Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Tuticorin Alkali Che... v. Cochin Silicate & Gl...

Madras High Court
Sep 11, 1991
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent challenges an order (Application No: 1627 of 1989) that refused leave under Clause 12 to sue the defendants in this Court for recovery of Rs. 343,726.30. The plaintiff/appellant contended that most of the cause of action arose within the city of Madras, while the defendants asserted that the entire cause of action arose only at Cochin and not in Madras. The learned single Judge, Srinivasan, J., decided the matter assuming that part of the cause of action had arisen within Madras, but refused leave to sue in this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether leave under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent should be granted to sue in the High Court of Madras when the cause of action arises wholly or in part within its jurisdiction.
  2. Whether the pleadings of the defendant denying any part of the cause of action arising within Madras can be ignored in deciding leave under Clause 12.
  3. The applicability of the principle of balance of convenience in deciding whether to grant leave to sue under Clause 12.
  4. The extent to which the Court should examine facts and pleadings before granting or refusing leave under Clause 12.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff/Appellant's Arguments

  • The plaintiff alleged that most of the cause of action arose within the city of Madras, justifying the suit in this Court.
  • Argued that the defendants’ claim that no part of the cause of action arose in Madras should not preclude the suit being instituted here.
  • Contended that the necessity of calling records from the Central Excise Department was irrelevant to the jurisdiction question.

Defendants' Arguments

  • Asserted that the entire cause of action arose at Cochin and not within Madras jurisdiction.
  • Argued that the trial would require all evidence to be produced in Madras, which would be highly impossible and expensive.
  • Claimed that defendants would suffer acute hardship if the suit were to be tried in Madras, whereas the plaintiff would not be inconvenienced if the suit were filed at Cochin where the plaintiff has a branch and distributor.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K. Murugesan v. Seethalakshmi (O.S Appeal Nos. 151, 165 and 166 of 1989, 1992-1-L.W. 277) Scope of Clause 12 of the Letters Patent regarding original jurisdiction and when leave to sue is required. Used to establish that leave is required only if cause of action arises in part within jurisdiction; also that defendant’s pleadings denying jurisdiction cannot be ignored.
Bengal A. & I. Corporation v. Corporation of Calcutta Construction of Clause 12 of the Letters Patent and jurisdiction when multiple defendants reside inside and outside jurisdiction. Quoted to demonstrate that all necessary defendants must be within jurisdiction for the Court to entertain suit and that claims abandoned against some defendants affect jurisdictional considerations.
In re. Lakshminarayana Chettiar (Full Bench of this Court) Definition of "cause of action". Referred to clarify that cause of action is a bundle of facts giving the plaintiff a right to relief.
State of Rajasthan v. Swaika Properties (AIR 1985 SC 1289) Definition and legal understanding of cause of action. Supported the Court's explanation of cause of action as facts necessary for plaintiff to prove to obtain judgment.
Seshatri Row v. Nawab Ka Askur Jung Aftal Dowlah Mushral Mulk (ILR 30 Madras 438) Principle of balance of convenience in refusing or granting leave under Clause 12. Confirmed that balance of convenience is a relevant consideration and that leave may be refused despite part cause of action arising within jurisdiction.
Parasaram v. Chitandas (AIR 1952 Calcutta 82) Application of balance of convenience in original jurisdiction cases. Reiterated the importance of considering convenience in jurisdictional decisions under Clause 12.
Bihar State Agro Industrial Development Corporation Ltd. v. Ram Chand Khosla (AIR 1982 Calcutta 537) Balance of convenience principle in jurisdictional matters. Used to support the view that courts should consider convenience in granting leave to sue under Clause 12.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by interpreting Clause 12 of the Letters Patent, which empowers the High Court of Madras to entertain suits if the cause of action arises wholly or in part within its original jurisdiction, or if the defendant resides or carries on business within such limits. The Court emphasized that leave to sue is required only if the cause of action arises in part within the jurisdiction.

The Court rejected the notion that a defendant’s denial of any part of the cause of action arising within Madras jurisdiction can be ignored. It referenced earlier judgments to affirm that all necessary defendants must be within jurisdiction and that the Court must consider the entire pleadings and facts.

The Court then focused on the principle of balance of convenience, explaining that even if part of the cause of action arises within the jurisdiction, the Court may refuse leave if it would cause undue hardship or inconvenience to the defendants. The Court cited precedents to confirm that the balance of convenience is a relevant consideration in such applications.

However, the Court noted that the learned single Judge had not properly adjudicated on all relevant facts and convenience considerations before refusing leave. The Court expressed that it would have examined the facts to determine whether the majority of transactions occurred within the Court's jurisdiction and whether the defendants’ plea of convenience was genuine or a tactic to defeat jurisdiction.

Since the learned single Judge did not conduct a full factual inquiry, the Court set aside the impugned order and remitted the matter for rehearing and decision in accordance with law, emphasizing the need for proper adjudication of all relevant facts and the balance of convenience.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the order refusing leave under Clause 12, and remitted the case to the Original Side of the Court for re-hearing and decision on the question of leave to sue, in accordance with law.

The direct effect is that the plaintiff may seek leave to sue in the Madras High Court after proper consideration of all facts and balance of convenience. No new precedent was established; the Court emphasized adherence to established principles and proper factual inquiry before granting or refusing leave under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent.

Show all summary ...

ORDER Mishra, J.

This appeal under clause 15 of the Letters patent is directed against the order in Application No: 1627 of 1989 refusing leave under Clause 12 thereof to sue in this Court, the defendants for recovery in a sum of Rs. 343,726-30. The plaintiff/appellant has alleged that most part of the cause of action for the suit has arisen within the city of Madras. The defendants, however, have said that the entire cause of action has arisen only at Cochin and not in Madras. Learned single Judge, Srinivasan, J. in his impugned judgment has said;

“In my opinion, it is not necessary to consider whether any part of the cause of action has arisen within the City of Madras. I propose to decide the matter on the assumption that part of the cause of action has arisen within the City of Madras.”.

2. Clause 12 of the Letters Patent which speaks about the Original jurisdiction as to suits, runs as follows:—

“And we do further ordain that the said High Court of Judicature at Madras, in exercise of its Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction, shall be empowered to receive, try, and determine suits of every description if, in the case of suits for land or other immovable property, such land or property shall be situated, or, in all other cases, if the cause of action shall have arisen, either wholly, or, in case the leave of the Court shall have been first obtained, in part, within the local limits of the Ordinary Original Jurisdiction of the said High Court, or if the defendant at the time of the commencement of the suit shall dwell or carry on business or personally work for gain, within such limits; except that the said High Court shall not have such original jurisdiction in cases falling within the jurisdiction of the Small Cause at Madras, in which the debt or damage, or value of the property sued for does not exceed one hundred rupees.”

The words “determine suits of every description if in all other cases, if the cause of action shall have arisen or, in case the leave of the court shall have been first obtained, in part, within the local limits of the Ordinary Original jurisdiction clearly establish the right of a litigant to institute a suit on the original side of this Court if the cause of action would have arisen wholly within the local limits of the Ordinary Original jurisdiction of the Court. The leave of the Court is required only in a case in which the cause of action would have arisen in part within the local limits of the Ordinary Original Jurisdiction. It is thus not possible to ignore the case of a litigant who decided to file the suit on the Original Side of the Court on the plea that most part of the cause of action had arisen within the city of Madras, only on the ground that the defendant had pleaded otherwise and alleged that no part of the cause of action had arisen in Madras but had arisen at Cochin. In K. Murugesan v. Seethalakshmi O.S Appeal Nos. 151, 165 and 166 of 1989 Judgment dated 18-6-1991 Since reported in 1992-1-L.W. 277 we had the occasion to examine the scope of Clause 12 of the Letters Patent to find out when this Court shall have jurisdiction to entertain a suit under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent. In our Judgment in the said cases we have noticed.

“The chartered High Courts of Calcutta, Bombay besides this Court, are having the original jurisdiction as found in Clause 12 of our Letters Patent. They have to find before a suit is entertained on Original Side that it satisfied the requirements of the land or other immovable property, in the case of suit for land or other immovable property, that the land or other immovable property is situated within the local limits of the ordinary original jurisdiction of the Court, and in all other cases whether the cause of action wholly arises within the local limits of extraordinary original jurisdiction, or in case the leave of the court is asked for, whether the cause of action arises in part within the local limits of the ordinary original jurisdiction of the court or not. Besides this, there would be no difficulty in entertaining a suit under Clause 12, if the defendant, at the time of commencement of the suit, dwelt or carried on business or personally worked for gain within the Ordinary Original Jurisdiction of this Court. The Court's special jurisdiction under its Letters Patent has been left free from some of the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, including Ss. 16, 17 and 20 by S. 120 theeof, for, the Letters Patent has not only fixed a territorial jurisdiction, but has in Clause 12 declared that in the case of suits for land or other immovable property such land or property should be found within its territorial jurisdiction and in all other cases if the cause of action is found either wholly or in part arising within the jurisdiction of the Court or the defendant is found at the time of the commencement of the suit dwelling or carrying on business or personally working for gain within such territory”

Although the case in O.S Appeal Nos. 151, 165 and 166 of 1989 was one in which the question had not directly arisen whether in deciding to grant leave, the pleadings of the defendant would be taken into consideration or not, we took notice of a celebrated judgment of the Calcutta High Court in Bengal A. & I. Corporation v. Corporation of Calcutta, to quote in some detail the law on the subject including the passage:

“On a correct construction of Cl. 12 of the Letters Patent, not all suits in which there are more then one defendant, not all of them being within jurisdiction, are liable to dismissed as against all including those who reside or carry on business within jurisdiction. Again, it is not correct to say that in a case in which the plaintiff abandons his claim either wholly or in part against some of the defendants, for determining the nature of the suit and the jurisdiction of the Court, the Court is to look at the plaint as originally filed and not as it stands after the claim has been abandoned as against some of the defendants wholly or in part. Neither reason nor authority warrants such a proposition. If the suit is on a single cause of action and there are more defendants than one, than all the defendants being necessary parties, having regard to the nature of the claim and the reliefs sought, then all the defendants must be within jurisdiction in order that the Court can entertain such a suit. In such a suit the Court cannot pass a decree against one and dismiss the suit against the other”.

3. In that very appeal we also considered as to what a cause of action means and recorded our considered opinion following the decision of a Full Bench of this Court in In re. Lakshminarayana Chettiar2 and a judgment of the Supreme Court State of Rajasthan v. Swaika Properties AIR 1985 SC 1289

“Cause of action is a fact which, if traversed, would be necessary for the plaintiff to prove in order to support his right to a judgment of the Court. In other words, it is a bundle of facts, which taken with law applicable to them, gives the plaintiff a right is relief against the defendant.”

The learned single Judge is, however, right in saying that in all cases where a part of the cause of action has arison within the jurisdiction of one court and the other part within the jurisdiction of some other court, the relevant question will be the balance of convenience, but then has said,

“In paragraph 5 of the counter-affidavit the defendant has stated that the entire evidence whether documentary or witnesses, has to be produced at Madras for conducting the trial which would be highly impossible apart from being expensive. The defendants will be subjected to acute hardship and loss on the other hand, the plaintiff will not be subjected to any hardship as the plaintiff is having a branch at Mattancherry, Cochin and their distributor Devika Chemicals (P) Ltd. is also at Cochin. The defendants have also referred to the necessity of summoning the records from Central Excise Department to speak to the supply of goods. Learned counsel for the plaintiff urges that there is no relevance and that it may not call for records from the Central Excise Department. But, it is not a matter which has to be considered at this stage, But, I am of the opinion that the defendants will be put to undue hardship if the suit is filed in this Court. On the other hand, since the plaintiff is having its branch office admittedly at Cochin, it will not be put to any inconvenience if the suit is filed in a competent Court at Cochin, where admittedly a part of the cause of action has arisen.”

4. The principle of balance of convenience, which is an extension of the doctrine ‘forum convenient’ has been considered in a judgment of this court in Seshatri Row v. Nawab Ka Askur Jung Aftal Dowlah Mushral Mulk ILR 30 Madras 438. It has been observed in the said Judgment,

“Having regard to the wording of article 12, it is clear that the fact that the cause of action arises in part within the local limits is not conclusive, and that, notwithstanding that the cause of action arises in part within the local limits, the Court may decline to give leave to sue”

XX XX XXX

“As regards the law of this country, so far as we are aware, it has never been held that the question of convenience is not a question which may be taken into consideration in dealing with applications under Clause 12, and we are certainly not prepared to hold that this question should be excluded from consideration.”

This view has been reiterated in several judgments of the Courts having original jurisdiction including the judgments of the Calcutta High Court in Parasaram v. Chitandas AIR 1952 Calcutta 82 and Bihar State Agro Industrial Development Corporation Ltd. v. Ram Chand Khosla AIR 1982 Calcutta 537. But then, in considering the balance of convenience the Court is required to see the plaint and the facts stated therein. The Court has to necessarily see the entire bundle of facts and then to determine the question of convenience. Stating though with respect to grant of interlocutory injunctions in Halsbury's Laws of England, Third Edition, Vol. 21 at pages 364 and 365, the balance of convenience is stated as follows:

“Where any doubt exists as to the plaintiff's right, or if his right is not disputed, but its violation is denied, the Court in determining whether an interlocutory injunction should be granted, takes into consideration the balance of convenience to the parties and the nature of the injury which the defendant, on the one hand, would suffer if the injunction was granted and he should ultimately turn out to be right, and that which the plaintiff, on the other hand, might sustain if the injunction was refused and he should ultimately turn out to be right. The burden of proof that the inconvenience which the plaintiff will suffer by the refusal of the injunction is greater than that which the defendant will suffer, if it is granted, lies on the plaintiff.

5. We do not say that in considering the balance of convenience as to the forum for instituting a suit it would be necessary (like the principles of injunction) to see the ultimate injury that a party may suffer but we do find support to our view and we state in no uncertain terms that in deciding whether to refuse leave or not, it would be necessary to see on facts and not on assumptions, who shall suffer-the plaintiff or the defendant-if the leave is granted or refused, as the case may be.

6. We would have proceeded ourselves to examine the facts pleaded on behalf of the plaintiff to see whether facts show that most of the transactions took place within the jurisdiction of this Court or a small part of the cause of action arose within the jurisdiction of this Court, for, if most of the transactions were done within the jurisdiction of this Court obviously the defendants found it convenient to transact their business for all purposes within the jurisdiction of this Court but only to defeat the grant of leave on the Original Side of this Court, the plea of convenience is raised. We would also have examined ourselves as to whether keeping in view the nature of the transactions between the parties from which transactions the present suit has arisen, it would be inconvenient to the defendants to defend themselves before this Court or would be inconvenient to the plaintiff if he is asked to go to institute the suit in Cochin as pleaded by the defendants. We, however, refrain for, it we do so, we shall usurp the jurisdiction and discretion of the learned single Judge, who is to decide whether to grant leave or not. Since we are of opinion that a proper adjudication is necessary on all relevant facts of the case before deciding whether to grant leave or not and since it has not been done in passing the impugned judgment we are inclined to interfere with the impugned order. The impugned order, for the said reason, is set aside. The case is remitted to the Original Side of this Court for a re-hearing and decision on the question whether leave should be granted or not, in accordance with law. This appeal is accordingly allowed. No costs.

RR/VCS