- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Subba Naicker v. Durairaj
1. This revision is directed against the order of the learned District Munsif, Manamadurai, passed on 30th November, 1982 allowing the execution to proceed and fixing a date for proclamation and sale. The respondent obtained a decree in O.S 130 of 1973 on the file of the District Munsif, Manamadnrai, against the revision petitioner for Rs. 3,500. E.P 103 of 1982 was filed by the decree-holder to realise the amount of Rs 7,126.15. The decree-holder attached three items of properties worth about more than a lakh. The trial Court ordered sale of the property notwithstanding the fact that it was brought to the notice of the court that for a decree debt of Rs. 7,000 and odd, properties worth several lakhs cannot be brought to sale.
2. From the records it is seen that the judgment-debtor, namely, the revision petitioner has valued first item at Rs. 20,000, the second item at Rs. 4,500 and the third item at Rs. 3,500. The value given by the revision petitioner judgment-debtor is mentioned in the sale proclamation. The Amin has also valued items 1, 2 and 3 at Rs. 66,800. Rs. 28,000 and Rs. 22,800 respectively.
3. The contention of the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner is that the learned District Munsif has not followed the provisions of O. 21, R. 64, C.P.C and there is therefore excesive execution. Even at the outset, I must point out that no application for proceeding under O. 21, R. 64, C.P.C was filed before the trial Court. It is not disputed that the properties in question were attached. As the properties attached are separate items, the court, in my view, cannot sell more than such portion as may be necessary to satisfy the decree. The Supreme Court in T.P.S Reddi v. Padmavathamma,1 while dealing with the words ‘necessary to satisfy the decree’ occurring in O. 21, R. 64, C.P.C observes that those words clearly indicate that no sale can be allowed beyond the decretal amount mentioned in the sale proclamation and that where the sale fetches a price equal to or higher than the amount mentioned in the sale proclamation and is sufficient to satisfy the decree, no further sale should be held and the Court should stop it at that stage. In this case, several items are brought to sale, in execution of the decree. The execution itself was for Rs. 7,126. It would therefore be sufficient if item No. 3 is first sold and that if it is found that the sale does not fetch a price sufficient to cover the decree amount mentioned in the proclamation of sale, the court can then auction item No. 2. If again the sale proceeds are not sufficient to satisfy the decree then sale of item I can be proceeded with. If a sale of all items is held that would cause considerable prejudice to the judgment-debtor. As the Court has not applied the provisions of O. 21, R. 64, C.P.C which goes to the root of the matter of jurisdiction, this Court has necessarily to interfere with the order passed by it. On that view, the civil revision petition is allowed and order is set aside and the matter is remitted to the court below. The Court will order proclamation and sale of item No. 3 first and if it is found that the sale proceeds are not sufficient to satisfy the decree amount, then the sale of other items may be ordered. There will be no order as to costs.
VCS.
Alert