Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

R. S. K. V. Raghavan... v. G. R. Gopal & Co, By...

Madras High Court
Sep 19, 1980
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant's father, Santhanakrishna Naidu, began manufacturing and selling a medicinal oil under the name R. S. Krishna & Co. around 1918, using a trade mark containing the words "Thennamarakkudi oil." This mark was registered under No. 89873 in 1949. After the appellant's father's death, the appellant continued the business and use of the mark. In or about October 1952, the first respondent began using a similar mark also containing "Thennamarakkudi oil" for medicinal oil preparations and later registered the mark under No. 164933 in 1954. The appellant issued a legal notice to the first respondent demanding cessation of use, but the respondent continued using the mark. The appellant filed an application under Section 36 of the Trade and Merchandise Act seeking rectification of the register by removing or deleting the words "Thennamarakkudi oil" from the respondent's mark, alleging infringement and likelihood of public confusion.

The Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks dismissed the application in 1961 on grounds that the appellant failed to prove distinctiveness of the word "Thennamarakkudi" and that it was a geographical name not subject to exclusive rights. The appellant's appeal to Venkatadri, J. was dismissed on similar grounds. However, the Letters Patent Appeal (L.P.A No. 66 of 1965) was allowed on the procedural ground that the appellant should not be required to prove invalidity of his own registration but that the respondent must prove non-distinctiveness. The matter was remitted for fresh consideration.

Upon reconsideration, the Assistant Registrar again rejected the application in 1976, holding that "Thennamarakkudi oil" was a common descriptive expression for medicinal oil and not distinctive of the appellant's goods. The appellant challenged this decision in the present appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the words "Thennamarakkudi oil" in the respondent’s registered trade mark are distinctive of the appellant’s goods or are a common descriptive term and geographical name not subject to exclusive trade mark rights.
  2. Whether the appellant can claim exclusive rights in the word "Thennamarakkudi" contained in his registered label mark, despite it being a geographical name and not separately registered as a trade mark.
  3. Whether the respondent’s use and registration of the mark containing "Thennamarakkudi oil" amounts to infringement or is permissible as the term is publici juris (common to the trade).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant claimed prior continuous use of a trade mark containing "Thennamarakkudi oil" since 1918 and registration of the mark in his father's name.
  • The appellant contended that the word "Thennamarakkudi" formed an essential and distinctive part of the trade mark and that the respondent’s use infringed this right and caused public confusion.
  • The appellant argued that the Assistant Registrar exceeded the remit order by dismissing the application on the ground that "Thennamarakkudi" is a geographical name, rather than considering evidence on distinctiveness.
  • The appellant submitted that the evidence did not justify the finding that "Thennamarakkudi" was a common or non-distinctive name for medicinal oil.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent contended that "Thennamarakkudi" is a geographical name of a village where medicinal oil preparations have been made and sold for over half a century.
  • The respondent argued that the term "Thennamarakkudi oil" is commonly used descriptively by various merchants in the region and is not distinctive of the appellant’s goods.
  • The respondent maintained that the appellant cannot monopolize a geographical name and that the use of the term by others, including the respondent, is legitimate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Registrar of Trade Marks v. Ashok Chandra Rakhit Ltd, A.I.R 1998 S.C. 558 Registration of a distinctive label as a whole does not confer exclusive rights in any particular word contained therein. The Court applied this principle to hold that the appellant's registration of a label containing "Thennamarakkudi" did not grant exclusive rights to the word itself apart from the entire mark.
Ford v. Forest A trade mark originally exclusive may become publici juris (common to the trade) if it is widely used and no longer deceives the public. The Court relied on this to conclude that the term "Thennamarakkudi oil" had become publici juris due to widespread use by multiple traders, extinguishing any exclusive rights.
Tujnana Smalls Tm2 (cited through Graham, J.) Geographical names that are generally used by multiple traders should not be monopolized by one trader, unless the name is used fancifully and has acquired distinctiveness. The Court used this reasoning to determine that "Thennamarakkudi" as a geographical name was commonly used descriptively and not distinctive of the appellant's goods.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined whether the word "Thennamarakkudi" in the trade mark was distinctive or merely descriptive and geographical in nature. It noted that the appellant did not register the word "Thennamarakkudi" separately but only as part of a composite label containing other features. The Court emphasized that registration of a composite mark does not confer exclusive rights in any individual word contained therein.

The Court considered the evidence that multiple merchants in the Thanjavur district used the term "Thennamarakkudi oil" to describe medicinal oil preparations, indicating that the term was descriptive and commonly appropriated in trade. The appellant’s past conduct, including compromise with other traders using similar marks and failure to oppose the respondent’s registration, further suggested the lack of distinctiveness.

Applying established principles, the Court held that a geographical name used descriptively by multiple traders is publici juris and cannot be monopolized. Even if the appellant’s father originally used the term distinctively, widespread use by others had rendered it common to trade and incapable of exclusive appropriation.

The Court declined to revisit the validity of the appellant’s original registration and focused solely on whether the respondent’s use of the term infringed any exclusive rights. It concluded that the respondent was entitled to use the term as it was descriptive and not distinctive of the appellant’s goods.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED the appeal, affirming the rejection of the application for rectification of the respondent’s trade mark.

The direct effect is that the respondent may continue to use and retain registration of the trade mark containing the words "Thennamarakkudi oil." The appellant does not have exclusive rights to the word "Thennamarakkudi" as it is a geographical name commonly used descriptively in the trade. No new precedent was established; the decision reinforces the principle that geographical names used descriptively cannot be monopolized as trade marks unless distinctiveness is clearly established and separately registered.

Show all summary ...

1. This appeal is directed against the dismissal of an application filed by the appellant under S. 36 of the Trade and Merchandise Act for rectification of the register by removing the trade mark No. 164933 or by deleting from the said mark the words ‘Thennamarakkudi oil’

2. The facts as set out in the application for rectification are as follows:—The appellant's father Santhanakrishna Naidu started, in or about the year 1918, a business in the manufacture and sale of a medicinal oil preparation for curing sprains, and fractures under the name and style of R. S. Krishna & Co. In order to distinguish his goods from that of the other merchants the appellant's father adopted a mark consisting of a device in which the word ‘Thennamarakkudi oil’ formed an essential part. The appellant's father, and, after his death, the appellant have been continuously using the said mark on the tins of the medicinal oil prepared and sold by them. The mark adopted by them for their goods had been registered in the name of appellant's father under No. 89873 and a certificate of registration, dt. 4th March, 1949 has been issued. After the appellant's father he has been continuing the business as sole proprie-tor and using his mark on the oil manufactured by him. In or about October, 1952, the first respondent company has been using a similar trade mark in the medicinal oil preparations with the same name. The appellant issued a lawyer's notice, dt. 7th October, 1952, apprising the first respondent about his prior user of the mark by his father and about the registration of the same. The first respondeat by his reply, dt. 13th October, 1952 promised to take steps to effect the changes in the mark but, however, without effecting any change in the mark it has been selling medioinal preparations of ‘Thennamarakkudi oil’. Subsequently, he came to know that the first respondent had also registered his mark as No. 164933 in pursuance of an application made on 12th July, 1954. Hence the appellant had to file an application for rectification of the register on the ground that the mark containing the words ‘thennamarakkudi oil’ registered by the first respondent is a clear infringement of his mark and its user by the first respondent is likely to cause deception or confusion in the minds of the purchasing public.

3. The said application for rectification was resisted by the first respondent contending that ‘Thennamarakkudi’ is a village in Nannilam taluk in Thanjavur district, where a family of native physicians began to manufacture such oil preparations and sell is to the public more than half a century ago and their preparation took its name from the village that in view of the popularity of that oil several merchants in Thennamarakkudi, Mannargudi, Mayuram, Kumbakonam and other places in Thanjavur district, have been selling the medicinal oil as Thennamarakkudi oil, and that the said word is not distinctive of the medicinal oil prepared and sold by the respondent.

4. The Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks dismissed the application for rectification by his order, dt. 22nd May, 1961 on the ground that the appellant had not adduced any evidence of the distinctiveness of the word Thennamarakkudi’ as postulated under S. 9 (2), that there was no evidence to show that there was a quality in the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ which earmarked the appellant's goods as distinct from those of other producers of such goods, that the appellant cannot have a monopoly to the word in question and that, in the absence of such a monopoly he cannot prevent other persons from using that word.

5. The appellant took the matter in appeal. Venkatadri, J. dismissed the appeal holding that the application for rectification has rightly been refused by the Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks as ‘Thennamarakkudi’ was a geographical name of which none can acquire a trade mark The matter was taken further in Letters Patent appeal by the appellant in L.P.A No. 66 of 1965. On the ground that the appellant cannot be called upon in his application for rectification under S. 56 (2) to prove the invalidity of his own registration on the ground of want of distinctiveness and that it is for the person who wanted to contend to the contrary to lead evidence to establish that Thennamarakkudi oil has not been used to denote the distinctive character of the medicinal preparation of the appellant, the Letters Patent appeal was allowed, and the matter was remitted to the Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks for fresh disposal in the light of the appellate judgment.

6. After the said remit order the Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks considered the matter afresh and by his order, dated 19th February, 1976. he again rejected the application for rectification and the reasons for refusing rectification of the register are these:—

1. Thennamarakkudi oil had no status as a distinctive expression at any time, much less on the date of the commencement of these rectification proceedings;

2. The appellant himself did not demur against the use of the expression ‘Thennamarakkudi’ by other persons but he objected only to the use of a similar label by him;

3. Thennamarakkudi oil is a common descriptive expression of a medicinal oil preparation and the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ was not distinctive of the applicant's goods and therefore, the appellant cannot claim any valid exclusive right or conclusive title to the expression ‘Thennamarakkudi oil’ by virtue of the registration of his mark under No. 89873, and

4. It is open to the first respondent to prove invalid a registration to any word or words contained in a trade mark if the word or words are not descriptive of the goods manufactured by the appellant and as a fact, the first respondent herein has clearly proved by evidence that the words ‘thennamarakkudi appearing in the appellant's mark have a well known and established use of the name of description of ayurvedic medical oil and the words are being so used by persons trading in the said medicinal oil and therefore, Thennamarakkudi oil should be taken as a general term or Publici juris, descriptively used to denote a medicinal oil having certain ingredients and used for the cure of certain diseases and the expression has been commonly appropriated by all merchants in the trade for describing a medicinal oil.

The correctness of the view taken by the Assistant Registrar has been challenged in this appeal by the appellant.

7. According to the appellant, the Assistant Registrar of Trade marks has gone beyond the remit order, that the remit order merely directs the Assistant Registrar to allow the parties to adduce evidence on the distinctive character of the words ‘Thennamarakkudi oil’ but the Assistant Registrar has proceeded on the basis that it is geographical name and therefore, no one can claim a trade mark in respect of that name. A perusal of the order of the Assistant Registrar clearly indicates that he has not dismissed the rectification application merely on the ground that ‘Thennamarakkudi’ is a geographical name. The learned counsel for the appellant further submits that the evidence does not sustain the finding of the Assistant Registrar that Thennamarakkudi is not a distinctive name for the medicinal preparation made by the appellant and that it is a common name applied to the preparation of the medicinal oil under a formula. Thus the main question is whether the first respondent has made out his case that the expression ‘Thennamarakkudi’ is a common name as used for the preparation of medicinal oil under a particular formula and it is not distinctive of the appellant's medicinal preparations?

8. In this case, admittedly the appellant did not register the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ as a mark. He has merely registered a label containing a device wherein the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ is found. However, according to the appellant the word ‘thennamarakkudi formed an essential part of the trade mark and therefore, no one can use the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ in respect of preparations made by him. But, a perusal of the label which has been registered as his (appellant's) trade mark would show that it contains not only the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ but also several other words and therefore, the whole label containing the word Thennmarakkudi’ along with other features should be taken into consideration. It has been pointed out by the Supreme Court in Registrar of Trade Marks v. Ashok Chandra Rakhit Ltd. . A.I.R 1998 S.C 558. that when a distinctive label is registered as a whole, such registration cannot possibly give an exclusive statutory right to the proprietor of the trade mark to the use of any particular word or name contained therein apart from the mark as a whole. Therefore, it is for the appellant who has filed the application for rectification to establish that the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ has been used in the label registered as a trade mark to distinguish his goods from those of others. Thennamarakkudi, being a geographical name, the appellant could claim a trade mark in that name only if he establishes that the geographical name has acquired a distinctive character and has been associated with his goods and therefore, it is a distinctive mark for his goods. It has been held in a number of cases that a geographical name adopted as a distinctive mark without its conveying any idea of the geographical origin or association would come within clause (e) of S. 9 (1) and as such, registrable, if the Registrar is satisfied of its distinctiveness. In this case, it has been found by the Registrar that several merchants in Thanjavur district are manufacturing medicinal oil preparation called ‘Thennamarakkudi oil’ and the preparation itself took its name from the village Thennamarakkudi in Nannilam taluk. Although a geographical name is prima facie not adopted to distinguish, it may be considered for registration upon evidence of its distinctiveness as will be clear from S. 9 (2) of the Act. In this case, apart from the use of the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ in the appellant's label no evidence has been adduced by him to show that he is the only person manufacturing such a medicinal preparation in that place and that the name has come to indicate only the oil manufactured by him and that there are no other persons manufacturing the same oil in the place Thennamarakkudi. As pointed out by Graham, J. in Tujnana Smalls Tm2 there are words whose primary signification is geographical, and where the geographical significance is so general and so likely to be adopted or desired for use by more than one trader it would be wrong, however distinctive they may in fact have become, ever to allow one trader by registration to seek to monoplise them…There are other ‘geographical’ words where, for one reason or another, when considered as applied to the goods in respect of which it is sought to register them, it is clear that the use is in fact clearly not geographical, but fanciful and is therefore, at least capable, particularly by use, being distinctive in practice of one manufacturer's goods, and registration can, therefore, in such cases be allowed without causing inconvenience to or encroaching upon the reasonable trading rights of other manufacturers, But, however, the question whether it fallsin the former or latter category, will have to be decided on the facts and circumstances of each individual case.

9. In this case, the appellant had his mark registered on 6th December, 1943 and we are not concerned in these proceedings as to the validity of the said mark. The appeal having arisen out of the proceedings for rectification of the first respondent's mark we cannot now go into the question as to whether the appellant's mark containing the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ ash been rightly registered in the year 1943. Therefore, in these proceedings we have to consider whether the first respondent by virtue of his label mark could use the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ on the medicinal oil prepared and dea It with by him. In this case, the Assistant Registrar held that the particular medicinal preparation goes by the common name, Thennamarakkudi oil. As a matter of fact, he has referred to another instance wherein the appellant did not question the use of the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ oil’ by a rival trader but he merely objected to the similarity in the label, and ultimately compromised the matter with the rival trader in O.S No. 11 of 1947 wherein, he has not objected to the use of the word Thennamarakkudi oil with a slight change in the label. It is also found by the Assistant Registrar that at least three other persons are using the name Thennamarakkudi in their medicinal oil preparation. It is well establised that any symbol, word or get-up commonly used by traders in connection with their trade and in respect of which no particular trader can claim an exclusive right to use may be considered common to that particular trade, or publici juris. Thus words, expressions or devices which are descriptive of particular goods are open to use by all persons dealing with those goods. It is true, whether a mark is or is not, common to a trade is a question of fact. It is equally well-established that a mark which was common to the trade at one time may in the course of time become distinctive and vice versa. In Ford v. Forest, it has been held that a word or device which was originally a trade mark, to the exclusive use of which a particular trader or his successors in business, may have been entitled, may subsequently become publici juris and the exclusive right may be lost. Therefore, even assuming that the appellant's father used the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ to show a distinctive character of the medicinal preparation as it has subsequently been used by persons making similar medicinal oil preparations, the expression has become publici juris. If the mark has come to be so public and in such universal use that nobody can be deceived by the use of it, or can be induced from the use of it to believe that he is buying the goods of the original trader, the right to the trade mark must have gone. The proper test to decide whether a mark which was originally a trade mark has become publici juris, is to see whether the use of it by other persons is still calculated to deceive the public.

10. Apart from these things, the appellant herein has registered his label which contains a particular device as his trade mark. It is true that the label contains the words Thennamarakkudi oil’. But, there is no clear evidence whether the appellant's father at the time of registration of this label intended to claim proprietory right in the word ‘Thennamarakkudi. Admittedly, there is no separate registration of the word as a trade mark. Therefore, the appellant cannot be taken to have acquired a proprietory right in the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ though he might have acquired the proprietory right in the label by its registration, especially when Thennamarakkudi is geographical name not shown to have been used to distinguish the medicinal oil prepared by the appellant's father. If the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ which is admittedly a geographical name, had been specifically and separately registered as a mark after establishing its distinctiveness by the appellant's father the position would have been different. But, where the word ‘Thennamarakkudi’ finds a place along with the other features in the label, it is not possible to assume that the geographical name has been used in the label to show the distinctiveness of the goods. Further, the conduct of the appellant in keeping quiet since the registration of the first respondent's mark in the year 1954 also indicates that the name ‘Thennamarakkudi’ cannot be distinctive in its use. Even before the first respondent registered his name, the appellant caused a notice to be issued claming proprietory right in the label and not particularly with reference to the use of the word Thennamarakkudi nor did he file any opposition for the registration of the first respondent's mark in the year 1954. In this view of the matter, I am inclined to agree with the view taken by the Assistant Registrar.

11. The appeal is, therefore, dismissed. There will however, be no order as to costs.

VCS