Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

A.T.A Nataraja Chettiar & Company And Another v. State Of Tamil Nadu

Madras High Court
Sep 30, 1980
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Tax Cases Nos. 490 and 493 of 1979 involve one assessee concerning tax payable under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 and the Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970. Tax Cases Nos. 491 and 492 of 1979 involve a different assessee, Lakshmi Jewellery House, Karaikudi, with similar tax issues under the same Acts. The core issue in both sets of cases relates to the tax liability on turnover arising from the purchase and sale of old jewels. The assessees purchased old jewels from non-dealers within Tamil Nadu and either sold them locally as new jewels after conversion or sold them at Bombay as standard gold after conversion. The Tribunal had to determine whether these transactions attracted tax under section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the turnover from the purchase of old jewels and their subsequent sale after conversion is liable to purchase tax under section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.
  2. Whether the transportation of old jewels by the dealer in person to a place outside the State (Bombay) constitutes "despatch" under section 7-A(1)(c) of the Act, thereby attracting tax liability on such turnover.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellants contended that since the goods were taken in person by them to Bombay, there was no "despatch" of goods to a place outside the State within the meaning of section 7-A(1)(c).
  • They argued that "despatch" should imply sending goods via a transport vehicle and not when the dealer himself accompanies the goods.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Appellate Assistant Commissioner rejected the narrow interpretation of "despatch," relying on dictionary meanings which include "send away hastily" or "dispose of," and held that the dealer carrying the goods in person still constitutes despatch.
  • The Tribunal relied on the decision in State of Tamil Nadu v. M.K Kandaswami to support the view that transportation by dealer in person falls within section 7-A(1)(c) and thus attracts tax liability.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K. Chennakesavalu v. Commissioner, Board of Revenue (Commercial Taxes), Chepauk, Madras (T.C No. 152 of 1979) [1981] 47 STC 403 Purchase of old silver jewellery and conversion into new silver jewellery within the State falls under section 7-A(1)(a). The Court held that the turnover of Rs. 1,46,161.06 in T.C Nos. 490 and 493 is governed by this precedent, confirming liability under section 7-A(1)(a).
Bapalal and Co. (Manufacturing), Madras v. State of Tamil Nadu (T.C No. 301 of 1979) [1982] 49 STC 20 Purchase of old gold jewellery and conversion into new gold jewellery within the State falls under section 7-A(1)(a). Applied to turnover of Rs. 40,012.11 in T.C Nos. 491 and 492, confirming tax liability under section 7-A(1)(a).
State of Tamil Nadu v. M.K Kandaswami [1975] 36 STC 191 (SC) Section 7-A is a charging and remedial provision aimed at plugging leakage and preventing tax evasion; transportation of goods outside the State by dealers attracts tax liability under clauses (b) or (c) of section 7-A(1). The Tribunal relied on this precedent to hold that transportation of goods by the dealer himself constitutes "despatch" under section 7-A(1)(c), but the Court disagreed on this point in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the applicability of section 7-A(1)(c) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, which imposes tax on goods "despatched" outside the State except in certain inter-State trade circumstances. The Tribunal had held that the dealer carrying the old jewellery personally to Bombay constituted despatch, thereby attracting tax liability.

However, the Court distinguished the meaning of "despatch" by referring to authoritative dictionary definitions, which define "despatch" as "sending off" or "sending away" and do not include a person carrying goods along with himself. The Court found that the Tribunal erred in equating transportation by the dealer in person with "despatch."

The Court further noted that the precedent relied upon by the Tribunal, State of Tamil Nadu v. M.K Kandaswami, did not interpret the word "despatch" in the context of section 7-A(1)(c). Therefore, the Court rejected the Tribunal's reliance on that case for this specific interpretation.

Consequently, the Court concluded that since the dealer personally carried the goods to Bombay, the transaction does not fall within section 7-A(1)(c), and the turnover related to such transactions must be excluded from taxable turnover under that provision.

The Court remanded the matter to the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal to determine the petitioners' liability for sales tax under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, and the Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970, after excluding the turnover not liable under section 7-A(1)(c).

Holding and Implications

The Court set aside the Tribunal's finding that transportation of goods by the dealer in person constitutes "despatch" under section 7-A(1)(c) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.

The Court held that the turnover relating to old jewels personally carried by the dealer to Bombay is not liable to tax under section 7-A(1)(c) because such transportation does not amount to "despatch."

The matter was remanded to the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal for reassessment of tax liability excluding the turnover not covered by section 7-A(1)(c). No order as to costs was made.

No new precedent was established; the decision clarifies the interpretation of "despatch" in the context of section 7-A(1)(c) and limits its application to cases where goods are sent or dispatched, not carried by the dealer in person.

Show all summary ...

M.M Ismail, C.J:— Tax Cases Nos. 490 and 493 of 1979 are by the same assessee, one dealing with the tax payable under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act; 1959, and the other dealing with the tax payable under the Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970. Tax Cases Nos. 491 and 492 of 1979 have been preferred by a different assessee (Lakshmi Jewellery House, Karaikudi), the former dealing with the tax payable under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, and the latter dealing with the tax payable under the Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970. However, the point involved in both the sets of cases is that same.

2. As far as T.C No. 490 of 1979 is concerned, the assessee purchased old jewels from non-dealers in the State of Tamil Nadu for a sum of Rs. 17,40,988.20 and sold them at Bombay as standard gold after conversion. The assessee also purchased old jewels on a turnover of Rs. 1,46,161.06 from non-dealers in the State, converted them into new jewels and sold them locally. As far as C. Nos. 491 and 492 of 1979 are concerned, the assessee purchased old jewels from non-dealers in the State of Tamil Nadu for a sum of Rs. 8,12,770.80 and sold/them at Bombay as standard gold after conversion. The assessee also purchased old jewels on a turnover of Rs. 40,012.11 from non-dealers in the State, concerted them into new jewels and sold them locally.

3. The question that came to be considered by the Tribunal with reference to these two turnovers was whether they were liable to purchase tax under section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959. As far as the turnover of Rs. 1,46,161.06 in T.C Nos. 490 and 493 of 1979 is concerned the case is covered by our judgments dated 23rd September, 1980, in K. Chennakesavalu v. Commissioner, Board of Revenue (Commercial Taxes), Chepauk, Madras-5 (T.C No. 152 of 1979) [1981] 47 STC 403 and Bapalal and Co. (Manufacturing), Madras-3 v. State of Tamil Nadu represented by the Joint Commercial Tax Officer, Madras-1 (T.C No. 301 of 1979) [1982] 49 STC 20 the former dealing with the case of purchase of old silver jewellery and conversion thereof into new silver jewellery and sale thereof within the State, and the latter being concerned with the purchase of old gold jewellery, conversion thereof into new gold jewellery and sale thereof in the State. We held that the transaction came within the scope of section 7-A(1)(a) of the Act, as old jewellery was consumed in the process of manufacture of new jewellery. Admittedly this decision will govern the point in the present case in respect of the turnover of Rs. 1,46,161.06 in T.C Nos. 490 and 493 of 1979 and the turnover of Rs. 40,012.11 in T.C Nos. 491 and 492 of 1979.

4. Then there remains the next question regarding the liability to tax on the turnover of Rs. 17,40,988.20 in one case and Rs. 8,12,770.80 in the other case under section 7-A of the Act. Section 7-A(1)(c) of the Act, omitting the provisos, which are not relevant for the purpose of deciding the question involved in the case, reads as follows:

“7-A. (1) Every dealer who in the course of his business purchases from a registered dealer or from any other person, any goods (the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under this Act) in circumstances in which no tax is payable under section 3, 4 or 5, as the case may be, and either, —

(c) despatches them to a place outside the State except as a direct result of sale or purchase in the course of inter-State trade or commerce, shall pay tax on the turnover relating to the purchase aforesaid at the rate mentioned in section 3, 4 or 5, as the case may be, whatever be the quantum of such turnover in a year.”

5. The Tribunal held that both the turnovers were covered by section 7-A(1)(c) of the Act. As the extract from the section shows, the expression used in the section is “despatches them to a place outside the State”. In this particular case, the finding is that the dealer himself carried the old jewellery to Bombay, concerted them as standard gold and sold them in Bombay. On that finding the Tribunal held that the carrying of the gold by the dealers from this State to Bombay would constitute “despatch of the goods” under section 7-A(1)(c) of the Act and that therefore the petitioners were liable to tax on the purchase turnover. The Tribunal states in its order:

“It is contended that as the goods were taken in person by the appellants to Bombay there was no ‘despatch’ of the goods to a place outside the State. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner had held that there was no basis for the interpretation that ‘despatch’ can only mean sending of goods by some transport vehicle. The Chambers's 20th Century Dictionary refers to ‘despatch’ (dispatch) as ‘send away hastily’; ‘send out of the world’; ‘to put to death’; ‘to dispose of’; ‘to perform speedily’; ‘to make haste’.

The interpretation on behalf of the appellants that the goods cannot be said to have been despatched when the sender himself accompanies the goods does not fit in with the meaning given in the dictionary. In State of Tamil Nadu v. M.K Kandaswami [1975] 36 STC 191 at 198 (SC), in dealing with the interpretation and scope of section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, it was pointed out (at page 198) that in the case of arecanuts, gingelly seeds, turmeric and grams purchased from agriculturists, if the purchasing dealers transported these goods outside the State for sale on consignment basis their case would also be covered by clause (b) or (c) of section 7-A(1) and that such dealers would be liable to tax on the purchase turnover of these goods. It was further held:

‘It may be remembered that section 7-A is at once a charging as well as a remedial provision. Its main object is to plug leakage and prevent evasion of tax. In interpreting such a provision, a construction which would defeat its purpose and, in effect, obliterate it from the statute book, should be eschewed. If more than one construction is possible, that which preserves its workability and efficacy is to be preferred to the one which would render it otiose or sterile.’

It seemes to us that the word ‘despatch’ mentioned in the section refers to transportation of the goods only and there is no warrant to make a distinction between the transport of the goods through a carrier and the same by the dealer in person. We are, therefore, in agreement with the authorities below that the purchase turnover relating to old jewels which had been transported to Bombay and sold as standard gold after conversion attracts the levy under section 7-A, notwithstanding the circumstance that the dealer had transported the goods in person to Bombay.”

6. We are of the opinion that the decision in State of Tamil Nadu v. M.K Kandaswami [1975] 36 STC 191 (SC) did not deal with the interpretation of the word “despatches” occurring in section 7-A(1)(c) of the Act and, therefore, the Tribunal erred in relying on the same as confirming its view that the present case fell within the scope of section 7-A(1)(c) of the Act. The word “despatch” is a very simple word and has a definite connotation. The meaning of this word given in the Shorter Oxford English Dictionary is: “the sending off (of a messenger, letter, etc.)” (page 530). The meaning for the word given in the Webster's Third New International Dictionary is: “to send off or away (as to a special destination) with promptness or speed often as a matter of official business' (page 653). Consequently the meaning of the word contemplates the sending of a thing from one place to another, and certainly that will not take in a person carrying the gold, that he had purchased, along with him in person from one place to another. Therefore, on the finding of the Tribunal itself in this case that the dealer carried with him in person the articles in question from Madras to Bombay, it cannot be held that the articles in question were despatched from the State of Tamil Nadu to Bombay. If so, section 7-A(1)(c) of the Act has no application to the transaction in question, with the result that the said turnover, has to be excluded from the taxable turnover. After excluding this turnover the Tribunal will have to decide the liability of the petitioners to payment of sales tax under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, and under the Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970. For the purpose of working out this liability on the basis of our conclusion in this behalf, the matter will stand remanded to the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal (Additional Bench), Madurai. There will be no order as to costs in any of these cases.

7. Ordered accordingly.