- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Philip Jeyasingh v. The Joint Registrar ...
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion addresses a reference made once again to a Full Bench concerning the maintainability of a writ petition against a Special Officer of a Co-operative society. The matter had previously been considered and decided by a Full Bench on 22nd January, 1992 in Philip Jeyasingh v. The Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies (1992) 1 L.W. 216, which held that the judgment in R. Tamilarasan v. Director of Handlooms and Textiles (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.) was a valid precedent. Despite this, a single Judge referred the matter again to a Full Bench, persuaded by a single Judge's judgment in K. Ganesan v. Special Officer, Salem Co-operative Sugars Mills Ltd. (1992) 2 L.W. 406. The present Full Bench examines the correctness of that referral and the maintainability of the writ petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the judgment of the Full Bench in R. Tamilarasan v. Director of Handlooms and Textiles (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.) can be characterized as per incuriam or obiter dicta, thus not binding.
- Whether a writ petition is maintainable against a Co-operative society represented by a Special Officer.
- Whether the dismissal of a Special Leave Petition (SLP) by the Supreme Court without reasons amounts to a declaration of law binding under Article 141 of the Constitution of India.
- Whether the present reference to a Full Bench is sustainable in light of prior Full Bench decisions and Supreme Court rulings.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The question of maintainability of a writ petition against a Special Officer of a Co-operative society was not considered in Tamilarasan's case and thus remains open for consideration by a single Judge.
- The Division Bench judgment in A. Natarajan v. Registrar of Co-operative Societies (1991) 2 L.L.J. 296 : (1991) 2 L.W. 420, which questioned the validity of Tamilarasan's case, was challenged in the Supreme Court, and the dismissal of the Special Leave Petition after admission implies affirmation of that Division Bench view.
- The dismissal of the Special Leave Petition by the Supreme Court should be treated as a binding declaration of law under Article 141.
- Where Special Leave has been granted and a civil appeal dismissed, that dismissal automatically declares the law on the subject.
- The Full Bench in the present case should not have considered Tamilarasan's case as binding precedent, based on the Supreme Court's ruling in Narendra Prasadji v. State of Gujarat.
Court's Response to Arguments
- The Full Bench in Philip Jeyasingh already answered the question negatively, confirming that Tamilarasan's case is not per incuriam or obiter dicta but a binding precedent.
- In Tamilarasan's case, the Full Bench explicitly considered and held that writ petitions against Co-operative societies represented by Special Officers are not maintainable.
- The dismissal of the Special Leave Petition by the Supreme Court without reasons does not constitute a declaration of law under Article 141, as supported by Supreme Court precedent and the Full Bench's prior judgment.
- The civil appeal was dismissed on grounds other than the maintainability of writ petitions against Co-operative societies; hence, no binding ruling on that issue was made.
- The Full Bench's view that Tamilarasan's case is a valid precedent is consistent with Supreme Court jurisprudence, including the principle that a larger Bench cannot overrule an earlier five-Judge Bench.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Philip Jeyasingh v. The Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies (1992) 1 L.W. 216 | Confirmed that Tamilarasan's case is a binding precedent and answered the referral question negatively. | Used as authoritative precedent to reject the referral and uphold the binding nature of Tamilarasan's case. |
| R. Tamilarasan v. Director of Handlooms and Textiles (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.) | Held that writ petitions against Co-operative societies, whether represented by Board or Special Officer, are not maintainable; binding Full Bench precedent. | Found to be valid and binding precedent not per incuriam or obiter dicta. |
| A. Natarajan v. Registrar of Co-operative Societies (1991) 2 L.L.J. 296 : (1991) 2 L.W. 420 | Division Bench opinion that Tamilarasan's case was per incuriam and obiter dicta. | Rejected by the Full Bench as incorrect and not binding. |
| Co-operative Central Bank Ltd. v. Additional Industrial Tribunal (1969) 2 L.L.J. 698 | Bye-laws of co-operative societies do not have force of law; co-operative societies are not statutory functionaries. | Supported the view that a Special Officer stepping into the shoes of the governing body is not a government servant. |
| S.S. Dhanoa v. Municipal Corporation Delhi (1981) 2 L.L.J. 231 | Officer appointed to co-operative society is not discharging public servant functions. | Applied to hold that a Special Officer is not a government servant for writ petition maintainability purposes. |
| Salem District Co-operative Sector Bank Employees' Union v. A. Natarajan (1992) 2 L.W. 30 (J.S.) | Dismissal of appeal by Supreme Court without reasons does not amount to declaration of law. | Accepted to reject petitioner's contention regarding binding effect of dismissal of SLP. |
| Employees Welfare Association v. Union of India | Dismissing SLP without reasons does not amount to declaration of law under Article 141. | Referred to support the principle that dismissal simpliciter is not binding precedent. |
| Union of India v. All India Services Pensioners Association | If Supreme Court dismisses SLP with reasons, it becomes binding under Article 141. | Distinguished on facts as no reasons were given in the present case. |
| Narendra Prasadji v. State of Gujarat | A five-Judge Bench cannot overrule an earlier five-Judge Bench. | Applied to affirm the binding nature of the earlier Full Bench decision in Tamilarasan's case. |
| K. Ganesan v. Special Officer, Salem Co-operative Sugars Mills Ltd. (1992) 2 L.W. 406 | Single Judge's referral to a larger Bench regarding the correctness of Tamilarasan's case. | Rejected as improper referral since the issue was already settled by Full Bench. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by noting that the issue had been conclusively decided by a prior Full Bench in Philip Jeyasingh, which held that the Full Bench decision in Tamilarasan's case was binding and not per incuriam or obiter dicta. The Court pointed out that despite this, a single Judge had referred the matter again to a Full Bench, influenced by another single Judge's opinion in K. Ganesan, which was incorrect as the matter was already settled.
The Court examined whether the maintainability of a writ petition against a Special Officer was an open question. It found that Tamilarasan's case had explicitly considered and decided this issue, holding such petitions as not maintainable. The Court rejected the petitioner's contention that the question was not decided.
Regarding the effect of dismissal of a Special Leave Petition by the Supreme Court, the Court emphasized that dismissal without reasons does not amount to a binding declaration of law under Article 141. It referred to prior Supreme Court rulings and the Full Bench's own earlier judgment to support this principle. Consequently, the Court rejected the petitioner's argument that the dismissal of the SLP affirmed the Division Bench's view against Tamilarasan's case.
The Court also rejected the argument that a civil appeal dismissal after SLP admission automatically declares the law on the subject, noting that the appeal was dismissed on other grounds without considering writ petition maintainability.
Finally, the Court relied on the principle that a later Full Bench cannot overrule an earlier five-Judge Bench, reinforcing the binding nature of Tamilarasan's case. The Court concluded that the present reference to a Full Bench was unsustainable but exercised its discretion to dispose of the writ petition to avoid further delay.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is not maintainable and is dismissed with costs.
The Court held that the Full Bench decision in Tamilarasan's case remains binding precedent, conclusively deciding that writ petitions against Co-operative societies represented by either a Board of Directors or a Special Officer are not maintainable. The dismissal of Special Leave Petitions without reasons by the Supreme Court does not alter this position or create binding precedent. The present referral to a Full Bench was improper and unsustainable. The direct effect is the dismissal of the writ petition with costs, and no new precedent has been established.
1. We are somewhat surprised that this matter has been referred to us once again, though it has been considered by a Full Bench to which one of us was a party earlier and by judgment dated 22nd January, 1992, the reference had been answered. The judgment is reported in Philip Jeyasingh v. The Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies (1992) 1 L.W. 216.
2. The question referred to that Full Bench was "can the judgment of the Full Bench in R. Tamilarasan v. Director of Handlooms and Textiles (1991) 2 L.W. 409 be characterised as ant per incuriam or obiter dicta as opined by the Division Bench of this Court in A. Natarajah v. Registrar of Co-operative Societies (1991) 2 L.L.J. 296 : (1991) 2 L.W. 420. The question was answered in paragraph 63 of the judgment which reads thus:
We have no hesitation in answering the question referred to us in the negative and holding that the judgment of the Full Bench in R. Tamilarasan v. Director of Handlooms and Textiles (1991) 2 L.W. 409 : (1991) 2 L.L.J. 296 (F.B.), is not per incuriam or obiter dicta and the view taken by the Division Bench in A. Natarajan v. Registrar of Co-operative Societies (1991) 2 L.L.J. 296 : (1991) 2 L.W. 420, is not correct. We hold that the judgment of the Full Bench is a valid precedent binding on Division Benches and single Judges of this Court as well as subordinate courts.
3. The last sentence in the judgment clearly holds that the judgment of the Full Bench in R. Tamilarasan v. Director of Handlooms and Textiles (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.), is a valid precedent binding on Division Benches, single Judges of this Court as well as Subordinate Courts. Inspite of that clear direction, this matter has once again been referred to, to a Full Bench by a single Judge who had nothing to do except to follow the Full Bench in (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.) and dismiss the writ petition as not maintainable. He has been persuaded to refer the matter again to a Full Bench in view of the judgment of a single Judge of this Court in K. Ganesan v. Special Officer, Salem Co-operative Sugars Mills Ltd. (1992) 2 L.W. 406, on which reliance was placed by learned Counsel for the petitioner. Referring to the observation in that judgment that the case was being referred to a larger Bench with a request to the Hon'ble the Chief Justice to constitute a larger Bench, which can go into the correctness or otherwise of the pronouncements of the Full Bench in Tamilarasan's case (1989) 1 L.L.J. 588, the learned Judge observed in this case
"since already the very decision rendered by the Full Bench in this very case has already been referred to the Hon'ble the Chief Justice for consideration by a larger Bench by P.S. Mishra, J. I have no other go, but to have this matter directed to be posted and considered along with the reference already made by the learned Judge as referred to above."
4. The view taken by the learned Judge that he has no other go but to refer the matter to a Full Bench is not correct. In this very case, as noticed by the learned Judge himself, the Full Bench had already answered the reference and held that the decision in Tamilarasan's case (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.) was binding upon the Division Bench as well as the single Judge. The only consequential result of that answer given by the Full Bench was to dismiss the writ petition as not maintainable. The learned single Judge ought not to have referred the matter to the Full Bench just because another single Judge has chosen to question the correctness of the later Full Bench also.
5. Learned Counsel for the petitioner contends that the question whether a writ petition is maintainable as against the Special Officer of a Co-operative society was not considered in Tamilarasan's case (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.), and, therefore, the question was still open to be considered by the single Judge. According to learned Counsel, it is that question which has now been referred to a larger Bench by the single Judge. We are unable to accept this contention. In Tamilarasan's case (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.), the respondents in one of the writ petitions was the Special Officer of the concerned co-operative society. The question arose whether the writ petition could be maintained. In fact in paragraph 24 of the judgment, the question has been considered by the Full Bench in that case. The said paragraph reads as follows:
The issue can be looked from another angle. The Supreme Court in Co-operative Central Bank Ltd. v. Additional Industrial Tribunal (1969) 2 L.L.J. 698, has held that the bye-laws of a cooperative society framed in pursuance of the provisions of the Act cannot be held to be law or to have the force of law. This also supports the view that a co-operative society is not a statutory functionary. Whether the fact that whenever the governing body is superseded and in its place a Special Officer or other Government official is appointed to administer the affairs of the society makes any difference has to be considered now. We are of the view that having regard to the decision of the Supreme Court in S.S. Dhanoa v. Municipal Corporation Delhi (1981) 2 L.L.J. 231, the position is that it does not make any difference. Any officer appointed in the place of the governing body stepping into the shoes of the governing body and discharging the functions as such definitely is not a Government servant. In the case referred to above the Supreme Court has clearly held that when the services of an Indian Administrative Officer are placed at the disposal of a co-operative society, he was not discharging the functions as a public servant." There can be no doubt that the Full Bench took the view that the position would not be different whether the co-operative society is represented by the Board of Directors or a Special Officer. Hence, the contention that the question was not decided in Tamilarasan's case (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.), is not acceptable. This matter has been considered by the Full Bench in Philip Jeyasingh v. The Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies (1992) 1 L.W. 216. In paragraph 50 of the Judgment, the Full Bench referring to Tamilamsan's case (1991) 2 L,W. 409 (F.B.) said, Hence, the Full Bench had to consider (1) whether a society managed by a Board of Directors was amenable to the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, and (2) whether a society managed by a Special Officer was amenable to the said jurisdiction.
Thus, it has been held that Tamilarasan 's case (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.) decides not only that a writ petition against a cooperative society represented by Board of Directors is not maintainable but also that a writ petition against cooperative society represented by Special Officer is not maintainable.
6. In those circumstances, no question survives for consideration in the present case.
7. However, learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that the Division Bench judgment in A. Natarajan v. Registrar of Co-operative Societies (1991) 2 L.L.J. 296 : (1991) 2 L.W. 420, which held that the judgment in Tamilamsan's case (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.) was not valid as it was perincuriam and obiter dictum was challenged in the Supreme Court of India by a Special Leave Petition. Learned Counsel submits that in view of the fact that the special leave petition has been dismissed by the Supreme Court after admission, the Supreme Court is deemed to have upheld the view expressed by the Division Bench in that case. Therefore, it is submitted that the view taken by the Full Bench in Tamilamsan's case (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.) as well as in this case by the later Full Bench is no longer good law. We are unable to accept this contention. A copy of the order of the Supreme Court in the special leave petition which was later registered as Civil Appeal No. 4357 of 1991 has been produced before us by learned Counsel for the petitioner. The order of the Supreme Court in Salem District Co-operative Sector Bank Employ ees' Union v. A. Natarajan (1992) 2 L.W. 30 (J.S.), reads thus:
All that the High Court has stated is that until the by-laws are changed, the service condition cannot be altered. We see no reason to interfere. The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed. No costs.
It has been held by the Supreme Court in several leases that mere dismissal of a special leave petition without giving any reasons will not amount to declaration of law laid down by the judgment against which the special leave petition was filed, One such judgment is reported in Supreme Court Employees Welfare Association v. Union of India . The Court said that when no reason is given, but a special leave petition is dismissed simpliciter, it cannot be said that there has been a declaration of law by the Supreme Court under Art 141. In fact, the said ruling was referred to by the Full Bench in this case in its judgment dated 22nd January, 1992 in paragraph 58 of the judgment. After referring to a number of decisions of the Supreme Court, the Full Bench said that the dismissal of a special leave petition simpliciter without reason will not be a declaration of law by the Supreme Court and, therefore, the confirmation of the judgment of the Division Bench by dismissal of the civil appeal in the present case will not amount to a declaration of law that a writ petition against co-operative society is maintainable.
8. Learned Counsel invites our attention to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. All India Services Pensioners Association . In that case, the court held that if reasons are given by the Supreme Court when dismissing a special leave petition, that decision becomes binding under Article 141 of the Constitution of India as it declares the law on the subject. In the present case, we have already quoted the order of the Supreme Court in the civil appeal. We find that the question which is before us has not been considered by the Supreme Court and no declaration of law has been made by the Supreme Court. Hence, the ruling in Union of India v. All India Services Pensioners Association , will not apply to the present case.
9. Learned Counsel contends that in any case where special leave has been granted and civil appeal has been taken on file and a decision is rendered dismissing the appeal, it would automatically declare the law on the subject. We are unable to accept that contention. Civil appeal has been dismissed only on some other ground and not on the ground that a writ petition was sustainable against cooperative society. That question was not considered by the Supreme Court at all.
10. Learned Counsel refers to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Narendra Prasadji v. State of Gujarat . In that case, the Supreme Court held that a Bench of 5 Judges of that Court cannot sit in judgment over the correctness or otherwise of the views expressed by an earlier Bench consisting of five Judges. Learned Counsel submits that the view expressed in Tamilarasan 's case (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.), could not have been considered by the Full Bench which decided this case earlier by the judgment dated 22nd January, 1992 Philip Jeyasingh v. The Joint Registrar of Cooperative Societies (1992) 1 L.W. 216. The circumstances under which that Full Bench was constituted have been set out in detail in the judgment of the Full Bench. There is no need to refer to the same in this judgment. The Full Bench has taken the view that the decision of the Full Bench in Tamilarasan's case (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (K.B.) cannot, be characterised perincuriam or obiter dictum and it is a valid precedent. The Full Bench has also pointed out the questions decided in Tamilarasan's case (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (K.B.).
11. In the circumstances, the present reference to a Full Bench is not really sustainable, but having regard to the fact that this case has been pending for quite a long time and the parties will suffer if we send back the matter to be decided by a single Judge once again, we pass the order in the writ petition itself, by exercising our discretionary power under O.I, Rule 7 of the Appellate Side Rules. We are also of the view that the writ petition has itself been referred to us. In view of the judgment of the Full Bench in Tamilarasan's case (1991) 2 L.W. 409 (F.B.), this writ petition is not maintainable and it is dismissed with costs. Counsel fee Rs. 3,000 to be shared equally by counsel for respondents 1 and 2 and counsel for the third respondent.
Alert