Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

The State Of Tamil Nadu v. Gopal Nair And Sons

Madras High Court
Oct 15, 1981
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision concerns the classification of shaving cream sold by the assessee for the assessment year 1972-73 under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959. The assessee sold shaving cream manufactured by M/s. Hindustan Lever Ltd. The primary issue was whether this shaving cream fell under entry 37 of the First Schedule, which included soaps and related products, or some other entry. The Tribunal had held that the shaving cream fell within entry 37, attracting a tax rate of 5½ per cent. However, the assessee contested this classification.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the shaving cream sold by the assessee falls within entry 37 of the First Schedule to the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, for the assessment year 1972-73.
  2. Whether shaving cream should be classified as soap or as a distinct commodity for the purposes of sales tax.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • The shaving cream does not fall within entry 37, which covers soaps and related products.
  • Commercially, shaving cream is distinct from soap and would not be supplied if a customer asked for soap.
  • The legislative introduction of entry 51-B in 1977 specifically including shaving creams indicates a legislative intention to treat shaving cream differently from soap.
  • The precedent cited by the opposing party (State Of Gujarat v. Prakash Trading Co.) concerning shampoo as a liquid soap is not applicable since shampoo and shaving cream are different commodities.

Tribunal's View

  • The Tribunal had taken the view that shaving cream fell within the scope of entry 37, classifying it as soap for taxation purposes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State Of Gujarat v. Prakash Trading Co., Ahmedabad, [1972] 30 STC 348 (SC) Determination whether shampoo falls within the category of soap. Distinguished from the present case as shampoo is a liquid soap with essential soap ingredients, whereas shaving cream is a different commodity not fitting the soap category.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the entries in the First Schedule applicable during the relevant period. Entry 37 covered soaps and related products, while entry 51 covered scents and perfumes but did not include shaving creams until the introduction of entry 51-B in 1977. The court noted that the legislative introduction of a separate entry for shaving cream in 1977 indicates an intention to treat shaving cream as distinct from soap. The court emphasized that classification must be guided by commercial nomenclature; in commercial parlance, shaving cream is not considered soap. The Tribunal's classification of the shaving cream under entry 37 was therefore incorrect. Furthermore, the court distinguished the precedent concerning shampoo, clarifying that shampoo’s classification as soap does not extend to shaving cream. Based on this analysis, the court concluded that the shaving cream should not be taxed under entry 37 but rather under the multi-point levy applicable to shaving cream as a separate category.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is allowed.

The court held that shaving cream sold by the assessee does not fall within entry 37 of the First Schedule to the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, for the assessment year 1972-73. Instead, shaving cream is a distinct commodity, and the Tribunal's contrary classification was erroneous. The direct effect is that the shaving cream should not be taxed as soap under entry 37. No new precedent beyond this case’s decision was established.

Show all summary ...

Sethuraman, J.:— In this revision, the only point for consideration is whether the shaving cream sold by the assessee falls within entry 37 of the First Schedule to the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, for the assessment year 1972-73. The cream that is sold by the assessee is manufactured by M/s. Hindustan Lever Ltd. Entry 37 of the First Schedule as in force in the relevant year runs as follows:

“All kinds of soaps (excluding hand-made soaps), soap flakes, soap powders, detergent powders and liquids and metal polishing bars.”

2. The Tribunal has taken the view that it did fall within the scope of entry 37. At the relevant time, there was another entry, numbered 51, running as follows:

“Scents and perfumes, powders, snows (including all purpose creams and cold and vanishing creams) and scented hair oils.”

3. While, if the article fell within entry 37, the tax payable was 5½ per cent at the point of first sale in the State. If it fell within item 51, the tax was 12 per cent at the point of first sale. The cream under consideration did not also fall within entry 51. Now item 51-B has been introduced by Tamil Nadu Act 7 of 1977 and the entry runs as follows:

“Shaving sets (with or without contents), razors, safety-razors, razor-blades, shaving-brushes and shaving creams.”

4. The sales are taxable at 8 per cent at the point of first sale in the State. Thus, shaving creams have been brought within the scope of the First Schedule only in the year 1977. The cream cannot be classified as soap as if it did so entry 51-B would not have been introduced so as to include shaving cream. Thus, even the legislative intention appears to be to treat shaving creams differently from soap and that is how shaving creams have been specifically brought into the ambit of the First Schedule to entry 51-B.

5. The question as to whether a particular article or commodity falls within the scope of a particular expression used in the Sales Tax Act has to be determined with its nomenclature in commercial parlance. In commercial parlance, if a person goes and asks for soap, he would not be given shaving cream. The cream under consideration is commercially a different commodity. It, therefore, follows that the Tribunal, in so far as it held that the shaving creams fell within the scope of entry 37, is clearly wrong, and therefore, the article could only be treated as coming within the multi-point levy.

6. The learned counsel drew our attention to the decision in State Of Gujarat v. Prakash Trading Co., Ahmedabad , [1972] 30 STC 348 (SC). In that case, the question was whether shampoo fell within the category of soap. The Supreme Court pointed out that shampoo is a kind of liquid soap and has all the essential ingredients of a soap. Shampoo is different from a shaving cream and we do not consider that a shaving cream can be considered to be either liquid or any category of soap. The collocation of the expression in the entry considered by the Supreme Court was also different. In these circumstances, we do not think it possible to apply the decision of the Supreme Court to the facts of the present case. The result is, the revision petition succeeds. In the circumstances, there will be no order as to costs.

7. Petition allowed.