- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ganesan v. K. Madurai Achari
Factual and Procedural Background
The defendant in two suits filed in the District Munsif Court, Chingleput, preferred second appeals concerning whether he was entitled to benefits under the Tamil Nadu Occupants of Kudiyiruppu (Conferment of Ownership) Act, 1971, and the Tamil Nadu Occupants of Kudiyiruppu (Protection from Eviction) Act, 1961, and whether the civil court had jurisdiction to entertain the suits.
Originally, Rajaram Naidu and others owned lands including the suit site of 3 cents. The defendant became a tenant of the suit site around March 1971, erected a superstructure, and enjoyed possession. The land was later sold by Balasubramaniam to the plaintiffs in two halves. The plaintiffs alleged the defendant attorned tenancy to them but failed to pay rent and asserted hostile title, giving notice to terminate tenancy. The defendant denied tenancy, claiming the site was poromboke land and that neither plaintiffs nor vendor had title.
The plaintiffs filed suits, and the defendant contended the sale deeds were sham, asserted an agreement for sale with prior owners, and claimed protection under the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act. The trial court rejected these contentions and upheld jurisdiction of the civil court. Appeals failed, leading to the present second appeals by the defendant.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the defendant is entitled to the benefits of the Tamil Nadu Occupants of Kudiyiruppu (Conferment of Ownership) Act, 1971, and the Tamil Nadu Occupants of Kudiyiruppu (Protection from Eviction) Act, 1961.
- Whether the civil court has jurisdiction to entertain the suits involving the said lands and tenancy claims.
- Whether the suit site qualifies as a "Kudiyiruppu" under the relevant Acts.
- Whether the defendant, as a tenant or occupant, is entitled to protection from eviction under the statutory provisions.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's Arguments
- The defendant claimed tenancy over the suit site dating back to around March 1971.
- He argued entitlement to benefits under the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act and the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act.
- He denied the validity of the sale deeds, alleging they were sham and nominal.
- He contended the suit site was poromboke land and that neither plaintiffs nor vendor held title.
- The defendant asserted that the civil court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the suits due to the statutory protections under the Kudiyiruppu Acts.
- He claimed to be an agriculturist entitled to protection under the Acts.
Plaintiffs' Arguments
- The plaintiffs asserted valid title through purchase deeds and claimed the defendant attorned tenancy to them.
- They alleged the defendant failed to pay rent and asserted hostile title.
- They gave notice terminating the tenancy and sought possession through civil suits.
- The plaintiffs maintained that the civil court had jurisdiction to entertain the suits.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Govindaswami Gounder v. Ramaswami Gounder, 1958 2 M.L.J 184 | Requirement for civil court to give definite finding on cultivating tenant status under S. 6-A of the Cultivating Tenants Protection Act. | Used to distinguish that the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act lacks a similar provision, thus limiting civil court's role. |
| Ramachandra Sastrigal v. Kuppuswami Vanniar | Civil court must give a definite finding, not mere prima facie, on cultivating tenant status. | Supports the court's reasoning that no analogous provision exists in Kudiyiruppu Acts, affecting jurisdiction. |
| Md. Sukri Sahib v. Madhavan Kurup, 1949 1 M.L.J 376 | Civil court's power to pass decree for possession under Transfer of Property Act despite rent control legislation. | Analogized to the present case to support civil court's jurisdiction to grant possession subject to statutory protections. |
| Mohamedunni v. Melepurakkal Unniri, 1949 1 M.L.J 452 | Similar principle on civil court's decree for possession under rent control laws. | Reinforces the applicability of possession decrees under civil law with statutory safeguards. |
| Thalai Vaidiu andar v. Venugopal Chettiar, 1960 1 M.L.J 356 | Civil court's jurisdiction to pass possession decrees under rent control statutes. | Further supports the court's approach to possession decrees under statutory regimes. |
| Ethirajamma v. Hassan Kanoo alias N. M. Hussain (Judgment dated 10th August 1977) | Clarification that a civil court decree for possession outside rent control scope cannot be questioned in execution. | Used to analogize that possession decrees subject to Kudiyiruppu Protection Act similarly bind executing authorities. |
| Muniyandi v. Rajangam Iyer | Interpretation of bar on civil court jurisdiction under S. 16-A of Tamil Nadu Agricultural Lands Record of Tenancy Rights Act. | Distinguished to show that the question of whether a site is Kudiyiruppu is not exclusively within Authorised Officer's jurisdiction. |
| Palaniswami v. Ramaswami Gounder and others (Judgment dated 5th January 1977) | Civil court's jurisdiction to entertain injunction suits and decide possession and tenancy questions despite statutory bars. | Supports the court's conclusion that civil courts retain jurisdiction to determine tenancy and possession issues. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the scope and effect of the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act and the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act in relation to civil court jurisdiction. It noted that the Protection Act originally was temporary but was later re-enacted permanently, while the Ownership Act conferred ownership rights on occupants as of 19 June 1971.
The court analyzed the definition of "Kudiyiruppu" as a dwelling site occupied by an agriculturist or agricultural labourer and emphasized that only an owner conceding the site as Kudiyiruppu can approach the Authorised Officer for eviction proceedings. If ownership is denied or the site is not conceded to be a Kudiyiruppu, the civil court retains jurisdiction to decide the question.
The court clarified that while the civil court can decide whether a site is a Kudiyiruppu, it cannot decide on eviction grounds under S. 3(3) of the Protection Act, which falls exclusively within the Authorised Officer's jurisdiction. The court drew analogy from the Cultivating Tenants Protection Act, noting the absence of a similar provision in the Kudiyiruppu Acts that would mandate transfer of suits to a special authority.
The court further held that the civil court can grant possession decrees subject to the statutory protections, drawing parallels with rent control legislation where possession decrees are granted but execution is subject to statutory procedures.
Regarding the Ownership Act, the court observed that disputes about occupation as of 19 June 1971 are to be decided by the Authorised Officer, but the question whether the site is a Kudiyiruppu is not exclusively within that officer's jurisdiction and remains a matter for the civil court.
Addressing the defendant’s claim of being an agriculturist, the court found no evidence that the defendant or his family contributed manual labour to cultivation, a necessary condition under the Acts’ definitions. Consequently, the site was held not to be a Kudiyiruppu.
Since the site was not a Kudiyiruppu, the court found it unnecessary to consider the applicability of the Ownership Act or the Protection Act for eviction, holding the plaintiffs entitled to possession without the decree being subject to the Protection Act.
The court also upheld the decree for future damages granted by the lower courts.
Holding and Implications
The appeals are dismissed.
The court held that the civil court has jurisdiction to entertain suits concerning possession and tenancy where the site is not conceded to be a Kudiyiruppu. The defendant failed to establish that the suit site was a Kudiyiruppu, and thus was not entitled to the protections under the Kudiyiruppu Acts. Consequently, the plaintiffs are entitled to possession, and the decree for possession and future damages granted by the courts below is affirmed.
No new precedent was set beyond clarifying jurisdictional boundaries between civil courts and statutory authorities under the Kudiyiruppu Acts. The immediate effect is the dismissal of the defendant’s appeals and confirmation of possession in favor of the plaintiffs, with a six-month period allowed for vacant possession. No order as to costs was made.
1. The defendant in the two suits (OS. 608 and 663 of 1974) on the file of the District Munsif Court, Chingleput) has preferred these two second appeals. The question in both the cases is whether the defendant is entitled to the benefits of the Tamil Nadu Occupants of Kudiyiruppu (Conferment of Ownership) Act (Act 40 of 1971), hereinafter referred to as the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act, and the Tamil Nadu Occupants of Kudiyiruppu (Protection from Eviction) Act (Act 38 of 1961;, hereinafter referred to as the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act, and whether the civil court has jurisdiction to entertain the suits.
2. One Rajaram Naidu and others owned certain lands extending 2-89 acres of which the suit site (3 cents) is part. The defendant became a tenant of the suit site under the above owners as evidenced by Ex. A-7, dated 20th March 1973, which says that he had become tenant even two years prior to the date of the document. It is now common ground that he so became tenant in or about March 1971. He put up a superstructure and has been enjoying the same. One Balasubramaniam purchased the land (including the suit site) under Ex. A.8 dated 4th December, 1973. He sold half of the suit site (1½ cents) to the plaintiff in one of the suits and the other half (1½ cents) to the plaintiff in the other suit, under the sale deeds, Exs. A.1 and A.2, both dated 5th December, 1973. According to the plaintiffs, the defendant attorned the tenancy to them, but failed to pay the rent and began asserting hostile title. They gave notice terminating the tenancy. The defendant totally denied the tenancy in his reply notice and stated that he had never paid rent to any one. He contended that the site is part of a poromboke and that neither the plaintiffs nor the vendor had any title to the same.
3. The plaintiffs filed the two suits. The defendant in his written statement reiterated his stand in the reply notice and contended that the sale deeds are sham and nominal and and bogus. It was also contended that the defendant had an agreement for sale with the prior owners and that he was in possession in part performance of the contract. The written statement concluded by saying that the defendant was entitled to protection under the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act.
4. All these contentions were negatived by the trial court. It also negatived the contentions put forward by the defendant at the trial that by virtue of the provisions contained in the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act, and the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act, the civil court had no jurisdiction to entertain the suits. The defendant filed two appeals against the common judgment and decrees in the suits, but they failed. Hence, these two second appeals by him.
5. The point raised by Mr. T. V. Ramanujam, learned counsel for the defendant (appellant) is that on the case of the plaintiffs and the findings of the courts below, that the defendant was a tenant in respect of the suit site, S. 3 of the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act would confer title on the defendant to the same (3 cents), that in any event, the defendant would be entitled to the benefits of the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act and that the civil court has no jurisdiction to entertain the suits.
6. The first question is how far the provisions of the two Acts exclude the jurisdiction of the civil court. The Kudiyiruppu Protection Act when it was originally enacted was meant to be a temporary provision. Sub-Sec.(3) of S. 1 as it originally stood said that the Act shall be in force for a period of 9 years, and later, it was amended to the effect that it shall be in force for a period of 12 years. The said Act came into force on 29th November 1961 and it had force only upto 1973. Subsequently, that is, by Tamil Nadu Act 23 of 1975, the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act was re-enacted as a permanent measure. In the meanwhile, the other Act, namely, the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act came into force with effect from 23rd December 1971.
7. Under this Act ownership was conferred on an agriculturist or an agricultural labourer occupying a Kudiyiruppu on 19th June 1971. There is provision for payment of compensation to the owner and recovery of such compensation from the occupier. At the moment it is enough to note that if the subsequent Act, namely, the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act, applied and thereby the person occupying the Kudiyiruppu had become the owner, then there is no need to invoke the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act.
8. Under the former Act, an agriculturist or an agricultural labourer occupying a ‘Kudiyiruppu’, which word is defined, can be evicted only as per the provisions contained in the Act. S 3 states that save as otherwise provided in that Act, no person occupying any Kudiyiruppu shall be evicted from such Kudiyiruppu. Sub-sec.(3) of that section states that sub-secs.(1) and (2) shall not apply to a person occupying a Kudiyiruppu if he had been guilty of any negligence which is destructive of, or injurious to, the property belonging to the owner of the Kudiyiruppu, or if he had wilfully denied the title of the owner of the Kudiyiruppu. The explanation states that a denial of the owner's title under a bona fide mistake of fact is not wilful within the meaning of the above clause. S. 4 provides for restoration of possession under certain circumstances. S. 5 states that any owner of Kudiyiruppu seeking to evict for any of the reasons mentioned in sub-sec.(3) of S. 3 has to apply for eviction to the Authorised Officer within whose jurisdiction the Kudiyiruppu is situated. S. 6 provides for enquiry by the Authorised Officer and passing of orders on the aforesaid application while S. 7 provides for an appeal by the aggrieved party to the District Collector. S. 11 of that Act says that no civil court shall have jurisdiction in respect of any matter in which the Authorised Officer or the District Collector is empowered by or under the Act to decide. It further says that no injunction shall be granted by any court in respect of any action taken or to be taken in exercise of any power conferred by or under the Act.
9. Now, turning to the definition of the word ‘Kudiyiruppu’ which is in sub-sec.(6) of S. 2, it is seen that it [must be a site of any dwelling house or hut occupied, either as tenant or as licencee, by any agriculturist or agricultural labourer and includes such other area adjacent to the dwelling house or hut as may be necessary for the convenient enjoyment of such dwelling house or hut. There is an explanation to the above definition which purports to create a presumption which I will deal with later. The word ‘agriculturist’ is defined in sub-sec.(3) thereof, and it is similar to the definition contained in the Tamil Nadu Cultivating Tenants Protection Act, 1955, namely, that a person who cultivates agricultural land by the contribution of his own manual labour or of the manual labour of any member of his family.
10. It is to be noted that the special jurisdiction of the Authorised Officer (apart from that under S 4) is to enquire into and pass orders on applications for eviction filed by any owner of a Kudiyiruppu. The appeal to the Collector also relates to the same matter. Under this Act, no other question is within the special jurisdiction of the Authorised Officer or the District Collector. Particularly the question whether any house site is a ‘Kudiyiruppu’ or not is certainly not within the special jurisdiction of the Authorised Officer and the District Collector. As a matter of fact, only in a case where it is admitted that the house site is a Kudiyiruppu, an application for eviction can be filed, for, S. 5 makes it clear that only an owner of a Kudiyiruppu seeking to evict can file an application before the Authorised Officer. In other words, only the owner who concedes that the site is a Kudiyiruppu can go before the Authorised Officer for eviction That makes it absolutely clear that if the owner does not concede that it is a Kudiyiruppu, his remedy is not to go before the Authorised Officer but only to come to the civil court. Of course, it would be open to the tenant to raise the question that the site is a Kudiyiruppu as defined under the Act and that he is entitled to protection under the Act. In such a case, what is to happen to the suit in ejectment filed by the owner in the civil court? Undoubtedly, the civil court has to go into the question whether the site is a Kudiyiruppu ©r not. In it finds that it is not a kudiyiruppu, then the further questions, arising in the suit have to be determined and the suit is to be disposed of on merits.
11. There are other situations where the civil court would have necessarily to go into the question whether the site is a Kudiyiruppu. In a suit for injunction on alleged attempted trespass or in a suit for possession on the allegation that the defendant is a trespasser, the latter might raise a contention that he is a tenant and the lite is a Kudiyiruppu. A person occupying a site or alleging that he is occupying the same and that it is a Kudiyiruppu might file a suit for injunction. In all such cases the civil court has to decide the question as to whether it is a Kudiyiruppu or not. Therefore, there can be no doubt that the civil court has jurisdiction regarding that question.
12. However, in a suit in ejectment or for possession, if the civil court finds that the lite is a Kudiyiruppu, then it cannot go into the question whether the tenant is entitled to the benefits of the Act; in other words, whether he is not liable to be evicted under S. 3(3). Eviction on the grounds mentioned in S. 3(3) can be only on an application to the authorised officer under S. 5. It is within his special jurisdiction to find whether any of the grounds under S. 3(3) is made out on such application under S. 5 being filed.
13. Under analogus law, namely, the Tamil Nadu Cultivating Tenants Protection Act, S. 6 which is he similar to S. 11 of the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act, bars the jurisdiction of the civil court in respect of any matter within the jurisdiction of the revenue court. Even so, the civil court always had the jurisdiction to go into the question whether a person is a cultivating tenant. By virtue of S. 6-A of the Cultivating Tenants Protection Act, which was introduced by way of amendment, in a suit in ejectment the civil court has to give a finding not only regarding the question whether the defendant is a cultivating tenant but also regarding the question whether he is entitled to the benefit of the said Act. If the civil Court finds in favour of the defendant on those two points, then the suit has to be transferred to the revenue court In Govindaswami Gounder v. Ramaswami Gounder . 1958 2 M.L.J 184. Panchapakesa Ayyar, J. has held that in a case where the civil court acts under S. 6-A of the Cultivating Tenants Protection Act, it need not give a final finding regarding the question whether the defendant is a cultivating tenant or not and that if it is prima facie satisfied that the defendant is a cultivating tenant, it has to transfer the suit to the revenue court. But, in Ramachandra Sastrigal v. Kuppuswami Vanniar,2 a Bench of this court has held that the civil court has to give a definite finding and not a mere prima facie finding.
14. There being no corresponding provision as S. 6-A of the Cultivating Tenants Protection Act, in the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act, there is no scope for the civil court going into the question whether the defendant is entitled to the benefits of the Act (if it holds that the site is a Kudiyiruppu) and transferring the matter to the authorised officer. There is also no question of giving only a prima facie finding regarding the point whether the site is a Kudiyiruppu or not. As I indicated earlier, there has to be a final finding inasmuch as that question is not within the special jurisdiction of the auhorised officer.
15. Still the question remains as to what should be done by the civil court once it finds that the site is a Kudiyiruppu. I am of the view that even though it is not to embark on the question whether the tenant is liable to be evicted under S. 3(3), that being a question within the special jurisdiction of the authorised officer, there is no bar for the civil court to grant a decree for possession, subject to the provisions of the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act.
16. It has been held in a number of decisions of this court that even in respect of a building governed by the Madras Buildings (Lease and Rent Control Act) (Act 18 of 1960) the civil court can pass a decree for possession (under the Transfer of Property Act)—Vide: Md. Sukri Sahib v. Madhavan Kurup . 1949 1 M.L.J 376. Mohamedunni v. Melepurakkal Unniri . 1949 1 M.LJ 452. and Thalai Vaidiu andar v. Venugopal Chettiar . 1960 1 M.L.J 356. But, such a decree for possession would be subject to Act 18 of 1960. In other words, if the building is governed by that Act, the decree cannot be executed without the landlord going before the Rent Controller under S. 10 of that Act, and establishing any one of the grounds thereunder for eviction. It would be a different matter if the civil court comes to the conclusion that the building is outside the scope of Act 18 of 1960. If it gives such a finding, then there would be no occasion for the landlord to go before the Rent Controller for eviction If the civil court passes a decree for possession after holding that the building is outside the scope of Act 18 of 1960, then it would not be open to the excuting court to go behind it—See my judgment, dated 10th August 1977 in Ethirajamma v. Hassan Kanoo alias N. M. Hussain.
17. I do not see why the principle enunciated in the decisions under Act 18 of 1960 referred above are not applicable to a case where the civil court holds that the site is a Kudiyiruppu. As I said, it can pass a decree for possession under the Transfer of Property Act, if the plaintiff is entitled to possession Of course, the decree should make it clear that the same is subject to the provisions of the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act.
18. Now, coming to the provisions of the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act, the definitions are the same as in the other Act. S. 3 says that save as otherwise provided in the Act, any agriculturist or agricultural labourer who was occupying any Kudiyiruppu on the 19th June 1971, either as tenant or as licencee shall, with effect from the date of the commencement of the Act, be the owner of such Kudiyiruppu, and such Kudiyiruppu shall vest in him absolutely free from all encumbrances. Sub sec.(2) of the said Section vests absolute title in such agriculturist or agricultural labourer in the superstructure also even if the same belongs to any other person. Sub-sec. (3) makes certain exception. S. 4(1) says (hat if any dispute arises whether any agriculturist or agricultural labourer was occupying any Kudiyiruppu on 19th June 1971, for purposes of S. 3 of the Act such dispute shall be decided by the authorised officer. Sub-S.(2) of the said Section speaks of the procedure to be followed by the authorised officer. S. 5 provides for appeal to the District Collector. S. 6 relates to payment of compensation to the person having interest in the kudiyiruppu. S. 7 relates to determination of compensation, while S. 8 provides for an appeal to the civil court (which word is defined) against the decision regarding compensation. S. 9 is about the apportionment of compensation, while S. 10 is about payment of compensation. S. 11 speaks of a second appeal to the High Court against the decision of the civil court under certain circumstances. S. 23 regarding jurisdiction is similar to S. 11 of the other Act. It is unnecessary to note the other provisions except to say that they relate to the mode of payment of compensation and the mode of recovery of compensation from the occupant of a kudiyiruppu, apart from certain other matters.
19. It is quite clear that the question of determination of compensation and allied matters are within the special jurisdiction of the Authorised Officer subject, of course, to appeal to the civil court and a second appeal under certain circumstances to the High Court. S. 4 also confers special jurisdiction on the Authorised Officer to determine any dispute ‘whether any agriculturist or agricultural labourer was occupying any Kudiyiruppu on the 19th June 1971.” Rule 3 of the Tamil Nadu Occupants of Kudiyiruppu (Conferment of Ownership) Rules 1972, made by virtue of S. 27 of the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act, contemplates an application for the settlement of a dispute under S. 4 of the said Act to be made to the Authorised Officer having jurisdiction over the area within a period of 2 months from the date on which the dispute arose, with a proviso that the Authorised Officer may, for reasons to be recorded in writing, extend the period.
20. It is not possible to read these provisions as conferring exclusive jurisdiction on the Authorised Officer to decide the question whether a site is a Kudiyiruppu or not. The Act nowhere says that such a question is one that has to be decided by the Authorised Officer. As already seen, all that S. 4 says is that if there is a dispute as to whether an agriculturist or agricultural labourer was occupying a Kudiyiruppu on the 19th June 1971 (—if he had so occupied, the ownership of the site would vest in him), this dispute has to be decided by the Authorised Officer. That does not mean that the question whether the site is a Kudiyiruppu, or not it within his exclusive jurisdiction. It should also be remembered that this Act is allied to the other Act, namely, the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act. It was already noticed that under that Act only an owner of a Kudiyiruppu can approach the Authorised Officer to evict the tenant on any one of the grounds contained in S. 3(3) of the said Act, which presupposes that if the owner does not concede that the site is a Kudiyiruppu, he cannot possibly go to the Authorised Officer. Therefore, I am quite clear that even under the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act the question whether a site is a Kudiyiruppu or not is within the jurisdiction of the civil court. A decision by the civil court on that point would be final. If, however, before any civil court renders a decision on the question whether the site is a Kudiyiruppu or not, the dispute under S. 4(1) goes before the Authorised Officer, he may incidentally have to decide whether it is a Kudiyiruppu. But, if the civil court has given a decision already, that would be binding on the parties.
21. Mr. Ramanujam, learned counsel for the defendant-appellant referred to Muniyandi v. Rajangam Iyer, which arose under the Tamil Nadu Agricultural Lands Record of Tenancy Rights Act, 1969 (Act 10 of 1969, as amended by Act 34 of 1972) and contended that even the question as to whether the site is a Kudiyiruppu or not, must be deemed to be within the jurisdiction of the Authorised Officer. The Division Bench which decided the above case has only held that as per S. 16-A of that Act (which corresponds to S. 11 of the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act and S. 23 of the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act relating to the bar of jurisdiction of civil court), a civil court has no jurisdiction to decide any matter which the Record Officer, District Collector or other Officer or authority empowered by or under the Act to determine. What matter or matters are within the special jurisdiction of the Record Officer, etc., has not been decided.
22. It may be noted that the provisions of the above said Act relate only to preparation of a record of tenancy rights. It does not confer any other right on a cultivating tenant. His rights, as the law stands now, are only under the Cultivating Tenants Protection Act. Even that Act does not take away the jurisdiction of the civil court regarding the question whether a person is a cultivating tenant or not. If in a suit, the question as to whether a party is a cultivating tenant or not arises, the civil court has to decide it. If it decides that he is not a cultivating tenant, then the suit should be disposed of on merits. However, because of S. 6-A of the said Act, if it finds that the defendant in a suit is a cultivating tenant it has to transfer the suit to the revenue court.
23. In the judgment dated 5th January 1977 in Palaniswami v. Ramaswami Gounder and others, Ramanujam, J. has held that S. 16-A of the Tamil Nadu Agricultural Lands Record of Tenancy Rights Act is not a bar for the civil court to entertain a suit for injunction, and in such a suit, the Civil court has to incidentally go into the question as to who is in possession of the property and in what capacity. If any party contends that be is occupying the land as a cultivating tenant, that question has necessarily to be gone into by the civil court. Similarly, if a suit for possession of agricultural land is filed and the defendant contends that he is a cultivating tenant that question has necessarily to be gone into by the civil court. That is the position even under the Cultivating Tenants Protection Act which provides for an application to the revenue court for eviction of a cultivating tenant.
24. One question would be, if an entry in the register prepared under the Record of Tenancy Rights Act has already been made and has become final, how far such an entry would be binding on the civil court in deciding as to whether a particular person was in possession as a tenant or not. S. 15 of the said Act says that any entry in the approved record of tenancy rights shall be presumed to be true and correct until the contrary is proved or a new entry is lawfully substituted therefore. Therefore, prima fade such an entry cannot be conclusive regarding the question whether the person concerned is a cultivating tenant or not. However, it is unnecessary for me to express a final opinion on that point in this case. It is enough to note that the decision reported in Muniyandi v. Rajangam Iyer, would not help the defendant as it did not decide what is within the special jurisdiction and what is not. The above jndgment does not say that the question whether a person is a cultivating tenant or not, is within the special jurisdiction of the Record Officer. It does not say that the civil court has no jurisdiction to investigate such a question.
25. Now, the remaining point for consideration is whether the suit site is a Kudiyiruppu. I have already referred to the clause relating to presumption under the definition of the word, ‘Kudiyiruppu’ which says that any person occupying the Kudiyiruppu is an agricultural labourer or an agriculturist until the contrary is proved. But, on an examination of the provisions, I am clear that whatever be the intention of the Legislature, the above provision relating to the presumption is a dead letter. The presumption would arise only if it is established that the site is a Kudiyiruppu. In order to establish that the site is a Kudiyiruppu, it should be shown that the site or dwelling house or hut, as the case may be, is occupied by an agriculturist or agricultural labourer (cither as tenant or as licencee). Therefore, the person who is occupying the site claiming that the site, etc., is a Kudiyiruppu should establish that he is an agriculturist or an agricultural labourer. Undoubtedly, every house site or a dwelling house or a hut is not a Kudiyiruppu. Needless to stress that the person occupying the same should be an agriculturist or an agricultural labourer to make it a Kudiyiruppu. Then there is no meaning in the explanation to the definition to the word ‘Kudiyiruppu’ purporting to create a presumption that any person occupying the Kudiyiruppu is an agriculturist or an agricultural labourer.
26. It is not claimed by the defendant that he is an agricultural labourer. But, the contention is that he is an agriculturist as defined in the Acts. As already noticed, an agriculturist is one who cultivates agricultural land by the contribution of his own manual labour or of the manual labour of any member of his family.
27. In the present case, apart from the laconic plea in the written statement that the defendant is entitled to the benefits of the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act, there is no averment of fact regarding the question whether the site is a Kudiyiruppu or not. It is true that in the plaint the defendant is described as an agriculturist. But, the question is whether he is an agriculturist as defined in the Act. In common parlance, even a person who owns agricultural land and cultivates the same through hired labour is called an agriculturist, but under the definition, unless he contributes his own labour or that of any member of his family in the cultivation of the land, he would not be an agriculturist. The evidence in the case also does not support the contention that the site is a Kudiyiruppu on the basis that the defendant who occupies the same is an agriculturist. The defendant as D.W.1 has not said a word that either he or any member of his family contributes manual labour in the cultivation of agricultural lands. In chief-examination he stated that he owns agricultural lands and added that his mother also owns lands and that she is cultivating the same. In cross-examination he has stated—
He conceded that he has no record to show that he was cultivating any land. Even assuming that the defendant was cultivating agricultural lands, there is absolutely no evidence to show that such cultivation was with the manual labour of himself or any member of his family. Under these circumstances, it is not possible to hold that the site is a Kudiyiruppu.
28. In this view, it is unnecessary to go into the question whether the Kudiyiruppu Ownership Act applies, thereby the site vesting in the defendant or whether the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act applies in which event the defendant can be evicted only as per the provisions of that Act. The plaintiffs are entitled to a decree for possession without the same being made subject to the Kudiyiruppu Protection Act.
29. The decree for future damages granted by the Courts below which shall be determined in separate proceedings is also correct.
30. The appeals fail and they are accordingly dismissed. But under the circumstances of the case, there would be no order as to costs. Time for giving vacant possession, six months.
VCS
Alert