Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Raghavan And Another v. Nagammal Alias Nagabhushanammal And Another

Madras High Court
Apr 26, 1978
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs are the first plaintiff (the wife) and the second plaintiff Lakshmi (their daughter). The first defendant (first appellant) is the husband of the first plaintiff; the second defendant adopted the written statement of the first defendant. The marriage of the first plaintiff and the first defendant took place in 1948 in Madras.

From 1951 the first defendant began to ill‑treat the first plaintiff and ceased to look after her and the second plaintiff. The plaintiffs filed O.S. No. 1829 of 1958 for maintenance, which ended in compromise awarding the second plaintiff future maintenance at Rs. 35 per month and Rs. 400 for past maintenance; the first plaintiff's claim was not pressed in that action. The first defendant later filed O.P. No. 205 of 1961 for restitution of conjugal rights; the trial court dismissed it but this Court allowed restitution in C.M.A. No. 196 of 1963.

After disposal of the C.M.A., the first defendant kept the second defendant as his concubine, did not take back the first plaintiff, defaulted in maintenance payments to the second plaintiff, and settled his properties in the name of the second defendant. The plaintiffs then filed the present suit in forma pauperis (O.S. No. 3785 of 1970) claiming maintenance (past and future), various ancillary sums (including Rs. 5,000 for the second plaintiff's marriage expenses), and a charge over the plaint A schedule property to secure the decreed amounts.

The trial court made findings: the first plaintiff was entitled to maintenance at Rs. 50/month and three years' past maintenance at Rs. 50/month; the second plaintiff was awarded Rs. 1,000 for marriage expenses and maintenance at Rs. 35/month (no enhancement); the settlement deed in favour of the second defendant was held to be gratuitous with knowledge of plaintiffs' rights and the plaintiffs were given a charge over A schedule properties. The defendants appealed against that decree.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a charge can be created over the plaint A schedule properties in favour of the first plaintiff (and the second plaintiff) to secure maintenance, when those properties were gifted by the husband to the second defendant.
  2. Whether the suit against the second plaintiff was maintainable given the earlier decree in O.S. No. 1829 of 1958 and the trial court's finding that the second plaintiff was not entitled to enhanced maintenance.
  3. Whether the second plaintiff's subsequent marriage affected her entitlement to maintenance.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (Defendants') Arguments — as summarized in the opinion

  • The suit is bad for misjoinder of causes of action.
  • The first plaintiff's claim for maintenance is unsustainable because of the decree for restitution of conjugal rights in C.M.A. No. 196 of 1963.
  • The second plaintiff had married Arumugam and therefore was not entitled to Rs. 5,000 for marriage expenses.
  • The second plaintiff was not entitled to enhanced maintenance beyond the sums previously decreed.
  • The plaintiffs are not entitled to have a charge over A schedule properties because those properties had been settled in favour of the second defendant for proper and valid consideration (or as contended, at least not subject to a charge); the settlement deed (Ex. B‑6) was executed since the second defendant undertook to discharge a mortgage on the suit properties.
  • More specifically (raised on appeal): (1) the trial Judge ought not to have created a charge over the plaint A schedule properties; (2) having found that the second plaintiff was not entitled to enhanced maintenance, the suit as against the second plaintiff should have been dismissed as she already had a maintenance decree in O.S. No. 1829 of 1958.

Plaintiffs' (Respondents') Position — as can be inferred from the opinion

  • The plaintiffs sought maintenance (past and future), marriage expenses for the second plaintiff and a charge over A schedule properties to secure the decreed amounts because the husband had alienated properties to the second defendant and defaulted on maintenance.
  • They contended that the settlement deed (Ex. B‑6) was gratuitous and executed with notice of the plaintiffs' maintenance rights and therefore the transferee took property subject to those rights.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pavayammal v. Samiappa, A.I.R. 1947 Mad. 376 Held that S.39 T.P. Act could not be invoked to create a charge in favour of wife/daughter; the plaintiffs did not have a right to receive maintenance "from the profits of immovable property" for S.39 to apply. The Court acknowledged this decision as supportive of the appellants' submission but examined its correctness and found later authorities to be inconsistent with it; the Court did not follow Pavayammal as laying down the correct law for the present matter.
Lakshman Ramachandra v. Satyabbama Held that by marriage a wife acquires an interest in the husband's property (albeit in a secondary sense) rather than complete independent ownership. Used to support the proposition that a wife's rights are connected with a subordinate interest in husband's property and are relevant to the question whether a charge can be created.
Jamna (Plaintiff) v. Machul Sahu (Defendant), I.L.R. 2 All. 315 Held that where a husband alienated property leaving the wife without maintenance, the donee took the estate subject to the wife's right of maintenance. Cited to support the view that a gratuitous transferee can take property subject to the wife's maintenance rights and that alienation does not defeat such right.
Narbadabai v. Mahadeo Narayan, I.L.R. 5 Bom. 99 Held that alienation of the husband's immovable property does not affect the wife's right to maintenance and that a wife's right is not dependent on the husband having property. Relied upon to show that a wife's maintenance right survives alienation and supports creation of a charge to secure maintenance.
Lakshmi Devi Amma v. Naganna, A.I.R. 1925 Mad. 757 Recognized that husband has an obligation to support his wife independent of property ownership, but where family property exists the wife's claim may be regarded as a suit against the family represented by the husband. Used to underline that the wife's right can be pressed against family/joint funds and is not purely an abstract personal liability.
Manikyam v. Venkayamma, A.I.R. 1957 A.P. 710 Held that though a wife's right to separate maintenance does not by itself form a charge, a court can create a specific charge on a reasonable portion of property to enforce or preserve such right, including against gratuitous transferees with notice. Followed and relied upon as a principal authority: the Court treated this decision as supporting creation of a charge under S.39 against property transferred gratuitously with notice.
Chandramma v. Venkata Reddi (Andhra Pradesh decisions) After examining Hindu texts and authorities, held that wife has a subordinate interest in husband's property and may enforce maintenance against property in hands of alienees with notice under S.39. Quoted approvingly; the Court adopted Chandramma's reasoning that S.39 protects the wife's right to be maintained out of husband's property and can be enforced against transferees with notice.
Vellayammal v. Srikumara Pillai Ramaswami Dealt with a similar situation and dissented from Pavayammal and Chandramma (as described in the opinion). Noted as a decision that sided with creating a charge; the present Court referenced it among authorities favouring that a charge could be created for maintenance.
K. M. S. Rudrappa v. Basamma Considered whether wife and children were entitled to a charge over properties when husband gifted them; rejected Pavayammal and followed decisions holding a charge could be created. Followed by the Court as part of a line of authorities supporting creation of a charge in favour of wife and children over husband's property.
V. Tulasamma v. Sesha Reddi, 1977 3 S.C.C. 99 Supreme Court decision describing the wife's right as a tangible right against property — a legal charge on the husband's estate — and treating wife's maintenance as a right which may be enforced against property. Used as persuasive support from the Supreme Court that the basis for treating a wife's maintenance right as a charge on property is well‑founded; the Court relied on this decision to reinforce its conclusion to follow authorities permitting charges.
Periambal Chettiar v. Sundarammal Held that where a will had the effect of defeating a wife's right to maintenance, she was entitled to be maintained out of the husband's estate. Referenced to demonstrate jurisprudence that alienation or testamentary dispositions do not defeat the wife's right to maintenance out of the estate.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in steps:

  1. Considered whether S.28 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act could support the creation of a charge in favour of the first plaintiff. The Court noted S.28 permits enforcement of a dependant's right against a transferee when the transferee has notice or when the transfer is gratuitous, but observed that the term "dependant" (S.21) does not include a wife. On that basis the appellants' submission that S.28 could not be availed of by the first plaintiff was regarded as well founded as to S.28.
  2. Turned to S.39 of the Transfer of Property Act, which applies where "a third person has a right to receive maintenance ... from the profits of immovable property" and permits enforcement against transferees with notice or gratuitous transferees. The appellants argued S.39 does not apply because a husband's obligation to maintain his wife is a purely personal obligation not dependent on property, and therefore a wife has no right "from the profits of immovable property."
  3. Reviewed conflicting precedents. Pavayammal v. Samiappa (Madras) was recognized as supporting the appellants' position that S.39 would not apply. However the Court surveyed other authorities (including Jamna v. Machul Sahu, Narbadabai v. Mahadeo Narayan, Lakshman Ramachandra v. Satyabbama, Lakshmi Devi Amma v. Naganna, Manikyam v. Venkayamma, Chandramma v. Venkata Reddi, Vellayammal v. Srikumara Pillai and K.M.S. Rudrappa v. Basamma) and the recent Supreme Court decision in V. Tulasamma v. Sesha Reddi.
  4. Analysed Hindu law doctrine: while a husband's duty to maintain his wife is a personal obligation not contingent on property ownership, ancient texts and later High Court decisions recognise that a wife acquires a subordinate interest in the husband's property and that courts may create a charge on property to enforce maintenance when necessary. The Court emphasized that the personal obligation does not preclude treating the right as enforceable against property to secure maintenance.
  5. Concluded that the authorities favouring the creation of a charge under S.39 were persuasive. The Court expressly followed the decisions in Vellayammal, Manikyam, Chandramma and K. M. S. Rudrappa and held that a Hindu wife is entitled to a charge on her husband's property and can claim protection under S.39 of the Transfer of Property Act. Consequently Ex. B‑6 (the gift to the second defendant) could not defeat the first plaintiff's right to a charge for maintenance.
  6. Rejected the defendants' contentions that (a) heavy liabilities on the property or a low net value prevented creation of a charge, and (b) because the restitution of conjugal rights decree in 1965 (C.M.A. No. 196 of 1963) meant the first plaintiff had no right to separate maintenance at the time Ex. B‑6 was executed (1961), the gift could not be impugned. The Court held that the wife's right of maintenance and its connection with her subordinate interest in the husband's property meant that the gift, if gratuitous and executed without provision for maintenance, could be made subject to a charge to secure maintenance.
  7. Addressed the second plaintiff's position: the Court held that the second plaintiff's suit was maintainable because it sought enhanced maintenance and marriage expenses in addition to the earlier decree. The Court noted the second plaintiff had married Arumugam (on 4 July 1974) and concluded she would not be entitled to maintenance from that date; accordingly the decree was to be modified so that maintenance for the second plaintiff would run only until 4 July 1974.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court confirmed the trial court's decree subject to one modification and dismissed the appeal.

CORE RULING: The appeal is dismissed with costs; the judgment and decree of the trial court are confirmed except that the second plaintiff is entitled to maintenance only until 4 July 1974 (the date of her marriage with Arumugam).

Implications and direct effects:

  • The Court held that a Hindu wife is entitled to have a charge on her husband's property and to claim protection under S.39 of the Transfer of Property Act. Consequently, a gratuitous transfer (gift) of the husband's property to a transferee who takes with notice or gratuitously may be subject to a charge for maintenance in favour of the wife (and similarly for children as appropriate).
  • Ex. B‑6 (the gift to the second defendant) could not be used to defeat the plaintiffs' right to a charge in respect of maintenance decreed in their favour.
  • The trial court's awards were maintained: first plaintiff's maintenance (as fixed by the trial court) and the second plaintiff's awarded sums remain in effect, except that the second plaintiff's entitlement to future maintenance is limited to the date of her marriage (4 July 1974). The Court noted that the sum of Rs. 1,000 allowed to the second plaintiff for marriage expenses had already been deposited in Court.
  • No broader new precedent beyond these conclusions was claimed by the Court; rather, the Court expressly followed and aligned with a line of existing High Court and Supreme Court decisions recognizing the wife's subordinate interest in the husband's property and permitting creation of a charge under S.39.

Result: Appeal dismissed with costs; decree of the trial court is confirmed subject to the modification limiting the second plaintiff's maintenance to 4 July 1974.

VCS
Show all summary ...

1. The defendants in O.S No. 3785 of 1970 on the file of the City Civil Court at Madras are the appellants. The plaintiffs filed the suit in forma pauperis for recovery of maintenance past and future and for the recovery of a sum of Rs. 5,000/- for the marriage expenses of the second plaintiff in the following circumstances. The first defendant (first appellant is the husband of the first plaintiff, (first respondent). Their marriage took place in 1948 at Madras. The second plaintiff Lakshmi, is the daughter born to them. In 1951 the first defendant began to ill that the first plaintiff and ceased to look after her and the second plaintiff. The plaintiffs were therefore, compelled to file O.S No. 1829 of 1958 on the file of the City Civil Court for maintenence. That ended in a compromise under which the second plaintiff was awarded future maintenance at the rate of Rs. 35/- per month and a sum of Rs. 400/- for past maintenance. The claim of the first plaintiff for maintenance was not pressed. Thereafter, the first defendant filed O.P No. 205 of 1961 for restitution of conjugal rights against the first plaintiff. Though the petition was dismissed by the trial court, this Court ordered restitution in C.M.A No. 196 of 1963. Subsequent to the disposal of C.M.A No. 196 of 1963 by this Court, the first defendant hat been keeping the second defendant as his concubine in his house and did not bother to take back the first plaintiff to live with him. He also committed default in the payment of monthly maintenance to the second plaintiff, He had settled all his properties in the name of the second defendant, his concubine. The plaintiffs, therefore, filed the suit in forma pauperis claiming maintenance, for the first plaintiff at Rs. 100/- per month, a sum of Rs 2,880/- towards past maintenance, a sum of Rs. 600.for residence and clothing for the past three years, Rs. 50/- per month for residence and clothing for the future period. A charge is also claimed over the plaint A schedule property. The prayer in respect of the second plaintiff is future maintenance at the rate of Rs. 65/- per month for recovery of a sum of Rs. 2,340/- towards past maintenance and a sum of Rs. 5,000/- towards marriage expenses. For these amounts also a charge is claimed over the plaint A schedule property.

2. The first defendant filed a written statement which was adopted by the second defendant. The first defendant contended that the suit was bad for misojinder of causes of action. He further pleaded that the claim of the first plaintiff for maintenance was not sustainable on account of the decree for restitution of conjugal rights passed in C.M.A No. 196 of 1963 on the file of this Court. It was also pleaded that the second plaintiff had married one Arumugam and was therefore, not entitled to get Rs. 5,000/- for marriage expenses. The second plainatiff's right for enhanced maintenance was also denied the first defendant further stated that the plaintiffs are not entitled to get a charge over A schedule properties as they had been settled in favour of the second defendant for proper and valid consideration. The settlement deed itself was executed since the second defendant undertook to discharge the mortgage which subsisted on the suit properties.

3. The trial court raised the necessary issues for consideration. The trial Court held That the first plaintiff was entitled to claim maintenance and it fixed the quantum of maintenance at the rate of Rs. 50/- per month. It disallowed the claim of the first plaintiff for Rs. 600/- for residence and clothing for the past three years and Rs. 50/- per month for residence and clothing for the future period. It however, held that the first plaintiff would be entitled to past maintenance for three years at the rate of Rs. 50/- per month.

4. As regards the second plaintiff the learned Judge held that she would be entitled to a sum of Rs. 1,000/- for marriage expenses. He also found that the second plaintiff would be entitled only to get maintenance at the rate of Rs. 35/- per month and was not entitled to any enhanced maintenance. He further found that the settlement deed was executed gratuitously with knowledge of the plaintiff's right for maintenance over the first defendant and accordingly he further held t hat the plaintiffs were entitled to a charge for the maintenance amount over the plaint A Schedule properties. The learned Judge accordingly decreed the suit. Against this decree of the trial Court the defendants, have filed the appeal.

5. Sri R. Alagar raised the following two contentions: (1) The learned trial Judge ought not to have created a charge over the plaint A schedule properties for the maintenance amount. (2) The learned trial Judge having found that the second plaintiff was not entitled to enhanced maintenance should have dismissed the suit as against the second plaintiff in view of the fact that the second plaintiff had already obtained a decree for maintenance in O.S No. 1829 of 1958 against the first defendant. The learned counsel for the appellants fairly conceded that in view of the fact that it has been admitted that the first defendant is now living with the second defendant, he could not challenge the finding of the trial Court that the first plaintiff would be entitled to maintenance from the first defendant. He was also fair enough to state that he could not assail the quantum of maintenance fixed by the trial Court in favour of the first plaintiff at Rs. 50/- per month. The learned counsel also submitted that the sum of Rs. 1,000/- allowed by the trial Court in favour of the second plaintiff towards the marriage expenses has already been deposited in Court, and this fact was admitted to be correct by the learned counsel for the respondents. It is also now admitted that the second plaintiff has married one Arumugham on 4th July, 1974. The appellants have filed the invitation for the marriage of the second plaintiff, with an application to receive the same as additional evidence under O. 41, R. 27, C.P.C The learned counsel for the respondents also does not object to the said additional document being received in evidence. I therefore, allow C.M.P, No. 1729 of 1978 filed by the appellants and the said letter of invitation is marked as Ex. B-9.

6. Let me first take up the contention of Sri Alagar that a charge could not be created over the plaint A schedule properties for the maintenance amount. According to Sri Alagar the first defendant had gifted the property to the second defendant, his second wife on 20th June, 1961 and, therefore, the right to maintenante of the first plaintiff cannot be enforced against the said property. In other words, the contention of Sri Alagar is that the first plaintiff is not entitled to a charge on her husband's property, and if that is so, then the right to maintenance cannot be enforced against the property that had been gifted to the second defendant by the first defendant under Ex. B-6. According to learned counsel, S. 28 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act could not be availed of by the first plaintiff. S. 28 of the Act reads thus:

“Where a dependant has a right to receive maintenance out of an estate, and such estate or any par thereof is transferred, the right to receive maintenance may be enforced against the transferee if the transferee has notice of the right, or if the transfer is gratuitous but not against the transferee for consideration and without notice of the right”.

It is clear from this section that a person whose right to maintenance is protected under the section must be a dependant. A dependant is defined in S. 21 of the Act. It is (sic) not necessary to extract the entire S. 21 herein except to say that a wife is not taken in the definition of the word ‘dependant’. In the circumstances, Sri Alagar is well founded in his contention that the first plaintiff will not be entitled to have a charge over the suit properties for maintenance and that the same cannot be enforced against the property gifted to the second defendant under S. 28 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act.

7. The only other provision under which the first plaintiff could claim a charge for maintenance against the property of her husband, the first defendant, is under the provisions of S. 39 of the Transfer of Property Act. 5.39 of the Act reads thus:

“Where a third person has a right to receive maintenance or a provision for advancement or marriage, from the profits of immovable property and such property is transferred, the right may be enforced against the transferee, if he has notice thereof or if the transfer is gratuitous, but not against a transferee for consideration and without notice of the right, nor against such property in his hands.”

In the submission of Sri Alagar S. 39 of the Transfer of Property Act would not entitle the first plantiff to have a charge created over the suit properties in respect of her maintenance. According to the learned counsel the liability of a Hindu to maintain his wife under Hindu Law is a personal obligation and does not depend upon the fact whether he possessed properties or not. S. 39 would apply only to persons who will be entitled to maintenance from and out of the income from immovable property. So long as a Hindu wife is not entitled to maintenance out of immovable properties of her husband, so argues the learned counsel, she will not be entitled to charge over the properties of her husband.

8. The question for consideration is whether this submission of the learned counsel is correct. The learned counsel relied upon a decision in Pavayammal v. Samiappa . A. I. R. 1947 Mad. 376=60 L.W 377.. There, the wife and the daughter of a Hindu filed a suit against him and two of his alienees for maintenance, In the suit they claimed a charge in respect of the properties alienated by the husband and father to the alienees. The question arose whether under S. 39 of the Transfer of Property Act the plaintiffs would be entitled to have a charge on the properties alienated. Chandrxsekhara Aiyar, J. as he then was, stated as follows:

“In the first place, it cannot be said of the plaintiff's that they have got a right to receive maintenance ‘from the profits of immovable property’ when only S. 39 will come into play. Secondly, mere knoweledge of the legal right would not appear to be enough as, if it were so, there could be no sale by a husband of his properties to third parties without the risk of the wife turning up later and saying that they had notice of her right and that therefore the transferees were bound to recognise her right. What the section contemplates is a claim based on the right to receive maintenance and notice of such claim”.

In this view, the learned Judge held that no charge could be created under.S 39. Certainly, this decision supports the learned counsel for the appellants, But, we have to examine how far this case has been correctly decided and accepted as such by other High Courts and by our own High court later,

9. Before we consider the applicability of S. 39 of the Transfer of Property Act in such cases we have to see what the right of Hindu wife for maintenance against her husbandu nder Hindu Law is. Under Hindu Law the maintenance of a wifeby her husband is, of course, a matter of personal obligation which attached from the moment of marriage. From the date of her marriage her home is necessarily in her husband's house. He is bound to maintain her in it while she is willing to reside with him and discharge her duties. If she quits him of her own accord, either without cause or on account of such ordinary quarrels as are incidental to married life in general, she can set up a claim for seperate maintenance. Under S. 2 of the Hindu Married Women's Rights to Separate Residence and Maintenance Act, 1946, a Hindu married woman is entitled to separate residence and maintenance from her husband on grounds stated therein. The doctrine of maintenance of a wife can be traced to the smritis and the principal Hindu commentaries upon them. These texts enjoin a mandatory duty upon the husband to maintain his wife. The duty does not depend upon the husband possessing any property. It imposes a personal obligation on him enforceable by the Sovereign or State. However, when it is stated that there is a personal obligation on the part of the husband to maintain the wife it does not mean that the obligation is not referred at all to his property and that he can alienate all his property and deprive his wife of the right to maintenance from the income of his property. In fact, the exact meaning and scope of the personal obligation on the part of the husband to maintain the wife is even wider in the sense that his obligation will exist even if he has no properties from which he could derive any income. It is unnecessary for me to state the various texts of ancient Hindu Law on this subject as they have been elaborately dealt with and discussed in the various decisions which I shall now presently refer to. But, it may be stated, even according to the ancient texts the wife was supposed to be a co-owner of her husband's property though in a secondary sense.

10. As early as Lakshman Ramachandra v. Satyabbama West, J. considered the Hindu Law texts pertaining to the rights of a Hindu woman in her husband's property and pointed out that, by marriage, she acquired an interest in the husband's property though only, according to some writers, of a secondary kind such as may be divested by gift by the husband to a third party.

11. In Jamna…(Plaintiff); v. Machul Sahu…(Defendant). . I.L.R 2 All. 315. it was ruled by the Allahabad High Court that a wife is, under the Hindu Law, in a subordinate sense a co-owner with her husband and, therefore, the husband cannot alienate his property or dispose of it by a will in such a wholesale manner as to deprive her of her maintenance.

12. In Narbadabai v. Mahadeo Narayan . I. L. R. 5 Bom. 99 West, J. made the following observations: “The co-ownership of the wife in her husband's property, if that can properly be called ownership at all which involves no independent or co-equal powers of disposition or exclusive enjoyment, is not of a kind that accepts the rules applicable to an ownership in the ordinary sense. Her right to maintenance does not depend on it, for the husband is bound to support her, though he should have no property at all. It is rather a latent right coming into operation only when natural affection which usually prompts the mutual acts of members of families, fails of its proper effect, and law has to step in with its rigid rules and imperfect remedies. Unless she be deserted or the family be divided, the wife is strictly dependent as to her so-called property. In these events a right to a share of the estate springs up, but till then she has only a right which is completely subordinate. It is not one that she can transfer by individual act, as this is opposed to the theory even of joint ownership and no substitution is possible of another for herself in the supposed co-ownership with her husband in the common estate. No other could take her place in the joint celebration of the family sacrifices with the family estate or some interest in it must accompany and suppport Her right to maintenance is connected with the right called co-ownership with her husband and rests on the same conception of a moral identity arising from the marriage relations but the two are rather co-ordinate rights than one the basis of the other. The husband's duty of maintaining his wife is one which he cannot owe to another. Her right as against him is one that she cannot transfer to another.”

13. In Lakshmi Devi Amma v. Naganna . A. I. R. 1925 Mad. 757. Srinivasa Aiyaagar, J. stated the law thus:

“It Is true that the Hindu Law imposes an obligation on the Hindu husband to support his wife, without any reference to any property or share possessed by him, even as it imposes a similar obligation on sons to maintain their mother and father. But, when the joint family is possessed of property, a claim by the wife against her husband need not be regarded merely as a suit for the enforcement of any personal obligation, but may well be regarded at a suit against the family itself, represented to her by her husband, through whom alone, so long as he is alive, she has to obtain the relief.”

The same question arose for consideration before Viswanatha Sastri, J. in Manikyam v. Venkayamma. The learned Judge considered the following questions: “Do the words “right to receive maintenance from the profits of immovable property” occurring in S. 39 exclude the case of a wife entitled to claim separate maintenance from her husband, because the obligation of the husband to maintain the wife exists irrespective of his ownership of any property. Does the existence of a personal obligation on the part of the husband negative the right of the wife to be maintained out of his properties, ancestral or self acquired? Is not the personal liability of the husband something in addition to the liability to maintain his wife of his properties? Is not the wife entitled to the protection of S. 39 and pursue her clarim for maintenance against the property of her husband in the hands of a gratuitous transferee who has taken with full notice of her claim, when the husband is left with no other means of providing for the maintenance of the wife ?'’ The learned Judge after a due consideration of the relevant authorities on the subject held as follows: “Though the right of the wife to separate maintenance does not form a charge upon her husband's property, ancestral or self-acquired, yet, when it becomes necessary to enforce or preserve such a right effectively, it could be made a specific charge on a reasonable portion of the property. If the right of maintenance is imperilled or jeopardised by the conduct and dealings of the husband or father with reference to his properties, the Court can create a charge on a suitable portion thereof, securing the payment of maintenance to the wife or children.

Such a charge could be created not only over the properties in the hands of the husband or father but also over properties transferred by him either gratuitously or to person having notice of the right to maintenance. A transferees like the appellant, who joins in a fraudulent and clandestine arrangement for defeating the right of maintenance binding on the conscience of the transferor and who pays no consideration for the transfer by her son in her favour takes the properties subject to that right. The property in her hands is legally chargeable with the payment of maintenance to the wife and children of the transferor under S. 39 of the Transfer of Property Act.” it may also be mentioned that Viswanatha Sastri, J. considered the decision of Chandrasekhara Aiyar, J., in Pavmyamal v, Samiappa, and held that the said decision was contrary to earlier Bench decisions and dissented therefrom.

14. The right of a Hindu wife to a charge on her husband's properties and to the protection of S. 39 of the Transfer of Property Act arose for consideration before a Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Chandramma v. Venkata Reddi. Subba Rao, C.J, as he then was who spoke for the Bench went into the question in a very elaborate manner. The learned Judge referred to the passages in Manu, Vyasa and Jimutavahana and Apastamba Dharma Sutras and held that the Hindu Law texts recognised that a wife, by reason of her status, acquires an interest in the property of her husband though according to some writers, not co-equal with him but of a secondary kind. They also impose a personal obligation on him to maintain his wife enforceable by the Sovereign or the State other texts prohibit a person from alienating all his properties in such a way as to deprive his dependents including his wife of their maintenance. The learned Judge referred to the conflict of views of Chandrasekhara Aiyar, J. in Pavayammal v. Samappa and Viswanatha Sastri, J. in Manikyam v. Venkayamma and observed thus: “Chandrasekhara Ayyar, J. in Pavayammal v. Samiappa in a brief sentence rejected the claim of the wife by stating that it cannot be said of the plaintiffs that they have got a right to receive maintenance from the profits of immovable property. But, Viswanatha Sastri, J. in Manikyam v. Venkayammagave a considered and elaborate treatment to the subject. After considering the different aspects he summarised his view thus at page 1026 of Andhra W.R (at P. 713 of A.I.R)

“This right to separate maintenance which was previously bated an texts and decisions is now expressly conferred by statute under Act 19 of 1546. It is true that the husband or father is under a personal obligation to maintain his wife or infant children. This does not mean that the obligation could be enforced only by sending him to jail in case, of default and that the wife or infant children have no right to be maintained out of the property of the husband or the father as the case may be. The rule as to personal obligation only emphasises the legal and imperative duty of the husband to maintain his wife and minor children irrespective of the possession of any property”.

We respectfully agree with the aforesaid observation. Finally, the learned Judge summarised the law in the following words:—

“The Hindu Law Texts and the Important commentaries impose a legal personal obligation on a husband to maintain his wife irrespective of his possession of any property, whether joint or self-acquired. They recognise the subordinate interest of the wife in her husband's property arising out of her married status. They also prohibit the alienation of properties by the husband which has the effect of depriving her and other dependants of their maintenance. They further treat her as a member of a Hindu joint family entitled to be maintained out of joint funds. The decisions of the various High Courts to the same line, recognise her subordinate interest in her husband's property and enforce his personal obligation by creating a charge on his properties either self-acquired or ancestral. A wife, therefore, is entitled to be maintained out of the profits of her husband's property and, if so, under the express terms of S. 39 of the Transfer of Property Act, she can enforce her right against the properties in the hands of the alienee with notice of her claim.”

15. In Vellayammal v. Srikumara Pillai Ramaswami, J. had to deal with a similar situation. The learned Judge dissented from Pava yammal v. Samiappa and Chandramma v. M. Venkata Reddi

16. In K. M. S. Rudrappa v. Basamma the question that was posed for consideration was whether the plaintiffs, the wife and children were entitled to a charge over the suit properties for the maintenance decree in their favour. It should be remembered that the husband has gifted the properties in favour of others. The same contention was urged before the learned Judges that the obligation of a Hindu husband to provide maintenance to his wife and children was only a personal liability and that it has nothing to do with his property. In other words, an obligation was there irrespective of his possessing any property and consequently S. 39 of the Transfer of Property Act could not be attracted. Pavayammal v. Samiappa was relied upon in support of the argument that S. 39 of the Transfer of Property Act could not be attracted, while on the other side the decisions in Manikyam v. Venkayamma . A.I.R 1957 A.P 710. Chandramma v. M. Venkata Reddi and Velayammal v. Srikumara Pillai were relied on for the view that the wife and children were entitled to have a charge upon the properties and could enforce the same against the the gratuitous transferee. The learned Judge has held that Pavayammal v. Samiappa did not lay down the correct law and chose to follow the other decisions and held that a charge could be created in favour of the wife and minor children over the husband's property.

17. A recent decision of the Supreme Court in V. Tulasamma v. Sesha Reddi . 1977 3 S.C.C 99=90 L.W 89 S.N though not exactly on the point in controversy before me would show that the basis on which the earlier decisions proceeded in holding that a Hindu wife will be entitled to a charge on her husband's property and claim protection under S. 39 of the Transfer of Property Act is well-founded. The learned Judge has referred to the following passage as regards the nature of the liability of the husband as found in Hindu Law by Golap Chandra Sarkar Sastri:

“When the husband is alive, he is personally liable for the wife's maintenance, which is also a legal charge upon his property, this charge being a legal incident of her marital co-owneship in all her husband's property. But after his death, his widow's right of maintenance becomes limited to his estate, which when it passes to any other heir, is charged with the same. There cannot be any doubt that under Hindu Law, the wife's or widow's maintenance is a legal charge on the husband's estate; but the Courts appear to hold, in consequence of the proper materials not being placed before them, that it is not so by itself but is merely, a claim against the husband's heir, or an equitable charge on his estate; hence the husband's debts are held to have priority unless it is made a charge on the property by a decree.”

‘The learned Judge then observed: ‘To sum up, therefore according to Sastri's interpretation of Shastric Hindu Law the right to maintenance possessed by a Hindu widow is a very important right which amounts to a charge on the property of her husband which continues to the successor of the property and the wife is regarded as a sort of co-owner of the husband's property though in a subordinate sense, i.e, the wife has no dominion over the property.

18. Therefore, in the light of the above decisions, I respectfully follow the decisions in Velayammal v. Srikumara Pilla; Manikyam v. Venkayamma; Chandramma v. M. Venkata Reddi and K. M. S. Rudrappa v. Basamma and hold that a Hindu wife is entitled to have a charge on the property of her husband and to claim protection under S. 39 of the Transfer of Property Act. Once I come to that view, then Ex. B-6 being a gift in favour of the second defendant by the first defendant-husband cannot avail against the right of the plaintiff to have a charge for maintenance amount.

19. The learned counsel for the defendants contended that even at the time of Ex. B-6 the suit property was subject to heavy liability and after setting off the liabilities the property would be worth really only Rs. 140/-. I do not agree with this submission of the learned counsel for the defendants or with the manner in which he arrived at the value of the property. In any event, that cannot in any way prevent a charge being created in favour of the first plaintiff over the suit property in respect of the amount decreed for maintenance.

20. Another contention that was put forward by the learned counsel for the defendants is that even assuming that a charge could be claimed under S. 39 at the time Ex. B-6 was executed the first plaintiff had no right to separate maintenance and that consequently no charge could be created and that the right to maintenance cannot be enforced against the second defendant. The argument is elaborated by the learned counsel thus: The settlement was in 1961, In 1965 this Court allowed C.M.A No. 196 of 1963 granting restitution of conjugal right in favour of the first defendant. That meant that the first plaintiff had no right to separate residence and maintenance, and that consequently Ex. B-6 which was executed at the time when the first plaintiff had no right to separate residence and maintenance could not be defeated by any decree for maintenance which might be passed subsequently. The decisions already referred to by me would show that the right of a Hindu wife to maintenance is also interlinked with her interest in her husband's property. The Supreme Court in V. Tulasamma v. Sesha Reddi, described the right of maintenance of a Hindu female thus:

“The Hindu Female's right to maintenance is not an empty formality or an illusory claim being conceeded as a matter of grace and generosity, but is a tangible right against property which flows from the spiritual relationship between the husband and the wife and is recognised and enjoined by pure Shastric’ Hindu Law as has been strongly stressed even by the earlier Hindu jurists starting from Yajnavalkya to Manu. Such a right may not be a right to property but it is a right against property and the husband has a personal obligation to maintain his wife and if he or the family has property, the female has the legal right to be maintained therefrom. If a charge is created for the maintenance of a female, the said right becomes a legally enforceable one. At any rate, even without a charge the claim for maintenance is doubtless a preexisting right.”

21. Where a Hindu husband alienated the whole of his immovable property, though self-acquired, without making a suitable provision for his wife's maintenance it was ruled in Narbadabai v. Mahadeo Narayan that the alienation would not affect her right to maintenance. So too, where a husband made a gift of his entire estate leaving his wife without maintenance, it was ruled in Jamna…(Plaintiff); v. Machul Sahu…(Defendant). . I.L.R 2 All 315. that the donee took the estate subject to her right of maintenance. Where a husband executed a will which had the effect of defeating his wife's right to maintenance it was held in Periambal Chettiar v. Sundarammal that she was entitled to be maintained out of the estate of her husband. Subba Rao, C.J in Chandramma v. Venkatareddi, held that the restriction imposed on the husband's power to alienate his properties to protect the wife's right to maintenance is indicative of the subordinate interest of the wife in the property and also the link between the obligation and the property of the husband. Viewed on this basis it is not necessary that the right to maintenance should become crystallsed in the form of a decree to enable the wife to proceed against the property in the hands of the husband or her transferees. Merely because at the time Ex. B-6 was executed the first plaintiff had not obtained a decree for maintenance, it would not mean that she will not be entitled to enforce the right of maintenance against the property gratuitously transferred by the first defendant to the second defendant. When once it is seen that the first defendant has gifted the properties in favour of the second defendant, without making provision for the maintenance of the first plaintiff, then she will be entitled to have a charge created against the very properties and enforce the charge against the properties. I therefore, overrule the contention of Sri Alagar and hold that the plaintifls are entitled to a charge over the suit properties in respect of maintenance decree in their favour.

22. The next contention of Sri Alagar is that the suit as against the second plaintiff ought to have been dismissed as not maintainable on the ground that she has obtained a decree for maintenance in O.S No. 1829 of 1958. According to the learned counsel a second suit for maintenance is not maintainable. However, the learned counsel concedes that it will be open to the second plaintiff to file a suit for maintenance at an enhanced rate. Now the present suit by the second plaintiff is not merely for maintenance but for maintenance at enhanced rate and also for marriage expenses of Rs. 5,000/-. In that sense therefore, it cannot be said that the suit filed by the second plaintiff is not maintainable. No doubt, a decree for maintenance at the enhanced rate has not been granted but merely because the relief prayed for was not granted it would not make the suit not maintainable. Further a decree has been granted in favour of the second plaintiff for for Rs. 1000/- for marriage expenses. Therefore, I hold that the suit by the second plaintiff was maintainable. Then it is argued that the second plaintiff would not be entitled for maintenance since she has married one Arumugham on 4th July 1974. As the factum of marriage is not disputed by the counsel for the respondents, 1 hold that the second plaintiff will not be entitled to maintenance from 4th April, 1974. In the result I confirm the judgment and decree of the Court below subject to this modification that the second plaintiff will be entitled to maintenance only till 4th July 1974, the date of her marriage with Arumugam. Subject to this modification, the appeal is dismissed with costs.

VCS