Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Tamil Nadu-V v. Manjushree Plantations Ltd.

Madras High Court
Jun 16, 1980
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The assessee, a public limited company, paid cash leave allowances to certain employees during assessment years 1968-69 to 1971-72. The Income-tax Officer disallowed the amounts under section 40(c)(iii) or section 40(a)(v) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, treating them as salary, benefit, amenity, or perquisite. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner confirmed the disallowance, but the Tribunal held that the payments were not salary, benefit, amenity, or perquisite. [1]

The Revenue obtained a reference to the High Court on whether the leave allowance was a perquisite and therefore subject to restriction under the relevant statutory provisions. [1][2][3]

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the cash leave allowance paid to employees was a “perquisite” under section 40(c)(iii) for assessment year 1968-69. [4][2]
  2. Whether the cash leave allowance was a “perquisite” under section 40(a)(v) for assessment years 1969-70 to 1971-72. [5][3]

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CIT v. Kanan Devan Hills Produce Company Ltd., [1979] 119 ITR 431 A direct cash payment to an employee is not a perquisite under section 40(c)(iii) or the corresponding section 40(a)(v). [6] The Court relied on this decision as supporting the assessee’s position. [6]
Special Leave Petitions Nos. 2970/76, etc. The Revenue’s challenges concerning bonus, house rent allowance, and conveyance allowance were dismissed by the Supreme Court. [6] The Court treated the dismissal, in the context described, as consistent with the view that contractual cash payments are not perquisites. [6][7]
Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Madras-Ii v. G. Venkataraman, [1978] 111 ITR 444 A “benefit or perquisite” cannot be money itself, because valuation or conversion into money would then be unnecessary. [7][8] The Court applied this reasoning to conclude that a perquisite must be a payment other than a cash payment made under a contract of service. [9]

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that the issue had already been considered in CIT v. Kanan Devan Hills Produce Company Ltd., where direct cash payments to employees were held not to constitute perquisites under the relevant provisions. [6]

The Court also considered the Supreme Court’s dismissal of special leave petitions concerning bonus, house rent allowance, and conveyance allowance, as well as the position taken in related Bombay proceedings that “perquisite” covers only non-cash benefits. [6][7]

Relying on its earlier decision in G. Venkataraman, the Court reasoned that a benefit or perquisite cannot itself be money; otherwise, valuation or conversion into money would be unnecessary. [7][8]

Accordingly, the Court held that a payment can be treated as a perquisite only if it is something other than a cash payment made pursuant to a contract of service. The Revenue identified no contrary authority, and the Court found that the weight of authority favoured the assessee. [9]

Holding and Implications

Answered in the affirmative and against the Revenue. The Tribunal was correct in holding that the cash leave allowance was not a perquisite and was therefore not subject to disallowance under section 40(c)(iii) or section 40(a)(v), as applicable. There was no order as to costs. [9]

The direct effect was that the assessee’s cash leave-allowance payments were not restricted under the cited provisions. No broader implications were discussed, and no new precedent was set.

Show all summary ...

Ramaswami, J.:— The assessee is a public limited company. In making the assessments for the assessment years 1968-69 to 1971-72, the ITO disallowed certain amounts in each year representing leave allowance paid in cash to certain of its employees. The view of the ITO was that these payments would either amount to salary or benefit or perquisite within the meaning of s. 40(c)(iii) or the substituted s. 40(a)(v), as the case may be. This view was confirmed by the AAC. But, on further appeal, the Tribunal held that the cash amounts paid as leave allowance were neither salary, nor benefit or amenity or perquisite, and as such, the disallowance was improper. Though the Tribunal had considered the question whether the leave allowance would be salary, or benefit or amenity or perquisite, the revenue sought a reference only on the question whether the leave allowance was not a perquisite, and the two questions that are referred to us read as follows:

For the assessment year 1968-69:

“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in law in holding that the leave allowance was not a perquisite and, therefore, the allowance of the same would not fall to be restricted in terms of section 40(c)(iii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961?”

For the assessment years 1969-70 to 71-72:

“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in law in holding that the leave allowance was not a perquisite and, therefore, the allowance of the same would not fall to be restricted in terms of section 40(a)(v) of the Income-tax Act, 1961?”

2. The matter is not res Integra. It has been decided by the Calcutta High Court with reference to the same provision in CIT v. Kanan Devan Hills Produce Company Ltd., [1979] 119 ITR 431 and it was to the effect that any cash payment directly made to the employee cannot be considered to be a perquisite within the meaning of s. 40(c)(iii) of the I.T Act, 1961, or the corresponding later provision, s. 40(a)(v). In a batch of Special Leave Petitions Nos. 2970/76, etc, the revenue raised a question whether bonus, house rent allowance and conveyance allowance paid to the employees are not perquisites and those petitions were dismissed by the Supreme Court.

3. It appears that in those decisions which arose from the orders of the Bombay Benches of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, the Tribunal had held that cash payments made by the employer to the employees in terms of service conditions cannot be treated as perquisites for the purpose of disallowance under s. 40(c)(iii) or s. 40(a)(v). The petitions filed under s. 256(1) before the Bombay High Court also were dismissed in the view that the expression “perquisite” would cover only non-cash benefits to the employees. It also appears that it was brought to the notice of the learned judges of the Supreme Court that the Central Board of Direct Taxes had also issued certain circulars from time to time that payments made to the employees under the terms of service cannot be treated as perquisites. Since these facts were on record we think that the Supreme Court ultimately did not consider it necessary to dictate a lengthy or reasoned order but dismissed the same in limine. This court in Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Madras-Ii v. G. Venkataraman, [1978] 111 ITR 444 had occasion to consider a similar provision contained in s. 2(6C)(iii) of the Indian I.T Act, 1922, which defines income as including “the value of any benefit or perquisite, whether convertible into money or not obtained from a company”.

4. This court held (p. 448):

“From this language it is clear that the ‘benefit or perquisite’ contemplated cannot be money itself. If it is money, the question of its value being taken into account or the benefit or perquisite being converted into money will not arise.”

5. Therefore, the view of this court also was that in order to term a payment as perquisite, it shall be a payment, other than a cash payment, in pursuance of a contract of service. The learned counsel for the revenue did not bring to our notice any other decision which has taken any contrary view. In view of this preponderance of opinion in favour of the assessee, we have to answer the questions referred to us in the affirmative and against the revenue; but there will be no order as to costs.