- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sri Pushpagiri Mutt,... v. Ramalinga Sastri And...
Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner in this revision is the plaintiff of O.S. No. 4087 of 1969 (Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddappah) whose suit was filed in the Fourth Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Madras. An Executive Officer had been appointed to administer the Mutt under a scheme framed by the Andhra Pradesh Commissioner of Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (Administration). The suit sought a declaration of title and possession in respect of property at No. 20, Ekambareswarar Agraharam, Park Town, Madras.
The pleadings described the plaintiff as "The Executive Officer of Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddappah, Cuddappah District" rather than naming the Mutt itself; this description persisted into the appeal memorandum. The suit proceeded on contest but was dismissed for default on 4 October 1971. An application for restoration (I.A. No. 17709 of 1971) was dismissed. The plaintiff-Mutt appealed (C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972) to the Principal Judge, City Civil Court, Madras; that appeal was heard and decided by Judgment and decree dated 16 August 1974.
During the pendency of the appeal, the plaintiff-Mutt filed C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973 seeking permission to amend the cause title to show the Peedathipathy (Sri Vidya Nrusimha Bharathy Swamy Varu) represented by its Manager, on the ground that the earlier scheme had become inoperative and representation had changed. C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973 was dismissed by the Principal Judge on 15 July 1974; a revision (C.R.P. No. 295 of 1976) against that dismissal was later dismissed by this Court for failure to take steps to serve the respondents (11 July 1977).
The Principal Judge dismissed the main appeal, C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972, on the ground that the Executive Officer was not competent to maintain the appeal in view of the dismissal of C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973. The present revision challenges that judgment and decree dismissing the appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Court below was correct in dismissing the main appeal (C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972) on the basis that the Executive Officer of Sri Pushpagiri Mutt was not competent to maintain the appeal because C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973 had been dismissed.
- Whether a wrong description of a juridical party (here, the Mutt) in pleadings and in an appeal memorandum — where representation or the name of the representative is given in place of the party's proper designation — is a matter of misdescription that can be corrected by the Court, rather than requiring addition or substitution of parties.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mura Mohideen v. V.O.A. Mohamed, I.L.R. (1955) Mad. 1293; 1 M.L.J. 337; 68 L.W. 181; A.I.R. 1955 Mad. 294 | The legal principle that a misdescription of a party in pleadings is not an addition or substitution of a party but a clarification of what was previously obscured; if the Court can discover the person intended to sue or be sued and the mistake was bona fide, a mere misdescription can be corrected (reference to Order 1, Rule 10, G.P. Code). Such correction does not attract Section 22(1) of the Limitation Act (i.e., it does not operate as an addition of a party for limitation purposes). | The Court relied on this authority to conclude that the error in describing the plaintiff in the suit and appeal was a correctable misdescription. Applying the precedent, the Court allowed the revision, directed correction of the cause title to state "Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddappah, Cuddappah District, Andhra Pradesh" and ordered restoration of the appeal for hearing on merits after proper amendment. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the matter by focusing on (a) the identity of the real party (a juridical person, Sri Pushpagiri Mutt), and (b) the nature of the error in the pleadings and appeal memorandum (misdescription of the party by naming the representative rather than the Mutt).
The reasoning proceeded in these steps (as reflected in the opinion):
- The Court affirmed that a Mutt is a juridical person capable of suing and being represented by a human agency; therefore "Sri Pushpagiri Mutt" was the real plaintiff and appellant, regardless of how the representative was described in the pleadings.
- The appeal memorandum was signed and presented by the same counsel who had represented the plaintiff in the suit. The Court held that signing by the pleader satisfied Order 41, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The opinion also cites Order 3, Rule 4 (sub-rules (2) and (3), as they stood before the 1976 amendments) to show that a pleader's appointment continues for appeals from any decree or order in the suit, and that the representation in the appeal was competent on the original appointment.
- The Court considered the form and substance of C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973 (the application to amend the cause title) and concluded that the prayer for amendment was not properly couched and would not solve the underlying issue. The Court emphasized that representation may change over time and that such change concerns description, not the addition of a new party.
- Relying on the Mura Mohideen precedent, the Court explained that where a party is imperfectly or incorrectly designated, the correction is not treated as substitution/addition of a party but as clarification of what the pleadings intended to show; if the intention can be discovered and the mistake is bona fide, the Court can correct the misdescription (Order 1, Rule 10, G.P. Code was referenced in the precedent).
- Applying these principles to the facts, the Court found no legal warrant for the Court below to dismiss the appeal merely because the amendment application (C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973) had been dismissed. The Court concluded that the appropriate course was to allow correction of the cause title and to restore the appeal for hearing on merits after amendment.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The Court allowed the present revision and set aside the dismissal of the appeal by the Court below. The Court directed that the petitioner should seek correction of the cause title to show "Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddappah, Cuddappah District, Andhra Pradesh" as the plaintiff/appellant, represented by the proper authority or representative as on the date.
The Court ordered the following specific consequences:
- The Court below is to restore C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972 to its file and fix and notify a hearing date for that appeal after receiving the records.
- The petitioner must make an application to amend the cause title in the Courts below within a fortnight from the date of the hearing of the appeal as fixed and notified by the Court below; if the application for amendments is not made within that time, the Court below will dismiss the appeal C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972 for non-compliance with this Court's directions.
- Considering the petitioner's lack of promptness in seeking the proper amendment, the petitioner is directed to pay costs of Rs. 100 to the counsel for respondents 1 and 2 within two weeks from the date of the order.
Implications: The decision directs correction of a misdescription of a juridical party and restoration of the appeal for merits, without treating the correction as adding or substituting parties. The opinion applies existing precedent on misdescription; it does not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond that precedent. The direct effect is the opportunity to amend the cause title and to have the appeal heard on merits subject to compliance with the Court's directions.
1. The plaintiff in O.S. No. 4087 of 1969 on the file of the Fourth Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Madras, is the petitioner in this revision. The respondents herein are the defendants in that suit. The plaintiff is Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddappah, Cuddappah District, Andhra Pradesh. From a perusal of the records in the Court below, certain -essential features of the case do emerge out. An Executive Officer was appointed for the plaintiff-Mutt by the Commissioner of Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (Administration), Andhra Pradesh, in pursuance of a scheme framed therefor. The plaintiff-Mutt Sled the suit for a declaration of title regarding the property at No. 20, Ekambareswarar Agraharam, Park Town, Madras, and for possession of the said property. There is no gainsaying that a Mutt, like an idol is a juridical person and is capable of acquiring, holding and vindicating legal rights through the medium of some human agency, which is ordinarily the agency of the person in charge of its affairs. It is beyond doubt that "Sri Pushpagiri Mutt", is the plaintiff in the suit. However, because an Executive Officer was appointed and was functioning for the plaintiff-Mutt, at the relevant times, the plaintiff-Mutt was described in the pleadings as follows:
The Executive Officer of Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddappah, Cuddappah District". This may not be a proper description of the plaintiff-Mutt. The name or designation of the person representing the plaintiff-Mutt is only secondary. However, the suit on contest by the defendants, on merits was proceeded with and while it was part-heard was dismissed for default on 4th October, 1971. The application, I.A. No. 17709 of 1Q71, for restoration was also dismissed by the Fourth Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Madras. The plaintiff-Mutt filed an appeal, C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972 against the orders in I.A. No. 17709 of 1971, and the same cause title in the suit and in the subsequent proceedings in the suit was adopted in filing the said appeal, C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972, which was heard and disposed of by the Principal Judge, City Civil Court, Madras, by Judgment and decree dated 16th August, 1974.
2. During the pendency of the appeal, C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972, the aintiff-Mutt preferred C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973 for permission to amend the cause title by removing the present cause title and inserting the new cause title as:
Sri Vidya Nrusimha Bharathy Swamy Varu, Peedathipathy, Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddappah, represented by its Manager.
in the plaint as well as in the appeal memorandum. The provocation for this move was found in certain events, which occurred subsequent to the filing of the suit. It was stated that according to the Andhra Pradesh Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act, 1966, the scheme framed earlier, became inoperative, and the person to represent the plaintiff-Mutt became the Peedathipathy himself even before the filing of the said appeal. As noted earlier, the cause title found in the proceedings was adopted in the appeal. The prayer for amendment in C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973 itself was not properly couched. Once it is remembered that it is "Sri Pushpagiri Mutt" which had and has a "cause" to be agitated and vindicate certain legal rights, its representation through one or other human agency cannot be of much significance, and if it is described wrongly, it is a case of misdescription of parties, which can be corrected by the Court at any time. To complete the narration of events, C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973 in C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972, was dismissed by the Principal Judge, City Civil Court, Madras, on 15thJuly, 1974. A revision, C.R.P. No. 295 of 1976, was preferred to this Court as against the order in C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973 and the said revision has been dismissed by this Court on 11th July, 1977, for not taking steps to serve the respondents therein.
3. The Principal Judge, City Civil Court, Madras, has dismissed C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972 on the reasoning that the Executive Officer of Sri Pushpagiri Mutt is not competent to maintain the appeal in view of the orders passed in C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973. The present revision is directed against the judgment and decree in C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972. The question that comes up for consideration in this revision is as to whether the Court below is right in dismissing the main appeal itself on the reasoning given by it.
4. There is no dispute that the appeal memorandum in C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972 was signed and presented by the very same counsel, who was also appearing for the plaintiff-Mutt in the suit. The signing of the memorandum by the pleader would satisfy Order 41, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Order 3, Rule 4, Sub-rule (2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, as it stood prior to the amendments introduced by Act CIV of 1976, states that every appointment of pleader filed in Court shall be deemed to be in force...until all proceedings in the suit are ended so far as regards the client. Sub-rule (3) of the said Rule says that for the purposes of Sub-rule (2)... any appeal from any decree or order in the suit...shall be deemed to be proceedings in, the suit. Hence the representation of the plaintiff-Mutt for the appeal and the presentation of the appeal by the counsel who appeared fur it in the suit, were competent on the original appoinment given to him. It must also be remembered that the suit and the appeal were on the file of the City Civil Court, Madras, the suit on the file of the Fourth Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Madras, and the appeal on the file of the Principal Judge, City Civil Court, Madras. Whatever wisdom prompted the plaintiff-Mutt to file the application, C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973, seeking the amendment of the cause title in the form it was sought, the granting of the said application would not find a solution for the real problem. The reliefs claimed in the suit and in the appeal, C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972 are by the plaintiff-Mutt, viz. "Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddappah". The plaintiff Mutt has to be represented by some person. Instead of filing the suit as "Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddppah, represented by the proper person", the plaintiff-Mutt has been wrongly described, giving the representative's name and designation in the first place, and stating him to represent the plaintiff-Mutt. This mistake in the description of the plaintiff-Mutt has crept in the plaint in the suit itself, and has been carried over and repeated in the appeal memorandum in C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972. As stated above, the prayer, in the application for amendment of the cause title in C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973 is not on a better footing, and the dismissal of the said application has not worsened the position.
5. Once it is remembered that it is "Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddappah", which intend to sue in the suit and which alone wants, reliefs in the appeal, C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972, its wrong description in the sense of its wrong representation or improper representation can always be corrected by the Court. Any change in the representation of the plaintiff-Mutt due to change of circumstances or subsequent events can be taken note of, and the plaintiff-Mutt must be allowed to bring in the proper representative on record in the proper representation of the party is a question of description of the party, and not one of addition of new parties. Neither the description of the plaintiff-Mutt in the appeal memorandum in C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972, which has merely carried over and adopted the description in the suit, nor the description that was sought to be introduced in the application, C.M.P. No. 1013, is a proper one; and it does not bring to the forefront the patent fact that it is really "Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddappah" who is the plaintiff in the suit and the appellant in the appeal. Viewed in the above light, and taking into consideration the features of the case, as disclosed above, there was no warrant in law for the Court below, to dismiss the appeal, C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972, itself on the ground that C.M.P. No. 1013 of 1973 has come to be dismissed. The appellant is "Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Cuddappah". On the facts disclosed and placed before the Court, its representation by the Executive Officer, needs deletion and correction. The proper person competent to represent it on date must be brought on record In Mura Mohideen v. V.O.A. Mohamed I.L.R. (1955) Mad. 1293 : 1 M.L.J. 337 : 68 L.W. 181 : A.I.R. 1955 Maad. 294, a Division Bench of this Court consisting of Rajamannar, C.J. and Rajagopala Ayyangar, J., laid down the law with regard to amendment arising out of misdescription of parties in the following, terms:
If, however imperfectly and incorrectly a party is designated in a plaint the correction of the error is not the addition or substitution of a party but merely clarifies and makes apparent what was previously shrouded in obscurity by reason of the error or mistake. The question in such a case is one of intention of the party and if the Court is able to discover the person or persons intended to sue or to be sued a mere misdescription of such a party can always be corrected provided the mistake was bona fide. Vide Order 1, Rule 10, G.P. Code. Such an amendment does not involve the addition of a party so as to attract Section 22(1), Limitation Act.
6. Applying the above principles, I allow this revision and to meet the ends of justice, I direct the petitioner herein to seek the proper amendment of the proceedings in the Courts below to show "Sri Pushpagiri Mutt, Guddappah, Cuddappah District, Andhra Pradesh" as the plaintiff or the appellant, as the case may be, represented by the proper authority or representative as on date. The Court below will restore the appeal, C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972 to its file, to hoar the same on merits, after allowing the petitioner herein to amend the cause title in the proceedings as indicated above, if the application for such amendments is made within a fortnight from the date of hearing of the said appeal to be fixed and notified by the Court below, on receipt of the records by the Court below. If such an application for amendments is not made by the petitioner herein within the time given above, the Court below will dismiss the appeal, C.M.A. No. 65 of 1972 for, non-compliance with the directions given by this Court. Considering the fact that the petitioner herein has not been alert in seeking the proper amendment, the petitioner will pay the counsel for respondents 1 and 2 herein a sum of Rs. 100 as costs within two weeks from this day.
Alert