Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

N. Saroja v. Sri Vidya Chits And Finance (P) Ltd., 102, I Floor, Dindigul Road, Karur And Another

Madras High Court
Jan 9, 1995
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns an application (I.A. No. 44/1985) in O.P. No. 43/1979 that resulted in the revocation of Letters of Administration said to have been granted in respect of an unregistered will dated 27-4-1973, allegedly executed by Kaliammal. The petitioning party (the mortgagee) alleged that respondents 2 and 3 borrowed money on the basis of an equitable mortgage of property originally belonging to their mother, Kaliammal, and that despite a preliminary decree (27-1-1977) and a final decree (27-6-1979) for sale of the hypothec, the respondents did not pay the debt.

The petitioner asserted that the respondents had relied on a will (produced in the mortgage transaction) that was a forgery. It was alleged that respondents 2 and 3 colluded with the person who obtained Letters of Administration (the first respondent in the probate application) to procure Letters of Administration in O.P. No. 43/1979 without citing the mortgagee (the petitioner), who claimed to be a person interested in the property. On the basis of these pleadings the learned Principal District Judge, Tiruchirappalli, allowed the application and revoked the Letters of Administration. The first respondent (who had been granted Letters of Administration) appealed against that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Letters of Administration granted in respect of the alleged unregistered Will dated 27-4-1973 should be revoked on the grounds asserted by the petitioner (including alleged forgery, collusion, and failure to cite an interested person).
  2. Whether an application to revoke Letters of Administration is governed by the limitation period in Article 137 of the Limitation Act (i.e., whether the application was time-barred).
  3. Whether the illustrative grounds listed in Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act are exhaustive for establishing "just cause" to revoke probate or Letters of Administration, or whether other causes (such as failure to cite an interested person) may suffice.
  4. Whether the petitioner was estopped or had acquiesced (by conduct or prior knowledge) from challenging the Letters of Administration.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Applicant in I.A. No. 44/1985)

  • The respondents 2 and 3 borrowed money from the petitioner by hypothecating property that originally belonged to their mother, Kaliammal, and later failed to repay the debt, leading to O.S. No. 474/1975 (renumbered O.S. No. 308/1975) and a final decree for sale.
  • The will produced in court in respect of Kaliammal (dated 27-4-1973) is a forgery; Kaliammal died on 28-4-1973 and could not have executed the document alleged to be a will in the circumstances asserted.
  • The application in O.P. No. 43/1979 for Letters of Administration was filed collusively by respondents 2 and 3 with the first respondent to defeat the petitioner's decree, and the petitioner, despite being a person interested in the property, was not cited as a party and was kept in the dark.
  • Because an interested person was omitted from citation in the probate application and because of suspicious circumstances relating to the dates and subsequent acts (e.g., transfer of assessment and kist payments by respondents 2 and 3 but not by the person granted Letters), the Letters of Administration should be revoked.

First Respondent's / Appellant's Arguments

  • The first respondent asserted absolute right in the property by virtue of the alleged will dated 27-4-1973, contending that Kaliammal executed the will while of sound mind.
  • The allegation of collusion with respondents 2 and 3 was denied as false.
  • The petitioner (mortgagee) need not have been cited in the probate proceedings because, according to the first respondent, the petitioner could not claim any right in the property and therefore could not object to the grant of Letters of Administration.
  • The first respondent argued that the petitioner had knowledge of the probate proceedings (citing the execution petition counter and the petitioner's appearance in subsequent proceedings) and was therefore estopped or had waived objections; accordingly, the revocation application was barred by limitation.
  • Counsel for the appellant contended that none of the five conditions enumerated in Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act were shown, and therefore revocation under that Section should not have been allowed; reliance was placed on a decision (Hari Narain v. Subhash Chander) to support a three-year limitation principle for revocation applications.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hari Narain v. Subhash Chander (A.I.R. 1985 Punjab & Haryana 211) Authority for the proposition that an application for revocation of probate could be filed only within three years from the date when the right to apply accrues and that Article 137 of the Limitation Act applies. The decision was relied upon by counsel for the appellant to argue the revocation application was time-barred. The court noted the citation but ultimately treated Article 137 as inapplicable in light of contrary High Court authority discussed below, so it did not apply Hari Narain to dismiss the revocation on limitation grounds.
Last Will of Smt. Jayalakshmi - S. Krishnaswami (1990 (1) L.W. 337) Authority for the proposition that Article 137 of the Limitation Act will not apply to proceedings filed for grant of probate or Letters of Administration, and that delay is nonetheless relevant to test the genuineness of a propounded will (delay gives rise to suspicion). The court followed this High Court decision to hold that Article 137 did not bar the revocation application. The court nevertheless considered delay as a factor raising suspicion as to the genuineness of the will, and examined the parties' conduct and timings accordingly. This precedent underpinned the court's refusal to sustain the limitation/estoppel argument of the appellant while validating scrutiny of delay and suspicious circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the pleadings, chronology of events and the legal points raised by both sides. The principal strands of the court's reasoning were:

  1. Suspicious chronology and conduct: the court stressed the chronological anomalies. According to the record, a registered will in favour of the sons (respondents 2 and 3) was dated 24-4-1973 and registered on 26-4-1973, while an alleged unregistered will in favour of the first respondent is dated 27-4-1973. Kaliammal died on 28-4-1973. The court found it suspicious that a daughter-in-law would receive an unregistered will the day after a registered will in favour of the sons was executed and registered, and found that suspicious circumstances supported inquiry into genuineness.
  2. Failure to cite an interested person: the court treated the omission of an evidently interested party (the mortgagee/petitioner) from the probate/administration proceedings as a material ground. The court observed that failure to cite a person who has an interest over the property may constitute a valid ground to revoke probate or Letters of Administration.
  3. Section 263 - "just cause" is illustrative, not exhaustive: addressing the appellant's submission that revocation must fall within one of the five expressly enumerated circumstances in Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act, the court held the term "just cause" in that Section is illustrative rather than exhaustive. Accordingly, the court accepted that other grounds, such as failure to cite a person interested in the estate or collusion, can constitute just cause for revocation.
  4. Limitation/knowledge and estoppel: the appellant argued the petition was barred by limitation and that the petitioner had knowledge earlier (citing a counter in an execution petition and prior appearances). The court reviewed the sequence of proceedings and concluded the petitioner may not have had such clear or actionable knowledge as to justify holding the revocation application to be time-barred. The court relied on the High Court decision in the Jayalakshmi case to hold that Article 137 of the Limitation Act does not apply to revocation proceedings for probate/letters of administration, though delay remains a factor relevant to assessing genuineness.
  5. Delay and suspicion: although Article 137 was held inapplicable, the court accepted the principle from Jayalakshmi that delay may give rise to suspicion about the genuineness of a will. The court examined whether the petitioner had in practice acquiesced or waived rights and concluded there was insufficient basis to find acquiescence or estoppel. The court found the petitioner had a "very good case" on merits to have the Letters of Administration revoked.
  6. Overall conclusion: based on the suspicious circumstances surrounding the dates of the wills, the failure to cite an interested person, and the absence of convincing evidence of prior knowledge or waiver, the court concluded that the learned Principal District Judge correctly allowed the revocation application and that there was no basis to interfere with that order.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The appeal is dismissed.

Implications:

  • The impugned order of the learned Principal District Judge, Tiruchirappalli, revoking the Letters of Administration granted in respect of the alleged unregistered will dated 27-4-1973 is sustained (i.e., the revocation stands).
  • The court rejected the contention that Article 137 of the Limitation Act barred the revocation application, relying on High Court authority to treat Article 137 as inapplicable to probate/administration revocation proceedings; nonetheless, delay remains a relevant factor for assessing genuineness of a propounded will.
  • The court treated Section 263's illustrative list of "just causes" as non-exhaustive and accepted that other circumstances (including failure to cite an interested person and suspicious facts surrounding execution of the will) can constitute just cause to revoke probate or Letters of Administration.
  • No costs were awarded. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel precedent; it applies existing principles and authority to the facts and upholds the trial court's exercise of discretion to revoke Letters of Administration in the circumstances presented.
Show all summary ...

This appeal arises out of the order passed by the learned Principal District Judge, Tiruchi in I.A No. 44/1985 in O.P No. 43/1979 allowing the same and revoking the Letters of Administration granted in respect of the unregistered will dated 27-4-1973 said to have been executed by one Kaliammal.

2. The averments in the petition are as follows: Respondents 2 and 3 borrowed monies from the petitioner on the foot of an equitable mortgage. Since they did not pay the money, the petitioner filed O.S No. 474/1975 on the file of the Sub Court, Tiruchirappalli which was later on transferred to the Sub Court, Karur and numbered as O.S No. 308/1975. In spite of the contest made by the respondents 2 and 3, a preliminary decree was passed in favour of the petitioner on 27-1-1977. Since the respondents have not paid any money even after the passing of the preliminary decree, the petitioner filed an Application in I.A No. 555/1977 and a final decree has been passed on 27-6-1979 for the sale of the hypotheca. The respondents have borrowed the money representing that the property which originally belonged to their mother Kaliammal has been bequeathed in the their favour by means of a registered will on 24-4-1973. The petitioner became the mortgagee in respect of the said property and is a person interested in the property. The title deeds in respect of the property and the registered will have been handed over to the petitioner by the respondents 2 and 3 at the time of the mortgage. It appears that the respondents 2 and 3 in collusion with the first respondent have filed an application in O.P No. 43/1979 for the grant of Letters of Administration in respect of the will of Kaliammal alleged to have been executed by her on 27-4-1973. The documents produced in Court purporting to be a Will is rank forgery. Kaliammal did not and could not have executed the same. She died on 28-4-1973. The first respondent seems to have got the Letters of Administration to the said Will. The first respondent is aware of the fraudulent nature of the document and scheme of the respondents 2 and 3. The petitioner who is entitled to object and who is a person interested in the property has not been cited as a party to the proceedings. No application has been made. The petitioner has been kept in dark. The first respondent along with her daughter filed a suit in O.S No. 7/1982 on the file of Sub Court, Karur for declaration that they are entitled to the suit property execlusively. A reference has been made about the O.P, filed by the first respondent for getting Letters of Administration. The petitioner is contesting the said suit disputing the validity and genuineness of the Will. Since the Letters of Administration have been granted by this Court in favour of the first respondent, the petitioner has filed this application for revoking the same. The petitioner came to know the grant of Letters of Administration only recently. Hence the petition.

3. The first respondent in her counter contends as follows: The respondents 2 and 3 have no right in the petition mentioned property and they cannot deal with the same. The first respondent has absolute right in the property by virtue of the Wilt dated 27-4-1973 executed in her favour by Kaliammal. The allegation that the O.P has been filed in collusion and conspiracy between her and the respondents 2 and 3 is false. The Will in favour of the first respondent has been executed by Kaliammal while she was in a sound and disposing state of mind. The petitioner need not be cited as a party to the proceedings since the petitioner cannot claim any right in the property and could not object the grant of Letters of Administration. In O.S No. 308/1975, the petitioner filed E.P No. 287/1980 and in that petition, the second respondent has filed a counter stating the O.P No., and the date of probate granted by the Court in respect of the Will dated 27-4-1973. The petitioner has got knowledge about the proceedings on that date itself. The petitioner has entered appearance in the proceedings in O.P No. 44/1981 filed by the first respondent as an indigent person. The allegation that the petitioner has got knowledge about the proceedings only recently is false. The petitioner is estopped from questioning the Letters of Administration. The petitioner has acquiesced and waived the rights, if any. The peresent application is barred by limitation. The petition is therefore liable to be dismissed.

4. On the above pleadings, the learned Principal District Judge, Tiruchirapalli has rendered the impugned order holding that the order granting Letters of Administration in respect of the unregistered Will dated 27-4-1973 has to be revoked and that the petitioner has not acquiesced the proceedings in O.P.S No. 43/1979 and that the petitioner is not estopped from questioning the same.

5. Aggrieved over the same, the first respondent has preferred this appeal.

6. In this appeal, the appellant seeks to set aside the order passed by the learned Principal District Judge, Tiruchi in I.A No. 44/1985 in O.P 43/1979 in which the learned District Judge has allowed the application revoking the Letters of Administration granted in favour of the first respondent herein on 23-6-1979. The case of the petitioner is that the property which has been mortgaged in their favour originally belonged to Kaliammal, mother of respondents 2 and 3 and the respondents 2 and 3 have got a loan sanctioned in their favour by mortgaging the properties in favour of the plaintiff contending that their mother has bequeathed the property in their favour by means of a registered Will dated 24-4-1973 which was registered on the 26-4- 1973 and by producing the said Will as well as the other documents like the transfer of the assessment in respect of the property, receipts for payment of tax and also rental value certificate issued by the Commissioner. The borrowing under the mortgage has ended in a preliminary decree followed by a filial decree being passed against the respondents 2 and 3 on 27-6-1979. Subsequent to the preliminary decree dated 27-1-1977 and the final decree application filed in 1977 being ordered, the wife of the second respondent has filed O.P No. 43/1979 and got Letters of Administration in her favour on 23-6-1979. These facts are not disputed.

7. The petitioner contends that in pursuance of a collusion between the respondents 2 and 3 on the one hand and the first respondent on the other, this O.P, has been filed collusively for the grant of Letters of Administration and she has got the same ordered in her favour and it is liable to be set aside on the ground that the petitioner, as the person interested in the property, has not been cited as a respondent in that application and the application has been filed Only to defeat his decree in O.S No. 308/1975 on the file of Sub Court, Karur. The dates and relationship are very relevant in this appeal. The appellant herein is the wife of the second respondent, and the third respondent is the younger brother of the second respondent. Second and third respondents are the sons of deceased Kaliammal to whom the property originally belonged. She had executed a Wilt bequeathing the property in favour of her sons on 24-4-1973 and it has been registered on 26-4-1973. The appellant herein who is the first respondent in the application claimed that her mother-in-law had executed an unregistered Will on 27-4-1973 bequeathing the entire properties belonging to her in her favour and she had obtained the Letters of Administration on that basis on 23-6-1979. It has to be noted that on 28-4-1973, Kaliammal breathed her last. When the mother had executed a Will bequeathing her propertied in favour of her two sons, just four days prior to her death and registered same also two days later, there appears to be no necessity for her to bequeath the property in favour of her daughter-in-law on the next day of the registration of the Will. The execution of the alleged Will dated 27-4-1973 therefore leads us to a grave suspiction. The petitioner in the I.A 44/1985 who is the first respondent herein has, in the meanwhile obtained a preliminary decree on the basis of the mortgage executed by the respondents 2 and 3, just two days prior to the passing of the final decree, the first respondent has obtained the Letters of Administration in her favour. In the meanwhile, in pursuance of the Will in their favour, the respondents 2 and 3 have got the assessment transferred in their name, paid kist, and also obtained a certificate from the Commissioner of Karur Municipality which would show that they have a right over the property. But, no such transfer of assessment or enjoyment of the property by paying kist etc., is shown in favour of the first respondent in the I.A 44/1985 who is the appellant herein. Therefore, the conclusion arrived at by the learned Principal District Judge, Tiruchi that the execution of the Will dated 27-4-1973 by Kaliammal in favour of the appellant herein is in suspicious circumstances and cannot be said as an incorrect conclusion. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant would argue tat under Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act, where the grant of probate or Letters of Administration is sought to be revoked, it must be shown that there exists just cause for the same and the Section itself gives a list as to what are all the just causes, which the person seeking to revoke the Letters of Administration can choose to establish. According to the learned counsel, none of the five conditions or circumstances which are listed in Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act, has been shown as existing in the present case to invoke Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act and revoke the Letters of Administration already granted. But, I wish to state that the expression “just cause” explained in Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act, is only illustrative and not exhaustive. It is not necessary that anyone who seeks to revoke the Letters of Administration or probate granted, should show the existence of any one of these five circumstances or conditions alone. There may be other causes also which can be incorporated as just cause. In the present case, in spite of the fact that the petitioner before the learned District Judge, viz., the first respondent herein had an interest over the properties which the appellant claims, as having been bequeathed in her favour, the petitioner has not been cited in the application. Failure to cite a person who has an interest over the property is also a ground to revoke the probate or Letters of Administration granted. Therefore, on merits, the petitioner in I.A No. 44/1985 has got a very good case to have the Letters of Administration granted in favour of the first respondent revoked. The learned District Judge, has therefore allowed the application and I am of opinion that it cannot be interfered with by this court.

8. The learned senior counsel Mr. Gandhi would argue that the petition filed by the first respondent herein is barred by limitation since any application to revoke the Letters of Administration should have been filed within three years from the date of knowledge and that in the counter in the Execution Petition filed by the second respondent he has specifically stated that he has no interest over the properties and has also mentioned about the grant of Letters of Administration in the O.P No. 43/1979 and therefore, it must be held that the petitioner in I.A No. 44/1985 had knowledge even when the counter in the Execution Petition has been filed and yet, the application has been filed only in the year 1985 long after the expiry of three years and therefore, it may be held that the application is barred by limitation. In support of his above contention, the learned Counsel also relies upon the decision reported in Hari Narain v. Subhash Chander(A.I.R 1985 Punjab and Haryana 211) wherein it has been held an application for revocation of probate could be filed only within three years from date when the right to apply accrues and Article 137 of the Limitation Act applies in all force. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent would on the other hand refer to a decision of our High Court reported in the matter of Last Will of Smt. Jayalakshmi - S. Krishnaswami (1990-(1) Law Weekly 337) wherein it has been held that Article 137 of the Limitation Act will not apply to proceedings filed for grant of Probate or Letters of Administration with or without the Will annexed. In view of the decisions of our High Court regarding the applicability of Article 137 of the Limitation Act to an application for grant of Probate, I am of opinion that the argument of the learned counsel that the application for revoking the Letters of Administration ought to have been filed within three years from the date of his knowldege, is not tenable.

9. The next question that has to be considered is whether there is any justifiable reason for the delay even if Article 137 of the Limitation Act is not applicable, since it has been held in the decision reported in the matter of Last Will of Smt. Jayalakshmi - S. Krishnswami (1990-1-L.W. 337) that though the proceedings filed for grant of probate or Letters of Administration may not come within the mischief of Article 137 of the Limitation Act, yet the delay aspect is relevant to test the genuineness of the Will propounded and that delay in taking steps gives rise to suspicion and the longer the delay the stronger the suspicion. It is to be noted that the learned counsel appearing for the appellant contends that the application is barred by limitation since the petitioner had knowledge when the second respondent has filed his counter in the Execution Petition. The second respondent was a judgment-debtor against whom a preliminary decree has been passed. In the final decree proceedings, the second respondent has not stated that his wife has filed O.P No. 43/1979 and has obtained Letters of Administration on 23-6-1979. It cannot be stated that he was not aware of the grant of Letters of Administration when the final decree proceedings were pending from 1977. The final decree has been passed only on 27-6-1979 after the grant of Letters of Administration. Therefore, he had sufficient time to raise this before the final decree could be passed against him three days after the grant of Letters of Administration in favour of his wife. It cannot be stated that he was not aware of the alleged Will in favour of his wife till the final decree is passed. In the above circumstances, the failure of the second respondent to say that his mother had executed an unregistered Will in favour of his wife and she is taking steps to get the Letters of Administration and has obtained Letters of Administration on 23-6-1979 are all to be noted. The petitioner, who has filed the Execution Petition, therefore might not have taken the objection raised by the second respondent in the Execution Petition, that Letters of Administration has been granted in favour of his wife, seriously on acknowledgement of his failure to take such a stand during the final decree proceedings. Therefore, it cannot be stated that the petitioner had knowledge of the Letters of Administration being granted and he has committed delay in filing the application to revoke the Letters of Administration. Thus viewing from any manner, it is thus seen that the order passed by the Principal District Judge, Tiruchi revoking the Letters of Administration is well-founded and does not call for any interference by this Court and the appeal is liable to be dismissed as of no merits.

10. In the result, the appeal is dismissed. No costs.

RR/VCS