Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Computer Graphics Pvt. Ltd. v. Union Of India

Madras High Court
Nov 14, 1990
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner imports jumbo rolls of graphic art films after paying customs and auxiliary duties. The jumbo rolls are slit into various widths (e.g., 20", 30", 40"), cut into various lengths (e.g., 10 feet, 200 feet), packed in separate cartons and marketed in India.

On 28-7-1987 the third respondent directed the petitioner to take out a Central Excise licence, asserting that the slitting and cutting constituted "manufacture." The petitioner challenged that direction. On 5-9-1988 the Central Board of Excise and Customs (second respondent) issued a clarification stating that cutting/slitting of duty-paid imported jumbo rolls into smaller sizes would not amount to "manufacture" for central excise purposes; accordingly the direction was not pursued at that time.

Subsequently, the third respondent renewed the insistence (communication dated 16-6-1989) based on a later Board letter dated 12-5-1989 which relied on the Supreme Court decision in Empire Industries Ltd. v. Union of India and took the position that the effect of the operation on the commodity is material in deciding whether an operation is a manufacturing process. The Board argued that conversion of jumbo rolls into flats could amount to manufacture because the flats fall under a different tariff entry.

The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging the direction. The writ petition was admitted and kept pending for nearly a year at the time of the opinion. The principal issue for decision was whether the petitioner's cutting/slitting activities constituted a manufacturing process that would require a Central Excise licence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner's activity of cutting and slitting imported duty-paid jumbo rolls of graphic art film into smaller sizes (including flats) constitutes "manufacture" for the purposes of Central Excise law.
  2. Whether, consequent upon any finding on manufacture, the petitioner is required to obtain a Central Excise licence.
  3. Whether the existence of separate tariff entries for rolls and for flats (Tariff Entry 37.02 and 37.01 respectively) can, by themselves, be used to hold that cutting rolls into flats amounts to manufacture.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as summarized in the opinion)

  • The test for liability to take out a Central Excise licence is whether the person carries on an activity which can be prescribed as "manufacture" — not merely whether there exists a tariff entry for the commodity.
  • The Board's earlier clarification dated 5-9-1988 expressly stated that slitting, cutting into required lengths and even perforation of duty-paid imported jumbo rolls of certain films would not amount to "manufacture" for central excise purposes; the petitioner relies on this view.
  • Mere cutting of a longer length of film into shorter lengths or cutting into flats does not produce a distinct or different commodity used for a different purpose; therefore no manufacturing process is involved.
  • The presence of a separate tariff entry for flats does not convert the physical act of cutting into a manufacturing process.

Respondents' Arguments (as summarized in the opinion)

  • The clarification issued by the Board under Section 37B of the Central Excises and Salt Act is binding on the Central Excise Officer making assessment and the petitioner should pursue alternative remedies (appeal to Appellate Collector or Tribunal) rather than bypass them.
  • The petitioner engages in a process of manufacture because it converts jumbo rolls (an identifiable commodity) into a distinct and different commodity known in the market as flats; therefore the Board's later clarification (12-5-1989) relying on Empire Industries is correct and a licence is required.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Empire Industries Ltd. v. Union of India The Board relied on the decision to assert that the effect of an operation on the commodity is material in determining whether the operation constitutes part of manufacture. The court noted that the Board invoked this decision to justify treating the conversion of rolls into flats as manufacture but the court did not accept that reliance as sufficient to convert mere cutting into a manufacturing process; the court rejected the contention that tariff entries alone could sustain the requirement of a licence.
Union of India v. Delhi Cloth and General Mills States that 'manufacture' as a verb is generally understood to mean "bringing into existence a new substance" and does not mean merely to produce some minor change in a substance. The court applied this principle to conclude that mere cutting of jumbo rolls into flats does not bring into existence a new substance and therefore does not constitute 'manufacture' for central excise purposes.
Brakes India Ltd. v. Superintendent of Central Excise Holds that 'manufacture' implies a change that results in a distinct and different commodity; processes incidental or ancillary to completion of a manufactured product may amount to manufacture; this is linked to Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act. The court relied on this exposition to reason that manufacture requires a change producing a distinct and different commodity; because the cutting of jumbo rolls into flats does not produce such a distinct and different commodity, the act does not amount to manufacture under Section 2(f).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying the operative facts: the petitioner imports duty-paid jumbo rolls of graphic art film and restricts its activity to slitting and cutting these rolls into smaller widths and lengths (flats), which are then packed and sold. The principal alleged manufacturing operation was the cutting of jumbo rolls into flats.

The court reviewed the administrative history: an initial direction by the third respondent to take out a Central Excise licence (28-7-1987), an administrative clarification by the Board dated 5-9-1988 stating that slitting, cutting and perforation of duty-paid imported jumbo rolls did not constitute manufacture for excise purposes, and a later Board communication dated 12-5-1989 which, invoking Empire Industries, took the contrary position insofar as conversion into flats was concerned.

Turning to the legal test, the court cited authoritative precedents (Union of India v. Delhi Cloth and General Mills and Brakes India Ltd.) explaining that 'manufacture' ordinarily means bringing into existence a new substance or producing a distinct and different commodity as the end result of one or more processes. The court emphasized that not every change in a substance qualifies as manufacture; the change must result in a distinct and different commodity.

Applying that test to the facts, the court found it "inconceivable" that mere cutting of jumbo roll films into similar lengths (flats) would amount to manufacture. The Board itself had previously held that cutting and slitting into smaller rolls would not amount to manufacture. The court reasoned that the mere existence of separate tariff entries for rolls (Tariff Entry 37.02) and flats (Tariff Entry 37.01) does not, by itself, transform the act of cutting into a manufacturing process. Tariff entries identify resultant products of manufacture; they do not create manufacture where none exists.

Therefore, where the petitioner's activity is confined to cutting jumbo rolls into flats and plates (without any process resulting in a new or distinct commodity), the activity does not meet the legal test for 'manufacture' and cannot be used to compel the petitioner to obtain a Central Excise licence.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The direction that persons like the petitioner should take out a Central Excise licence is set aside insofar as the activity is confined to cutting jumbo rolls into flats and plates of smaller sizes.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The petitioner is not required to obtain a Central Excise licence for the limited activity of cutting/slitting imported duty-paid jumbo rolls into smaller lengths and flats, as that activity does not amount to 'manufacture' under the principles applied by the court.
  • The court rejected the respondents' reliance on the existence of separate tariff entries as sufficient to establish manufacture; tariff classification alone cannot convert a non-manufacturing operation into manufacture.
  • No broader precedent beyond the application of existing principles was purportedly created by this order; the decision addresses the particular legal consequence of the facts presented (and the opinion ends by ordering the writ petition in the petitioner's favour and awarding no costs).

No costs.

Show all summary ...

1. Petitioner imports from abroad Jumbo rolls of Graphic art films after payment of customs duty and auxiliary duty. Thereafter, the jumbo rolls are slit into various widths such as 20", 30" and 40" and cut into various lengths of 10 feets 200 feet etc., and packed in separate cartons and marketed in India.

2. In Section 11 under the Heading 37 of the Central Excise Tariff, photographic and Cinematographic rules are specified.

3. On 28-7-1987, the third respondent called upon the petitioner to take out a Central Excise Licence stating that the process of slitting and cutting of Jumbo roll films into smaller sizes would amount of to "manufacture". While the petitioner was agitating the validity of this direction by the third respondent, the Central Board of Excise and Customs (second respondent) issued a clarification in their letter F. No. 11/1/88 CX. 3, dated 5-9-1988. The second respondent clarified that the process of cutting into smaller sizes and repacking of jumbo rolls of sensitised photographic paper on which the customs duty including C.V. duty was paid would not amount to "manufacture" for the purpose of levying Central Excise duty. In view of this clarification, the direction given by the third respondent to the petitioner to take out a Central Excise Licence was not pursued.

4. However, the third respondent by his communication dated 16-6-1989 insisted that the petitioner should take out a Central Excise licence. This order apparently was because of a subsequent clarification given by the second respondent in their letter F.No. 119/1/89 CX. 3, dated 12-5-1989. The second respondent has stated that in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in Empire Industries Ltd. v. Union of India , the petitioner should take out a licence because whatever may be the operation, it is the effect of the operation on the commodity that is material for the purpose of determining whether the operation constitutes such a process which will be part of manufacture. The Second Respondent-Board held that though cutting and slitting into smaller rolls may not amount to a process of 'manufacture' because no distinct product emerged as a result of cutting and slitting when the said Graphic Art films in jumbo rolls are converted into plates and film in flat form, then the said product has to be held to be the resultant product of a manufacturing process in view of the changed Entry in the Tariff. In Chapter 37, Tariff Entry 37.01 reads as follows :-

"Photographic plates and film in the flat, sensitised, unexposed, of any material other than paper, paper board of textiles; instant print film in the flat, sensitised, unexposed, whether or not in packs."

Tariff Entry 37.02 reads as follows :

"Photographic film in rolls, sensitised, unexposed, or of any material other than paper, paper board or textiles; instant print film in rolls, sensitised, unexposed."

5. It was the case of the second Respondent-Board that since manufacture of photographic films in rolls (jumbo rolls) fall under Tariff Entry 37.02 and is attracted to Central Excise duty at the rate prescribed for that Entry, yet, for photographic films of the description mentioned in Tariff Entry 37.01, separate rate of duty prescribed and hence, when jumbo rolls films are converted into photographic plates and films in flat form, the petitioner who so converts the jumbo films can be held to be engaged in a process of 'manufacture' and in that event, the petitioner has to take out a Central Excise licence.

6. Mr. Habibullah Badsha, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner would contend that the test for the liability to take out a Central Excise licence is not whether there is any Entry in the Central Excise Tariff Act regarding a commodity, but whether the concerned person carries on an activity which can be prescribed as 'manufacture'. He relies on the clarification given by the second Respondent-Board on 5-9-1988, wherein it is stated as follows :

"The Ministry has, in consultation with the office of the Controller and Auditor General of India, taken a view earlier that the process of cutting into similar sizes and repacking of jumbo rolls of sensitised photographic paper on which the duty of customs including C.V. duty has been paid, would not amount to 'manufacture' for the purpose of levying Central Excise duty. On the same lines, this Ministry is also of the view that the process of slitting, into required width and cutting into required length of duty-paid imported jumbo rolls of cinematographic films, graphic art film, industrial X-ray films and medical X-ray films cannot be treated as process of 'manufacture' for the purpose of levying Central Excise duty. It has been reported by you that, in the case of duty paid imported jumbo rolls of cinematographic film, the process of perforation is also carried out in addition to the process of cutting and slitting. The Board is of the view that the process of perforation also cannot be treated as a process of manufacture since the cinematographic films in question will remain cinematographic film only both before and after perforation. You are advised to take suitable action in accordance with the above guidelines with regard to assessment of the goods in question."

He would contend that the second respondent-Board as well as the Ministry were of the confirmed view that not only the process of slitting into required width, but also cutting into required length would not amount to a process of 'manufacture' for the purpose of levy of Central Excise duty. He would state that the above view has stood the test of time for a consideration period. However, by the subsequent clarification dated 12-5-1989, the second respondent-Board though would admit that cutting and slitting into smaller rolls would not amount to a process of 'manufacture' in respect of graphic art films (it would even go to the extent of stating that cutting into flats would not amount to 'manufacturing' process and in respect of sensitised photographic paper) would nevertheless held that cutting into flats of jumbo rolls of graphic art film would amount to manufacturing process. The petitioner would state that no manufacturing process is involved by mere cutting of a longer length of film into shorter length or cutting it into smaller sizes of flats. The petitioner would plead that no distinct or different commodity used for a different purpose emerges by reason of mere cutting of longer roll film into shorter flats. He would further contend that merely because there is a separate Entry for flats, the second respondent-Board cannot come to the conclusion that cutting rolls into flats would amount to a process of 'manufacture'.

7. Mr. Jayachandran appearing for the respondents would contend that the clarification given by the second respondent-Board under Section 37B of the Central Excises and Salt Act is binding on the Central Excise Officer, who is making an order of assessment and it is not even binding on the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) and in any event, the petitioner can agitate these questions either before the Appellate Collector or before the Tribunal and the alternative remedy being efficacious should not be allowed to be by-passed. He would further contend that the petitioner engages itself in a process of manufacture because it is converting jumbo rolls which are identifiable as a separate commodity into a distinct and different commodity known in the market as flats and therefore, the clarification given by the second respondent-Board is correct.

8. Since the writ petition has already been admitted and has been kept pending for nearly a year, it would not be fair to dismiss the writ petition on the ground that the petitioner should exhaust the alternative remedy by appealing before the Appellate Collector of Tribunal. The matter for decision does not involve any complicated question of fact.

9. The main question for consideration is, whether the petitioner carries on any manufacturing process ? It has already been seen that what the petitioner does in to import jumbo rolls of graphic art film and it cuts these films into sheets of various sizes which are thereafter packed and sold in market. The alleged manufacture is the cutting of jumbo rolls into shorter lengths called flats.

10. In deciding whether there is any manufacture, the following decision of the Supreme Court on this aspect has to be referred to in Union of India v. Delhi Cloth and General Mills it was held thus :

"The word 'manufacture' used as a verb is generally understood to mean as "bringing into existence a new substance" and does not mean merely "to produce some change in a substance" however minor in consequence the change may be :

In Brakes India Ltd. v. Superintendent of Central Excise [1986 (26) ELT 211], a Division Bench of this Court has held as follows :

"'Manufacture' implies a change though every change is not manufacture. If by a process a change is effected in a product which was not there previously and which change facilitates the utility of the product for which it is meant, then the process not a simple one but a process incidental or ancillary to the completion of a manufactured product. Commonly, 'Manufacture' is the end result of one or more processes through which the original commodity is made to pass. The nature and extent of processing may vary from one product to another and there could be several stages of processing and different kinds of processing depending upon the utility for which the end product is meant. Any process if it is incidental and ancillary to the completion of manufactured product, it will certainly amount to 'manufacture' within the meaning of Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act."

It is, therefore, obvious that as commonly understood the word 'manufacture' would mean a process, the end result of one or more process through which the original commodity is made to pass, resulting in a distinct and different commodity.

11. Deciding in the light of the law so laid down, is would be inconceivable to conclude that mere cutting of jumbo roll films into similar lengths called flats would amount to a manufacturing process. In fact, the second respondent-Central Board itself has in unequivocal terms held that cutting and slitting into smaller rolls would not amount to a process of manufacture. If that were so, cutting jumbo roll films into smaller sizes not in the form of rolls, but in the form of flats could ever not be held an amounting to manufacturing process.

12. The contention of the respondents that merely because there is a separate Tariff Entry for the flats as distinct from jumbo rolls, the flats cut from jumbo rolls can be classified as a manufactured product, cannot be sustained. Tariff Entry 37.01 and 37.02 deal with two different resultant products of manufacture. If a person manufactures photographic film rolls, such manufacturing process would attract the levy of duty under Entry 37.01. If another person manufactures photographic flats and films, then that manufacturing process would attract Tariff Entry 37.01. But, if photographic flats or films are not manufactured at all, but only made out of jumbo rolls by cutting into smaller pieces, then there being no manufacturing process involved, Tariff Entry 37.01 cannot be made use of to hold that the petitioner should take out a licence.

13. Since the main question involved for decision, viz., whether by cutting jumbo rolls into smaller flats, the petitioner is manufacturing a new and different product has been answered in the negative, it follows that the direction given by the second respondent-Board stating that persons like the petitioner should take out a Central Excise licence cannot be sustained so long as what the petitioner does, is confined to cutting jumbo rolls into flats and plates of smaller sizes. This writ petition accordingly ordered in the above terms. No costs.