- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sundararajan v. Ashok Kumar
Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
These proceedings arise from M.C. 102/84, a petition under Section 125 Cr. P.C. filed by the respondents in the Court of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Chidambaram, seeking maintenance from the petitioner. The parties were married on 26-3-80. The first respondent lived with the petitioner briefly, then returned to her elder sister Ranganayaki's house in Chidambaram where she had been brought up by her sister and her husband (Dhamodharan, P.W.2). The first respondent stayed with the petitioner in Cuddalore for about six months during which the second respondent was conceived and was later born on 13-6-1981. The petitioner allegedly did not take the first respondent and the child back, filed a petition for divorce at Vellore and obtained an ex parte decree. The first respondent claimed maintenance (Rs. 500 per month for both and Rs. 1,000 per year for clothing), stating she was employed with a monthly pay of Rs. 175 and needed funds for the child's education and her own maintenance.
The petitioner admitted the marriage but denied the other averments, denied paternity of the second respondent, and alleged the first respondent lived in adultery with P.W.2. At the Magistrate's enquiry, the first respondent and other witnesses were examined and various exhibits (Exs. P.1–P.6; R.1–R.3, etc.) were marked. The Magistrate held that despite the ex parte divorce decree (Ex. R.2), the first respondent remained a "wife" entitled to maintenance and awarded her Rs. 150 per month; the Magistrate rejected the second respondent's claim, finding the child was not born to the petitioner.
The first respondent filed Crl. R.C. 62/86 before the Sessions Judge, Cuddalore seeking maintenance for the second respondent and enhanced maintenance for herself; the petitioner filed Crl. R.C. 50/86 challenging the Magistrate's award to the first respondent. The Sessions Judge, by a common order, partly allowed the revision by the first respondent, granted the second respondent maintenance of Rs. 75 per month, and confirmed the maintenance and quantum awarded to the first respondent. The petitioner's Crl. R.C. 50/86 was dismissed. Aggrieved, the petitioner filed Crl. R.C. 487/87 (challenging award to second respondent) and Crl. M.P. 8339/87 under Section 482 Cr. P.C. (challenging the award to the first respondent).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the order of the learned Sessions Judge granting maintenance to the respondents (both the first respondent and the second respondent) can be legally sustained.
- Whether an ex parte civil decree of divorce granted on the ground of adultery (Ex. R.2) disentitles the first respondent from claiming maintenance under Section 125 Cr. P.C., and how Section 127(2) Cr. P.C. should operate where a civil court has given such a decree.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The Sessions Judge erred in granting maintenance to the second respondent by setting aside the Magistrate's order.
- The ex parte decree for divorce (Ex. R.2), given by the Civil Court under Section 13(1)(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act on the ground of adultery, disentitles the first respondent from claiming maintenance.
Respondents' Arguments
- Ex. R.2 is an ex parte decree rendered without evidence from the respondent's side and therefore cannot properly be construed as a finding of adultery that would disentitle the first respondent from maintenance.
- The criminal court (proceedings under Section 125 Cr. P.C.) is not bound by the ex parte civil decree and can independently consider the evidence presented in the maintenance proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Zohara Khatoon v. Mohd. Ibrahim | Section 125 (referred to as Section 488 historically) carves out an independent sphere; it provides a summary machinery for determining maintenance and may exclude, to some extent, other Acts; however personal law questions (validity of marriage, mode of divorce) remain governed by personal law. | The Court used this authority to show that Chapter IX of the Cr.P.C. creates an independent scheme for maintenance claims and that criminal courts have a separate role to play; this supports the view that a civil decree does not automatically bar relief under Section 125. |
| Ramesh Chander Kaushan v. Veena Kaushal | As an abstract proposition, a final determination of a civil right by a Civil Court must generally prevail against a like decision by a Criminal Court. | The Court acknowledged the general principle but applied it alongside other authorities and statutory provisions (Section 127(2)) to explain that while civil decrees are important, they do not automatically bind the Magistrate dealing with maintenance under Section 125. |
| K. Narayana Rao v. Bhagyalakshmi (1984 Crl. L.J. 276) | The Magistrate dealing with maintenance under Section 125 should carefully examine and take into consideration decrees of the civil/matrimonial court, though the Magistrate is not strictly bound by such decrees; the Magistrate must exercise independent discretion. | The Court cited this authority to support the approach that the criminal court must consider civil decrees but retain its discretionary power to assess evidence and not be bound to "surrender its own discretion." |
| Fakruddin Shamsuddin v. Bai Jenab (AIR 1944 Bom. 11) | The Magistrate should not "surrender his own discretion" simply because the husband was armed with a Civil Court decree for restitution of conjugal rights (principle about not abdicating discretion to civil decrees). | The Court relied on this statement to reinforce that a Magistrate must independently assess claims under Section 125 and should not be mechanically influenced by civil decrees. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in a stepwise analysis grounded in both statutory provisions and precedents concerning the interplay between civil decrees and maintenance proceedings under Chapter IX of the Cr.P.C.:
- Scope and statutory framework: The Court emphasized that Section 125 Cr.P.C. (referred to historically as Section 488) establishes an independent summary mechanism for awarding maintenance. While personal law matters (validity of marriage, mode or cessation of marriage) must be determined according to personal law, Section 125 governs the quantum and circumstances for maintenance awards.
- Effect of civil decrees: The Court examined Section 127(2) Cr.P.C., which requires a Magistrate to consider whether an earlier civil court decision necessitates cancellation or variation of a maintenance order. The Magistrate must consider civil decisions but is not required to accept them uncritically; the provision is flexible and leaves room for evaluation.
- Precedent synthesis: The Court grouped earlier authorities to show the settled approach: civil decisions should be taken into account but do not automatically bind the Magistrate; each case depends on its facts; the Magistrate must exercise independent discretion.
- Assessment of the ex parte divorce decree (Ex. R.2): The Court closely inspected the divorce judgment which showed the respondent was set ex parte, petitioner examined as P.W.1, and the judgment recorded that allegations in the petition were found true based on P.W.1 and certain documents (A.1–A.3). The Court noted procedural and evidentiary shortcomings in Ex. R.2: the petitioner was not an eyewitness to the alleged adultery; the counter filed by the first respondent was not referred to; no issues were framed; the petitioner’s evidence was neither summarized nor discussed; the contents of documents were not referred to. For these reasons the civil decree was described as a "very formal matter" and placed on a different footing than a decree after contest.
- Concurrent findings in maintenance proceedings: Both the Magistrate and the Sessions Judge had reached conclusions, particularly that the first respondent was entitled to maintenance; those factual findings were concurrent. The Court held that under Section 482 Cr. P.C. the petitioner could not re-canvass the factual issue of adultery that had been considered by the courts below. The Sessions Judge had positively found no basis for holding the first respondent guilty of adultery with P.W.2.
- Evidence relevant to the first respondent's entitlement: The first respondent produced documentary evidence of her guardianship by P.W.2 (Ex. P.1 SSLC book showing P.W.2 as guardian) and the marriage invitation in P.W.2's name (Ex. P.2). The Court noted the personal history that the first respondent had been brought up by her sister and P.W.2 and that she had initially attempted to contest the divorce but could not continue the contest for lack of means. These facts supported the Courts below in not acting solely on the ex parte civil decree.
- Second respondent's claim: The Sessions Judge accepted Ex. P.5 (an out-patient chit from the Government Hospital at Cuddalore) as sufficient evidence that the first respondent lived with the petitioner around the time the second respondent was conceived. The Magistrate had rejected Ex. P.5 because it did not mention the petitioner’s address; the appellate court found that objection immaterial (an out-patient chit typically does not contain the husband's address). The trial and appellate courts’ appreciation of this evidence was held to be reasonable.
- Conclusion of analysis: Given the deficiencies in the ex parte civil decree and the concurrent factual findings by the Magistrate and Sessions Judge favoring maintenance, the Court found no illegality or error in the Sessions Judge's orders granting maintenance to both respondents.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court dismissed both the criminal revision petition and the miscellaneous petition. Concretely, the Court's final disposition was to dismiss Crl. Revision Petition 487/87 as well as Crl. M.P. 8339/87.
Direct implications:
- The maintenance orders granted by the Sessions Judge (maintenance to the first respondent as earlier awarded and maintenance of Rs. 75 per month to the second respondent) stand.
- The petitioner’s challenge—based principally on the ex parte civil decree of divorce (Ex. R.2) alleging adultery—was rejected insofar as it sought to defeat the criminal-court maintenance awards.
Broader implications: The opinion reiterates and applies established principles—drawn from precedent and statutory provisions—that while civil decrees are relevant (and Section 127(2) requires consideration), Magistrates exercising jurisdiction under Section 125 Cr. P.C. retain independent discretion to evaluate evidence. The decision does not purport to lay down a novel precedent beyond applying these established principles to the facts of this case.
1. These proceedings arise out of M.C. 102/84 filed by the respondents herein under Section 125 Cr. P.C. in the Court of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Chidambaram, seeking maintenance from the petitioner.
2. The claim was made on the averment that the first respondent was married to the petitioner on 26-3-80, they lived together in the house of the petitioner at Ranipet for three months, that in Adi 1980 she went to her elder sister Ranganayaki's house at Chidambaram, where, since she became fatherless even as a child, she had been brought up by her elder sister and her husband Dhamodharan, who had arranged and conducted her marriage, that the petitioner showed no interest in marital life and did not take her back, that the petitioner was then in Cuddaiore, where the first respondent lived with him for six months during which period, the second respondent was conceived, that she came to her elder sister's house for delivery and the second respondent was born 13.6.1981 but the petitioner never came and took back the respondents. Instead, he filed a petition for divorce at Vellore and since she had no means to conduct the case, she suffered an exparte decree and on the basis of that decree, the petitioner has married again and though she is employed in Nutritious Meal Centre, getting a monthly pay of Rs. 175/-she needs money for the expenses for the education of the second respondent, and some more money for her own maintenance, the petitioner having means had failed and neglected to maintain them. She had therefore, sought Rs. 500/- as monthly maintenance for them both and Rs. 1000/- per year for the expenses of clothing.
3. The petitioner resisted the claim, admitting the marriage with the first respondent but denying the other averments, as well as the paternity of the second respondent and alleged that the first respondent was living in adultery with her elder sister's husband Dhamodharan and on coming to know about it, he filed a petition in the Court of the Subordinate Judge, Vellore for divorce and the same had been decreed and the respondents have means to maintain themselves.
4. During the enquiry the first respondent was examined as P.W. 1, her eider sister's husband Dhamodbaran as P.W. 2 and a corroborating witness P.W. 3. Exs. P. 1 to P. 6 were marked. The petitioner examined himself, as R.W. 1 and Exs. R. 1 R. 3 were marked on his side. The learned Magistrate held that in spite of the exparte decree of divorce Ex. R. 2, the first respondent was still a 'wife' entitled for maintenance and accordingly ordered her monthly maintenance at the rate of Rs. 150/- Regarding the second respondent he held that the second respondent was not born to the petitioner and rejected the second respondent's claim for maintenance. The first respondent filed Crl. R.C. 62/86 before the Sessions Judge, Cuddnlore claiming maintenance for the second respondent and enhanced maintenance for herself, while the petitioner filed Cr. R.C. 50/86 challenging the award of maintenance to the first respondent. The learned Sessions Judge in a Common, order, partly allowed the revision filed by the first respondent and granted maintenance to the second respondent at the rate of Rs. 75/- per month and confirmed the maintenance and quantum awarded to the first respondent. Crl. R.C, 50/86 filed by the petitioner was therefore dismissed, Aggrieved with the granting of maintenance to the second repondent, the petitioner has filed Crl. R.C. 487/87 and challenging the award of maintenance to the first respondent, he has filed Crl. MP. No. 8339/87 under Section 482 Cr. P.C.
5. Thiru K.V. Sridharan, learned Counsel for the petitioner would contend that the learned Sessions Judge was in error in granting maintenance to the second respondent by setting aside the order of the learned Magistrate. In that regard, he further submitted that Ex. R. 2 the decree for divorce by the Civil Court under Section 13(l)(lb) of the Hindu Marriage Act on the ground of adultery, disentitled the first respondent from claiming maintenance.
6. Per contra, Thiru S. Shanmugavelayudham, learned Counsel for the respondents submitted that Ex. R. 2 being on exparte decree, based on no evidence, can never be construed as rendering a finding of adultery so as to disentitled the first respondent from claiming maintenance. According to the learned Counsel, a mere reading of Ex. R. 2 would show that the criminal Court could never be bound by a decision of the type rendered in Ex. R. 2.
7. The question that arises for consideration is whether the order of the learned Sessions Judge, granting maintenance to the respondents can be legally sustained.
8. As far as the first respondent is concerned, since the marriage between the parties and the fact of the respondent living separately are admitted the only question is whether there is material to hold that the first respondent was living in adultery with Dhamodharan P.W. 2. Even in the petition filed under Section 125 Cr.P.C., the first respondent had stated that she lost her father when she was a child and it was her elder sister Ranganayaki and her husband P.W. 2, who brought her up, conducted her marriage at their own expense and settled her in life. As P.W. 1, she has stated so. In proof of the same, she has filed Ex. P. 1, which is her S.S.L.C. Book, in which P.W. 2 is shown as her guardian. She has also filed Ex. P. 2 her marriage invitation, which is in the name of P.W. 2. It is further stated that, after the marriage was settled and before the marriage actually took place, the petitioner got one lakh of rupees under a lottery ticket and after this, he tried to avoid the marriage in the hope of getting a better alliance. The marriage was however, pushed through and the petitioner having been an unwilling party, stated living a luxurious life of his own, deciding to marry a second wife. The allegation of the petitioner is that the first respondent is living in adultery with P.W. 2. On the evidence adduced, both the Courts have held that the first respondent was entitled for maintenance, and had awarded maintenance to her. These findings of fact being concurrent this Court under Section 482 Cr. P.C, cannot permit the petitioner to re-canvass that issue.
9. A legal contention, is submitted that in the light of Ex. R. 2 the exparte decree of diverce, the first respondent is not entitled for maintenance. Reference is made to Section 127(2) Cr. P.C which is as follows :
"(2) Where it appears, to the Magistrate that, in consequence of any decision of a competent Civil Court, any order made under Section 125 should be cancelled or varied, he shall cancel the order or, as the case may be, vary the same accordingly."
On the basis of this on behalf of the petitioner, it is submitted, that a competent Civil Court having granted a divorce on the ground of adultery, it is not open to the Criminal Court under Section 125 Cr.P.C, to go behind the decision and try to recanvass the issue.
10. The relative scope of proceedings under Chapter IX of the Criminal Procedure Code and other proceedings under the personal law of the parties, had come up for consideration before the Supreme Court in Zohara Khatoon v. Mohd. Ibrahim, . The Court observed.
A perusal of Section 488 (the present Section 125) would clearly reveal that it carves out an independent sphere of its own and is a general law providing a summary machinery for determining the maintenance to be awarded by the Magistrate under the circumstances mentioned in the Section. The provision may not be inconsistent with other parallel Acts is so far as maintenance is concerned, but the Section undoubtedly excludes to some extent the application of any other Act. At the same time, it cannot be said that the personal law of the parlies is completely excluded for all purposes. For instance, where the validity of a marriage or mode of divorce or cessation of marriage under the personal law of a party is concerned that would have to be determined according to the said personal law. Thus, the exclusion by Section 488 (the present Section 125) extends only to the quantum of the maintenance and the circumstances under which it could be granted (brackets supplied).
11. Earlier, the Supreme Court in Ramesh Chander Kaushan v. Veena Kaushal, , dealing with Section 125, Cr, P.C, observed.
"Broadly stated and as an abstract proposition, it is valid to assert....that a final determination of a civil right by a Civil Court must prevail against a like decision by a Criminal Court."
12. A plain reading of Section 127(2), makes it clear, that it is incumbent on the part of the Magistrate who is faced with a decree of a Civil Court, to consider whether the earlier order of maintenance passed by him, should be cancelled or varied in compliance with the decision of the Civil Court. As such, the provision requires the Magistrate to consider the decision of the Civil Court vis-a-vis his own order of maintenance. He cannot ignore the decision of the Civil Court, nor is he to blindly accept the decision as such. A learned Judge of the Karnataka High Court in K. Narayana Rao v. Bhagyalakshmi 1984 Crl. L.J. 276 faced with a situation such as this, stated.
This is not to say that it should simply neglect the decree, if any, obtained by the husband in the matrimonial Court. The Court dealing with the maintenance claim under Section 125 will have to carefully examine and take into consideration such decrees also, though as stated above, it is not bound by the findings. It may be difficult to give instances where such decree or the observations made in such orders, touching questions relevant for consideration under Section 125, will be sufficient to negative the claim of the wife. All that can be said is as observed by Chief Justice Beaunmont in Fakruddin Shamsuddin v. Bai Jenab, (AIR 1944 Bom. 11): (1944-45 Cr. L J. 271), that the Magistrate should not "surrender his own discretion" simply because the husband was armed with a Civil Court decree for restitution of conjugal rights".
13. The above decisions would show that each case would depend on its own facts. Though an exparte decree, is as much executable as a decree given after contest, so far as the present proceedings are concerned decree will stand on a slightly different footing from a decree rendered after contest. There could be several reasons why a decree ultimately turns out to be an exparte decree. The contesting party might be ignorant of his rights and remedies, might not have means to litigate and so on. On little or no evidence, exparte decree might ultimately come into existence. The criminal Court therefore, keeping in mind, that despite the several personal laws relating to maintenance, the legislature had found it necessary to put down Chapter IX in the Criminal Procedure Code, creating additional rights and entrusting to the criminal Courts, the task of enforcing them, with the machinery available to them, is to cancel or vary the order of maintenance earlier passed by it, only if it appears to the Criminal Court, that consequent to the decision of the Civil Court, its earlier order requires cancellation or alteration. It is not the legislative intent that any hard and fast rule should be laid down on this aspect, since the legislature itself, has left Section 127(2) flexible.
14. Coming to the instant case, the first respondent has stated that she had no means to contest the divorce proceedings. Initially she had engaged a Counsel and had filed a counter Ex. P. 4 but later she had not been able to pursue it. She had therefore been set exparte. Ex. R. 2 is now to be perused to find out, whether maintenance has to be denied to the first respondent on account of the decision rendered therein, Ex. R. 2 the judgment, is extracted hereunder in its entirely.
"Petition is posted today for oral evidence of both sides. Petitioner is ready for enquiry with his Counsel. Respondent called absent. Counsel for the Respondent has not turned up No representation on Respondent's side. Respondent is set exparte. Petitioner is examined as P.W. 1. Ex. A. 1 to A. 3 marked. Heard, Allegations in the petition are found true in the light of evidence of P.W. 1 and the documents Exhibits A. 1 to A. 3 Hence the petition is allowed with costs"
15. The above judgment would show that the learned Subordinate Judge has made a very formal matter out of it. The petitioner is not an eye witness to the alleged adultery. The first respondent from her childhood had been living with her sister and P.W. 2 is shown as guardian even in the S.S.L.C. Book, produced by her here. Naturally the wedding invitation Ex. P. 2, also produced by her here, is in his name. The oral evidence of the petitioner in the divorce O.P. proved nothing, so far as the adultery was concerned. Ex. A. 1 in the divorce O.P. is the marriage invitation, Ex. P. 2 here. A. 2 is a notice issued by the petitioner's Counsel to the respondent and A. 3 is the postal acknowledgement signed by the first respondent. It is on this material, that the learned Subordinate Judge holds that the allegation of adultery made in the petition is found true in the light of the evidence of P.W. 1 and documents Exs. A. 1 to A. 3. In Ex. R. 2, there is no reference to the counter filed by the first respondent and to its contents. No issue have been framed. The evidence of the petitioner is neither summarised nor discussed for being either accepted or rejected. Nor are the contents of the documents referred to. Neither of the Courts below had held that the first respondent was guilty of adultery. Rightly the Courts below declined to act upon this exparte decree of divorce. They had instead, appreciated the evidence adduced before them on this aspect and the learned Sessions Judge has given a positive finding, that there is no basis for holding that the respondent is not guilty of adultery with P.W. 21 find no illegality or error in the learned Sessions Judge holding so. The first respondent therefore, is entitled for maintenance as found by the learned Sessions Judge.
16. Regarding the second respondent, the learned Sessions Judge has found that Ex. P. 5 the out-patient chit of the Government Hospital at Cuddalore, is sufficient to prove that the first respondent lived with the petitioner at or about that time when the second respondent was concieved. The only reason given by the learned Magistrate for rejecting Ex. P. 5 is that, the address of the petitioner is not mentioned in it. No out-patient chit ever contains the address of the husband of the patient. I see no perversity or error in the finding of the learned Sessions Judge awarding maintenance to the second respondent.
17. In the result, the Crl. Revision Petition 487/87 as well as the Crl. M.P. 8339/87 are dismissed.
Alert