the above, the plaintiff will have to necessarily succeed and get a declaration and injunction prayed for by him.”
Mr. Somayajee, learned counsel for the appellant further relied upon the following decisions, in support of his contention:
(1) State Of Kerala, Etc. v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial, Etc (AIR 1970 S.C 2079;
(2) State of Punjab v. Dewan Chunilal (AIR 1971 S.C 2086;
(3) D.A.V College, Jullandur v. State of Punjab (AIR 1971 S.C 1737);
(4) A.P Christians Medical Educational Society v. Government of A.P 1986 (2) S.C.J 594);
(5) Vice Chancellor, L.N Mithila University v. Dayanandjha 1982 (2) S.C.J 605;
(6) R.M.B.T School v. State (1973 Ker. 87);
(7) N. Prameswara Kurup v. State (AIR 1986 Mad 126) and
(8) Virendra Nath Gupta & Another v. Delhi Administration & Others (J.T 1990 (1) S.C 403).
8. Mr. A.L Somayaji, learned counsel for the appellant also relied upon an unreported Judgment of this Court dated 8.4.91 made in W.P No. 3754/91 (The Congregation of the Sisters of the St. Annem, Tiruchirappalli v. The Joint Director of School Education (Secondary) Madras, 6 and others, for the proposition that when once the High Court recognised the school as a minority institution holding that the provisions of Tamil Nadu Recognised Private Schools (Regulation) Act, 1973 are not applicable to the minority institution, it is not necessary that at every stage, an institution that is run or being run or would be started by an agency should get a declaration of minority status for every school that is to be stated and that the school should be protected under Art. 30 of the Constitution of India. This Court has held that there is no need or necessity to obtain separate declaration from Civil Court on each occasion when a new educational institution is stated. Mr. Somayaji, learned counsel for the appellant also relied upon the Judgment of this Court rendered by me in W.P No. 19419/90 dated 3.9.1991 (His Holiness Srilasri Kasivasi Muthukumaraswami Tambiran Swamigal Avergal, Head of Sri Kasi Mutt, Tirupppanandal v. The State of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary to Government, Education Department Fort St. George, Madras-9 and another. In that case also, it was held it is unnecessry even for the Government to insist upon such declaration for each and every one of the schools was already held that it is a religious denoninational institution.
8. Learned Additional Government Pleader is unable to rely upon any decision in support of his contention. In the circumstances, the Judgment and decree of the lower Appellate Court are not according to law and facts and therefore the same are set aside and the Judgment and decree of the trial Court are restored.
9. In the result, the second appeal is allowed and the suit is decreed as prayed for. In the circumstances, there is no order as to costs.
KA/RR/VCS
Alert